Policing international trade in endangered species: The CITES treaty and compliance

Policing International Trade in Endangered Species: The CITES Treaty and Compliance

Volumn , Issue , 2014, Pages 1-346

  Reeve, Rosalind ^a  

^a Verification ResearchTraining and Information Centre (VERTIC)   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 85069327080     PISSN: None     EISSN: None     Source Type: Book    
DOI: 10.4324/9781315071954     Document Type: Book

References (175)

1. John Lanchbery, ‘Long-Term Trends in Systems for Implementation Review in International Agreements on Fauna and Flora’, in David G. Victor, Kal Raustiala and Eugene B. Skolnikoff (eds), The Implementation and Effectiveness of International Environmental Commitments (International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis, 1998) (hereinafter ‘Lanchbery’), at p. 69.
2. Peter H. Sand, ‘Commodity or Taboo? International Regulation of Trade in Endangered Species’, Green Globe Yearbook 1997 (hereinafter ‘Sand (1997)'), at p. 26
3. Christopher Stone, ‘The Question of Compliance’, in The Gnat is Older than Man (Princeton University Press, 1993), p. 100.
4. Philippe Sands, Principles of International Environmental Law (Manchester University Press, 1995) (hereinafter ‘Sands (1995)') at p. 369
5. Patricia Birnie, ‘The Case of the Convention on Trade in Endangered Species’, in Rudiger Wolfrum (ed), Enforcing Environmental Standards: Economic Mechanisms as Viable Means (Heidelberg: Springer, 1996), pp. 233-64.
6. Dee Cook, Martin Roberts and Jason Lowther, The International Wildlife Trade and Organized Crime: A Review of the Evidence and Role of the UK (WWF-UK, Jun 2002) (hereinafter ‘Cook et al./WWF-UK’).
7. Rob Barnett, Food for Thought: the Utilization of Wild Meat in Eastern and Southern Africa (TRAFFIC East/Southern Africa, 2000); .
8. Vivek Menon and Ashok Kumar, Wildlife Crime: an Enforcement Guide (Wildlife Protection Society of India/Natraj Publishers, 1998), p. 62.
9. Mark Trexler, ‘The Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora: Political or Conservation Success?', PhD thesis (University of California at Berkeley, 1990), p. 9
10. Duncan Brack, Kevin Gray and Gavin Hayman, Controlling the International Trade in Illegally Logged Timber and Wood Products (RIIA, Feb 2002) (hereinafter ‘Brack et al. (Feb 2002)')
11. .
12. T. De Meulenaer, ‘Wildlife Law Enforcement in Europe’, in Proceedings of the EU Wildlife Enforcement Workshop, London 1-2 March 1998 (UK DETR, 1998), pp. 84-8.
13. A. Kumar, ‘Shahtoosh Trade and the Tiger Connection’, in Proceedings of the EU Wildlife Enforcement Workshop, London 1-2 March 1998 (UK DETR, 1998), pp. 104-106.
14. Joseph Franke and Teresa Telecky, Reptiles as Pets: An Examination of the Trade in Live Reptiles in the United States (Humane Society of the United States, 2001).
15. S. Galster, S. LaBudde and C. Stark, Crime against Nature: Organized Crime and the Illegal Wildlife Trade (Endangered Species Project, 1994).
16. Ronald B. Mitchell, ‘Compliance Theory: An Overview’, in James Cameron, Jacob Werksman and Peter Roderick (eds), Improving Compliance with International Environmental Law (Earthscan, 1996) (hereinafter ‘Mitchell’), at p. 17.
17. Nordic Research Project on the Effectiveness of International Environmental Agreements: draft report (Finnish Ministry of the Environment, 1995), at p. 6.
18. David G. Victor, Kal Raustiala and Eugene B. Skolnikoff, ‘Introduction and Overview’ in David G. Victor, Kal Raustiala and Eugene B. Skolnikoff (eds), The Implementation and Effectiveness of International Environmental Commitments (International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis, 1998) (hereinafter ‘Victor et al.'), p. 5.
19. Martti Koskenniemi, ‘New Institutions and Procedures for Implementation Control and Reaction’, in Jacob Werksman (ed.), Greening International Institutions (Earthscan, 1996), p. 237.
20. Kal Raustiala, Reporting and Review Institutions in 10 Multilateral Environmental Agreements (UNEP, 2001).
21. Robert O. Keohane, International Institutions and State Power: Essays in International Relations Theory (Westview Press, 1989).
22. Duncan Brack, International Environmental Disputes: International Forums for Noncompliance and Dispute Settlement in Environment-related Cases (RIIA/UK DETR, Mar 2001)
23. Winfried Lang, ‘Compliance Control in International Environmental Law: Institutional Necessities’, Heidelberg Journal of International Law, 1996, 56, pp. 685-95
24. K. Sachariew, ‘Promoting Compliance with International Environmental Standards:Reflections on Monitoring and Reporting Mechanisms’, Yearbook of International Environmental Law, 2 (1991), pp. 31-52
25. Peter H. Sand, ‘International Economic Instruments for Sustainable Development: Sticks, Carrots and Games’, Indian Journal of International Law, 36/2 (1996), pp. 1-16
26. Steve Charnovitz, ‘Encouraging Environmental Cooperation Through the Pelly Amendment’, Journal of Environment and Development, 3/1 (1994), pp. 3-28.
27. Peter H. Sand, ‘Trusts for the Earth: New International Financial Mechanisms for Sustainable Development’, in Winfried Lang (ed.), International Law and Sustainable Development (Kluwer, 1996), pp. 167-84.
28. R. Mott, ‘The GEF and the Conventions on Climate Change and Biological Diversity’, International Environmental Affairs, 5 (1993): 299.
29. Kal Raustiala, and David G. Victor, ‘Conclusions’, in David G. Victor, Kal Raustiala and Eugene B. Skolnikoff (eds), The Implementation and Effectiveness of International Environmental Commitments (International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis, 1998) (hereinafter ‘Raustiala and Victor’), at p. 681.
30. Antonia H. Chayes, Abram Chayes and Ronald B. Mitchell, ‘Active Compliance Management in Environmental Treaties’, in Winfried Lang (ed.), International Law and Sustainable Development (Kluwer, 1996).
31. George W. Downs, David M. Rocke and Peter N. Barsoom, ‘Is the Good News about Compliance Good News about Cooperation?' International Organization, 50/3 (1996), p. 379
32. George W. Downs, ‘Enforcement and the Evolution of Cooperation’, Michigan Journal of International Law (1998), p. 319.
33. Willem Wijnstekers, The Evolution of CITES: A Reference to the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES Secretariat/IFAW, 2001) (hereinafter ‘Wijnstekers’), at p. 15.
34. Elizabeth N. Layne, ‘Eighty Nations Write Magna Carta for Wildlife’, Audubon Magazine, 75/3 (1973), p. 99.
35. Caroline Raymakers, ‘Biodiversity and Wildlife Trade: From Fauna and Flora in Trade to Sanctions’, in Monika Anton, Nicholas Dragffy, Stephanie Pendry and Tomme Rozanne Young (eds), Proceedings of the International Expert Workshop on the Enforcement of Wildlife Trade Controls in the EU, 5-6 Nov 2001 (TRAFFIC/IUCN, 2002).
36. Simon Lyster, International Wildlife Law (Grotius, 1985), p. 256.
37. Gwyneth G. Stewart, ‘Enforcement Problems in the Endangered Species Convention:Reservations Regarding the Reservation Clauses’, Cornell International Law Journal, 14 (1981), p. 429
38. Paul Matthews, ‘Problems Related to the Convention on the International Trade in Endangered Species’, International and Comparative Law Quarterly, 45 (1996), p. 421
39. Valerie Karno, ‘Protection of Endangered Gorillas and Chimpanzees in International Trade: Can CITES Help?' Hastings International and Comparative Law Review, 14 (1991), pp. 989-1015
40. Martijn Wilder, ‘Quota Systems in International Wildlife and Fisheries Regimes’, Journal of Environment and Development, 4/2 (1995), p. 55.
41. Patricia W. Birnie and Alan E. Boyle, International Law and the Environment (Clarendon Press, 1992), at p. 26
42. M. N. Shaw, International Law (Cambridge University Press, 1997), at p. 92.
43. Jacob Werksman, ‘The Conference of Parties to Environmental Treaties’, in Jacob Werksman (ed), Greening International Institutions (Earthscan, 1996), pp. 55-68
44. Laura H. Kosloff and Mark C. Trexler, ‘The Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species: No Carrot, but Where’s the Stick?' Environmental Law Reporter, 14 (1987), p. 10222-36
45. .
46. Cyrille de Klemm, Guidelines for Legislation to Implement CITES, IUCN Environmental Policy and Law Paper No. 26 (IUCN-World Conservation Union, 1993).
47. Marceil Yeater, ‘Enforcement and the CITES National Legislation Project’, and Caroline Raymakers, ‘Biodiversity and Wildlife Trade: From Fauna and Flora in Trade to Sanctions’ both in Monika Anton, Nicholas Dragffy, Stephanie Pendry and Tomme Rozanne Young (eds), Proceedings of the International Expert Workshop on the Enforcement of Wildlife Trade Controls in the EU, 5-6 Nov 2001 (TRAFFIC/IUCN, 2002).
48. Farhana Yamin and Annabella L. Gualdoni, ‘A Case Study of a Regional Approach to Compliance with CITES in Southern Africa’, in James Cameron, Jacob Werksman and Peter Roderick (eds), Improving Compliance with International Environmental Law (Earthscan, 1996), pp. 187-218.
49. John Caldwell and Lorraine Collins, ‘A Report on Annual Reports Submitted by the Parties to CITES’, CITES Doc 30 Thilo Marauhn, ‘Towards a Procedural Law of Compliance Control in International Environmental Relations’, Heidelberg Journal of International Law, 56 (1996), pp. 696-731
50. Kal Raustiala, Reporting and Review Institutions in 10 Multilateral Environmental Agreements (UNEP, 2001).
51. Masayuki Sakamoto, Analysis of the Amended Management System of Domestic Ivory Trade in Japan (JWCS, Jan 1999)
52. Tom Milliken and Louisa Sangalakula, ‘A Report on the Status of the Elephant Trade Information System (ETIS) to COP11', CITES Doc. 11.31.1, Annex 5 (Apr 2000).
53. Kim Howell and Michael Griffin, ‘Regional Reports: Africa’, CITES AC18 Doc. 5.1 (Rev. 1)
54. Kim Howell and Michael Griffin, ‘Regional Reports: Africa’, CITES AC18 Doc. 5.1 (Rev. 1)
55. Kathryn S. Fuller, Ginette Hemley and Sarah Fitzgerald, ‘Wildlife Trade Law Implementation in Developing Countries: the Experience in Latin America’, Boston University International Law Journal, 5 (1987), pp. 289-310.
56. Eric McFadden, ‘Asian Compliance with CITES: Problems and Prospects’, Boston University International Law Journal, 5 (1987), pp. 311-325.
57. Phyllis Mofson, ‘Protecting Wildlife from Trade: Japan’s Involvement in the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species’, Journal of Environment and Development, 3/1 (1994), pp. 91-107.
58. Eric McFadden, ‘Asian Compliance with CITES: Problems and Prospects’, Boston University International Law Journal, 5 (1987), pp. 311-25
59. Phyllis Mofson, ‘Protecting Wildlife from Trade: Japan’s Involvement in the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species’, Journal of Environment and Development, 3/1 (1994), pp. 91-107.
60. Keith Bradsher, ‘Sea Turtles Put New Friction in US-Japan Trade Quarrels’, New York Times (17 May 1991).
61. Elizabeth DeSombre, Domestic Sources of International Environmental Law: Industry, Environmentalists, and US Power (MIT Press, 2000)
62. Phyllis Mofson, ‘Protecting Wildlife from Trade: Japan’s Involvement in the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species’, Journal of Environment and Development, 3/1 (1994), pp. 91-107.
63. Esmond Martin, ‘Ivory, Rhino Horn and other Wildlife Trade in the United Arab Emirates’, Swara Magazine, 15/4 (East African Wildlife Society, 1992) (hereinafter ‘Martin (1992)'), p. 25.
64. A. Kumar, ‘Wildlife Trade in the UAE: April 1991', TRAFFIC Bulletin, 12/3 (1991), p. 78
65. Joanna Langley, ‘Trade in Endangered Species: For Sale: the World’s Wildlife Heritage’, Gulf News (3 Feb 2001).
66. Matthew McAllester, ‘Tough Times for Afghan Animal Traders’, Newsday (10 Feb 2002).
67. Nissar Hoath and Mildred Fernandes, ‘Endangered Primates Confiscated’, Gulf News (29 Jan 2002).
68. K. Nowell, Far from a Cure: The Tiger Trade Revisited (TRAFFIC International, 2000).
69. Debbie Banks, Dave Currey and Faith Doherty, Thailand’s Tiger Economy (EIA, Jun 2001).
70. Esmond Martin and Daniel Stiles, The South and South East Asian Ivory Markets (Save the Elephants, 2002).
71. Godelieve A. Vandeputte, ‘Why the European Community should become a Member of the Convention on the International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES)', Georgetown Environmental Law Review, 3/2 (1990), pp. 245-65
72. Nicole Magel, ‘More than CITES: the EU Wildlife Trade Regulations’, in Monika Anton, Nicholas Dragffy, Stephanie Pendry and Tomme Rozanne Young (eds), Proceedings of the International Expert Workshop on the Enforcement of Wildlife Trade Controls in the EU, 5-6 Nov 2001 (TRAFFIC/IUCN, 2002).
73. ‘Europe Seeks Tougher Enforcement of Wildlife Smuggling Law’, Environment News Service (12 Nov 2001),
74. Monika Anton, Nicholas Dragffy, Stephanie Pendry and Tomme Rozanne Young (eds) Proceedings of the International Expert Workshop on the Enforcement of Wildlife Trade Controls in the EU, 5-6 Nov 2001 (TRAFFIC/IUCN, 2002).
75. .
76. Philippe Sands and Albert Bedecarré, ‘Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species: The Role of Public Interest Non-Governmental Organizations in Ensuring the Effective Enforcement of the Ivory Ban’, Environmental Affairs, 17 (1990). p. 799
77. Rosalind Reeve, ‘The Trade in Reptiles from Madagascar and Comoros: Summary Report’, for IFAW (2002) (hereinafter ‘Reeve/IFAW, 2002')
78. David S. Favre, International Trade in Endangered Species: A Guide to CITES (Kluwer, 1989), at p. 115
79. ‘Russian Guards Seize Sturgeon’, Associated Press (13 Aug 2001).
80. Richard Drew, ‘Authorities Target Outbreak of Caviar Crime’, USA Today (16 Dec 2001).
81. Miguel Llanos, ‘Ban on Caviar Trade Lifted’, MSNBC/Reuters (6 Mar 2002).
82. ‘American Courts Asked to Ban Imports of Beluga Caviar’, Guardian (6 Jun 2002).
83. Ann Michels, History of Species Reviewed under Resolution Conf. 8.9 (Rev.): Part I:Aves (SSN, Jul 2001).
84. Wang Xinxia, ‘The Implementation of CITES in China’, in James Cameron, Jacob Werksman and Peter Roderick (eds), Improving Compliance with International Law (Earthscan, 1996), pp. 204-10.
85. Esmond Martin, UNEP Special Envoy for Rhino Conservation, Final Report (20 Jan 1993) (hereinafter ‘Martin, 1993a’), p. 20.
86. Rhino Horn, Journal of Commerce (17 Nov 1992)
87. Rhino Row’, China News (19 Nov 1992).
88. Michael Werikhe, ‘Taiwan’, unpublished report on file with author (1993).
89. David S. Favre, ‘Trade in Endangered Species’ Yearbook of International Environmental Law, 5 (1994), p. 260
90. David S. Favre, ‘Trade in Endangered Species’, Yearbook of International Environmental Law, 5 (1994), p. 258
91. Lucy Vigne and Esmond Martin, ‘Closing Down the Illegal Trade in Rhino Horn in Yemen’, Pachyderm, 30 (Jan-Jun 2001), p. 87.
92. ‘African Rhinos Edge Back from the Brink’, Environment News Service (12 Jun 2002)
93. Joanna Langley, ‘Trade in Endangered Species: For Sale: the World’s Heritage’, Gulf News (3 Feb 2001).
94. Esmond Martin, ‘What Strategies are Effective for Nepal’s Rhino Conservation: A Recent Case Study’, Pachyderm, 31 (Jul-Dec 2001), p. 42.
95. D. Banks, ‘Tigers and Traditional Medicine - a Study’, in Proceedings of the EU Wildlife Enforcement Workshop, London 1-2 March 1998 (UK DETR, 1998), pp. 93-5
96. Robert Hepworth, ‘Notes of Talk delivered to Discussion Meeting on Enforcing Multilateral Environmental Agreements’ (RIIA, London, 20 Oct 2000).
97. Debbie Banks, Dave Currey and Faith Doherty, Thailand’s Tiger Economy (EIA, Jun 2001).
98. Wang Xi, ‘China’, in Terri Mottershead (ed.), Environmental Law and Enforcement in the Asia-Pacific Rim (Sweet & Maxwell Asia, 2002), p. 95.
99. Terri Mottershead, ‘Hong Kong’, in Terri Mottershead (ed.), Environmental Law and Enforcement in the Asia-Pacific Rim (Sweet & Maxwell Asia, 2002), pp. 184-7.
100. Vivek Menon and Ashok Kumar, Wildlife Crime: an Enforcement Guide (Wildlife Protection Society of India/Natraj Publishers, 1998), p. 14.
101. Deepak Gajurel, ‘Nepal’s New Weapon against Illicit Wildlife Trade’, Environment News Service (25 Jul 2002), .
102. M. Roberts, D. Cook, P. Jones and J. Lowther, Wildlife Crime in the UK: Towards a National Wildlife Crime Unit (DEFRA, 2001). .
103. ‘National Wildlife Crime Intelligence Unit launched at NCIS’, NCIS press release (22 Apr 2002),
104. .
105. M. Brewer, ‘The Partnership for Action against Wildlife Crime: What Is It and What Does It Do?' in Proceedings of the EU Wildlife Law Enforcement Workshop 1-2 March 1998 (UK DETR, 1998), p. 18.
106. Eugene Lapointe, ‘CITES under Siege: A Party Turns a Deaf Ear to the Majority: The Hostile Take-Over Bid’, Conservation Tribune, special edn (IWMC-World Conservation Trust, Sep 1998), p. 5.
107. Jytte Ekdahl, ‘Interpol Wildlife Crime Subgroup: Role and Activities’, in Proceedings of the EU Wildlife Enforcement Workshop, London 1-2 March 1998 (UK DETR, 1998), pp. 77-80
108. .
109. R. Reeve and L. A. Carter, Proceedings of the First African Wildlife Law Enforcement Cooperation Conference, 9-11 Dec 1992 (Zambia Ministry of Tourism).
110. Odhiambo Orlale, ‘Recovered Ivory Originated from Zambia’, Daily Nation (10 Jul 2002), .
111. L. A. Carter and R. Reeve, Proceedings of Working Group 2 Meeting for the Development of the Lusaka Agreement, 26-27 Jun 1993 (Zambia Ministry of Tourism/Kenya Ministry for Tourism and Wildlife).
112. David S. Favre, ‘Trade in Endangered Species: Enforcement Developments’, Yearbook of International Environmental Law, 5 (1994), p. 260.
113. Marceil Yeater, ‘Enforcement and the CITES National Legislation Project’, in Monika Anton, Nicholas Dragffy, Stephanie Pendry and Tomme Rozanne Young (eds), Proceedings of the International Expert Workshop on the Enforcement of Wildlife Trade Controls in the EU, 5-6 Nov 2001 (TRAFFIC/IUCN, 2002).
114. R. Reeve and L. A. Carter (eds), Proceedings of the First African Wildlife Law Enforcement Cooperation Conference, 9-11 Dec 1992 (Zambia Ministry of Tourism).
115. I. Topkov, ‘Summary and Conclusions’, in Proceedings of the EU Wildlife Enforcement Workshop, London 1-2 March 1998 (UK DETR, 1998), p. 107.
116. Peter Haas, ‘Introduction: Epistemic Communities and International Policy Coordination’, International Organization, 46 (1992), p. 3.
117. ‘Suspected Reptiles Exporter Arrested’, Daily Nation (30 May 2000).
118. Rosalind Reeve, The Reptile Trade in Kenya (IFAW, 2002).
119. Tomme Rozanne Young, ‘National Wildlife Trade Regulation in EU Member States’, in Monika Anton, Nicholas Dragffy, Stephanie Pendry and Tomme Rozanne Young (eds), Proceedings of the International Expert Workshop on the Enforcement of Wildlife Trade Controls in the EU, 5-6 Nov 2001 (TRAFFIC/IUCN, 2002).
120. ‘Big Fines, Harsh Words for Tortoise Smugglers’, Pretoria News (13 Dec 2001)
121. ‘Jamaica Imposes Record Fines on Turtle Poachers’, Environment News Service (24 Jan 2002).
122. .
123. David S. Favre, ‘Trade in Endangered Species’, Yearbook of International Environmental Law, 1 (1990), p. 195.
124. David S. Favre, ‘Trade in Endangered Species’, Yearbook of International Environmental Law, 1 (1990), p. 195.
125. David S. Favre, ‘Trade in Endangered Species’, Yearbook of International Environmental Law, 2 (1991), p. 206.
126. ‘A Brief Analysis of the CITES Technical Committees Meetings’, Earth Negotiations Bulletin, 21/17 (18 Dec 2000)
127. .
128. Peter H. Sand, ‘Carrots Without Sticks? New Financial Mechanisms for Global Environmental Agreements’, Max Planck Yearbook of United Nations Law, 3 (1999), pp. 363-88
129. Duncan Brack, ‘Funding Ozone Protection: The Multilateral Fund of the Montreal Protocol’, prepared for Multilateral Fund Secretariat (2001)
130. .
131. .
132. Kal Raustiala, Reporting and Review Institutions in 10 Multilateral Environmental Agreements (UNEP, 2001)
133. Duncan Brack, ‘International Environmental Disputes: International Forums for Noncompliance and Dispute Settlement in Environment-related Cases’, prepared for UK DETR (March 2001)
134. Duncan Brack, ‘Funding Ozone Protection: The Multilateral Fund of the Montreal Protocol’, prepared for the Multilateral Fund Secretariat (2001).
135. Molly Anderson, Verification of the Kyoto Protocol: Filling in the Detail, VERTIC Briefing Paper 02/02 (May 2002).
136. Michael Grubb, Christiaan Vrolijk and Duncan Brack, The Kyoto Protocol: A Guide and Assessment (RIIA/Earthscan, 1999)
137. Farhana Yamin, ‘The Kyoto Protocol:Origins, Assessment and Future Challenges’, RECIEL, 7:2 (1998), p. 113.
138. .
139. Rosalind Reeve, ‘Practical Experience with Visiting Mechanisms in International Environmental Law’, in Visits under Public International Law: Theory and Practice, Proceedings of an APT Workshop, 23-24 September 1999 (Association for the Prevention of Torture, Nov 2000).
140. Jacob Werksman, ‘Compliance and Transition: Russia’s Non-Compliance Tests the Ozone Regime’ Heidelberg Journal of International Law, 56 (1996), pp. 750-73
141. Patrick Széll, ‘The Development of Multilateral Mechanisms for Monitoring Compliance’ in Winfried Lang (ed.), Sustainable Development and International Law (Graham and Trotman, 1995), pp. 97-109
142. Jacob Werksman, ‘Responding to Non-Compliance under the Climate Change Regime’, draft OECD Information Paper on file with author (1998).
143. Jacob Werksman, ‘Responding to Non-Compliance under the Climate Change Regime’, Information Paper for the OECD on file with author (1998).
144. Jacob Werksman, ‘Designing a Compliance System for the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change’, in James Cameron, Jacob Werksman and Peter Roderick (eds), Improving Compliance with International Environmental Law (Earthscan, 1996), pp. 85-147
145. Hermann E. Ott, ‘Elements of a Supervisory Procedure for the Climate Regime’, Heidelberg Journal of International Law, 56/3 (1996), pp. 732-49.
146. Christiaan Vrolijk, A New Interpretation of the Kyoto Protocol: Outcomes from The Hague, Bonn and Marrakesh, RIIA Briefing Paper (Apr 2002),
147. Michael Grubb and Farhana Yamin, ‘Climate Collapse at The Hague: What Happened, Why and Where Do We Go From Here?', International Affairs, 77:2 (Apr 2001), pp. 261-76
148. .
149. Cesare Romano, The ILO System of Supervision and Compliance Control: A Review and Lessons for Multilateral Environmental Agreements (International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis, 1996) (hereinafter ‘Romano’).
150. Peter H. Sand, Lessons Learned in Global Environmental Governance (World Resources Institute, 1990), p. 33
151. E. A. Landy, The Effectiveness of International Supervision: Thirty Years of ILO Experience’ (Stevens & Sons, 1966) which documents ILO case histories.
152. .
153. Thomas J. Schoenbaum, ‘International Trade and Protection of the Environment: The Continuing Search for Reconciliation’, American Journal of International Law, 91 (1997), p. 288
154. Duncan Brack, Trade and Environment after Seattle, RIIA Briefing Paper (Mar 2000).
155. James Cameron and Karen Campbell, ‘Challenging the Boundaries of the DSU through Trade and Environment Disputes’, in James Cameron and Karen Campbell (ed.), Dispute Resolution in the World Trade Organization (Cameron May, 1998).
156. Duncan Brack, ‘The US Shrimp-Turtle Case: Implications for the Multilateral Environmental Agreement - World Trade Organization Debate’, Yearbook of International Environmental Law, 9, (1998) (Oxford University Press, 2000).
157. .
158. Duncan Brack, ‘Environmental Treaties and Trade: Multilateral Environmental Agreements and the Multilateral Trading System’, in Gary P. Sampson and W. Bradnee Chambers (eds), Trade, Environment and the Millennium (second edition) (United Nations University Press, 2001) (hereinafter ‘Brack (2001b)).
159. Thomas J. Schoenbaum, ‘International Trade and Protection of the Environment: The Continuing Search for Reconciliation’, American Journal of International Law, 91 (1997), p. 281.
160. Steve Charnovitz, ‘The Role of Trade Measures in Treaties’, in Agata Fijalkowski and James Cameron (eds), Trade and the Environment:Bridging the Gap (Cameron May, 1998)
161. Duncan Brack, Michael Grubb and Craig Windram, International Trade and Climate Change Policies (RIIA/Earthscan, 1999).
162. Christoph Bail, Robert Falkner and Helen Marquard (eds), The Cartagena Protocol on Biosafety:Reconciling Trade in Biotechnology with Environment and Development? (RIIA/Earthscan, 2002).
163. .
164. Duncan Brack, ‘The US Shrimp-Turtle Case: Implications for the Multilateral Environmental Agreement-World Trade Organization Debate’, Yearbook of International Environmental Law, 9 (1998) (Oxford University Press, 2000).
165. .
166. ‘UNEP and WTO Promote Synergies between Trade and Environment’, Bridges Weekly Trade News Digest (27 Oct 2000), .