International variations in primary care physician consultation time: A systematic review of 67 countries

BMJ Open

Volumn 7, Issue 10, 2017, Pages

  Irving, Greg ^a   Neves, Ana Luisa ^b,c   Dambha Miller, Hajira ^a,d   Oishi, Ai ^e   Tagashira, Hiroko ^f   Verho, Anistasiya ^g,h   Holden, John ⁱ  

^a UNIVERSITY OF CAMBRIDGE   (United Kingdom)

^b UNIVERSITY OF PORTO   (Portugal)

^c IMPERIAL COLLEGE LONDON   (United Kingdom)

^d UNIVERSITY OF OXFORD   (United Kingdom)

^e UNIVERSITY OF EDINBURGH   (United Kingdom)

^f OXFORD UNIVERSITY HOSPITALS NHS FOUNDATION TRUST   (United Kingdom)

^g UNIVERSITY OF HELSINKI   (Finland)

^h National Institutefor Health and Welfare (THL)   (United Kingdom)

ⁱ Garswood Surgery   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

consultation; global health; primary care

Indexed keywords

BANGLADESH; CHINESE; CONSULTATION; ELECTRONIC PATIENT RECORD; EMBASE; GENERAL PRACTITIONER; HEALTH SERVICE; HUMAN; JAPANESE (PEOPLE); LINEAR REGRESSION ANALYSIS; LOW INCOME COUNTRY; MEDLINE; MIDDLE INCOME COUNTRY; OBSERVATIONAL STUDY; PATIENT SATISFACTION; PRIVATE PRACTICE; REVIEW; SWEDEN; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW; AMBULATORY CARE; DOCTOR PATIENT RELATION; GENERAL PRACTICE; HOSPITAL MANAGEMENT; ORGANIZATION AND MANAGEMENT; PATIENT REFERRAL; STATISTICS AND NUMERICAL DATA; TIME FACTOR;

APPOINTMENTS AND SCHEDULES; FAMILY PRACTICE; HUMANS; OFFICE VISITS; PATIENT SATISFACTION; PHYSICIAN-PATIENT RELATIONS; PHYSICIANS, PRIMARY CARE; REFERRAL AND CONSULTATION; TIME FACTORS;

EID: 85042152173     PISSN: None     EISSN: 20446055     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1136/bmjopen-2017-017902     Document Type: Review

References (139)

1. Starfield B, Shi L, Macinko J. Contribution of primary care to health systems and health. Milbank Q 2005;83:457-502.
2. Wilson A, McDonald P, Hayes L, et al. Longer booking intervals in general practice: effects on doctors' stress and arousal. Br J Gen Pract 1991;41:184-7.
3. Osborn R, Moulds D, Schneider EC, et al. Primary care physicians in ten countries report challenges caring for patients with complex health needs. Health Aff 2015;34:2104-12.
4. Mercer SW, Hasegawa H, Reilly D, et al. Length of consultations. Time and stress are limiting holistic care in Scotland. BMJ 2002;325:1241.
5. Kringos DS. De sterkte van de eerste lijn in Europa, 2012.
6. Mercer SW, Fitzpatrick B, Gourlay G, et al. More time for complex consultations in a high-deprivation practice is associated with increased patient enablement. Br J Gen Pract 2007;57:960-6 http:// bjgp. org/ content/ 57/ 545/ 960
7. Akl OA, El Mahalli AA, Elkahky AA, et al. WHO/INRUD drug use indicators at primary healthcare centers in Alexandria, Egypt. J Taibah Univ Med Sci 2014;9:54-64.
8. Kringos D, Boerma W, Bourgueil Y, et al. The strength of primary care in Europe: an international comparative study. Br J Gen Pract 2013;63:742-50.
9. Wilson A, Childs S. The relationship between consultation length, process and outcomes in general practice: a systematic review. Br J Gen Pract 2002;52:1012-20 http://www. ncbi. nlm. nih. gov/ pubmed/ 12528590
10. Prescription and Dispensing Practices in Public Sector Health Facilities in Pakistan: Survey Report.
11. Chattopadhyay A, Mondal T, Saha T, et al. An audit of prescribing practices in CGHS dispensaries of Kolkata. India, 2013.
12. Wilson AD, Childs S. Effects of interventions aimed at changing the length of primary care physicians' consultation. Cochrane database Syst Rev 2006:CD003540.
13. Hutton C, Gunn J, et al. Do longer consultations improve the management of psychological problems in general practice? A systematic literature review. BMC Health Serv Res 2007;7:71.
14. Mercer SW, Fitzpatrick B, Guthrie B, et al. The CARE Plus study-A whole-system intervention to improve quality of life of primary care patients with multimorbidity in areas of high socioeconomic deprivation: exploratory cluster randomised controlled trial and cost-utility analysis. BMC Med 2016;14:88.
15. Mercer SW, Watt GCM. The inverse care law: clinical primary care encounters in deprived and affluent areas of Scotland. Ann Fam Med 2007;5:503-10.
16. McWhinney IR, Stewart M. Innovative consultation time as a common European currency. Eur J Gen Pract 1995;1:175.
17. Holden JD. Hawthorne effects and research into professional practice. J Eval Clin Pract 2001;7:65-70.
18. Pringle M, Stewart-Evans C. Does awareness of being video recorded affect doctors' consultation behaviour? Br J Gen Pract 1990;40:455-8.
19. Outomuro D, Actis AM. Analysis of ambulatory consultation length in medical clinics]. Rev medica Chile 2013;141:361-6.
20. World Health Organization. The World Medicines Situation: Chapter 8. Rational use of medicines. Geneva, 2004:75-92
21. StataCorp. Stata Statistical Software: Release 13. College Station, TX: StataCorp LP, 2013
22. NIH Quality Assessment Tool for Observational Cohort and Cross-Sectional Studies. https://www. nhlbi. nih. gov/ health-pro/ guidelines/ in-develop/ cardiovascular-risk-reduction/ tools/ cohort (accessed 6 July 2017).
23. European Forum of Medical Associations and WHO. http://www. efma-forum. com/ index. php/ efma-members/ national-medicalassociations (accessed 6 July 2017).
24. OECD Health Care Resources. https:// stats. oecd. org/ Index. aspx? DataSetCode= HEALTH-REAC (accessed 6 July 2017).
25. Nivel: Primary Care in Europe. https://www. nivel. nl/ en/ primary-care (accessed 6 July 2017).
26. Soler JK, Yaman H, Esteva M, et al. Burnout in European family doctors: the EGPRN study. Fam Pract 2008;25:245-65.
27. van den Berg MJ, van Loenen T, Westert GP. Accessible and continuous primary care may help reduce rates of emergency department use. An international survey in 34 countries. Fam Pract 2016;33:42-50.
28. Osborn R, Moulds D, Schneider EC, et al. Primary Care Physicians In Ten Countries Report Challenges Caring For Patients With Complex Health Needs. Health Aff 2015;34:2104-12.
29. Eurobarometer. http://www. gesis. org/ eurobarometer-data-service/ home/ (accessed 6 July 2017).
30. Hobbs FDR, Bankhead C, Mukhtar T, et al. Clinical workload in UK primary care: a retrospective analysis of 100 million consultations in England, 2007-14. Lancet 2016;387:2323-30.
31. Nizami S, Khan I, Bhutta Z. Paediatric prescribing in Karachi. J Pak Med Assoc 1997.
32. Jin G, Zhao Y, Chen C, et al. The length and content of general practice consultation in two Urban districts of Beijing: a preliminary observation study. PLoS One 2015;10:e0135121.
33. Guyon AB, Barman A, Ahmed JU, et al. A baseline survey on use of drugs at the primary health care level in Bangladesh. Bull World Health Organ 1994;72:265-71.
34. Nizami SQ, Khan IA, Bhutta ZA. Drug prescribing practices of general practitioners and paediatricians for childhood diarrhoea in Karachi, Pakistan. Soc Sci Med 1996;42:1133-9.
35. Reeve J, Dowrick CF, Freeman GK, et al. Examining the practice of generalist expertise: a qualitative study identifying constraints and solutions. JRSM Short Rep 2013;4:204253331351015.
36. ISRCTN-ISRCTN34092919: Living well with multiple morbidity.
37. Collings J. General practice in ENGLAND today-A reconnaissance. Lancet 1950;255:555.
38. Irving G, Reeve J. Do GPs really provide 47 minutes a year for the patient? Br J Gen Pract 2012;62:404-5.
39. Saunders CL, Elliott MN, Lyratzopoulos G, et al. Beyond the ecological fallacy: potential problems when studying healthcare organisations. J R Soc Med 2016;109:92-7.
40. Australian GP Statistics and Classification Centre. General practice activity in Australia 2006-07, 2006.
41. NAMCS/NHAMCS-About the Ambulatory Health Care Surveys. https://www. cdc. gov/ nchs/ ahcd/ index. htm (accessed 6 July 2017).
42. Afghanistan Medicine Use Study: A Survey of 28 Health Facilities in 5 Provinces, 2009
43. Britt H, Valenti L, Miller G. Time for care. Length of general practice consultations in Australia. Aust Fam Physician 2002;31:876-80.
44. Health Information Directorate. Health Statistics 2007. Bahrain: Arabian Printing Press, 2007.
45. Hogerzeil HV, Ross-Degnan D, et al. Field tests for rational drug use in twelve developing countries. Lancet 1993;342:1408-10.
46. Ahmed SM, Islam QS. Availability and rational use of drugs in primary healthcare facilities following the National drug policy of 1982: is Bangladesh on right track? J Health Popul Nutr 2012;30:99-108.
47. Alamgir H, Ahmed M. Studies on Drug Use Pattern and Cost Efficiency in Upozila Health Complexes in Dhaka Division of Bangladesh. Am Sci Res J ? 2015.
48. Deveugele M, Derese A. Consultation length in general practice: cross sectional study in six European countries. BMJ 2002;325:472.
49. INAMI/RIZIV. Register van de huisartsen: aantal en profiel van de huisartsen in 2005, 2005.
50. dos SV, Nitrini S. Indicadores do uso de medicamentos prescritos e de assistência ao paciente de serviços de saúde. Rev Saude Publica 2004;38:819-34.
51. Lopes AEC, Teixeira ACA, Gurgel MLF. Drug use of evaluation in health services in Fortaleza, Brasil. INRUD 1996;6.
52. Cunha M, Zorzatto J, Castro L. Avaliacao do uso de medicamentos na Rede Publica Municipal de Saude de Campo Grande/MS, 2002.
53. Portela A, Silva PCDda, Simões MOdaS, et al. Indicadores de prescrição e de cuidado ao paciente na atenção básica do município de Esperança, Paraíba, 2007. Epidemiol e Servicos Saude 2012;21:341-50.
54. Marcondes NSP. A assistencia farmaceutica basica e o uso de medicamentos na zona urbana do municipio de Ponta Grosssa. Paraná: estudo de caso, 2002.
55. Kringos DS, Boerma WGW, Spaan E, et al. Evaluation of the organizational model of primary care in Turkey: a survey-based pilot project in two provinces of Turkey. 2008 http://www. narcis. nl/ publication/ RecordID/ publicat% 3A1001602
56. Chareonkul C, Khun VL, Boonshuyar C. Rational drug use in Cambodia: Study of three pilot health centers in Kampong Thom province. Southeast Asian J Trop Med Public Health 2002;33:418-24.
57. Wolfe S, Badgley RF, Kasius RV, et al. The work of a group of doctors in Saskatchewan. Milbank Mem Fund Q 1968;46:103-29.
58. Collyer JA. A Family Doctor's Time. Can Fam physician Medecin Fam Can 1969;15:63-9.
59. Stewart M, Brown JB, Weston WW. Patient-Centred Interviewing Part III: Five Provocative Questions. Can Fam physician Medecin Fam Can 1989;35:159-61.
60. Ugalde A, Homedes N. Estudio de consulta externa en Costa Rica. Development Technologies, San José, Costa Rica 1988;1988.
61. Ozvacić Adzić Z, Katić M, Kern J, et al. Patient, physician, and practice characteristics related to patient enablement in general practice in Croatia: cross-sectional survey study. Croat Med J 2008;49:813-23.
62. Embaye A. Drug Use Studies in Eritrean Health Facilities, 1999.
63. Tähepõld H, Maaroos H, Kalda R, et al. Structure and duration of consultations in Estonian family practice. Scand J Prim Health Care 2009.
64. Mulugeta T, Angamo NTW. Assessment of patterns of drug use by using World Health Organization's Prescribing, patient care and health facility indicators in selected health facilities in Southwest Ethiopia. J Appl Pharm Sci 2011;1:62-6.
65. Desta Z, Abula T, Beyene L, et al. Assessment of rational drug use and prescribing in primary health care facilities in north west Ethiopia. East Afr Med J 1997;74:758-63.
66. Srikanth B. A prospective study on evaluation of use of drugs at prescriber, dispenser and patients level based on 'who' core drug. Editor board. h ttps ://www.r esearchg ate.net/profi le/ Akshaya-B hagavathul a/ publication/ 254559 382 A-PROSPECT IVE STU DY-ON-EVA LUA TION-OF-USE OF-DRUGS-AT-P RESCRIBER DISPE NSER-A ND-PATI ENTS-LEVEL BAS ED-ON-WHO-C ORE DRUG-USE INDIC ATOR S IN ETH IOPI A/links/ 0046351fcf7ade2310000000.p
67. Kuusela M, Vainiomäki P, Kiviranta A, et al. The Missing Evaluation at the End of GP's Consultation. Int J Family Med 2013;2013:1-6.
68. Breuil-Genier PGC. La durée des séances des médecins généralistes. Etudes Result 2006:481-8.
69. Fry J. Hong Kong: Need for improvement in primary care. Lancet 1990;336:558.
70. Sharma J, Kataria M, Gandhi H. Quality of medical care by central government health scheme-A study. Heal Popul 1978 http:// europepmc. org/ abstract/ med/ 10247249
71. Sarwal R. Reforming Central Government Health Scheme into a 'Universal Health Coverage'model. Natl Med J INDIA 2015.
72. Roy Chaudhury R, et al. Quality medicines for the poor: experience of the Delhi programme on rational use of drugs. Health Policy Plan 2005;20:124-36.
73. Promoting rational use of drugs in indonesia.
74. Khori V, Changizi S, Biuckians E, et al. Relationship between consultation length and rational prescribing of drugs in Gorgan City, Islamic Republic of Iran. EMHJ 2012;18:480-6.
75. Omer W. Use of mobile phones to calculate consultation time and comparing with perceived time in private clinics in erbil city, Iraq. 141st APHA Annual Meeting and Exposition (November 2-November 6, 2013): APHA, 2013.
76. Vinker S, Nathan T. Annual accumulated duration of time of primary care visits and its association in preventive medicine: A crosssectional study.
77. Ohtaki S, Ohtaki T, Fetters MD. Doctor-patient communication: a comparison of the USA and Japan. Fam Pract 2003;20:276-82.
78. Wooldridge AN, Arató N, Sen A, et al. Truth or fallacy? Three hour wait for three minutes with the doctor: Findings from a private clinic in rural Japan. Asia Pac Fam Med 2010;9:11.
79. Mochizuki A. Conference proceeding of The 3rd JPCA academic conference:258.
80. Evaluation of Drug Use in Jordan Using WHO Patient Care and Health Facility Indicators.
81. Performance of health providers in primary health care services in Jordan, 2004.
82. Awad A, Al-Saffar N. Evaluation of drug use practices at primary healthcare centers of Kuwait. Eur J Clin Pharmacol 2010.
83. Institution T personal health care. Year analysis of patients state fund of Vilnius Zone 2008.
84. Sosola A. An assessment of prescribing and dispensing practices in public health facilities of southern Malawi, 2007.
85. Sciortino P. A service profile of maltese general practitioners. A provider survey of the general practice component of the Maltese Health Care system 2002.
86. Dahal P, Bhattarai B, Adhikari D, et al. Drug use pattern in Primary Health Care facilities of Kaski District, Western Nepal. Sunsari Tech 2013;1:1-8 http://www. nepjol. info/ index. php/ STCJ/ article/ view/ 8652
87. Berg MJ, Kolthof ED. De Bakker DH.Vder ZJ. Second Dutch National Study of diseases and procedurs in general practice. The workload of general practitioners 2004.
88. Baker AS. What do New Zealand general practitioners do in their offices? N Z Med J 1976;83:187-90.
89. Chedi B. Drug use pattern in out-patient children: a comparison between primary and secondary health care facilities in Northern Nigeria. Afr J Pharm Pharmacol 2015;9:74-81.
90. Mjell J. Pasientene tror vi har god tid. Utposten 1989;4:182-3.
91. Gadgil ME. Average consultation length per GP. Norway, 2009.
92. Thaver I. Prescribing patterns of primary care providers in squatter areas of Karachi. JOURNAL-PAKISTAN Med Assoc 1995.
93. Perú (AMF 2015). Ser médico de familia en. http:// amf-semfyc. com/ web/ article-ver. php? id= 1497
94. Pawlikowska TRB, Walker JJ, Nowak PR, et al. Patient involvement in assessing consultation quality: a quantitative study of the Patient Enablement Instrument in Poland. Health Expect 2010;13:13-23.
95. Nogueira JD. Duracao da Consulta: Perspectivas dos Medicos e dos Pacientes, 2002, 2002.
96. Granja M, Ponte C, Cavadas LF. What keeps family physicians busy in Portugal? A multicentre observational study of work other than direct patient contacts. BMJ Open 2014;4:e005026.
97. Bener A, Almarri S, Ali B, et al. Do minutes count for health care? Consultation length in a tertiary care teaching hospital and in general practice. Middle East J Fam 2007 http://www. mejfm. com/ journal/ Jan2007/ MEJFM-Jan2007. pdf# page=3
98. Tehepold H. Patient consultation in family medicine. Dissertation of the degree of doctor of medical sciences 2006.
99. Evaluation of the organizational model of primary care in the Russian Federation. 2014.
100. Al-Shammari SAI. Factors associated with consultation Time in Riyad Primary Health Care Centres, Saudi Arabia. Saudi Med J 1991;12:371-5.
101. James E, Assawaf K, Zarie AH, et al. Factors influencing rational drug use in primary health care centres in Qassim region, Saudi Arabia. Saudi Pharm J 2003;11:126-35.
102. El Mahalli AA, Oam A, Al-Dawood SF, et al. WHO/INRUD patient care and facility-specific drug use indicators at primary health care centres in Eastern province, Saudi Arabia. East Mediterr Heal J = La Rev sante la Mediterr Orient = al-Majallah al-s. ih. h. iyah li-sharq al-mutawassit 2012;18:1086-90.
103. Al-Abbad H. Gender Differences in Consultation Time and its Relation to Patient's Satisfaction: a cross-sectional study at King Khalid University Primary Health Care Clinics. From Ed 2015.
104. Balbaid O, Al-Dawood K. Factors associated with patient's care during consultation in ministry of health facilities, Jeddah city, Saudi Arabia. J Fam community 1997 http://www. ncbi. nlm. nih. gov/ pmc/ articles/ PMC3437133/
105. Stojanović B, Janković S. An analysis of drug use indicators within primary care health facilities in Jagodina. Medicus 2002.
106. Voo YO. Consultation length and case mix in a general practice clinic. Singapore Med J 1999;40:13-17.
107. Svab I, Petek Ster M, Kersnik J, et al. Cross sectional study of performance of Slovene General practitioners. Zdr var 2005;44:183-92.
108. Petek Ster M, Svab I, Zivcec Kalan G. Factors related to consultation time: experience in Slovenia. Scand J Prim Health Care 2008;26:29-34.
109. Hart JT. Primary medical care in Spain. Br J Gen Pract 1990;40:255-8.
110. P U, I. G. Estudio sobre el uso de los medicamentos en un área de salud por medio de una encuesta. Ars Pharm 2001;42:185-202.
111. Rational Use of Medicine Pratical Work Paper-Documents.
112. Andersson SO, Mattsson B. Length of consultations in general practice in Sweden: views of doctors and patients. Fam Pract 1989;6:130-4.
113. inrud news. INRUD News, 1992:3:3.
114. Nsimba SED. Assessing prescribing and patient care indicators for children under five years old with malaria and other disease conditions in public primary health care facilities. Southeast Asian J Trop Med Public Health 2006;37:206-14.
115. Kringos DS, Boerma WGW, Spaan E, et al. A snapshot of the organization and provision of primary care in Turkey. BMC Health Serv Res 2011;11:90.
116. Sensoy N. A Research on Patient Satisfaction with Primary Health Care in the Center of Afyonkarahisar. J Clin Anal Med 2014;5:29-34.
117. Eczacinin Sesi: Pratisyen Hekimlerin Recete Yazimini Sekillendiren Faktorler.
118. Minstry of Health. Annual Health Report, Ministry of Health,. Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates 2004.
119. Ah A. Consultation Length in Primary Health Care: Is It Getting Longer? Amani Al Hajeri.
120. Abdul Rasool BK, Fahmy SA, Abu-Gharbieh EF, et al. Prácticas profesionales y percepción sobre el uso racional de medicamentos según la metodología de OMS en Emiratos Arabes Unidos. Pharm Pract;8:70-6.
121. Fry J. A year in General Practice: a study of morbidity. 1952;2:249-52.
122. Watt C. A year of General Practice. BMJ 1952;2:115-6.
123. Mair A, Mair G. Facts of importance to the organisation of the national health service from a five year study of general practice. Bmj 1959;1:281-4.
124. Crombie DL, Cross KW. The work-load in general practice. Lancet 1964;2:354-6 http://www. ncbi. nlm. nih. gov/ pubmed/ 14172341
125. Morrell DC. Expressions of morbidity in general practice. Br Med J 1971;2:454-8.
126. Scottish Home and Health Department. The study of consultations in general practice: Scottish health service statistics. 1973;27.
127. Hughes D. Consultation length and outcome in two group general practices. J R Coll Gen Pract 1983;33:143-7.
128. Wilkin D, Metcalfe DH. List size and patient contact in general medical practice. Br Med J 1984;289:1501-5.
129. Department of Health and Social Security. General medical practitioners' workload. A report prepared for the doctors' and dentists' review body. London 1985.
130. Peter L, Tate JB, Catchpole PJ. Practice activity analysis: collaboration between general practitioners and a family practitioner committee. J R Coll Gen Pract 1989;39:297-9.
131. Ogden J, Bavalia K, Bull M, et al. "I want more time with my doctor": a quantitative study of time and the consultation. Fam Pract 2004;21:479-83.
132. HSCIC. 2006/2007 GP workload survey, 2007.
133. Bwera A, Lamunu M. Survey of essential drug use in Rakai district Uganda, June, 1996. J Clin 1997 https:// scholar. google. co. uk/ scholar? start= 60& q= INRUD+ AND+% 22consultation+ time% 22+ OR+% 22+ consultation+ length% 22+& hl= en& as-sdt= 0, 5#0
134. Marvel MK, Epstein RM, Flowers K, et al. Soliciting the Patient's Agenda. JAMA 1999;281:283.
135. Rhoades DR, McFarland KF, Finch WH, et al. Speaking and interruptions during primary care office visits. Fam Med;33:528-32.
136. Blankfield RP, Goodwin M, Jaén CR, et al. Addressing the unique challenges of inner-city practice: a direct observation study of inner-city, rural, and suburban family practices. J Urban Health 2002;79:173-85.
137. Prescriptionpatternsf O. Micky Ndhlovu, 2009. http:// 146. 141. 12. 21/ handle/ 10539/ 8006
138. Public sector survey 2000. Harare, Directorate of Pharmacy Services Ministry of Health and Child Welfare. Zimbabwe 2000.
139. Trap B, Hansen E, Hogerzeil H. Prescription habits of dispensing and non-dispensing doctors in Zimbabwe. Health Policy Plan 2002.