Geographic and demographic correlates of autism-related anti-vaccine beliefs on Twitter, 2009-15

Social Science and Medicine

Volumn 191, Issue , 2017, Pages 168-175

  Tomeny, Theodore S ^a   Vargo, Christopher J ^b   El Toukhy, Sherine ^c  

^a UNIVERSITY OF ALABAMA   (United States)

^b UNIVERSITY OF COLORADO   (United States)

^c NATIONAL INSTITUTE ON MINORITY HEALTH AND HEALTH DISPARITIES   (United States)

Author keywords

Autism spectrum disorder; Beliefs; Big data; Machine learning algorithms; Social media; Twitter; Vaccines

Indexed keywords

ALGORITHM; DEMOGRAPHY; GEOGRAPHICAL DISTRIBUTION; INTERNET; MACHINE LEARNING; MENTAL HEALTH; SOCIAL MEDIA; TEMPORAL VARIATION; VACCINE;

ADOLESCENT; ADULT; AGE; ARTICLE; AUTISM; BIRTH; CALIFORNIA; CONNECTICUT; CONTROLLED STUDY; CORRELATIONAL STUDY; DEMOGRAPHY; EDUCATIONAL STATUS; FEMALE; GENDER; GEOGRAPHIC DISTRIBUTION; HEALTH BELIEF; HIGHEST INCOME GROUP; HOUSEHOLD; HUMAN; INFORMATION DISSEMINATION; MACHINE LEARNING; MALE; MASSACHUSETTS; NEW YORK; ONLINE SYSTEM; PENNSYLVANIA; POPULATION RESEARCH; PUBLIC OPINION; SOCIAL MEDIA; THERAPEUTIC MISCONCEPTION; TREND STUDY; VACCINATION; ANTI-VACCINATION MOVEMENT; ATTITUDE TO HEALTH; DEVICES; GEOGRAPHIC MAPPING; PSYCHOLOGY;

UNITED STATES;

ANTI-VACCINATION MOVEMENT; ATTITUDE TO HEALTH; AUTISTIC DISORDER; GEOGRAPHIC MAPPING; HUMANS; SOCIAL MEDIA; VACCINATION;

EID: 85029469486     PISSN: 02779536     EISSN: 18735347     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2017.08.041     Document Type: Article

References (93)

1. Adams, D., Thomas, K., Jajosky, R., et al. Summary of notifiable infectious diseases and conditions – United States 2014. Morb. Mortal. Wkly. Rep. 63 (2016), 1–152.
2. Anderson, M., 5 facts about Vaccines in the U.S. 2015, Pew Research Center.
3. Avery, E.J., Lariscy, R.W., Preventable disease practices among a lower SES, multicultural, nonurban, U.S. community: the roles of vaccination efficacy and personal constraints. Health Commun. 29 (2014), 826–836.
4. Bazzano, A., Zeldin, A., Schuster, E., Barrett, C., Lehrer, D., Vaccine-related beliefs and practices of parents of children with autism spectrum disorders. Am. J. Intellect. Dev. Disabil. 117 (2012), 233–242.
5. Bean, S.J., Emerging and continuing trends in vaccine opposition website content. Vaccine 29 (2011), 1874–1880.
6. Begg, N., Ramsay, M., White, J., Bozoky, Z., Media dents confidence in MMR vaccine. Br. Med. J., 316, 1998, 561.
7. Betsch, C., Brewer, N.T., Brocard, P., Davies, P., Gaissmaier, W., Haase, N., et al. Opportunities and challenges of Web 2.0 for vaccination decisions. Vaccine 30 (2012), 3727–3733.
8. Betsch, C., Renkewitz, F., Betsch, T., Ulshofer, C., The influence of vaccine-critical websites on perceiving vaccination risks. J. Health Psychol. 15 (2010), 446–455.
9. Bradley, A., The use of the area under the ROC curve in the evaluation of machine learning algorithms. Pattern Recognit. 30 (1997), 1145–1159.
10. Brewer, N., Chapman, G., Gibbons, F., Gerrard, M., McCaul, K., Weinstein, N., Meta-analysis of the relationship between risk perception and health behavior: the example of vaccination. Health Psychol. 26 (2007), 136–145.
11. Broniatowski, D.A., Paul, M.J., Dredze, M., National and local influenza surveillance through twitter: an analysis of the 2012-2013 influenza epidemic. PLoS One, 8, 2013, e83672.
12. Call, K.T., Davern, M., Boudreaux, M., Johnson, P.J., Nelson, J., Bias in telephone surveys that do not sample cell phones. Med. Care 49 (2011), 355–364.
13. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Achievements in public health, 1900-1999 impacts of vaccines universally recommended for children – United States, 1990-1998. Morb. Mortal. Wkly. Rep. 48 (1999), 243–248.
14. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Recommended childhood and adolescent immunization schedule–United States, January-June 2004. Morb. Mortal. Wkly. Rep., 53, 2004 Q1.
15. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Vaccines Do Not Cause Autism. 2015.
16. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (n.d.). Science summary: CDC studies on thimerosal in vaccines.
17. Chen, R.T., DeStefano, F., Vaccine adverse events: causal or coincidental?. Lancet 351 (1998), 611–612.
18. Chen, R.T., Hibbs, B., Vaccine safety: current and future challenges. Pediatr. Ann. 27 (1998), 445–455.
19. Christensen, D., Baio, J., Van Naarden Braun, K., Bilder, D., Charles, J., Constantino, J.M., et al. Prevalence and characteristics of autism spectrum disorder among children aged 8 years – autism and developmental disabilities monitoring networks, 11 sites, United States, 2012. Morb. Mortal. Wkly. Rep. 65 (2016), 1–23.
20. Chu, S.Y., Barker, L.E., Smith, P.J., Racial/ethnic disparities in preschool immunizations: United States, 1996-2001. Am. J. Public Health 94 (2004), 973–977.
21. Cole-Lewis, H., Pugatch, J., Sanders, A., Varghese, A., Posada, S., Yun, C., et al. Social listening: a content analysis of e-cigarette discussions on Twitter. J. Med. Internet Res., 17, 2015, e243.
22. Diekema, D.S., Responding to parental refusals of immunization of children. Pediatrics 115 (2005), 1428–1431.
23. Diresta, R., Lotan, G., Anti-vaxxers are using Twitter to manipulate a vaccine bill. Wired, 2015 Retrieved from: https://www.wired.com/2015/06/antivaxxers-influencing-legislation/.
24. Dredze, M., Broniatowski, D.A., Smith, M.C., Hilyard, K.M., Understanding vaccine refusal why we need social media now. Am. J. Prev. Med. 50 (2016), 550–552.
25. Duggan, M., Mobile messaging and Social Media 2015. 2015, Pew Research Center.
26. Duggan, M., Ellison, N.B., Lampe, C., Lenhart, A., Madden, M., Social Media Update 2014. 2015, Pew Research Center.
27. Feikin, D.R., Lezotte, D.C., Hamman, R.F., Salmon, D.A., Chen, R.T., Hoffman, R.E., Individual and community risks of measles and pertussis associated with personal exemptions to immunization. JAMA 284 (2000), 3145–3150.
28. Firger, J., California bans religious and philosophical vaccine exemptions for schoolchildren. Newsweek, 2015 Retrieved from: http://www.newsweek.com/california-bans-religious-and-philosophical-vaccine-exemptions-schoolchildren-346987.
29. Fischbach, R.L., Harris, M.J., Ballan, M.S., Fischbach, G.D., Link, B.G., Is there concordance in attitudes and beliefs between parents and scientists about autism spectrum disorder?. Autism 20 (2016), 353–363.
30. Freed, G.L., Clark, S.J., Butchart, A.T., Singer, D.C., Davis, M.M., Parental vaccine safety concerns in 2009. Pediatrics 125 (2010), 654–659.
31. Fronstin, P., Sources of health insurance and characteristics of the uninsured: analysis of the March 2005 current population survey. EBRI Issue Brief., 287, 2005.
32. Ginsberg, J., Mohebbi, M.H., Patel, R.S., Brammer, L., Smolinski, M.S., Brilliant, L., Detecting influenza epidemics using search engine query data. Nature 457 (2009), 1012–1014.
33. Google, Google Places API. 2016, Google, Mountain View, CA.
34. Guo, D., Chen, C., Detecting non-personal and spam users on geotagged twitter network. Trans. GIS 18 (2014), 370–384.
35. Gust, D., Strine, T., Maurice, E., Smith, P., Yusuf, H., Wilkinson, M., et al. Underimmunization among children: effects of vaccine safety concerns on immunization status. Pediatrics 114 (2004), e16–e22.
36. Gust, D.A., Brown, C.J., Sheedy, K., Hibbs, B., Weaver, D., Nowak, G., Immunization attitudes and beliefs among parents: beyond a dichotomous perspective. Am. J. Health Behav. 29 (2005), 81–92.
37. Gust, D.A., Darling, N., Kennedy, A.M., Schwartz, B., Parents with doubts about vaccines: which vaccines and reasons why. Pediatrics 122 (2008), 718–725.
38. Hackett, A.J., Risk, its perception and the media: the MMR controversy. Community Pract. 81 (2008), 22–25.
39. Hill, H.A., Vaccination coverage among children aged 19–35 months—United States, 2015. Morb. Mortal. Wkly. Rep., 65, 2016.
40. Hill, H.A., Elam-Evans, L.D., Yankey, D., Singleton, J.A., Kolasa, M., National, state, and selected local area vaccination coverage among children aged 19–35 months — United States, 2014. Morb. Mortal. Wkly. Rep. 64 (2015), 889–896.
41. Hviid, A., Stellfeld, M., Wohlfahrt, J., Melbye, M., Association between thimerosal-containing vaccine and autism. J. Am. Med. Assoc. 290 (2003), 1763–1766.
42. Institute of Medicine Board on Health Promotion and Disease Prevention, Immunization Safety Review. Vaccines and Autism. 2004, The National Academies Press, Washington D C.
43. Joint statement of the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) and the United States Public Health Service (USPHS), Pediatrics 104 (1999), 568–569.
44. Kata, A., Anti-vaccine activists, Web 2.0, and the postmodern paradigm – an overview of tactics and tropes used online by the anti-vaccination movement. Vaccine 30 (2012), 3778–3789.
45. Kennedy, A.M., Basket, M., Sheedy, K., Vaccine attitudes, concerns, and information sources reported by parents of young children: results from the 2009 HealthStyles Survey. Pediatrics 127 (2011), S92–S99.
46. Kim, A.E., Hansen, H.M., Murphy, J., Richards, A.K., Duke, J., Allen, J.A., Methodological considerations in analyzing Twitter data. JNCI Monogr. 47 (2013), 140–146.
47. Krumpal, I., Determinants of social desirability bias in sensitive surveys: a literature review. Qual. Quant. 47 (2013), 2025–2047.
48. Landis, J.R., Koch, G.G., The measurement of observer agreement for categorical data. Biometrics 33 (1977), 159–174.
49. Larson, H.J., Jarrett, C., Eckersberger, E., Smith, D., M.D, Paterson, P., Understanding vaccine hesitancy around vaccines and vaccination from a global perspective: a systematic review of published literature, 2007–2012. Vaccine 32 (2014), 2150–2159.
50. Lieu, T., Ray, G.T., Klein, N.P., Chung, C., Kulldorff, M., Geographic clusters in underimmunization and vaccine refusal. Pediatrics 135 (2015), 280–289.
51. Love, B., Himelboim, I., Holton, A., Stewart, K., Twitter as a source of vaccination information: content drivers and what they are saying. Am. J. Infect. Control 41 (2013), 568–570.
52. Luman, E., Barker, L., Shaw, K., Timeliness of childhood vaccinations in the United States: days undervaccinated and number of vaccines delayed. J. Am. Med. Assoc. 293 (2005), 1204–1211.
53. Luman, E., Shaw, K., Stokley, S., Compliance with vaccination recommendations for U.S. children. Am. J. Prev. Med. 34 (2008), 463–470.
54. Mayfield, E., Rosé, C.P., LightSIDE: open source machine learning for text accessible to non-experts. Shermis, M.D., Burstein, J., (eds.) Handbook of Automated Essay Evaluation, 2013, Routledge, New York, NY, 124–135.
55. McCombs, M.E., Shaw, D.L., Weaver, D.H., New directions in agenda-setting theory and research. Mass Commun. Soc. 17 (2014), 781–802.
56. National Conference of State Legislatures, States with Religious and Philosophical Exemptions from School Immunization Requirements. 2016.
57. Nyhan, B., Reifler, J., Richey, S., Freed, G.L., Effective messages in vaccine promotion: a randomized trial. Pediatrics 133 (2014), e835–e842.
58. Offit, P., Autism's False Prophets: Bad Science, Risky Medicine, and the Search for a Cure. 2008, Columbia University Press, New York.
59. Omer, S.B., Enger, K.S., Moulton, L.H., Halsey, N.A., Stokley, S., Salmon, D.A., Geographic clustering of nonmedical exemptions to school immunization requirements and associations with geographic clustering of pertussis. Am. J. Epidemiol. 168 (2008), 1389–1396.
60. Omer, S.B., Pan, W.K.Y., Halsey, N.A., Stokley, S., Moulton, L.H., Navar, A.M., et al. Nonmedical exemptions to school immunization requirements: secular trends and association of state policies with pertussis incidence. J. Am. Med. Assoc. 296 (2006), 1757–1763.
61. Omer, S.B., Salmon, D.A., Orenstein, W.A., deHart, M.P., Halsey, N.A., Vaccine refusal, mandatory immunization, and the risks of vaccine-preventable diseases. N. Engl. J. Med. 360 (2009), 1981–1988.
62. Park, A., Whistleblower Claims CDC Covered up Data Showing Vaccine-autism Link. 2014, Time Inc, Time.
63. Phadke, V.K., Bednarczyk, R.A., Salmon, D.A., Omer, S.B., Association between vaccine refusal and vaccine-preventable diseases in the United States: a review of measles and pertussis. JAMA 315 (2016), 1149–1158.
64. Plotkin, S., “Herd immunity:” a rough guide. Clin. Infect. Dis. 52 (2011), 911–916.
65. Polgreen, P.M., Chen, Y., Pennock, D.M., Nelson, F.D., Using internet searches for influenza surveillance. Clin. Infect. Dis. 47 (2008), 1443–1448.
66. Richards, J.L., Wagenaar, B.H., Van Otterloo, J., Gondalia, R., Atwell, J.E., Kleinbaum, D.G., et al. Nonmedical exemptions to immunization requirements in California: a 16-year longitudinal analysis of trends and associated community factors. Vaccine 31 (2013), 3009–3013.
67. Sadilek, A., Kautz, H.A., Silenzio, V., Modeling spread of disease from social interactions. ICWSM, 2012, 322–329.
68. Salmon, D.A., Haber, M., Gangarosa, E.J., Phillips, L., Smith, N.J., Chen, R.T., Health consequences of religious and philosophical exemptions from immunization laws: individual and societal risk of measles. Jama 282 (1999), 47–53.
69. Salmon, D.A., Moulton, L.H., Omer, S.B., deHart, P., Stokley, S., Halsey, N.A., Factors associated with refusal of childhood vaccines among parents of school-aged children: a case-control study. Arch. Pediatr. Adolesc. Med. 159 (2005), 470–476.
70. Scanfield, D., Scanfield, V., Larson, E.L., Dissemination of health information through social networks: twitter and antibiotics. Am. J. Infect. Control 38 (2010), 182–188.
71. Signorini, A., Segre, A.M., Polgreen, P.M., The use of Twitter to track levels of disease activity and public concern in the US during the influenza A H1N1 pandemic. PLoS One, 6, 2011, e19467.
72. Smailbegovic, M.S., Laing, G.J., Bedford, H., Why do parents decide against immunization? The effect of health beliefs and health professionals. Child Care Health Dev. 29 (2003), 303–311.
73. Smith, A., 13% of Online Adults Use Twitter, and Half of Twitter Users Access the Service on a Cell Phone. 2011, Pew Research Center.
74. Smith, A., Rainie, L., 8% of Online Americans Use Twitter. 2010, Pew Research Center.
75. Smith, P.J., Chu, S.Y., Barker, L.E., Children who have received no vaccines: who are they and where do they live?. Pediatrics 114 (2004), 187–195.
76. Smith, P.J., Humiston, S.G., Parnell, T., Vannice, K.S., Salmon, D.A., The association between intentional delay of vaccine administration and timely childhood vaccination coverage. Public Health Rep. 125 (2010), 534–541.
77. Song, G., Understanding public perceptions of benefits and risks of childhood vaccinations in the United States. Risk Anal. 34 (2014), 541–555.
78. Stavrakantonakis, I., Gagiu, A., Kasper, H., Toma, I., Thalhammer, A., An approach for evaluation of social media monitoring tools. Common Value Manag. 52 (2012), 52–64.
79. Stratton, K., Ford, A., Rusch, E., Clayton, E.W., (eds.) Adverse Effects of Vaccines: Evidence and Causality, 2012, The National Academies Press, Washington DC.
80. Streefland, P., Chowdhury, A.M.R., Ramos-Jimenez, P., Patterns of vaccination acceptance. Soc. Sci. Med. 49 (1990), 1705–1716.
81. Taylor, L.E., Swerdfeger, A.L., Eslick, G.D., Vaccines are not associated with autism: an evidence-based meta-analysis of case-control and cohort studies. Vaccine 32 (2014), 3623–3629.
82. Thomas, K., Grier, C., Paxson, V., Adapting social spam infrastructure for political censorshi. Proceedings of the 5th USENIX Conference on Large-scale Exploits and Emergent Threats, 2012, USENIX Association, San Jose, CA, 13.
83. Tibshirani, R., Regression shrinkage and selection via the lasso: a retrospective. J. Roy. Stat. Soc. B Met. 73 (2011), 273–282.
84. UserVoice, Census Reporter. 2016, UserVoice, San Francisco, CA.
85. van Panhuis, W.G., Grefenstette, J., Jung, S.Y., Chok, N.S., Cross, A., Eng, H., et al. Contagious diseases in the United States from 1888 to the present. N. Engl. J. Med. 369 (2013), 2152–2158.
86. Vargo, C.J., Hopp, T., Socioeconomic status, social capital, and partisan polarity as predictors of political incivility on Twitter: a congressional district-level analysis. Soc. Sci. Comput. Rev. 35 (2015), 10–32.
87. Washington State Department of Health, Washington State School Immunization Slide Set, 2015-2016 School Year. 2016.
88. Winter, K., Glaser, C., Watt, J., Harriman, K., Control, C.f.D., & Prevention. Pertussis epidemic—California, 2014. Morb. Mortal. Wkly. Rep. 63 (2014), 1129–1132.
89. Witteman, H.O., Zikmund-Fisher, B.J., The defining characteristics of Web 2.0 and their potential influence in the online vaccination debate. Vaccine 30 (2012), 3734–3740.
90. Wolfe, R.M., Sharp, L.K., Vaccination or immunization? The impact of search terms on the internet. J. Health Commun. 10 (2005), 537–551.
91. World Health Organization. (n.d.). Six common misconceptions about immunization.
92. Zastrow, M., Science on the map. Nature, 519, 2015, 119.
93. Zipprich, J., Winter, K., Hacker, J., Xia, D., Watt, J., Harriman, K., Measles outbreak—California, December 2014–February 2015. Morb. Mortal. Wkly. Rep. 64 (2015), 153–154.