The global burden of diagnostic errors in primary care

BMJ Quality and Safety

Volumn 26, Issue 6, 2017, Pages 484-494

  Singh, Hardeep ^a   Schiff, Gordon D ^b   Graber, Mark L ^c,d   Onakpoya, Igho ^e   Thompson, Matthew J ^f  

^a MICHAEL E DEBAKEY VETERANS AFFAIRS MEDICAL CENTER   (United States)

^b BRIGHAM AND WOMEN S HOSPITAL   (United States)

^c RTI INTERNATIONAL   (United States)

^d STONY BROOK UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^e UNIVERSITY OF OXFORD   (United Kingdom)

^f UNIVERSITY OF WASHINGTON SCHOOL OF MEDICINE   (United States)

Author keywords

Diagnostic errors; Health policy; Information technology; Patient safety; Primary care

Indexed keywords

ACCREDITATION; BULLET; DIAGNOSTIC ERROR; FEMALE; FUNDING; HEALTH CARE POLICY; HUMAN; HUMAN EXPERIMENT; INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY; LEADERSHIP; MALE; MEDICAL EDUCATION; NARRATIVE; PATIENT SAFETY; PRIMARY MEDICAL CARE; RESEARCH PRIORITY; SCIENTIST; SYMPTOM; WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION; CLINICAL DECISION MAKING; DIAGNOSTIC PROCEDURE; ECONOMICS; GLOBAL HEALTH; INFORMATION SYSTEM; ORGANIZATION AND MANAGEMENT; PATIENT PARTICIPATION; PRIMARY HEALTH CARE; PROCEDURES; RISK ASSESSMENT; STATISTICS AND NUMERICAL DATA; TOTAL QUALITY MANAGEMENT;

CLINICAL DECISION-MAKING; DIAGNOSTIC ERRORS; DIAGNOSTIC TECHNIQUES AND PROCEDURES; EDUCATION, MEDICAL; GLOBAL HEALTH; HEALTH POLICY; HUMANS; INFORMATION SYSTEMS; PATIENT PARTICIPATION; PATIENT SAFETY; PRIMARY HEALTH CARE; QUALITY IMPROVEMENT; RISK ASSESSMENT; WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION;

EID: 85019560185     PISSN: 20445415     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1136/bmjqs-2016-005401     Document Type: Review

References (119)

1. Cresswell KM, Panesar SS, Salvilla SA, et al. Global research priorities to better understand the burden of iatrogenic harm in primary care: an international Delphi exercise. PLoS Med 2013;10: e1001554.
2. Evidence scan: Improving safety in primary care. The Health Foundation, 2011 (cited 16 May 2016). http: //www. health. org. uk/sites/default/files/ImprovingSafetyInPrimaryCare. pdf
3. Graber ML, Trowbridge RL, Myers JS, et al. The next organizational challenge: finding and addressing diagnostic error. Jt Comm J Qual Patient Saf 2014;40: 102-10.
4. Verstappen W, Gaal S, Bowie P, et al. A research agenda on patient safety in primary care. Recommendations by the LINNEAUS collaboration on patient safety in primary care. Eur J Gen Pract 2015;21(Suppl): 72-7.
5. Primary health care: Main terminology. World Health Organization, 2016 (cited 14 June 2016).
6. Kostopoulou O, Delaney BC, Munro CW. Diagnostic difficulty and error in primary care-a systematic review. Fam Pract 2008;25: 400-13.
7. Singh H, Sittig DF. Setting the record straight on measuring diagnostic errors. Reply to: 'Bad assumptions on primary care diagnostic errors' by Dr Richard Young. BMJ Qual Saf 2015;24: 345-8.
8. Goyder CR, Jones CHD, Heneghan CJ, et al. Missed opportunities for diagnosis: lessons learned from diagnostic errors in primary care. Br J Gen Pract 2015;65: e838-44.
9. Panesar SS, de Silva D, Carson-Stevens A, et al. Howsafe is primary care? A systematic review. BMJ Qual Saf 2016;25: 544-53.
10. Graber ML, Franklin N, Gordon R. Diagnostic error in internal medicine. Arch Intern Med 2005;165: 1493-9.
11. Zwaan L, Singh H. The challenges in defining and measuring diagnostic error. Diagnosis (Berl) 2015;2: 97-103.
12. Singh H, Giardina TD, Meyer AN, et al. Types and origins of diagnostic errors in primary care settings. JAMA Intern Med 2013;173: 418-25.
13. Singh H, Sittig DF. Advancing the science of measurement of diagnostic errors in healthcare: the Safer Dx framework. BMJ Qual Saf 2015;24: 103-10.
14. Institute of Medicine. Improving diagnosis in health care. Washington, DC: National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine, 2015 (http: //iom. nationalacademies. org/Reports/2015/Improving-Diagnosis-in-Healthcare. aspx).
15. Casalino LP, Dunham D, Chin MH, et al. Frequency of failure to inform patients of clinically significant outpatient test results. Arch Intern Med 2009;169: 1123-9.
16. Singh H, Esquivel A, Sittig DF, et al. Follow-up actions on electronic referral communication in a multispecialty outpatient setting. J Gen Intern Med 2011;26: 64-9.
17. Schiff GD, Hasan O, Kim S, et al. Diagnostic error in medicine: analysis of 583 physician-reported errors. Arch Intern Med 2009;169: 1881-7.
18. Singh H. Editorial: Helping health care organizations to define diagnostic errors as missed opportunities in diagnosis. Jt Comm J Qual Patient Saf 2014;40: 99-101.
19. Singh H, Daci K, Petersen LA, et al. Missed opportunities to initiate endoscopic evaluation for colorectal cancer diagnosis. Am J Gastroenterol 2009;104: 2543-54.
20. Singh H, Hirani K, Kadiyala H, et al. Characteristics and predictors of missed opportunities in lung cancer diagnosis: an electronic health record-based study. J Clin Oncol 2010;28: 3307-15.
21. Singh H, Giardina TD, Petersen LA, et al. Exploring situational awareness in diagnostic errors in primary care. BMJ Qual Saf 2012;21: 30-8.
22. Singh H, Giardina TD, Forjuoh SN, et al. Electronic health record-based surveillance of diagnostic errors in primary care. BMJ Qual Saf 2012;21: 93-100.
23. Fischhoff B. Hindsight does not equal foresight: the effect of outcome knowledge on judgment under uncertainty. J Exp Psychol Hum Percept Perform 1975;1: 288-99.
24. Singh H, Meyer AN, Thomas EJ. The frequency of diagnostic errors in outpatient care: estimations from three large observational studies involving US adult populations. BMJ Qual Saf 2014;23: 727-31.
25. Khoo EM, Lee WK, Sararaks S, et al. Medical errors in primary care clinics-a cross sectional study. BMC Fam Pract 2012;13: 127.
26. Phillips RL Jr, Bartholomew LA, Dovey SM, et al. Learning from malpractice claims about negligent, adverse events in primary care in the United States. Qual Saf Health Care 2004;13: 121-6.
27. Schiff GD, Puopolo AL, Huben-Kearney A, et al. Primary care closed claims experience of Massachusetts malpractice insurers. JAMA Intern Med 2013;173: 2063-8.
28. Sandars J, Esmail A. The frequency and nature of medical error in primary care: understanding the diversity across studies. Fam Pract 2003;20: 231-6.
29. Bhasale AL, Miller GC, Reid SE, et al. Analysing potential harm in Australian general practice: an incident-monitoring study. Med J Aust 1998;169: 73-6.
30. Singh H, Thomas EJ, Wilson L, et al. Errors of diagnosis in pediatric practice: a multisite survey. Pediatrics 2010;126: 70-9.
31. Health statistics and information systems: definition of region groupings. World Health Organization, 2016 (cited 14 June 2016). http: //www. who. int/healthinfo/global-burden-disease/ definition-regions/en/
32. Data: Country and Lending Groups. The World Bank, 2016 (cited 16 May 2016); http: //data. worldbank. org/about/ country-and-lending-groups
33. Berner ES, Graber ML. Overconfidence as a cause of diagnostic error in medicine. Am J Med 2008;121(Suppl 1): S2-23.
34. Graber ML. The incidence of diagnostic error in medicine. BMJ Qual Saf 2013;22(Suppl 2): ii21-7.
35. Schiff GD, Kim S, Abrams R, et al. Diagnosing diagnostic errors: Lessons from a multi-institutional collaborative project. Advances in Patient Safety: from Research to Implementation (Volume 2: Concepts and Methodology). Rockville, MD: Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality, AHRQ Publication Nos. 050021 (1-4), 2005: 255-78.
36. Sarkar U, Bonacum D, Strull W, et al. Challenges of making a diagnosis in the outpatient setting: a multi-site survey of primary care physicians. BMJ Qual Saf 2012;21: 641-8.
37. Gandhi TK, Kachalia A, Thomas EJ, et al. Missed and delayed diagnoses in the ambulatory setting: a study of closed malpractice claims. Ann Intern Med 2006;145: 488-96.
38. Gandhi TK. Fumbled handoffs: one dropped ball after another. Ann Intern Med 2005;142: 352-8.
39. Ely JW, Kaldjian LC, D'Alessandro DM. Diagnostic errors in primary care: lessons learned. J Am Board Fam Pract 2012;25: 87-97.
40. Silk N. What Went Wrong in 1, 000 Negligence Claims. Health Care Risk Report. Medical Protection Society. 2000.
41. Liu L, Johnson HL, Cousens S, et al. Global, regional, and national causes of child mortality: an updated systematic analysis for 2010 with time trends since 2000. Lancet 2012;379: 2151-61.
42. Leslie T, Mikhail A, Mayan I, et al. Rapid diagnostic tests to improve treatment of malaria and other febrile illnesses: patient randomised effectiveness trial in primary care clinics in Afghanistan. BMJ 2014;348: g3730.
43. Ollé Goig JE. Diagnostic errors related with tuberculosis in hospitalized patients. Arch Bronconeumol 2000;36: 515-18.
44. Szczuka I, Pawlicka L, Kus J, et al. Analysis of diagnostic errors and recommendations of diagnostic procedures in bacteriologically negative pulmonary tuberculosis. Pneumonol Alergol Pol 1998;66: 17-23.
45. Winters B, Custer J, Galvagno SM Jr, et al. Diagnostic errors in the intensive care unit: a systematic review of autopsy studies. BMJ Qual Saf 2012;21: 894-902.
46. Samuels TA, Cohen D, Brancati FL, et al. Delayed diagnosis of incident type 2 diabetes mellitus in the ARIC study. Am J Manag Care 2006;12: 717-24.
47. Edelman D. Outpatient diagnostic errors: unrecognized hyperglycemia. Eff Clin Pract 2002;5: 11-16.
48. Chow CK, Teo KK, Rangarajan S, et al. Prevalence, awareness, treatment, and control of hypertension in rural and urban communities in high-, middle-, and low-income countries. JAMA 2013;310: 959-68.
49. Singh H, Khan R, Giardina TD, et al. Postreferral colonoscopy delays in diagnosis of colorectal cancer: a mixed-methods analysis. Qual Manag Health Care 2012;21: 252-61.
50. Noro R, Hubaux JP, Meuli R, et al. Real-time telediagnosis of radiological images through an asynchronous transfer mode network: the ARTeMeD project. J Digit Imaging 1997;10(3 Suppl 1): 116-21. 51 Toddler dies of leukaemia after medics miss condition
51. times. The Telegraph. http: //www. Telegraph. co. uk/news/ health/12133228/Toddler-dies-of-leukaemia-after-medics-misscondition-35-times. html. Date accessed: 15 February 2016.
52. Onysko J, Maxwell C, Eliasziw M, et al. Large increases in hypertension diagnosis and treatment in Canada after a healthcare professional education program. Hypertension 2006;48: 853-60.
53. Lyratzopoulos G, Vedsted P, Singh H. Understanding missed opportunities for more timely diagnosis of cancer in symptomatic patients after presentation. Br J Cancer 2015;112(Suppl 1): S84-91.
54. Singh H, Sethi S, Raber M, et al. Errors in cancer diagnosis: current understanding and future directions. J Clin Oncol 2007;25: 5009-18.
55. Hamilton W, Lancashire R, Sharp D, et al. The risk of colorectal cancer with symptoms at different ages and between the sexes: a case-control study. BMC Med 2009;7: 17.
56. Wallace E, Lowry J, Smith SM, et al. The epidemiology of malpractice claims in primary care: a systematic review. BMJ Open 2013;3: e002929.
57. UNICEF. Levels and trends in child mortality, estimates developed by the UN Inter-agency Group for Child Mortality Estimation. New York: United Nations Children's Fund, 2014.
58. Thompson MJ, Ninis N, Perera R, et al. Clinical recognition of meningococcal disease in children and adolescents. Lancet 2006;367: 397-403.
59. Rinke ML, Singh H, Ruberman S, et al. Primary care pediatricians' interest in diagnostic error reduction. Diagnosis 3. 2 (2016): 65-69.
60. Meyer AN, Payne VL, Meeks DW, et al. Physicians' diagnostic accuracy, confidence, and resource requests: a vignette study. JAMA Intern Med 2013;173: 1952-8.
61. Podbregar M, Voga G, Krivec B, et al. Should we confirm our clinical diagnostic certainty by autopsies? Intensive Care Med 2001;27: 1750-5.
62. Schiff GD. Minimizing diagnostic error: the importance of follow-up and feedback. Am J Med 2008;121(Suppl 1): S38-42.
63. McDonald KM, Matesic B, Contopoulos-Ioannidis DG, et al. Patient safety strategies targeted at diagnostic errors: a systematic review. Ann Intern Med 2013;158(Pt 2): 381-9.
64. Graber ML, Kissam S, Payne VL, et al. Cognitive interventions to reduce diagnostic error: a narrative review. BMJ Qual Saf 2012;21: 535-57.
65. Singh H, Graber ML, Kissam SM, et al. System-related interventions to reduce diagnostic errors: a narrative review. BMJ Qual Saf 2012;21: 160-70.
66. Singh H. Diagnostic errors: moving beyond 'no respect' and getting ready for prime time. BMJ Qual Saf 2013;22: 789-92.
67. Balla J, Heneghan C, Goyder C, et al. Identifying early warning signs for diagnostic errors in primary care: a qualitative study. BMJ Open 2012;2: e001539.
68. Kostopoulou O, Devereaux-Walsh C, Delaney BC. Missing celiac disease in family medicine: the importance of hypothesis generation. Med Decis Making 2009;29: 282-90.
69. Kostopoulou O, Russo JE, Keenan G, et al. Information distortion in physicians' diagnostic judgments. Med Decis Making 2012;32: 831-9.
70. Balla JI, Heneghan C, Glasziou P, et al. A model for reflection for good clinical practice. J Eval Clin Pract 2009;15: 964-9.
71. Mamede S, Schmidt HG, Rikers R. Diagnostic errors and reflective practice in medicine. J Eval Clin Pract 2007;13: 138-45.
72. Lambe KA, O'Reilly G, Kelly BD, et al. Dual-process cognitive interventions to enhance diagnostic reasoning: a systematic review. BMJ Qual Saf 2016; Published Online First 12 February 2016.
73. Ely JW, Graber ML, Croskerry P. Checklists to reduce diagnostic errors. Acad Med 2011;86: 307-13.
74. Ramnarayan P, Cronje N, Brown R, et al. Validation of a diagnostic reminder system in emergency medicine: a multi-centre study. Emerg Med J 2007;24: 619-24.
75. Kostopoulou O, Rosen A, Round T, et al. Early diagnostic suggestions improve accuracy of GPs: a randomised controlled trial using computer-simulated patients. Br J Gen Pract 2014;65: e49-54.
76. Riches N, Panagioti M, Alam R, et al. The effectiveness of electronic differential diagnoses (DDX) generators: a systematic review and meta-analysis. PLoS ONE 2016;11: e0148991.
77. Croskerry P, Singhal G, Mamede S. Cognitive debiasing 1: origins of bias and theory of debiasing. BMJ Qual Saf 2013;22(Suppl 2): ii58-64.
78. Larrick R. Debiasing. In: Koehler D, Harvey N, eds. The Blackwell Handbook of Judgment and Decision Making. Oxford: Blackwell Publishing, 2004: 316-37.
79. Zwaan L, Monteiro S, Sherbino J, et al. Is bias in the eye of the beholder? A vignette study to assess recognition of cognitive biases in clinical case workups. BMJ Qual Saf 2016; Published Online First 29 January 2016.
80. Dhaliwal G. Premature closure? Not so fast. BMJ Qual Saf 2016; Published Online First 15 March 2016.
81. Monteiro SD, Sherbino JD, Ilgen JS, et al. Disrupting diagnostic reasoning: do interruptions, instructions, and experience affect the diagnostic accuracy and response time of residents and emergency physicians? Acad Med 2015;90: 511-17.
82. Singh H, Petersen LA, Thomas EJ. Understanding diagnostic errors in medicine: a lesson from aviation. Qual Saf Health Care 2006;15: 159-64.
83. Starfield B, Shi L, Macinko J. Contribution of primary care to health systems and health. Milbank Q 2005;83: 457-502.
84. Wolfe I, Thompson M, Gill P, et al. Health services for children in Western Europe. Lancet 2013;381: 1224-34.
85. Anant P, Bergkvist S, Chandani T, et al. Landscaping of primary healthcare in India. ACCESS Health International, 2016 (cited 14 June 2016). http: //accessh. org/wp-content/ uploads/2016/05/Primary-Care-Landscape-ACCESS-Health-International. pdf
86. Singh H, Graber M. Reducing diagnostic error through medical home-based primary care reform. JAMA 2010;304: 463-4.
87. El-Kareh R, Hasan O, Schiff GD. Use of health information technology to reduce diagnostic errors. BMJ Qual Saf 2013;22(Suppl 2): ii40-51.
88. Makaula P, Bloch P, Banda HT, et al. Primary health care in rural Malawi-a qualitative assessment exploring the relevance of the community-directed interventions approach. BMC Health Serv Res 2012;12: 328.
89. Druetz T, Siekmans K, Goossens S, et al. The community case management of pneumonia in Africa: a review of the evidence. Health Policy Plan 2015;30: 253-66.
90. Nurek M, Kostopoulou O, Delaney BC, et al. Reducing diagnostic errors in primary care. A systematic meta-review of computerized diagnostic decision support systems by the LINNEAUS collaboration on patient safety in primary care. Eur J Gen Pract 2015;21(Suppl): 8-13.
91. Singh H, Naik AD, Rao R, et al. Reducing diagnostic errors through effective communication: harnessing the power of information technology. J Gen Intern Med 2008;23: 489-94.
92. Singh H, Sittig DF. Were my diagnosis and treatment correct? No news is not necessarily good news. J Gen Intern Med 2014;29: 1087-9.
93. Sittig DF, Singh H. A new sociotechnical model for studying health information technology in complex adaptive healthcare systems. Qual Saf Health Care 2010;19(Suppl 3): i68-74.
94. Murphy DR, Wu L, Thomas EJ, et al. Electronic trigger-based intervention to reduce delays in diagnostic evaluation for cancer: a cluster randomized controlled trial. J Clin Oncol 2015;33: 3560-7.
95. Murphy DR, Thomas EJ, Meyer AN, et al. Development and validation of electronic health record-based triggers to detect delays in follow-up of abnormal lung imaging findings. Radiology 2015;277: 81-7.
96. Murphy DR, Laxmisan A, Reis BA, et al. Electronic health record-based triggers to detect potential delays in cancer diagnosis. BMJ Qual Saf 2014;23: 8-16.
97. Schiff GD, Bates DW. Can electronic clinical documentation help prevent diagnostic errors? N Engl J Med 2010;362: 1066-9.
98. Southwick FS, Cranley NM, Hallisy JA. A patient-initiated voluntary online survey of adverse medical events: the perspective of 696 injured patients and families. BMJ Qual Saf 2015;24: 620-9.
99. McDonald KM, Bryce CL, Graber ML. The patient is in: patient involvement strategies for diagnostic error mitigation. BMJ Qual Saf 2013;22(Suppl 2): ii33-9.
100. Graber ML. Reducing diagnostic error in medicine-there's a job for everyone. NPSF Focus Patient Saf 2009;12: 6-7.
101. Patient Toolkit. Society to Improve Diagnosis in Medicine. 2015 (cited 16 A. D. May 2016).
102. Almond S, Mant D, Thompson M. Diagnostic safety-netting. Br J Gen Pract 2009;59: 872-4.
103. Bhutta ZA, Das JK, Walker N, et al. Interventions to address deaths from childhood pneumonia and diarrhoea equitably: what works and at what cost? Lancet 2013;381: 1417-29.
104. World Health Organization. Implementation tools: package of essential noncommunicable (PEN) disease interventions for primary health care in low-resource settings. Geneva: World Health Organization, 2014.
105. Lyratzopoulos G, Wardle J, Rubin G. Rethinking diagnostic delay in cancer: how difficult is the diagnosis? BMJ 2014;349: g7400.
106. Howick J, Cals JWL, Jones C, et al. Current and future use of point-of-care tests in primary care: an international survey in Australia, Belgium, The Netherlands, the UK and the USA. BMJ Open 2014;4: e005611.
107. Lorincz CY, Drazen E, Sokol PE, et al. Research in Ambulatory Patient Safety 2000-2010: A 10-Year Review. American Medical Association, 2011.
108. Wynia MK, Classen DC. Improving ambulatory patient safety: learning from the last decade, moving ahead in the next. JAMA 2011;306: 2504-5.
109. Improving diagnosis in health care. National Academies of Sciences Engineering and Medicine 2015 (cited 14 June 2016). http: //iom. nationalacademies. org/Reports/2015/ Improving-Diagnosis-in-Healthcare. aspx
110. Singh H, Thomas EJ, Khan MM, et al. Identifying diagnostic errors in primary care using an electronic screening algorithm. Arch Intern Med 2007;167: 302-8.
111. Okafor N, Payne VL, Chathampally Y, et al. Using voluntary reports from physicians to learn from diagnostic errors in emergency medicine. Emerg Med J 2016;33: 245-52.
112. Al-Mutairi A, Meyer AN, Thomas EJ, et al. Accuracy of the Safer Dx instrument to identify diagnostic errors in primary care. J Gen Intern Med 2016;31: 602-8.
113. Ely JW, Osheroff JA, Ebell MH, et al. Obstacles to answering doctors' questions about patient care with evidence: qualitative study. BMJ 2002;324: 710.
114. Plüddemann A, Wallace E, Bankhead C, et al. Clinical prediction rules in practice: review of clinical guidelines and survey of GPs. Br J Gen Pract 2014;64: e233-42.
115. Sittig DF, Krall MA, Dykstra RH, et al. A survey of factors affecting clinician acceptance of clinical decision support. BMC Med Inform Decis Mak 2006;6: 6.
116. Harnden A, Mayon-White R, Mant D, et al. Child deaths: confidential enquiry into the role and quality of UK primary care. Br J Gen Pract 2009;59: 819-24.
117. Cantwell R, Clutton-Brock T, Cooper G, et al. Saving Mothers' Lives: reviewing maternal deaths to make motherhood safer: 2006-2008. The Eighth Report of the Confidential Enquiries into Maternal Deaths in the United Kingdom. BJOG 2011;118(Suppl 1): 1-203.
118. Zwaan L, Schiff GD, Singh H. Advancing the research agenda for diagnostic error reduction. BMJ Qual Saf 2013;22(Suppl 2): ii52-7.
119. Sittig DF, Kahol K, Singh H. Sociotechnical evaluation of the safety and effectiveness of point-of-care mobile computing devices: a case study conducted in India. Stud Health Technol Inform 2013;192: 515-19.