Systematic review comparing penetrating keratoplasty and deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty for management of keratoconus

Contact Lens and Anterior Eye

Volumn 40, Issue 1, 2017, Pages 3-14

  Henein, Christin ^a   Nanavaty, Mayank A ^a  

^a SUSSEX EYE HOSPITAL   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

DALK; Keratoconus; PK

Indexed keywords

ASTIGMATISM; BEST CORRECTED VISUAL ACUITY; CELL DENSITY; DEEP ANTERIOR LAMELLAR KERATOPLASTY; ENDOTHELIUM CELL; FOLLOW UP; GRAFT REJECTION; GRAFT SURVIVAL; HUMAN; INTERMETHOD COMPARISON; KERATOCONUS; KERATOMETRIC ASTIGMATISM; KERATOPLASTY; META ANALYSIS; OUTCOME ASSESSMENT; PENETRATING KERATOPLASTY; POSTOPERATIVE PERIOD; PRIORITY JOURNAL; QUANTITATIVE ANALYSIS; REFRACTIVE ASTIGMATISM; REVIEW; SPHERICAL EQUIVALENT; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW; UNCORRECTED VISUAL ACUITY; VISUAL ACUITY; VISUAL SYSTEM PARAMETERS; ADULT; CAUSALITY; COMORBIDITY; CORNEA TRANSPLANTATION; FEMALE; MALE; MIDDLE AGED; POSTOPERATIVE COMPLICATIONS; STATISTICS AND NUMERICAL DATA; TREATMENT OUTCOME; VISION DISORDERS;

ADULT; CAUSALITY; COMORBIDITY; CORNEAL TRANSPLANTATION; FEMALE; HUMANS; KERATOCONUS; KERATOPLASTY, PENETRATING; MALE; MIDDLE AGED; POSTOPERATIVE COMPLICATIONS; TREATMENT OUTCOME; VISION DISORDERS;

EID: 85005950411     PISSN: 13670484     EISSN: 14765411     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.clae.2016.10.001     Document Type: Review

References (59)

1. [1] Castroviejo, R., Keratoplasty in treatment of keratoconus. Arch. Ophthalmol. 42:6 (1949), 776–800.
2. [2] Coster, D.J., Lowe, M.T., Keane, M.C., Williams, K.A., A comparison of lamellar and penetrating keratoplasty outcomes: a registry study. Ophthalmology 121:5 (2014), 979–987.
3. [3] Jaycock, P.D., Jones, M.N., Males, J., et al. Outcomes of same-sizing versus oversizing donor trephines in keratoconic patients undergoing first penetrating keratoplasty. Ophthalmology 115:2 (2008), 268–275.
4. [4] Williams, K.A., Lowe, M.T., Bartlett, C.M., Kelly, L., Coster, D.J., The Australian Corneal Graft Registry Report., 2007, Flinders University, Adelaide.
5. [5] Fogla, R., Padmanabhan, P., Results of deep lamellar keratoplasty using the big-bubble technique in patients with keratoconus. Am. J. Ophthalmol. 141:2 (2006), 254–259.
6. [6] Fontana, L., Parente, G., Tassinari, G., Clinical outcomes after deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty using the big-bubble technique in patients with keratoconus. Am. J. Ophthalmol. 143:1 (2007), 117–124.
7. [7] Sarnicola, V., Toro, P., Gentile, D., Hannush, S.B., Descemetic DALK and predescemetic DALK: outcomes in 236 cases of keratoconus. Cornea 29:1 (2010), 53–59.
8. [8] Feizi, S., Javadi, M.A., Jamali, H., Mirbabaee, F., Deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty in patients with keratoconus: big-bubble technique. Cornea 29:2 (2010), 177–182.
9. [9] Han, D.C.Y., Mehta, J.S., Por, Y.M., et al. Comparison of outcomes of lamellar keratoplasty and penetrating keratoplasty in keratoconus. Am. J. Ophthalmol. 148:5 (2009), 744–751 (e1).
10. [10] Coombes, A.G., Kirwan, J.F., Rostron, C.K., Deep lamellar keratoplasty with lyophilised tissue in the management of keratoconus. Br. J. Ophthalmol. 85:7 (2001), 788–791.
11. [11] Sugita, J., Kondo, J., Deep lamellar keratoplasty with complete removal of pathological stroma for vision improvement. Br. J. Ophthalmol. 81:3 (1997), 184–188.
12. [12] Nanavaty, M.A., Daya, S.M., Outcomes of deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty in keratoconic eyes with previous hydrops. Br. J. Ophthalmol. 96:10 (2012), 1304–1309.
13. [13] Anwar, M., Teichmann, K.D., Deep lamellar keratoplasty: surgical techniques for anterior lamellar keratoplasty with and without baring of Descemet's membrane. Cornea 21:4 (2002), 374–383.
14. [14] Amayem, A.F., Hamdi, I.M., Hamdi, M.M., Refractive and visual outcomes of penetrating keratoplasty versus deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty with hydrodissection for treatment of keratoconus. Cornea 32:4 (2013), e2–5.
15. [15] Melles, G.R., Remeijer, L., Geerards, A.J., Beekhuis, W.H., A quick surgical technique for deep, anterior lamellar keratoplasty using visco-dissection. Cornea 19:4 (2000), 427–432.
16. [16] Melles, G.R., Lander, F., Rietveld, F.J., et al. A new surgical technique for deep stromal, anterior lamellar keratoplasty. Br. J. Ophthalmol. 83:3 (1999), 327–333.
17. [17] Gaster, R.N., Dumitrascu, O., Rabinowitz, Y.S., Penetrating keratoplasty using femtosecond laser-enabled keratoplasty with zig-zag incisions versus a mechanical trephine in patients with keratoconus. Br. J. Ophthalmol. 96:9 (2012), 1195–1199.
18. [18] Shehadeh-Mashor, R., Chan, C.C., Bahar, I., et al. Comparison between femtosecond laser mushroom configuration and manual trephine straight-edge configuration deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty. Br. J. Ophthalmol. 98:1 (2014), 35–39.
19. [19] Baradaran-Rafii, A., Eslani, M., Femtosecond laser-assisted corneal transplantation. Br. J. Ophthalmol. 97:6 (2013), 675–676.
20. [20] Smadja, D., Colin, J., Krueger, R.R., et al. Outcomes of deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty for keratoconus: learning curve and advantages of the big bubble technique. Cornea 31:8 (2012), 859–863.
21. [21] Reinhart, W.J., Musch, D.C., Jacobs, D.S., et al. Deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty as an alternative to penetrating keratoplasty a report by the american academy of ophthalmology. Ophthalmology 118:1 (2011), 209–218.
22. [22] Fontana, L., Parente, G., Sincich, A., Tassinari, G., Influence of graft-host interface on the quality of vision after deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty in patients with keratoconus. Cornea 30:5 (2011), 497–502.
23. [23] Higgins J, Altman D, Sterne J. Chapter 8: Assessing risk of bias in included studies. Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions; Version 5.1.0 ( http://handbook.cochrane.org/).
24. [24] Wells, G., Shea, B., O'Connell, D., et al. The Newcastle-Ottawa Scale (NOS) for Assessing the Quality of Nonrandomised Studies in Meta-Analyses. 2015, Ottawa Hospital Research Institute.
25. [25] Review Manager (RevMan), Computer Program]. Version 5.3. Copenhagen. 2014, The Nordic Cochrane Centre, The Cochrane Collaboration.
26. [26] Javadi, M.A., Feizi, S., Yazdani, S., Mirbabaee, F., Deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty versus penetrating keratoplasty for keratoconus: a clinical trial. Cornea 29:4 (2010), 365–371.
27. [27] Sari, E.S., Kubaloglu, A., Unal, M., et al. Penetrating keratoplasty versus deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty: comparison of optical and visual quality outcomes. Br. J. Ophthalmol. 96:8 (2012), 1063–1067.
28. [28] Akdemir, M.O., Kandemir, B., Sayman, I.B., et al. Comparison of contrast sensitivity and visual acuity between deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty and penetrating keratoplasty in patients with keratoconus. Int. J. Ophthalmol. 5:6 (2012), 737–741.
29. [29] Bahar, I., Kaiserman, I., Srinivasan, S., et al. Comparison of three different techniques of corneal transplantation for keratoconus. Am. J. Ophthalmol. 146:6 (2008), 905–912 (e1).
30. [30] Cohen, A.W., Goins, K.M., Sutphin, J.E., et al. Penetrating keratoplasty versus deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty for the treatment of keratoconus. Int. Ophthalmol. 30:6 (2010), 675–681.
31. [31] Funnell, C.L., Ball, J., Noble, B.A., Comparative cohort study of the outcomes of deep lamellar keratoplasty and penetrating keratoplasty for keratoconus. Eye (Lond.) 20:5 (2006), 527–532.
32. [32] Han, D.C., Mehta, J.S., Por, Y.M., et al. Comparison of outcomes of lamellar keratoplasty and penetrating keratoplasty in keratoconus. Am. J. Ophthalmol. 148:5 (2009), 744–751 (e1).
33. [33] Jafarinasab, M.R., Feizi, S., Javadi, M.A., Hashemloo, A., Graft biomechanical properties after penetrating keratoplasty versus deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty. Curr. Eye Res. 36:5 (2011), 417–421.
34. [34] Jones, M.N., Armitage, W.J., Ayliffe, W., et al. Penetrating and deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty for keratoconus: a comparison of graft outcomes in the United kingdom. Invest. Ophthalmol. Vis. Sci. 50:12 (2009), 5625–5629.
35. [35] Kim, K.H., Choi, S.H., Ahn, K., et al. Comparison of refractive changes after deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty and penetrating keratoplasty for keratoconus. Jpn. J. Ophthalmol. 55:2 (2011), 93–97.
36. [36] Kubaloglu, A., Koytak, A., Sari, E., et al. Corneal endothelium after deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty and penetrating keratoplasty for keratoconus: a four-year comparative study. Indian J. Ophthalmol. 60:1 (2012), 35–40.
37. [37] MacIntyre, R., Chow, S.P., Chan, E., Poon, A., Long-term outcomes of deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty versus penetrating keratoplasty in Australian keratoconus patients. Cornea 33:1 (2014), 6–9.
38. [38] Mashor, R.S., Rootman, D.B., Bahar, I., et al. Outcomes of deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty versus intralase enabled penetrating keratoplasty in keratoconus. Can. J. Ophthalmol. 46:5 (2011), 403–407.
39. [39] Oh, B.L., Kim, M.K., Wee, W.R., Comparison of clinical outcomes of same-size grafting between deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty and penetrating keratoplasty for keratoconus. Korean J. Ophthalmol. 27:5 (2013), 322–330.
40. [40] Watson, S.L., Ramsay, A., Dart, J.K., et al. Comparison of deep lamellar keratoplasty and penetrating keratoplasty in patients with keratoconus. Ophthalmology 111:9 (2004), 1676–1682.
41. [41] Zhang, Y.M., Wu, S.Q., Yao, Y.F., Long-term comparison of full-bed deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty and penetrating keratoplasty in treating keratoconus. J. Zhejiang Univ. Sci. B 14:5 (2013), 438–450.
42. [42] Cheng, Y.Y., Visser, N., Schouten, J.S., et al. Endothelial cell loss and visual outcome of deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty versus penetrating keratoplasty: a randomized multicenter clinical trial. Ophthalmology 118:2 (2011), 302–309.
43. [43] Kim, M.H., Chung, T.Y., Chung, E.S., A retrospective contralateral study comparing deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty with penetrating keratoplasty. Cornea 32:4 (2013), 385–389.
44. [44] Borderie, V.M., Sandali, O., Bullet, J., et al. Long-term results of deep anterior lamellar versus penetrating keratoplasty. Ophthalmology 119:2 (2012), 249–255.
45. [45] Borderie, V.M., Guilbert, E., Touzeau, O., Laroche, L., Graft rejection and graft failure after anterior lamellar versus penetrating keratoplasty. Am. J. Ophthalmol. 151:6 (2011), 1024–1029 (e1).
46. [46] Jensen, L.B., Hjortdal, J., Ehlers, N., Longterm follow-up of penetrating keratoplasty for keratoconus. Acta Opthalmol. 88:3 (2016), 347–351.
47. [47] Keane, M., Coster, D., Ziaei, M., Williams, K., Deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty versus penetrating keratoplasty for treating keratoconus. Cochrane Database Syst. Rev., 7, 2014, CD009700.
48. [48] Shi, J.L., Feng, Y.F., Yu, J.G., Wang, Q.M., Meta analysis of deep lamellar keratoplasty and penetrating keratoplasty for keratoconus. Zhonghua Shiyan Yanke Zazhi/Chin. J. Exp. Ophthalmol. 30:10 (2012), 926–931.
49. [49] Jiang, X., Hong, J., Contrastive study of deep lamellar keratoplasty and penetrating keratoplasty in treating keratoconu. Int. J. Ophthalmol. 11:9 (2011), 1588–1590.
50. [50] Liu, P.W.Y., Wang, X., Xue, C.L., Li, H.Y., Observation of curative effects of DLKP and PKP in patients with keratoconus. Chin. J. Ocular Trauma Occup. Eye Dis. 30:8 (2008), 615–618.
51. [51] Van Den Biggelaar, F.J.H.M., Cheng, Y.Y.Y., Nuijts, R.M.M.A., et al. Economic evaluation of deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty versus penetrating keratoplasty in the Netherlands. Am. J. Ophthalmol. 59:3 (2011), 449–459 (e2).
52. [52] Perry, H.D., Foulks, G.N., Oversize donor buttons in corneal transplantation surgery for keratoconus. Ophthalmic Surg. 18:10 (1987), 751–752.
53. [53] Wilson, S.E., Bourne, W.M., Effect of recipient-donor trephine size disparity on refractive error in keratoconus. Ophthalmology 96:3 (1989), 299–305.
54. [54] Shimmura, S., Ando, M., Ishioka, M., et al. Same-size donor corneas for myopic keratoconus. Cornea 23:4 (2004), 345–349.
55. [55] Javadi, M.A., Feizi, S., Rastegarpour, A., Effect of vitreous length and trephine size disparity on post-DALK refractive status. Cornea 30:4 (2011), 419–423.
56. [56] Morris, E., Kirwan, J.F., Sujatha, S., Rostron, C.K., Corneal endothelial specular microscopy following deep lamellar keratoplasty with lyophilised tissue. Eye (Lond.) 12:Pt. 4 (1998), 619–622.
57. [57] Shimazaki, J., Shimmura, S., Ishioka, M., Tsubota, K., Randomized clinical trial of deep lamellar keratoplasty vs penetrating keratoplasty. Am. J. Ophthalmol. 134:2 (2002), 159–165.
58. [58] Ardjomand, N., Hau, S., McAlister, J.C., et al. Quality of vision and graft thickness in deep anterior lamellar and penetrating corneal allografts. Am. J. Ophthalmol. 143:2 (2007), 228–235 (e1).
59. [59] Baradaran-Rafii, A., Eslani, M., Sadoughi, M.-M., et al. Anwar versus melles deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty for keratoconus: a prospective randomized clinical trial. Ophthalmology 120:2 (2013), 252–259.