Spatial Polarization of Presidential Voting in the United States, 1992–2012: The “Big Sort” Revisited

Annals of the American Association of Geographers

Volumn 106, Issue 5, 2016, Pages 1047-1062

  Johnston, Ron ^a   Manley, David ^a   Jones, Kelvyn ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF BRISTOL   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

polarization; presidential voting; spatial scale; United States

Indexed keywords

DEMOCRACY; PARTY POLITICS; POLITICAL HISTORY; VOTING BEHAVIOR;

UNITED STATES;

EID: 84987968656     PISSN: 24694452     EISSN: 24694460     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/24694452.2016.1191991     Document Type: Article

References (60)

1. A.I.Abramowitz, and K.L.Saunders. 2008. Is polarization a myth? The Journal of Politics 70:542–55.
2. S.J.Abrams, and M.P.Fiorina. 2012. “The big sort” that wasn't:A sceptical re-examination. PS:Political Science and Politics 49:203–10.
3. B.Bishop, and R.G.Cushing. 2008. The big sort:Why the clustering of like-minded America is tearing us apart. Boston:Houghton Mifflin.
4. H.Brady, and R.Johnston, eds. 2006. Capturing campaign effects. Ann Arbor:University of Michigan Press.
5. W.J.Browne, S.V.Subramanian, K.Jones, and H.Goldstein. 2005. Variance partitioning in multilevel logistic models that exhibit over-dispersion. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society Series A 168:599–613.
6. B.C.Burden, and D.C.Kimball. 2004. Why Americans split their tickets:Campaigns, competition and divided government. Ann Arbor:University of Michigan Press.
7. W.Cho, J., K.Tam, J.G.Gimpel, and I.S.Hui. 2013. Voter migration and the geographic sorting of the American electorate. Annals of the Association of American Geographers 103:856–70.
8. W.A.V.Clark, E.Anderson, J.Östh, and B.Malmberg. 2015. A multiscalar analysis of neighborhood composition in Los Angeles, 2000–2010:A location-based approach to segregation and diversity. Annals of the Association of American Geographers 105:1260–84.
9. O.D.Duncan, R.P.Cuzzort, and B.Duncan. 1961. Statistical geography:Problems in analysing areal data. Glencoe, IL:The Free Press.
10. D.J.Elazar, 1984. American federalism:View from the states. 3rd ed. New York:Harper & Row.
11. M.P.Fiorina, and S.J.Abrams. 2008. Political polarization in the American public. Annual Review of Political Science 11:563–88.
12. M.P.Fiorina, S.J.Abrams, and J.C.Pope. 2008. Polarization in the American public:Misconceptions and misreadings. Journal of Politics 70:556–60.
13. C.S.Fischer, G.Stockmayer, J.Stiles, and M.Hout. 2004. Distinguishing the geographic levels and social dimensions of U.S. metropolitan segregation. Demography 41 (1):37–59.
14. C.S.Fowler, 2015. Segregation as a multiscalar phenomenon and its implications for neighbourhood-scale research:The case of South Seattle, 1990–2010. Urban Geography Advance online publication. doi:10.1080/02723638.2015.1043775.
15. A.Gelman, 2008. Red state, blue state, rich state, poor state:Why Americans vote the way they do. Princeton, NJ:Princeton University Press.
16. J.G.Gimpel, and I.S.Hui. 2015. Seeking politically compatible neighbors? The role of neighborhood partisan composition in residential sorting. Political Geography 48:130–42.
17. J.G.Gimpel, F.E.Lee, and J.Kaminski. n.d. The political geography of campaign contributions in American politics. http://www.thebrokenwindow.net/papers/c/contributions.pdf (last accessed 10 June 2016).
18. E.Glaeser, and J.Vigdor. 2012. The end of the segregated century:Racial separation in America's neighborhoods, 1890–2010. New York:The Manhattan Institute. http://www.manhattan-institute.org/pdf/cr_66.pdf (last accessed 9March2016).
19. E.Glaeser, and B.A.Ward. 2006. Myths and realities of American political geography. Working Paper 11857, CambridgeMA:National Bureau of Economic Research.
20. M.S.Granovetter, 1973. The strength of weak ties. American Journal of Sociology 78:1360–80.
21. D.Hopmann, J.Matthes, and L.Nir. 2015. Informal political conversation across time and space:Setting the research agenda. International Journal of Public Opinion Research 27:448–60.
22. R.J.Johnston, J.Forrest, K.Jones, and D.Manley. 2016. The scale of segregation:Ancestral groups in Sydney, 2011. Urban Geography. Advance online publication. doi:10.1080/02723638.2016.1139867
23. R.J.Johnston, D.Voas, and M.F.Poulsen. 2003. Measuring spatial concentration:The use of threshold profiles. Environment and Planning B:Planning and Design 30:3–14.
24. K.Jones, R.J.Johnston, D.Manley, D.Owen, and C.Charlton. 2015. Ethnic residential segregation:A multi-level, multi-group, multi-scale approach—Exemplified by London in 2011. Demography 52:1995–2019.
25. C.Kinsella, C.McTague, and K.N.Raleigh. 2015. Unmasking geographic polarization and clustering:A micro-scalar analysis of partisan voting behaviour. Applied Geography 62:404–19.
26. P.A.Klinkner, and A.Hapanowicz. 2005. Red and blue déjà vu:Measuring political polarization in the 2004 presidential election. Forum 3:2. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/40823274_Red_and_Blue_Dj_Vu_Measuring_Political_Polarization_in_the_2004_Election (last accessed 10 June 2016).
27. K.Larsen, and J.Merlo. 2005. Appropriate assessment of neighborhood effects on individual health:Integrating random and fixed effects in multilevel logistic regression. American Journal of Epidemiology 161:81–88.
28. G.C.Layman, T.M.Carsey, and J.M.Horowitz. 2006. Party polarization in American politics:Characteristics, causes and consequences. Annual Review of Political Science 9:83–110.
29. G.Leckie, R.Pillinger, K.Jones, and H.Goldstein. 2012. Multilevel modelling of social segregation. Journal of Educational and Behavioral Statistics 37:3–30.
30. B.A.Lee, S.F.Reardon, G.Firebaugh, C.R.Farrell, S.A.Matthews, and D.O'Sullivan. 2008. Beyond the census tract:Patterns and determinants of racial segregation at multiple geographic scales. American Sociological Review 73:766–91.
31. M.S.Levendusky, 2009a. The microfoundations of mass polarization. Political Analysis 17:162–76.
32. ———. 2009b. The partisan sort:How liberals became Democrats and conservatives became Republicans. Chicago:University of Chicago Press.
33. ———. 2010. Clearer cues, more consistent voters:A benefit of elite polarization. Political Behavior 32:111–31.
34. M.S.Levendusky, J.C.Pope, and S.D.Jackman. 2008. Measuring district-level partisanship with implications for the analysis of U.S. elections. Journal of Politics 70:736–53.
35. D.Manley, 2014. Scale, aggregation, and the modifiable areal unit problem. In Handbook of regional science, ed. M.M.Fischer and P.Nijkamp, 1157–71. Heidelberg, Germany:Springer.
36. D.Manley, R.J.Johnston, K.Jones, and D.Owen. 2015a. Macro-, meso- and micro-scale segregation:Modelling changing ethnic residential patterns in Auckland, New Zealand, 2001–2013. Annals of the Association of American Geographers 105:951–67.
37. ———. 2015b. Occupational segregation in London:A multilevel framework for modelling segregation. In Socio-economic segregation in European capital cities:East meets west, ed. T.Tammaru, S.Marcinczak, M.van Ham, and S.Musterd, 30–54. London and New York:Routledge.
38. I.McDonald, 2011. Migration and sorting in the American electorate:Evidence from the 2006 Cooperative Congressional Election Study. American Politics Research 39:512–33.
39. S.C.McKee, 2008. Rural voters and the polarization of American presidential elections. PS:Political Science and Politics 41:101–08.
40. N.Mellow, and P.Trubowitz. 2005. Red versus blue:American electoral geography and congressional bipartisanship, 1989–2002. Political Geography 24:659–77.
41. J.L.Mitchell, K.Sebold, A.Dowdle, S.Limbocker, and P.A.Stewart. 2015. The political geography of campaign finance:Fundraising and contribution patterns in presidential elections, 2004–2012. Basingstoke, UK:Palgrave Macmillan.
42. R.L.Morrill, L.Knopp, and M.Brown. 2011. Anomalies in red and blue II:Towards an understanding of the role of setting, values and demography in the 2004 and 2008 U.S. presidential elections. Political Geography 30:153–68.
43. A.S.Myers, 2013. Secular geographical polarization in the American south:The case of Texas, 1996–2010. Electoral Studies 32:48–62.
44. C.Nall, and J.Mummolo. 2013. Why partisans don't sort:How neighbourhood quality concerns limit Americans' pursuit of like-minded neighbors. http://web.stanford.edu/∼nall/docs/gp2.1.pdf (last accessed 10 June 2016).
45. L.M.Nunn, and J.H.Evans. 2006. Geographic polarization in social attitudes. http://citation.allacademic.com/meta/p_mla_apa_research_citation/1/0/3/6/5/p103658_index.html (last accessed 10 June 2016).
46. J.Östh, W.A.V.Clark, and S.Malmberg. 2014. Measuring the scale of segregation using k-nearest neighbor aggregates. Geographical Analysis 47:34–49.
47. D.Parisi, D.T.Lichter, and M.C.Taquino. 2011. Multi-scale residential segregation:Black exceptionalism and America's changing color line. Social Forces 89:829–52.
48. C.J.Pattie, and R.J.Johnston. 2000. “People who talk together, vote together”:An exploration of contextual effects in Great Britain. Annals of the Association of American Geographers 90:41–66.
49. S.F.Reardon, C.R.Farrell, S.A.Matthews, D.O'Sullivan, K.Bischoff, and G.Firebaugh. 2009. Race and space in the 1990s:Changes in the geographic scale of racial residential segregation, 1990–2000. Social Science Research 38:57–72.
50. S.Reardon, S.A.Matthews, D.O'Sullivan, B.A.Lee, G.Firebaugh, C.R.Farrell, and K.Bischoff. 2008. The geographic scale of metropolitan racial segregation. Demography 45:489–514.
51. S.F.Reardon, J.T.Yun, and T.M.Eitle. 2000. The changing structure of school segregation:Measurement and evidence of multiracial metropolitan-area school segregation, 1989–1995. Demography 37:351–64.
52. D.J.Scala, K.M.Johnson, and K.T.Rogers. 2015. Red rural, blue rural? Presidential voting patterns in a changing rural America. Political Geography 48:108–18.
53. S.V.Subramanian, C.Duncan, and K.Jones. 2001. Multilevel perspectives on modelling census data. Environment and Planning A 33:399–417.
54. S.V.Subramanian, K.Jones, A.Kaddour, and N.Krieger. 2009. Revisiting Robinson:The perils of individualistic and ecological fallacy. International Journal of Epidemiology 38:342–60.
55. C.Sunstein, 2009. Going to extremes:How like minds unite and divide. Oxford, UK:Oxford University Press.
56. J.Sussell, 2013. New support for the big sort hypothesis:An assessment of partisan geographic sorting in California, 1992–2010. PS:Political Science and Politics 50:768–73.
57. P.J.Taylor, 1988. History's dialogue:An exemplification from human geography. Progress in Human Geography 12:1–14.
58. M.Tranmer, and D.G.Steel. 2001. Ignoring a level in a multilevel model:Evidence from UK census data. Environment and Planning A 33:941–48.
59. D.Voas, and P.Williamson. 2000. The scale of dissimilarity:Concepts, measurement and an application to socio-economic variation across England and Wales. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers NS25:465–81.
60. I.S.Wing, and J.L.Walker. 2010. The geographic dimensions of electoral polarization in the 2004 U.S. presidential vote. In Progress in spatial analysis, ed. A.Páez, J.Gallo, R.N.Buliung, and S.Dall'erba, 253–85. Berlin:Springer.