Spinal Manipulation Vs Sham Manipulation for Nonspecific Low Back Pain: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis

Journal of Chiropractic Medicine

Volumn 15, Issue 3, 2016, Pages 165-183

  Ruddock, Jay K ^a   Sallis, Hannah ^b,c   Ness, Andy ^d   Perry, Rachel E ^d  

^a Align Body Clinic   (United Kingdom)

^b UNIVERSITY OF BRISTOL   (United Kingdom)

^c UNIVERSITY OF BRISTOL   (United Kingdom)

^d UNIVERSITY HOSPITALS BRISTOL NHS FOUNDATION TRUST   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Low back pain; Manipulation; Placebo; Review of the literature; Spinal

Indexed keywords

EID: 84969695219     PISSN: 15563707     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.jcm.2016.04.014     Document Type: Article

References (90)

1. 1 CBI, Healthy returns? Absence and Workplace Health Survey 2010. 2010, CBI, London [Available from: http://www.cbi.org.uk/pdf/20100607-cbi-pfizer-absence-report.pdf].
2. 2 Guo, HR, Tanaka, S, Halperin, WE, Back pain prevalence in US industry and estimates of lost work days. Am J Public Health 89 (1999), 1029–1035.
3. 3 Barnes, PM, Bloom, B, Nahin, R, CDC national health statistics report #12. Complementary and alternative medicine use among adults and children: United States, 2007, 2008.
4. 4 Fawkes, C, Leach, J, Mathias, S, Moore, AP, Standardised data collection within osteopathic practice in the UK: development and first use of a tool to profile osteopathic care in 2009. 2010, National Council for Osteopathic Research, Brighton [Available from: http://www.osteopathy.org.uk/news-and-resources/document-library/research-and-surveys/standardised-data-collection-project/].
5. 5 Seffinger, M, Hruby, R, Evidence Based Manual Medicine – A Problem Based Approach. 2007, Elsevier, Philadelphia.
6. 6 Magee, D, Zachazewski, J, Quillen, W, Pathology and intervention in musculoskeletal rehabilitation. 2009, Elsevier, St Louis.
7. 7 Bronfort, G, Haas, M, Evans, R, Leininger, B, Triano, J, Effectiveness of manual therapies; the UK evidence report. Chiropr Osteopat, 18, 2010, 3.
8. 8 Urquhart, DM, Hoving, JL, Assendelft, WJ, Roland, M, van Tulder, MW, Antidepressants for non-specific low back pain. Cochrane Database Syst Rev(1), 2008, CD001703.
9. 9 Furlan, AD, van Tulder, MW, Cherkin, D, et al. Acupuncture and dry-needling for low back pain. Cochrane Database Syst Rev(1), 2005, CD001351.
10. 10 Bogduk, N, Jull, G, The theoretical pathology of acute locked back; a basis for manipulative therapy. Man Med 1 (1985), 78–82.
11. 11 Shekelle, P, Spine update; spinal manipulation. Spine 6 (1994), 858–861.
12. 12 Triano, J, Biomechanics of spinal manipulative therapy. Spine J 1 (2001), 121–130.
13. 13 Pickar, J, McLain, R, Responses of mechanosensitive afferents to manipulation of the lumbar facet in the cat. Spine 20 (1995), 2379–2385.
14. 14 Pickar, J, Neurophysiological effects of spinal manipulation. Spine J 2 (2002), 357–371.
15. 15 Ernst, E, Does spinal manipulation have specific treatment effects?. Fam Pract 17 (2000), 554–556.
16. 16 Ernst, E, Harkness, E, Spinal manipulation: a systematic review of sham-controlled, double-blind, randomized controlled trials. J Pain Symptom Manag 22:4 (2001), 879–889.
17. 17 Evans, D, Mechanisms and effects of spinal high-velocity, low-amplitude thrust manipulation: previous theories. J Manipulative Physiol Ther 25 (2002), 251–262.
18. 18 Herbert, J, Stronski, N, Frensh, S, Rubenstein, S, Serious adverse events and spinal manipulative therapy of the low back region: a systematic review of cases. J Manipulative Physiol Ther, 2013, 10.1016/j.jmpt.2013.05.009.
19. 19 Koes, B, How to evaluate manual therapy; value and pitfalls of randomised controlled trials. Man Ther 9 (2004), 183–184.
20. 20 Hancock, M, Maher, C, Latimer, J, McAuley, J, Selecting an appropriate placebo for a trial of spinal manipulative therapy. Aust J Physiother 52 (2006), 135–138.
21. 21 Maitland, G, 1986. Vertebral manipulation (5th Edition). London, Butterworths cited in Hancock M, Maher C, Latimer J, McAuley J. Selecting an appropriate placebo for a trial of spinal manipulative therapy. Aust J Physiother 52 (2006), 135–138.
22. 22 Fulda, K, Slicho, T, Stoll, S, Patient expectations for placebo treatments commonly used in osteopathic manipulative treatment (OMT) clinical trials; a pilot study. Osteopath Med Prim Care, 1, 2007, 3.
23. 23 Hawk, C, Long, C, Use of a pilot to refine the design of a study to develop a manual placebo treatment. J Neuromuscuolskelet Syst 8 (2000), 39–48.
24. 24 Machado, L, Kamper, SJ, Herbert, RD, Maher, CG, McAuley, JH, Imperfect placebos are common in low back pain trials: a systematic review of the literature. Eur Spine J 17 (2008), 889–904.
25. 25 Kirsch, W, Weixal, L, Double-blind versus deceptive administration of a placebo. Behav Neurosci 102 (1988), 319–323.
26. 26 Turner, J, Deyo, RA, Loeser, JD, Von Korff, M, Fordyce, WE, The importance of the placebo effects in pain treatment and research. JAMA 271 (1994), 1609–1614.
27. 27 Benedetti, F, Placebo effects; understanding the mechanisms in health and disease. 2009, Oxford University Press, New York.
28. 28 Licciardone, J, Brimhall, A, King, L, Osteopathic manipulative treatment for low back pain: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. BMC Musculoskelet Disord 6:4 (2005), 43–55.
29. 29 Rubinstein, SM, van Middelkoop, M, Assendelft, WJ, de Boer, MR, van Tulder, MW, Spinal manipulative therapy for chronic low-back pain. Cochrane Database Syst Rev(2), 2011, CD008112.
30. 30 Rubinstein, SM, Terwee, CB, Assendelft, WJJ, de Boer, MR, van Tulder, MW, Spinal manipulative therapy for acute low-back pain. Cochrane Database Syst Rev(9), 2012, CD008880.
31. 31 Wreje, U, Nordgren, B, Aberg, H, Treatment of pelvic joint dysfunction in primary care—a controlled study. Scand J Prim Health Care 10:4 (1992), 310–315.
32. 32 Licciardone, J, Stoll, ST, Fulda, KG, et al. Osteopathic manipulative treatment for chronic low back pain: a randomised controlled trial. Spine 28:13 (2003), 1355–1362.
33. 33 Waagen, G, Halderman, S, Cook, G, Lopez, D, Deboer, K, Short term trial of chiropractic adjustments for the relief of chronic low back pain. Man Med 2 (1986), 63–67.
34. 34 Hondras, M, Long, CR, Cao, Y, Rowell, RM, Meeker, WC, A randomised controlled trial comparing two types of spinal manipulation and minimal conservative medical care for adults 55 years and older with subacute or chronic low back pain. J Manipulative Physiol Ther 32:5 (2009), 330–343.
35. 35 Triano, J, McGregor, M, Hondras, M, Brennan, P, Manipulative therapy versus education in chronic low back pain. Spine 20:8 (1995), 948–953.
36. 36 Hidalgo, B, Detrembleur, C, Hall, T, Mahaudens, P, Nielens, H, The efficacy of manual therapy and exercise for different stages of non-specific low back pain: an update of systematic reviews. J Manipulative Physiol Ther 22:2 (2014), 59–74.
37. 37 Furlan, A, Pennick, V, Bombardier, C, van Tulder, M, Editorial Board, Cochrane Back Review Group, Updated method guidelines for systematic reviews in the Cochrane Back Review Group. Spine 34:18 (2009), 1929–1941.
38. 38 Moher, D, Liberati, A, Tetzlaff, J, Altman, DG, for the PRISMA Group, Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. BMJ, 339, 2009, b2535.
39. 39 Harris, RM, Bradburn, MJ, Deeks, JJ, Harbord, RM, Altman, DG, Sterne, J, metan: fixed- and random-effects meta-analysis. Stata J 8:1 (2008), 3–28.
40. 40 Sterne, JA, Harbord, RM, Funnel plots in meta-analysis. Stata J 4 (2004), 127–141.
41. 41 Deeks, JJ, Altman, DG, Bradburn, MJ, Statistical methods for examining heterogeneity and combining results from several studies in meta-analysis. systematic reviews in health care. BMJ, 2008, 285–312.
42. 42 Hedges, LV, Vevea, JL, Fixed- and random-effects models in meta-analysis. Psychol Methods 3:4 (1998), 486–504.
43. 43 Higgins, J, Thompson, SG, Deeks, JJ, Altman, DG, Measuring inconsistency in meta-analyses. BMJ 327 (2003), 557–560.
44. 44 Senna, K, Machaly, S, Does maintained spinal manipulation therapy for chronic nonspecific low back pain result in better long-term outcome?. Spine 36:18 (2011), 1427–1437.
45. 45 Hadler, N, Curtis, P, Gillings, D, Stinnet, S, A benefit of spinal manipulation as adjunctive therapy for acute lower back pain: a stratified controlled trial. Spine 12:7 (1987), 702–706.
46. 46 Hoiiris, K, Pfleger, B, McDuffie, F, et al. A randomized clinical trial comparing chiropractic adjustments to muscle relaxants for sub acute low back pain. J Manipulative Physiol Ther 27:6 (2004), 388–398.
47. 47 Bialosky, J, George, SZ, Horn, ME, Price, DD, Staud, R, Robinson, ME, Spinal manipulative therapy-specific changes in pain sensitivity in individuals with low back pain. J Pain 15:2 (2014), 136–148.
48. 48 Kawchuk, G, Haugen, R, Fritz, J, A true blind for subjects who receive spinal manipulative therapy. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 90 (2009), 366–368.
49. 49 Ghroubi, S, Elleuch, H, Baklouti, S, Elleuch, M, Chronic low back pain and vertebral manipulation. Ann Readapt Med Phys 50:7 (2007), 570–576.
50. 50 Von Heymann, V, Schloemer, P, Timm, J, Muehlbauer, B, Spinal high-velocity low amplitude manipulation in acute nonspecific low back pain. Spine 38:7 (2013), 540–548.
51. 51 Ward, R C, American Osteopathic Association, (eds.) Foundations for osteopathic medicine, 2nd ed., 2003, Lippincott, Williams and Wilkins, Philadelphia.
52. 52 Learman, K, Yers, JB, Lephart, SM, Sell, TC, Kerns, GJ, Cook, CE, Effects of spinal manipulation on trunk proprioception in subjects with chronic low back pain during symptom remission. J Manipulative Physiol Ther 32:2 (2009), 118–126.
53. 53 Cohen, J, Statistical power analysis for the behavioural sciences. 1st ed., 1988, Academic Press, New York, San Francisco, London [1-474].
54. 54 Higgins, JPT, Green, S, (eds.) Cochrane handbook for systematic reviews of interventions version 5.1.0 [updated March 2011] The Cochrane Collaboration, 2011 [Available from www.cochrane-handbook.org, [accessed 21/4/14]].
55. 55 Furlan, A, Immamura, M, Dryden, T, Irvin, E, Massage for low back pain. Cochrane Database Syst Rev(4), 2008, CD001929.
56. 56 Halpern, J, Empathy, using resonance emotions in the service of curiosity. J Gen Intern Med 22:5 (2007), 696–700.
57. 57 Thomas, K, General practice consultations; is there any point being positive?. BMJ 294 (1987), 1200–1202.
58. 58 Easterbrook, P, Berlin, A, Gopalan, R, Matthews, R, Publication bias in clinical research. Lancet 337:8746 (1991), 867–872.
59. 59 Ernst, E, Pittler, M, Alternative therapy bias. Nature, 385(6616), 1997, 480.
60. 60 Ernst, E, Publication bias in complementary/alternative medicine. J Clin Epidemiol 60:11 (2007), 1093–1094.
61. 61 Ernst, E, ‘First, do no harm’ with complementary and alternative medicine. Trends Pharmacol Sci 28:2 (2007), 48–50.
62. 62 Haldeman, S, Kohlbeck, F, McGregor, M, Risk factors and precipitating neck movements causing vertebral artery dissection after cervical trauma and spinal manipulation. Spine 24 (1999), 785–794.
63. 63 Powell, F, Hanigan, W, Olivero, W, A risk/benefit analysis of spinal manipulation therapy for relief of lumbar or cervical pain. Neurosurgery 33 (1993), 73–78.
64. 64 Goldstein, M, A challenge to the profession; initiate evidence-based osteopathic medicine now. J Am Osteopath Assoc, 97, 1997, 448.
65. 65 Howell, J, The paradox of osteopathy. N Engl J Med 341 (1999), 1465–1468.
66. 66 Ernst, E, Canter, P, A systematic review of systematic reviews of spinal manipulation. J R Soc Med 99 (2006), 189–193.
67. 67 Scrimshaw, S, Maher, C, Responsiveness of visual analogue scale and Mcgill pain scale measures. J Manipulative Physiol Ther 24:8 (2001), 501–504.
68. 68 Million, R, Hall, W, Nilsen, KH, Baker, RD, Jayson, MI, Assessment of the progress of the back pain patient. Spine 7:3 (1982), 204–212.
69. 69 Deyo, R, Dworkin, S, Amtmann, D, et al. Report of the Task Force on Research. Standards for chronic low-back pain. 2013, National Institutes of Health, Bethesda [Available from: http://painconsortium.nih.gov/NIH_Pain_Programs/Task_Force/cLBP_RTF_FullReport.pdf].
70. 70 Assendelft, W, Morton, S, Yu, E, Suttorp, M, Shekelle, P, Spinal manipulative therapy for low back pain. A meta-analysis of effectiveness relative to other therapies. Ann Intern Med 138 (2003), 898–906.
71. 71 Clark, B, Walkowski, S, Conatser, RR, Eland, DC, Howell, JN, Muscle functional magnetic resonance imaging and acute low back pain; a pilot study to characterize lumbar muscle activity asymmetries and examine the effects of osteopathic manipulative treatment. Osteopath Med Prim Care, 27(3), 2009, 7.
72. 72 Cleary, C, Fox, J, Menopausal symptoms; an osteopathic intervention. Complement Ther Med 2 (1994), 181–186.
73. 73 Cleland, J, Fritz, J, Childs, J, Kulig, K, Comparison of three manual physical therapy techniques in a subgroup of patients with low back pain who satisfy a clinical prediction rule; study protocol of a randomised clinical trial. BMC Musculoskelet Disord, 10(7), 2006, 11.
74. 74 Cote, P, Mior, S, Vernon, H, The short term effect of a spinal manipulation on pain/pressure threshold in patients with chronic mechanical low back pain. J Manipulative Physiol Ther 17:6 (1994), 364–368.
75. 75 Cramer, G, Gregerson, DM, Knudsen, JT, Hubbard, BB, Ustas, LM, Cantu, JA, The effects of side-posture positioning and spinal adjusting on the lumbar Z joints; a randomised controlled trial with sixty-four subjects. Spine 15:27 (2002), 2459–2466.
76. 76 Dishman, J, Ball, K, Burke, J, Central motor excitability changes after spinal manioulation; a transcranial magnetic stimulation study. J Manipulative Physiol Ther 25:1 (2002), 1–9.
77. 77 Hancock, M, Maher, CG, Latimer, J, et al. Assessment of diclofenac or spinal manipulative therapy, or both, in addition to recommended first line treatment for acute low back pain; a randomised controlled trial. Lancet 10:370 (2007), 1638–1643.
78. 78 Hancock, M, Maher, CG, Latimer, J, Herbert, RD, McAuley, JH, Independent evaluation of a clinical prediction rule for spinal manipulative therapy; a randomised controlled trial. Eur Spine J 17:7 (2008), 936–943.
79. 79 Hawk, C, Long, CR, Rowell, RM, Gudavalli, MR, Jedlicka, J, A randomised trial investigating a chiropractic manual placebo, a novel design using standardised forces in the delivery of active and control treatments. J Altern Complement Med, 11(1), 2005, 109.
80. 80 Hoehler, F, Tobis, J, Beurger, A, Spinal manipulation for low back pain. JAMA 245:18 (1981), 1835–1838.
81. 81 Hondras, M, Long, C, Brennan, P, Spinal manipulative therapy versus a low force mimic manoeuvre for women with primary dysmenorrhoea; a randomised observer blinded trial. Pain 81:1 (1999), 105–114.
82. 82 Kokjohn, K, Schmidt, D, Triano, J, Brennan, P, The effect of spinal manipulation on pain and prostoglandin levels in women with primary dysmenorrhea. J Manipulative Physiol Ther 15:5 (1992), 279–285.
83. 83 Krekoukias, G, Petty, N, Cheek, L, Comparison of surface electromyographic activity of erector spinae before and after the application of central posteroanterior mobilization on the lumbar spine. J Manipulative Physiol Ther 19:1 (2009), 39–45.
84. 84 Licciardone, J, Minotti, DE, Gatchel, RJ, Kearns, CM, Singh, KP, Osteopathic manual treatment and ultrasound therapy for chronic low back pain: a randomised controlled trial. Ann Fam Med 11:2 (2013), 122–129.
85. 85 Ongley, M, Droman, T, Klein, R, Eek, B, Hubert, L, A new approach to low back pain. Lancet 2:855 (1987), 143–146.
86. 86 Mandara, A, Fusaro, A, Musicco, M, Bado, F, A randomised controlled trial on the effectiveness of osteopathic manipulative treatment of chronic low back pain. Int J Osteopath Med, 11, 2008, 156.
87. 87 Perry, J, Green, A, An investigation into the effects of a unilaterally applied lumbar mobilization technique on peripheral sympathetic nervous system activity in the lower limbs. Man Ther 13:6 (2008), 492–499.
88. 88 Puetendura, E, Landers, MR, Hurt, K, Meissner, M, Mills, J, Young, D, Immediate effects of lumbar spine manipulation on the resting and contraction thickness of transverse abdominis in asymptomatic individuals. J Orthop Sports Phys Ther 41:1 (2011), 13–21.
89. 89 Roy, R, Boucher, J, Comtois, A, Heart rate variability modulation after manipulation in pain free patients vs patients with pain. J Manipulative Physiol Ther 32:4 (2009), 277–286.
90. 90 Santilli, V, Behgi, E, Finucci, S, Chiropractic manipulation in the treatment of acute low back pain and sciatica with disc protrusion; a randomised double-blind clinical trial of active and simulated spinal manipulations. Spine J 6:2 (2006), 131–137.