Neuroimaging measures of error-processing: Extracting reliable signals from event-related potentials and functional magnetic resonance imaging

NeuroImage

Volumn 132, Issue , 2016, Pages 247-260

  Steele, Vaughn R ^a,b,c   Anderson, Nathaniel E ^b   Claus, Eric D ^b   Bernat, Edward M ^d   Rao, Vikram ^b   Assaf, Michal ^e,f   Pearlson, Godfrey D ^e,f   Calhoun, Vince D ^b,c,e   Kiehl, Kent A ^b,c  

^a NATIONAL INSTITUTE ON DRUG ABUSE   (United States)

^b Lovelace Biomedical and Environmental Research Institute   (United States)

^c UNIVERSITY OF NEW MEXICO   (United States)

^d UNIVERSITY OF MARYLAND   (United States)

^e YALE UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF MEDICINE   (United States)

^f INSTITUTE OF LIVING   (United States)

Author keywords

ERP; Error processing; FMRI; Independent component analysis; Principal component analysis; Reliability; Time frequency analysis

Indexed keywords

ADOLESCENT; ADULT; ARTICLE; BOLD SIGNAL; DATA ANALYSIS; DELTA RHYTHM; ELECTROENCEPHALOGRAM; ERROR PROCESSING MEASUREMENT; EVENT RELATED POTENTIAL; FEMALE; FUNCTIONAL MAGNETIC RESONANCE IMAGING; GO NOGO TASK; HUMAN; HUMAN EXPERIMENT; INDEPENDENT COMPONENT ANALYSIS; MALE; NEUROIMAGING; NEUROPSYCHOLOGICAL TEST; NORMAL HUMAN; PRINCIPAL COMPONENT ANALYSIS; PRIORITY JOURNAL; QUALITY CONTROL PROCEDURES; REGION OF INTEREST ANALYSIS; RELIABILITY; SAMPLE SIZE; THETA RHYTHM; TIME DOMAIN WINDOWED ANALYSIS; TIME FREQUENCY ANALYSIS; BRAIN; BRAIN MAPPING; ELECTROENCEPHALOGRAPHY; EVOKED RESPONSE; MIDDLE AGED; NUCLEAR MAGNETIC RESONANCE IMAGING; PHYSIOLOGY; PROCEDURES; REPRODUCIBILITY; SIGNAL PROCESSING; YOUNG ADULT;

ADOLESCENT; ADULT; BRAIN; BRAIN MAPPING; BRAIN WAVES; ELECTROENCEPHALOGRAPHY; EVOKED POTENTIALS; FEMALE; HUMANS; MAGNETIC RESONANCE IMAGING; MALE; MIDDLE AGED; REPRODUCIBILITY OF RESULTS; SIGNAL PROCESSING, COMPUTER-ASSISTED; YOUNG ADULT;

EID: 84960193034     PISSN: 10538119     EISSN: 10959572     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2016.02.046     Document Type: Article

References (70)

1. Anderson N.E., Steele V.R., Maurer J.M., Bernat E.M., Kiehl K.A. Psychopathy, attention, and oddball target detection: new insights from PCL-R facet scores. Psychophysiology 2015.
2. Bellemann M.E., Spitzer M., Brix G., Kammer T., Loose R., Schwartz A., Fuckel F. Neurofunctional MRI imaging of higher cogntive performance of the human brain. Radiologe 1995, 35:272-282.
3. Bernat E.M., Williams W.J., Gehring W.J. Decomposing ERP time-frequency energy using PCA. Clin. Neurophysiol. 2005, 116:1314-1334.
4. Bernat E.M., Nelson L.D., Holroyd C.B., Gehring W.J., Patrick C.J. Separating cognitive processes with principal components analysis of EEG time-frequency distributions. Adv. Sig. Process. Algoritm., Archit., and Implement. 2008, 7074:707401-7074010.
5. Bernat E.M., Nelson L.D., Steele V.R., Gehring W.J., Patrick C.J. Externalizing psychopathology and gain-loss feedback in a simulated gambling task: dissociable components of brain response revealed by time-frequency analysis. J. Abnorm. Psychol. 2011, 120:352-364.
6. Bernat E.M., Nelson L.D., Baskin-Sommers A.R. Time-frequency theta and delta measures index separable components of feedback processing in a gambling task. Psychophysiology 2015, 52:626-637.
7. Calhoun V.D., Adali T. Multisubject independent component analysis of fMRI: a decade of intrinsic networks, default mode, and neurodiagnostic discovery. IEEE Rev. Biomed. Eng. 2012, 5:60.
8. Calhoun V.D., Adali T., Pearlson G.D., Pekar J.J. A method for making group inferences from functional MRI data using independent component analysis. Hum. Brain Mapp. 2001, 14:140-151.
9. Calhoun V.D., Stevens M.C., Pearlson G.D., Kiehl K.A. fMRI analysis with the general linear model: removal of latency-induced amplitude bias by incorporation of hemodynamic derivative terms. NeuroImage 2004, 22:252-257.
10. Calhoun V.D., Adali T., Stevens M.C., Kiehl K.A., Pekar J.J. Semi-blind ICA of fMRI: a method for utilizing hypothesis-derived time courses in a spatial ICA analysis. NeuroImage 2005, 25:527-538.
11. Carbonnell L., Falkenstein M. Does the error negativity reflect the degree of response conflict?. Brain Res. 2006, 1095:124-130.
12. Carter C.S., Braver T.S., Barch D.M., Botvinick M., Noll D., Cohen J.D. Anterior cingulate cortex, error detection, and the online monitoring of performance. Science 1998, 280:747-749.
13. Chapman R.M., McCarry J.W. EP component identification and measurment by principal component analysis. Brain Cogn. 1995, 27:288-310.
14. Cohen J., Polich J. On the number of trials needed for P300. Int. J. Psychophysiol. 1997, 25:249-255.
15. Delorme A., Makeig S. EEGLAB: an open source toolbox for analysis of single-trial EEG dynamics including independent component analysis. J. Neurosci. Methods 2004, 134:9-21.
16. Demiralp T., Ademoglu A., Istefanopulos Y., Basar-Eroglu C., Basar E. Wavelet analysis of oddball P300. Int. J. Psychophysiol. 2001, 39:221-227.
17. Desmond J.E., Glover G.H. Estimating sample size in functional MRI (fMRI) neuroimaging studies: statistical power analyses. J. Neurosci. Methods 2002, 118:115-128.
18. Dien J. Addressing misallocation of variance in principal components analysis of event-related potentials. Brain Topogr. 1998, 11:43-55.
19. Dien J., Khoe W., Mangun G.R. Evaluation of PCA and ICA of simulated ERPs: Promax vs. Infomax rotations. Hum. Brain Mapp. 2007, 28:742-763.
20. Edwards B.G., Calhoun V.D., Kiehl K.A. Joint ICA of ERP and fMRI during error-monitoring. NeuroImage 2012, 59:1896-1903.
21. Endrass T., Reuter B., Kathmann N. ERP correlates of conscious error recognition: aware and unaware errors in an antisaccade task. Eur. J. Neurosci. 2007, 26:1714-1720.
22. Erhardt E.B., Rachakonda S., Bedrick E.J., Allen E.A., Adali T., Calhoun V.D. Comparison of multi-subject ICA methods for analysis of fMRI data. Hum. Brain Mapp. 2011, 32:2075-2095.
23. Falkenstein M., Hohnsbein J., Hoormann J., Blanke L. Effects of errors in choice reaction tasks on the ERP under focused and divided attention. Psychophysiological brain research 1990, 192-195. Tilburg University Press, Tilburg. C.H.M. Brunia, A.W.K.G., A. Kok (Eds.).
24. Falkenstein M., Hohnsbein J., Hoormann J., Blanke L. Effects of crossmodal divided attention on late ERP components. II. Error processing in choice reaction tasks. Electroencephalogr. Clin. Neurophysiol. 1991, 78:447-455.
25. First M.B., Spitzer R.L., Gibbon M.W.J.B., Williams J.B.W. Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-IV Axis I (SCID-I), Clinician Version 1997, American Psychiatric Press, Washington DC.
26. Foti D., Kotov R., Hajcak G. Psychometric considerations in using error-related brain activity as a biomarker in psychotic disorders. J. Abnorm. Psychol. 2013, 122:520-531.
27. Freire L., Mangin J.F. Motion correction algorithms may create spurious brain activations in the absence of subject motion. NeuroImage 2001, 14:709-722.
28. Freire L., Roche A., Mangin J.F. What is the best similarity measure for motion correction in fMRI time series?. IEEE Trans. Med. Imaging 2002, 21:470-484.
29. Friston K.J., Holmes A.P., Worsley K.J., Poline J.-P., Frith C.D., Frackowiak R.S.J. Statistical parametric maps in functional imaging: a general linear approach. Hum. Brain Mapp. 1994, 2:189-210.
30. Gehring W.J., Goss B., Coles M.G.H., Meyer D.E., Donchin E. A neural system for error detection and compensation. Psychol. Sci. 1993, 4:385-390.
31. Gilmore C.S., Malone S.M., Bernat E.M., Iacono W.G. Relationship between the P3 event-related potential, its associated time-frequency components, and externalizing psychopathology. Psychophysiology 2010, 47:123-132.
32. Hall J.R., Bernat E.M., Patrick C.J. Externalizing psychopathology and the error-related negativity. Psychol. Sci. 2007, 18:326-333.
33. Handy T.C. Event-related Potentials: A Methods Handbook 2005, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
34. Harper J., Malone S.M., Bernat E.M. Theta and delta band activity explain N2 and P3 ERP component activity in a go/no-go task. Clin. Neurophysiol. 2014, 125:124-132.
35. Holroyd C.B., Coles M.G.H. The neural basis of human error processing: reinforcement learning, dopamine, and the error-related negativity. Psychol. Rev. 2002, 109:679-709.
36. Huettel S.A., McCarthy G. The effects of single-trial averageing upon the spatial extend of fMRI activation. Neuroreport 2001, 12:2411-2416.
37. Jasper H.H. The ten-twenty electrode system of the International Federation. Electroencephalogr. Clin. Neurophysiol. 1958, 10:371-375.
38. Jung T.-P., Makeig S., Westerfield M., Townsend J., Courchesne E., Sejnowski T.J. Removal of eye activity artifacts from visual event-related potentials in normal and clinical subjects. Clin. Neurophysiol. 2000, 111:1745-1758.
39. Kiehl K.A., Liddle P.F., Hopfinger J.B. Error processing and the rostral anterior cingulate: an event-related fMRI study. Psychophysiology 2000, 37:216-223.
40. Laaksoa M.P., Vaurioc O., Koivstod E., Savolainenc L., Eronenc M., Aronenb H.J., Hakolac P., Repoc E., Soininena H., Tihonenc J. Psychopathy and the posterior hippocampus. Behav. Brain Res. 2001, 118:187-193.
41. Leuthold H., Sommer S. ERP correlates of error processing in spatial S-R compatibility tasks. Clin. Neurophysiol. 1999, 110:342-357.
42. Luck S.J. Ten simple rules for designing ERP experiments. Event-related Potentials: A Methods Handbook 2005, 262083337.
43. Luck S.J. An Introduction to the Event-related Potential Technique 2014, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
44. Malinen S., Hlushchuk Y., Hari R. Towards natural stimulation in fMRI-issues of data analysis. NeuroImage 2007, 35:131-139.
45. Maurer J.M., Steele V.R., Edwards B.G., Bernat E.M., Calhoun V.D., Kiehl K.A. Dysfunctional error-related processing in female psychopathy. Soc. Cogn. Affect. Neurosci. 2016, (in press).
46. Meyer A., Riesel A., Proudfit G.H. Reliability of the ERN across multiple tasks as a function of increasing errors. Psychophysiology 2013, 50:1220-1225.
47. Miltner W.H.R., Lemke U., Weiss T., Holroyd C., Scheffers M.K., Coles M.G.H. Implementation of error-processing in the human anterior cingulate cortex: a source analysis of the magnetic equivalent of the error-related negativity. Biol. Psychol. 2003, 64:157-166.
48. Murphy K., Garavan H. An empirical investigation into the number of subjects required for an event-related fMRI study. NeuroImage 2004, 22:879-885.
49. Nelson L.D., Patrick C.J., Collins P., Lang A.R., Bernat E.M. Alcohol impairs brain reactivity to explicit loss feedback. Psychopharmacology 2011, 218:419-428.
50. Niendam T.A., Laird A.R., Ray K.L., Dean Y.M., Glahn D.C., Carter C.S. Meta-analytic evidence for a superordinate cognitive control network subserving diverse executive functions. Cogn. Affect. Behav. Neurosci. 2012, 12:241-268.
51. Nieuwenhuis S., Ridderinkhof K.R., Blom J., Band G.P.H., Kok A. Error-related brain potentials are differentially related to awareness of response errors: evidence from an antisaccade task. Psychophysiology 2001, 38:752-760.
52. Olvet D.M., Hajcak G. The stability of error-related brain activity with increasing trials. Psychophysiology 2009, 46:957-961.
53. Overbeek T.J.M., Nieuwenhuis S., Ridderinkhof K.R. Dissociable components of error processing: on the functional significance of the Pe vis-à-vis the ERN/Ne. J. Psychophysiol. 2005, 19:319-329.
54. Pontifex M.B., Scudder M.R., Brown M.L., O'Leary K.C., Wu C.T., Themanson J.R., Hillman C.H. On the number of trials necessary for stabilization of error-related brain activity across the life span. Psychophysiology 2010, 47:767-773.
55. Rietdijk W.J., Franken I.H., Thurik A.R. Internal consistency of event-related potentials associated with cognitive control: N2/P3 and ERN/Pe. PLoS One 2014, 9.
56. Shalgi S., Deouell L.Y. Is any awareness necessary for an Ne?. Front. Hum. Neurosci. 2012, 6:124.
57. Shalgi S., Deouell L.Y. Is there any electrophysiological evidence for subliminal error processing?. Front. Neurosci. 2013, 7:150.
58. Steele V.R., Aharoni E., Munro G.E., Calhoun V.D., Nyalakanti P., Stevens M.C., Pearlson G., Kiehl K.A. A large scale (N = 102) functional neuroimaging study of response inhibition in a Go/NoGo task. Behav. Brain Res. 2013, 256:529-536.
59. Steele V.R., Bernat E.M., van den Broek P., Collins P.F., Patrick C.J., Marsolek C.J. Separable processes before, during, and after the N400 elicited by previously inferred and new information: evidence from time-frequency decompositions. Brain Res. 2013, 1492:92-107.
60. Steele V.R., Claus E.D., Aharoni E., Munro G.E., Calhoun V.D., Nyalakanti P., Stevens M.C., Pearlson G., Kiehl K.A. A large scale (N = 102) functional neuroimaging study of error-processing in an Go/NoGo task. Behav. Brain Res. 2014, 268:127-138.
61. Steele V.R., Fink B.C., Maurer J.M., Arbabshirani M.R., Wilber C.H., Jaffe A.J., Sidz A., Pearlson G.D., Calhoun V.D., Clark V.P., Kiehl K.A. Brain potentials measured during a Go/NoGo task predict completion of substance abuse treatment. Biol. Psychiatry 2014, 76:75-83.
62. Steele V.R., Claus E.D., Aharoni E., Vincent G.M., Calhoun V.D., Kiehl K.A. Multimodal imaging measures predict rearrest. Front. Hum. Neurosci. 2015, 9:425.
63. Steele V.R., Maurer J.M., Bernat E.M., Calhoun V.D., Kiehl K.A. Error-related processing in adult males with elevated psychopathic traits. Personality Disorders: Theory, Research, and Treatment 2016, (in press).
64. Tie Y., Whalen S., Suarez R.O., Golby A.J. Group independent component analysis of language fMRI from word generation tasks. NeuroImage 2008, 42:1214-1225.
65. Ullsperger M., Harsay H.A., Wessel J.R., Ridderinkhof K.R. Conscious perception of errors and its relation to the anterior insula. Brain Struct. Funct. 2010, 214:629-643.
66. van Veen V., Carter C.S. The timing of action-monitoring processes in the anterior cingulate cortex. J. Cogn. Neurosci. 2002, 14:593-602.
67. Xu J., Potenza M.N., Calhoun V.D. Spatial ICA reveals functional activity hidden from traditional fMRI GLM-based analyses. Front. Neurosci. 2013, 7:154.
68. Xu J., Zhang S., Calhoun V.D., Monterosso J., Li C.S., Worhunsky P.D., Stevens M., Pearlson G.D., Potenza M.N. Task-related concurrent but opposite modulations of overlapping functional networks as revealed by spatial ICA. NeuroImage 2013, 79:62-71.
69. Yeung N., Summerfield C. Metacognition in human decision-making: confidence and error monitoring. Philos. Trans. R. Soc. B 2012, 367:1310-1321.
70. Yeung N., Botvinick M.M., Cohen J.D. The neural basis of error detection: conflict monitoring and the error-related negativity. Psychol. Rev. 2004, 111:931-959.