Climates of suspicion: 'Chemtrail' conspiracy narratives and the international politics of geoengineering

Geographical Journal

Volumn 182, Issue 1, 2016, Pages 70-84

  Cairns, Rose ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF SUSSEX   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Chemtrails; Climate change; Conspiracy; Discourse analysis; Geoengineering; Public engagement

Indexed keywords

CLIMATE CHANGE; ENGINEERING; POLITICS; WEATHER MODIFICATION;

EID: 84958636867     PISSN: 00167398     EISSN: 14754959     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/geoj.12116     Document Type: Article

References (132)

1. Aircrap 2013 Health and social consequences of geoengineering (http//aircrap.org/health-societal-consequences-geoengineering/338536/) Accessed 7 April 2014
2. Anderson J W 1996 Conspiracy theories, premature entextualisation, and popular political analysis Arab Studies Journal 4 96-102
3. Appadurai A 1996 Modernity at large: cultural dimensions of globalization University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis
4. Bartlett J and Miller C 2010 The power of unreason: conspiracy theories, extremism and counter-terrorism Demos, London, UK
5. Bayat A 2006 Conspiracies & Theories ISIM 18 5
6. BBC 2013 Pakistan polio team hit by deadly attack (www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-26397602) Accessed 27 March 2014
7. Bellamy R, Chilvers J, Vaughan N E and Lenton T M 2012 A Review of climate geoengineering appraisals WIREs Climate Change 3 597-615
8. Bellamy R, Chilvers J, Vaughan N E and Lenton T M 2013 'Opening up' geoengineering appraisal: multi-criteria mapping of options for tackling climate change Global Environmental Change 23 926-937
9. Belter C and Seidel D J 2013 A bibliometric analysis of climate engineering research Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Climate Change 4 417-427
10. Birchall C 2002 The commodification of conspiracy theory in Conspiracy nation. The politics of paranoia in postwar America New York University Press, New York 233-253
11. Birchall C 2006 Knowledge goes pop: from conspiracy theory to gossip Berg, London
12. Bodansky D 2011 Governing climate engineering: scenarios for analysis The Harvard Project on Climate Agreements Discussion Paper 11-47 Cambridge, MA
13. Bodansky D 2013 The who, what, and wherefore of geoengineering governance Climatic Change 121 539-551
14. Bratich J 2002 Injections and truth serums: AIDS conspiracy theories and the politics of articulation in Knight P ed Conspiracy nation. The politics of paranoia in postwar America New York University Press, New York 148
15. Bratich J 2006 Public secrecy and immanent security Cultural Studies 20 493-511
16. Brewer P G 2007 Evaluating a technological fix for climate Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 104 9915-9916
17. Buck H J 2010 What can geoengineering do for us? Public participation and the new media landscape Paper for Workshop: The Ethics of Solar Radiation Management, 18 October 2010, University of Montana
18. Cairns R and Stirling A 2014 'Maintaining planetary systems' or 'Concentrating global power'? High stakes in contending framings of climate geoengineering Global Environmental Change 28 25-38
19. Carnicom C 2012 Consciousness beyond chemtrails keynote address: Geo-engineering and bio-engineering: the unmistakable link (www.youtube.com/watch?v=fXfd8VUUJTg) Accessed 20 March 2014
20. Chemtrails Planet 2014 Category archives: chemtrail (http://chemtrailsplanet.net/category/chemtrail/) Accessed 23 March 2014
21. Chemtrails Project UK 2014 About us page (www.chemtrailsprojectuk.com/about-us/) Accessed 20 March 2014
22. Clarke S 2002 Conspiracy theories and conspiracy theorizing Philosophy of the Social Sciences 32 131-150
23. Coady D 2006 An introduction to the philosophical debate about conspiracy theories in Coady D ed Conspiracy theories: the philosophical debate Ashgate Publishing, Burlington, VT 1-12
24. Coalition Against Geo-Engineering 2011 A pilots response to the chemtrail/contrail debate (www.coalitionagainstgeoengineering.org/pages/45) Accessed 20 March 2014
25. Contrail Science 2011 How to debunk chemtrails (http://contrailscience.com/how-to-debunk-chemtrails/) Accessed 5 March 2014
26. Corner A, Parkhill K and Pidgeon N 2011 'Experiment Earth?' Reflections on a public dialogue on geoengineering Cardiff School of Psychology, Understanding Risk Working Paper 11-02, 1-33
27. Cosmic Convergence 2013a Chemtrails: a planetary catastrophe created by geoengineering (updated) (http://cosmicconvergence.org/?p=5818) Accessed 20 March 2014
28. Cosmic Convergence 2013b Chemtrails: the biggest coverup of all time (http://cosmicconvergence.org/?p=5856) Accessed 25 March 2014
29. Dean J 2000 Theorizing conspiracy theory Theory and Event 4 (https://muse.jhu.edu/journals/theory_and_event/v004/4.3r_dean.html) Accessed 20 March 2014
30. Dean J 2002 If anything is possible in Knight P ed Conspiracy nation. The politics of paranoia in postwar America vol 2 New York University Press, New York 85-106
31. Dean J 2004 Secrecy since September 11 Interventions 6 362-380
32. Disinformation Directory 2014 Rose Cairns' climates of suspicion: chemtrail conspiracy... (http://disinformationdirectory.com/d/forum/professors-teachers-academia/38-rose-cairns-climates-of-suspicion-chemtrail-conspiracy) Accessed 25 July 2014
33. Dixon D 2009 Creating the semi-living: on politics, aesthetics and the more-than human Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 34 411-425
34. Dryzek J S 1997 The politics of the earth. Environmental discourses Oxford University Press, Oxford
35. Educate-Yourself 2014 Chemtrails (http://educate-yourself.org/ct/) Accessed 25 March 2014
36. Escobar A 1993 Welcome to Cyberia: notes on the anthropology of cyberculture Current Anthropology 35 211-231
37. Fenster M 1999 Conspiracy theories: secrecy and power in American culture University of Minnesota Press, Minnesota
38. Fiske J 1996 Media matters: everyday culture and political change University of Minnesota Press, Minnesota
39. Fleming J 2010 Fixing the sky Columbia University Press, New York
40. Flint C ed 2004 Spaces of hate: geographies of discrimination and intolerance in the USA Routledge, London
41. Gardiner S S M, Caney S, Jamieson D, Shue H, Franklin B, Cicerone R, Fleming J, Gamlund E, Gillespie M, Humphrey M, Johnson M, Miller R, Robock A, Rodgers W, Somerville R, Taebi B, Wallace M, Maier D and Preston C 2010 Is 'arming the future' with geoengineering really the lesser evil? Some doubts about the ethics of intentionally manipulating the climate system Climate Ethics: Essential Reading (http://folk.uio.no/gasheim/Gar2010b.pdf) Accessed 22 August 2014
42. GeoEngineering Watch 2014a CHEMTRAILS: covert crimes against humanity (www.geoengineeringwatch.org/chemtrails-gross-violation-of-the-public-trust-flagrant-breach-of-the-social-contract/) Accessed 20 March 2014
43. GeoEngineering Watch 2014b Dane Wigington video: Climate engineering, weather warfare and the collapse of civilization (www.geoengineeringwatch.org/) Accessed 15 April 2014
44. GeoEngineering Watch 2014c How the PhDs have wrecked the world (www.geoengineeringwatch.org/how-the-phds-have-wrecked-the-world/) Accessed 7 April 2014
45. GeoEngineering Watch 2014d How to get involved (www.geoengineeringwatch.org/how-to-get-involved/) Accessed 20 March 2014
46. GeoEngineering Watch 2014e How to test your water (www.geoengineeringwatch.org/how-to-test-2/) Accessed 12 April 2014
47. GeoEngineering Watch 2014f Media increases mass distraction while the walls close in on us all (www.geoengineeringwatch.org/media-increases-mass-distraction-while-the-walls-close-in-on-us-all/#more-15336) Accessed 20 March 2014
48. GeoEngineering Watch 2014g Passive democide: drought and starvation (www.geoengineeringwatch.org/passive-democide-drought-and-starvation/) Accessed 20 March 2014
49. GeoEngineering Watch 2014h The history of weather modification, how far back does it go? (www.geoengineeringwatch.org/the-history-of-weather-modification-is-very-long-and-extensive-indeed-those-that-deny-this-have-simple-not-investigated/) Accessed 20 April 2014
50. Gerstenfeld P B, Grant D R and Chiang C-P 2003 Hate online: a content analysis of extremist internet sites Analyses of Social Issues and Public Policy 3 29-44
51. Global March Against Geoengineering and Chemtrails 2014 Home page (www.globalmarchagainstchemtrailsandgeoengineering.com/) Accessed 20 April 2014
52. Global Skywatch 2014a About us (http://globalskywatch.com/about-us.html) Accessed 19 April 2014
53. Global Skywatch 2014b Chemtrails and the 5 stages of grief (www.globalskywatch.com/stories/Chemtrails-and-the-5-Stages-of-Grief.html#.U1jrw_ldV8E) Accessed 20 March 2014
54. Global Skywatch 2014c My chemtrail story (www.globalskywatch.com/stories/my-chemtrail-story/index.html) Accessed 20 March 2014
55. Goldberg R A 2001 Enemies within: the culture of conspiracy in modern America Yale University Press, New Haven, CT
56. Guardian 2013 Edward Snowden: the whistleblower behind the NSA surveillance revelations (www.theguardian.com/world/2013/jun/09/edward-snowden-nsa-whistleblower-surveillance?CMP=twt_gu) Accessed 25 July 2014
57. Hajer M A 1997 The politics of environmental discourse: ecological modernization and the policy process Oxford University Press, Oxford
58. Hamblin J D 2013 Arming mother nature Oxford University Press, New York
59. Hamilton C 2013 Earthmasters: the dawn of the age of climate engineering Yale University Press, London
60. Harding S and Stewart K 2003 Anxieties of influence: conspiracy theory and therapeutic culture in millennial America in West H and Sanders T eds Transparency and conspiracy: ethnographies of suspicion in the new world order Duke University Press, Durham, NC 258-286
61. Hellinger D 2003 Paranoia, conspiracy and hegemony in American politics in West H G and Sanders T eds Transparency and conspiracy: ethnographies of suspicion in the new world order Duke University Press, Durham 204-232
62. Hofstadter R 1964 The paranoid style in American politics Harper's Magazine
63. House of Commons 2010 House of Commons Science and Technology Committee report on The regulation of geoengineering London
64. Hulme M 2008 The conquering of climate: discourses of fear and their dissolution The Geographical Journal 174 5-16
65. Hulme M 2012 Climate change: climate engineering through stratospheric aerosol injection Progress in Physical Geography 36 694-705
66. Humphreys D 2011 Smoke and mirrors: some reflections on the science and politics of geoengineering The Journal of Environment & Development 20 99-120
67. Inhofe J 2012 The greatest hoax: how global warming conspiracy threatens your future WND Books, Washington DC
68. IPCC 2013 Climate change 2013: the physical science basis Working Group I Contribution to the Fifth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel of Climate Change. Summary for policy makers Geneva
69. Jamieson D 2013 Some whats, whys and worries of geoengineering Climatic Change 121 527-537
70. Jew Watch 2014 Home page (www.jewwatch.com/index.htm) Accessed 20 April 2014
71. Jones L 2009 'How do the American people know...?' Embodying post-9/11 conspiracy discourse GeoJournal 75 359-371
72. Jones L 2012 The commonplace geopolitics of conspiracy Geography Compass 6 44-59
73. Keeley B L 1999 Of conspiracy theories The Journal of Philosophy 96 109-126
74. Keith D 2013 A case for climate engineering MIT Press, Cambridge, MA
75. Knight P 2000 Conspiracy culture: from Kennedy to the X-Files Routledge, London
76. Koteyko N, Jaspal R and Nerlich B 2013 Climate change and 'climategate' in online reader comments: a mixed methods study The Geographical Journal 179 74-86
77. Kydd A H 2005 Trust and mistrust in international relations Princeton University Press, Princeton
78. Lahsen M 1999 The detection and attribution of conspiracies: the controversy over Chapter 8 in Marcus G ed Paranoia within reason: a casebook on conspiracy as explanation University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL 111-136
79. Lane L 2013 Climate engineering and the anthropocene era in Burns W C G and Strauss A L eds Climate change geoengineering: philosophical perspectives, legal issues and governance frameworks Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 115-145
80. Latour B 2004 Why has critique run out of steam? Critical Inquiry 30 225-228
81. Lewandowsky S, Oberauer K and Gignac G E 2013 NASA faked the moon landing - therefore, (climate) science is a hoax: an anatomy of the motivated rejection of science Psychological Science 24 622-633
82. Locke S 2009 Conspiracy culture, blame culture, and rationalisation The Sociological Review 57 567-585
83. Look-up! 2014a Coping with the knowledge (www.look-up.org.uk/further-information/coping-with-knowledge-and-the-gateway-to-hell/) Accessed 19 March 2014
84. Look-up! 2014b Home page (www.look-up.org.uk/) Accessed 22 March 2014
85. Lovbrand E, Stripple J and Wiman B 2009 Earth system governmentality reflections on science in the anthropocene Global Environmental Change 19 7-13
86. MacKian S 2011 Crossing spiritual boundaries: encountering, articulating and representing otherworlds Methodological Innovations Online 6 61-73
87. Macnaghten P and Owen R 2011 Environmental science: good governance for geoengineering Nature 479 293
88. Macnaghten P and Szerszynski B 2013 Living the global social experiment: An analysis of public discourse on solar radiation management and its implications for governance Global Environmental Change 23 465-474
89. Malykhina B E 2013 8 apps that turn citizens into scientists Scientific American 5 November
90. Marcus G 1999 Introduction to the volume: the paranoid style now in Marcus G ed Paranoia within reason: a casebook on conspiracy as explanation Chicago University Press, Chicago, IL 1-12
91. Markusson N, Ginn F, Ghaleigh N S and Scott V 2013 'In case of emergency press here': framing geoengineering as a response to dangerous climate change WIREs Climate Change 5 281-290
92. Mason F 2002 A poor person's cognitive mapping in Knight P ed Conspiracy nation: the politics of paranoia in postwar America New York University Press, New York 40-56
93. Mercer A M, Keith D W and Sharp J D 2011 Public understanding of solar radiation management Environmental Research Letters 6 044006
94. Metabunk 2014 Contrails and chemtrails (www.metabunk.org/forums/contrails-and-chemtrails.9/) Accessed 20 April 2014
95. Methmann C, Rothe D and Stephan B 2013 Introduction: how and why to deconstruct the greenhouse in Methmann C, Rothe D and Stephan B eds Interpretive approaches to global climate governance Routledge, Oxon 1-22
96. NAS 2002 Abrupt climate change: inevitable surprises National Academies Press, Washington, DC
97. Nerlich B and Jaspal R 2012 Metaphors we die by? Geoengineering, metaphors, and the argument from catastrophe Metaphor and Symbol 27 131-147
98. Niehaus I and Jonsson G 2006 Dr. Wouter Basson, Americans, and wild beasts: men's conspiracy theories of HIV/AIDS in the South African Lowveld Medical Anthropology 24 179-208
99. Northland New Zealand Chemtrails Watch 2014 Opinions regarding the functions of chemtrails/stratospheric aerosol geoengineering (http://chemtrailsnorthnz.wordpress.com/opinions-regarding-the-functions-of-chemtrailsstratospheric-aerosol-geoengineering/) Accessed 21 March 2014
100. Oreskes N and Conway E M 2010 Merchants of doubt: how a handful of scientists obscured the truth on issues from tobacco smoke to global warming Bloomsbury Press, New York
101. Oushakine S A 2009 'Stop the invasion!': money, patriotism, and conspiracy in Russia Social Research 76 71-116
102. Owen R, Macnaghten P and Stilgoe J 2012 Responsible research and innovation: from science in society to science for society, with society Science and Public Policy 39 751-760
103. Paterson M and Stripple J 2013 My space: governing individuals' carbon emissions in Methmann C, Rothe D and Stephan B eds Interpretive approaches to global climate governance Routledge, Oxon 139-151
104. Pelkmans M and Machold R 2011 Conspiracy theories and their truth trajectories Focaal - Journal of Global and Historical Anthropology 59 66-80
105. Pidgeon N, Corner A, Parkhill K, Spence A, Butler C and Poortinga W 2012 Exploring early public responses to geoengineering Philosophical Transactions. Series A, Mathematical, Physical, and Engineering Sciences 370 4176-4196
106. Pielke Jr R 2010 The climate fix. What scientists and politicians won't tell you about climate change Basic Books, New York
107. Pipes D 1997 Conspiracy: how the paranoid style flourishes and where it came from Simon and Schuster, New York
108. Porter K and Hulme M 2013 The emergence of the geoengineering debate in the UK print media: a frame analysis The Geographical Journal 179 342-355
109. Public debate 'The case for and against geoengineering' 2013 Exchange between David Keith and an audience member during a public debate organised by the Oxford Martin School 'The case for and against geoengineering' (www.youtube.com/watch?v=OXaxMRyRIlU) Accessed 3 April 2014
110. QSR International Pty Ltd 2012 Nvivo 10 (www.qsrinternational.com/products_nvivo.aspx) Accessed March 20 2014
111. Rayner A 2008 Beck is back but what's the conspiracy about chemtrails? The Guardian Music Blog 23 June (www.theguardian.com/music/musicblog/2008/jun/23/chemtrailsbeckisbackbutis) Accessed 20 March 2014
112. Robinson W 1996 Promoting polyarchy: globalization, US intervention, and hegemony Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
113. Sanders T and West H 2003 Power revealed and concealed in the new world order in West H ed Transparency and conspiracy: ethnographies of suspicion in the new world order Duke University Press, London 1-37
114. Scholte S, Vasileiadou E and Petersen A C 2013 Opening up the societal debate on climate engineering: how newspaper frames are changing Journal of Integrative Environmental Sciences 10 1-16
115. Showalter E 1998 Hystories: hysterical epidemics and modern culture Columbia University Press, New York
116. Sikka T 2012 A critical discourse analysis of geoengineering advocacy Critical Discourse Studies 9 163-175
117. Skyder ALERT 2014 Get app page (www.skyderalert.com/mobile-app/) Accessed 20 March 2014
118. Smith O 2013 'Chemtrails' and other aviation conspiracy theories The Telegraph September (www.telegraph.co.uk/travel/travelnews/travel-truths/10329986/Chemtrails-and-other-aviation-conspiracy-theories.html) Accessed 22 August 2014
119. Sorensen E and Torfing J 2005 Network governance and post-liberal democracy Administrative Theory and Praxis 27 197-237
120. Soukup C 2008 9/11 conspiracy theories on the world wide web: digital rhetoric and alternative epistemology Journal of Literacy and Technology 9 2-25
121. Stevenson H and Dryzek J S 2012 The discursive democratisation of global climate governance Environmental Politics 21 189-210
122. Stop Spraying California 2014 Desiccated human red blood cells and chemtrails (www.stopsprayingcalifornia.com/Desiccated_Human_Red_Blood_Cells.php) Accessed 20 March 2014
123. Sweeney J 2014 Command-and-control: alternative futures of geoengineering in an age of global weirding Futures 57 1-13
124. The Health Coach 2013 Chemtrail syndrome: a global pandemic of epic proportions (http://thehealthcoach1.com/?p=3403) Accessed 15 April 2014
125. Thomas W 1999 January contrails mystify, sicken Americans Environment News Service (http://web.archive.org/web/19990503013500/ens.lycos.com/ens/jan99/1999L-01-08-05.html) Accessed 20 March 2014
126. Victor D G 2008 On the regulation of geoengineering Oxford Review of Economic Policy 24 322-336
127. Vidal J 2013 Rogue geoengineer could hijack world's climate The Guardian January (www.theguardian.com/environment/2013/jan/08/geoengineering-hijack-world-climate) Accessed 20 March 2014
128. West H and Sanders T eds 2003 Transparency and conspiracy: ethnographies of suspicion in the new world order Duke University Press, Durham, NC
129. Wheen F 2004 How mumbo jumbo conquered the world: a short history of modern delusions Harper Perennial, New York
130. Whyte J 2012 Opening address, consciousness beyond chemtrails conference (www.youtube.com/watch?v=fXfd8VUUJTg) Accessed 21 March 2014
131. Willman S 2002 Spinning paranoia: the ideologies of conspiracy and contingency in postmodern culture in Knight P ed Conspiracy nation. The politics of paranoia in postwar America New York University Press, New York 21-39
132. Wood M J, Douglas K M and Sutton R M 2012 Dead and alive: beliefs in contradictory conspiracy theories Social Psychological and Personality Science 3 767-773