Propensity Score–based Methods Versus MTE-based Methods in Causal Inference: Identification, Estimation, and Application

Sociological Methods and Research

Volumn 45, Issue 1, 2016, Pages 3-40

  Zhou, Xiang ^a   Xie, Yu ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN   (United States)

Author keywords

causal effects; exclusion restriction; heterogeneity; ignorability; instrumental variable; marginal treatment effect; propensity score; selection bias

Indexed keywords

EID: 84953243899     PISSN: 00491241     EISSN: 15528294     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1177/0049124114555199     Document Type: Article

References (60)

1. J.D.AngristJoshua D.1990. “Lifetime Earnings and the Vietnam Era Draft Lottery: Evidence from Social Security Administrative Records.” American Economic Review80:313–35.
2. J.D.AngristJoshua D.G.W.ImbensGuido W.D.B.RubinDonald B. 1996. “Identification of Causal Effects Using Instrumental Variables.” Journal of the American Statistical Association91:444–55.
3. J.D.AngristJoshua D.A.B.KruegerAlan B. 1999. “Empirical Strategies in Labor Economics.” Pp. 1277–366 in Handbook of Labor Economics, vol. 3A, edited by. Amsterdam, the Netherlands: Elsevier.
4. A.AnsariAsimJ.KamelJedidi. 2000. “Bayesian Factor Analysis for Multilevel Binary Observations.” Psychometrika65:475–96.
5. D.J.BauerDaniel J.P.J.CurranPatrick J. 2003. “Distributional Assumptions of Growth Mixture Models: Implications for Overextraction of Latent Trajectory Classes.” Psychological Methods8:338–63.
6. A.BjörklundAndersR.MoffittRobert. 1987. “The Estimation of Wage Gains and Welfare Gains in Self-selection Models.” The Review of Economics and Statistics69:42–49.
7. R.BlundellRichardL.DeardenLorraineB.SianesiBarbara. 2005. “Evaluating the Effect of Education on Earnings: Models, Methods, and Results from the National Child Development Survey.” Journal of the Royal Statistical Society: Series A168:473–512.
8. J.E.BrandJennie E.Y.XieYu. 2010. “Who Benefits Most from College? Evidence for Negative Selection in Heterogeneous Economic Returns to Higher Education.” American Sociological Review75:273–302.
9. S.V.CameronStephen V.C.TaberChristopher. 2004. “Estimation of Educational Borrowing Constraints Using Returns to Schooling.” Journal of Political Economy112:132–82.
10. D.CardDavid. 1995. “Using Geographic Variation in College Proximity to Estimate the Return to Schooling.” Pp. 201–22 in Aspects of Labour Market Behavior: Essays in Honor of John Vanderkamp, edited by. Toronto, Canada: University of Toronto Press.
11. P.CarneiroPedroJ.HeckmanJamesE.VytlacilEdward. 2011. “Estimating Marginal Returns to Education.” American Economic Review101:2754–81.
12. J.CornfieldJeromeW.HaenszelWilliamE.Cuyler HammondA.M.LilienfeldAbraham M.M.B.ShimkinMichael B.E.L.WynderErnst L. 1959. “Smoking and Lung Cancer: Recent Evidence and a Discussion of Some Questions.” Journal of the National Cancer Institute22:173–203.
13. F.CunhaFlavioJ.J.HeckmanJames J.S.NavarroSalvador. 2005. “Separating Uncertainty from Heterogeneity in Life Cycle Earnings, the 2004 Hicks Lecture.” Oxford Economic Papers57:191–261.
14. J.CurrieJanetE.MorettiEnrico. 2003. “Mother’s Education and the Intergenerational Transmission of Human Capital: Evidence from College Openings.” Quarterly Journal of Economics118:1495–532.
15. T.DiPreteThomasM.GanglMarkus. 2004. “Assessing Bias in the Estimation of Causal Effects: Rosenbaum Bounds on Matching Estimators and Instrumental Variables Estimation with Imperfect Instruments.” Sociological Methodology34:271–310.
16. S.GreenlandSanderC.PooleCharles. 1988. “Invariants and Noninvariants in the Concept of Interdependent Effects.” Scandinavian Journal of Work, Environment & Health14:125–29.
17. Z.GrilichesZvi. 1977. “Estimating the Returns to Schooling: Some Econometric Problems.” Econometrica45:1–22.
18. D.J.HardingDavid J.2003. “Counterfactual Models of Neighborhood Effects: The Effect of Neighborhood Poverty on High School Dropout and Teenage Pregnancy.” American Journal of Sociology109:676–719.
19. T.HastieTrevorR.TibshiraniRobertJ.FriedmanJerome. 2008. The Elements of Statistical Learning: Data Mining, Inference and Prediction. New York: Springer.
20. J.J.HeckmanJames J.1979. “Sample Selection Bias as a Specification Error.” Econometrica47:153–61.
21. J.J.HeckmanJames J.2001. “Micro Data, Heterogeneity, and the Evaluation of Public Policy: Nobel Lecture.” Journal of Political Economy109:673–748.
22. J.J.HeckmanJames J.2005. “The Scientific Model of Causality.” Sociological Methodology35:1–98.
23. J.J.HeckmanJames J.S.Navarro-LozanoSalvador. 2004. “Using Matching, Instrumental Variables, and Control Functions to Estimate Economic Choice Models.” The Review of Economics and Statistics86:30–57.
24. J.J.HeckmanJames J.R.RobbRichard. 1985. “Alternative Methods for Evaluating the Impact of Interventions.” Pp.156-245 in Longitudinal Analysis of Labor Market Data, edited by James Heckman and Burton Singer. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
25. J.J.HeckmanJames J.S.UrzuaSergioE.VytlacilEdward. 2006a. “Understanding Instrumental Variables in Models with Essential Heterogeneity.” The Review of Economics and Statistics88:389–432.
26. J.J.HeckmanJames J.S.UrzuaSergioE.VytlacilEdward. 2006b. “Estimation of Treatment Effects under Essential Heterogeneity.” Retrieved October 12, 2010 (http://jenni.uchicago.edu/underiv/documentation_2006_03_20.pdf).
27. J.J.HeckmanJames J.E.J.VytlacilEdward J. 1999. “Local Instrumental Variables and Latent Variable Models for Identifying and Bounding Treatment Effects.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America96:4730–34.
28. J.J.HeckmanJames J.E.J.VytlacilEdward J. 2001. “Local Instrumental Variables.” Pp. 1–46 in Nonlinear Statistical Modeling: Proceedings of the Thirteenth International Symposium in Economic Theory and Econometrics: Essays in Honor of Takeshi Amemiya, edited by. New York: Cambridge University Press.
29. J.J.HeckmanJames J.E.J.VytlacilEdward J. 2005. “Structural Equations, Treatment Effects, and Econometric Policy Evaluation.” Econometrica73:669–738.
30. P.W.HollandPaul W.1986. “Statistics and Causal Inference.” Journal of American Statistical Association81:945–60.
31. G.W.ImbensGuido W.2004. “Nonparametric Estimation of Average Treatment Effects under Exogeneity: A Review.” Review of Economics and Statistics86:4–30.
32. T.J.KaneThomas J.C.E.RouseCecilia E. 1995. “Labor-market Returns to Two- and Four-year College.” American Economic Review85:600–14.
33. G.H.LubkeGitta H.B.MuthénBengt. 2005. “Investigating Population Heterogeneity with Factor Mixture Models.” Psychological Methods10:21–39.
34. C.ManskiCharles. 1995. Identification Problems in the Social Sciences. Boston, MA: Harvard University Press.
35. C.ManskiCharles. 2007. Identification for Prediction and Decision. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
36. R.MoffittRobert. 1996. “Identification of Causal Effects Using Instrumental Variables: Comment.” Journal of the American Statistical Association91:462–65.
37. R.MoffittRobert. 2008. “Estimating Marginal Treatment Effects in Heterogeneous Populations.” Annuals of Economics and Statistics91/92:239–61.
38. S.MorganStephenC.WinshipChristopher. 2007. Counterfactuals and Causal Inference: Methods and Principles for Social Research. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
39. J.PearlJudea. 2009. Causality: Models, Reasoning, and Inference. 2nd ed. New York: Cambridge University Press.
40. P.PuhaniPatrick. 2000. “The Heckman Correction for Sample Selection and Its Critique.” Journal of Economic Surveys14:53–68.
41. P.R.RosenbaumPaul R.2002. Observational Studies. New York: Springer.
42. P.R.RosenbaumPaul R.D.B.RubinDonald B. 1983. “The Central Role of the Propensity Score in Observational Studies for Causal Effects.” Biometrika70:41–55.
43. P.R.RosenbaumPaul R.D.B.RubinDonald B. 1984. “Reducing Bias in Observational Studies Using Subclassification on the Propensity Score.” Journal of the American Statistical Association79:516–24.
44. K.J.RothmanKenneth J.S.GreenlandSander, eds. 1998. Modern Epidemiology. 2nd ed. Philadelphia, PA: Lippincott-Raven Publishers.
45. D.B.RubinDonald B.1974. “Estimating Causal Effects of Treatments in Randomized and Nonrandomized Studies.” Journal of Educational Psychology66:688–701.
46. D.B.RubinDonald B.1986. “What Ifs Have Causal Answers?” Journal of American Statistical Association81:961–62.
47. D.B.RubinDonald B.1997. “Estimating Causal Effects from Large Data Sets Using Propensity Scores.” Annals of Internal Medicine5:757–63.
48. W.R.ShadishWilliam R.M.H.ClarkP.M.SteinerPeter M. 2008. “Can Nonrandomized Experiments Yield Accurate Answers? A Randomized Experiment Comparing Random and Nonrandom Assignments.” Journal of American Statistical Association103:1334–44.
49. P.J.SmockPamela J.W.D.ManningWendy D.S.GuptaSanjiv. 1999. “The Effect of Marriage and Divorce on Women’s Economic Well-being.” American Sociological Review64:794–812.
50. M.E.SobelMichael E.2000. “Causal Inference in the Social Science.” Journal of the American Statistical Association95:647–51.
51. S.-L.TsaiShu-LingY.XieYu. 2011. “Heterogeneity in Returns to College Education: Selection Bias in Contemporary Taiwan.” Social Science Research40:796–810.
52. R.J.WillisRobert J.S.RosenSherwin. 1979. “Education and Self-selection.” Journal of Political Economy87:S7–36.
53. C.WinshipChristopherR.D.MareRobert. D. 1992. “Models for Sample Selection Bias.” Annual Review of Sociology18:327–50.
54. C.WinshipChristopherS.L.MorganStephen L. 1999. “The Estimation of Causal Effects from Observational Data.” Annual Review of Sociology25:659–707.
55. C.WinshipChristopherM.SobelMichael. 2004. “Causal Inference in Sociological Studies.” Pp. 481–503 in Handbook of Data Analysis, edited by. London, UK: Sage.
56. J.M.WoodridgeJeffery M.2001. Econometric Analysis of Cross Section and Panel Data. 1st ed. Cambridge: The MIT Press.
57. Y.XieYu. 2000. “Assessment of the Long-term Benefits of Head Start.” Pp.139–67 in Into Adulthood: A Study of the Effects of Head Start, edited by. Ypsilanti, MI: High/Scope Press.
58. Y.XieYu. 2007. “Otis Dudley Duncan’s Legacy: The Demographic Approach to Quantitative Reasoning in Social Science.” Research in Social Stratification and Mobility25:141–56.
59. Y.XieYuJ.BrandJennieB.JannBen. 2012. “Estimating Heterogeneous Treatment Effects with Observational Data.” Sociological Methodology42:314–47.
60. Y.XieYuX.WuXiaogang. 2005. “Market Premium, Social Process, and Statisticism.” American Sociological Review70:865–70.