Therapist drift redux: Why well-meaning clinicians fail to deliver evidence-based therapy, and how to get back on track

Behaviour Research and Therapy

Volumn 77, Issue , 2016, Pages 129-137

  Waller, Glenn ^a   Turner, Hannah ^b  

^a UNIVERSITY OF SHEFFIELD   (United Kingdom)

^b SOUTHERN HEALTH NHS FOUNDATION TRUST   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Cognitive behavioral therapy; Evidence based practice; Psychotherapies; Therapist drift; Training

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; BEHAVIOR CHANGE; CLINICAL COMPETENCE; CLINICAL EFFECTIVENESS; CLINICAL PRACTICE; CLINICAL SUPERVISION; COGNITION; COGNITIVE THERAPY; EMOTION; EVIDENCE BASED PRACTICE; HEALTH BELIEF; HEALTH CARE DELIVERY; HEALTH CARE PLANNING; HUMAN; KNOWLEDGE BASE; PATIENT COMPLIANCE; PATIENT PARTICIPATION; PATIENT SAFETY; PERSONALITY; PHILOSOPHY; PROFESSIONAL KNOWLEDGE; PSYCHOTHERAPIST ATTITUDE; PSYCHOTHERAPY; TREATMENT FAILURE; EDUCATION; FEMALE; HEALTH CARE PERSONNEL; HEALTH PERSONNEL ATTITUDE; MALE; PROCEDURES; PROTOCOL COMPLIANCE; PSYCHOLOGY; STANDARDS; TRENDS;

ATTITUDE OF HEALTH PERSONNEL; CLINICAL COMPETENCE; COGNITIVE THERAPY; EVIDENCE-BASED PRACTICE; FEMALE; GUIDELINE ADHERENCE; HEALTH PERSONNEL; HUMANS; MALE; PSYCHOTHERAPY;

EID: 84952660333     PISSN: 00057967     EISSN: 1873622X     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.brat.2015.12.005     Document Type: Article

References (107)

1. Addis M.E., Krasnow A.D. A national survey of practicing psychologists' attitudes towards psychotherapy treatment manuals. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 2000, 68:331-339.
2. Addis M.E., Wade W., Hatgis C. Barriers to evidence based practice: addressing practitioners' concerns about manual based psychotherapies. Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice 1999, 6:430-441.
3. Addis M.E., Waltz J. Implicit and untested assumptions about the role of psychotherapy treatment manuals in evidence-based mental health practice. Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice 2002, 9:421-424.
4. Bambling M., Kavanagh D., Lewis G., King R., King D., Sturk H., et al. Challenges faced by general practitioners and allied mental health services in providing mental health services in rural Queensland. Australian Journal of Rural Health 2007, 15:126-130.
5. Becker C.B., Meyer G., Price J.S., Graham M.M., Arsena A., Armstrong D.A., et al. Law enforcement preferences for PTSD treatment and crisis management alternatives. Behaviour Research and Therapy 2009, 47:245-253.
6. Becker C.B., Zayfert C., Anderson E. A survey of psychologists' attitudes towards and utilization of exposure therapy for PTSD. Behaviour Research and Therapy 2004, 42:277-292.
7. Beck A.T., Rush A.J., Shaw B.F., Emery G. Cognitive therapy of depression 1979, Guilford, New York, NY.
8. Beidas R.S., Edmunds J., Ditty M., Watkins J., Walsh L., Marcus S., et al. Are inner context factors related to implementation outcomes in cognitive-behavioral therapy for youth anxiety?. Administration and Policy in Mental Health 2014, 41:788-799.
9. Beutler L.E., Crago M., Arizmendi T.G. Therapist variables in psychotherapy process and outcome. Handbook of psychotherapy and behavior change 1986, 257-310. Wiley, New York, NY. 3rd ed. A.E. Bergin, S.L. Garfield (Eds.).
10. Brosan L., Reynolds S., Moore R.G. Factors associated with competence in cognitive therapists. Behavioural and Cognitive Psychotherapy 2006, 35:179-190.
11. Brosan L., Reynolds S., Moore R.G. Self-evaluation of cognitive therapy performance: do therapists know how competent they are?. Behavioural and Cognitive Psychotherapy 2008, 36:581-587.
12. Brown A., Mountford V.A., Waller G. An idea worth researching: Is the therapeutic alliance overvalued in the treatment of the eating disorders?. International Journal of Eating Disorders 2013, 46:779-782.
13. Brown A., Mountford V., Waller G. Therapeutic alliance and weight gain during cognitive-behaviour therapy for anorexia nervosa. Behaviour Research and Therapy 2013, 51:216-220.
14. Brown A., Mountford V., Waller G. Clinician beliefs about what therapeutic techniques drive weight gain over the early part of outpatient cognitive behavioral therapy for anorexia nervosa. The Cognitive Behaviour Therapist 2014, 7:e1-e7.
15. Cahill S.P., Foa E.B., Hembree E.A., Marshall R.D., Nacash N. Dissemination of exposure therapy in the treatment of posttraumatic stress disorder. Journal of Traumatic Stress 2006, 19:597-610.
16. Campbell B.K., Buti A., Fussell H.E., Srikanth P., McCarty D., Guydish J.R. Therapist predictors of treatment delivery fidelity in a community-based trial of 12-step facilitation. American Journal of Drug and Alcohol Abuse 2013, 39:304-311.
17. Cook J.M., Schnurr P.P., Biyanova T., Coyne J.C. Apples don't fall far from the tree: influences on psychotherapists' adoption and sustained use of new therapies. Psychiatric Services 2009, 60:671-676.
18. Cowdrey N.D., Waller G. Are we really delivering evidence-based treatments for eating disorders? How eating-disordered patients describe their experience of cognitive behavioral therapy. Behaviour Research and Therapy 2015, 75:72-77.
19. Crits-Cristoph P., Baranackie K., Kurcias J.S., Beck A.T., Carroll K., Perry K., et al. Meta-analysis of therapist effects in psychotherapy outcome studies. Psychotherapy Research 1991, 1:81-91.
20. Crits-Cristoph P., Gibbons M.B.C., Hearon B. Does the alliance cause good outcome? Recommendations for future research on the alliance. Psychotherapy: Theory, Research, Practice, Training 2006, 43:280-285.
21. Cukrowicz K.C., Timmons K.A., Sawyer K., Caron K.M., Gummelt H.D., Joiner T.E. Improved treatment outcome associated with the shift to empirically supported treatments in an outpatient clinic is maintained over a ten-year period. Professional Psychology: Research and Practice 2011, 42:145-152.
22. De Jong K., van Sluis P., Nugter M.A., Heiser W.J., Spinhoven P. Understanding the differential impact of outcome monitoring: therapist variables that moderate feedback effects in a randomized clinical trial. Psychotherapy Research 2012, 22:464-474.
23. Deacon B.J., Farrell N.R. Therapist barriers in the dissemination of exposure therapy. Treating variants and complications in anxiety disorders 2013, 363-373. Springer, New York, NY. E. Storch, D. McKay (Eds.).
24. Deacon B.J., Farrell N.R., Kemp J.J., Dixon L.J., Sy J.T., Zhang A.R., et al. Assessing therapist reservations about exposure therapy for anxiety disorders: the Therapist Beliefs about Exposure Scale. Journal of Anxiety Disorders 2013, 27:772-780.
25. Deacon B.J., Lickel J.J., Farrell N.R., Kemp J., Hipol L.J. Therapist perceptions and delivery of interoceptive exposure for panic disorder. Journal of Anxiety Disorders 2013, 27:259-264.
26. Dennhag I., Gibbons M.B., Barber J.P., Gallop R., Crits-Christoph P. Do supervisors and independent judges agree on evaluations of therapist adherence and competence in the treatment of cocaine dependence?. Psychotherapy Research 2012, 22:720-730.
27. Ehlers A., Gene-Cos N., Perrin S. Low recognition of posttraumatic stress disorder in primary care. London Journal of Primary Care 2009, 1:36-42.
28. Fairburn C.G., Cooper Z. Therapist competence, therapy quality, and therapist training. Behaviour Research and Therapy 2011, 49:373-378.
29. Farrell N.R., Deacon B.J., Dixon L.J., Lickel J.J. Theory-based training strategies for modifying practitioner concerns about exposure therapy. Journal of Anxiety Disorders 2013, 27:781-787.
30. Farrell N.R., Deacon B.J., Kemp J.J., Dixon L.J., Sy J.T. Do negative beliefs about exposure therapy cause its suboptimal delivery? An experimental investigation. Journal of Anxiety Disorders 2013, 27:763-771.
31. Franklin M., Huppert J., Garcia A., Freeman J., March J., Foa E. Therapist effects in a randomized controlled trial for pediatric OCD. Poster presented at the association for advancement of behavior therapy, New Orleans, LA, November 2004.
32. Fung C.H., Elliott M.N., Hays R.D., Kahn K.L., Kanouse D.E., McGlynn E.A., et al. Patients' preferences for technical versus interpersonal quality when selecting a primary care physician. Health Services Research 2005, 40:957-977.
33. Gibbons C.R., Stirman S.W., DeRubeis R.J., Newman C.F., Beck A.T. Research setting versus clinic setting: which produces better outcomes in cognitive therapy for depression?. Cognitive Therapy and Research 2013, 37:605-612.
34. Gielen N., Krumeich A., Havermans R.C., Smeets F., Jansen A. Why clinicians do not implement integrated treatment for comorbid substance use disorder and posttraumatic stress disorder: a qualitative study. European Journal of Psychotraumatology 2014, 5:e1-e10.
35. The therapeutic relationship in the cognitive behavioural psychotherapies 2007, Routledge, London, UK. R. Gilbert, R.L. Leahy (Eds.).
36. Green H., Barkham M., Kellett S., Saxon D. Therapist effects and IAPT Psychological Wellbeing Practitioners (PWPs): a multilevel modelling and mixed methods analysis. Behaviour Research and Therapy 2014, 63:43-54.
37. Grove W.M., Zald D.H., Lebow B.S., Snitz B.E., Nelson C. Clinical versus mechanical prediction: a meta-analysis. Psychological Assessment 2000, 12:19-30.
38. Guydish J., Campbell B.K., Manuel J.K., Delucchi K.L., Le T., Peavy K.M., et al. Does treatment fidelity predict client outcomes in 12-step facilitation for stimulant abuse?. Drug and Alcohol Dependence 2014, 134:330-336.
39. Hansen N.B., Lambert M.J., Forman E.M. The psychology dose-response effect and its implications for treatment delivery services. Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice 2002, 9:308-327.
40. Harned M.S., Dimeff L.A., Woodcock E.A., Contreras I. Predicting adoption of exposure therapy in a randomized controlled dissemination trial. Journal of Anxiety Disorders 2013, 27:754-762.
41. Hartley S., Scarratt P., Bucci S., Kelly J., Mulligan J., Neil S.T., et al. Assessing therapist adherence to recovery-focused cognitive behavioural therapy for psychosis delivered by telephone with support from a self-help guide: psychometric evaluations of a new fidelity scale. Behavioural and Cognitive Psychotherapy 2014, 42:435-451.
42. Hipol L.J., Deacon B.J. Dissemination of evidence-based practices for anxiety disorders in Wyoming: a survey of practicing psychotherapists. Behavior Modification 2013, 37:170-188.
43. Hogue A., Henderson C., Dauber S., Barajas P., Fried A., Liddle H. Treatment adherence, competence, and outcome in individual and family therapy for adolescent behavior problems. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 2008, 76:544-555.
44. Horvath A., Symonds B. The relationship between working alliance and outcome in psychotherapy. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 1991, 38:139-149.
45. Hukkelberg S.S., Ogden T. Working alliance and treatment fidelity as predictors of externalizing problem behaviors in parent management training. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 2013, 81:1010-1020.
46. Institute of Medicine Crossing the quality chasm: A new health system for the 21st century 2001, National Academy Press, Washington, D.C.
47. Karačić M., Wales J.A., Arcelus J., Palmer R.L., Cooper Z., Fairburn C.G. Changes in alcohol intake in response to transdiagnostic cognitive behaviour therapy for eating disorders. Behaviour Research and Therapy 2011, 49:573-577.
48. Koerner K. What must you know and do to get good outcomes with DBT?. Behavior Therapy 2013, 44:568-579.
49. Layard R., Clark D.M. Thrive: The power of evidence-based psychological therapies 2014, Allen Lane, London, UK.
50. Lilienfeld S.O., Ritschel L.A., Lynn S.J., Brown A.P., Cautin R.L., Latzman R.D. The research-practice gap: bridging the schism between eating disorder researchers and practitioners. International Journal of Eating Disorders 2013, 46:386-394.
51. Long M.E., Grubaugh A.L., Elhai J.D., Cusack K.J., Knapp R., Frueh B.C. Therapist fidelity with an exposure-based treatment of PTSD in adults with schizophrenia or schizoaffective disorder. Journal of Clinical Psychology 2010, 66:383-393.
52. Lowe M.R., Bunnell D.W., Neeren A.M., Chernyak Y., Greberman L. Evaluating the real-world effectiveness of cognitive-behavior therapy efficacy research on eating disorders: a case study from a community-based clinical setting. International Journal of Eating Disorders 2011, 44:9-18.
53. Mannix K.A., Blackburn I.M., Garland A., Gracie J., Moorey S., Reid B., et al. Effectiveness of brief training in cognitive behaviour therapy techniques for palliative care practitioners. Palliative Medicine 2006, 20:579-584.
54. Martin D.J., Garske J.P., Davis K.M. Relation of the therapeutic alliance with outcome and other variables: a meta-analytic review. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 2000, 68:438-450.
55. McAleavey A.A., Castonguay L.G., Goldfried M.R. Clinical experiences in conducting cognitive-behavioral therapy for social phobia. Behavior Therapy 2014, 45:21-35.
56. McHugh P.R. Psychotherapy awry. American Scholar 1994, 63:17-30.
57. McManus F., Rakovshik S., Kennerley H., Fennell M., Westbrook D. An investigation of the accuracy of therapists' self-assessment of cognitive-behaviour therapy skills. British Journal of Clinical Psychology 2012, 51:292-306.
58. Meehl P.E. Clinical versus statistical prediction: A theoretical analysis and a review of the evidence 1954, University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, MN.
59. Meehl P.E. Why I do not attend case conferences. Psychodiagnosis: Selected papers 1973, 225-302. University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis. P.E. Meehl (Ed.).
60. Meehl P.E. Causes and effects of my disturbing little book. Journal of Personality Assessment 1986, 50:370-375.
61. Meyer J.M., Farrell N.R., Kemp J.J., Blakey S.M., Deacon B.J. Why do clinicians exclude anxious clients from exposure therapy?. Behaviour Research and Therapy 2014, 54:49-53.
62. Miller W.R., Yahne C.E., Moyers T.B., Martinez J., Pirritano M. A randomized trial of methods to help clinicians learn motivational interviewing. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 2004, 72:1050-1062.
63. Morrant J.C. Boredom in psychiatric practice. Canadian Journal of Psychiatry 1984, 29:431-434.
64. Nissen-Lie H.A., Monsen J.T., Rønnestad M.H. Therapist predictors of early patient-rated working alliance: a multilevel approach. Psychotherapy Research 2010, 20:627-646.
65. Nissen-Lie H.A., Monsen J.T., Ulleberg P., Rønnestad M.H. Psychotherapists' self-reports of their interpersonal functioning and difficulties in practice as predictors of patient outcome. Psychotherapy Research 2013, 23:86-104.
66. Öst L.-G., Karlstedt A., Widén S. The effects of cognitive behavior therapy delivered by students in a psychologist training program: an effectiveness study. Behavior Therapy 2012, 43:,160-173.
67. Parker Z., Waller G. Factors related to psychotherapists' self-assessment bias when treating anxiety disorders. Behaviour Research and Therapy 2015, 66:1-7.
68. Perepletchikova F. On the topic of treatment integrity. Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice 2011, 18:148-153.
69. Persons J.B., Bostram A., Bertagnolli A. Results of randomized controlled trials of cognitive therapy for depression generalize to private practice. Cognitive Therapy and Research 1999, 23:535-548.
70. Persons J.B., Roberts N.A., Zalecki C.A., Brechwald W.A.G. Naturalistic outcome of case formulation-driven cognitive-behavior therapy for anxious depressed outpatients. Behaviour Research and Therapy 2006, 44:1041-1051.
71. Peters-Scheffer N., Didden R., Korzilius H., Sturmey P. Therapist characteristics predict discrete trial teaching procedural fidelity. Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities 2013, 51:263-272.
72. Raykos B.C., McEvoy P.M., Erceg-Hurn D., Byrne S.M., Fursland A., Nathan P. Therapeutic alliance in Enhanced Cognitive Behavioural Therapy for bulimia nervosa: probably necessary but definitely insufficient. Behaviour Research and Therapy 2014, 57:65-71.
73. Roth A.D., Pilling S. Competences required to deliver effective cognitive and behaviour therapy for people with depression and with anxiety disorders 2007, HMSO, Department of Health, London, UK.
74. Royal College of Psychiatrists Report of the second round of the National Audit of Psychological Therapies (NAPT) 2013 2013, Healthcare Quality Improvement Partnership, London, UK.
75. Russell M., Silver S.M. Training needs for the treatment of combat-related posttraumatic stress disorder: a survey of Department of Defense clinicians. Traumatology 2007, 13:4-10.
76. Shafran R., Clark D.M., Fairburn C.G., Arntz A., Barlow D.H., Ehlers A., et al. Mind the gap: Improving the dissemination of CBT. Behaviour Research and Therapy 2009, 47:902-909.
77. Shapiro D.A., Shapiro D. Meta-analysis of comparative therapy outcome studies: a replication and refinement. Psychological Bulletin 1982, 92:581-604.
78. Sharpless B., Barber J. A conceptual and empirical review of the meaning, measurement, development, and teaching of intervention competence in clinical psychology. Clinical Psychology Review 2009, 29:47-56.
79. Simmons A.M., Milnes S.M., Anderson D.A. Factors influencing the utilization of empirically supported treatments for eating disorders. Eating Disorders 2008, 16:342-354.
80. Simpson-Southward C., Hardy G., Waller G. The impact of case presentation and intra-individual factors on how supervisors guide clinicians in treatment of depressed cases. The Cognitive Behaviour Therapist 2015, (under consideration).
81. Simpson-Southward C., Waller G., Hardy G. Supervision for treatment of depression: an experimental study of the role of therapist gender and anxiety. Behaviour Research and Therapy 2016, 77:17-22.
82. Sinai D., Gur M., Lipsitz J.D. Therapist adherence to interpersonal vs. supportive therapy for social anxiety disorder. Psychotherapy Research 2012, 22:381-388.
83. Sprang G., Craig C., Clark J. Factors impacting trauma treatment practice patterns: the convergence/divergence of science and practice. Journal of Anxiety Disorders 2008, 22:162-174.
84. Stewart R.E., Chambless D.L. Interesting practitioners in training in empirically supported treatments: research reviews versus case studies. Journal of Clinical Psychology 2010, 66:73-95.
85. Stobie B., Taylor T., Quigley A., Ewing S., Salkovskis P.M. "Contents may vary": a pilot study of treatment histories of OCD patients. Behavioural and Cognitive Psychotherapy 2007, 35:273-282.
86. Szkodny L.E., Newman M.G., Goldfried M.R. Clinical experiences in conducting empirically supported treatments for generalized anxiety disorder. Behavior Therapy 2014, 45:7-20.
87. Tang T.Z., DeRubeis R.J. Sudden gains and critical sessions in cognitive-behavioral therapy for depression. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 1999, 67:894-904.
88. Tobin D.L., Banker J.D., Weisberg L., Bowers W. I know what you did last summer (and it was not CBT): a factor analytic model of international psychotherapeutic practice in the eating disorders. International Journal of Eating Disorders 2007, 40:754-757.
89. Turner H., Bryant-Waugh R., Marshall E. The impact of early symptom change and therapeutic alliance on treatment outcome in cognitive-behavioural therapy for eating disorders. Behaviour Research and Therapy 2015, 73:165-169.
90. Turner H., Tatham M., Lant M., Mountford V.A., Waller G. Clinicians' concerns about delivering cognitive-behavioural therapy for eating disorders. Behaviour Research and Therapy 2014, 57:38-42.
91. van Ingen D.J., Freiheit S.R., Vye C.S. From the lab to the clinic: effectiveness of cognitive-behavioral treatments for anxiety disorders. Professional Psychology: Research and Practice 2009, 40:69-74.
92. van Minnen A., Hendriks L., Olff M. When do trauma experts choose exposure therapy for PTSD patients? A controlled study of therapist and patient factors. Behaviour Research and Therapy 2010, 48:312-320.
93. von Ranson K.M., Wallace L.M., Stevenson A. Psychotherapies provided for eating disorders by community clinicians: infrequent use of evidence-based treatment. Psychotherapy Research 2013, 23:333-343.
94. von Ranson K.M., Wallace L.M., Stevenson A. What is "eclectic" eating disorders treatment, exactly? Alberta therapists' approaches. Paper presented at the international conference on eating disorders, Montreal, May 2013.
95. Walfish S., McAlister B., O'Donnel P., Lambert M. An investigation of self-assessment bias in mental health providers. Psychological Reports 2012, 110:1-6.
96. Wallace L.M., von Ranson K.M. Perceptions and use of empirically-supported psychotherapies among eating disorder professionals. Behaviour Research and Therapy 2012, 50:215-223.
97. Waller G. Evidence-based treatment and therapist drift. Behaviour Research and Therapy 2009, 47:119-127.
98. Waller G., D'Souza K., Wright C. Impact of education on clinicians' attitudes to exposure therapy for eating disorders. Behaviour Research and Therapy 2016, 76:76-80.
99. Waller G., Mountford V.A., Tatham M., Turner H., Gabriel C., Webber R. Attitudes towards psychotherapy manuals among clinicians treating eating disorders. Behaviour Research and Therapy 2013, 51:840-844.
100. Waller G., Stringer H., Meyer C. What cognitive-behavioral techniques do therapists report using when delivering cognitive-behavioral therapy for the eating disorders?. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 2012, 80:171-175.
101. Wang P.S., Demler O., Kessler R.C. Adequacy of treatment for serious mental illness in the United States. American Journal of Public Health 2002, 92:92-98.
102. Wang P.S., Lane M., Olfson M., Pincus H.A., Wells K.B., Kessler R.C. Twelve-month use of mental health services in the United States: results from the National Comorbidity Survey Replication. Archives of General Psychiatry 2005, 62:629-640.
103. Westra H.A., Aviram A., Connors L., Kertes A. Therapist emotional reactions and client resistance in cognitive behavioral therapy. Psychotherapy 2012, 49:163-172.
104. Wiborg J.F., Knoop H., Wensing M., Bleijenberg G. Therapist effects and the dissemination of cognitive behavior therapy for chronic fatigue syndrome in community-based mental health care. Behaviour Research and Therapy 2012, 50:393-396.
105. Wilson G.T. Manual-based treatments: the clinical application of research findings. Behaviour Research and Therapy 1996, 34:295-314.
106. Wilson G.T., Fairburn C.G., Agras W.S. Cognitive behavioral therapy for bulimia nervosa. Handbook of treatment for eating disorders 1997, 67-93. Guilford, New York, NY. D.M. Garner, P.E. Garfinkel (Eds.).
107. Wolf A.W., Goldfried M.R. Clinical experiences in using cognitive-behavior therapy to treat panic disorder. Behavior Therapy 2014, 45:36-46.