Separation of powers without checks and balances: The failure of semi-presidentialism and the making of the Russian constitutional system, 1991-1993

Law in Eastern Europe

Volumn 62, Issue , 2012, Pages 105-140

  Partlett, William ^a  

^a NONE

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 84948152225     PISSN: 0075823X     EISSN: None     Source Type: Book Series    
DOI: 10.1163/9789004203334_008     Document Type: Article

References (137)

1. Informatsionnoe agentsvo "Khakasiia", "Dmitrii Medvedev schitaet chto v Rossii mozhet byt' partiinyi prezident", RIA Novosti (1 October 2007), available at 〈http://www.19rus.info/news/20592.html〉.
2. "Bol'shinstvo Rossiian khotiat, chtoby prezident ostavalsia bespartiinym", Newsru.com (25 July 2006), available at 〈http://www.newsru.com/russia/25jul2006/party.html〉.
3. "Vladimir Putin: Partiinyi prezident - eto netselesoobrazno", Komsomol'skaia Pravda (15 April 2008), available at 〈http://spb.kp.ru/online/news/78377〉.
4. Irina Gusakova, "Dmitrii Medvedev nameknul, kto stanet sleduiushchim prezidentom", Newsinfo. ru (15 September 2009), available at 〈http://www.newsinfo.ru/articles/2009-09-15/valdaj/722137〉.
5. "Ne dolzhno byt' partiinogo prezidenta", Gazeta.ru (10 April 2009), available at 〈http://www.gazeta.ru/interview/nm/s2969481.shtml〉.
6. "Partiinyi prezident - khorosho, bespartiinyi - luchshe", Regions.ru (18 February 2007), available at 〈http://www.regions.ru/news/2058174〉.
7. Marat Baglai, Presidenty Rossiiskoi Federatsii i Soedinnennykh Shtatov Ameriki: rol', poriadok vyborov, polnomochiia (Norma, Moscow, 2008), 20-21.
8. Charles de Secondat Montesquieu, The Spirit of Laws, Vol. 1 (Printed for G. and A. Ewing and G. Faulkner, 1751).
9. M.J.C. Vile writes: "The doctrine of the separation of powers, standing alone as a theory of government, has, as will be demonstrated later, uniformly failed to provide an adequate basis for an effective, stable political system. It has therefore been combined with other political ideas, the theory of mixed government, the idea of balance, the concept of checks and balances, to form the complex constitutional theories that provided the basis of modern Western political systems." Constitutionalism and the Separation of Powers (Liberty Fund, Indianapolis, IN, 1998), 2.
10. Darryl Levinson, "On Parchment and Politics: The Positive Puzzle of Constitutional Commitment", 124 Harvard Law Review (2011), 657.
11. Alexander Hamilton, No. 37, in The Federalist Papers (1788, reprinted: Arlington House, New Rochelle, NY, 1966), 423.
12. James Madison, No.37, in The Federalist Papers (1788, reprinted: Arlington House, New Rochelle, NY, 1966), 227.
13. James Madison, No.51, in The Federalist Papers (1788, reprinted: Arlington House, New Rochelle, NY, Robert Scigliano, ed. 2001), 321-322.
14. Francis Fukuyama, The End of History and the Last Man (Avon Books, Inc., New York, NY, 1992).
15. Samuel Huntington, The Third Wave: Democratization in the Late Twentieth Century (University of Oklahoma Press, Norman, OK, 1991).
16. 'Transitology' can best be traced to the seminal work of Guillermo O'Donnell and Phillipe Schmitter. See Transitions from Authoritarian Rule: Tentative Conclusions about Uncertain Democracies (Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, MD, 1986).
17. Thomas Carothers, "The End of the Transition Paradigm", 13(1) Journal of Democracy (2002), 5.
18. William Partlett, "Reclassifying Russian Law: Mechanisms, Outcomes, and Solutions for an Overly Politicized Field", 2(1) Columbia Journal of East European Law (2008), 42.
19. Robert Sharlet, "Legal Transplants and Political Mutations: The Reception of Constitutional Law in Russia and the Newly Independent States", 7 East European Constitutional Review (1998), 59.
20. Jacques deLisle, "Lex American? United States Legal Assistance, American Legal Models, and Legal Change in the Post-Communist World and Beyond", 20 University of Pennsylvania Journal of International Economic Law (1999), 181.
21. Rossiiskaia Gazeta (25 December 1993).
22. Bruce Ackerman, "The Rise of World Constitutionalism", 83 Virginia Law Review (1997), 786.
23. Dana Atchison, "Notes on Constitutionalism for a 21st-Century Russian President", 6 Cardozo Journal of International and Comparative Law (1998), 351.
24. Richard Sakwa, Russian Politics and Society (Routledge, New York, NY, 4th ed. 2008), 40.
25. Richard Sakwa, "The Struggle for the Constitution in Russia and the Triumph of Ethical Individualism", 48 Studies in East European Thought (1996), 131.
26. F. Joseph Dresen and William E. Pomeranz (eds.), "The Russian Constitution at Fifteen: Assessments and Current Challenges to Russia's Legal Development", conference proceedings at the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars, Washington, DC (19 March 2009), 3, available at 〈http://www.wilsoncenter.org/topics/pubs/KI-090623-Occ%20Paper%20304.pdf〉.
27. Robert Sharlet, "Legal Transplants and Political Mutations: The Reception of Constitutional Law in Russia and the Newly Independent States", 7 Eastern European Constitutional Review (1998), 64.
28. Rett Ludwikowski, "Mixed Constitutions: Product of an East-Central European Constitutional Melting Pot", 16 Boston University International Law Journal (1998), 41.
29. Cindy Skach, "The Newest Separation of Powers: Semipresidentialism", 5 International Journal of Constitutional Law (2007), 93.
30. Tiffany Troxel, Parliamentary Power in Russia, 1994-2001: President vs. Parliament (Palgrave MacMillan, Houndmills, UK, 2003), 33.
31. Robert Sharlet, "Reinventing the Russian State: Problems of Constitutional Interpretation", 28 John Marshall Law Review (1995), 777.
32. Stephen Holmes, "Superpresidentialism and Its Problems", 2(4) Eastern European Constitutional Review (1993), 123.
33. Joshua Briones, "Religious Minorities in Russia", 8 University of California Davis Journal of International Law and Policy (2004), 338.
34. Jeffrey Waggoner, "Discretion and Valor at the Russian Constitutional Court: Adjudicating the Russian Constitutions in the Civil-Law Tradition", 8 Indiana International and Comparative Law Review (1997), 191.
35. Andrew Wilson, Virtual Politics: Faking Democracy in the Post-Soviet World (Yale University Press, New Haven, CT, 2005).
36. Robert W. Ortung, Nations in Transit: Russia (Freedom House, New York, NY, 2008), available at 〈http://www.freedomhouse.hu/images/fdh-galleries/NIT2008/NT-Russia-final.pdf〉.
37. Kim Lane Scheppelle, "We Forgot About the Ditches: Russian Constitutional Impatience and the Challenge of Terrorism", 53 Drake Law Review (2005), 963-1027.
38. Ian Brown, "Clinging to Democracy: Assessing the Russian Legislative-Executive Relationship under Boris Yeltsin's Constitution", 33 Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law (2000), 663.
39. William Hayden, "Seeds of Unrest: The Political Genesis of the Conflict in Chechnya", 24 Fletcher Forum of World Affairs (2000), 69.
40. Molly Lien, "Red Star Trek: Seeking a Role for Constitutional Law in Soviet Disunion" 30 Stanford Journal of International Law (1994), 110.
41. Stephen Kotkin, Magnetic Mountain: Stalinism as a Civilization (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA, 1995).
42. Robert Sharlet, Soviet Constitutional Crisis: From De-Stalinization to Disintegration (M.E. Sharpe, Inc., Armonk, NY, 1992).
43. Christopher Osakwe, "The Theories and Realities of Modern Soviet Constitutional Law: An Analysis of the 1977 USSR Constitution", 127 University Pennsylvania Law Review (1979), 1350.
44. Konstitutsiia RSFSR (1978
45. Vedomosti VS RSFSR (1978)
46. Eugene Huskey, Presidential Power in Russia (M.E. Sharpe, Inc., Armonk, NY, 1999), 14.
47. Hans Oversloot, "Uncivic Culture and Presidential Power in Contemporary Russia", 26(2) Review of Central and East European Law (2000), 164.
48. Thomas F. Remington, Russian Parliament: Institutional Evolution in a Transitional Regime 1989-1999 (Yale University Press, New Haven, CT, 2001), 85.
49. Carla Thornson, "Why Politicians Want Constitutional Courts: The Russian Case", 37 Communist and Post-Communist Studies (2004), 195-96.
50. Alexei Trochev, Judging Russia: Constitutional Court in Russian Politics (Cambridge University Press, Cambidge, 2008), 71.
51. Valerii D. Zor'kin, Chicherin (Iuridicheskaia literatura, Moscow, 1984).
52. "We Can be Fully Confident that Russia Will Revive", Izvestiia (10 July 1991), 1, 3
53. 43(28) Current Digest of the Post Soviet Press (hereinafter CDPSP) (14 August 1991), 1-3.
54. Darrell Slider, "Federalism, Discord, and Accommodation", in Theodore H. Friedgut and Jeffrey W. Hahn (eds.), Local Power and Post-Soviet Politics (M.E. Sharpe, Inc., Armonk, NY, 1994), 251.
55. Aleksandr Dergachov, "The First Days of the Russian President's Local Representatives", Izvestiia (28 August 1991), 2
56. 43(35) CDPSP (2 October 1991), 21-22.
57. Tim McDaniel, The Agony of the Russian Ideal (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ, 1996), 174.
58. John F. Young, "Institutions, Elites, and Local Politics: The Case of Omsk", in Jeffrey W. Hahn (ed.), Regional Russia in Transition: Studies in Yaroslavl' (Woodrow Wilson Press, Washington, DC, 2001), 138-61, at 142.
59. Izvestiia (7 October 1991), 2.
60. Eugene Huskey, "Executive-Legislative Relations", in Eugene Huskey (ed.), Executive Power and Soviet Politics: The Rise and Decline of the Soviet State (M.E. Sharpe, Armonk, NY, 1992), 90-91.
61. Vestnik Konstitutsionnogo Suda Rossiiskoi Federatsii (1993) No.1, 11-19.
62. Robert Ahdieh, Russia's Constitutional Revolution: Legal Consciousness and the Transition to Democracy (Penn State University Press, University Park, PA, 1997), 80.
63. Vestnik Konstitutsionnogo Suda Rossiiskoi Federatsii (1993) No.1, 3.
64. "The Russian Democratic Reform Movement is for Presidential Rule", Nezavisimaia Gazeta (5 November 1992), 2
65. 44(45) CDPSP (9 December 1992), 1.
66. "The Seventh Congress of People's Deputies", speech by B.N. El'tsin, Rossiiskaia Gazeta (2 December 1992), 3-4
67. 44(48) CDPSP (30 December 1992), 2-4.
68. "The President of Russia Sees Holding a Nationwide Referendum as the Only Way Out of the Crisis", Izvestiia (10 December 1992), 1
69. 44(50) CDPSP (13 January 1993), 1.
70. Ruslan Khasbulatov, "The Congress of People's Deputies and Constitutional Reform", Rossiiskaia Gazeta (9 January 1993), 2
71. 45(2) CDPSP (10 February 1993), 7.
72. Ruslan Khasbulatov, "The Congress of People's Deputies and Constitutional Reform", Rossiiskaia Gazeta (10 January 1993), 2
73. 45 (2) CDPSP (10 February 1993), 8.
74. Leonid Nikitsky, "Interview with Boris Ebzeev, Justice of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation", 6 Eastern European Constitutional Review (1997), 86.
75. S. Alekseev, "Absolute Power for the Soviets is Incompatible with True Democracy", Izvestiia (4 February 1993), 5
76. 45(6) CDPSP (10 March 1993), 8.
77. Aleksandr Sidiachko, Megapolis-Express (19 May 1993), 23
78. 45(19) CDPSP (9 June 1993), 4.
79. Nikolai Troitskii, "What does Yeltsin Want?" Megapolis-Express (3 March 1993), 3
80. 45(9) CDPSP (31 March 1993), 1.
81. "The President's Appeal to the Constitutional Court and Supreme Soviet" Izvestiia (2 March 1993), 1
82. 45(9) CDPSP (31 March 1993), 4.
83. "Speech by R. Khasbulatov, Chairman of the Supreme Soviet", Rossisskaia Gazeta (11March 1993), 1
84. 45(10) CDPSP (7 April 1993), 1.
85. "If you Destroy the Presidency, you Destroy Russia", Izvestiia (12 March 1993), 1.
86. Roy Medvedev, Post-Soviet Russia: A Journey through the Yeltsin Era (Columbia University Press, New York, NY, 2000), 96.
87. "Boris Yeltsin Offers the Country a Peaceful Way Out of the Crisis", Rossiiskie Vesti (23 March 1993), 1-2
88. 45(12) CDPSP (12 April 1993), 1.
89. Andrew Felkay, Yeltsin's Russia and the West (Praeger Publishers, Westport, CT, 2002), 74.
90. Viktor Kozhemiako, "Threat of a State of Emergency", Pravda, 1
91. 45(16) CDPSP (19 May 1993), 9.
92. Sergei Chugaev, "The Russian Federation Supreme Soviet is Conducting a Political Campaign using the Taxpayers' Money", Izvestiia (21 April 1993), 1-2
93. 45(16) CDPSP (19 May 1993), 7.
94. Editorial, "Think Again", Rossiiskie Vesti (24 April 1993), 1
95. 45(16) CDPSP (19 May 1993), 11.
96. Georgii Ivanov-Smolenskii, "According to the Latest Data from the Central Election Commission, 58.05% of Russian Citizens Participating in the Referendum Cast their Votes for Boris Yeltsin", Izvestiia (28 April 28 1993), 2
97. 45(17) CDPSP (26 May 1993), 1.
98. Vasilii Kononenko, "President of Russia begins Promised Changes by Presenting Draft of New Constitution", Izvestiia (30 April 1993), 1-2
99. 45(17) CDPSP (26 May 1993), 7.
100. Sergei Shakhrai, "The Deputies Must Repeal their Most Recent Decisions", Rossiiskie Vesti (28 April 1993), 1
101. 45(17) CDPSP (26 May 1993), 3-4.
102. "Vlasti posle referenduma: Prezident naznachaet datu konstitutsionnogo soveshchaniia", Kommersant, Vlast' (12 May 1993).
103. Sergei Chugaev, "S. Shakhrai on the New Constitution", Izvestiia (30 April 1993), 2
104. 45(18) CDPSP (2 June 1993), 6.
105. Levent Gönenc, Prospects for Constitutionalism in Post-Communist Countries, in William B. Simons (ed.), Law in Eastern Europe, No.50 (Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, Leiden, Boston, MA, 2002), 161.
106. "No, not a Tsar but a President", interview with S. Alekseev by Elena Dikun, Megapolis- Express (5 May 1993), 26
107. 45(18) CDPSP (2 June 1993), 7.
108. Konstitutsionnoe soveshchanie. Informatsionnyi biulleten' (Iuridicheskaia literatura, Moscow, 1993), 14.
109. Konstitutsionnoe soveshchanie: Stenogrammy. Materialy. Dokumenty. 20 aprelia-10 noiabria 1993 g. v 20 tomakh, Vol.1 (Iuridicheskaia literatura, Moscow, 1995), 7.
110. Edict No.1400, Rossiiskaia Gazeta (14 January 1994 and 19 January 1994).
111. Boris El'tsin, Zapiski Prezidenta (Ogonek, Moscow, 1994), 381.
112. James H. Brusstar and Ellen Jones, The Russian Military's Role in Politics (National Defense University Institute, Washington, DC, 1995), 24.
113. Alexander Iaklovev, "Russia: The Struggle for a Constitution", 7 Emory International Law Review (1993), 291.
114. Statement of the Ministry of Justice at the Constitutional Meeting. See Informatsionnyi Biulleten' (1993) No.2, 26.
115. "Decree of the President of the Russian Federation", Rossiiskie Vesti (19 October 1993), 1
116. 45(42) CDPSP (17 November 1993), 7.
117. Dmitry Volkov and Aleksei Zubro, "Boris Yeltsin's Basic Law", Segodnia (11 November 1993), 1
118. 45(45) CDPSP (8 December 1993), 1-2.
119. Aleksei Zuichenko and Lev Bruni, "The Council of Federation Will be Formed by the Voters", Segodnia (12 October 1993), 1
120. 45(41) CDPSP (10 November 1993), 16.
121. Paul Chaisty, Legislative Politics and Economic Power in Russia (Palgrave Macmillan, New York, NY, 2006), 104.
122. "Boris Yeltsin: The New Constitution Will Protect Democracy in Russia", Izvestiia (10 November 1993), 1
123. (45)45 CDPSP (8 December 1993), 1-2.
124. "As President I Have a Greater Stake than Others Do in Social Stability", interview with Boris El'tsin, Izvestiia (16 November 1993), 1, 4
125. 45(46) CDPSP (15 December 1993), 9.
126. "To Adopt the New Constitution Means Saving Russia from a Repeat of the October Events", Izvestiia (10 December 1993), 1
127. 45(49) CDPSP (5 January 1994), 1-2.
128. Vladimir Lysenko, "At a Fork in the Road", Nezavisimaia Gazeta (11November 1993), 1
129. 45(45) CDPSP (8 December 1993), 3.
130. Vera Kuznetsova, "Will a Fundamentally Reformed Government be Able to Conduct Fundamental Reform?", Nezavisimaia Gazeta (23 December 1993), 1
131. 45(51) CDPSP (19 January 1994), 1.
132. Walter Moss, A History of Russia: Since 1855 (Anthem, London, 2000), 557.
133. Postanovlenie (30 April 1996)
134. Vestnik Konstitutsionnogo Suda Rossiiskoi Federatsii (1996).
135. Postanovlenie (11 December 1998)
136. Vestnik Konstitutsionnogo Suda Rossiiskoi Federatsii (1998).
137. "A Conversation with Dmitry Medvedev", Council on Foreign Relations, (15 November 2008), available at 〈http://www.cfr.org/publication/17775/conversation-with-dmitry-medvedev.html〉.