Do Policy Makers Use Academic Research? Reexamining the "Two Communities" Theory of Research Utilization

Public Administration Review

Volumn 76, Issue 1, 2016, Pages 24-32

  Newman, Joshua ^a   Cherney, Adrian ^b   Head, Brian W ^b  

^a FLINDERS UNIVERSITY   (Australia)

^b UNIVERSITY OF QUEENSLAND   (Australia)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 84946429686     PISSN: 00333352     EISSN: 15406210     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/puar.12464     Document Type: Article

References (60)

1. Adams, David. 2004. Usable Knowledge in Public Policy. Australian Journal of Public Administration 63(1): 29-42.
2. Amara, Nabil, Mathieu Ouimet, and Réjean Landry . 2004. New Evidence on Instrumental, Conceptual, and Symbolic Utilization of University Research in Government Agencies. Science Communication 26(1): 75-106.
3. Banks, Gary. 2009. Evidence-Based Policy-Making: What Is It? How Do We Get It? Canberra, Australia: Productivity Commission.
4. Bardach, Eugene. 1984. The Dissemination of Policy Research to Policymakers. Science Communication 6(2): 125-44.
5. Belkhodja, Omar, Nabil Amara, Réjean Landry, and Mathieu Ouimet . 2007. The Extent and Organizational Determinants of Research Utilization in Canadian Health Services Organizations. Science Communication 28(3): 377-417.
6. Biesta, Gert. 2007. Why "What Works" Won't Work: Evidence-Based Practice and the Democratic Deficit in Educational Research. Educational Theory 57(1): 1-22.
7. Bogenschneider, Karen, and Thomas J. Corbett . 2010. Evidence-Based Policymaking: Insights from Policy-Minded Researchers and Research-Minded Policymakers. New York: Routledge.
8. Caplan, Nathan. 1979. The Two-Communities Theory and Knowledge Utilization. American Behavioral Scientist 22(3): 459-70.
9. Caplan, Nathan, Andrea Morrison, and Russell J. Stambaugh . 1975. The Use of Social Science Knowledge in Policy Decisions at the National Level: A Report to Respondents. Ann Arbor, MI: Institute for Social Research.
10. Carden, Fred. 2004. Issues in Assessing the Policy Influence of Research. International Social Science Journal 56(179): 135-51.
11. Cherney, Adrian. 2013. Academic-Industry Collaborations and Knowledge Co-Production in the Social Sciences. Journal of Sociology. Published electronically on July 8. doi:10.1177/1440783313492237.
12. Cherney, Adrian, Brian W. Head, Paul Boreham, Jenny Povey, and Michele Ferguson . 2012. Perspectives of Academic Social Scientists on Knowledge Transfer and Research Collaborations: A Cross-Sectional Survey of Australian Academics. Evidence and Policy 8(4): 433-53.
13. Cherney, Adrian, Brian W. Head, Jenny Povey, Paul Boreham, and Michele Ferguson . 2013. The Utilisation of Social Science Research-The Perspectives of Academic Researchers in Australia. Journal of Sociology 51(2): 252-70.
14. Cherney, Adrian, Brian W. Head, Jenny Povey, Michele Ferguson, and Paul Boreham . 2015. Use of Academic Social Research by Public Officials: Exploring Preferences and Constraints That Impact on Research Use. Evidence and Policy 11(2): 169-88.
15. Considine, Mark, and Jenny M. Lewis . 2003. Bureaucracy, Network, or Enterprise? Comparing Models of Governance in Australia, Britain, the Netherlands, and New Zealand. Public Administration Review 63(2): 131-40.
16. Cunningham, Robert, and Louis Weschler . 2002. Theory and the Public Administration Student/Practitioner. Public Administration Review 62(1): 104-11.
17. Dunn, William N. 1980. The Two-Communities Metaphor and Models of Knowledge Use: An Exploratory Case Survey. Science Communication 1(4): 515-36.
18. Edwards, Meredith. 2005. Social Science Research and Public Policy: Narrowing the Divide. Australian Journal of Public Administration 64(1): 68-74.
19. European Commission. 2010. Communicating Research for Evidence-Based Policymaking: A Practical Guide for Researchers in Socio-Economic Sciences and Humanities. Brussels: European Commission.
20. Frenk, Julio. 1992. Balancing Relevance and Excellence: Organizational Responses to Link Research with Decision Making. Social Science and Medicine 35(11): 1397-1404.
21. Fricker, Ronald D., Jr. 2008. Sampling Methods for Web and E-Mail Surveys. In The Sage Handbook of Online Research Methods, edited by Nigel Fielding, Raymond M. Lee, and Grant Blank, 195-217. London: Sage Publications.
22. Hall, Jeremy L., and Edward T. Jennings, Jr. 2008. Taking Chances: Evaluating Risk as a Guide to Better Use of Best Practices. Public Administration Review 68(4): 695-708.
23. Hammersley, Martyn. 2014. The Perils of "Impact" for Academic Social Science. Contemporary Social Science 9(3): 345-55.
24. Hargadon, Andrew B. 1998. Firms as Knowledge Brokers: Lessons in Pursuing Continuous Innovation. California Management Review 40(3): 209-27.
25. Haynes, Abby S., James A. Gillespie, Gemma E. Derrick, Wayne D. Hall, Sally Redman, Simon Chapman, and Heidi Sturk . 2011. Galvanizers, Guides, Champions, and Shields: The Many Ways That Policymakers Use Public Health Researchers. Milbank Quarterly 89(4): 564-98.
26. Head, Brian W. 2010. Reconsidering Evidence-Based Policy: Key Issues and Challenges. Policy and Society 29(2): 77-94.
27. Head, Brian W. . 2013. Evidence-Based Policymaking-Speaking Truth to Power? Australian Journal of Public Administration 72(4): 397-403.
28. Head, Brian W., Michele Ferguson, Adrian Cherney, and Paul Boreham . 2014. Are Policy-Makers Interested in Social Research? Exploring the Sources and Uses of Valued Information among Public Servants in Australia. Policy and Society 33(2): 89-101.
29. Hemsley-Brown W., Jane. 2004. Facilitating Research Utilisation: A Cross-Sector Review of Research Evidence. International Journal of Public Sector Management 17(6): 534-52.
30. Howlett, Michael, and Joshua Newman . 2010. Policy Analysis and Policy Work in Federal Systems: Policy Advice and Its Contribution to Evidence-Based Policy-Making in Multi-Level Governance Systems. Policy and Society 29(2): 123-36.
31. Jacobson, Nora. 2007. Social Epistemology: Theory for the "Fourth Wave" of Knowledge Transfer and Exchange Research. Science Communication 29(1): 116-27.
32. Jennings, Edward T., Jr., and Jeremy L. Hall . 2012. Evidence-Based Practice and the Use of Information in State Agency Decision Making. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory 22(2): 245-66.
33. Kalmuss, Debra. 1981. Scholars in the Courtroom: Two Models of Applied Social Science. American Sociologist 16(4): 212-23.
34. Knight, Christine, and Claire Lightowler . 2010. Reflections of "Knowledge Exchange Professionals" in the Social Sciences: Emerging Opportunities and Challenges for University-Based Knowledge Brokers. Evidence and Policy 6(4): 543-56.
35. Landry, Réjean, Moktar Lamari, and Nabil Amara . 2003. The Extent and Determinants of the Utilization of University Research in Government Agencies. Public Administration Review 63(2): 192-205.
36. Lavis, John N., Suzanne E. Ross, and Jeremiah E. Hurley . 2002. Examining the Role of Health Services Research in Public Policymaking. Milbank Quarterly 80(1): 125-54.
37. Legrand, Timothy. 2012. Overseas and Over Here: Policy Transfer and Evidence-Based Policy-Making. Policy Studies 33(4): 329-48.
38. Lester, James P. 1993. The Utilization of Policy Analysis by State Agency Officials. Science Communication 14(3): 267-90.
39. Maynard, Rebecca A. 2006. Evidence-Based Decision Making: What Will It Take for the Decision Makers to Care? Journal of Policy Analysis and Management 25(2): 249-65.
40. Nutley, Sandra, Isabel Walter, and Huw T.O. Davies . 2003. From Knowing to Doing: A Framework for Understanding the Evidence-into-Practice Agenda. Evaluation 9(2): 125-48.
41. Nutley, Sandra, Isabel Walter, and Huw T.O. Davies . 2007. Using Evidence: How Research Can Inform Public Services. Bristol, UK: Policy Press.
42. O'Malley, Martin. 2014. Doing What Works: Governing in the Age of Big Data. Public Administration Review 74(5): 555-56.
43. Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD). 2013. Strengthening Evidence-Based Policy Making on Security and Justice in Mexico. Paris: OECD.
44. Orr, Kevin, and Mike Bennett . 2012. Public Administration Scholarship and the Politics of Coproducing Academic-Practitioner Research. Public Administration Review 72(4): 487-96.
45. Page, Edward C. 2012. Policy without Politicians: Bureaucratic Influence in Comparative Perspective. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
46. Parsons, Wayne. 2002. From Muddling Through to Muddling Up-Evidence Based Policy Making and the Modernisation of British Government. Public Policy and Administration 17(3): 43-60.
47. Productivity Commission. 2010. Strengthening Evidence-Based Policy in the Australian Federation. Vol. 1, Proceedings, Roundtable Proceedings. Canberra, Australia: Productivity Commission.
48. Raadschelders, Jos C.N. 2011. Public Administration: The Interdisciplinary Study of Government. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
49. Sanderson, Ian. 2003. Is It "What Works" That Matters? Evaluation and Evidence-Based Policy-Making. Research Papers in Education 18(4): 331-45.
50. Shonkoff, Jack P. 2000. Science, Policy and Practice: Three Cultures in Search of a Shared Mission. Child Development 71(1): 181-87.
51. Snow, C.P. 1959. The Two Cultures and the Scientific Revolution. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
52. Talbot, Colin, and Carole Talbot . 2014. Sir Humphrey and the Professors: What Does Whitehall Want from Academics? Manchester, UK: University of Manchester. http://www.policy.manchester.ac.uk/resources/reports/ [accessed August 23, 2015].
53. Tseng, Vivian, and Sandra Nutley . 2014. Building the Infrastructure to Improve the Use and Usefulness of Research in Education. In Using Research Evidence in Education: From the Schoolhouse Door to Capitol Hill, edited by Kara S. Finnigan, and Alan J. Daly, 163-75. New York: Springer.
54. Ward, Vicky, Allan House, and Susan Hamer . 2009. Knowledge Brokering: The Missing Link in the Evidence to Action Chain? Evidence and Policy 5(3): 267-79.
55. Webber, David J. 1986. Explaining Policymakers' Use of Policy Information: The Relative Importance of the Two-Community Theory versus Decision-Maker Orientation. Science Communication 7(3): 249-90.
56. Weiss, Carol H. 1979. The Many Meanings of Research Utilization. Public Administration Review 39(5): 426-31.
57. Weiss, Carol H. 1980. Knowledge Creep and Decision Accretion. Science Communication 1(3): 381-404.
58. Weiss, Janet A. 1979. Access to Influence: Some Effects of Policy Sector on the Use of Social Science. American Behavioral Scientist 22(3): 437-58.
59. Williams, Paul. 2002. The Competent Boundary Spanner. Public Administration 80(1): 103-24.
60. Wingens, Matthias. 1990. Toward a General Utilization Theory: A Systems Theory Reformulation of the Two-Communities Metaphor. Science Communication 12(1): 27-42.