The mind behind anthropomorphic thinking: Attribution of mental states to other species

Animal Behaviour

Volumn 109, Issue , 2015, Pages 167-176

  Urquiza Haas, Esmeralda G ^a   Kotrschal, Kurt ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF VIENNA   (Austria)

Author keywords

Animals; Anthropomorphism; Dual process theory; Empathy; Reasoning; Social cognition

Indexed keywords

ANIMAL WELFARE; BEHAVIORAL ECOLOGY; COGNITION; CONSERVATION PLANNING; HYPOTHESIS TESTING; MODEL TEST; NATURE-SOCIETY RELATIONS; PERCEPTION; RESEARCH WORK; SOCIAL BEHAVIOR;

ANIMALIA;

EID: 84941946383     PISSN: 00033472     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.anbehav.2015.08.011     Document Type: Review

References (130)

1. Allison T., Puce A., McCarthy G. Social perception from visual cues: role of the STS region. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 2000, 4(7):267-278.
2. Apostol L., Rebega O.L., Miclea M. Psychological and sociodemographic predictors of attitudes towards animals. Procedia- Social and Behavioral Sciences 2013, 78:521-525.
3. Atkinson A.P., Dittrich W.H., Gemmell A.J., Young A.W. Emotion perception from dynamic and static body expressions in point-light and full-light displays. Perception 2004, 33(6):717-746.
4. Baddeley A.D. The concept of working memory: a view of its current state and probable future development. Cognition 1981, 10(1-3):17-23.
5. Baddeley A.D., Thomson N., Buchanan M. Word length and the structure of short-term memory. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior 1975, 14(6):575-589.
6. Baron-Cohen S. The extreme male brain theory. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 2002, 6(6):248-254.
7. Baron-Cohen S., Wheelwright S. The empathy quotient: an investigation of adults with Asperger syndrome or high functioning autism, and normal sex differences. Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders 2004, 34(2):163-175.
8. Barrett H.C. Cognitive development and the understanding of animal behavior. Origins of the social mind 2005, 438-467. The Guilford Press, New York, NY. B.J. Elis, D.F. Bjorklund (Eds.).
9. Barrett H.C., Todd P.M., Miller G.F., Blythe P.W. Accurate judgments of intention from motion cues alone: a cross-cultural study. Evolution and Human Behavior 2005, 26(4):313-331.
10. Blakemore S.J., Boyer P., Pachot-Clouard M., Meltzoff A., Segebarth C., Decety J. The detection of contingency and animacy from simple animations in the human brain. Cerebral Cortex 2003, 13(8):837-844.
11. Blythe P.W., Todd P.M., Miller G.F. How motion reveals intention: categorizing social interactions. Simple heuristics that make us smart. Evolution and cognition 1999, 257-285. Oxford University Press, New York, NY. G. Gigerenzer, P.M. Todd (Eds.).
12. Buccino G., Lui F., Canessa N., Patteri I., Lagravinese G., Benuzzi F., et al. Neural circuits involved in the recognition of actions performed by nonconspecifics: an FMRI study. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 2004, 16(1):114-126.
13. Burkart J., Kupferberg A., Glasauer S., van Schaik C. Even simple forms of social learning rely on intention attribution in marmoset monkeys (Callithrix jacchus). Journal of Comparative Psychology 2011, 126(2):129-138.
14. Caporael L.R., Heyes C. Why anthropomorphize? Folk psychology and other stories 1997, 59-73. University of New York Press, Albany, NY. R.W. Mitchell, N.S. Thompson, H.L. Miles (Eds.).
15. Caramazza A., Mahon B.Z. The organization of conceptual knowledge: the evidence from category-specific semantic deficits. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 2003, 7(8):354-361.
16. Caramazza A., Shelton J.R. Domain-specific knowledge systems in the brain: the animate-inanimate distinction. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 1998, 10(1):1-34.
17. Caselli M.C., Bates E., Casadio P., Fenson J., Fenson L., Sanderl L., et al. A cross-linguistic study of early lexical development. Cognitive Development 1995, 10(2):159-199.
18. Castelli F., Happe F., Frith U., Frith C. Movement and mind: a functional imaging study of perception and interpretation of complex intentional movement patterns. NeuroImage 2000, 12(3):314-325.
19. Chao L.L., Haxby J.V., Martin A. Attribute-based neural substrates in temporal cortex for perceiving and knowing about objects. Nature Neuroscience 1999, 2(10):913-919.
20. Cheng Y., Lin C.P., Liu H.L., Hsu Y.Y., Lim K.E., Hung D., et al. Expertise modulates the perception of pain in others. Current Biology 2007, 17(19):1708-1713.
21. Cikara M., Eberhardt J.L., Fiske S.T. From agents to objects: sexist attitudes and neural responses to sexualized targets. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 2011, 23(3):540-551.
22. Cowan N. The magical mystery four: how is working memory capacity limited, and why?. Current Directions in Psychological Science 2010, 19(1):51-57.
23. Crane E., Gross M. Motion capture and emotion: Affect detection in whole body movement 2007, Paper presented at the Affective Computing and Intelligent Interaction Conference, Portugal, September, Lisbon.
24. Cunningham W., Zelazo P.D. Attitudes and evaluations: a social cognitive neuroscience perspective. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 2007, 11(3):97-104.
25. Damasio A.R. Descartes' error: Emotion, reason, and the human brain 1994, Grosset/Putnam, New York, NY.
26. Darwin C. The expression of the emotions in man and animals 1872, Oxford University Press, New York, NY.
27. Davila-Ross M., Hutchinson J., Russell J.L., Schaller J., Billard A., Hopkins W.D., et al. Triggering social interactions: chimpanzees respond to imitation by a humanoid robot and request responses from it. Animal Cognition 2014, 17(3):589-595.
28. Dawkins R., Krebs J.R. Arms races between and within species. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London, Series B 1979, 205:489-511.
29. Decety J., Yang C.-Y., Cheng Y. Physicians down-regulate their pain empathy response: an event-related brain potential study. NeuroImage 2010, 50(4):1676-1682.
30. DeLoache J.S., Pickard M.B., LoBue V. How very young children think about animals. How animals affect us: Examining the influence of human-animal interaction on child development and human health 2011, 85-99. American Psychological Association, Washington, DC. P. McCardle, S. McCune, J.A. Griffin, V. Maholmes (Eds.).
31. Dennett D.C. Intentional systems. Journal of Philosophy 1971, 68(4):87-106.
32. Descola P. Beyond nature and culture. Proceedings of the British Academy 2006, 139:137-155.
33. Driscoll J.W. Attitudes toward animals: species ratings. Society and Animals 1995, 3(2):139-150.
34. Eddy T.J., Gallup G.G., Povinelli D.J. Attribution of cognitive states to animals: anthropomorphism in comparative perspective. Journal of Social Issues 1993, 49(1):87-101.
35. Engle R.W. Working memory capacity as executive attention. Current Directions in Psychological Science 2002, 11(1):19-23.
36. Epley N., Waytz A., Cacioppo J.T. On seeing human: a three-factor theory of anthropomorphism. Psychological Review 2007, 114(4):864-886.
37. Evans J.S.B.T. Dual-processing accounts of reasoning, judgment, and social cognition. Annual Review of Psychology 2008, 59:255-278.
38. Filippi M., Riccitelli G., Falini A., Di Salle F., Vuilleumier P., Comi G., et al. The brain functional networks associated to human and animal suffering differ among omnivores, vegetarians and vegans. PLoS One 2010, 5(5). e10847-e10847.
39. Fisher J.A. Disambiguating anthropomorphism: An interdisciplinary review. Perspectives in Ethology 1991, 9:49-85.
40. Fisher A.V., Sloutsky V.M. When induction meets memory: evidence for gradual transition from similarity-based to category-based induction. Child Development 2005, 76(3):583-597.
41. Franklin R.G., Nelson A.J., Baker M., Beeney J.E., Vescio T.K., Lenz-Watson A., et al. Neural responses to perceiving suffering in humans and animals. Social Neuroscience 2013, 8(3):217-227.
42. Fritz J., Bisenberger A., Kotrschal K.M. Stimulus enhancement in greylag geese: socially mediated learning of an operant task. Animal Behaviour 2000, 59(6):1119-1125.
43. Furnham A., McManus C., Scott D. Personality, empathy and attitudes to animal welfare. Anthrozoos 2003, 16(2):135-146.
44. Gallese V., Goldman A. Mirror neurons and the simulation theory of mind-reading. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 1998, 2(12):493-501.
45. Gao T., Newman G.E., Scholl B.J. The psychophysics of chasing: a case study in the perception of animacy. Cognitive Psychology 2009, 59(2):154-179.
46. Gazzola V., Rizzolatti G., Wicker B., Keysers C. The anthropomorphic brain: the mirror neuron system responds to human and robotic actions. NeuroImage 2007, 35(4):1674-1684.
47. Giese M.A., Poggio T. Neural mechanisms for the recognition of biological movements. Nature Reviews Neuroscience 2003, 4(3):179-192.
48. Gobbini M.I., Gentili C., Ricciardi E., Bellucci C., Salvini P., Laschi C., et al. Distinct neural systems involved in agency and animacy detection. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 2011, 23(8):1911-1920.
49. Goldman A.I. Simulating minds: The philosophy, psychology, and neuroscience of mindreading 2006, Oxford University Press, New York, NY.
50. Goodson J.L. The vertebrate social behavior network: evolutionary themes and variations. Hormones and Behavior 2005, 48(1):11-22.
51. Gould J.L., Marler P. Learning by instinct. Scientific American 1987, 255(1):74-85.
52. Gray H.M., Gray K., Wegner D.M. Dimensions of mind perception. Science 2007, 315(5812). 619-619.
53. Guthrie S.E. Anthropomorphism: a definition and a theory. Anthropomorphism, anecdotes, and animals 1997, 50-58. State University of New York Press, Albany, NY. R.W. Mitchell, N.S. Thompson, H.L. Miles (Eds.).
54. Harrison M.A., Hall A.E. Anthropomorpohism, empathy, and perceived communicative ability vary with phylogenetic relatedness to humans. Journal of Social, Evolutionary, and Cultural Psychology 2010, 4(1):34-48.
55. Heit E. Properties of inductive reasoning. Psychonomic Bulletin & Review 2000, 7(4):569-592.
56. Herzog H.A., Galvin S. Anthropomorphism, common sense, and animal awareness. Anthropomorphism, anecdotes, and animals 1997, 237-253. State University of New York Press, Albany, NY. R.W. Mitchell, N.S. Thompson, H.L. Miles (Eds.).
57. Horowitz A.C., Bekoff M. Naturalizing anthropomorphism: behavioral prompts to our humanizing of animals. Anthrozoos 2007, 20(1):23-35.
58. Iacoboni M., Lieberman M.D., Knowlton B.J., Molnar-Szakacs I., Moritz M., Throop C.J., et al. Watching social interactions produces dorsomedial prefrontal and medial parietal BOLD fMRI signal increases compared to a resting baseline. NeuroImage 2004, 21:1167-1173.
59. Jack A.I., Dawsona A.J., Beganya K.L., Leckiea R.L., Barrya K.P., Cicciab A.H., et al. fMRI reveals reciprocal inhibition between social and physical cognitive domains. NeuroImage 2013, 66:385-401.
60. Julius H., Beetz A., Kotrschal K., Turner D., Uvnäs-Moberg K. Attachment to pets. An integrative view of human-animal relationships with implications for therapeutic practice 2012, Hogrefe Publishing, Göttingen, Germany.
61. Kaiser M.D., Shiffrar M., Pelphrey K.A. Socially tuned: brain responses differentiating human and animal motion. Social Neuroscience 2012, 7(3):301-310.
62. Karg M., Kühnlenz K., Buss M. Recognition of affect based on gait patterns. IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics. Part B, Cybernetics: A Publication of the IEEE Systems, Man, and Cybernetics Society 2010, 40(4):1050-1061.
63. Kellert S.R., Berry J.K. Attitudes, knowledge, and behaviors toward wildlife as affected by gender. Wildlife Society Bulletin 1987, 15(3):363-371.
64. Kennedy J.S. The new anthropomorphism 1992, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, U.K.
65. Kingstone A., Tipper C., Ristic J., Ngan E. The eyes have it!: an fMRI investigation. Brain and Cognition 2004, 55(2):269-271.
66. Knight S., Vrij A., Cherryman J., Nunkoosing K. Attitudes towards animal use and belief in animal mind. Anthrozoos 2004, 17(1):43-62.
67. Kracher A. Imposing order- the varieties of anthropomorphism. Studies in Science and Theology 2002, 8:239-261.
68. Kupferberg A., Glasauer S., Burkart J.M. Do robots have goals? How agent cues influence action understanding in non-human primates. Behavioural Brain Research 2013, 246:47-54.
69. Kupferberg A., Huber M., Helfer B., Lenz C., Knoll A., Glasauer S. Moving just like you: motor interference depends on similar motility of agent and observer. PLoS One 2012, 7(6). e39637-e39637.
70. Kwan V.S.Y., Gosling S.D., John O.P. Anthropomorphism as a special case of social perception: a cross-species comparative approach and a new empirical paradigm. Social Cognition 2008, 26(2):129-142.
71. Lahnakoski J.M., Glerean E., Salmi J., Jääskeläinen L.P., Sams M., Hari R., et al. Naturalistic fMRI mapping reveals superior temporal sulcus as the hub for the distributed brain network for social perception. Frontiers in Human Neuroscience 2012, 6:1-14.
72. Lee S.M., Gao T., McCarthy G. Attributing intentions to random motion engages the posterior superior temporal sulcus. Social, Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience 2012, 9(1):81-87.
73. Leppänen J.M., Nelson C.A. Tuning the developing brain to social signals of emotions. Nature Reviews Neuroscience 2009, 10(1):37-47.
74. Lorenz K.Z. Evolution and modification of behavior 1965, University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL.
75. Mahon B.Z., Anzellotti S., Schwarzbach J., Zampini M., Caramazza A. Category-specific organization in the human brain does not require visual experience. Neuron 2009, 63(3):397-405.
76. Mars R.B., Neubert F.-X., Noonan M., Sallet J., Toni I., Rushworth M.F.S. On the relationship between the "default mode network" and the "social brain". Frontiers in Human Neuroscience 2012, 6:1-9.
77. Martin A. The representation of object concepts in the brain. Annual Review of Psychology 2007, 58:25-45.
78. Martín-Forés I., Martín-López B., Montes C. Anthropomorphic factors influencing Spanish conservation policies of vertebrates. International Journal of Biodiversity 2013, 2013:1-9.
79. Martín-López B., Montes C., Benayas J. The non-economic motives behind the willingness to pay for biodiversity conservation. Biological Conservation 2007, 139(1-2):67-82.
80. Martin L.J., Hathaway G., Isbester K., Mirali S., Acland E.L., Niederstrasser N., et al. Reducing social stress elicits emotional contagion of pain in mouse and human strangers. Current Biology 2015, 25(3):326-332.
81. Martin A., Weisberg J. Neural foundations for understanding social and mechanical concepts. Cognitive Neuropsychology 2003, 20(3-6):575-587.
82. McDonnell R., Jörg S., McHugh J., Newell F.N., O'Sullivan C. Investigating the role of body shape on the perception of emotion. ACM Transactions on Applied Perception 2009, 6(3):1-11.
83. Meints K., Racca A., Hickey N. How to prevent dog bite injuries? Children misinterpret dogs facial expression. Injury Prevention 2010, 16:A68.
84. Mitchell R.W., Hamm M. The interpretation of animal psychology: anthropomorphism or behavior reading?. Behaviour 1997, 134(3):173-204.
85. Mithen S. The prehistory of the mind. A search for the origins of art, religion and science 1996, Thames and Hudson, London, U.K.
86. Morris P., Doe C., Godsell E. Secondary emotions in non-primate species? Behavioural reports and subjective claims by animal owners. Cognition & Emotion 2008, 22(1):3-20.
87. Mukamel R., Ekstrom A.D., Kaplan J., Iacoboni M., Fried I. Single-Neuron responses in humans during execution and observation of actions. Current Biology 2010, 20(8):750-756.
88. Nakajima S., Arimitsu K., Lattal M. Estimation of animal intelligence by university students in Japan and the United States. Anthrozoos 2002, 15(3):194-205.
89. Nelson K. Structure and strategy in learning to talk. Monographs of the Society for Research in Child Development 1973, 38(1/2):1-135.
90. New J., Cosmides L., Tooby J. Category-specific attention for animals reflects ancestral priorities, not expertise. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 2007, 104(42):16593-16603.
91. Norring M., Wikman I., Hokkanen A.-H., Kujala M., Hänninen L. Empathic veterinarians score cattle pain higher. Veterinary Journal 2014, 200(1):186-190.
92. Osaka N., Ikeda T., Osaka M. Effect of intentional bias on agency attribution of animated motion: an event-related fMRI study. PLoS One 2012, 7(11). e49053-e49053.
93. Panksepp J. Affective consciousness: core emotional feelings in animals and humans. Consciousness and Cognition 2005, 14(1):30-80.
94. Panksepp J., Biven L. The archaeology of mind: neuroevolutionary origins of human emotions 2012, W. W. Norton, New York, NY.
95. Paul E.S., Podberscek A.L. Veterinary education and students' attitudes towards animal welfare. Veterinary Record 2000, 146(10):269-272.
96. di Pellegrino G., Fadiga L., Fogassi L., Gallese V., Rizzolatti G. Understanding motor events: a neurophysiological study. Experimental Brain Research 1992, 91(1):176-180.
97. Phillips C., Izmirli S., Aldavood J., Alonso M., Choe B.I., Hanlon A., et al. An international comparison of female and male students' attitudes to the use of animals. Animals 2011, 1(1):7-26.
98. Preston S.D., de Waal F.B.M. Empathy: its ultimate and proximate bases. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 2002, 25(1):1-20.
99. Range F., Horn L., Viranyi Z., Huber L. The absence of reward induces inequity aversion in dogs. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 2009, 106(1):340-345.
100. Rasmussen J.L., Rajecki D.W., Craft H.D. Humans' perceptions of animal mentality: ascriptions of thinking. Journal of Comparative Psychology 1993, 107(3):283-290.
101. Rilling J.K., Sanfey A.G., Aronson J.A., Nystrom L.E., Cohen J.D. The neural correlates of theory of mind within interpersonal interactions. NeuroImage 2004, 22(4):1694-1703.
102. Rizzolatti G., Fabbri-Destro M. The mirror system and its role in social cognition. Current Opinion in Neurobiology 2008, 18(2):179-184.
103. Scholl B.J., Tremoulet P.D. Perceptual causality and animacy. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 2000, 4(8):299-309.
104. Schultz J., Friston K.J., O'Doherty J., Wolpert D.M., Frith C.D. Activation in posterior superior temporal sulcus parallels parameter inducing the percept of animacy. Neuron 2005, 45(4):625-635.
105. Schultz J., Imamizu H., Kawato M., Firth C.D. Activation of the human superior temporal gyrus during observation of goal attribution by intentional objects. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 2004, 16(10):1695-1705.
106. Shultz S., Lee S.M., Pelphrey K., McCarthy G. The posterior superior temporal sulcus is sensitive to the outcome of human and non-human goal-directed actions. Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience 2011, 6(5):602-611.
107. Sih A., Bell A.M., Johnson J.C. Behavioral syndromes: an ecological and evolutionary overview. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 2004, 19(7):372-378.
108. Simion F., Regolin L., Bulf H. A predisposition for biological motion in the newborn baby. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 2008, 105(2):809-813.
109. Simmons W.K., Martin A. Spontaneous resting-state BOLD fluctuations reveal persistent domain-specific neural networks. Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience 2012, 7(4):467-475.
110. Singer P. Animal liberation 1975, Harpers Collins, New York, NY.
111. Sloutsky V.M., Fisher A.V. Induction and categorization in young children: a similarity-based model. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 2004, 133(2):166-188.
112. Sloutsky V.M., Kloos H., Fisher A.V. When looks are everything: appearance similarity versus kind information in early induction. Psychological Science 2007, 18(2):179-185.
113. Swami V., Furnham A., Christopher A. Free the animals? Investigating attitudes toward animal testing in Britain and the United States. Scandinavian Journal of Psychology 2008, 49(3):269-276.
114. Tavares P., Lawrence A.D., Barnard P.J. Paying attention to social meaning: an FMRI study. Cerebral Cortex 2008, 18(8):1876-1885.
115. Taylor N., Signal T. Empathy and attitudes to animals. Anthrozoos 2005, 18(1):18-27.
116. Tinbergen N. On aims and methods of ethology. Zeitschrift für Tierpsychologie 1963, 20:410-433.
117. von Uexküll J. Umwelt und Innenwelt der Tiere 1909, Verlang von Julius Springer, Berlin, Germany.
118. Vaina L.M., Solomon J., Chowdhury S., Sinha P., Belliveau J.W. Functional neuroanatomy of biological motion perception in humans. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 2001, 98(20):11656-11661.
119. Viveiros de Castro E. Cosmological deixis and Amerindian perspectivism. Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute 1998, 4(3):469-488.
120. Watson R., Latinus M., Charest I., Crabbe F., Belin P. People-selectivity, audiovisual integration and heteromodality in the superior temporal sulcus. Cortex 2014, 50(100):125-136.
121. Waytz A., Gray K., Epley N., Wegner D.M. Causes and consequences of mind perception. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 2010, 14(8):383-388.
122. Waytz A., Schroeder J., Epley N. The lesser minds problem. Are we all human? Advances in understanding humanness dehumanization 2014, 49-67. Psychology Press, New York, NY. P. Bain, J. Vaes, J.P. Leyens (Eds.).
123. Weber M., Thompson-Schill S.L., Osherson D., Haxby J., Parsons L. Predicting judged similarity of natural categories from their neural representations. Neuropsychologia 2009, 47(3):859-868.
124. Wedl M., Kotrschal K. Social and individual components of animal contact in preschool children. Anthrozoos 2009, 22(4):383-396.
125. Welder A.N., Graham S.A. The influences of shape similarity and shared labels on infants' inductive inferences about nonobvious object properties. Child Development 2001, 72(6):1653-1673.
126. Westbury H.R., Neumann D.L. Empathy-related responses to moving film stimuli depicting human and non-human animal targets in negative circumstances. Biological Psychology 2008, 78(1):66-74.
127. Wheatley T., Milleville S., Martin A. Understanding animate agents: distinct roles for the social network and mirror system. Psychological Science 2007, 18(6):469-474.
128. Willerslev R. Not animal, not-not animal: hunting, imitation and empathetic knowledge among the Siberian Yukaghirs. Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute 2004, 10(3):629-652.
129. Wilson E.O. Biophilia 1984, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.
130. Würbel H. Ethology applied to animal ethics. Applied Animal Behaviour Science 2009, 118(3-4):118-127.