Hydropower, Anti-Politics, and the Opening of New Political Spaces in the Eastern Himalayas

World Development

Volumn 76, Issue , 2015, Pages 13-25

  Huber, Amelie ^a,b   Joshi, Deepa ^c  

^a UNIVERSITAT AUTÒNOMA DE BARCELONA   (Spain)

^b BOGAZICI UNIVERSITY   (Turkey)

^c WAGENINGEN UNIVERSITY   (Netherlands)

Author keywords

Asia; Depoliticization; Environmental governance; India; Large dams; Water conflicts

Indexed keywords

DAM; GOVERNANCE APPROACH; HYDROELECTRIC POWER; POLITICAL RELATIONS; PRIVATE SECTOR; STATE;

HIMALAYAS; INDIA; SIKKIM;

EID: 84934274466     PISSN: 0305750X     EISSN: 18735991     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.worlddev.2015.06.006     Document Type: Article

References (91)

1. Ahlers R., Budds J., Joshi D., Mehta S., Merme V., Zwarteveen M. Framing hydropower as green energy: Assessing drivers, risks and tensions in the Eastern Himalayas. Earth Systems Dynamics 2015, 6:195-204.
2. Arora V. They are all set to dam(n) our future': Contested development through hydel power in democratic Sikkim. Sociological Bulletin 2009, 58(1):94-114.
3. Arora V. The paradox of democracy in the Northeast and the Eastern Himalayas. Routeing democracy in the Himalayas 2013, 101-132. Routledge, New Delhi. V. Arora, N. Jayaram (Eds.).
4. Arora V. Walking the 'Shangri-La' Sikkim trail. Globalization, marginalization, and the marginalized: The emerging context 2010, 121-144. Manohar, New Delhi. D.K. Singha Roy (Ed.).
5. Baruah S. Whose river is it anyway? Political economy of hydropower in the Eastern Himalayas. Economic and Political Weekly 2012, 47(29):41-52.
6. Basu, J. (2010, December 29). Hydel plan on Sikkim 'Holy River' hit. The Telegraph (Calcutta, India). <> Accessed October 25, 2014. http://www.telegraphindia.com/1101229/jsp/bengal/story_13364150.jsp.
7. Bending, T. (2003). The emperor's new clothes: Rethinking the mechanics of the "anti-politics machine". Paper presented at the EIDOS Workshop, Order and Disjuncture: The Organisation of Aid and Development, London (26-28 September).
8. Bentley J. 'Vanishing Lepcha': Change and culture revival in a mountain community in Sikkim. Bulletin of Tibetology 2007, 43(1/2):59-80.
9. Independent people's tribunal on dams, environment and displacement 2012, Human Rights Law Network, New Delhi. D.T. Bhutia (Ed.).
10. Blaikie P. A review of political ecology issues, epistemology and analytical narratives. Zeitschrift für Wirtschaftsgeographie 1999, 43(3-4):131-147.
11. Bosshard P. The dam industry, the World Commission on Dams and the HSAF process. Water Alternatives 2010, 3(2):58-70.
12. Bryant R.L. Putting politics first: The political ecology of sustainable development. Global Ecology and Biogeography Letters 1991, 1(6):164-166.
13. Büscher B. Anti-politics as political strategy: Neoliberalism and transfrontier conservation in Southern Africa. Development and Change 2010, 41(1):29-51.
14. Chettri, M. (2013). Ethnic politics in the Nepali public sphere: Three cases from the Eastern Himalaya (Ph.D. thesis). SOAS, University of London.
15. Chhotray V. The 'anti-politics machine' in India: Depoliticisation through local institution building for participatory watershed development. Journal of Development Studies 2007, 43(6):1037-1056.
16. Chhotray V. The anti-politics machine in India: State, decentralization and participatory watershed development 2011, Anthem Press, London and New York.
17. Coelho V.S.P., Favaretto A. Questioning the relationship between participation and development: A case study of the Vale do Ribeira, Brazil. World Development 2008, 36(12):2937-2952.
18. Cole M.A., Elliott J.R., Strobl E. Climate change, hydro-dependency, and the African dam boom. World Development 2014, 60:84-98.
19. Das U. Does political activism and affiliation affect allocation of benefits in the rural employment guarantee program: Evidence from West Bengal, India. World Development 2015, 67:202-217.
20. Dharmadikary S. Mountains of concrete: Dam building in the Himalayas 2008, International Rivers, Berkeley.
21. Down To Earth. (1999). The lone crusader. <> Accessed October 25, 2014. http://www.downtoearth.org.in/node/19330.
22. EC [European Commission] Directive 2004/101/EC of the European parliament of the council of 27 October 2014. Official Journal of the European Union 2004, L338:18-23.
23. Erlewein A., Nüsser M. Offsetting greenhouse gas emissions in the Himalaya? Clean development dams in Himachal Pradesh, India. Mountain Research and Development 2011, 31(4):293-304.
24. Escobar A. Planning. The development dictionary: A guide to knowledge as power 1999, 132-157. Zed Books, London and New York. W. Sachs (Ed.).
25. Ferguson J. The anti-politics machine: "Development", depoliticization and bureaucratic power in Lesotho 1990, University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis.
26. Finley-Brook M., Thomas C. Renewable energy and human rights violations: Illustrative cases from indigenous territories in Panama. Annals of the Association of American Geographers 2011, 101(4):863-872.
27. Fletcher R. When environmental issues collide: Climate change and the shifting political ecology of hydroelectric power. Peace and Conflict Review 2010, 5(1):1-15.
28. Gergan M. Precarity and possibility: On being Young and Indigenous in Sikkim, India. Himalaya, The Journal of the Association for Nepal and Himalayan Studies 2014, 34(2):67-80.
29. Goldman M. Constructing an environmental state: Eco-governmentality and other transnational practices of a 'green' World Bank. Social Problems 2001, 48(4):499-523.
30. The national rehabilitation and resettlement policy, 2007 2007, GOI [Government of India], Government of India, Ministry of Rural Development, New Delhi.
31. Sikkim - 15 triumphant years of democracy (1994-2009): A call to action 2009, GOS [Government of Sikkim], Government of Sikkim, Information and Public Relations Department, Gangtok.
32. Annual report 2008-09 2009, GOS [Government of Sikkim], Government of Sikkim, Energy and Power Department Website, Accessed 14 September 2011.
33. Energy and power sector vision 2015 2010, GOS [Government of Sikkim], Government of Sikkim, Energy and Power Department, Gangtok.
34. Budget speech by Chief Minister and the Minister-in-Charge, Finance, Revenue and Expenditure Department, on 26th June 2012 2012, GOS [Government of Sikkim], Government of Sikkim, Finance, Revenue & Expenditure Department, Gangtok.
35. Achievements, recognitions and awards 2013, GOS [Government of Sikkim], Government of Sikkim Website, Gangtok, Accessed 27 August 2013.
36. Grumbine R.E., Pandit M.K. Threats from India's Himalaya dams. Science 2013, 339:36-37.
37. Harriss J. Depoliticising development: The World Bank and social capital 2002, Leftword, New Delhi.
38. Haya B., Parekh P. Hydropower in the CDM: Examining additionality and criteria for sustainability. Energy and Resources Group working paper ERG-11-001 2011, University of California, Berkeley.
39. Herman E., Chomsky N. Manufacturing consent: The political economy of the mass media 1994, Vintage, London.
40. Iimi, A. (2007). Estimating global climate change impacts on hydropower projects: Applications in India, Sri Lanka and Vietnam. World Bank policy research working paper no. 4344. Washington, DC.
41. Khagram S. Dams and development: Transnational struggles for water and power 2004, Cornell University Press, Ithaca.
42. Kohli K. Inducing vulnerabilities in a fragile landscape'. Economic and Political Weekly 2011, 46(51):19-22.
43. Larsen R.K., Mamosso C.A. Aid with blinkers: Environmental governance of uranium mining in Niger. World Development 2014, 56:62-76.
44. Li T.M. The will to improve: Governmentality, politics and the practice of development 2007, Duke University Press, Durham.
45. Little K. Lepcha narratives of their threatened sacred landscapes. Transforming Cultures eJournal 2008, 3(1):227-255.
46. Little K. Deep ecology, dams, and Dzonguland - Lepchas protest narratives about their threatened land. The Trumpeter 2009, 35(1):34-64.
47. Little K. Democracy reigns supreme in Sikkim? A long march and a short visit strains democracy for Lepcha marchers in Sikkim. Australian Humanities Review 2010, 48:109-129.
48. Marden P. The decline of politics. Governance, globalisation and the public sphere 2003, Ashgate, Aldershot.
49. Matthews N. Water grabbing in the Mekong basin - An analysis of the winners and losers of Thailand's hydropower development in Lao PDR. Water Alternatives 2012, 5(2):392-411.
50. Mazumdar, J. (2011, October 2). Introspecting faultlines. The Times of India. <> Accessed October 25, 2014. http://articles.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/2011-10-02/special-report/30235047_1_major-quakes-richter-scale-widespread-devastation.
51. McCormick S. Damming the Amazon: Local movements and transnational struggles over water. Society & Natural Resources: An International Journal 2010, 24(1):34-48.
52. McCully P. Silenced rivers - The ecology and politics of large dams 2001, Zed Books, London. 2nd ed.
53. McDuie-Ra D. The dilemmas of pro-development actors: Viewing state-ethnic minority relations and intra-ethnic dynamics through contentious development projects. Asian Ethnicity 2011, 12(1):77-100.
54. McDuie-Ra D. Deep democracy or ethnocentrism? Locating voice in the protests against development in Northeastern India. Routeing democracy in the Himalayas 2013, 133-155. Routledge, New Delhi. V. Arora, N. Jayaram (Eds.).
55. Mehta L. The manufacture of popular perceptions of scarcity: Dams and water-related narratives in Gujarat, India. World Development 2001, 29(12):2025-2041.
56. Menon M. Saved! The story of Rathong Chu. The Ecologist Asia 2003, 11(1):33.
57. Menon M., Vagholikar N., Kohli K., Fernandes A. Large dams in the Northeast - A bright future?. The Ecologist Asia 2003, 11(1):3-8.
58. Moore D., Dore J., Gyawali D. The World Commission on Dams + 10: Revisiting the large dam controversy. Water Alternatives 2010, 3(2):3-13.
59. Mouffe C. On the political 2005, Routledge, Abingdon and New York.
60. Newell P., Phillips J., Purohit P. The political economy of clean development in India: CDM and beyond. IDS Bulletin 2011, 42(3):89-96.
61. Nustad K.G. Development: The devil we know?. Third World Quarterly 2001, 22(4):479-498.
62. Orr S., Pittock J., Chapagain A., Dumaresq D. Dams on the Mekong River: Lost fish protein and the implications for land and water resources. Global Environmental Change 2012, 22:925-932.
63. Liberation ecologies: Environment, development, social movements 1996, Routledge, London. R. Peet, M. Watts (Eds.).
64. Pittock J. Viewpoint - Better management of hydropower in an era of climate change. Water Alternatives 2010, 3(2):444-452.
65. Pottinger L. Bad deal for the planet: Why carbon offsets aren't working. . . and how to create a fair global climate accord 2008, International Rivers, Berkeley.
66. Pottinger L. Africa: The wrong climate for big dams 2009, World Rivers Review, (December).
67. Resneck J. The green mountain state. The Caravan 2010, Accessed October 25, 2014.
68. Rest M. Generating power: Debates on development around the Nepalese Arun-3 hydropower project. Contemporary South Asia 2012, 20(1):105-117.
69. Robbins P. Political ecology: A critical introduction 2004, Blackwell, Oxford.
70. Robins S. Breaking out of the politics and the straitjacket of tradition: Rhetoric of 'development' in Zimbabwe. World Development 1998, 26(9):1604-1677.
71. Save Dzongu. (2013). The background. Save Dzongu Website. <> Accessed October 25, 2014. http://savedzongu.wordpress.com/background/.
72. Schaefer, L. (1995). A Sikkim awakening. Himal South Asian, September/October 1995.
73. Schneider, H. (2013, May 8). World Bank turns to hydropower to square development with climate change. Washington Post. <> Accessed October 25, 2014. http://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/world-bank-turns-to-hydropower-to-square-development-with-climate-change/2013/05/08/b9d60332-b1bd-11e2-9a98-4be1688d7d84_story.html.
74. Scott J. Weapons of the weak: Everyday forms of peasant resistance 1985, Yale University Press, New Haven.
75. Shah M. Water: Towards a paradigm shift in the Twelfth Plan. Economic and Political Weekly 2013, 48(3):40-52.
76. Sikkim Express. (2009, July 21). Union Power Minister dedicates 510MW Teesta stage V hydro power plant to the nation.
77. Sikkim Now! (2011a, November 18). Protest grows against Tashiding HEP, area MLA approached. <> Accessed October 25, 2014. http://sikkimnow.blogspot.it/2011/11/protest-grows-against-tashiding-hep.html.
78. Sikkim Now! (2011b, December 7). Organisations launch joint action against hydel projects in West Sikkim. <> Accessed October 25, 2014. http://sikkimnow.blogspot.de/2011/12/organisations-launch-joint-action.html?q=common+platform.
79. Sikkim Now! (2012b, May 18). State Day message of Chief Minister Pawan Chamling. <> Accessed October 25, 2014. http://sikkimnow.blogspot.it/2012/05/state-day-message-of-chief-minister.html.
80. Skinner J., Haas L.J. Watered down? A review of social and environmental safeguards for large dam projects 2014, Natural Resource Issues No. 28, IIED, London.
81. Sneddon C., Fox C. Struggles over dams as struggles for justice: The World Commission on Dams (WCD) and anti-dam campaigns in Thailand and Mozambique. Society & Natural Resources: An International Journal 2008, 21(7):625-640.
82. Swyngedouw E. Depoliticized environments: The end of nature, climate change and the post-political condition. Royal Institute of Philosophy Supplements 2011, 69:253-274.
83. Swyngedouw E. Interrogating post-democratization: Reclaiming egalitarian political spaces. Political Geography 2011, 30(7):370-380.
84. Swyngedouw E. Impossible "sustainability" and the postpolitical condition. The sustainable development paradox: Urban political economy in the United States and Europe 2007, 13-40. Guilford Press, New York. R. Krueger, D. Gibbs (Eds.).
85. The Sikkim Times. (2007a, May 7). Lachen says no to hydroelectric power project. <> Accessed October 25, 2014. http://sikkimnews.blogspot.de/2007/05/lachen-says-no-to-hydro-electric-power.html.
86. The Sikkim Times. (2007b, July 13). Sikkim government rejects ACT protests on power projects, Government of Sikkim's statement on hydel policy. <> Accessed October 25, 2014. http://sikkimnews.blogspot.de/2007/07/sikkim-government-rejects-act-protests.html.
87. The Telegraph. (2011, August 12). Sikkim bill for public order. <> Accessed October 25, 2014. http://www.telegraphindia.com/1110812/jsp/frontpage/story_14369595.jsp.
88. Dams and development: A new framework for decision-making 2000, WCD [World Commission on Dams], The Report of the World Commission on Dams, Earthscan, London.
89. Vagholikar N., Das P.J. Damming Northeast India 2010, Kalpavriksh, Aaranyak, and Action Aid India, Pune/Guwahati/New Delhi.
90. World Bank. (2014, June 11). Government of India and World Bank sign $100 million agreement to support Himachal Pradesh in its green growth agenda. <> Accessed October 25, 2014. http://www.worldbank.org/en/news/press-release/2014/06/11/india-and-world-bank-sign-usd-100-million-agreement-to-support-himachal-pradesh-in-its-green-growth-agenda.
91. Yumnam J. An assessment of dams in India's Northeast seeking carbon credits from Clean Development Mechanism of the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change 2012, Citizens' Concern for Dams and Development and International Rivers, Imphal.