Successes we may not have had: A retrospective analysis of selected weed biological control agents in the United States

Invasive Plant Science and Management

Volumn 7, Issue 4, 2014, Pages 565-579

  Hinz, Hariet L ^a   Schwarzländer, Mark ^b   Gassmann, André ^a   Bourchier, Robert S ^c  

^a CABI   (Switzerland)

^b UNIVERSITY OF IDAHO   (United States)

^c AGRICULTURE AND AGRI FOOD CANADA   (Canada)

Author keywords

Biological control of weeds; Host range; Introduction policy; Non target attack; Risk assessment

Indexed keywords

EID: 84929660500     PISSN: 19397291     EISSN: 1939747X     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1614/IPSM-D-13-00095.1     Document Type: Conference Paper

References (96)

1. Albach DC, Meudt HM, Oxelman B (2005) Piecing together the ‘‘new’’ Plantaginaceae. Am J Bot 92:297–315
2. Andres LA (1985) Interactions of Chrysolina quadrigemina and Hypericum species in California. Pages 235–239 in Proceedings of the VI International Symposium on Biological Control of Weeds. Ottawa, Canada: Agriculture Canada
3. Baker JL, Webber NAP, Johnson KK (2004) Non-target impacts of Aphthona nigriscutis, a biological control agent for Euphorbia esula (leafy spurge), on a native plant Euphorbia robusta. Pages 247–251 in Proceedings of the XI International Symposium on Biological Control of Weeds. Canberra, Australia: CSIRO Entomology
4. Barratt BIP, Moeed A (2005) Environmental safety of biological control: policy and practice in New Zealand. Biol Control 35: 247–252
5. Blossey B, Casagrande R, Tewksbury L, Landis DA, Wiedenmann RN, Ellis DR (2001) Nontarget feeding of leaf-beetles introduced to control purple loosestrife (Lythrum salicaria L.). Nat Areas J 21: 368–377
6. Blossey B, Schroeder D, Hight SD, Malecki RA (1994) Host specificity and environmental impact of two leaf beetles (Galerucella calmariensis and G. pusilla) for biological control of purple loosestrife (Lythrum salicaria). Weed Sci 42:134–140
7. Boldt PE, Rosenthal SS, Srinivasan R (1998) Distribution of field bindweed and hedge bindweed in the USA. J Prod Agric 11:377–381
8. Bredow E, Pedrosa-Macedo JH, Medal JC, Cuda JP (2007) Open field host specificity tests in Brazil for risk assessment of Metriona elatior (Coleoptera: Chrysomelidae), a potential biological control agent for Solanum viarum (Solanaceae) in Florida. Fla Entomol 90:559–564
9. Breiter N, Seastedt TR (2007) Postrelease evaluation of Mecinus janthinus host specificity, a biological control agent for invasive toadflax (Linaria spp.). Weed Sci. 55:164–168
10. Briese DT (2004) Weed biological control: applying science to solve seemingly intractable problems. Aust J Ecol 43:304–317
11. Center TD, Pratt PD, Tipping PW, Rayamajhi MB, Van TK, Wineriter SA, Dray, Jr., FA (2007) Initial impacts and field validation of host range for Boreioglycaspis melaleucae Moore (Hemiptera: Psyllidae), a biological control agent of the invasive tree Melaleuca quinquenervia (Cav.) Blake (Myrtales: Myrtaceae: Leptospermoidaea). Environ Entomol 36:569–576
12. Clement SL, Cristofaro M (1995) Open-field tests in host-specificity determination of insects for biological control of weeds. Biocontrol Sci Technol 5:395–406
13. Cofrancesco AF, Shearer JF (2004) Technical Advisory Group for Biological Control Agents of Weeds. Pages 38–41 in Coombs EM, Clark JK, Piper GL, Cofrancesco AF, eds. Biological Control of Invasive Plants in the United States. Corvallis, OR: Oregon State University Press
14. Corrigan JE, Mackenzie DL, Simser L (1998) Field observations of nontarget feeding by Galerucella calmariensis (Coleoptera: Chrysomelidae), an introduced biological control agent of purple loosestrife, Lythrum salicaria (Lythraceae). Pages 99–106 in Proceedings of the Entomological Society of Ontario Vol. 129. Guelph, Ontario: Entomological Society of Ontario
15. Cristofaro M, De Biase A, Smith L (2013) Field release of a prospective biological control agent of weeds, Ceratapion basicorne, to evaluate potential risk to a nontarget crop. Biol Control 64:305–314
16. Cullen JM, Delfosse ES (1985) Echium plantigineum: catalyst for conflict and change in Australia. Pages 249–292 in Proceedings of the VI International Symposium on Biological Control of Weeds. Ottawa, Canada: Agriculture Canada
17. Currie GA, Garthside S (1932) The possibility of the entomological control of St. John’s Wort in Australia. Melbourne, Australia: Progress Rep. Council for Scientific and Industrial Research 29. 28 p
18. DeBach P, Rosen D (1991) Biological control by natural enemies. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press. 211 p
19. De Clerck-Floate RA, Harris P (2002) Linaria dalmatica (L.) Miller, Dalmatian toadflax (Scrophulariaceae) Pages 368–374 in Mason PG, Huber JT, eds. Biological Control Programmes in Canada, 1981–2000. Wallingford, UK: CABI Publishing
20. Diaz R, Manrique V, Hibbard K, Fox AM, Roda A, Gandolfo D, McKay F, Medal J, Hight S, Overholt WA (2014) Successful biological control of tropical soda apple (Solanales: Solanaceae) in Florida: a review of key program components. Fla Entomol 1: 179–190
21. Dudley TL, Kazmer DJ (2005) Field assessment of the risk posed by Diohabda elongata, a biocontrol agent for control of saltcedar (Tamarix spp.), to a nontarget plant Frankenia salina. Biol Control 35:265–275
22. Fernández-Mazuecos M, Blanco-Pastor J, Vargas P (2013) A phylogeny of toadflaxes (Linaria Mill.) based on nuclear internal transcribed spacer sequences: systematic and evolutionary consequences. Int J Plant Sci 174:234–249
23. Fowler SV, Gourlay AH, Hill RH, Withers T (2004) Safety in New Zealand weed biocontrol: a retrospective analysis of host-specificity testing and the predictability of impacts on non-target plants. Pages 265–270 in Proceedings of the XI International Symposium on Biological Control of Weeds. Canberra, Australia: CSIRO Entomology
24. Frye MJ, Lake EC, Hough-Goldstein J (2010) Field host-specificity of the mile-a-minute weevil, Rhinoncomimus latipes Korotyaev (Coleoptera: Curculionidae). Biol Control 55:234–240
25. Gandolfo D, McKay F, Medal JC, Cuda JP (2007) Open-field host specificity test of Gratiana boliviana (Coleoptera: Chrysomelidae), a biological control agent of tropical soda apple (Solanaceae) in the United States. Fla Entomol 90:223–228
26. Gaskin JF, Bon MC, Cock MJW, Cristofaro M, De Biase A, De Clerck-Floate R, Ellison CA, Hinz HL, Hufbauer RA, Julien MH, Sforza R (2011) Applying molecular-based approaches to classical biological control of weeds. Biol Control 58:1–21
27. Gassmann A, Louda SM (2001) Rhinocyllus conicus: initial evaluation and subsequent ecological impacts in North America. Pages 147–183 in Wajnberg E, Scott JK, Quimby PC, eds. Evaluating Indirect Ecological Effects of Biological Control. Wallingford, UK: CABI Publishing
28. Gassmann A, Toševski I, Speiwak E, Heinlein G, Rechner H, Yaworski K, Thalmann M (2002) Biological Control of Toadflaxes, Linaria spp. Annual Report 2001. Delémont, Switzerland: CABI Bioscience Switzerland Centre. 15 p
29. Groenteman R, Fowler SV, Sullivan JJ (2011) St. John’s wort beetles would not have been introduced to New Zealand now: a retrospective host range test of New Zealand’s most successful weed biocontrol agents. Biol Control 57:50–58
30. Hill R, Campbell D, Hayes L, Corin S, Fowler S (2013) Why the New Zealand regulatory system for introducing new biological control agents works. Pages 75–83 in Proceedings of the XIII International Symposium on Biological Control of Weeds. Morgantown, West Virginia: USDA Forest Service Forest Health Technology Enterprise Team
31. Holloway JK (1948) Biological control of Klamath weed. Progress report. Econ Entomol 41:56–57
32. Huffaker CB (1967) A comparison of the status of biological weed control of St. Johnswort in California and Australia. Mushi 39(suppl.):51–73
33. Huffaker CB, Kennett CE (1959) A ten-year study of vegetational changes associated with biological control of Klamath weed. J Range Manag 12:69–82
34. Jeanneret P, Schroeder D (1992) Biology and host specificity of Mecinus janthinus Germar (Col.: Curculionidae), a candidate for the biological control of yellow and Dalmatian toadflax, Linaria vulgaris (L.) Mill. and Linaria dalmatica (L.) Mill. (Scrophulariaceae) in North America. Biocontrol Sci Technol 2:25–34
35. Jensen KIN, Harris P, Sampson MG (2002) Hypericum perforatum L., St John’s wort (Clusiaceae). Pages 361–368 in Mason PG, Huber JT, eds. Biological Control Programmes in Canada, 1981–2000. Wallingford, UK: CABI Publishing
36. Julien MH, Griffiths MW (1998) Biological Control of Weeds. A World Catalogue of Agents and their Target Weeds. 4th edn. Wallingford, UK: CAB International. 223 p
37. Kok LT, McAvoy TJ, Malecki RA, Hight SD, Drea JJ, Coulson JR (1992) Host specificity tests of Galerucella calmariensis (L.) and G. pusilla (Duft.) (Coleoptera: Chrysomelidae), potential biological control agents of purple loosestrife, Lythrum salicaria L. (Lythraceae). Biol Control 2:282–290
38. Landis DA, Sebolt DC, Haas MJ, Klepinger M (2003) Establishment and impact of Galerucella calmariensis L. (Coleoptera: Chrysomelidae) on Lythrum salicaria L. and associated plant communities in Michigan. Biol Control 28:78–91
39. Lindgren CJ, Corrigan J, De Clerck-Floate RA (2002) Lythrum salicaria L., purple loosestrife (Lythraceae). Pages 383–390 in Mason PG, Huber JT, eds. Biological Control Programmes in Canada, 1981–2000. Wallingford, UK: CABI Publishing
40. Littlefield JL (2004) Bindweeds. Pages 150–151 in Coombs EM, Clark JK, Piper GL, Cofrancesco AF Jr, eds. Biological Control of Invasive Plants in the United States. Corvallis, Oregon: Oregon State University Press
41. Louda SM, Rand TA, Arnett AE, McClay AS, Shea K, McEachern AK (2005a) Evaluation of ecological risk to populations of a threatened plant from an invasive biocontrol insect. Ecol Appl 15:234–249
42. Louda SM, Rand TA, Russell FL, Arnett AE (2005b) Assessment of ecological risks in weed biocontrol: input from retrospective ecological analyses. Biol. Control 35:253–264
43. McClay AS, De Clerck-Floate RA (2002a) Convolvulus arvensis L., field bindweed (Convolvulaceae). Pages 331–337 in Mason PG, Huber JT, eds. Biological Control Programmes in Canada, 1981–2000. Wallingford, UK: CABI Publishing
44. McClay AS, De Clerck-Floate RA (2002b) Linaria vulgaris Miller, Yellow Toadflax (Scrophulariaceae). Pages 375–382 in Mason PG, Huber JT, eds. Biological Control Programmes in Canada, 1981–2000. Wallingford, UK: CABI Publishing
45. McClay AS, De Clerck-Floate RA (2013) Convolvulus arvensis L., field bindweed (Convolvulaceae). Pages 307–309 in Mason PG, Gillespie DR, eds. Biological Control Programmes in Canada, 2001–2012. Wallingford, UK: CABI Publishing
46. McFadyen REC (1998) Biological control of weeds. Ann Review Entomol 43:369–393
47. McFadyen RE, Vitelli M, Setter C (2002) Host specificity of the rubber vine moth, Euclasta whalleyi Popescu-Gorj and Constantinescu (Lepidoptera: Crambidae: Pyraustinae): field host-range compared to that predicted by laboratory tests. Aust J Entomol 41:321–323
48. Medal J, Bustamante N, Vitorino M, Beal L, Overholt W, Diaz R, Cuda J (2010) Host specificity tests of Gratiana graminea (Coleoptera: Chrysomelidae), a potential biological control agent of tropical soda apple, Solanum viarum (Solanaceae). Fla Entomol 93:231–242
49. Medal JC, Cuda JP (2010) Establishment and initial impact of the leaf-beetle Gratiana boliviana (Chrysomelidae), first biocontrol agent released against tropical soda apple in Florida. Fla Entomol 93: 493–500
50. Medal J, Overholt WA, Stansly P, Roda A, Osborne L, Hibbard K, Gaskalla R, Burns E, Chong J, Sellers B, Hight SD, Cuda JP, Vitorino M, Bredow E, Pedrosa-Macedo JH, Wikler C (2008) Establishment, spread and initial impacts of Gratiana boliviana (Chrysomelidae) on Solanum viarum in Florida. Pages 389–393 in Proceedings of the XII International Symposium on Biological Control of Weeds. Wallingford, UK: CABI International
51. Medal JC, Pitelli RA, Santana A, Gandolfo D, Gravena R, Habeck DH (1999) Host specificity of Metriona elatior, a potential biological control agent of tropical soda apple, Solanum viarum, in the USA. BioControl 44:421–436
52. Medal JC, Sudbrink D, Gandolfo D, Ohashi D, Cuda JP (2002) Gratiana boliviana, a potential biocontrol agent of Solanum viarum: quarantine host-specificity testing in Florida and field surveys in South America. BioControl 47:445–461
53. Miller ML, Aplet GH (2005) Applying legal sunshine to the hidden regulation of biological control. Biol Control 35:358–365
54. Mullahey JJ, Mislevy P, Brown WF, Kline WN (1996) Tropical soda apple, an exotic weed threatening agriculture and natural systems. Dow Elanco. Down to Earth Vol. 51, No. 1. 8 p
55. Mullahey JJ, Nee M, Wunderlin RP, Delaney KR (1993) Tropical soda apple (Solanum viarum): a new weed threat in subtropical regions. Weed Technol 7:783–786
56. Nowierski RM (2004) Toadflax. Pages 379–395 in Coombs EM, Clark JK, Piper GL, Cofrancesco AF Jr, eds. Biological Control of Invasive Plants in the United States. Corvallis, Oregon: Oregon State University Press
57. Overholt WA, Diaz R, Hibbard K, Roda A, Amalin D, Fox A, Hight SD, Medal J, Stansly P, Carlisle B, Walter J, Hogue P, Gary L, Wiggins L, Kirby C, Crawford S (2009) Releases, distribution and abundance of Gratiana boliviana (Coleoptera: Chrysomelidae), a biological control agent for tropical soda apple (Solanum viarum, Solanaceae), in Florida. Fla Entomol 92:450–457
58. Overholt WA, Diaz R, Markle L, Medal JC (2010) The effect of Gratiana boliviana (Coleoptera: Chrysomelidae) herbivory on growth and population density of tropical soda apple (Solanum viarum) in Florida. Biocontrol Sci Technol 20:791–807
59. Paynter Q, Fowler SV, Gourlay AH, Haines ML, Harman HM, Hona SR, Peterson PG, Smith LA, Wilson-Davey JRA, Winks CJ, Withers TM (2004) Safety in New Zealand weed biocontrol: a nationwide survey for impacts on non-target plants. NZ Plant Protect 57: 102–107
60. Pemberton RW (2000) Predictable risk to native plants in weed biological control. Oecologia 125:489–494
61. Piper GL (2004) St. Johnswort. Pages 322–334 in Coombs EM, Clark JK, Piper GL, Cofrancesco AF Jr, eds. Biological Control of Invasive Plants in the United States. Corvallis, Oregon: Oregon State University Press
62. Piper GL, Coombs EM, Blossey B, McEvoy PB, Schooler SS (2004) Purple loosestrife. Pages 281–292 in Coombs EM, Clark JK, Piper GL, Cofrancesco AF Jr, eds. Biological Control of Invasive Plants in the United States. Corvallis, Oregon: Oregon State University Press
63. Pratt PD, Rayamajhi MB, Center TD, Tipping PW, Wheeler GS (2009) The ecological host range of an intentionally introduced herbivore: a comparison of predicted versus actual host use. Biol. Control 49:146–153
64. Rector BG, De Biase A, Cristofaro M, Primerano S, Belvedere S, Antonini G, Sobhian R (2010) DNA Fingerprinting to improve data collection efficiency and yield in an open-field host-specificity test of a weed biological control candidate. Invasive Plant Sci Manag 3: 429–439
65. Rosenthal SS, Platts BE (1990) Host specificity of Aceria (Eriophyes) malherbe, [Acari: Eriophyidae], a biological control agent for the weed, Convolvulus arvensis [Convolvulaceae]. Entomophaga 35:459–463
66. Salaudeen T, Thomas M, Harding D (2012) II. Economics of tropical soda apple in Florida. Pages 10–19 in Medal J, Overholt W, Charudattan R, Mullahey J, Gaskalla R, Díaz R, Cuda J, eds. Tropical Soda Apple Management Plan. Gainesville, FL: University of Florida-IFAS. Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services-DPI. 87 p
67. Schaffner U (2001) Host range testing of insects for biological weed control: how can it be better interpreted? BioScience 51:951–959
68. Schat M, Sing SE, Peterson RKD, Menalled FD, Weaver DK (2011) Growth inhibition of Dalmatian toadflax, Linaria dalmatica (L.) Miller, in response to herbivory by the biological control agent Mecinus janthinus Germar. J Entomol Sci 46:232–246
69. Schooler SS, Coombs EM, McEvoy P (2003) Nontarget effects on crepe myrtle by Galerucella pusilla and G. calmariensis (Chrysomelidae), used for biological control of purple loosestrife (Lythrum salicaria). Weed Sci 51:449–455
70. Sheppard AW, Hill R, DeClerck-Floate RA, McClay A, Olckers T, Quimby PC Jr, Zimmermann HG (2003) A global review of risk-benefit-cost analysis for the introduction of classical biological control agents against weeds: a crisis in the making? Biocontrol News Inf 24: 91N–108N
71. Sheppard AW, van Klinken RD, Heard TA (2005) Scientific advances in the analysis of direct risks of weed biological control agents to nontarget plants. Biol Control 35:215–226
72. Smith JM (1958) Biological control of Klamath weed, Hypericum perforatum L., in British Columbia. Pages 561–565 in Proceedings of the 10th International Congress of Entomology. Ottawa, Canada: Mortimer
73. Smith L (2007) Physiological host range of Ceratapion basicorne, a prospective biological control agent of Centaurea solsticialis (Asteraceae). Biological Control 41:120–133
74. Smith L, de Lillo E, Amrine JW Jr (2010) Effectiveness of eriophyid mites for biological control of weedy plants and challenges for future research. Exp Appl Acarol 51:115–149
75. Smith L, Hayat R, Cristofaro M, Tronci C, Tozlu G, Lecce F (2006) Assessment of risk of attack to safflower by Ceratapion basicorne (Coleoptera: Apionidae), a prospective biological control agent of Centaurea solstitialis (Asteraceae). Biol Control 36:337–344
76. Suckling DM, Sforza RFH (2014) What magnitude are observed nontarget impacts from weed biocontrol? PLOS ONE 9:1–12
77. Taylor DBJ, Heard TA, Paynter Q, Spafford H (2007) Nontarget effects of a weed biological control agent on a native plant in Northern Australia. Biol Control 42:25–33
78. Toševski I, Caldara R, Jović J, Hernandez-Vera G, Baviera C, Gassmann A, Emerson BC (2011) Morphological, molecular and biological evidence reveal two cryptic species in Mecinus janthinus Germar (Coleoptera, Curculionidae), a successful biological control agent of Dalmatian toadflax, Linaria dalmatica (Lamiales, Plantaginaceae). Syst Entomol 36:741–753
79. Toševski I, Mitrović M, Krstić O, Jović J, Gassmann A (2012) Biological Control of Dalmatian and Yellow Toadflaxes (Linaria dalmatica and L. vulgaris). Annual Report 2011. Delémont, Switzerland: CABI Bioscience Switzerland Centre. 69 p
80. st Edition.
81. USDA APHIS (2014) Technical Advisory Group for Biological Control Agents of Weeds TAG Petitions – APHIS Actions. http://www.aphis.usda.gov/plant_health/permits/tag/downloads/TAGPetitionAction.pdf. Accessed: November 13, 2014
82. Van Hezewijk BH, Bourchier RS, De Clerck-Floate RA (2010) Regional-scale impact of the weed biocontrol agent Mecinus janthinus on Dalmatian toadflax (Linaria dalmatica). Biol Control 55:197–202
83. Van Klinken RD, Edwards OR (2002) Is host-specificity of weed biological control agents likely to evolve rapidly following establishment? Ecol Lett 5:590–596
84. Van Wilgen BW, Moran VB, Hoffmann JH (2013) Some perspectives on the risks and benefits of biological control of invasive alien plants in the management of natural ecosystems. Environ Manag 52: 531–540
85. Villegas B (2009) Biological control of Dalmatian toadflax in California. Pages 59–60 in Woods DM, ed. Biological Control Program 2008 Annual Summary. Sacramento, California: California Department of Food and Agriculture Plant Health and Pest Prevention Services
86. Villegas B, Gibbs C, Donnelly J (2011) A case of fortuitous biological control of Dalmatian toadflax in Susanville. Pages 64–66 in Woods DM, ed. Biological Control Program 2010 Annual Summary. Sacramento, California: California Department of Food and Agriculture Plant Health and Pest Prevention Services
87. Wagner V, Nelson CR (2014) Herbicides can negatively affect seed performance in native plants. Restor Ecol 22:288–291
88. Waipara N, Barton J, Smith LA, Harman HM, Winks C, Massey B, Wilkie JP, Gianotti A, Cripps MG (2009) Safety in New Zealand weed biocontrol: a nationwide pathogen survey for impacts on nontarget plants. NZ Plant Protect 62:41–49
89. Wapshere AJ (1989) A testing sequence for reducing rejection of potential biological control agents for weeds. Ann Appl Biol 114: 515–526
90. Ward SM, Fleischmann CE, Turner MF, Sing SE (2009) Hybridization between invasive populations of Dalmatian toadflax (Linaria dalmatica) and yellow toadflax (Linaria vulgaris). Invasive Plant Sci Manag 2:369–378
91. Weed AS, Schwarzländer M (2014) Density dependence, precipitation and biological control agent herbivory influence landscape-scale dynamics of the invasive Eurasian plant Linaria dalmatica. J Appl Ecol 51:825–834
92. Willis AJ, Berentson PR, Ash JE (2003) Impacts of a weed biocontrol agent on recovery from water stress in a target and non-target Hypericum species. J Appl Ecol 40:320–333
93. Winston RL, Schwarzländer M, Hinz HL, Day MD, Cock MJW, Julien MH (in press) Biological Control of Weeds: A World Catalogue of Agents and their Target Weeds. 5th edn. MorgantownWest Virginia: USDA Forest Service, Forest Health Technology Enterprise Team. FHTET-2014-XX. 223 p
94. Wilson LM, Sing SE, Piper GL, Hansen RW, De Clerck-Floate RA, MacKinnon DK, Randall C (2005) Biology and biological control of Dalmatian and yellow toadflax. Morgantown, West Virginia: USDA Forest Service, Forest Health Technology Enterprise Team-05-13. 116 p
95. Zimmermann HG, Moran VC, Hoffmann JH (2000) The renowned cactus moth, Cactoblastis cactorum: its natural history and threat to native Opuntia floras in Mexico and the United States of America. Divers Distrib 6:259–269
96. Zwölfer H (1967) The Host Range, Distribution, and Life-History of Rhinocyllus conicus Fröl. (Col, Curculionidae). Progress Report. Delémont, Switerland: CAB International Institute of Biological Control. 18 p