Some perspectives on the risks and benefits of biological control of invasive alien plants in the management of natural ecosystems

Environmental Management

Volumn 52, Issue 3, 2013, Pages 531-540

  Van Wilgen, B W ^a,b   Moran, V C ^c   Hoffmann, J H ^c  

^a DSI CSIR Nanotechnology Innovation Centre   (South Africa)

^b STELLENBOSCH UNIVERSITY   (South Africa)

^c UNIVERSITY OF CAPE TOWN   (South Africa)

Author keywords

Biodiversity; Environmental conservation; Weed biocontrol

Indexed keywords

BIOLOGICAL CONTROL AGENT; DEGRADED ECOSYSTEMS; ECOSYSTEM DEGRADATION; ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERVATION; ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGERS; INVASIVE PLANT CONTROL; MANAGEMENT STRATEGIES; REGULATORY ENVIRONMENT;

BIODIVERSITY; ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT; RESTORATION; WEED CONTROL;

ECOSYSTEMS;

BIODIVERSITY; BIOLOGICAL CONTROL; BIOLOGICAL INVASION; CONSERVATION MANAGEMENT; ECOSYSTEM MANAGEMENT; ENVIRONMENTAL DEGRADATION; ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT; ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING; ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION; STRATEGIC APPROACH; WEED CONTROL;

BIOLOGICAL PEST CONTROL; CONSERVATION BIOLOGY; CROP MANAGEMENT; ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT; ENVIRONMENTAL SUSTAINABILITY; INTRODUCED SPECIES; INVASIVE SPECIES; NONHUMAN; PLANT COMMUNITY; REVIEW; RISK ASSESSMENT; RISK BENEFIT ANALYSIS; SAFETY; WEED;

INTRODUCED SPECIES; PEST CONTROL, BIOLOGICAL; PLANT WEEDS; RISK ASSESSMENT;

EID: 84883446273     PISSN: 0364152X     EISSN: 14321009     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1007/s00267-013-0099-4     Document Type: Review

References (106)

1. Abdoun H (2012) Albert Koebele (1853-1924). Biographical sketch by Hany Abdoun, Archives Intern, California Academy of Sciences. http://researcharchive. calacademy.org/research/library/special/bios/Koebele.pdf. Accessed 8 June 2013
2. Andres LA, Davis CJ, Harris P, Wapshere AJ (1976) Biological control of weeds. In: Huffaker CB, Messenger PS (eds) Theory and practice of biological control. Academic Press, New York, pp 481-499
3. Anon (2000) The CRC for weed management systems. An impact assessment. Centre for International Economics, Canberra
4. Baranyovits FLC (1978) Cochineal carmine: an ancient dye with a modern role. Endeavour 2:85-92
5. Barton J (2012) Predictability of pathogen host range in classical biological control of weeds: an update. Biol Control 57:289-305
6. Bennett FD, Habeck DH (1995) Cactoblastis cactorum: a successful weed control agent in the Caribbean, now a pest in Florida? In: Delfosse ES, Scott RR (eds) Proceedings of the VII international symposium on biological control of weeds. 1992. CSIRO, Melbourne, pp 21-26
7. Blossey B, Schroeder D, Hight SD, Malecki RA (1994) Host specificity and environmental impact of two leaf beetles (Galerucella calmariensis and G. pusilla) for biological control of purple loosestrife (Lythrum salicaria). Weed Sci 42:134-140
8. Coombs EM, Radtke H, Isaacson DL, Snyder SP (1996) Economic and regional benefits from the biological control of tansy ragwort, Senecio jacobaea, in Oregon. In: Moran VC, Hoffmann JH (eds) Proceedings of the IX international symposium on biological control of weeds. 1996. University of Cape Town, South Africa, pp 489-494
9. Coombs EM, Clark JK, Piper GL, Cofrancesco A (eds) (2004) Biological control of invasive plants in the United States. Oregon State University Press, Corvallis
10. Crawley MJ (1989) Insect herbivores and plant population dynamics. Annu Rev Entomol 34:531-564
11. De Lange WJ, van Wilgen BW (2010) An economic assessment of the contribution of weed biological control to the management of invasive alien plants and to the protection of ecosystem services in South Africa. Biol Invasions 12:4113-4124
12. De Wit M, Crookes D, van Wilgen BW (2001) Conflicts of interest in environmental management: estimating the costs and benefits of a tree invasion. Biol Invasions 3:167-178
13. DeBach P, Bartlett BR (1964) Methods of colonization, recovery and evaluation. In: DeBach P, Schlinger EI (eds) Biological control of insect pests and weeds. Chapman and Hall, London, pp 402-426
14. DeBach P, Schlinger EI (eds) (1964) Biological control of insect pests and weeds. Chapman and Hall, London
15. Dhileepan K, Treviño M, Raghu S (2006) Temporal patterns in incidence and abundance of Aconophora compressa (Hemiptera: Membracidae), a biological control agent for Lantana camara, on target and nontarget plants. Environ Entomol 35:1001-1012
16. Dodd AP (1940) The biological campaign against prickly pear. In: Commonwealth Prickly-pear Board Bulletin. Government Printer, Brisbane, Australia
17. Doutt RL (1964) The historical development of biological control. In: DeBach P, Schlinger EI (eds) Biological control of insect pests and weeds. Chapman and Hall, London, pp 21-42
18. Ehler LE (2000) Critical issues related to nontarget effects in classical biological control of insects. In: Follett PA, Duan JJ (eds) Nontarget effects of biological control. Kluwer, Boston, pp 3-13
19. Finkel AM (2011) Solution-focused risk assessment: a proposal for the fusion of environmental analysis and action. Hum Ecol Risk Assess 17:754-787
20. Finney GL, Fisher TW (1964) Culture of entomophagous insects and their hosts. In: DeBach P, Schlinger EI (eds) Biological control of insect pests and weeds. Chapman and Hall, London, pp 328-355
21. Follett PA, Duan JJ (eds) (2000) Nontarget effects of biological control. Kluwer, Boston
22. Fowler SV, Paynter Q, Dodd S, Groenteman R (2012) How can ecologists help practitioners minimise non-target effects in weed biocontrol? J Appl Ecol 49:307-310
23. Gassmann A, Louda SM (2001) Rhinocyllus conicus; initial evaluation and subsequent ecological impacts in North America. In: Wajnberg E, Scott JK, Quimby PC (eds) Evaluating indirect ecological effects of biological control. CABI Publishing, Wallingford, pp 147-183
24. Goeden RD, Kok LT (1986) Comments on a proposed "new" approach for selecting agents for the biological control of weeds. Can Entomol 118:51-58
25. Green EE (1912) On the cultivated and wild forms of cochineal insects. J Econ Biol 7:79-93
26. Hobbs RJ, Arico S, Aronson J, Baron JS, Bridgewater P, Cramer VA, Epstein PR, Ewel JJ, Klink CA, Lugo AE, Norton D, Ojima D, Richardson DM, Sanderson EW, Valladares F, Vilà M, Zamora R, Zobel M (2006) Novel ecosystems: theoretical and management aspects of the new ecological world order. Global Ecol Biogeogr 15:1-7
27. Hoddle MS (2004) Restoring balance: using exotic species to control invasive exotic species. Conserv Biol 18:38-49
28. Hoffmann JH, Moran VC, van Wilgen BW (2011) Prospects for biological control of invasive Pinus species (Pinaceae) in South Africa. Afr Entomol 19:393-401
29. Hokkanen HMT, Pimentel D (1984) New associations in biological control: theory and practice. Can Entomol 121:829-840
30. Holloway JK (1964) Projects in biological control of weeds. In: DeBach P, Schlinger EI (eds) Biological control of insect pests and weeds. Chapman and Hall, London, pp 650-670
31. Huffaker CB (1959) Biological control of weeds with insects. Annu Rev Entomol 4:251-276
32. Huffaker CB (1964) Fundamentals of biological weed control. In: DeBach P, Schlinger EI (eds) Biological control of insect pests and weeds. Chapman and Hall, London, pp 631-649
33. Huffaker CB (1974) Biological control. Plenum, New York
34. Huffaker CB, Kennett CE (1959) A ten-year study of vegetational changes associated with biological control of Klamath weed. J Range Manage 12:69-82
35. Impson FAC, Kleinjan CA, Hoffmann JH, Post JA, Wood AR (2011) Biological control of Australian Acacia species and Paraserianthes lophantha (Willd.) Nielsen (Mimosaceae) in South Africa. Afr Entomol 19:186-207
36. Julien MH, Griffiths MW (1998) Biological control of weeds: a world catalogue of agents and their target weeds. CAB International, Wallingford, UK
37. Klein H (2011) A catalogue of the insects, mites and pathogens that have been used or rejected, or are under consideration, for the biological control of invasive alien plants in South Africa. Afr Entomol 19:515-549
38. Klein H, Hill MP, Zachariades C, Zimmermann HG (2011) Regulation and risk assessments for importations and releases of biological control agents against invasive alien plants in South Africa. Afr Entomol 19:488-497
39. Lever C (2001) The cane toad: the history and ecology of a successful colonist. Westbury Academic and Scientific Publishing, Otley
40. Liebherr JK, Polhemus DA (1997) Comparisons to the century before: the legacy of R. C. L. Perkins and Fauna Hawaiiensis as the basis for a long-term ecological monitoring program. Pac Sci 51:490-504
41. Lonsdale WM, Briese DT, Cullen JM (2001) Risk analysis and weed biological control. In: Wajnberg E, Scott JK, Quimby PC (eds) Evaluating indirect ecological effects of biological control. CABI Publishing, Wallingford, pp 185-210
42. Louda SM (1998) Population growth of Rhinocyllus conicus (Coleoptera: Curculionidae) on two species of native thistles in prairie. Environ Entomol 27:834-841
43. Louda SM (2000) Negative ecological effects of the musk thistle biological control agent, Rhinocyllus conicus. In: Follett PA, Duan JJ (eds) Nontarget effects of biological control. Kluwer, Boston, pp 215-243
44. Louda SM, Stiling P (2003) The double-edged sword of biological control in conservation and restoration. Conserv Biol 18:50-53
45. Louda SM, Kendall D, Connor J, Simberloff D (1997) Ecological effects of an insect introduced for the biological control of weeds. Science 277:1088-1090
46. Louda SM, Pemberton RW, Johnson MT, Follett PA (2003) Nontarget effects - the Achilles' heel of biological control? Retrospective analyses to reduce risk associated with biocontrol introductions. Annu Rev Entomol 48:365-396
47. Lounsbury CP (1915) Plant killing insects: the Indian cochineal. Agric J S Afr 1:537-543
48. Lynch LD, Hokkanen HMT, Babendreier D, Bigler F, Burgio G, Gao Z-H, Kuske S, Loomans A, Menzler-Hokkanen I, Thomas MB, Tommasini G, Waage JK, van Lenteren JC, Zeng Q-Q (2001) Insect biological control and non-target effects: a European perspective. In: Wajnberg E, Scott JK, Quimby PC (eds) Evaluating indirect ecological effects of biological control. CABI Publishing, Wallingford, pp 99-125
49. Maguire LA, Albright EA (2005) Can behavioural decision theory explain risk-averse fire management decisions? For Ecol Manage 211:47-58
50. Mann J (1969) Cactus-feeding insects and mites. Bulletin 256. United States National Museum, Washington, DC
51. Marohasy J (1998) The design and interpretation of host-specificity tests for weed biological control with particular reference to insect behaviour. Biocontrol News Inf 19:13N-20N
52. McConnachie AJ, De Wit MP, Hill MP, Byrne MJ (2003) Economic evaluation of the successful biological control of Azolla filiculoides in South Africa. Biol Control 28:25-32
53. McConnachie M, Cowling RM, van Wilgen BW, McConnachie DA (2012) Evaluating the cost-effectiveness of invasive alien plant control: a case study from South Africa. Biol Conserv 155:128-135
54. McEvoy PB (1996) Host specificity and biological pest control. Biosci 46:401-405
55. McEvoy PB, Coombs EM (2000) Why things bite back: unintentional consequences of biological control. In: Follett PA, Duan JJ (eds) Nontarget effects of biological control. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Boston, pp 167-194
56. McEvoy PB, Cox C, Coombs EM (1991) Successful biological control of ragwort, Senecio jacobaea, by introduced insects in Oregon. Ecol Appl 1:430-442
57. McFadyen REC (1998) Biological control of weeds. Annu Rev Entomol 43:363-393
58. Memmott J (2000) Food webs as a tool for studying nontarget effects in biological control. In: Follett PA, Duan JJ (eds) Nontarget effects of biological control. Kluwer, Boston, pp 147-163
59. Miller D (1936) Biological control of noxious weeds. N Z J Sci Technol 18:581-584
60. Mooney HA (2005) Invasive alien species: the nature of the problem. In: Mooney HA, Mack RN, McNeely JA, Neville LE, Schei PJ, Waage JK (eds) Invasive alien species: a new synthesis. Island Press, Washington, DC, pp 1-15
61. Moore JL, Runge MC, Webber BL, Wilson JRU (2011) Attempt to contain or eradicate? Optimising the management of Australian Acacia invasions in the face of uncertainty. Divers Distrib 17:1047-1059
62. Moran VC, Hoffmann JH (2012) Conservation of the fynbos biome in the Cape Floral Region: the role of biological control in the management of invasive alien trees. Biocontrol 57:139-149
63. Moran VC, Hoffmann JH, Zimmermann HG (2005) Biological control of invasive alien plants in South Africa: necessity, circumspection, and success. Front Ecol Environ 3:77-83
64. O'Riordan T, Cameron J (1994) Interpreting the precautionary principle. Earthscan, London
65. Obrycki JJ, Elliott NC, Giles KL (2000) Coccinellid introductions: potential for and evaluation of nontarget effects. In: Follett PA, Duan JJ (eds) Nontarget effects of biological control. Kluwer, Boston, pp 127-145
66. Page AR, Lacey KL (2006) Economic impact assessment of Australian weed biological control. Technical Series Report 10, CRC for Australian Weed Management, Adelaide, Australia
67. Peacock D, Abbott I (2010) The mongoose in Australia: failed introduction of a biological control agent. Aust J Zool 58:205-227
68. Pearson DE, Callaway RM (2003) Indirect effects of host-specific biological control agents. Trends Ecol Evol 9:456-461
69. Pemberton RW (1995) Cactoblastis cactorum (Lepidoptera: Pyralidae) in the United States: an immigrant biological control agent or an introduction of the nursery industry? Am Entomol 41:230-232
70. Pemberton RW (2000) Predictable risk to native plants in weed biological control. Oecologia 125:489-494
71. Perkins RCL, Swezey OH (1924) The introduction into Hawaii of insects that attack lantana. Bulletin 19, Hawaiian Sugar Planters' Association Experimental Station, Hawaii
72. Pluess T, Vojtch J, Pysk P, Cannon R, Pergl J, Breukers A, Bacher S (2012) Which factors affect the success or failure of eradication campaigns against alien species? PLoS ONE 7:e48157
73. Post JA, Kleinjan CA, Hoffmann JH, Impson FAC (2010) Biological control of Acacia cyclops in South Africa: the fundamental and realized host range of Dasineura dielsi (Diptera: Cecidomyiidae). Biol Control 53:68-75
74. Pratt PD, Center TD (2012) Biocontrol without borders: the unintended spread of introduced weed biological control agents. Biocontrol 57:319-329
75. Rao VP, Ghani MA, Sankaran T, Mathur KC (1971) A review of biological control of insects and other pests in South-East Asia and the Pacific region. Technical Communication 6, Commonwealth Institute of Biological Control, Slough, UK
76. Rose KE, Louda SM, Rees M (2005) Demographic and evolutionary impacts of native and invasive insect herbivores: a case study with Platte thistle, Cirsium canescens. Ecology 86:453-465
77. Rose R, Weeks R, Usnick S (2011) Cactus moth, Cactoblastis cactorum 2011 survey plan for PPQ and State Cooperators. USDA-APHIS Plant Health, Plant Protection and Quarantine, Washington, DC, pp 1-18
78. Santha CR, Grant WE, Neill WH, Strawn RK (1991) Biological control of aquatic vegetation using grass carp: simulation of alternative strategies. Ecol Model 59:229-245
79. Seastedt TR, Hobbs RJ, Suding KN (2008) Management of novel ecosystems: are novel approaches required? Front Ecol Environ 6:547-553
80. Sheppard AW, Hill R, DeClerck-Floate RA, McClay A, Olckers T, Quimby PC, Zimmermann HG (2003) A global review of risk-benefit-cost analysis for the introduction of classical biological control agents against weeds: a crisis in the making? Biocontrol News Inf 24:91N-108N
81. Sheppard AW, van Klinken R, Heard T (2005) Scientific advances in the analysis of direct risks of weed biological control agents to non-target plants. Biol Control 35:215-222
82. Sheppard AW, Haines M, Thomann T (2006) Native-range research assists risk analysis for non-targets in weed biological control: the cautionary tale of the broom seed beetle. Aust J Entomol 45:292-297
83. Simberloff D (2012) Risks of biological control for conservation purposes. Biocontrol 57:263-276
84. Simberloff D, Stiling P (1996) Risks of species introduced for biological control. Biol Conserv 78:185-192
85. Spafford JH, Briese DT (2003) Improving the selection, testing and evaluation of weed biological control agents. In: Proceedings of the CRC for Australian weed management biological control of weeds symposium and workshop, 13 September 2002, University of Western Australia, Perth, Australia. Technical Series - CRC Australian Weed Manage 2003, 7:1-98
86. Stiling P, Simberloff D (2000) The frequency and strength of nontarget effects of invertebrate biological control agents of plant pests and weeds. In: Follett PA, Duan JJ (eds) Nontarget effects of biological control. Kluwer, Boston, pp 31-43
87. Strong DR, Pemberton RW (2001) Food webs, risks of alien enemies and reform of biological control. In: Wajnberg E, Scott JK, Quimby PC (eds) Evaluating indirect ecological effects of biological control. CABI Publishing, Wallingford, pp 57-80
88. Syrett P, Briese DT, Hoffmann JH (2000) Success in biological control of terrestrial weeds by arthropods. In: Gurr G, Wratten S (eds) Biological control: measures of success. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, pp 189-230
89. Tryon H (1910) The "Wild cochineal insects", with reference to its injurious action on prickly pear (Opuntia spp.) in India etc. and to its availability for the subjugation of this plant in Queensland and elsewhere. Qld Agric J 25:188-197
90. van Driesche RG (2012) The role of biological control in wildlands. Biocontrol 57:131-137
91. van Driesche RG, Carruthers RI, Center T, Hoddle MS et al (2010) Classical biological control for the protection of natural ecosystems. Biol Control 54:s2-s33
92. van Klinken RD (2000) Host specificity testing: Why do we do it and how can we do it better. pp 54-68 In: van Driesche RG, Heard TA, McClay AS, Reardon R. (eds) Proc: Host specificity testing of exotic arthropod biological agents: The biological basis for improvement in safety. X Int Symp Biol Control Weeds, July 4-14, 1999, Bozeman, Montana. USDA. Forest Service Bull, FHTET-99-1, Morgantown, West Virginia, USA
93. van Wilgen BW, de Wit MP, Anderson HJ, Le Maitre DC, Kotze IM, Ndala S, Brown B, Rapholo MB (2004) Costs and benefits of biological control of invasive alien plants: case studies from South Africa. S Afr J Sci 100:113-122
94. van Wilgen BW, Dyer C, Hoffmann JH, Ivey P, Le Maitre DC, Richardson DM, Rouget M, Wannenburgh A, Wilson JRU (2011) National-scale strategic approaches for managing introduced plants: insights from Australian acacias in South Africa. Divers Distrib 17:1060-1075
95. van Wilgen BW, Forsyth GG, Le Maitre DC, Wannenburgh A, Kotzé I, van den Berg L, Henderson L (2012) An assessment of the effectiveness of a large, national-scale invasive alien plant control strategy in South Africa. Biol Conserv 148:28-38
96. van Wyk E, van Wilgen BW (2002) The control of water hyacinth (Eichhornia crassipes): a case study approach to compare the costs of three control options in South Africa. Afr J Aquat Sci 27:141-149
97. Wajnberg E, Scott JK, Quimby PC (2001) Evaluating indirect ecological effects of biological control. CABI Publishing, Wallingford
98. Wapshere AJ (1974) A strategy for evaluating the safety of organisms for biological weed control. Ann App Biol 77:201-211
99. Warner KD (2012) Fighting pathophobia: how to construct constructive public engagement with biocontrol for nature without augmenting public fears. Biocontrol 57:307-317
100. Wilson F (1949) The entomological control of weeds. Int Union Biol Sci Series B 5:53-64
101. Wise RM, van Wilgen BW, Le Maitre DC (2012) Costs, benefits and management options for an invasive alien tree species: the case of mesquite in the Northern Cape. J of Arid Environ 84:80-90
102. Zimmermann HG, Pérez-Sandi M (2006) The consequences of introducing the cactus moth Cactoblastis cactorum, to the Caribbean and beyond. PRONATURA, FMCN, USAID, Mexico City, pp 1-63
103. Zimmermann HG, Moran VC, Hoffmann JH (2001) The renowned cactus moth, Cactoblastis cactorum: its natural history and threat to native Opuntia floras in Mexico and the United States of America. Divers Distrib 6:259-269
104. Zimmermann HG, Moran VC, Hoffmann JH (2009) Invasive cactus species (Cactaceae). In: Muniappan R, Reddy GV, Raman AA (eds) Biological control of tropical weeds using arthropods. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 108-129
105. Zwölfer H, Harris P (1984) Biology and host specificity of Rhinocyllus conicus (Froel.) (Col., Curculionidae), a successful agent for biological control of the thistle, Cardiuus nutans L. Z Angew Entomol 97:36-62
106. Zwölfer H, Zimmermann H (2004) The potential of phytophagous insects in restoring invaded ecosystems: examples from biological weed control. Ecol Stud 173:135-153