The role of guilt in the development of post-traumatic stress disorder: A systematic review

Journal of Affective Disorders

Volumn 182, Issue , 2015, Pages 138-150

  Pugh, Lauren R ^a   Taylor, Peter J ^b   Berry, Katherine ^c  

^a Salford Primary Care Trust   (United Kingdom)

^b UNIVERSITY OF LIVERPOOL   (United Kingdom)

^c UNIVERSITY OF MANCHESTER   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Appraisals; Guilt; PTSD; Responsibility; Self blame; Trauma

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; BEHAVIOR; CLINICAL PRACTICE; COGNITION; CONFOUNDING VARIABLE; DATA BASE; GUILT; HUMAN; POSTTRAUMATIC STRESS DISORDER; PRIORITY JOURNAL; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW; TREATMENT OUTCOME; CROSS-SECTIONAL STUDY; EMOTION; PSYCHOLOGY; REPRODUCIBILITY; SHAME; SOCIAL BEHAVIOR;

CROSS-SECTIONAL STUDIES; EMOTIONS; GUILT; HUMANS; REPRODUCIBILITY OF RESULTS; SHAME; SOCIAL BEHAVIOR; STRESS DISORDERS, POST-TRAUMATIC;

EID: 84929430797     PISSN: 01650327     EISSN: 15732517     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.jad.2015.04.026     Document Type: Review

References (109)

1. B. Alexander, C.R. Brewin, S. Vearnals, G. Wolff, and J. Leff An investigation of shame and guilt in a depressed sample Br. Med. J. 72 1999 323 338
2. American Psychiatric Association Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders fifth ed. 2013 APA Washington, DC
3. B. Andrews, C.R. Brewin, S. Rose, and M. Kirk Predicting PTSD symptoms in victims of violent crime: the role of shame, anger and childhood abuse J. Abnorm. Psychol. 109 2000 69 73
4. R.F. Baumeister, A.M. Stillwell, and T.F. Heatherton Guilt: an interpersonal approach Psychol. Bull. 115 1994 243 267
5. J.G. Beck, J. McNiff, J.D. Clapp, S.A. Olsen, M.L. Avery, and J.H. Hagewood Exploring negative emotion in women experiencing intimate partner violence: shame, guilt and PTSD Behav. Ther. 42 2011 740 750
6. J.C. Beckham, M.E. Feldman, and A.C. Kirby Atrocities exposure in Vietnam combat veterans with chronic posttraumatic stress disorder: relationship to combat exposure, symptom severity, guilt, and interpersonal violence J. Trauma. Stress 11 4 1998 777 785
7. E.G. Benotsch, K. Brailey, J.J. Vasterling, and M. Uddo War zone stress, personal and environmental resources, and PTSD symptoms in Gulf War veterans: a longitudinal perspective J. Abnorm. Psychol. 109 2000 205 213
8. D.D. Blake, F.W. Weathers, L.M. Nagy, D.G. Kaloupek, G. Klauminzer, D.S. Charney, and T.M. Keane A clinician rating scale for assessing current and lifetime PTSD: the CAPS-1 Behav. Ther. 13 1990 187 188
9. D.D. Blake, F.W. Weathers, L.M. Nagy, D.G. Kaloupek, F.D. Gusman, D.S. Charney, and T.M. Keane The development of a clinician-administered PTSD scale J. Trauma. Stress 8 1995 75 90
10. E.B. Blanchard, T.C. Buckley, E.J. Hickling, and A.E. Taylor Posttraumatic stress disorder and comorbid major depression: is the correlation an illusion? J. Anxiety Disord. 12 1998 21 37
11. N. Breslau, and G.C. Davis Posttraumatic stress disorder: the etiologic specificity of wartime stressors Am. J. Psychiatry 144 1987 578 583
12. C. Brewin, B. Andrews, and S. Rose Fear, helplessness and horror in posttraumatic stress disorder: investigating DSM-IV criterion 2 in victims of violent crime J. Trauma. Stress 13 3 2000 499 509
13. J. Briere Detailed Assessment of Posttraumatic Stress (DAPS) 2001 Psychological Assessment Resources Odessa, Florida
14. T. Browne, M. Evangeli, and N. Greenberg Trauma-related guilt and posttraumatic stress among journalists J. Trauma. Stress 25 2012 207 210
15. J. Burney, and H.J. Irwin Shame and guilt in women with eating disorder symptomology J. Clin. Psychol. 56 2000 51 61
16. L.A. Clark, and D.B. Watson Constructing validity: basic issues in objective scale development Psychol. Assess. 7 1995 309 319
17. M. Cloitre, B.C. Stolbach, J.L. Herman, B. Van der Kolk, R. Pynoos, and J. Wang A developmental approach to complex PTSD: childhood and adulthood cumulative trauma as predictors of symptom complexity J. Trauma. Stress 22 2009 399 408
18. H. Crisford, H. Dare, and M. Evangeli Offence-related posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) symptomatology and guilt in mentally disordered violent and sexual offenders J. Forensic Psychiatry Psychcol. 19 1 2008 86 107
19. T. Dalgleish Cognitive approaches to posttraumatic stress disorder: the evolution of multirepresentational theorizing Psychol. Bull. 130 20 2004 228 260
20. J.R.T. Davidson, S.W. Book, J.T. Colket, L.A. Tupler, S. Roth, and D. David Assessment of a new self-rating scale for posttraumatic stress disorder: the Davidson trauma scale Psychol. Med. 27 1997 153 160
21. A. Ehlers, and D.M. Clark A cognitive model of posttraumatic stress disorder Behav. Res. Ther. 38 2000 319 345
22. A. Ehlers, and R. Steil Maintenance of intrusive memories in posttraumatic stress disorder: a cognitive approach Behav. Cogn. Psychother. 23 1995 217 249
23. S.A. Falsetti, H.S. Resnick, P.A. Resick, and D.G. Kilpatrick The Modified PTSD Symptom Scale: a brief self-report measure of posttraumatic stress disorder Behav. Ther. 16 1993 161 162
24. T.J. Ferguson, and S.L. Crowley Measure for measure: a multitrait- multimethod analysis of guilt and shame J. Pers. Assess. 69 1997 425 441
25. E.B. Foa, and S.A.M. Rauch Cognitive changes during prolonged exposure verses prolonged exposure plus cognitive restructuring in female assault survivors with posttraumatic stress disorder J. Consult. Clin. Psychol. 72 2004 879 884
26. E.B. Foa, L. Cashman, L. Jaycox, and K. Perry The validation of a self-report measure of posttraumatic stress disorder: the Posttraumatic Diagnostic Scale Psychol. Assess. 9 4 1997 445 451
27. E.B. Foa, and B.O. Rothbaum Treating the Trauma of Rape: Cognitive Behavioural Therapy for PTSD 1999 Guilford Press New York, NY
28. E.B. Foa, D.S. Riggs, C.V. Dancu, and B.O. Rothbaum Reliability and validity of a brief instrument for assessing post-traumatic stress disorder J. Traum. Stress 6 1993 459 473
29. A. Fontana, and R. Rosenheck A causal model of the etiology of war related PTSD J. Trauma. Stress 6 1993 475 500
30. T. Galovski, and J.A. Lyons Psychological sequelae of combat violence: a review of the impact of PTSD on the veteran's family and possible interventions Aggress. Violent Behav. 9 2004 477 501
31. K. Ginzburg, B. Arnow, S. Hart, W. Gardener, C. Koopman, C.C. Classen, J. Giese-Davis, and D. Spiegal The abuse-related beliefs questionnaire for survivors of childhood sexual abuse Child Abuse Neglect. 30 2006 929 943
32. K. Ginzburg, L.D. Butler, J. Giese-Davis, C.E. Cavanaugh, E. Neri, and C. Koopman Shame, guilt, and posttraumatic stress disorder in adult survivors of childhood sexual abuse at risk for human immunodeficiency virus: outcomes of a randomized clinical trial of group psychotherapy treatment J. Nerv. Ment. Dis. 197 7 2009 536 542
33. H. Glover Guilt and aggression in Vietnam veterans Am. J. Soc. Psychiatry 1 1985 15 18
34. G.H. Gudjonsson, and K.K. Singh The revised Gudjonsson Blame Attribution Inventory Personal. Individ. Differ. 10 1989 67 70
35. M. Hammarberg Penn Inventory for posttraumatic stress disorder: psychometric properties Psychol. Assess. 4 1992 67 76
36. D.W. Harder Shame and guilt assessment, and relationships of shame-and guilt-proneness to psychopathology J.P. Tangney, K.W. Fischer, Self-Conscious Emotions: The Psychology of Shame, Guilt, Embarrassment and Pride 1995 Guildford Press NY 368 392
37. D.W. Harder, and D.F. Greenwald Further validation of the shame and guilt scales of the harder personal feelings questionnaire-2 Psychol. Rep. 85 1999 271 281
38. D.W. Harder, and S.J. Lewis The assessment of shame and guilt J.N. Butcher, C.D. Spielberger, Advances in Personality Assessment vol. 6 1986 Sage Beverly Hills, CA 89 114
39. M.S. Harned, K.E. Korslund, E.B. Foa, and M.M. Linehan Treating PTSD in suicidal and self-injuring women with borderline personality disorder: development and preliminary evaluation of a dialectical behavior therapy prolonged exposure protocol Behav. Res. Ther. 50 6 2012 381 386
40. L.M. Hathaway, A. Boals, and J.B. Banks PTSD symptoms and dominant emotional response to a traumatic event: an examination of DSM-IV Criterion A2 Anxiety Stress Coping 23 1 2010 119 126
41. P. Held, G.P. Owens, J.A. Schumm, K.M. Chard, and J.E. Hansel Disengagement coping as a mediator between trauma-related guilt and PTSD severity J. Trauma. Stress 24 6 2011 708 715
42. K.R. Henning, and B.C. Frueh Combat guilt and its relationship to PTSD symptoms J. Clin. Psychol. 53 8 1997 801 808
43. M.J. Horowitz, N. Wilner, and W. Alvarez Impact of event scale: a measure of subjective stress Psychosom. Med. 41 1979 209 218
44. R. Janoff-Bulman Assumptive worlds and the stress of traumatic events: applications of scheme construct Soc. Cognit. 7 1989 113 136
45. W.H. Jones, A.K. Schratter, and K. Kugler The guilt inventory Psychol. Rep. 87 2000 1039 1042
46. T.M. Keane, J.M. Caddell, and K.L. Taylor Mississippi Scale for combat-related posttraumatic stress disorder: three studies in reliability and validity J. Consult. Clin. Psychol. 56 1988 85 90
47. T.M. Keane, L.C. Kolb, D.G. Kaloupek, S.P. Orr, E.B. Blanchard, and R.G. Thomas Utility of psychophysiological measurement in the diagnosis of posttraumatic stress disorder: results from a department of Veterans affairs cooperative study J. Consult. Clin. Psychcol. 66 6 1998 914 923
48. R. Kessler Post-traumatic stress disorder: the burden to the individual and to society J. Clin. Psychiatry 61 2000 4 12
49. R.C. Kessler, W.T. Chiu, O. Demler, and E.E. Walters Prevalence, severity, and comorbidity of 12-month DSM-IV disorders in the national comorbidity survey replication Arch. Gen. Psychiatry 62 2005 617 627
50. E.S. Kubany, F.R. Abueg, W.L. Kilauano, F.P. Manke, and A.S. Kaplan Development and validation of the sources of trauma-related guilt survey - war-zone version J. Trauma. Stress 10 2 1997 235 258
51. E.S. Kubany, F.R. Abueg, J.A. Owens, J.M. Brennan, A.S. Kaplan, and S.B. Watson Initial examination of a multidimensional model of trauma-related guilt: applications to combat veterans and battered women J. Psychopathol. Behav. Assess. 17 4 1995 353 375
52. E.S. Kubany, S.N. Haynes, F.R. Abueg, F.P. Manke, J.M. Brennan, and C. Stahura Development and validation of the trauma-related guilt inventory (TRGI) Psychol. Assess. 8 4 1996 428 444
53. E.S. Kubany, E.E. Hill, and J.A. Owens Cognitive trauma therapy for battered women with PTSD: preliminary findings J. Trauma. Stress 16 1 2003 81 91
54. E.S. Kubany, E.E. Hill, J.A. Owens, C. Iannce-Spencer, M.A. McCaig, K.J. Tremayne, and P.L. Williams Cognitive trauma therapy for battered women with PTSD (CTT-BW) J. Consult. Clin. Psychol. 72 1 2004 3 18
55. Kubany E. S., Owens J. A., Leigh J., 1998. The Sources of Trauma- Related Guilt Survey - Partner Abuse Version (STRGS-PA), Unpublished survey.
56. E.S. Kubany Kubany, and F.P. Manke Cognitive therapy for trauma-related guilt: conceptual bases and treatment outlines Cogn. Behav. Pract. 2 1995 23 61
57. E.S. Kubany, M.B. Leisen, A.S. Kaplan, and M.P. Kelly Validation of a brief measure of posttraumatic stress disorder: the Distressing Event Questionnaire (DEQ) Psychol. Assess. 12 2000 197 209
58. E.S. Kubany, and S.B. Watson Guilt: elaboration of multidimensional model Psychol. Rec. 53 2003 51 90
59. K. Kugler, and W.H. Jones On conceptualizing and assessing guilt J. Pers. Soc. Psychol. 62 1992 318 327
60. D. Lauterbach, S. Vrana, D.W. King, and L.A. King Psychometric properties of the civilian version of the PTSD Mississippi scale J. Trauma. Stress 10 3 1997 499 513
61. Laufer R. S., Yager T., Frey-Wouters E., Donnellan J., 1981. Legacies of Vietnam: Vol. III. Post-war Trauma: Social and Psychological Problems of Vietnam Veterans and Their Peers, US Government Printing Office, Washington, DC.
62. D.A. Lee, P. Scragg, and S. Turner The role of shame and guilt in traumatic events: a clinical model of shame-based and guilt-based PTSD Br. J. Med. Psychol. 74 2001 451 466
63. J. Leskela, M. Dieperink, and P. Thuras Shame and posttraumatic stress disorder J. Trauma. Stress 15 3 2002 223 226
64. H. Littleton, S. Horsley, S. John, and D.V. Nelson Trauma coping strategies and psychological distress: a meta-analysis J. Trauma. Stress 20 2007 977 988
65. T. Lowinger, and Z. Solomon PTSD, guilt, and shame among reckless drivers J. Loss Trauma 9 2004 327 344
66. P. Luyten, J.R.J. Fontaine, and J. Corveleyn Does the test of self-conscious affect (TOSCA) measure maladaptive aspects of guilt and adaptive aspects of shame? An empirical investigation Pers. Indiv. Differ. 33 8 2002 1373 1387
67. B.P. Marx, K.M. Foley, B.A. Feinstein, E.J. Wolf, D.G. Kaloupek, and T.M. Keane Combat-related guilt mediates the relations between exposure to combat-related abusive violence and psychiatric diagnoses Depress. Anxiety 27 2010 287 293
68. R.F. Mollica, Y. Caspi-Yavin, P. Bollini, T. Truong, S. Tor, and J. Lavelle Validating a cross-cultural instrument for measuring torture, trauma, and posttraumatic stress disorder in Indochinese refugees J. Nerv. Ment. Dis. 180 1992 111 116
69. E.R. Niler, and S.J. Beck The relationship among guilt, dysphoria, anxiety and obsessions in a normal population Behav. Res. Ther. 27 1989 213 220
70. G.P. Owens, K.M. Chard, and T.A. Cox The relationship between maladaptive cognitions, anger expression, and posttraumatic stress disorder among veterans in residential treatment J. Adv. Manuf. Technol. 17 4 2008 439 452
71. G.P. Owens, M.F. Steger, A.A. Whitesell, and C.J. Herrera Posttraumatic stress disorder, guilt, depression, and meaning in life among military veterans J. Trauma. Stress 22 6 2009 654 657
72. E.J. Ozer, S.R. Best, T.L. Lipsey, and D.R. Weiss Predictors of posttraumatic stress disorder and symptoms in adults: a meta-analysis Psychol. Bull. 129 2003 52 73
73. J.E. Palmier-Claus, I. Myin-Germeys, E. Barkus, L. Bentley, A. Udachina, and P.A. Delespaul Experience sampling research in individuals with mental illness: reflections and guidance Acta Psychiatr. Scand. 123 1 2011 12 20
74. M. Panagioti, P.A. Gooding, and N. Tarrier A meta-analysis of the association between posttraumatic stress disorder and suicidality: the role of comorbid depression Compr. Psychiatry 53 2012 915 930
75. N. Pereda, M. Arch, M. Peró, J. Guàrdia, and M. Forns Assessing guilt after traumatic events: the Spanish adaptation of the trauma-related guilt inventory Eur. J. Psychol. Assess. 27 4 2011 251 257
76. R.K. Pitman, B. Altman, E. Greenwald, R.E. Longpre, M.M. Macklin, and R.E. Poire Psychiatric complications during flooding therapy for posttraumatic stress disorder J. Clin. Psychiatry 52 1 1991 17 20
77. M.J. Power, and C. Fyvie The role of emotion in PTSD: two preliminary studies Behav. Cogn. Psychother. 41 2 2013 162 172
78. P.A. Resick, P. Nishith, T.L. Weaver, M.C. Astin, and C.A. Feuer A comparison of cognitive-processing therapy with prolonged exposure and a waiting condition for the treatment of chronic posttraumatic stress disorder in female rape victims J. Consult. Clin. Psychol. 70 4 2002 867 879
79. P.A. Resick, M.O.B. Uhlmansiek, G.A. Clum, T.E. Galovski, C.D. Scher, and Y. Young-Xu A randomized clinical control trial to dismantle components of cognitive processing therapy for posttraumatic stress disorder in female victims of interpersonal violence J. Consult. Clin. Psychol. 76 2 2008 243 258
80. D.J. Robinaugh, and R.J. McNally Autobiographical memory for shame or guilt provoking events: association with psychological symptoms Behav. Res. Ther. 48 2010 646 652
81. N. Rüsch, P.W. Corrigan, M. Bohus, T. Kühler, G.A. Jacob, and K. Lieb The impact of posttraumatic stress disorder on dysfunctional implicit and explicit emotions among women with borderline personality disorder J. Nerv. Ment. Dis. 195 6 2007 537 539
82. J. Sareen, B.J. Cox, R.D. Goodwin, and G.J.G. Asmundson Co-occurrence of posttraumatic stress disorder with positive psychotic symptoms in a nationally representative sample J. Trauma. Stress 18 2005 313 322
83. O. Semb, L.J. Strömsten, E. Sundbom, P. Fransson, and M. Henningsson Distress after a single violent crime: how shame-proneness and event-related shame work together as risk factors for post-victimization symptoms Psychol. Rep. 109 1 2011 3 23
84. L.J. Shapiro, and S.E. Stewart Pathological guilt: a persistent yet overlooked treatment factor in obsessive-compulsive disorder Ann. Clin. Psychiatry 23 1 2011 63 70
85. Sheehan D. V., Lecrubier Y., Sheehan K.H., Amorim P., Janavs J., Weiller E.,Dunbar G.C., 1998. The Mini-International Neuropsychiatric Interview (MINI): the development and validation of a structured diagnostic psychiatric interview for DSM-IV and ICD-10, J. Clin. Psychiatr., 59 (Suppl. 20), 22-33.
86. M. Silfver Coping with guilt and shame: a narrative approach J. Moral Educ. 36 2 2007 169 183
87. E.A. Skinner, K. Edge, J. Altman, and H. Sherwood Searching for the structure of coping: a review and critique of category systems for classifying ways of coping Psychol. Bull. 129 2003 216 269
88. M.C. Smith-Fawsi, T. Pham, L. Lin, T.V. Nguyen, D. Ngo, E. Murphy, and R.F. Mollica The validity of posttraumatic stress disorder among Vietnamese refugees J. Trauma. Stress 10 1997 101 108
89. M. Startup, L. Makgekgenene, and R. Webster The role of self-blame for trauma as assessed by the Posttraumatic Cognitions Inventory (PTCI): a self-protective cognition? Behav. Res. Ther. 45 2 2007 395 403
90. A.E. Street, and I. Arias Psychological abuse and posttraumatic stress disorder in battered women: examining the roles of shame and guilt Violence Vict. 16 1 2001 65 78
91. A.E. Street, L.E. Gibson, and D.R. Holohan Impact of childhood traumatic events, trauma-related guilt, and avoidant coping strategies on PTSD symptoms in female survivors of domestic violence J. Trauma. Stress 18 3 2005 245 252
92. Z. Solomon, R. Benbenishty, Y. Neria, M. Abramowitz, K. Ginzburg, and A. Ohry Assessment of PTSD: validation of the revised PTSD Inventory Israel J. Psychiatr. Relat. Sci. 30 1993 110 115
93. R.L. Spitzer, J.B.W. Williams, M. Gibson, and M.D. First Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-IIIR Patient Version (SCID) 1989 State Psychiatric Institute New York, NY
94. J.P. Tangney Situational determinants of shame and guilt in young adulthood Pers. Soc. Psychol. Bull. 18 1992 199 206
95. J.P. Tangney, S.A. Burggraf, and P.E. Wagner Shame-proneness, guilt-proneness, and psychological symptoms J.P. Tangney, K.W. Fischer, Self-Conscious Emotions: The Psychology of Shame, Guilt, Embarrassment, and Pride 1995 Guilford Press NY 343 367
96. J.P. Tangney, R.S. Miller, L. Flicker, and D.H. Barlow Are shame, guilt and embarrassment distinct emotions? J. Pers. Soc. Psychol 70 1996 1256 1269
97. J.P. Tangney, R. Dearing, P. Wagner, and R. Gramzow The Test of Self-Conscious Affect-3 (TOSCA-3) 2000 George Mason University Fairfax, VA
98. J.P. Tangney, J. Stuewig, and D. Mashek Moral emotions and moral behaviour Annu. Rev. Psychol. 58 2007 345 372
99. J.P. Tangney, and R. Dearing Shame and Guilt 2002 Guilford Press New York
100. J.P. Tangney, P. Wagner, C. Fletcher, and R. Gramzow Shamed into anger? The relation of shame and guilt to anger and self-reported aggression J. Pers. Soc. Psychol. 62 1992 669 675
101. J.P. Tangney, P. Wagner, and R. Gramzow The Test of Self-Conscious Affect 1989 George Mason University Fairfax, VA
102. J.P. Tangney, P. Wagner, and R. Gramzow Proneness to shame, proneness to guilt, and psychopathology J. Abnorm. Psychol. 101 1992 469 478
103. C. Tilghman-Osborne, A.D. Cole, and J.W. Felton Definition and measurement of guilt: implications for clinical research and practice Clin. Psychol. Rev. 30 2010 536 546
104. D.L. Vreven, D.M. Gudanowski, L.A. King, and D.W. King The civilian version of the Mississippi PTSD scale: a psychometric evaluation J. Trauma. Stress 8 1995 91 109
105. Weathers F., Litz B., Herman D., Huska J. Keane T., 1993. The PTSD Checklist (PCL): reliability, validity, and diagnostic utility. Paper presented at the Annual Convention of the International Society for Traumatic Stress Studies, San Antonio, TX.
106. C. Williams, and J. Bybee What do children feel guilty about? Development and gender differences Dev. Psychol. 30 1994 617 623
107. J.P. Wilson, B. Drozdek, and S. Turkovic Posttraumatic shame and guilt Trauma Violence Abuse 7 2006 122 141
108. M.R. Wong, and D. Cook Shame and its contribution to PTSD J. Trauma. Stress 5 1992 557 562
109. R. Yehuda, S.M. Southwick, and E.L. Giller Exposure to atrocities and severity of chronic posttraumatic stress disorder in Vietnam combat veterans Am. J. Psychiatry 149 1992 333 336