'Wasteaware' benchmark indicators for integrated sustainable waste management in cities

Waste Management

Volumn 35, Issue , 2015, Pages 329-342

  Wilson, David C ^a   Rodic, Ljiljana ^b   Cowing, Michael J ^c   Velis, Costas A ^d   Whiteman, Andrew D ^e   Scheinberg, Anne ^f   Vilches, Recaredo ^a   Masterson, Darragh ^a   Stretz, Joachim ^g   Oelz, Barbara ^h  

^a IMPERIAL COLLEGE LONDON   (United Kingdom)

^b WAGENINGEN UNIVERSITY   (Netherlands)

^c Independent Consultant ^*  (Saint Lucia)

^d UNIVERSITY OF LEEDS   (United Kingdom)

^e RWA Group   (Bulgaria)

^f WASTE   (Netherlands)

^g Deutsche Gesellschaft für Internationale Zusammenarbeit GIZ GmbH   (Egypt)

^h GIZ   (Germany)

Author keywords

Benchmark indicators; Developing countries; Governance; Performance monitoring; Recycling rates; Solid waste management

Indexed keywords

BENCHMARKING; DEVELOPING COUNTRIES; RECYCLING; SOLID WASTES;

BENCHMARK INDICATORS; COMPREHENSIVE PERFORMANCE; FINANCIAL SUSTAINABILITY; GOVERNANCE; INTEGRATED SUSTAINABLE WASTE MANAGEMENTS; PERFORMANCE MONITORING; RECYCLING RATE; SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS;

WASTE DISPOSAL;

BENCHMARKING; DEVELOPING WORLD; GOVERNANCE APPROACH; PLANNING METHOD; RECYCLING; SOLID WASTE; SUSTAINABILITY; URBAN AREA; WASTE DISPOSAL; WASTE MANAGEMENT;

ARTICLE; CITY PLANNING; DEVELOPING COUNTRY; ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING; FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT; GOVERNMENT; QUALITY CONTROL; RECYCLING; SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT; WASTE DISPOSAL; CITY; PROCEDURES; WASTE MANAGEMENT;

BENCHMARKING; CITIES; RECYCLING; REFUSE DISPOSAL; WASTE MANAGEMENT;

EID: 84919621506     PISSN: 0956053X     EISSN: 18792456     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.wasman.2014.10.006     Document Type: Article

References (74)

1. Al Sabbagh M.K., Velis C.A., Wilson D.C., Cheeseman C.R. Resource management performance in Bahrain: a systematic analysis of municipal waste management, secondary material flows and organizational aspects. Waste Manage. Res. 2012, 30(8):813-824.
2. Armijo C., Puma A., Ojeda S. A set of indicators for waste management programs. Second International Conference on Environmental Engineering and Applications, IPCBEE 2011, vol. 17. IACSIT Press, Singapore.
3. Beccali G., Federico G., Iadicola G., Rizzo G., Traverso M. Integrated approach to the assessment of waste management systems within the SEA framework. Int. J. Environ. Technol. Manage. 2007, 7(1-2):68-84.
4. Bringhentia J.R., Zandonadeb E., Günther W.M.R. Selection and validation of indicators for programs selective collection evaluation with social inclusion. Resour. Conserv. Recycl. 2011, 55:876-884.
5. Caio, D.Z., Fernando, F., 2013. Selective waste collection effectiveness indicators proposal applied in Ibipor Brazil as a waste management tool. In: Proceedings of ISWA World Congress 2013, 7-11 October, International Solid Waste Association (ISWA), Vienna, Austria.
6. Carifio J., Perla R. Resolving the 50-year debate around using and misusing Likert scales. Med. Educ. 2008, 42:1150-1152.
7. CEPT University, 2010. Performance measurement framework for urban water and sanitation. Volume I: Approach and framework. Volume II: List of indicators and reliability assessment. [Online] (accessed 17.02.14). http://pas.org.in.
8. Chalmin P., Gaillochet C. From Waste to Resource: World Waste Survey 2009 2009, Economica, Paris.
9. Chirico, J.M., 2010. Catching the wave of the future: An analysis of sustainable waste management technologies. International Conference on Thermal Treatment Technologies and Hazardous Waste Combustors 2010, 17-20 May 2010, San Francisco, Code 81589 (via Scopus), pp. 357-382.
10. Cifrian E., Coz A., Viguri J., Andrés A. Indicators for valorisation of municipal solid waste and special waste. Waste Biomass Valorization 2010, 1(4):479-486.
11. Cifrian E., Galan B., Andrés A., Viguri J.R. Material flow indicators and carbon footprint for MSW management systems: Analysis and application at regional level, Cantabria, Spain. Resour. Conserv. Recycl. 2012, 68:54-66.
12. Cifrian E., Andrés A., Viguri J.R. Estimating monitoring indicators and the carbon footprint of municipal solid waste management in the region of Cantabria, Northern Spain. Waste Biomass Valorization 2013, 4(2):271-285.
13. Cleary J. Life cycle assessments of municipal solid waste management systems: a comparative analysis of selected peer-reviewed literature. Environ. Int. 2009, 35(8):1256-1266.
14. Coelho H.M.G., Lange L.C., Coelho L.M.G. Proposal of an environmental performance index to assess solid waste treatment technologies. Waste Manage. 2012, 32:1473-1481.
15. Del Borghi A., Gallo M., Del Borghi M. A survey of life cycle approaches in waste management. Int. J. Life Cycle Assess. 2009, 14(7):597-610.
16. Desmond M. Municipal solid waste management in Ireland: assessing for sustainability. Irish Geogr. 2006, 39(1):22-33.
17. Fragkou M.C., Vicent T., Gabarrell A general methodology for calculating the MSW management self-sufficiency indicator: application to the wider Barcelona area. Resour. Conserv. Recycl. 2010, 54(6):390-399.
18. Garcia Cortes, S., Whiteman, A.D., Soos, R., Wilson, D.C., Schwehn, E., 2013. Guidance on the selection of operator models for solid waste management in emerging and developing countries. Sardinia 2013. In: Proceedings of the Fourteenth International Waste Management and Landfill Symposium, 30 September-4 October, S. Margherita di Pula, Sardinia, Italy, Published by CSIA Environmental Sanitary Engineering Centre.
19. GCIF, 2012. Global City Indicators Facility. [Online] available at: [accessed 17.02.14]. http://www.cityindicators.org.
20. Greene K.L., Tonjes D.J. Quantitative assessments of municipal waste management systems: using different indicators to compare and rank programs in New York State. Waste Manage. 2014, 34(4):825-836.
21. Guimarães B., Simões P., Marques R.C. Does performance evaluation help public managers? A balanced scorecard approach in urban waste services. J. Environ. Manage. 2010, 91:2632-2638.
22. Handakas E.J., Sangiannis D.A. Solid waste management: a systems approach. Fresenius Environ. Bull. 2012, 21(11A):3330-3336.
23. Hoornweg, D., Bhada-Tata, P., 2012. What a waste: a global review of solid waste management. Urban Development Series Knowledge Papers, World Bank, Washington D.C. [Online] available at: (accessed 08.04.14). http://documents.worldbank.org.
24. 3R Policy Indicator Factsheets - Discussion Paper. Asia Resource Circulation Policy Research Group 2014, Institute for Global Environmental Strategies (IGES), Kanagawa, Japan, ( (accessed 23.04.12)). Y. Hotta (Ed.).
25. Huang Y.T., Pan T.C., Kao J.J. Performance assessment for municipal solid waste collection in Taiwan. J. Environ. Manage. 2011, 92:1277-1283.
26. IJgosse J., Anschütz J., Scheinberg A. Putting Integrated Sustainable Waste Management Into Practice: Using the ISWM Assessment Methodology as Applied in the UWEP Plus Programme (2001-2003) 2004, WASTE, Gouda, The Netherlands.
27. Karagiannidis A., Xirogiannopoulou A., Perkoulidis G., Moussiopoulos N. Assessing the collection of urban solid wastes: a step towards municipality benchmarking. Water Air Soil Pollut. Focus 2004, 4(4-5):397-409.
28. Karak T., Bhagat R.M., Bhattacharyya P. Municipal solid waste generation, composition, and management: the world scenario. Crit. Rev. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2012, 42(15):1509-1630.
29. Laurent A., Bakas I., Clavreul J., Bernstad A., Niero M., Gentil E., Hauschild M.Z., Christensen T.H. Review of LCA studies of solid waste management systems - Part I: Lessons learned and perspectives. Waste Manage. 2014, 34(3):573-588.
30. Laurent A., Clavreul J., Bernstad A., Bakas I., Niero M., Gentil E., Christensen T.H., Hauschild M.Z. Review of LCA studies of solid waste management systems - Part II: Methodological guidance for a better practice. Waste Manage. 2014, 34(3):589-606.
31. Likert R. A technique for the measurement of attitudes. Arch. Psychol. 1932, 22(140):5-55.
32. Linzner R., Lange U. Role and size of informal sector in waste management - a review. Proc. Inst. Civil Eng., Waste Res. Manage. 2013, 166(WR2):69-83.
33. MacDonald M.L. Bias issues in the utilization of solid waste indicators. J. Am. Plan. Assoc. 1996, 62(2):236-242.
34. Marchettini N., Ridolfi R., Rustici M. An environmental analysis for comparing waste management options and strategies. Waste Manage. 2007, 27(4):562-571.
35. Massood M., Barlow Y. Framework for integration of the informal waste management sector with the formal sector in Pakistan. Waste Manage Res 2012, 31(10 supplement):93-105.
36. Massood M., Barlow Y., Wilson D.C. An assessment of the current municipal solid waste management system in Lahore, Pakistan. Waste Manage Res 2014, 32(9):834-847.
37. Mavropoulos, A., Wilson, D.C., Appelqvist, B., Velis, C.A., Cooper, J., 2014. Globalisation and waste management - Final report from the ISWA Task Force, International Solid Waste Association (ISWA), Vienna, Austria. [Online] (accessed 30.10.2014). http://www.iswa.org/fileadmin/galleries/Task_Forces/TFGWM_Report_GWM_LR.pdf.
38. Mendes P., Santos A.C., Perna F., Teixeira M.R. The balanced scorecard as an integrated model applied to the Portuguese public service: a case study in the waste sector. J. Cleaner Prod. 2012, 24:20-29.
39. Mendes P., Santos A.C., Nunes L.M., Teixeira M.R. Evaluating municipal solid waste management performance in regions with strong seasonal variability. Ecol. Ind. 2013, 30:170-177.
40. Menikpura S.N.M., Gheewala S.H., Bonnet S. Framework for life cycle sustainability assessment of municipal solid waste management systems with an application to a case study in Thailand. Waste Manage. Res. 2012, 30(7):708-719.
41. Menikpura S.N.M., Gheewala S.H., Bonnet S., Chiemchaisri C. Evaluation of the effect of recycling on sustainability of municipal solid waste management in Thailand. Waste Biomass Valorization 2013, 4(2):237-257.
42. Michaud J-C., Farrant L., Jan O., Kjaer B., Bakas I. Environmental benefits of recycling - 2010 update. Waste and Resources Action Programme (WRAP) 2010, Banbury, UK, ( (accessed 23.09.14)).
43. Munizaga, J.A., Garcia, A.L., 2013. Garbometer: a methodology for comprehensive evaluation of municipal solid waste management systems. In: Proceedings of ISWA World Congress 2013, 7-11 October, International Solid Waste Association (ISWA), Vienna, Austria.
44. Nicolli F. Convergence of waste-related indicators of environmental quality in Italy. Environ. Econ. Policy Studies 2012, 14(4):383-401.
45. Passarini F., Vassura I., Monti F., Morselli L., Villani B. Indicators of waste management efficiency related to different territorial conditions. Waste Manage. 2011, 31:785-792.
46. Polaz C.N.M., Teixeira B.A.N. Indicadores de sustentabilidade para a gestão municipal de resíduos sólidos urbanos: Um estudo para São Carlos (SP) (Indicators of sustainability for municipal solid waste management: Case study of the city of São Carlos (SP)). Engenharia Sanitaria e Ambiental 2009, 14(3):411-420.
47. Rushbrook P., Pugh M. Solid Waste Landfills in Middle- and Lower-Income Countries - A Technical Guide to Planning, Design and Operation. World Bank Technical Paper No. 426 1999, World Bank, Washington, DC.
48. Scheinberg, A., 2011. Value added, modes of sustainable recycling in the modernisation of waste management systems. PhD thesis. Wageningen University, The Netherlands, pp. 120 [Online] (accessed 08.04.14). http://edepot.wur.nl/179408.
49. Scheinberg A., Wilson D.C., Rodic L. Solid Waste Management in the World's Cities: Water and Sanitation in the World's Cities 2010 2010, Earthscan on behalf of UN-HABITAT, London, [Online] ( (accessed 27.09.2014)).
50. Schübeler, P., 1996. Conceptual framework for municipal solid waste management in low-income countries. UMP/SDC Collaborative programme on Municipal Solid Waste Management in Developing Countries. Urban Management Programme (UMP) Working Paper Series, Number 9. St Gallen, SKAT, Switzerland.
51. Sharma S., Pandey S., Muzumdaar N.B. Indicators of waste management in India. Indian J. Environ. Protect. 2010, 30(8):617-628.
52. Sim N.M., Wilson D.C., Velis C.A., Smith S.R. Waste management and recycling in the former Soviet Union - case study of Bishkek, Kyrgyz republic (Kyrgyzstan). Waste Manage. Res. 2013, 31(10 Supplement):106-125.
53. Soos, R., Whiteman, A.D., Wilson, D.C., Briciu, C., 2013. Operator Models - Understanding Local Objectives: Respecting Diversity. In the series: Concepts for Sustainable Waste Management. GIZ (Deutsche Gesellschaft für Internationale Zusammenarbeit GmbH), Eschborn. [Online] ( (accessed 08.04.14)). http://www.giz.de.
54. Stevens S.S. On the theory of scales of measurement. Science 1946, 103(2684):677-680.
55. Stretz, J. 2013. Case Study Report for Maputo, Mozambique, prepared for GIZ Operator Models project. [Online] via, search the database for 'operator models', then select Annex 7 (accessed 27.09.14). http://www.giz.de/en/mediacenter/publications.html.
56. Suttibak S., Nitivattananon V. Assessment of factors influencing the performance of solid waste recycling programs. Resour. Conserv. Recycl. 2008, 53(1-2):45-56.
57. Tanguay G.A., Rajaonson J., Lefebvre J.F., Lanoie P. Measuring the sustainability of cities: an analysis of the use of local indicators. Ecol. Ind. 2010, 10:407-418.
58. Van de Klundert A., Anschütz J. Integrated sustainable waste management - the concept. Integrated Sustainable Waste Management: Set of Five Tools for Decision-makers - Experiences from the Urban Waste Expertise Programme (1995-2001) 2001, WASTE, Gouda, The Netherlands. A. Scheinberg (Ed.).
59. Velis C.A., Wilson D.C., Rocca O., Smith S.R., Mavropoulos A., Cheeseman C.R. InteRa - a new analytical framework and tool for integrating the informal recycling sector in waste and resource management systems in developing countries. Waste Manage. Res. 2012, 30(9 Supplement):43-66.
60. Wen L., Lin C.H., Lee S.C. Review of recycling performance indicators: a study on collection rate in Taiwan. Waste Manage. 2009, 29(8):2248-2256.
61. Whiteman, A., Smith, P. and Wilson, D.C., 2001. Waste management: an indicator of urban governance. In: Presented at UN-Habitat Global Conference on Urban Development, New York. Prepared for: UK Department for International Development (DFID). [Online] available at: (accessed 13.05.13). http://www.davidcwilson.com/Waste_Management_An_Indicator_of_Urban_Governance.pdf.
62. Wilson D.C. Development drivers for waste management. Waste Manage. Res. 2007, 25:198-207.
63. Wilson, D.C., Cowing, M.J., 2013. Operator Models - Understanding Local Objectives: Respecting Diversity. Annex 2: Benchmark Indicators for Integrated Sustainable Waste Management (ISWM) - Methodology and in-depth case studies results. In the series: Concepts for Sustainable Waste Management, GIZ (Deutsche Gesellschaft für Internationale Zusammenarbeit GmbH), Eschborn. [Online] via, search the database for 'operator models', then select Annex 2. (accessed 08.04.14). http://www.giz.de/en/mediacenter/publications.html.
64. Wilson D.C., Scheinberg A. What is good practice in solid waste management?. Waste Manage. Res. 2010, 28(12):1055-1056.
65. Wilson D.C., Rodic L., Scheinberg A., Velis C.A., Alabaster G. Comparative analysis of solid waste management in 20 cities. Waste Manage. Res. 2012, 30(3):237-254.
66. Wilson, D.C., Kangojera, J.B., Soos, R., Briciu, C., Spies, S., Whiteman, A.D., Schwehn, E., Smith, S.R., 2013a. Operator models for delivering municipal solid waste management services in emerging and developing countries. In: Proceedings of ISWA World Congress 2013, 7-11 October, International Solid Waste Association (ISWA), Vienna, Austria.
67. Wilson, D.C., Rodic, L., Cowing, M.J., Whiteman, A.D., Stretz, J., Scheinberg, A., 2013b. Benchmark Indicators for Integrated and Sustainable Waste Management (ISWM). In: Proceedings of ISWA World Congress 2013, 7-11 October, International Solid Waste Association (ISWA), Vienna, Austria. [Online] (accessed 03.11.2014). http://www.iswa.org/index.php?eID=tx_iswaknowledgebase_download%26documentUid=4194.
68. Wilson D.C., Velis C.A., Rodic L. Integrated sustainable waste management in developing countries. Proc. Inst. Civil Eng. Waste Res. Manage. 2013, 166(WR2):52-68.
69. Wilts H. National waste prevention programs: indicators on progress and barriers. Waste Manage. Res. 2012, 30(9 Supplement):29-35.
70. World Bank, 2012. How we classify countries. [Online] available at: (accessed 13.05.13). http://data.worldbank.org.
71. Zaki T., Kafafi A.G., Boushra M., El-Halim A.M. Annual Report for Solid Waste Management in Egypt 2013, Ministry of State for Environmental Affairs, National Solid Waste Management Programme (NSWMP), Cairo, Egypt.
72. Zaman A.U. Identification of key assessment indicators of the zero waste management systems. Ecol. Ind. 2014, 36:682-693.
73. Zaman A.U. Measuring waste management performance using the 'Zero Waste Index': the case of Adelaide, Australia. J. Cleaner Prod. 2014, 66:407-419.
74. Zaman A.U., Lehmann S. The zero waste index: a performance measurement tool for waste management systems in a 'zero waste city'. J. Cleaner Prod. 2013, 50:123-132.