Who’s afraid of dissent? Addressing concerns about undermining scientific consensus in public policy developments

Perspectives on Science

Volumn 22, Issue 4, 2014, Pages 593-615

  de Melo Martín, Inmaculada ^a   Intemann, Kristen ^b  

^a WEILL CORNELL MEDICAL COLLEGE   (United States)

^b MONTANA STATE UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 84911169246     PISSN: 10636145     EISSN: 15309274     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1162/POSC_a_00151     Document Type: Article

References (85)

1. Ackermann, Robert. 1986. “Consensus and Dissensus in Science.” PSA: Proceedings of the Biennial Meeting of the Philosophy of Science Association 1986 (2): 99-105.
2. Anderson, Elisabeth. 2011. “Democracy, Public Policy, and Lay Assessments of Scientific Testimony.” Episteme 8 (2): 144-64.
3. Arntzen, C. J., A. Coghlan, B. Johnson, J. Peacock, and M. Rodemeyer. 2003. “GM Crops: Science, Politics and Communication.” Nature Reviews Genetics 4 (10): 839-43.
4. Bateman, C. 2007. “Paying the Price for AIDS Denialism.” South African Medical Journal 97: 912-14.
5. Beatty, John. 2006. “Masking Disagreement among Experts.” Episteme 3 (1): 52-67.
6. Beatty, John, and Alfred Moore. 2010. “Should We Aim for Consensus?” Episteme 7 (3): 198-214.
7. Bijker, Wiebe E., Roland Bal, and Ruud Hendriks. 2009. The Paradox of Scientific Authority: The Role of Scientific Advice in Democracies. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press.
8. Brown, K. F., J. S. Kroll, M. J. Hudson, M. Ramsay, J. Green, S. J. Long, C. A. Vincent, G. Fraser, and N. Sevdalis. 2010. “Factors Underlying Parental Decisions about Combination Childhood Vaccinations including MMR: A Systematic Review.” Vaccine 28 (26): 4235-48.
9. Collins, H. M., and Robert Evans. 2007. Rethinking Expertise. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
10. de Melo-Martín Inmaculada, and Zahra Meghani. 2008. “Beyond Risk. A More Realistic Risk-Benefit Analysis of Agricultural Biotechnologies.” EMBO Rep 9 (4): 302-306.
11. Diethelm, P., and M. McKee. 2009. “Denialism: What Is It and How Should Scientists Respond?” European Journal for Public Health 19(1): 2-4.
12. Dietrich, Michael, and Robert Skipper. 2007. “Manipulating Underdetermination in Scientific Controversy: The Case of the Molecular Clock.” Perspectives on Science 15(3): 295-326.
13. Douglas, Heather. 2009. Science, Policy, and the Value-Free Ideal. Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press.
14. Douglas, Mary, and Aaron B. Wildavsky. 1982. Risk and Culture: An Essay on the Selection of Technical and Environmental Dangers. Berkeley: University of California Press.
15. Duesberg, P., C. Koehnlein, and D. Rasnick. 2003. “The Chemical Bases of the Various AIDS Epidemics: Recreational Drugs, Anti-Viral Chemotherapy and Malnutrition.” Journal of Biosciences 28(4): 383-412.
16. Duesberg, P., and D. Rasnick. 1998. “The AIDS Dilemma: Drug Diseases Blamed on a Passenger Virus.” Genetica 104(2): 85-132.
17. Editorial. 2007. “Another Inconvenient Truth. In Europe, No One Apparently Wants to Listen if You Have Good News about Genetically Modified Organisms (GMOs).” Nature Biotechnoly 25(12): 1330.
18. Elliott, Kevin. 2011. Is a Little Pollution Good for You? Incorporating Societal Values in Environmental Research. New York: Oxford University Press.
19. Elster, Jon. 1986. “The Market and the Forum: Three Varieties of Political Theory.” PP. 103-32 in Foundations of Social Choice Theory. Edited by J. Elster and A. Hyland. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
20. Enstrom, J. E., and G. C. Kabat. 2003. “Environmental Tobacco Smoke and Tobacco Related Mortality in a Prospective Study of Californians, 1960-1998.” British Medical Journal 326 (7398): 1057-67.
21. Frank, L. 2004. “Scientific Conduct. Charges Don’t Stick to the Skeptical Environmentalist.” Science 303 (5654): 28.
22. Geier, David A., and Mark R. Geier. 2006. “A meta-analysis epidemiological assessment of neurodevelopmental disorders following vaccines administered from 1994 through 2000 in the United States.” Neuroendocrinoly Letters 27 (4): 401-13.
23. Geier, David A., and Mark R. Geier. 2007. “A Prospective Study of Thimerosal-Containing Rho(D)-Immune Globulin Administration as a Risk Factor for Autistic Disorders.” Journal for Maternal Fetal Neonatal Medicine 20 (5): 385-90.
24. Gilbert, Margaret. 1987. “Modelling Collective Belief.” Synthese 73(1): 185-204.
25. Glanz, J. M., D. L. McClure, D. J. Magid, M. F. Daley, E. K. France, D. A. Salmon, and S. J. Hambidge. 2009. “Parental Refusal of Pertussis Vaccination Is Associated with an Increased Risk of Pertussis Infection in Children.” Pediatrics 123 (6): 1446-51.
26. Grundmann, Reiner. 2012. “The Legacy of Climategate: Revitalizing or Undermining Climate Science and Policy?” Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews-Climate Change 3 (3): 281-88.
27. Grundmann, Reiner, and Nico Stehr. 2012. The Power of Scientific Knowledge: From Research to Public Policy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
28. Gutmann, Amy. 2004. Why Deliberative Democracy? Princeton: Princeton University Press.
29. Hodgson, J. 2008. “Scientists Cry Foul as Europe Plays Politics with GM Crops.” Nature Biotechnology 26 (2): 138-40.
30. Horton, R. 2010. “Science Will Never Be the Same Again.” Lancet 376 (9736):143-44.
31. Intemann, Kristen, and Inmaculada de Melo-Martín. 2010. “Social Values and Scientific Evidence: The Case of the HPV Vaccines.” Biology & Philosophy 25 (2): 203-13.
32. IPCC. 2007. Climate Change 2007: Synthesis Report: Synthesis Report. Geneva: Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. http://www.ipcc.ch/pdf/assessment-report/ar4/syr/ar4_syr.pdf (accessed 4 February, 2014)
33. Jansen, V. A. A., N. Stollenwerk, H. J. Jensen, M. E. Ramsay, W. J. Edmunds, and C. J. Rhodes. 2003. “Measles Outbreaks in a Population with Declining Vaccine Uptake.” Science 301 (5634): 804. https://www.sciencemag.org/content/301/5634/804.full (accessed 4 February, 2014)
34. Jasanoff, Sheila. 2004. States of Knowledge: The Co-Production of Science and Social Order. London, New York: Routledge.
35. Jasanoff, Sheila. 2010. “Science and Society. Testing Time for Climate Science.” Science 328 (5979): 695-96.
36. Jones, W. E. 2002. “Dissident versus Loyalist: Which Scientists Should We Trust?” Journal of Value Inquiry 36 (4): 511-20.
37. Kidd, M., and I. M. Modlin. 1998. “A Century of Helicobacter Pylori: Paradigms Lost-Paradigms Regained.” Digestion 59(1): 1-15.
38. Kirby, David. 2005. Evidence of Harm: Mercury in Vaccines and the Autism Epidemic. A Medical Controversy, 1st ed. New York: St. Martin’s Press.
39. Kitcher, Philip. 2011. Science in a Democratic Society. New York: Prometheus Books.
40. Kuehn, R. R. 2004. “Suppression of Environmental Science.” American Journal for Law and Medicine 30 (2-3): 333-69.
41. Kuhn, Thomas S. 2012. The Structure of Scientific Revolutions. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
42. Longino, Helen E. 1990. Science as Social Knowledge: Values and Objectivity in Scientific Inquiry. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
43. Longino, Helen E. 2002. The Fate of Knowledge. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
44. Martin, Brian. 1999. “Suppression of Dissent in Science.” In Research in Social Problems and Public Policy. Edited by W. R. Freudenburg and T. I. K. Youn. Stamford: JAI Press.
45. Martin, Brian. 2004. “Dissent and Heresy in Medicine: Models, Methods, and Strategies.” Social Science & Medicine 58 (4): 713-25.
46. McGarity, Thomas O., and Wendy Wagner. 2008. Bending Science: How Special Interests Corrupt Public Health Research. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
47. McKee, M., and P. Diethelm. 2010. “How The Growth of Denialism Undermines Public Health.” BMJ 341: c6950. http://www.bmj.com/content/341/bmj.c6950 (accessed 4 February, 2014)
48. Michaels, David. 2008. Doubt is Their Product: How Industry’s Assault on Science Threatens Your Health. Oxford, New York: Oxford University Press.
49. Michaels, Patrick J. 2005. Shattered Consensus: The True State of Global Warming. Lanham: Rowman & Littlefield.
50. Mill, John Stuart. 1978. On Liberty. Edited by E. Rapaport. Indianapolis: Hackett.
51. Miller, Boaz. 2013. “When is Consensus Knowledge-Based: Distin-guishing Shared Knowledge from Mere Agreement.” Synthese 190: 1293-1316.
52. Miller, H. I. 2003. “First Salvo in Transatlantic Food Fight Is Far from Last Word.” Nature Biotechnology 21 (7):737-38.
53. Moffett, Marc. 2007. “Reasonable Disagreement and Rational Group Inquiry.” Episteme 4 (3): 352-67.
54. Mooney, Chris. 2005. The Republican War on Science. New York: Basic Books.
55. NOAA. 2011. “Inspector General’s Review of Stolen Emails Confirms No Evidence of Wrong-Doing by NOAA Climate Scientists,” February 24, 2011. http://www.noaanews.noaa.gov/stories2011/20110224_climate.html (accessed 4 February, 2014)
56. Olmsted, Dan, and Mark Blaxill. 2010. The Age of Autism: Mercury, Medicine, and a Man-Made Epidemic, 1st ed. New York: Thomas Dunne Books/St. Martin’s Press.
57. Omer, Saad B., Daniel A. Salmon, Walter A. Orenstein, M. Patricia deHart, and Neal Halsey. 2009. “Vaccine Refusal, Mandatory Immunization, and the Risks of Vaccine-Preventable Diseases.” New England Journal of Medicine 360 (19): 1981-88.
58. Oppenheimer, M., B. C. O’Neill, M. Webster, and S. Agrawala. 2007. “Climate Change. The Limits of Consensus.” Science 317 (5844): 1505-06.
59. Oreskes, Naomi. 2004. “Beyond the Ivory Tower. The Scientific Consensus on Climate Change.” Science 306 (5702): 1686.
60. Oreskes, Naomi, and Erik M Conway. 2010a. “Defeating the Merchants of Doubt.” Nature 465 (7299): 686-87.
61. Oreskes, Naomi, and Erik M Conway. 2010b. Merchants of Doubt: How a Handful of Scientists Obscured the Truth on Issues from Tobacco Smoke to Global Warming, 1st U.S. ed. New York: Bloomsbury Press.
62. Ottawa Citizen. 2013. “Esteemed Ottawa Scientist Says Cosmic Rays, Not Greenhouse Gases, Cause Global Warming,” January 17, 2006. http://www.canada.com/ottawacitizen/news/story.html?id875fbe67-8c67-4d12-ab86-a9c5f5250d0f.
63. Pidgeon, N, and B Fischoff. 2011. “The Role of Social and Decisions Sciences in Communicating Uncertain Climate Risks.” Nature Climate Change 1: 35-41.
64. Poland, Gregory A., and Ray Spier. 2010. “Fear, Misinformation, and Innumerates: How the Wakefield Paper, the Press, and Advocacy Groups Damaged the Public Health.” Vaccine 28 (12): 2361-62.
65. Ravetz, JR. 2011. “‘Climategate’ and the Maturing of Post-Normal Science.” Futures 43(2): 149-157.
66. Rescher, Nicholas. 1993. Pluralism: Against the Demand for Consensus. Oxford, New York: Oxford University Press.
67. Rind, D., R. A. Kahn, M. Chin, S. E. Schwartz, L. A. Remer, G. Feingold, H. Yu, P. K. Quinn, and R. Halthore. 2009. “The Way Forward.” Pp. 98-104 in Atmospheric Aerosol Properties and Climate Impacts. Edited by M. Chin, R. Kahn and S. Schwartz. Washington, D.C.: National Aeronautics and Space Administration. http://pubs.giss.nasa.gov/abs/ri09700z.html
68. Rosen, Gideon. 2001. “Nominalism, Naturalism, Epistemic Relativism.” Philosophical Perspectives 15: 69-91.
69. Rosi-Marshall, E. J., J. L. Tank, T. V. Royer, M. R. Whiles, M. EvansWhite, C. Chambers, N. A. Griffiths, J. Pokelsek, and M. L. Stephen. 2007. “Toxins in Transgenic Crop Byproducts May Affect Headwater Stream Ecosystems.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Science USA 104 (41): 16204-08.
70. Saleh-Lakha, S., and B. R. Glick. 2005. “Is The Battle over Genetically Modified Foods Finally Over?” Biotechnology Advances 23(2): 93-96.
71. Schiermeier, Q. 2009. “Storm Clouds Gather over Leaked Climate E-Mails.” Nature 462 (7272): 397.
72. Schiermeier, Q. 2010. “The Real Holes in Climate Science.” Nature 463 (7279): 284-87.
73. Selinger, Evan, and Robert P. Crease. 2006. The Philosophy of Expertise. New York: Columbia University Press.
74. Shrader-Frechette, Kristin. 2010. “Conceptual Analysis and Special-Interest Science: Toxicology and the Case of Edward Calabrese.” Synthese: 449-69.
75. Shwed, U., and P. S. Bearman. 2010. “The Temporal Structure of Scientific Consensus Formation.” American Sociological Review 75 (6): 817-40.
76. Solomon, Miriam. 2001. Social Empiricism. Cambridge: MIT Press.
77. Specter, Michael. 2007. “The Denialists: The Dangerous Attacks on the Consensus About H.I.V. and AIDS.” New Yorker: 32-38.
78. Tucker, A. 2003. “The Epistemic Significance of Consensus.” Inquiry 46 (4): 501-21.
79. van der Sluijs, J. P., R. van Est, and M. Riphagen. 2010. “Beyond Consensus: Reifections from a Democratic Perspective on the Interaction between Climate Politics and Science.” Current Opinion in Environmental Sustainability 2(5-6): 409-415.
80. Vastag, B. 2001. “Congressional Autism Hearings Continue—No Evidence MMR Vaccine Causes Disorder.” Journal of the American Medical Association 285 (20): 2567-69.
81. Wakefield, A. J., S. H. Murch, A. Anthony, J. Linnell, D. M. Casson, M. Malik, M. Berelowitz, A. P. Dhillon, M. A. Thomson, P. Harvey, A. Valentine, S. E. Davies, and J. A. Walker-Smith. 1998. “Ileal-Lymphoid-Nodular Hyperplasia, Non-Specific Colitis, and Pervasive Developmental Disorder in Children.” (Retracted article. See vol. 375, p. 445, 2010). Lancet 351 (9103): 637-41.
82. Waltz, E. 2009. “GM Crops: Battlefield.” Nature 461 (7260): 27-32.
83. Weare, B. C. 2000a. “Insights into the Importance of Cloud Vertical Structure in Climate.” Geophysical Research Letters: 907-910.
84. Weare, B. C. 2000b. “Near-Global Observations of Low Clouds.” Journal of Climate 13: 1255-1268. doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.1175/1520-0442(2000)0131255:NGOOLC2.0.CO;2
85. Wynne, Brian. 2010. “Strange Weather, Again. Climate Science as Political Art.” Theory, Culture & Society 27 (2-3): 289-305.