Effectiveness of fuel reduction treatments: Assessing metrics of forest resiliency and wildfire severity after the Wallow Fire, AZ

Forest Ecology and Management

Volumn 334, Issue , 2014, Pages 43-52

  Waltz, Amy E M ^a   Stoddard, Michael T ^a   Kalies, Elizabeth L ^a   Springer, Judith D ^a   Huffman, David W ^a   Meador, Andrew Sánchez ^a  

^a NORTHERN ARIZONA UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

Herbaceous community; Mega fire; Reference conditions; Restoration; Treatment effectiveness; Wildfire

Indexed keywords

ECOSYSTEMS; FORESTRY; FUELS; IMAGE RECONSTRUCTION;

ECOSYSTEM RESILIENCE; FORESTED LANDSCAPES; FUEL REDUCTION TREATMENT; HERBACEOUS COMMUNITY; MIXED-CONIFER FORESTS; REFERENCE CONDITION; TREATMENT EFFECTIVENESS; WILDFIRE;

FIRES;

CONIFEROUS FOREST; ECOSYSTEM RESILIENCE; FUEL; HERB; MORTALITY; PLANT COMMUNITY; RESTORATION ECOLOGY; UNDERSTORY; WILDFIRE;

ARIZONA; UNITED STATES;

EID: 84907561372     PISSN: 03781127     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.foreco.2014.08.026     Document Type: Article

References (86)

1. Abella S.R., Covington W.W., Fulé P.Z., Lentile L.B., Sánchez Meador A.J., Morgan P. Past, present, and future old growth in frequent-fire conifer forests of the western United States. Ecol. Soc. 2007, 12(2):16.
2. Agee J.K. Fire Ecology of Pacific Northwest Forests 1993, Island Press, Washington, DC.
3. Ager A.A., Vaillant N.M., Finney M.A. A comparison of landscape fuel treatment strategies to mitigate wildland fire risk in the urban interface and preserve old forest structure. For. Ecol. Manage. 2010, 259:1556-1570.
4. Allen C.R., Graeme S., Cumming A., Garmestani S., Taylor P.D., Walker B.H. Managing for Resilience. Wildlife Biol. 2011, 17(4):337-349.
5. Anderson M.J. A new method for non-parametric multivariate analysis of variance. Austral Ecol. 2001, 26:32-46.
6. Attiwill P., Binkley D. Exploring the mega-fire reality: a 'Forest Ecology and Management' conference. For. Ecol. Manage. 2013, 294:1-3.
7. Battaglia, M.A., Shepperd, W.D., 2007. Ponderosa pine, mixed conifer and spruce-fir forests. In: Fire Ecology and Management of the Major Ecosystems of Southern Utah, Chapter 2. RMRS-GTR-202.
8. Beisner B.E., Haydon D., Cuddington K.L. Alternative stable states in ecology. Front. Ecol. Environ. 2003, 1:376-382.
9. Benson M.H., Garmestani A.S. Can we manage for resilience? The integration of resilience thinking into natural resource management in the United States. Environ. Manage. 2011, 48(3):392-399.
10. Bowman D.M.J.S., Balch J.K., Artaxo P., Bond W.J., Carlson J.M., Cochrane M.A., D'Antonio C.M., DeFries R.S., Doyle J.C., Harrison S.P., Johnston F.H., Keeley J.E., Krawchuk M.A., Kull C.A., Marston J.B., Moritz M.A., Prentice I.C., Roos C.I., Scott A.C., Swetnam T.W., van der Werf G.R., Pyne S.J. Fire in the earth system. Science 2009, 324:482-484.
11. Bowman D.M.J.S., Murphy B.P., Boer M.M., Bradstock R.A., Cary G.J., Cochrane M.A., Fensham R.J., Krawchuk M.A., Price O.F., Williams R.J. Forest fire management, climate change, and the risk of catastrophic carbon losses. Front. Ecol. Environ. 2013, 11:66-68.
12. Buma Brian, Brown Carissa D., Donato Dan C., Fontaine Joseph B., Johnstone Jill F. The impacts of changing disturbance regimes on serotinous plant populations and communities. Bioscience 2013, 63(11):866-876.
13. Carpenter S., Walker B., Anderies J.M., Abel N. From metaphor to measurement: resilience of what to what?. Ecosystems 2001, 4(8):765-781.
14. Climate Central, 2012. The Age of Western Wildfires. Climate Central, Princeton, New Jersey; Palo Alto, California, p. 18. <>. http://www.climatecentral.org/wgts/wildfires/Wildfires2012.pdf.
15. Cochrane M.A., Moran C.J., Wimberly M.C., Baer A.D., Finney M.A., Beckendorf K.L., Eidenshink J., Zhu Z. Estimation of wildfire size and risk changes due to fuels treatments. Int. J. Wildland Fire 2012, 21:357-367.
16. Collins B.M., Stephens S.L. Stand-replacing patches within a 'mixed severity' fire regime: quantitative characterization using recent fires in a long-established natural fire area. Landscape Ecol. 2010, 25:927-939.
17. Combrink T., Cothran C., Fox W., Peterson J., Snider G. A Full Cost Accounting of the 2010 Schultz Fire 2013, Northern Arizona University, Ecological Restoration Institute.
18. Covington W.W., Moore M.M. Southwestern ponderosa forest structure: changes since Euro-American settlement. J. Forest. 1994, 92:39-47.
19. Cram, D.S., Baker, T.T., Boren, J.C., 2006. Wildland fire effects in silviculturally treated vs. untreated stands of New Mexico and Arizona. Res. Pap. RMRS-RP-55. Fort Collins, CO: U.S. Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, Rocky Mountain Research Station. p. 28.
20. Crawford J.S., Wahren C.H.A., Kyle S., Moir W.H. Responses of exotic plant species to fires in Pinus ponderosa forests in northern Arizona. J. Veg. Sci. 2001, 12:261-268.
21. Cruz M.G., Alexander M.E., Wakimoto R.H. Assessing canopy fuel stratum characteristics in crown fire prone fuel types of western North America. Int. J. Wildland Fire 2003, 12:39-50.
22. D'Antonio, C.M., Dudley, T.L., Mack, M., 2000. Disturbance and biological invasions: direct effects and feedbacks. Pages 429-468 in Walker LR, ed. Ecosystems of Disturbed Ground. Ecosystems of the World. Vol. 16. New York: Elsevier Science.
23. Evans A.M., Everett R.G., Stephens S.L., Youtz J.A. Comprehensive Fuels Treatment Guide for Mixed Conifer Forests: California, Central and Southern Rockies, and the Southwest 2011, Forest Guild and USDA Forest Service, Santa Fe, New Mexico.
24. Everett R., Baumgartner D., Ohlson P., Schellhaas R., Harrod R. Development of current stand structure in dry fir-pine forests of eastern Washington. J. Torrey Bot. Soc. 2007, 134(2):199-214.
25. Faith D.P., Minchin P.R., Belbin L. Compositional dissimilarity as a robust measure of ecological distance. Vegetatio 1987, 69:57-68.
26. Folke C., Carpenter S., Walker B., Scheffer M., Elmqvist T., Gunderson L., Holling C.S. Regime shifts, resilience, and biodiversity in ecosystem management. Annu. Rev. Ecol. Evol. Syst. 2004, 35:557-581.
27. Folke C., Hahn T., Olsson P., Norberg J. Adaptive governance of social-ecological systems. Annu. Rev. Environ. Resour. 2005, 30:441-473.
28. Franklin J.F., Lindenmayer D., MacMahon J.A., McKee A., Magnuson J., Perry D.A., Waide R., Foster D. Threads of continuity: ecosystem disturbance, recovery, and the theory of biological legacies. Conserv. Biol. Pract. 2000, 1:8-16.
29. Franklin, J.F., Hemstrom, M.A., Van Pelt, R., Buchanan, J.B., 2008. The Case for Active Management of Dry Forest Types in Eastern Washington: Perpetuating and Creating Old Forest Structures and Functions. Washington State Department of Natural Resources. Available and accessed 3/2009: <>. http://www.dnr.wa.gov/Publications/lm_ess_eog_mgmt.pdf.
30. Freid J.S., Torn M.S., Mills E. The impact of climate change on wildfire severity: a regional forecast for Northern California. Climatic Change 2004, 64:169-191.
31. Fulé P.Z., Laughlin D. Wildland fire effects on forest structure over an altitudinal gradient, Grand Canyon National Park, USA. J. Appl. Ecol. 2007, 44(1):136-146.
32. Fulé P.Z., Crouse J.E., Heinlein T.A., Moore M.M., Covington W.W., Verkamp G. Mixed-severity fire regime in a high-elevation forest: Grand Canyon, Arizona. Landscape Ecol. 2003, 18:465-486.
33. Fulé P.Z., Korb J.E., Wu R. Changes in forest structure of a mixed conifer forest, southwestern Colorado, USA. For. Ecol. Manage. 2009, 258:1200-1210.
34. Fulé P.Z., Crouse J.E., Roccaforte J.P., Kalies E.L. Do thinning and/or burning treatments in western USA ponderosa or Jeffrey pine-dominated forests help restore natural fire behavior?. For. Ecol. Manage. 2012, 269:68-81.
35. Griffis K.L., Crawford J.A., Wagner M.R., Moir W.H. Understory response to management treatments in northern Arizona ponderosa pine forests. For. Ecol. Manage. 2001, 146:239-245.
36. Haire S.L., MGarigal K. Effects of landscape patterns of fire severity on regenerating ponderosa pine forests (Pinus ponderosa) in New Mexico and Arizona, USA. Landscape Ecol. 2010, 25:1055-1069.
37. Hessburg P.F., Agee J.K., Franklin J.K. Dry forests and wildland fires of the inland Northwest USA: contrasting the landscape ecology of the pre-settlement and modem eras. For. Ecol. Manage. 2005, 211:117-139.
38. Hessburg P.F., Salter R.B., James K.M. Re-examining fire severity relations in pre-management era mixed conifer forests: inferences from landscape patterns of forest structure. Landscape Ecol. 2007, 22:5-24.
39. Holling C.S. Resilience and stability of ecological systems. Annu. Rev. 1973, 4:1-23.
40. Hudak, A. T., I. Rickert, P. Morgan, E. Strand, S.A. Lewis, P.R. Robichaud, C. Hoffman, Z.A. Holden, 2011. Review of fuel treatment effectiveness in forests and rangelands and a case study from the 2007 megafires in central idaho USA. (No. RMRS-GTR-252). Fort Collins, CO: Rocky Mountain Research Station Publishing Services.
41. Inciweb. Wallow Fire Maps. <> (accessed 14.03.12). http://inciweb.nwcg.gov/incident/maps/2262/1/.
42. Karl T.R., Melillo J.M., Peterson T.C. Global Climate Change Impacts in the United States 2009, Cambridge University Press, New York, USA.
43. Korb J.E., Fulé P.Z., Stoddard M.T. Forest restoration in a surface fire-dependent ecosystem: an example from a mixed conifer forest, southwestern Colorado, USA. For. Ecol. Manage. 2012, 269:10-18. 10.1016/J.FORECO.2012.01.002.
44. Kuenzi A.M., Fulé P.Z., Sieg C.H. Effects of fire severity and pre-fire stand treatment on plant community recovery after a large wildfire. For. Ecol. Manage. 2008, 255:855-865.
45. Larson A.J., et al. Latent resilience in ponderosa pine forest: effects of resumed frequent fire. Ecol. Appl. 2013, 23(6):1243-1249.
46. Littell J.S., McKenzie D., Peterson D.L., Westerling A.L. Climate and wildfire area burned in western U.S. ecoprovinces, 1916-2003. Ecol. Appl. 2009, 19:1003-1021.
47. Liu Y., Stanturf J., Goodrick S. Trends in global wildfire potential in a changing climate. For. Ecol. Manage. 2010, 259:685-697.
48. Margolis E.Q., Balmat J. Fire history and fire-climate relationships along a fire regime gradient in the Santa Fe Municipal Watershed, NM, USA. For. Ecol. Manage. 2009, 258:2416-2430.
49. Margolis E.Q., Swetnam T.W., Allen C.D. A stand-replacing fire history in upper montane forests of the Southern Rocky Mountains. Can. J. For. Res. 2007, 37:2227-2241.
50. Margolis E.Q., Swetnam T.W., Allen C.D. Historical stand-replacing fire in upper montane forests of the Madrean Sky Islands and Mogollon Plateau, southwestern USA. Fire Ecol. 2011, 7:88-107.
51. Margolis, E.Q., Huffman, D., Iniguez, J.M., 2013. Southwestern Mixed Conifer Forests: Evaluating Reference Conditions to Guide Ecological Restoration Treatments. Ecological Restoration Institute Working paper (28). <>. http://www.eri.nau.edu.
52. Martinson, E.J., Omi, P.N., 2013. Fuel Treatments and Fire Severity: A Meta-Analysis. RMRS-RP-103WWW. U.S. Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, Rocky Mountain Research Station, Fort Collins, CO. p. 35.
53. McCune, B., Mefford, M.J., 2006. PCORD. Multivariate Analysis of Ecological Data. Version 5.10.MjM Software, Gleneden Beach, Oregon, USA.
54. McGarigal, K., Cushman, S.A., Ene, E., 2012. FRAGSTATS v4: Spatial Pattern Analysis Program for Categorical and Continuous Maps. Available: <>. http://www.umass.edu/landeco/research/fragstats/fragstats.html.
55. Meyers, R. 2006. Living with fire: sustaining ecosystems and livelihoods through integrated fire management. Global Fire Initiative, The Nature Conservancy. <> (accessed 14.01.14). http://www.conservationgateway.org/Files/Pages/living-fire.aspx.
56. Miller J.D., Thode A.E. Quantifying burn severity in a heterogeneous landscape with a relative version of the delta Normalized Burn Ratio (dNBR). Remote Sens. Environ. 2007, 109:66-80.
57. National Forest System Land Management Planning; Final Rule and Record of Decision. 77 Federal Register No. 68 (April 9, 2012) pp. 21162-21275.
58. North M., Stine P., Zielinski W., Stephens S. An ecosystem management strategy for Sierran mixed-conifer forests 2009, USDA Forest Service, Pacific Southwest Research Station, Albany, CA, p. 49.
59. Pollet J., Omi P.N. Effect of thinning and prescribed burning on crown fire severity in ponderosa pine forests. Int. J. Wildland Fire 2002, 11:1-10. 10.1071/WF01045.
60. Prichard S.J., Peterson D.L., Jacobson K. Fuel treatments reduce the severity of wildfire effects in dry mixed conifer forest, Washington, USA. Can. J. For. Res. 2010, 40:1615-1626.
61. Radeloff V.C., Hammer R.B., Stewart S.I., Freid J.S., Holcomb S.S., McKeefry J.F. The wildland-urban interface in the United States. Ecol. Appl. 2005, 15:799-805.
62. RAVG (Rapid Assessment of Vegetation Condition after Wildfire). 2011. US Department of Agriculture, Forest Service. Wallow Fire - Apache-Sitgreaves NF. Remote Sensing Applications Center, Salt Lake City, UT. <> (Accessed 15.03.12). http://www.fs.fed.us/postfirevegcondition/index.shtml.
63. Raymond C.L., Peterson D.L. Fuel treatments alter the effects of wildfire in a mixed evergreen forest, Oregon, USA. Can. J. For. Res. 2005, 35:2981-2995.
64. Reynolds, R.T., Sánchez Meador, A.J., Youtz, J.A., Nicolet, T., Matonis, M.S., Jackson, P.L., DeLorenzo, D.G., Graves, A.D., 2013. Restoring Composition and Structure in Southwestern Frequent-Fire Forests: A Science-Based Framework for Improving Ecosystem Resiliency. General Technical Report RMRS-GTR-310. USDA, Forest Service, Rocky Mountain Research Station, Fort Collins, CO. p. 76.
65. Rist L., Moen J. Sustainability in forest management and a new role for resilience thinking. For. Ecol. Manage. 2013, 310:416-427.
66. Roccaforte J.P., Fule P.Z., Chancellor W.W., Laughlin D.C. Woody debris and tree regeneration dynamics following severe wildfires in Arizona ponderosa pine forests. Can. J. For. Res. 2012, 42:593-604.
67. Romme W.H., Floyd M.L., Hanna D. Historical Range of Variability and Current Landscape Condition Analysis: South Central Highlands Section 2009, Southwestern Colorado & Northwestern New Mexico, Colorado Forest Restoration Institute, Fort Collins, CO, USA.
68. Savage M., Mast J.N. How resilient are southwestern ponderosa pine forests after crown fires?. Can. J. For. Res. 2005, 35:967-977.
69. Seager R., Ting M., Held I., Kushnir Y., Lu J., Vecchi G., Huang H.-P., Harnik N., Leetmaa A., Lau N.-C., Li C., Velez J., Naik N. Model projections of an imminent transition to a more arid climate in southwestern North America. Science 2007, 316:1181-1184.
70. Shadish W., Cook T., Campbell D. Experimental and Quasi-Experimental Designs for Generalized Causal Inference 2002, Houghton Mifflin, New York, p. 656.
71. Shive K.L., Sieg C.H., Fulé P.Z. Pre-wildfire management treatments interact with fire severity to have lasting effects on post-wildfire vegetation responses. Forest Ecol. Mange. 2013, 297:75-83.
72. Shive, K.L., Kuenzi, A.M., Sieg, C.H., Fulé, P.Z., 2013b. Pre-fire fuel reduction treatments influence plant communities and exotic species 9 years after wildfire. Appl. Veg. Sci. doi:10.1111/avsc.12015.
73. Sitko S., Hurteau S. Evaluating the Impacts of Forest Treatments: The First Five Years of the White Mountain Stewardship Project 2010, The Nature Conservancy, Phoenix, Arizona.
74. Stephens S.L.J.D., McIver R.E.J., Boerner C.J.Fetting, Fontaine J.B., Hartsough B.R., Kennedy P.L., Schwilk D.W. The effects of forest fuel-reduction treatments in the United States. Bioscience 2012, 62:549-560.
75. Stephens S.L., Agee J.K., Fulé P.Z., North M.P., Romme W.H., Swetnam T.W., Turner M.G. Managing forests and fire in changing climates. Science 2013, 43:41-42.
76. Stoddard, M.S. 2011. Compilation of Historical Forest Structural Characteristics Across the Colorado Plateau. Ecological Restoration Institute Fact Sheet. <>. http://www.eri.nau.edu.
77. Strom B.A., Fulé P.Z. Pre-wildfire fuel treatments affect long-term ponderosa pine forest dynamics. Int. J. Wildland Fire 2007, 16:128-138.
78. Thomas, J.W., Anderson, R.G., Maser, C., Bull, E.L., 1979. Snags. In: Wildlife Habitats in Managed Forests-the Blue Mountains of Oregon and Washington. USDA Agricultural Handbook 553, Washington, DC, USA, pp. 60-77.
79. Turner M.G., Baker W.L., Peterson C.J., Peet R.K. Factors influencing succession: lessons from large, infrequent natural disturbances. Ecosystems 1998, 1:511-523.
80. Turner M.G., Gardner R.H., O'Niell R.V. Landscape Ecology in Theory and Practice Pattern and Process 2001, Springer-Verlag, New York.
81. US Congress, 2003. House Resolution 1904, Healthy Forests Restoration Act of 2003. 108th United States Congress, 1st Session, 7 January 2003. National Archives: Washington, DC.
82. US Forest Service, 2013. White Mountain Stewardship Contract <> (accessed 12.12.13). http://www.fs.usda.gov/detail/asnf/workingtogether/partnerships/?cid=STELPRDB5206733.
83. US Department of Agriculture (USDA), 2013. Land Management Planning Handbook (draft). Proposed FS 1909.12, version 02/14/2013. Available at <>. http://www.fs.usda.gov/goto/planningrule/directives.
84. Vose J.M., White A.S. Processes of understory seedling recruitment 1 year after prescribed fire in an Arizona ponderosa pine community. Can. J. Bot. 1987, 65:2280-2290.
85. Wadleigh, L. 2011. Wallow Fire 2011; Large Scale Event Recovery Fire/Fuels Report. Apache-Sitgreaves National Forest, Southwestern Region. July 29, 2011.
86. Westerling A.L., Hidalgo H.G., Cayan D.R., Swetnam T.W. Warming and earlier spring increase western US forest wildfire activity. Science 2006, 313:940-943.