Patient and public involvement in research in the English NHS: A documentary analysis of the complex interplay of evidence and policy

Evidence and Policy

Volumn 10, Issue 3, 2014, Pages 361-377

  Evans, David ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF THE WEST OF ENGLAND   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Evidence; Patient and public involvement; Policy; Research

Indexed keywords

EID: 84906994523     PISSN: 17442648     EISSN: 17442656     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1332/174426413X662770     Document Type: Article

References (74)

1. Abbott, S, Shaw, S, Elston, J, 2004, Comparative analysis of health policy implementation: The use of documentary analysis Policy Studies, 25, 4, 259-66.
2. Baxter, L, Thorn, L, Mitchell, A, 2001, Small voices big noises: Lay involvement in health research: Lessons from other fields Exeter: University of Exeter.
3. Beresford, P, 2002, User involvement in research and evaluation: Liberation or regulation? Social Policy & Society, 1, 2, 95-105.
4. Blackburn, H, Hanley, B, Staley, K, 2010, Turning the pyramid upside down: Examples of public involvement in social care research Eastleigh: INVOLVE.
5. Boaz, A, Gough, D, 2011, Beyond the simple logic of evidence-based policy Evidence & Policy, 7, 4, 399-401.
6. Bowling, A, 2009, Research methods in health: Investigating health and health services Maidenhead: Open University Press.
7. Brett, J, Staniszewska, S, Mockford, C, Seers, K, Herron-Marx, S, Baylis, H, 2010, The PIRICON study: A systematic review of the conceptual ization measurement impact and outcomes of patient and public involvement in health and social care research London: UKCRC.
8. Buckland, S, Gorin, S, 2001, Involving consumers? An exploration of consumer involvement in NHS res earch and development managed by Department of Health regional offices Winchester: Consumers in NHS Research.
9. Cameron, A, Salisbury, C, Lart, R, Stewart, K, Peckham, S, Calnan, M, Purdy, S, Thorp, H, 2011, Policy makers' perceptions of the use of evidence from Evaluations Evidence & Policy, 7, 4, 429-47.
10. Chalmers, I, 1995, What do, I, want from health research and researchers when, I, am a patient? British Medical Journal, 310, (6990), 1315-18.
11. Consumers in NHS Research, 2000, Working partnerships: Consumers in NHS Research, 3rd annual report Winchester: Consumers in NHS Research.
12. Cooksey, D, 2006, A, review of UK health research funding London: HM Treasury.
13. Cowan, K, 2010, The James-Lind Alliance: Tackling treatment uncertainties together Ambulatory Care Management, 33, 3, 241-8.
14. Crawford, M, Rutter, D, Manley, C, Weaver, T, Bhui, K, Fulop, N, Tyrer, P, 2002, Systematic review of involving patients in the planning and development of health care British Medical Journal, 325, 1263-7.
15. Crawford, M, Rutter, D, Thelwell, S, 2003, User involvement in change management: A review of the literature London: NCCSDO.
16. Daykin, N, Evans, D, Petsoulas, C, Sayers, A, 2007, The impact of patient and public involvement initiatives on UK health services: A literature review Evidence & Policy, 3, 1, 47-65.
17. Department of Health, 1991, Research for health: A research and development strategy for the NHS London: Department of Health.
18. Department of Health, 1993, Research for health London: Department of Health.
19. Department of Health, 1994, Research and d evelopment in the new NHS: Functions and responsibilities London: Department of Health.
20. Department of Health, 1995, Consumers and research in the NHS: An R&D contribution to consumer involvement in the NHS London: Department of Health.
21. Department of Health, 1998, Research and development: Towards an evidence-base for health services public health and social care Information pack London: Department of Health.
22. Department of Health, 2000, Research and development for a first class service: R&D funding in the new NHS London: Department of Health.
23. Department of Health, 2001, a Research and development for a fi rst class service: Next steps London: Department of Health.
24. Department of Health, 2001, b Research governance framework for health and social care London: Department of Health.
25. Department of Health, 2004, Patient and public involvement in health: The evidence for policy implementation London: Department of Health.
26. Department of Health, 2005, a Best research for best health: A national health resea rch strategy The NHS contribution to health research in England: A consultation London: Department of Health.
27. Department of Health, 2005, b Research governance framework for health and social care:, 2nd edn London: Department of Health.
28. Department of Health, 2006, Best research for best health: A new national health research strategy London: Department of Health.
29. Dixon, P, Peart, E, Carr-Hill, R, 1999, A, database of examples of consumer involvement in research York: Centre for Health Economics University of York.
30. Dixon-Woods, M, Ashcroft, R, 2008, Regulation and the social licence for medical research Medical Health Care and Philosophy, 11, 381-91.
31. Duke, K, 2001, Evidence-based policymaking? The interplay between research and the development of prison drugs policy Criminal Justice, 1, 3, 277-300.
32. Elston, J, Fulop, N, 2002, Percept ions of partnership: A documentary analysis of Health Improvement Programmes Public Health, 116, 207-13.
33. Faulkner, A, 2010, Changing our worlds: Examples of user controlled research in action Eastleigh: INVOLVE.
34. Freeman, R, Maybin, J, 2011, Documents practices and policy Evidence & Policy, 7, 2, 155-70.
35. Goodare, H, Smith, R, 1995, The rights of patients in research British Medical Journal, 310, (6990), 1277-8.
36. Grant-Pearce, C, Miles, I, Hills, P, 1998, Mismatches in priorities for health research between professionals and consumers Manchester: PREST University of Manchester.
37. Greener, I, 2003, Who chosing what? The evolution of the use of choice in the NHS and its importance for New Labour in Bochel, C, Ellison, N, Powell, M, (eds) Social Policy Review, 15, Br istol: Policy Press.
38. Greenhalgh, T, Russell, J, 2009, Evidence-based policymaking: A critique Perspectives in Biology and Medicine, 52, 2, 304-18.
39. Hanley, B, Bradburn, J, Gorin, S, Barnes, M, Evans, C, Goodare, H, Kelson, M, Kent, A, Oliver, S, Thomas, S, Wallcraft J2000, Involving the public in NHS public health and social care research: Briefing notes for researchers Eastleigh: Consumers in NHS Research.
40. Hanley, B, Bradburn, J, Barnes, M, Evans, C, Goodare, H, Kelson, M, Kent, A, Oliver, S, Thomas, S, Wallcraft, J, 2004, Involving the public in NHS public health and social care research: Briefing notes for researchers, 2nd edn Eastleigh: INVOLVE.
41. Hanney, S, Kuruvilla, S, Soper, B, Mays, N, 2010, Who needs what from a national health research system: Lessons fr om reforms to the English Department of Health's R&D system Health Research Policy and Systems, 8, 11.
42. Hogg, C, 2007, Patient and public involvement: What next for the NHS? Health Expectations, 10, 2, 129-38.
43. INVOLVE, 2003, Strategic plan, 2003-06: Creating the expert resource Eastleigh: INVOLVE.
44. INVOLVE, 2006, Report of a workshop: Researching public involvement in research Eastleigh: INVOLVE.
45. INVOLVE, 2007, a InvoNET biography, 1, Eastleigh: INVOLVE.
46. INVOLVE, 2007, b Strategic plan, 2007-11, Eastleigh: INVOLVE.
47. INVOLVE, 2009, InvoNET biography, 2, Eastleigh: INVOLVE.
48. INVOLVE, 2010, InvoNET biography, 3, Eastleigh: INVOLVE.
49. INVOLVE, 2012, About INVOLVE www.invo.og.uk.
50. Mockford, C, Staniszewska, S, Griffiths, F, Herron-Marx, S, 2011, The impact of patient and public involvement on UK NHS health care: A systematic review International Journal for Quality in Health Care, 24, 1, 28-38.
51. National Health Service Research and Development Taskforce, 1994, Supporting research and development in the NHS London: HMSO.
52. National Institute of Health, 2011, Getting involved at NIH http://getinvolved.nih. gov/.
53. Nilsen, E, Myrhaug, H, Johansen, M, Oliver, S, Oxman, A, 2006, Methods of consumer involvement in developing healthcare policy and research clinical practice guidelines and patient information material Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 3.
54. Nutley, S, Walter, I, Davies, H, 2007, Using evidence: How research can inform public service Bristol: Policy Press.
55. Mulgan, G, 2005, Government knowledge and the business of policy making: The potential and limits of evidence-based policy Evidence & Policy, 1, 2, 215-226.
56. Oliver, S, 1995, How can health serv ice users contribute to the NHS research and development programme? British Medical Journal, 310, (6990), 1318-20.
57. Oliver, S, Buchanan, P, 1997, Examples of lay involvement in research and development London: EPI-Centre Institute of Education.
58. Oliver, S, Clarke-Jones, L, Rees, R, Milne, R, Buchanan, P, Gabbay, J, Gyte, G, Oakley, A, Stein, K, 2004, Involving consumers in resear ch and development agenda setting for the NHS: Developing an evidence-based approach Health Technology Assessment, 8, 15, 1-148.
59. Saunders, C, Girgis, A, 2010, Status challenges and facilitators of consumer involvement in Australian health and medical research Health Research Policy and Systems, 8, 34.
60. Shergold, M, Grant, J, 2008, Freedom and need: The evolution of public strategy for biomedical and health research in England Health Research Policy and Systems, 6, 2.
61. Simpson, E, House, A, 2002, Involving users in the delivery and evaluation of mental health services: Systematic review British Medical Journal, 325, 1265.
62. Smith, E, Manthorpe, J, Brearley, S, Ross, F, Donovan, S, Sitzia, J, Beresford, P, 2005, User involvement in the design and undertaking of nursing midwifery and health visiting research London: NCCSDO.
63. Staley, K, 2009, Exploring impact: Public involvement in NHS public health and social care research Eastleigh: INVOLVE.
64. Staley, K, Buckland, S, Hayes, H, Tarpey, M, 2012, The missing links: Understanding how context and mechanism influence the impact of public involvement in research Health Expectations DOI:, 10.1111/hex.12017.
65. Standing Advisory Group on Consumer Involvement in the NHS Research and Development Programme, 1998a Health research: What's in it for consumers? Hassocks: Standing Advisory Group on Consumer Involvement in the NHS Research and Development Programme.
66. Standing Advisory Group on Consumer Involvement in the NHS Research and Development Programme, 1998b Research: What's in it for me? Conference report Hassocks: Standing Advisory Group on Consumer Involvement in the NHS Research and Development Programme.
67. Standing Advisory Group on Consumer Involvement in the NHS Res earch and Development Programme, 1999, Involvement works: The second report of the Standing Group of Consumers in NHS Research Winchester: Standing Advisory Group on Consumer Involvement in the NHS Research and Development Programme.
68. Tarpey, M, Faulkner, A, 2011, The publication of articles in relation to PPI in research: A scoping study unpublished paper Eastleigh: INVOLVE.
69. Two Can Associates, 2009, An evaluation of the process and impact of patient and public involvement in the advisory groups of the UK Clinical Research Collaboration London: UKCRC.
70. UKCRC, 2008, Patient and public involvement strategic plan, 2008-2011, London: UKCRC.
71. Wale, J, Colombo, C, Belizan, M, Nadel, J, 2010, International health consumers in the Cochrane Collaboration: Fifteen years on Journal of Ambulatory Care Management, 33, 3, 182-9.
72. Wa rd, P, Thompson, J, Barber, R, Armitage, C, Boote, J, Cooper, C, Jones, G, 2010, Critical perspectives on consumer involvement in health research: Epistemological dissonance and the know-do gap Journal of Sociology, 46, 1, 63-82.
73. Weiss, C, 1979, The many meanings of research utilisation Public Administration Review, 39, 5, 426-31.
74. Wells, P, 2007, New Labour and evidence based policymaking:, 1997-, 2007, People Place & Policy Online, 1, 1, 22-29