Human Capital Theory: A Holistic Criticism

Review of Educational Research

Volumn 84, Issue 3, 2014, Pages 411-445

  Tan, Emrullah ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF EXETER BUSINESS SCHOOL   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

human capital; neoclassical economics; rational choice theory

Indexed keywords

EID: 84905097987     PISSN: 00346543     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.3102/0034654314532696     Document Type: Article

References (145)

1. Acemoglu D.Reward structures and the allocation of talent.European Economic Review. 1995;39 (1): 17-33.
2. Arrow K. J.Methodological individualism and social knowledge.American Economic Association Papers and Proceedings. 1994;84 (2): 1-9.
3. Ayton P.Cognitive psychology. Braisby N.Gellatly A., ed. Florence, Italy: Oxford University Press; 2012:298-394.
4. Azzi C.,Ehrenberg R.Household allocation of time and church attendance.Journal of Political Economy. 1975;83 (1): 27-56.
5. Ball S.New voices, new knowledges and the new politics of education research: The gathering of a perfect storm?.European Educational Research Journal. 2010;9 (2): 124-137.
6. BassaniniA.ScarpettaS. (2001). Does human capital matter for growth in OECD countries: Evidence from pooled mean-group estimates (OECD Economics Department Working Papers, No. 282). Retrieved from http://dx.doi.org/10.1787/424300244276.
7. Battu H.,Belfield C.,Sloane P.How well can we measure graduate overeducation and its effects?.National Institute Economic Review. 2000;171 (1): 82-93.
8. BBC. (2010, March9). Call to scrap 50% university student target. Retrieved from http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/education/8556231.stm.
9. BBC. (2013, October2). David Cameron suggests cutting benefits for under-25s. Retrieved from www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-24369514.
10. BeckerG. S. (1960). An economic analysis of fertility. In CoaleA. J. (Ed.), Demographic and economic change in developed countries (pp. 209-240). New York, NY: Columbia University Press. Retrieved from http://www.nber.org/chapters/c2387.pdf.
11. Becker G. S.The economic approach to human behavior. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press; 1976:.
12. Becker G. S.Human capital: A theoretical and empirical analysis, with special reference to education. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press; 1993a:.
13. BeckerG. S. (1993b). Economic imperialism. Religion & Liberty, 3(2). Retrieved from http://www.acton.org/pub/religion-liberty/volume-3-number-2/economic-imperialism.
14. BeckerG. S.EwaldF. (2012). Becker on Ewald on Foucault on Becker. Public law and legal theory (Working Paper No. 401). University of Chicago. Retrieved from http://www.law.uchicago.edu/files/file/401-bh-Becker.pdf.
15. Becker G. S.,Landes W. M.Essays in the economics of crime and punishment. New York, NY: Colombia University Press; 1974:.
16. Becker G. S.,Stigler G. J.De gustibus non est disputandum [In matters of taste, there is no dispute].American Economic Review. 1977;67 (2): 76-90.
17. Benhabib J.,Spiegel M. M.The role of human capital in economic development.Journal of Monetary Economics. 1994;34 (2): 143-173.
18. BentataP. (2009). Replacing neo-classical maximization in the realm of human action (CAE Working Papers, No. 63). Marseille, France: Centre d' Analyse Economique. Retrieved from http://junon.u-3mrs.fr/afa10w21/RePEc/cgm/wpaper/DR_63_0910.Bentata.pdf.
19. Bentham J.An introduction to the principles of morals and legislation. Edinburgh, Scotland: Stevenson; 1789:.
20. BlairT. (1999, September28). Tony Blair's full speech. The Guardian. Retrieved from http://www.guardian.co.uk/politics/1999/sep/28/labourconference.labour14.
21. Blaug M.The empirical status of human capital theory: A slightly jaundiced survey.Journal of Economic Literature. 1976;14 (3): 827-855.
22. Blaug M.New York: New York University Press; 1987:.
23. Blaug M.The methodology of economics: Or how economists explain. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press; 1992:.
24. BonannoG. (2012). Signaling (Lecture notes). Retrieved http://www.econ.ucdavis.edu/faculty/bonanno/teaching/200C/Signaling.pdf.
25. Bowles S.,Gintis H.Schooling in capitalist America revisited.Sociology of Education. 2002;75 (1): 1-18.
26. Bröckling U.Governmentality: Current issues and future challenges. Bröckling U.Krasmann S.Lemke T., ed. New York, NY: Routledge; 2011:1-33.
27. Brown S.,Sessions J. G.Education and employment status: A test of the strong screening hypothesis in Italy.Economics of Education Review. 1999;18 (4): 397-404.
28. Brown S.,Sessions J. G.International handbook on the economics of education. Johnes G.Johnes J., ed. Cheltenham, England: Edward Elgar; 2005:58-100.
29. Brown S. L.,Brown R. M.,Preston S.Moving beyond self-interest: Perspectives from evolutionary biology, neuroscience, and the social sciences. Brown S. L.Brown R. M.Penner L., ed. New York, NY: Oxford University Press; 2011:75-88.
30. Buchanan J. M.Positive economics, welfare economics, and political economy.Journal of Law and Economics. 1959;2 (1): 124-138.
31. Buchanan J. M.,Tullock G.The calculus of consent. Ann Arbor: Michigan Press; 1962:.
32. Burchell G.,Gordon C.,Miller P.The Foucault effect: Studies in governmentality. London, England: Harvester Wheatsheaf; 1991:.
33. Caselli F.,Esquivel G.,Lefort F.Reopening the convergence debate.Journal of Economic Growth. 1996;1 (3): 363-389.
34. Castagnetti C.,Chelli F.,Rosti L.Educational performance as signaling device: Evidence from Italy.Economics Bulletin. 2005;9 (4): 1-7.
35. Cawley J.,Heckman J. J.,Vytlacil E. J.Three observations on wages and measured cognitive ability.Labour Economics. 2001;8 (4): 419-442.
36. Clark A.Signaling and screening in a transition economy: Three empirical models applied to Russia. Edinburgh, England: Herriot-Watt University CERT; 2000:.
37. Coffield F.Breaking the consensus: Lifelong learning as social control.British Education Research Journal. 1999;25 (4): 479-499.
38. Cohn E.,Kiker B.,De Oliveira M.Further evidence on the screening hypothesis.Economic Letters. 1987;25 (3): 289-294.
39. Cunningham P. M.Critical pedagogy and implications for HRD.Advances in Developing Human Resources. 2004;6 (2): 226-240.
40. Darmon I.,Frade C.,Hadjivassiliou K.Why's the beer up north always stronger Studies of lifelong learning in Europe. Coffield F., ed. Bristol, England: Policy Press; 1999:31-42.
41. Higher education: Students are at the hearth of the system. London, England: Stationery Office; 2011:.
42. Department for Education & Employment. (1998). The learning age: A renaissance for a new Britain (Report No. 3790). London, England: Stationary Office. Retrieved from http://www.lifelonglearning.co.uk/greenpaper/index.htm.
43. Dessus S.Human capital and growth: The recovered role of education systems. Jerusalem: OECD Development Centre; 1999:.
44. Di John JFrom windfall to curse? Oil and industrialization in Venezuela, 1920 to the present. University Park: Penn State University Press; 2009:.
45. Dilts A.From entrepreneur of the self to care of the self: Neoliberal governmentality and Foucault's ethics.Foucault Studies. 2011;12:130-146.
46. Elster J.Marxism, functionalism, and game theory.Theory and Society. 1982;11 (4): 453-482.
47. Elster J.Rational choice. Oxford, England: Basil Blackwell; 1986:.
48. European Parliament. (2000). Lisbon European council presidency conclusion. Retrieved from http://www.europarl.europa.eu/summits/lis1_en.htm.
49. Fang H.Disentangling the college wage premium: Estimating a model with endogenous education choices. New Haven, CT: Yale University; 2001:.
50. Fevre R.,Rees G.,Gorard S.Some sociological alternatives to human capital theory and their implications.Journal of Education and Work. 1999;12 (2): 117-140.
51. Field J.Governing the ungovernable: Why lifelong learning policies promise so much yet deliver so little.Educational Management Administration & Leadership. 2000;28 (3): 249-261.
52. Foucault M.Birth of bio-politics. London, England: Palgrave Macmillan; 1979:.
53. Friedman M.Essays in positive economics. Chicago, IL: Chicago University Press; 1953:3-43.
54. García-Mainar I.,Monteuenga-Gómez V. M.Education returns of wage earners and self-employed workers: Portugal vs. Spain.Economics of Education Review. 2005;24 (2): 161-170.
55. Garibaldi P.Personnel economics in imperfect labor markets. Oxford, England: Oxford Press; 2006:.
56. Glimcher P. W.Foundations of neuroeconomic analysis. New York, NY: Oxford University Press; 2011:.
57. Gonzalez N.,Oyelere R. H.Are returns to education on the decline?.Economics of Education Review. 2011;30 (6): 1348-1369.
58. GoodwinN. R. (2003). Five kinds of capital: Useful concepts for sustainable development (Working Paper No. 03-07). Medford, MA: Global Development and Environment Institute. Retrieved from www.ase.tufts.edu/gdae/publications/working_papers/03-07sustainabledevelopment.PDF.
59. Green D. P.,Shapiro I.Pathologies of rational choice theory. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press; 1994:.
60. GreenS. L. (2002). Rational choice theory: An overview. Waco, TX: Baylor University. Retrieved from http://business.baylor.edu/steve_green/green1.doc.
61. Groot W.,Maassen van den Brink H.Overeducation in the labor market: A meta-analysis.Economics of Education Review. 2000;19 (2): 149-158.
62. Hall R. E.,Jones C.Why do some countries produce so much more output per worker than others?.Quarterly Journal of Economics. 1999;114 (1): 83-116.
63. Hammond J. L.The resource curse and oil revenues in Angola and Venezuela.Science and Society. 2011;75 (3): 348-378.
64. Hechter M.,Kanazawa S.Sociological rational choice theory.Annual Review of Sociology. 1997;23:91-214.
65. Herfeld C.The potentials and limitations of rational choice theory: An interview with Gary Becker.Erasmus Journal for Philosophy and Economics. 2012;5 (1): 73-86.
66. Heywood J. S.,Wei X.Education and signaling: Evidence from a highly competitive labor market.Education Economics. 2004;12 (1): 1-16.
67. Hinman L. M.Ethics: A pluralistic approach to moral theory. Belmont, CA: Thomson Higher Education; 2008:.
68. Hirsch F.Social limitation to growth. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press; 1976:.
69. Hodgson G.The evolution of institutional economics. London, England: Routledge; 2004:.
70. Hodkinson P.,Sparkes A. C.,Hodkinson H.Triumphs and tears: Young people, markets, and the transition from school to work. London, England: David Fulton; 1996:.
71. Hsee C. K.,Lowenstein G. F.,Blount S.,Bazerman M. H.Preference reversals between joint and separate evaluations of option: A review and theoretical analysis.Psychological Bulletin. 1999;125 (5): 576-590.
72. Hyslop-Margison E.,Sears A.Neoliberalism, globalization and human capital learning: Reclaiming education for democratic citizenship. Dordrecht, Netherlands: Springer; 2006:.
73. Iannaccone L. R.Introduction to the economics of religion.Journal of Economic Literature. 1998;36 (3): 1465-1496.
74. Islam N.Growth empirics: A panel data approach.Quarterly Journal of Economics. 1995;110 (4): 1127-1170.
75. Jaeger D.,Page M.Degrees matter: New evidence on sheepskin effects in the returns to education.Review of Economics and Statistics. 1996;76 (4): 733-739.
76. Jenkins A.,Jones L.,Ward A.The long-term effects of a degree on graduate lives.Studies in Higher Education. 2001;26 (2): 247-261.
77. Johnes G.The economics of education. Hong Kong: Macmillan; 1993:.
78. Jolls C.,Sunstein S. R.,Thaler R.A behavioral approach to law and economics.Stanford Law Review. 1998;50 (5): 1471-1550.
79. JonesC. I. (1996). Human capital, ideas and economic growth (Mimeo). Stanford, CA: Stanford University. Retrieved from http://www.stanford.edu/~chadj/Rome100.pdf.
80. Kahneman D.Maps of bounded rationality: Psychology for behavioral economics.American Economic Review. 2003;93:1449-1475.
81. Kahneman D.Thinking, fast and slow. London, England: Penguin; 2012:.
82. Kahneman D.,Tversky A.The framing of decisions and the psychology of choice.Science. 1981;211:453-458.
83. Kahneman D.,Tversky A.Choices, values, and frames. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press; 2000:.
84. Karabel J.,Halsey A. H.Power and ideology in education. New York, NY: Oxford University Press; 1997:.
85. Karl T. L.The paradox of plenty: Oil booms and petro-states. Berkeley: University of California Press; 1997:.
86. Kiker B. F.The historical roots of the concept of human capital.Journal of Political Economy. 1966;74 (5): 481-499.
87. KrugmanP. (2009, September2). How did economist get it so wrong?New York Times. Retrieved from http://www.nytimes.com/2009/09/06/magazine/06Economic-t.html?pagewanted=all&_r=0.
88. Liu P. W.,Wong Y. C.Educational screening by certificates: An empirical test.Economic Inquiry. 1982;20 (1): 72-83.
89. Luth A. H.Behavioural economics in consumer policy: Economic analysis of standard terms in consumer contracts revisited. Rotterdam, Netherlands: Erasmus University; 2010:.
90. Machlup F.The economics of information and human capital. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press; 1984:.
91. Mankiw G.,Romer D.,Weil D.A contribution to the empirics of economic growth.Quarterly Journal of Economics. 1992;107 (2): 407-437.
92. Mankiw N. G.,Gans J.,King S.,Stonecash R.Principles of economics. South Melbourne, Victoria, Australia: Cengage Learning; 2012:.
93. Manktelow K.Reasoning and thinking. Hove, England: Psychology Press; 2000:.
94. Marginson S.Human capital theory and education policy. New South Wales, Australia: University of New South Wales; 1989:.
95. Marginson S.Education and public policy in Australia. Melbourne, Australia: Cambridge University Press; 1993:.
96. Marginson S.Markets in education. Crows Nest, New South Wales, Australia: Allen & Unwin; 1997:.
97. Marks A.,Turner E.,Osborne M.Not for the likes of me: The overlapping effect of social class and gender factors in the decision made by adults not to participate in higher education.Journal of Further and Higher Education. 2003;27 (4): 347-364.
98. Marshall A.Principles of economics. London, England: Macmillan; 1920:.
99. McGuinness S.Overeducation in the labour market.Journal of Economic Surveys. 2006;20 (3): 387-418.
100. McKenzie R. B.Predictably rational?. Berlin, Germany: Springer; 2010:.
101. Mehlum H.,Moene K.,Torvik R.Institutions and the resource curse.Economic Journal. 2006;116 (508): 1-20.
102. Mejia D.,Pierre M.Unequal opportunities and human capital formation.Journal of Development Economics. 2008;86 (2): 395-413.
103. Menger C.Investigation into the method of the social sciences. New York: New York University Press; 1985:.
104. Mill J. S.Principles of political economy. London, England: Longman; 1909:.
105. Nussbaum M. C. C.Not for profits: Why democracy needs the humanities. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press; 2010:.
106. OECD. (2001). Glossary of statistical terms. Retrieved from http://stats.oecd.org/glossary/detail.asp?ID=1264.
107. Ortega D.,Pritchett L.Venezuela before Chavez: Anatomy of an economic collapse. Hausmann R.Rodriguez F., ed. University Park: Penn State University Press; 2014:187-206.
108. Patrinos H. A.,Sakellariou C.Economic volatility and returns to education in Venezuela: 1992-2002.Applied Economics. 2006;38:1991-2005.
109. PissaridesC. A. (2000). Human capital and growth: A synthesis report (Technical Paper No. 168). Retrieved from http://www.oecd.org/social/poverty/1922754.pdf.
110. Pritchett L.Where has all the education gone?.World Bank Economic Review. 2001;15 (3): 367-391.
111. Pritchett L.Does schooling help explain any of the big facts about growth. Cambridge, MA: Harvard Kennedy School of Government; 2009:.
112. Psacharopoulos G.On the weak versus strong version of the screening hypothesis.Economic Letters. 1979;4 (2): 181-185.
113. Purcell K.,Pitcher J.Great expectations: The new diversity of graduate skills and aspirations. Manchester, England: CSU; 1996:.
114. QuintiniG. (2011). Over-qualified or under-skilled: A review of existing literature (Working Papers, No. 121). Retrieved from http://dx.doi.org/10.1787/5kg58j9d7b6d-en.
115. Read J.A genealogy of homo economicus: Neoliberalism and the production of subjectivity.Foucault Studies. 2009;6:25-36.
116. RodríguezP.MoralesJ.MonaldiF. (2012). Direct distribution of oil revenues in Venezuela: A viable alternative? (Working Paper No. 306). Retrieved from http://www.cgdev.org/files/1426486_file_Rodriguez_et_al_Venezuela_OTC_FINAL.pdf.
117. Rose N.Powers of freedom: Re-framing political thought. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press; 1999:.
118. Schuller T.,Burns A.Why's the beer up north always stronger? Studies of lifelong learning in Europe. Coffield F., ed. Bristol, England: Policy Press; 1999:51-61.
119. Schultz T.Investment in human capital.American Economic Review. 1961;51 (1): 1-17.
120. Schultz T. W.Investment in man: An economist's view.Social Service Review. 1959;33 (2): 109-117.
121. Schumpeter J.Methodological individualism. Brussels, Belgium: Institutum Europæum; 1980:.
122. Scott J. F.Understanding contemporary society: Theories of the present. Halcli A.Browning G.Webster F., ed. London, England: Sage; 2000:126-138.
123. Sen A.Utility and probability. Eatwell J.Milgate M.Newman P., ed. New York, NY: W. W. Norton; 1990:198-216.
124. Shaffer H. G.Investment in human capital: comment.American Economic Review. 1961;51 (5): 1026-1035.
125. Simon H. A.Rational choice and the structure of the environment.Psychological Review. 1956;63 (2): 129-138.
126. Slaughter S.,Rhoades G.Academic capitalism and the new economy: Markets, state, and higher education. Baltimore, MD: John Hopkins University Press; 2004:.
127. Soldatos G.Economics of education and work incentives.Labour. 1999;13 (2): 433-443.
128. Spence M.Job market signaling.Quarterly Journal of Economics. 1973;87 (3): 355-374.
129. Stigler G.The theory of price. New York, NY: Macmillan; 1987:.
130. Stuart M.Learning in partnership: Responding to the restructuring of the European steel and metal sector. 2005;:.
131. SueD. R. (2004). Cognitive anomalies and the assumption of economic rationality: An empirical investigation of UNC students. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina. Retrieved from http://econ.duke.edu/uploads/assets/dje/2004_Symp/Douglas%20Sue.pdf.
132. Swedberg R.Economics and sociology, redefining their boundaries: Conversations with economists and sociologists. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press; 1990:.
133. SzelényiI. (2011, March5). Smith: The invisible hand [Video]. Retrieved from http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d_ffla6X4Ps&feature=player_detailpage#t=213s.
134. Torvik R.Natural resources, rent seeking and welfare.Journal of Development Economics. 2002;67 (2): 455-470.
135. Tsang M.The impact of underutilisation of education of productivity: A case study of the U.S. Bell companies.Economics of Education Review. 1987;11:239-234.
136. Tullock G.The welfare costs of tariffs, monopolies, and theft.Western Economic Journal. 1967;5 (3): 224-232.
137. Tversky A.,Slovic P.,Kahneman D.The causes of preference reversal.American Economic Review. 1990;80 (1): 204-217.
138. Udehn L.The changing face of methodological individualism.Annual Review of Sociology. 2002;28:479-507.
139. Van der Sluis J.,Van Praag C. M.Economic returns to education for entrepreneurs: The development of a neglected child in the family of economics of education?.Swedish Economic Policy Review. 2004;11 (2): 183-226.
140. Verhofstadt E.,De Witte H.,Omey E.The impact of education on job satisfaction in the first job.International Journal of Manpower. 2007;28 (2): 135-151.
141. Walker I.,Zhu Y.The college wage premium, overeducation and the expansion of higher education in the UK.Scandinavian Journal of Economics. 2005;110 (4): 695-709.
142. WeintraubE. R. (1993). Neoclassical economics. Library of Economics and Liberty. Retrieved from http://www.econlib.org/library/Enc1/NeoclassicalEconomics.html.
143. Weiss A.Human capital vs. signaling explanations of wages.Journal of Economic Perspectives. 1995;9 (4): 133-154.
144. Wolf A.Does education matter? Myths about education and economic growth. London, England: Penguin; 2002:.
145. World Bank. (2010). Silent and lethal: How quiet corruption undermines Africa's development efforts. Retrieved from http://siteresources.worldbank.org/AFRICAEXT/Resources/english_essay_adi2010.pdf.