Impact of management strategies on the global warming potential at the cropping system level

Science of the Total Environment

Volumn 490, Issue , 2014, Pages 921-933

  Goglio, Pietro ^a   Grant, Brian B ^a   Smith, Ward N ^a   Desjardins, Raymond L ^a   Worth, Devon E ^a   Zentner, Robert ^b   Malhi, Sukhdev S ^c  

^a OTTAWA RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT CENTRE   (Canada)

^b Swift Current Research Station Swift Current   (Canada)

^c Melfort Research Farm   (Canada)

Author keywords

Crop management; Cropping systems; DNDC; Energy demand; GWP; LCA

Indexed keywords

AGRICULTURE; CARBON DIOXIDE; ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT; GLOBAL WARMING; GREENHOUSE GASES; LIFE CYCLE; NITROGEN FERTILIZERS; NITROGEN OXIDES;

CROP MANAGEMENTS; CROPPING SYSTEMS; DNDC; ENERGY DEMANDS; GWP; LCA;

INFORMATION MANAGEMENT;

AMMONIA; CARBON DIOXIDE; NITROGEN FERTILIZER; NITROUS OXIDE; FERTILIZER;

AGRICULTURAL MANAGEMENT; CROP PRODUCTION; CROPPING PRACTICE; ENVIRONMENTAL CHANGE; FARMING SYSTEM; GLOBAL WARMING; GREENHOUSE EFFECT; LIFE CYCLE ANALYSIS; NATURE-SOCIETY RELATIONS; STRATEGIC APPROACH;

ARTICLE; BIOMASS PRODUCTION; CANADA; CARBON FOOTPRINT; CLIMATE CHANGE; CROP MANAGEMENT; CROPPING SYSTEM; ENERGY CONSUMPTION; ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT; ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT; FERTILIZER APPLICATION; GREENHOUSE EFFECT; LIFE CYCLE ASSESSMENT; PRIORITY JOURNAL; SOIL PROPERTY; VOLATILIZATION; WASTE MANAGEMENT; AGRICULTURE; AIR POLLUTION; ANALYSIS; CROP; GROWTH, DEVELOPMENT AND AGING; PREVENTION AND CONTROL; PROCEDURES; STATISTICS AND NUMERICAL DATA;

ALBERTA; BRETON; CANADA; ELLERSLIE;

AGRICULTURE; AIR POLLUTION; CLIMATE CHANGE; CROPS, AGRICULTURAL; FERTILIZERS; GLOBAL WARMING; GREENHOUSE EFFECT;

EID: 84901990029     PISSN: 00489697     EISSN: 18791026     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2014.05.070     Document Type: Article

References (83)

1. AAFC The Canadian system of soil classification, 3rd edition. Canadian soil resource group. Agriculture agri-food Canada Available online:, [accessed on 15 Apr 2013]. http://sis.agr.gc.ca/cansis/taxa/cssc3/intro.html.
2. AARD Alberta agriculture and rural development: decision making tools. Alberta agriculture and rural development Available online:, [accessed on 4 Mar 2013]. http://www.agriculture.alberta.ca/app21/ldcalc.
3. Adler P.R., Grosso S.J.D., Parton W.J. Life-cycle assessment of net greenhouse-gas flux for bioenergy cropping systems. Ecol Appl 2007, 17(3):675-691.
4. Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada Cansis weather database Available online:, [accessed on 8 Aug 2006]. http://sisintprd.agr.gc.ca/cansis/nsdb/climate/wthrquery.html.
5. Archer D.W., Halvorson A.D. Greenhouse gas mitigation economics for irrigated cropping systems in northeastern Colorado. J Soil Sci Soc Am 2010, 74(2):446-452.
6. ASABE ASAE D497.4 FEB03 agricultural machinery management data. St. Joseph, Michigan: American Society of Agricultural and Biological Engineers 2003.
7. Audsley E., Alber S., Clift R., Cowell S., Crettaz P., Gaillard G., et al. Harmonisation of environmental life cycle assessment for agriculture. Final report. Concerted action AIR3-CT94-2028. Silsoe: Silsoe Research Institute 1997, European Commission DG VI Agriculture, Brussels.
8. Biswas W.K., Barton L., Carter D. Global warming potential of wheat production in Western Australia: a life cycle assessment. Water and Env J 2008, 22(3):206-216.
9. Bolinder M.A., Janzen H.H., Gregorich E.G., Angers D.A., VandenBygaart A.J. An approach for estimating net primary productivity and annual carbon inputs to soil for common agricultural crops in Canada. Agric Ecosyst Environ 2007, 118(1-4):29-42.
10. Börjesson P., Tufvesson L.M. Agricultural crop-based biofuels - resource efficiency and environmental performance including direct land use changes. J Clean Prod 2011, 19(2-3):108-120.
11. Brady N., Weil R. The nature and properties of soils, 13th edition. Upper Saddle River 2002, Prentice Hall, New Jersey.
12. Brentrup F., Küsters J., Kuhlmann H., Lammel J. Environmental impact assessment of agricultural production systems using the life cycle assessment methodology. I. Theoretical concept of a LCA method tailored to crop production. Eur J Agron 2004, 20(3):247-264.
13. Brentrup F., Küsters J., Lammel J., Barraclough P., Kuhlmann H. Environmental impact assessment of agricultural production systems using the life cycle assessment (LCA) methodology II. The application to N fertilizer use in winter wheat production systems. Eur J Agron 2004, 20:265-279.
14. Camargo G.G.T., Ryan M.R., Richard T.L. Energy use and greenhouse gas emissions from crop production using the farm energy analysis tool. Biosci 2013, 63(4):263-273.
15. Campbell C.A., Selles F., Zentner R.P., McConkey B.G., Brandt S.A., McKenzie R.C. Regression model for predicting yield of hard red spring wheat grown on stubble in the semiarid prairie. Can J Plant Sci 1997, 77(1):43-52.
16. Campbell C.A., Selles F., Lafond G.P., Zentner R.P. Adopting zero tillage management: impact on soil C and N under long-term crop rotations in a thin Black Chernozem. Can J Soil Sci 2001, 81(2):139-148.
17. Campbell C.A., Selles F., De Jong R., Zentner R.P., Hamel C., Lemke R., et al. Effect of crop rotations on NO3 leached over 17years in a medium-textured Brown Chernozem. Can J Soil Sci 2006, 86(1):109-118.
18. Campbell C.A., Selles F., Zentner R.P., De Jong R., Lemke R., Hamel C. Nitrate leaching in the semiarid prairie: effect of cropping frequency, crop type, and fertilizer after 37years. Can J Soil Sci 2006, 86(4):701-710.
19. CANSTAT Estimated areas, yield, production, average farm price and total farm value of principal field crops. Imperial units annual. Ottawa: Statistics Canada 2013.
20. Chang C., Entz T. Nitrate leaching losses under repeated cattle feedlot manure applications in southern Alberta. J Environ Qual 1996, 25(1):145-153.
21. Charles R., Jolliet O., Gaillard G., Pellet D. Environmental analysis of intensity level in wheat crop production using life cycle assessment. Agric Ecosyst Environ 2006, 113(1-4):216-225.
22. 2 emissions from lime and urea application. IPCC Guidelines for National Greenhouse Gas Inventories 2006, 11.1-11.54. IPCC International Panel on Climate Change, Geneva. M. Gytarsky, T. Hiraishi, W. Irving, T. Krug, J. Penman (Eds.).
23. Del Grosso S.J., Mosier A., Parton W., Ojima D. DAYCENT model analysis of past and contemporary soil NO and net greenhouse gas flux for major crops in the USA. Soil Tillage Res 2005, 83(1):9-24.
24. Del Grosso S., Halvorson A., Parton W. Testing DAYCENT model simulations of corn yields and nitrous oxide emissions in irrigated tillage systems in Colorado. J Environ Qual 2008, 37(4):1383-1389.
25. Dendooven L., Patino-Zuniga L., Verhulst N., Luna-Guido M., Marsch R., Govaerts B. Global warming potential of agricultural systems with contrasting tillage and residue management in the central highlands of Mexico. Agric Ecosyst Environ 2012, 152.
26. Dyer J.A., Desjardins R.L. Simulated farm fieldwork, energy consumption and related greenhouse gas emissions in Canada. Biosyst Eng 2003, 85(4):503-513.
27. 2 emissions from fossil fuel use for farm fieldwork related to harvesting annual crops and hay, changing tillage practices and reduced summerfallow in Canada. J Sustain Agric 2005, 25(3):141-155.
28. Dyer J.A., Desjardins R.L. Carbon dioxide emissions associated with the manufacturing of tractors and farm machinery in Canada. Biosyst Eng 2006, 93(1):107-118.
29. Dyer J.A., Vergé X.P.C., Desjardins R.L., Worth D.E., McConkey B.G. The impact of increased biodiesel production on the greenhouse gas emissions from field crops in Canada. Energy Sustain Dev 2010, 14(2):73-82.
30. Ellert B.H., Janzen H.H. Nitrous oxide, carbon dioxide and methane emissions from irrigated cropping systems as influenced by legumes, manure and fertilizer. Can J Soil Sci 2008, 88(2):207-217.
31. Environment Canada National Climate Data and Information Archive Available online:, [accessed on 2 Mar 2013]. http://climate.weatheroffice.gc.ca/climateData/canadae.html.
32. Franzluebbers A.J. Achieving soil organic carbon sequestration with conservation agricultural systems in the southeastern United States. Soil Sci Soc Am J 2010, 74(2):347-357.
33. Fujinuma R., Venterea R.T., Rosen C. Broadcast urea reduces NO but increases NO emissions compared with conventional and shallow-applied anhydrous ammonia in a coarse-textured soil. J Environ Qual 2011, 40(6):1806.
34. Gabrielle B., Gagnaire N. Life-cycle assessment of straw use in bio-ethanol production: a case study based on biophysical modelling. Biomass Bioenergy 2008, 32(5):431-441.
35. Gan Y., Liang C., Hamel C., Cutforth H., Wang H. Strategies for reducing the carbon footprint of field crops for semiarid areas. A review. Agron Sustain Dev 2011, 31(4):643-656.
36. Gasol C.M., Salvia J., Serra J., Antón A., Sevigne E., Rieradevall J., et al. A life cycle assessment of biodiesel production from winter rape grown in Southern Europe. Biomass Bioenergy 2012, 40:71-81.
37. Gelfand I., Snapp S.S., Robertson G.P. Energy efficiency of conventional, organic, and alternative cropping systems for food and fuel at a site in the U.S. midwest. Environ Sci Technol 2010, 44(10):4006-4011.
38. Goglio P., Bonari E., Mazzoncini M. LCA of cropping systems with different external input levels for energetic purposes. Biomass Bioenergy 2012, 42:33-42.
39. 2O emission reduction from a modelled low-greenhouse gas cropping system during 2009-2011. Environ Chem Lett 2013, 11(2):143-149.
40. Grant B.B., Smith W.N., Campbell C., Desjardins R.L., Lemke R.L., Kroebel R., et al. Comparison of DayCent and DNDC models: case studies using data from long-term experiments on the Canadian prairies. Advances in modeling agricultural systems: trans-disciplinary research, synthesize, modelling, and application. ASA-SSSA-CSSA book series Madison: ASA (American Society of Agronomy)-SSSA (Soil Science Society of America)-CSSA (Crop Science Society of America) 2014, (accepted). S. Del Grosso, B. Parton, G.P. Lajpat (Eds.).
41. Guinée J.B., Gorrée M., Heijungs R., Huppes G., Kleijn R., De Koning A., et al. Life cycle assessment - an operational guide to the iso standards. Ministry of Housing, Spatial Planning and Environment (VROM) and Centre of Environmental Science (CML), Den Haag and Leiden, Netherlands. Den Haag and Leiden: Ministry of Housing, Spatial Planning and Environment (VROM) and Centre of Environmental Science (CML) 2001.
42. Guinée J., Van Oers L., De Koning A., Tamis W. Life cycle approaches for conservation agriculture; Part I: A definition study for data analysis; Part II: Report of the Special Symposium on Life cycle approaches for Conservation Agriculture on 8th May 2006 at the SETAC - Europe. 16th annual meeting at the Hague. Leiden: CML report 2006, 171:156. Available at:http://www.leidenuniv.nl/cml/ssp/publications/life_cycle_conserv_agri.pdf.
43. Guinée J., Heijungs R., Voet E. A greenhouse gas indicator for bioenergy: some theoretical issues with practical implications. Int J Life Cycle Assess 2009, 14(4):328-339.
44. Hastings A.F., Wattenbach M., Eugster W., Li C., Buchmann N., Smith P. Uncertainty propagation in soil greenhouse gas emission models: an experiment using the DNDC model and at the Oensingen cropland site. Agric Ecosyst Environ 2010, 136(1-2):97-110.
45. 2O emission using NOE algorithm and soil database. Glob Chang Biol 2005, 11:115-127.
46. Hillier J., Brentrup F., Wattenbach M., Walter C., Garcia-Suarez T., Mila-i-Canals L., et al. Which cropland greenhouse gas mitigation options give the greatest benefits in different world regions? Climate and soil-specific predictions from integrated empirical models. Glob Chang Biol 2012, 18(6):1880-1894.
47. ISO SS-EN ISO 14040 environmental management - life cycle assessment, principles and framework. Geneva: international organization for standardization 2006.
48. ISO SS-EN ISO 14044 environmental management - life cycle assessment - requirements and guidelines. Geneva: International Organization for Standardization 2006.
49. Johnson J., Franzluebbers A., Weyers S., Reicosky D. Agricultural opportunities to mitigate greenhouse gas emissions. Environ Pollut 2007, 150(1):107-124.
50. JRC EUCAR, EUROCAR. Biofuels versus diesel and gasoline in the JEC-WTW report version 2c. Brussels: European Council for Automotive R&D (EUCAR), Brussels: European association for environment, health and safety in oil refining and distribution (CONCAWE), Ispra: the Institute for Environment and Sustainability of the EU Commission's Joint Research Centre (JRC/IES) 2007.
51. Kim S., Dale B., Jenkins R. Life cycle assessment of corn grain and corn stover in the United States. Int J Life Cycle Assess 2009, 14(2):160-174.
52. Kröbel R., Smith W., Grant B., Desjardins R., Campbell C., Tremblay N., et al. Development and evaluation of a new Canadian spring wheat sub-model for DNDC. Can J Soil Sci 2011, 91(4):503-520.
53. Lehuger S., Gabrielle B., Larmanou E., Laville P., Cellier P., Loubet B. Predicting the global warming potential of agro-ecosystems. Biogeosci Discuss 2007, 4:1059-1092.
54. Li C., Frolking S., Frolking T.A. A model of nitrous oxide evolution from soil driven by rainfall events: 1, Model structure and sensitivity. J Geophys Res Atmos 1992, 97(D9):9759-9776.
55. Li C., Hao X., Blackshaw R.E., O'Donovan J.T., Harker K.N., Clayton G.W. Nitrous oxide emissions in response to ESN and urea, herbicide management and canola cultivar in a no-till cropping system. Soil Tillage Res 2012, 118:97-106.
56. MacWilliam S., Wismer M., Kulshreshtha S. Life cycle and economic assessment of Western Canadian pulse systems: the inclusion of pulses in crop rotations. Agric Syst 2014, 123:43-53.
57. Malhi S.S., Nyborg M., Dyck M.F., Puurveen D. Influence of long-term tillage, straw, and N fertilizer management on crop yield, N uptake, and N balance sheet in two contrasting soil types. Commun Soil Sci Plant Anal 2011, 42(20):2548-2560.
58. Malhi S.S., Nyborg M., Solberg E.D., McConkey B., Dyck M., Puurveen D. Long-term straw management and N fertilizer rate effects on quantity and quality of organic C and N and some chemical properties in two contrasting soils in Western Canada. Biol Fertil Soils 2011, 47(7):785-800.
59. Mazzoncini M., Di Bene C., Coli A., Antichi D., Petri M., Bonari E. Rainfed wheat and soybean productivity in a long-term tillage experiment in central Italy. Agron J 2008, 100(5):1418-1429.
60. Nemecek T., Dubois D., Huguenin-Elie O., Gaillard G. Life cycle assessment of Swiss farming systems: I. Integrated and organic farming. Agric Syst 2011, 104(3):217-232.
61. Nemecek T., Huguenin-Elie O., Dubois D., Gaillard G., Schaller B., Chervet A. Life cycle assessment of Swiss farming systems: II. Extensive and intensive production. Agric Syst 2011, 104(3):233-245.
62. Pappa V.A., Rees R.M., Walker R.L., Baddeley J.A., Watson C.A. Nitrous oxide emissions and nitrate leaching in an arable rotation resulting from the presence of an intercrop. Agric Ecosyst Environ 2011, 141(1-2):153-161.
63. Pelletier N., Arsenault N., Tyedmers P. Scenario modeling potential eco-efficiency gains from a transition to organic agriculture: life cycle perspectives on Canadian canola, corn, soy, and wheat production. Environ Manag 2008, 42(6):989-1001.
64. R Development Core Team A language and environment for statistical computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing. Vienna, Austria 2005.
65. 2O emissions from agricultural soils in Canada. I. Development of a country-specific methodology. Can J Soil Sci 2008, 88(5):641-654.
66. Saggar S. Estimation of nitrous oxide emission from ecosystems and its mitigation technologies. Agric Ecosyst Environ 2010, 136(3-4):189-191.
67. Sheehan J., Camobreco V., Duffield J., Graboski M., Shapouri H. Life cycle inventory of biodiesel and petroleum diesel for use in an urban bus. Report N: NREL/SR-580-24089. US: U.S. Department of Energy's Office of Fuels Development; U.S. Department of Agriculture's Office of Energy; National Renewable Energy Laboratory; Midwest Research Institute 1998, 314. Available online:www.nrel.gov/docs/legosti/fy98/24089.pdf.
68. Siegel S., Castellan N. Nonparametric statistics for behavioral sciences 1998, McGraw-Hill, New York.
69. Shrestha B., Desjardins R., McConkey B., Worth D., Dyer J., Cerkowniak D. Change in carbon footprint of canola production in the Canadian prairies from 1986 to 2006. Renew Energy 2014, 63:634-641.
70. SimaPro 7.3 Simapro 7.3. Amersfoort, Netherlands: PRé consultants: life cycle consultancy and software solutions Available online:, [accessed on 8 Jan 2010]. http://www.pre.nl/default.htm.
71. Smith P., Martino D., Cai Z., Gwary D., Janzen H., Kumar P., et al. Chapter 8: agriculture. Climate change 2007: mitigation contribution of working group III to the fourth assessment report. Intergovernmental panel climate change 2007, 497-540. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, and New York. B. Metz, O.R. Davidsonn, P.R. Bosch, R. Dave, L.A. Meyer (Eds.).
72. Smith W.N., Grant B.B., Campbell C.A., McConkey B.G., Desjardins R.L., Kröbel R., et al. Crop residue removal effects on soil carbon: measured and inter-model comparisons. Agric Ecosyst Environ 2012, 161:27-38.
73. Smith W.N., Grant B.B., Desjardins R.L., Kroebel R., Li C., Qian B., et al. Assessing the effects of climate change on crop production and GHG emissions in Canada. Agric Ecosyst Environ 2013, 179:139-150.
74. Snyder C.S., Bruulsema T.W., Jensen T.L., Fixen P.E. Review of greenhouse gas emissions from crop production systems and fertilizer management effects. Agric Ecosyst Environ 2009, 133(3-4):247-266.
75. 2O and NO emission from agricultural fields and soils under natural vegetation: summarizing available measurement data and modeling of global annual emissions. Nutr Cycl Agroecosyst 2006, 74(3):207-228.
76. Sullivan B.W., Selmants P.C., Hart S.C. Does dissolved organic carbon regulate biological methane oxidation in semiarid soils?. Glob Chang Biol 2013, 19(7):2149-2157.
77. Tuomisto H.L., Hodge I.D., Riordan P., Macdonald D.W. Comparing energy balances, greenhouse gas balances and biodiversity impacts of contrasting farming systems with alternative land uses. Agric Syst 2012, 108:42-49.
78. USDA Soil taxonomy 1999, 871. United States Department of Agriculture, Natural Resources Conservation Service, Washington DC.
79. USDA Soil water characteristics: hydraulic properties calculator. Nat. Resources Conserv. Serv. United State Deparment Agric Available online:, [accessed on 18 Nov 2012]. http://hydrolab.arsusda.gov/soilwater/Index.htm.
80. VandenBygaart A.J., Bremer E., McConkey B.G., Janzen H.H., Angers D.A., Carter M.R., et al. Soil organic carbon stocks on long-term agroecosystem experiments in Canada. Can J Soil Sci 2010, 90(4):543-550.
81. VandenBygaart A.J., Bremer E., McConkey B.G., Ellert B.H., Janzen H.H., Angers D.A., et al. Impact of Sampling Depth on Differences in Soil Carbon Stocks in Long-Term Agroecosystem Experiments. Soil Sci Soc Am J 2011, 75(1):226-234.
82. West T.O., Six J. Considering the influence of sequestration duration and carbon saturation on estimates of soil carbon capacity. Clim Chang 2007, 80:25-41.
83. Zaher U., Stöckle C., Painter K., Higgins S. Life cycle assessment of the potential carbon credit from no- and reduced-tillage winter wheat-based cropping systems in Eastern Washington State. Agric Syst 2013, 122:73-78.