Collaborative governance for technological innovation: A comparative case study of wind energy in Xinjiang, Shanghai, and Guangdong

Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy

Volumn 32, Issue 3, 2014, Pages 509-529

  Mah, Daphne Ngar Yin ^a   Hills, Peter ^b  

^a HONG KONG BAPTIST UNIVERSITY   (Hong Kong)

^b UNIVERSITY OF HONG KONG   (Hong Kong)

Author keywords

Collaborative; Governance; Technological innovation; Wind energy in China

Indexed keywords

ALTERNATIVE ENERGY; GOVERNANCE APPROACH; INNOVATION; RENEWABLE RESOURCE; STATE OWNED ENTERPRISE; TECHNOLOGICAL CHANGE; TECHNOLOGICAL DEVELOPMENT; WIND POWER;

CHINA; GUANGDONG; SHANGHAI; XINJIANG UYGUR;

EID: 84901648089     PISSN: 0263774X     EISSN: 14723425     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1068/c11101     Document Type: Article

References (85)

1. Ansell C., Gash A, 2008, "Collaborative governance in theory and practice" Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory 18 543-571
2. Ashman D., 2001, "Civil society collaboration with business: bringing empowerment back in" World Development 29 1097-1113
3. Baker and McKenzie, Renewable Energy Generators Ltd, CREA, CRED, 2007, "Renewable energy law in China", RELaw Assist Issues Papers, Baker and McKenzie, Renewable Energy Generators Australia Ltd, Chinese Renewable Energy Industry Association, Centre for Renewable Energy Development, http://www.xebecinc.com/pdf/Renewable-Energy-Law-China.pdf
4. Bergek A., Jacobsson S, 2003, "The emergence of a growth industry: a comparative analysis of the German, Dutch and Swedish wind turbine industries", in Change, Transformation, and Development 8th edition, Eds J Stan Metcalfe, U Cantner (Physica-Verlag, Heidelberg) pp 197-228
5. BMU, 2007a EEG-The Renewable Energy Sources Act: The Success Story of Sustainable Policies for Germany Bundesministerium für Umwelt, Naturschutz und Reaktorsicherheit, Berlin
6. BMU, 2007b Gabriel: An Outstanding Success Story: Federal Environment Minister Presents Progress Report on Renewable Energy Sources Act BMU-Pressedienst No. 190/07, Bundesministerium für Umwelt, Naturschutz und Reaktorsicherheit, Berlin
7. Brinkerhoff D., 1999, "Exploring state-civil society collaboration: policy partnerships in developing countries" Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector 28 59-86
8. Burton D., 1993, "German technology policy: incentive for industrial innovation" Challenge 36 37-47
9. Buruku B., 2005, "Chinese renewable law: China approves renewable energy law in record time" Refocus 6(3) 56-57
10. Cames M., Fischer C, Voß N, Pehnt M, Praetorius B, Schneider L, Schumacher K, 2004, "Transformation", DP 5, Sozial-ökologische Forschung, Bonn
11. Carlsson B., Stankiewicz R, 1991, "On the nature, function and composition of technological systems" Journal of Evolutionary Economics 1 93-118
12. Chang P. L, Shih H Y, 2004, "The innovation systems of Taiwan and China: a comparative analysis" Technovation 24 529-539
13. Cheung P., 2002, "Guangdong under reform: social and political trends and challenges", in Rethinking China's Provinces Eds J Fitzgerald (Routledge, London) pp 125-152
14. CNREC, 2012 China 12th Five-year Plan for Renewable Energy Development China National Renewable Energy Centre, China Nation Energy Administration, Beijing
15. Cruz-Castro L, Rico-Castro P, Sanz-Menéndez L, 2002, "The dynamic of the Spanish public and semi-public non university research centres: country report", Spanish Policy Research on Innovation and Technology, Training and Education, Madrid
16. CSTS, 2009, "China science and technology statistics", volume 2011, Science and Technology Statistics Information Center, Beijing, http://www.sts.org.cn/sjkl/kjtjdt/data2009/cstsm09.htm
17. CWEA, 2010, "2009 nian zhongguo fengdian zhuangji rongliang tongji" [2009 statistics on wind installed capacity in China], Chinese Wind Energy Association, Beijing
18. CWEI, 2010, "Fengdian jizu baojia shouci diepo siqianyuan" [Wind turbine quotation price first drops below RMB 4000] Meizhou fengxun-2010 niandu tekan [Wind Weekly-2010 Special Issue] 3
19. Denise L., 1999, "Collaboration vs C-three (cooperation, coordination, and communication)" Innovating Reprint 7(3), http://www.enterprisecommunity.com/resources/ResourceDetails?ID=64621.pdf
20. DOE, 2008, "20% wind energy by 2030: increasing wind energy's contribution to US electricity supply", US Department of Energy, Washington, DC
21. Editorial Committee, 2005, "Zhongguo nengyuan fazhan baogao" [Report on China's energy development] (China Statistics Press, Beijing)
22. Edquist C., 2005, "Systems of innovation: perspectives and challenges", in The Oxford Handbook of Innovation Eds J Fagerberg, D Mowery, R Nelson (Oxford University Press, Oxford) pp 181-208
23. EU, 2011 Innovation Union Competitiveness Report 2011 (European Union, Brussels)
24. Fischer M., Diez J, Snickars F, 2001 Metropolitan Innovation Systems: Theory and Evidence from Three Metropolitan Regions in Europe (Springer, New York)
25. GDDRC, 2010, Guanyu zhengqiu dui{left double angle bracket}Guangdong shengxing nengyuan kaifa ji chanye fazhan guihua (zhengqiu yijian gao){right double angle bracket}yijian de han. Yuefagaiban nengdian han{left tortoise shell bracket}2010{right tortoise shell bracket}355 hao. 26 February, Guangdong Development and Reform Commission
26. Goldwind, 2009, "Goldwind", http://www.goldwind.cn/step/show.asp?id=53
27. Goldwind, 2011, "Company information", http://www.goldwindglobal.com/web/about.do
28. Guangdong S. TC, Guangdong Standards and Testing Commission, Guangdong 2008a, [Guanyu xiada 2010 nian dierpi Guangdong qiye keji tepaiyuan jihua de tongzhi], 8 July, http://cxy.gdstc.gov.cn/HTML/tzgg/12785592459416742713534230887753.html
29. Guangdong S. TS, 2011 The Top Ten Provinces/Cities in Local Government Science and Technology Appropriation in China (2008) [Guonei defang caizheng keji bokuan guimo qian shiming de shengshi) (2008)], Guangdong Provincial Department of Science and Technology, Guangzhou, http://www.sts.gd.cn/show.asp?ArticleID=546
30. GWEC, 2012a Global Trends, http://www.gwec.net/index.php?id=13
31. GWEC, 2012b Global Wind Report 2011 Global Wind Energy Council, Brussels HKTDC, Hong Kong Trade Development Council, Hong Kong 2009 Profiles of China Provinces, Cities and Industrial Parks: Guangdong Province 22 December, http://www.hktdc.com/info/mi/a/mpcn/en/1X06BUOU/1/Profiles-Of-China-Provinces-Cities-And-Industrial-Parks/GUANGDONG-PROVINCE.htm
32. IWTMA, Wind Power Works, GWEC, 2009 Indian Wind Energy Outlook 2009 Indian Wind Turbine Manufacturers Association, Global Wind Energy Council, and Wind Power Works, Chennai
33. Jacobsson S., Bergek A, 2004, "Transforming the energy sector: the evolution of technological systems in renewable energy technology", in Governance for Industrial Transformation: Proceedings of the 2003 Berlin Conference on the Human Dimensions of Global Environmental Change Eds K Jacob, M Binder, A Wieczorek (Environmental Policy Research Centre, Berlin) pp 208-236
34. Jacobsson S., Johnson A, 2000, "The diffusion of renewable energy technology: an analytical framework and key issues for research" Energy Policy 28 625-640
35. Jacobsson S., Lauber V, 2006, "The politics and policy of energy system transformation-explaining the German diffusion of renewable energy technology" Energy Policy 34 256-276
36. Johnson J., 1990 Selecting Ethnographic Informants (Sage, Thousand Oaks, CA)
37. Kamp L., Smits R, Andriesse C, 2004, "Notions on learning applied to wind turbine development in the Netherlands and Denmark" Energy Policy 32 1625-1637
38. Koh W., Wong P K, 2005, "Competing at the frontier: the changing role of technology policy in Singapore's economic strategy" Technological Forecasting and Social Change 72 255-285
39. Kristinsson K., Rao R, 2007, "Learning to grow: a comparative analysis of the wind energy sector in Denmark and India", WP 07-18, Danish Research Unit for Industrial Dynamics, Copenhagen, http://www2.druid.dk/conferences/working_papers/NEW/20070018.pdf
40. Lewis J., 2005, "Part of the climate change problem. and the solution? Chinese-made wind power technology and opportunities for dissemination", Proceedings of the 2005 Breslaver Symposium 'An interdisciplinary Look at a Global Problem: Social and Scientific Aspects of Climate Change', International and Area Studies, University of California, 25 February, http://escolarship.org/uc/item/8rt4q01k
41. Lewis J., 2006, "Leading the renewable energy revolution" Georgetown Journal of International Affairs 7 147-154
42. Lewis J., 2007 A Comparison of Wind Power Industry Development Strategies in Spain, India and China Center for Resource Solutions, San Francisco, CA
43. Lewis J., Wiser R, 2007, "Fostering a renewable energy technology industry: an international comparison of wind industry policy support mechanisms" Energy Policy 35 1844-1857
44. Li J., Shi P, Gao H, Xie H, Yang Z, Tang W, Ma L, 2010 China Wind Power Outlook 2010 Greenpeace China, Chinese Renewable Energy Industries Association, and Global Wind Energy Council, Beijing
45. Li J., Cao F, Tang W, Xie H, Gao H, Ma L, 2011 China Wind Power Outlook 2011 (China Environmental Sciences Publisher, Beijing)
46. Li J., Cai F, Qia L, Xie H, Gao H, Yang X, 2012 China Wind Power Outlook 2012 (China Envionmental Sciences Publisher, Beijing)
47. Liao C., Jochem E, Zhang Y, Farid N, 2010, "Wind power development and policies in China" Renewable Energy 35 1879-1886
48. Lieberthal K., 2004 Governing China: From Revolution Through Reform 2nd edition (W W Norton, London)
49. Liu H., Jiang Y, 2001, "Technology transfer from higher education institutions to industry in China: nature and implications" Technovation 21 175-188
50. Liu X., White S, 2001a, "Comparing innovation systems: a framework and application to China's transitional context" Research Policy 30 1091-1114
51. Liu X., White S, 2001b, "An exploration into regional variation in innovative activity in China" International Journal of Technology Management 21 114-129
52. Liu Y., 2006, "Made in China, or Made by China? Chinese wind turbine manufacturers struggle to enter own market" China Watch 19 May, http://www.worldwatch.org/features/chinawatch/stories/20060519-2
53. Loitera J., Norberg-Bohmb V, 1999, "Technology policy and renewable energy: public roles in the development of new energy technologies" Energy Policy 27 85-97
54. Lyons D., Deutz P, 2010, "Editorial: regional sustainable development: making development work in politically contingent space" Sustainable Development 18 183-186
55. Mah D., Hills P, 2008, "Central-local relations and pricing policies for wind energy in China" The China Review 8 261-293
56. Mah D., Hills P, 2009, "Policy choices, central-local relations, and policy learning: a case study of the pricing policies for wind energy in China (from 1994 to 2009)", paper presented at the International Workshop of Institutional Change and Environmental Governance: 'Comparing the dynamics of central-local relations in environmental policy-making', Tsinghua University, Beijing, 11-12 December, http://www.hku.hk/kadinst/PDF_file/KI_working_paper_5.pdf
57. Mah D., Hills P, 2012, "Collaborative governance for sustainable development: a comparative study of wind resource assessment in Xinjiang and Guangdong Provinces, China" Sustainable Development 20 85-97
58. Nielsen H., Nielsen K, Petersen F, Jensen H, 1998, "Risø National Laboratory-forty years of research in a changing society", Risø National Laboratory, Roskilde, http://130.226.56.153/rispubl/risofacts/factpdf/risoehistory.pdf
59. Phillips N., Lawrence T, Hardy C, 2000, "Inter-organizational collaboration and the dynamics of institutional fields" Journal of Management Studies 37 23-43
60. Pierre J., Peter G, 2000 Governance, Politics and the State (Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke, Hants)
61. Praetorius B., Bauknecht D, Cames M, Fischer C, Pehnt M, Schumacher K, Voβ J, 2009 Innovation for Sustainable Electricity Systems: Exploring the Dynamics of Energy Transitions (Physica-Verlag, Heidelberg)
62. Rabe B., 2002, "Greenhouse and statehouse: the evolving state government role in climate change", Pew Center on Global Climate Change, Arlington, VA
63. REN 21, 2010, "Renewables 2010 global status report", Renewable Energy Policy Network for the 21st Century, Washington, DC
64. Satterthwaite D., 1999, "Sustainable cities or cities that contribute to sustainable development?", in The Earthscan Reader in Sustainable Cities Ed. D Satterthwaite (Earthscan, London) pp 80-106
65. SCEC, 2009, "Shanghai Clean Energy Research and Industry Promotion Center", 20 May, http://www.scec.sh.cn/en/aboutus_bk.aspx
66. Schmidt E., Graversen E, Langberg K, 2003, "Innovation and dynamics in public research environments in Denmark: a research-policy perspective" Science and Public Policy 30 107-116
67. Shanghai Almanac Editorial Board, 2007 Shanghai Almanac 2007 [Shanghai Nian Jian 2007] Shanghai Renmin Chuban She, Shanghai
68. Shanghai Center for ACAE, 2006, "Consultation report on the strategies of energy, and clean energy motor vehicles in Shanghai" [Shanghaishi nengyuan qingjie nengyuan qiche fazhan zhanlue zixunhui: zixun baogao], Shanghai Consulting and Academic Activities Center for Academicians of Chinese Academy of Engineering, Shanghai
69. Shanghai Electric, 2010, "Wind energy", http://www.shanghai-electric.com/en/business/newenergy/windpower/Pages/default.aspx
70. Shanghai Electric, 2011, "Wind energy", http://www.shanghai-electric.com/en/business/newenergy/windpower/Pages/default.aspx
71. Shanghai Statistics, 2008 Shanghai Statistical Yearbook 2008 Shanghai Tongji Chubanshe, Shanghai
72. Shichor Y., 2005, "Blow up: internal and external challenges of Uyghur separatism and Islamic radicalism to Chinese rule in Xinjiang" Asian Affairs: An American Review 32 119-135
73. Skelcher C., 2000, "Changing images of the state: overloaded, hollowed-out, congested" Public Policy and Administration 15(3) 3-19
74. Stoker G., 1998, "Governance as theory: five propositions" International Social Science Journal 50(155) 17-28
75. Sych L., 1999, "Reinventing government and rural public transportation: lessons from five cases" Public Studies Review 16 220-242
76. The Climate Group, 2009, "China's clean revolution II: opportunities for a low carbon future", London
77. Thomson A., Perry J, 2006, "Collaboration processes: inside the black box" Public Administration Review 66(s1) 20-32
78. Verspagen B., 2006, "University research, intellectual property rights and European innovation systems" Journal of Economic Surveys 20 607-632
79. Wan C., Wang J, Yang G, Li X, Zhang X, 2009, "Optimal micro-siting of wind turbines by genetic algorithms based on improved wind and turbine models", paper presented at the Proceedings of the 48th IEEE Conference on Decison and Control, 15-1 Shanghai, 15-18 December, http://ieeexplore.ieee.org/stamp/stamp.jsp?tp=&arnumber=5399571
80. Watson J., Sauter R, Bahaj B, James P, Myers L, Wing R, 2006, "Unlocking the power house: policy and system change for domestic micro-generation in the UK", Science and Technology Policy Research, The Freeman Centre, University of Sussex, Brighton
81. Wu W., 2007, "Cultivating research universities and industrial linkages in China: the case of Shanghai" World Development 35 1075-1093
82. Yeung Y. M, 1998, "Introduction", in Guangdong: Survey of a Province Undergoing Rapid Change 2nd edition, Eds Y M Yeung, D Chu (The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong) pp 1-22
83. Yin R., 2003 Case Study Research: Design and Methods 3rd edition (Sage, Thousand Oaks, CA)
84. Zhang C., Zeng D, Mako W, Seward J, 2009 Promoting Enterprise-led Innovation in China (The World Bank, Washington, DC)
85. Zhang T., 2002, "Urban development and a socialist pro-growth coalition in Shanghai" Urban Affairs Review 37 475-499