OR without ontology? - A pragmatist critique of SSM

51st Annual Conference of the Operational Research Society 2009, OR51

Volumn , Issue , 2009, Pages 90-112

  Zhu, Zhichang ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF HULL   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Methodology of OR; Philosophy of OR; Practice of OR; Pragmatism; Soft Systems Methodology; Systems Thinking

Indexed keywords

METHODOLOGY OF OR; PHILOSOPHY OF OR; PRACTICE OF OR; PRAGMATISM; SOFT SYSTEMS METHODOLOGY; SYSTEMS THINKING;

PHYSICS;

ONTOLOGY;

EID: 84888020731     PISSN: None     EISSN: None     Source Type: Conference Proceeding    
DOI: None     Document Type: Conference Paper

References (99)

1. Ackoff RL (1974). The social responsibility of operational research. Opl Res Q 25: 361-371.
2. Ackoff RL (1996). On learning and the systems that facilitate it. Reflections 1: 14-24.
3. Aoki M (2001). Toward a Comparative Institutional Analysis. MIT Press: Cambridge, MA.
4. Baert P (2005). Philosophy of the Social Sciences: Towards Pragmatism. Polity Press: Cambridge, England.
5. Bateson G (1972). Steps to an Ecology of Mind. Ballantine: New York.
6. Bernstein RJ (1983). Beyond Objectivism and Relativism: Science, Hermeneutics, and Praxis. University of Pennsylvania Press: Philadelphia.
7. Blackburn S (1996). Metaphysics. In: Bunnin N and Tsui-James EP (eds). The Blackwell Companion to Philosophy. Blackwell: Oxford, England, pp 64-89.
8. Burrell G and Morgan G (1979). Sociological Paradigms and Organisational Analysis. Heinemann: London.
9. Carnap R (1967). The Logical Structure of the World and Pseudoproblems in Philosophy. George RA (trans). Routledge: London.
10. Carr D (1999). The Paradox of Subjectivity: The Self in the Transcendental Tradition. Oxford University Press: Oxford, England.
11. Carr D (2002). Response to Drummond and Zahavi. Human Stud 25: 117-123.
12. Cartwright N (1999). The Dappled World: A Study of the Boundaries of Science. Cambridge University Press: Cambridge, England.
13. Checkland PB (1981). Systems Thinking, Systems Practice. Wiley: Chichester.
14. Checkland PB (1985). From optimising to learning: A development of systems thinking for the 1990s. J Opl Res Soc 36 (9): 757-767.
15. Checkland PB (2000). Soft Systems Methodology: a thirty year retrospective. Syst Res Behav Sci 17: S11-S58. Reprinted from: Systems Thinking, Systems Practice (1999 ed). Wiley: Chichester, pp A3-A61.
16. Checkland PB (2006). Reply to Eden and Ackermann: Any future for problem structuring methods? J Opl Res Soc 57: 769-771.
17. Checkland PB (2008). Researching real-life: Reflections on 30 years of action research. In: Proceedings of the International Conference on Philosophy of Systems Science and Social Development. South China Normal University: Guangzhou, China, pp 31-33.
18. Checkland PB and Holwell S (2004). 'Classic' OR and 'soft'OR-an asymmetric complementarity. In Pidd M (ed). Systems Modelling: Theory and Practice. Wiley: Chichester, pp 43-60.
19. Checkland PB and Poulter J (2006). Learning for Action. Wiley: Chichester.
20. Chiasson M, Fildes R and Pidd M (2006). Intelligent thinking instead of critical realism? J Opl Res Soc 57: 1373-1375.
21. Churchman CW (1979). The Systems Approach and Its Enemies. Basic Books: New York.
22. Cummings S (2002). ReCtreating Strategy. Sage: London.
23. Deetz S (1996). Describing differences in approaches to organisation science: rethinking Burrell and Morgan and their legacy. Org Sci 7: 191-207.
24. Dewey J (1920). Reconstruction in Philosophy. Southern Illinois University Press: Carbondale and Edwardsville, IL.
25. Dewey J (1925). Experience and Nature. Southern Illinois University Press: Carbondale and Edwardsville (reprinted 1981).
26. Dewey J (1930). The Quest for Certainty: A Study of the Relationship between Knowledge and Action. Allen & Unwin: London.
27. Dewey J (1931). Philosophy and Civilisation. Balch & Company: New York.
28. Dewey J (1946). Problems of Men. Philosophical Library: New York.
29. Eden C and Ackermann F (2006). Where next for problem structuring methods. J Opl Res Soc 57: 766-768.
30. Fultner B (2003). Translator's introduction. In: Habermas J. Truth and Justification. MIT Press: Cambridge, MA., pp vii-xxii.
31. Gabriel Y (2002). On paragrammatic uses of organisational theory-a provocation. Org Stud 23: 133-151.
32. Gadamer H-G (1975). Truth and Method. Seabury Press: New York.
33. Gascoigne N (2008). Richard Rorty. Polity Press; Cambridge, England.
34. Gracia JJE (1999). Metaphysics and its Task: The Search for the Categorial Foundations of Knowledge. SUNY Press: New York.
35. Grayling AC (1996). Epistemology. In: Bunnin N and Tsui-James EP (eds). The Blackwell Companion to Philosophy. Blackwell: Oxford, England, pp 38-63.
36. Habermas J (2003). Truth and Justification. MIT Press: Cambridge, MA.
37. Hacking I (1999). The Social Construction of What? Harvard University Press: Cambridge, MA.
38. Jackson MC (2000). Checkland, Peter Bernard (1930-). Syst Res Behav Sci 17: S3-S10.
39. Jackson MC (2003). Systems Thinking: Creative Holism for Managers. Wiley: Chichester.
40. Jackson MC (2009). Fifty years of systems thinking for management. J Opl Res Soc 60: S24-S53.
41. Jackson N and Carter P (1991). In defence of paradigm incommensurability. Org Stud 12: 109-127.
42. Jackson N and Carter P (1993). Paradigm ward': a response to Hugh Willmott. Org Stud 14: 721-725.
43. James W (1904). The pragmatic method. J Phil 1: 673-687.
44. James W (1907). Pragmatism: A New Name for Some Old Ways of Thinking. (Reprinted 1975). Harvard University Press: Cambridge, MA.
45. Jones GC (1993). OR practice, systems methodologies, and the need to do better. J Opl Res Soc 44: 845-848.
46. Kant I (1787). Critique of Pure Reason (2nd ed). Akademieausgabe: Berlin.
47. Latour B (2005). Reassembling the Social: An Introduction to Actor-Network-Theory. Oxford University Press: New York.
48. Maturana H (1970). Biology of Cognition (Report 9.0). BCL, University of Illinois, Urbana, IL.
49. Maturana H (1990). Science and daily life: The ontology of scientific explanations. In: Krohn W, Kuppers G and Nowotny H (eds). Selforganisation: Portrait of a Scientific Revolution. Kluwer Group: Dordrecht, pp 12-35.
50. McCulloch WS (1970). Embodiments of Mind. MIT Press: Cambridge, MA.
51. Mingers J (1984). Subjectivism and soft systems methodology-a critique. J Appl Syst Anal 11: 85-103.
52. Mingers J (1993). The systems of systems methodologies-a reply to Schecter. J Opl Res Soc 44: 206-208.
53. Mingers J (2005). Viewpoint: 'More dangerous than an unanswered question is an unquestioned answer': a contribution to the Ulrich debate. J Opl Res Soc 56: 468-474.
54. Mingers J (2008). Management knowledge and knowledge management: realism and forms of truth. Knowl Mngt Res Pract 6: 62-76.
55. Mingers J, Liu W and Meng W (2009). Using SSM to structure the identification of inputs and outputs in DEA. J Opl Res Soc 60: 168-179.
56. Morecroft J (2004). Mental models and learning in system dynamics practice. In: Pidd M (ed). Systems Modelling: Theory and Practice. Wiley: Chichester, pp 102-126.
57. Murphy JP (1990). Pragmatism: From Peirce to Davidson. Westview Press: Boulder, CO.
58. Myers WT (2004). Pragmatist metaphysics: A defence. Trans Charles S. Peirce Soc XL: 39-52.
59. Neurath O (1935). The unity of science as task. Erkenntnis 5: 16-22. Reprinted in: Cohen RS and Neurath M (trans and ed 1983). Philosophical Papers 1913-46. Reidel: Dordrecht.
60. Nietzsche F (1988). The Birth of Tragedy. Kaufmann W (trans and ed). Vintage Books: New York.
61. Ormerod RJ (1997). Mixing methods in practice: A transformation-competence perspective. In: Mingers J and Gill A (eds). Multimethodology: The Theory and Practice of Combining Management Science Methdologies. Wiley: Chichester, pp 29-58.
62. Ormerod RJ (2001). Mixing methods in practice. In: Rosenhead J and Mingers J (eds). Rational Analysis for a Problematic World Revisited: Problem Structuring Methods for Complexity, Uncertainty and Conflict. Wiley: Chichester, pp 311-336.
63. Ormerod RJ (2002a). Should critical realism really be critical for OR? A comment on Mingers (2000): the contribution of critical realism as an underpinning philosophy for OR/MS and systems. J Opl Res Soc 53: 347-351.
64. Ormerod RJ (2002b). Response to Mingers-an overarching philosophy for OR/MS-Sed Quis Custodet Sustodies? [But who is to guard the guards themselves] (Juvenal, c. AD 60-130). J Opl Res Soc 53: 354-357.
65. Ormerod RJ (2006). The history and ideas of pragmatism. J Opl Res Soc 57: 892-909.
66. Ormerod RJ (2008). OR and systems-some comments on Checkland's reply to Eden and Ackermann. J Opl Res Soc 59: 139-142.
67. Oxford Companion to Philosophy (1995). Oxford University Press: Oxford, England.
68. Peirce CS (1934). The Collected Papers of C. S. Peirce. Harvard University Press: Cambridge, MA.
69. Piaget J (1937). The Construction of Reality in the Child. Cook M (trans 1971). Basic Books: New York.
70. Pidd M (2004a). Contemporary OR/MS in strategy development and policy-making: some reflection. J Opl Res Soc 55: 791-800.
71. Pidd M (2004b). Complementarity in systems modelling. In: Pidd M (ed). Systems Modelling: Theory and Practice. Wiley: Chichester, pp 1-20.
72. Pihlstrom S (2003). On the concept of philosophical anthropology. J Phil Res 28: 259-285.
73. Pihlstrom S (2004). Methodology without metaphysics? A pragmatic critique. Philo Today 48 (Summer): 188-215.
74. Pihlstrom S (2008). Metaphysics with a human face: William James and the prospects of pragmatist metaphysics. William James Stud 2 (1): http://williamjamesstudies.press.uiuc.edu/2.1/pihlstrom.html, accessed 29 October 2008.
75. Putnam H (1990). Realism with a Human Face. Harvard University Press: Cambridge, MA.
76. Putnam H (2004). Ethics without Ontology. Harvard University Press: Cambridge, MA.
77. Rescher N (2000). Realistic Pragmatism: An Introduction to Pragmatic Philosophy. SUNY Press: Albany.
78. Rorty R (1979). Philosophy and the Mirror of Nature. Princeton University Press: Princeton.
79. Rorty R (1982). Consequences of Pragmatism. Harvester: Sussex, England.
80. Scherer AG and Steinmann H (1999). Some remarks on the problem of incommensurability in organisation studies. Org Stud 20: 519-544.
81. Searle JR (1995). The Construction of Social Reality. Allen Lane/The Penguin Press: London.
82. Seigfried CH (2004). Ghosts walking underground: Dewey's vanishing metaphysics. Tran Charles S. Peirce Soc XL: 53-81.
83. Singer AE (1959). Experience and Reflection. Churchman CW (ed). University of Pennsylvania Press: Philadelphia.
84. Sosa E (1995) Problems of metaphysics. In: Oxford Companion to Philosophy. Honderich T (ed). Oxford University Press: Oxford, England, pp 559-563.
85. Sun LX (2002). Introduction: adaptive efficiency and evolving diversity of enterprise ownership and governance. J Comp Eco 30: 754-758.
86. Taket AR and White LA (1996). Pragmatic pluralism-an explication. Syst Pract 9: 571-586.
87. Tsoukas H (1994). Refining common sense: types of knowledge in management studies. J Mngt Stud 31: 761-780.
88. Ulrich W (2003). Beyond methodology choice: critical systems thinking as critically systemic discourse. J Opl Res Soc 54: 325-342.
89. Ulrich W (2004). Reply to the comments of Bowen. J Opl Res Soc 55: 553-554.
90. Ulrich W (2007). Philosophy for professionals: towards critical pragmatism. J Opl Res Soc 58: 1109-1113.
91. Vaughan D (1998). Rational choice, situated action, and the social control of organisations: the Challenger Launch decision. Law Soc Rev 32: 23-61.
92. Von Foerster H (2002). Understanding Systems: Conversations on Epistemology and Ethics. Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers: New York.
93. Von Foerster H (2003). Understanding Understanding: Essays on Cybernetics and Cognition. Springer: New York.
94. Von Glasersfeld E (1995). Radical Constructivism: A Way of Knowing and Learning. Routledge/Falmer: London.
95. White LA and Taket AR (1997). Critiquing multimethodology as metamethodology: working towards pragmatic pluralism. In: Mingers J and Gill A (eds). Multimethodology: The Theory and Practice of Combining Management Science Methdologies. Wiley: Chichester, pp 379-405.
96. Wicks AC and Freeman RE (1998). Organisation studies and the new pragmatism: positivism, anti-positivism, and the search for ethics. Org Sci 9: 123-140.
97. Willmott H (1993). Breaking the paradigm mentality. Org Stud 14: 681-719.
98. Wittgenstein L (1953). Philosophical Investigations. Basil Blackwell: Oxford, England.
99. Yang JM (2008). An approach applying SSM to problem situations of interest conflicts. In: Proceedings of the International Conference on Philosophy of Systems Science and Social Development. South China Normal University: Guangzhou, China, pp103-115.