What makes segmentation good? A case study in boreal forest habitat mapping

International Journal of Remote Sensing

Volumn 34, Issue 23, 2013, Pages 8603-8627

  Räsänen, Aleksi ^a   Rusanen, Antti ^a   Kuitunen, Markku ^a   Lensu, Anssi ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF JYVÄSKYLÄ   (Finland)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

DECISION TREES; ECOSYSTEMS; FORESTRY; MAPPING; SATELLITE IMAGERY;

CLASSIFICATION ACCURACY; DIGITAL ELEVATION MODEL; PARAMETER COMBINATION; RANDOM FOREST CLASSIFIER; SEGMENTATION EVALUATION; SUPERVISED SEGMENTATION EVALUATIONS; VISUAL INTERPRETATION; WATERSHED SEGMENTATION;

SURVEYING;

BOREAL FOREST; CANOPY; DIGITAL ELEVATION MODEL; HABITAT; IMAGE CLASSIFICATION; SATELLITE DATA; SATELLITE IMAGERY; SEGMENTATION; VEGETATION MAPPING; VISUAL ANALYSIS;

DECISION MAKING; FORESTRY; IMAGE ANALYSIS; SATELLITES; TREES;

FINLAND;

EID: 84886930214     PISSN: 01431161     EISSN: 13665901     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/01431161.2013.845318     Document Type: Article

References (80)

1. Ahti, T., L. Hämet-Ahti, and J. Jalas. 1968. "Vegetation Zones and their Sections in Northwestern Europe." Annales Botanici Fennici 5: 169-211.
2. Baatz, M., and A. Schäpe. 2000. "Multiresolution Segmentation - An Optimization Approach for High Quality Multi-Scale Image Segmentation." In Angewandte Geographische Informationsverarbeitung XII, edited by J. Strobl and G. Griesebner, 12-23. Heidelberg: Wichmann.
3. Bar Massada, A., R. Kent, L. Blank, A. Perevolotsky, L. Hadar, and Y. Carmel. 2012. "Automated Segmentation of Vegetation Units in a Mediterranean Landscape." International Journal of Remote Sensing 33: 346-364.
4. Benz, U. C., P. Hofmann, G. Willhauck, I. Lingenfelder, and M. Heynen. 2004. "Multi-Resolution, Object-Oriented Fuzzy Analysis of Remote Sensing Data for GIS-Ready Information." ISPRS Journal of Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing 58: 239-258.
5. Blaschke, T. 2010. "Object Based Image Analysis for Remote Sensing." ISPRS Journal of Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing 65: 2-16.
6. Bock, M., P. Xofis, J. Mitchley, G. Rossner, and M. Wissen. 2005. "Object-Oriented Methods for Habitat Mapping at Multiple Scales - Case Studies from Northern Germany and Wye Downs, UK." Journal of Nature Conservation 13: 75-89.
7. Böhner, J., and T. Selige. 2006. "Spatial Prediction of Soil Attributes Using Terrain Analysis and Climate Regionalisation." In SAGA - Analysis and Modelling Applications, Vol. 115, edited by J. Böhner, K. R. McCloy, and J. Strobl, 13-28. Göttingen: Goltze (Göttinger Geographische Abhandlungen 115).
8. Breidenbach, J., E. Næsset, V. Lien, T. Gobakken, and S. Solberg. 2010. "Prediction of Species Specific Forest Inventory Attributes Using a Nonparametric Semi-Individual Tree Crown Approach Based on Fused Airborne Laser Scanning and Multispectral Data." Remote Sensing of Environment 114: 911-924.
9. Breiman, L. 2001. "Random Forests." Machine Learning 45: 5-32.
10. Breiman, L., and A. Cutler. 2007. "Random Forest: Classification Description." Accessed October 3, 2013. http://www.stat.berkeley.edu/~breiman/RandomForests/cc_home.htm
11. Câmara, G., L. Vinhas, K. Reis Ferreira, G. Ribeiro de Queiroz, R. Cartaxo Modesto De Souza, A. Miguel Vieira Monteiro, M. Tílio de Carvalho, M. Antonio Casanova, and U. Moura De Freitas. 2008. "TerraLib: An Open Source GIS Library for Large-Scale Environmental and Socio-Economic Applications." In Open Source Approaches in Spatial Data Handling, edited by G. Brent Hall, and M. G. Leahy, 247-270. Berlin: Springer.
12. Carleer, A. P., O. Debeir, and E. Wolff. 2005. "Assessment of Very High Resolution Satellite Image Segmentations." Photogrammetric Engineering & Remote Sensing 71: 1285-1294.
13. Castilla, G., G. J. Hay, and J. R. Ruiz-Gallardo. 2008. "Size-Constrained Region Merging (SCRM): An Automated Delineation Tool for Assisted Photointerpretation." Photogrammetric Engineering & Remote Sensing 74: 409-419.
14. Chabrier, S., C. Rosenberger, B. Emile, and H. Laurent. 2008. "Optimization-Based Image Segmentation by Genetic Algorithms." EURASIP Journal on Image and Video Processing 2008: 842029. doi:10.1155/2008/842029.
15. Cherrill, A., and C. McClean. 1995. "An Investigation of Uncertainty in Field Habitat Mapping and the Implications for Detecting Land Cover Change." Landscape Ecology 10: 5-21.
16. Cherrill, A., and C. McClean. 1999. "The Reliability of 'Phase 1' Habitat Mapping in the UK: The Extent and Types of Observer Bias." Landscape and Urban Planning 45: 131-143.
17. Clinton, N., A. Holt, J. Scarborough, Li. Yan, and P. Gong. 2010. "Accuracy Assessment Measures for Object-Based Image Segmentation Goodness." Photogrammetric Engineering & Remote Sensing 76: 289-299.
18. Corcoran, P., A. Winstanley, and P. Mooney. 2010. "Segmentation Performance Evaluation for Object-Based Remotely Sensed Image Analysis." International Journal of Remote Sensing 31: 617-645.
19. Derivaux, S., G. Forestier, C. Wemmert, and S. Lefévre. 2010. "Supervised Image Segmentation Using Watershed Transform, Fuzzy Classification and Evolutionary Computation." Pattern Recognition Letters 31: 2364-2374.
20. Dingle Robertson, L., and D. J. King. 2011. "Comparison of Pixel- and Object-Based Classification in Land Cover Change Mapping." International Journal of Remote Sensing 32: 1505-1529.
21. dos Santos, J. A., P.-H. Gosselin, S. Phillipp-Foliguet, R. D. S. Torres, and A. X. Falcão. 2012. "Multiscale Classification of Remote Sensing Images." IEEE Transactions on Geoscience and Remote Sensing 50: 3764-3775.
22. Drǎguţ, L., D. Tiede, and S. R. Levick. 2010. "ESP: A Tool to Estimate Scale Parameter for Multiresolution Image Segmentation of Remotely Sensed Data." International Journal of Geographical Information Science 24: 859-871.
23. Duro, D. C., S. E. Franklin, and M. G. Dubé. 2012. "A Comparison of Pixel-Based and Object-Based Image Analysis with Selected Machine Learning Algorithms for the Classification of Agricultural Landscapes Using SPOT-5 HRG Imagery." Remote Sensing of Environment 118: 259-272.
24. Espindola, G. M., G. Camara, I. A. Reis, L. S. Bins, and A. M. Monteiro. 2006. "Parameter Selection for Region-Growing Image Segmentation Algorithms Using Spatial Autocorrelation." International Journal of Remote Sensing 27: 3035-3040.
25. Eysn, L., M. Hollaus, K. Schadauer, and N. Pfeifer. 2012. "Forest Delineation Based on Airborne LIDAR Data." Remote Sensing 4: 762-783. doi:10.3390/rs4030762.
26. Falkowski, M. J., M. A. Wulder, J. C. White, and M. G. Gillis. 2009. "Supporting Large-Area, Sample-Based Forest Inventories with Very High Spatial Resolution Satellite Imagery." Progress in Physical Geography 33: 403-423.
27. Feitosa, R. Q., G. A. O. P. Costa, T. B. Cazes, and B. Feijo. 2006. "A Genetic Approach for the Automatic Adaptation of Segmentation Parameters." International Archives of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences 36 (4/C42). http://www.isprs.org/proceedings/XXXVI/4-C42/Papers/11_Adaption%20and%20further%20development%20III/OBIA2006_Feitosa_et_al.pdf.
28. Freeman, T. G. 1991. "Calculating Catchment Area with Divergent Flow Based on a Regular Grid." Computers and Geosciences 17: 413-422.
29. Gao, Y., J. F. Mas, N. Kerle, and J. A. Navarrete Pacheco. 2011. "Optimal Region Growing Segmentation and its Effect on Classification Accuracy." International Journal of Remote Sensing 32: 3747-3763.
30. Geerling, G. W., M. Labrador-Garcia, J. P. G. W. Clevers, A. M. J. Ragas, and A. J. M. Smits. 2007. "Classification of Floodplain Vegetation by Data-Fusion of Spectral (CASI) and LiDAR Data." International Journal of Remote Sensing 28: 4263-4284.
31. Geerling, G. W., M. J. Vreeken-Buijs, P. Jesse, A. M. J. Ragas, and A. J. M. Smits. 2009. "Mapping River Floodplain Ecotopes by Segmentation of Spectral (CASI) and Structural (LiDAR) Remote Sensing Data." River Research and Applications 25: 795-813.
32. Gonzales, R. C., and R. E. Woods. 2002. Digital Image Processing. 2nd ed. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall.
33. Grabs, T., J. Seibert, K. Bishop, and H. Laudon. 2009. "Modeling Spatial Patterns of Saturated Areas: A Comparison of the Topographic Wetness Index and a Dynamic Distributed Model." Journal of Hydrology 373: 15-23.
34. Güntner, A., J. Seibert, and S. Uhlenbrook. 2004. "Modeling Spatial Patterns of Saturated Areas: An Evaluation of Different Terrain Indices." Water Resources Research 40: W05114. doi:10.1029/2003WR002864.
35. Hay, G. J., T. Blaschke, D. J. Marceau, and A. Bouchard. 2003. "A Comparison of Three Image-Object Methods for the Multiscale Analysis of Landscape Structure." ISPRS Journal of Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing 57: 327-345.
36. Hay, G. J., G. Castilla, M. A. Wulder, and J. R. Ruiz. 2005. "An Automated Object-Based Approach for the Multiscale Image Segmentation of Forest Scenes." International Journal of Applied Earth Observation and Geoinformation 7: 339-359.
37. Hou, Z., Q. Xu, T. Nuutinen, and T. Tokola. 2013. "Extraction of Remote Sensing-Based Forest Management Units in Tropical Forests." Remote Sensing of Environment 130: 1-10.
38. Isenburg, M. 2011. LAStools: Efficient Tools for LiDAR Processing. Version 110815. http://lastools.org
39. Ji, X., Y. Bo, J. Cheng, Y. He, and X. Liu. 2012. "The Method of Assessing Shape Similarity of Object-Based Classification Result of Remote Sensing Imagery." In Proceedings of the Second International Workshop on Earth Observation and Remote Sensing Applications (EORSA 2012), 157-160. IEEE. http://ieeexplore.ieee.org/xpl/mostRecentIssue.jsp?punumber=6248407/
40. Ke, Y., L. J. Quackenbush, and J. Im. 2010. "Synergistic Use of QuickBird Multispectral Imagery and LIDAR Data for Object-Based Forest Species Classification." Remote Sensing of Environment 114: 1141-1154.
41. Kim, M., M. Madden, and T. A. Warner. 2008. "Estimation of Optimal Image Object Size for the Segmentation of Forest Stands with Multispectral IKONOS Imagery." In Object-Based Image Analysis: Spatial Concepts for Knowledge-Driven Remote Sensing Applications, edited by T. Blaschke, S. Lang, and G. J. Hay, 291-307. Berlin: Springer.
42. Kim, M., M. Madden, and T. A. Warner. 2009. "Forest Type Mapping Using Object-Specific Texture Measures from Multispectral Ikonos Imagery: Segmentation Quality and Image Classification Issues." Photogrammetric Engineering & Remote Sensing 75: 819-829.
43. Kim, M., T. A. Warner, M. Madden, and D. S. Atkinson. 2011. "Multi-Scale GEOBIA with Very High Spatial Resolution Digital Aerial Imagery: Scale, Texture and Image Objects." International Journal of Remote Sensing 32: 2825-2850.
44. Kopecký, M., and Š. Čížková. 2010. "Using Topographic Wetness Index in Vegetation Ecology: Does the Algorithm Matter?" Applied Vegetation Science 13: 450-459.
45. Lang, S., F. Albrecht, S. Kienberger, and D. Tiede. 2010. "Object Validity for Operational Tasks in a Policy Context." Journal of Spatial Science 55: 9-22.
46. Lawrence, R. L., S. D. Wood, and R. L. Sheley. 2006. "Mapping Invasive Plants Using Hyperspectral Imagery and Breiman Cutler Classifications (RandomForest)." Remote Sensing of Environment 100: 356-362.
47. Leckie, D. G., F. A. Gougeon, N. Walsworth, and D. Paradine. 2003. "Stand Delineation and Composition Estimation Using Semi-Automated Individual Tree Crown Analysis." Remote Sensing of Environment 85: 355-369.
48. Li, H., H. Gu, Y. Han, and J. Yang. 2010. "Object-Oriented Classification of High-Resolution Remote Sensing Imagery Based on an Improved Colour Structure Code and a Support Vector Machine." International Journal of Remote Sensing 31: 1453-1470.
49. Li, N., H. Huo, and T. Fang. 2010. "A Novel Texture-Preceded Segmentation Algorithm for High-Resolution Imagery." IEEE Transactions on Geoscience and Remote Sensing 48: 2818-2828.
50. Liaw, A., and M. Wiener. 2002. "Classification and Regression by randomForest." R News 2/3: 18-22.
51. Lucieer, A., and A. Stein. 2002. "Existential Uncertainty of Spatial Objects Segmented from Satellite Sensor Imagery." IEEE Transactions on Geoscience and Remote Sensing 40: 2518-2521.
52. Marpu, P. R., M. Neubert, H. Herold, and I. Niemeyer. 2010. "Enhanced Evaluation of Image Segmentation Results." Journal of Spatial Science 55: 55-68.
53. Meinel, G., and M. Neubert. 2004. "A Comparison of Segmentation Programs for High Resolution Remote Sensing Data." International Archives of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences 35 (B4): 1097-1105. http://www.isprs.org/proceedings/XXXV/congress/comm4/papers/506.pdf.
54. Möller, M., L. Lymburner, and M. Volk. 2007. "The Comparison Index: A Tool for Assessing the Accuracy of Image Segmentation." International Journal of Applied Earth Observation and Geoinformation 9: 311-321.
55. Murphy, P. N. C., J. Ogilvie, and P. Arp. 2009. "Topographic Modeling of Soil Moisture Conditions: A Comparison and Verification of Two Models." European Journal of Soil Science 60: 94-109.
56. Mustonen, J., P. Packalén, and A. Kangas. 2008. "Automatic Segmentation of Forest Stands Using a Canopy Height Model and Aerial Photography." Scandinavian Journal of Forest Research 23: 534-545.
57. Neubert, M., and H. Herold. 2008. "Assessment of Remote Sensing Image Segmentation Quality." International Archives of Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences 38 (4/C1). http://www.isprs.org/proceedings/XXXVIII/4-C1/Sessions/Session2/6721_Neubert_Proc_pap.pdf.
58. Neubert, M., H. Herold, and G. Meinel. 2008. "Assessing Image Segmentation Quality - Concepts, Methods and Applications." In Object-Based Image Analysis: Spatial Concepts for Knowledge-Driven Remote Sensing Applications, edited by T. Blaschke, S. Lang, and G. J. Hay, 769-784. Berlin: Springer.
59. Neubert, M., and G. Meinel. 2003. "Evaluation of Segmentation Programs for High Resolution Remote Sensing Applications." In Proceedings Joint ISPRS/EARSeL Workshop "High Resolution Mapping from Space 2003", edited by M. Schroeder, K. Jacobsen, and C. Heipke, Hannover, October 6-8. http://www.ipi.uni-hannover.de/fileadmin/institut/pdf/neubert.pdf
60. Pekkarinen, A. 2002. "Image Segment-Based Spectral Features in the Estimation of Timber Volume." Remote Sensing of Environment 82: 349-359.
61. R Development Core Team. 2012. R: A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing. Vienna: R Foundation for Statistical Computing. ISBN 3-900051-07-0. http://www.R-project.org
62. Radoux, J., and P. Defourny. 2007. "A Quantitative Assessment of Boundaries in Automated Forest Stand Delineation Using Very High Resolution Imagery." Remote Sensing of Environment 110: 468-475.
63. Räsänen, A., M. Kuitunen, E. Tomppo, and A. Lensu. Forthcoming. "Coupling High-Resolution Satellite Imagery with LiDAR-Based Canopy Height Model and Digital Elevation Model in Object-Based Boreal Forest Habitat Type Classification." Manuscript submitted for publication.
64. Rodriguez-Galiano, V. F., B. Ghimire, J. Rogan, M. Chica-Olmo, and J. P. Rigol-Sanchez. 2012. "An Assessment of the Effectiveness of a Random Forest Classifier for Land-Cover Classification." ISPRS Journal of Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing 67: 93-104.
65. Smith, A. 2010. "Image Segmentation Scale Parameter Optimization and Land Cover Classification Using the Random Forest Algorithm." Journal of Spatial Science 55: 69-79.
66. Sørensen, R., U. Zinko, and J. Seibert. 2006. "On the Calculation of the Topographic Wetness Index: An Evaluation of Different Methods Based on Field Observations." Hydrology and Earth System Sciences 10: 101-112.
67. Tian, J., and D.-M. Chen. 2007. "Optimization in Multi-Scale Segmentation of High-Resolution Satellite Images for Artificial Feature Recognition." International Journal of Remote Sensing 28: 4625-4644.
68. Verbeeck, K., M. Hermy, and J. van Orshoven. 2012. "External Geo-Information in the Segmentation of VHR Imagery Improves the Detection of Imperviousness in Urban Neighborhoods." International Journal of Applied Earth Observation and Geoinformation 18: 428-435.
69. Vesterbacka, R. 2010. Luontopalvelujen Luontotyyppi-Inventoinnin Maastotyöohje. Vantaa: Metsähallitus.
70. Wang, L., W. Sousa, and P. Gong. 2004. "Integration of Object-Based and Pixel-Based Classification for Mapping Mangroves with IKONOS Imagery." International Journal of Remote Sensing 25: 5655-5668.
71. Wang, Z., J. R. Jensen, and J. Im. 2010. "An Automatic Region-Based Image Segmentation Algorithm for Remote Sensing Applications." Environmental Modelling and Software 25: 1149-1165.
72. Weidner, U. 2008. "Contribution to the Assessment of Segmentation Quality for Remote Sensing Applications." International Archives of Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences 37 (B7): 479-484. http://www.isprs.org/proceedings/XXXVII/congress/7_pdf/4_WG-VII-4/01.pdf.
73. Whiteside, T. G., G. S. Boggs, and S. W. Maier. 2011. "Comparing Object-Based and Pixel-Based Classifications for Mapping Savannas." International Journal of Applied Earth Observation and Geoinformation 13: 884-893.
74. Wulder, M. A., J. C. White, G. J. Hay, and G. Castilla. 2008. "Towards Automated Segmentation of Forest Inventory Polygons on High Spatial Resolution Satellite Imagery." The Forestry Chronicle 84: 221-230.
75. Yang, L., F. Albregtsen, T. Lønnestad, and P. Grøttum. 1995. "A Supervised Approach to the Evaluation of Image Segmentation Methods." In Computer Analysis of Images and Patterns: 6th International Conference, CAIP '95 Prague Czech Republic, September 6-8, 1995 Proceedings, edited by V. Hlaváč, and R. Šára, Vol. 970, 759-765. Lecture Notes on Computer Science. Heildelberg: Springer.
76. Yue, A., J. Yang, C. Zhang, W. Su, W. Yun, D. Zhu, S. Liu, and Z. Wang. 2012. "The Optimal Segmentation Scale Identification Using Multispectral WorldView-2 Images." Sensor Letters 10: 285-291.
77. Zhan, Q., M. Molenaar, K. Tempfli, and W. Shi. 2005. "Quality Assessment for Geo-Spatial Objects Derived from Remotely Sensed Data." International Journal of Remote Sensing 26: 2593-2974.
78. Zhang, H., J. E. Fritts, and S. A. Goldman. 2008. "Image Segmentation Evaluation: A Survey of Unsupervised Methods." Computer Vision and Image Understanding 110: 260-280.
79. Zhang, Y. J. 1996. "A Survey on Evaluation Methods for Image Segmentation." Pattern Recognition 29: 1335-1346.
80. Zhang, Y. J. 1997. "Evaluation and Comparison of Different Segmentation Algorithms." Pattern Recognition Letters 18: 963-974.