On the Myths of Indicator Species: Issues and Further Consideration in the Use of Static Concepts for Ecological Applications

PLoS ONE

Volumn 8, Issue 10, 2013, Pages

  Zettler, Michael L ^a   Proffitt, C Edward ^b   Darr, Alexander ^a   Degraer, Steven ^c   Devriese, Lisa ^d   Greathead, Clare ^e   Kotta, Jonne ^f   Magni, Paolo ^g,j   Martin, Georg ^f   Reiss, Henning ^h,k   Speybroeck, Jeroen ⁱ   Tagliapietra, Davide ^j   Van Hoey, Gert ^d   Ysebaert, Tom ^l,m  

^a LEIBNIZ INSTITUTE FOR BALTIC SEA RESEARCH   (Germany)

^b FLORIDA ATLANTIC UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^c ROYAL BELGIAN INSTITUTE OF NATURAL SCIENCES   (Belgium)

^d INSTITUTE FOR AGRICULTURAL AND FISHERIES RESEARCH ILVO   (Belgium)

^e MARINE LABORATORY   (United Kingdom)

^f UNIVERSITY OF TARTU   (Estonia)

^g CNR   (Italy)

^h NORD UNIVERSITY   (Norway)

ⁱ RESEARCH INSTITUTE FOR NATURE AND FOREST INBO   (Belgium)

^j INSTITUTE OF MARINE SCIENCES   (Italy)

^k SENCKENBERG DEUTSCHES ENTOMOLOGISCHES INSTITUT   (Germany)

^l ROYAL NETHERLANDS INSTITUTE FOR SEA RESEARCH   (Netherlands)

^m WAGENINGEN UNIVERSITY   (Netherlands)

more..

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ORGANIC MATTER;

AMPHARETE BALTICA; ARTICLE; AUTECOLOGY; BATHYPOREIA PILOSA; BIOGEOGRAPHIC REGION; CERASTODERMA GLAUCUM; CORBULA GIBBA; ENVIRONMENTAL FACTOR; HABITUAL ADAPTATION; HEDISTE DIVERSICOLOR; INDICATOR ORGANISM; MARINE ENVIRONMENT; MARINE SPECIES; NONHUMAN; POPULATION ABUNDANCE; QUALITY CONTROL; SALINITY; SEDIMENT; SPECIES DISTRIBUTION; TRAVISIA FORBESII;

AMPHIPODA; ANIMALS; BIODIVERSITY; ECOLOGY; ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING; SALINITY; WATER POLLUTANTS, CHEMICAL;

EID: 84885798009     PISSN: None     EISSN: 19326203     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0078219     Document Type: Article

References (87)

1. Gray JS, Pearson TH, (1982) Objective selection of sensitive species indicative of pollution-induced change in benthic communities. I. Comparative methodology. Mar Ecol Prog Ser 9: 111-119. doi:10.3354/meps009111.
2. Pearson TH, Gray JS, Johannessen PJ, (1983) Objective selection of sensitive species indicative of pollution-induced change in benthic communities. 2. Data analyses. Mar Ecol Prog Ser 12: 237-225. doi:10.3354/meps012237.
3. Dauvin J-C, Bellan G, Bellan-Santini D, (2010) Benthic indicators: From subjectivity to objectivity - Where is the line? Mar Pollut Bull 60: 947-953. doi:10.1016/j.marpolbul.2010.03.028. PubMed: 20413132.
4. Zettler ML, Darr A, Labrenz M, Sagert S, Selig U, et al. (2013) The indicator value of organisms. In: Snoeijs P, Schubert H, Radziejewska T, eds. Biological Oceanography of the Baltic Sea. Springer Verlag. In press.
5. Reish DJ, (1957) The relationship of the polychaetous annelid Capitella capitata to waste discharge of biological origin. In: Tarzwell CM, eds. Biological Problems in Water Pollution. Cincinnati, OH: US Public Health Service. pp. pp. 195-200.
6. Word JQ, Myers BL, Mearns AJ, (1977) Animals that are indicators of marine pollution. Annu Rep, Coastal Water Research Project, El Segundo, Calif. pp. pp. 199-206.
7. Word JQ, (1979) The infaunal trophic index. Annu Rep, 1978: Coastal Water Research Project, El Segundo, Calif. pp. pp. 19-39.
8. Marchand M, Vas D, Duursma EK, (1976) Levels of PCBs and DDTs in mussels from the NW Mediterranean. Mar Pollut Bull 7: 65-69. doi:10.1016/0025-326X(76)90014-X.
9. Carignan V, Villard M-A, (2002) Selecting indicator species to monitor ecological integrity: A review. Environ Monit Assess 78: 45-61. doi:10.1023/A:1016136723584. PubMed: 12197640.
10. Van Hoey G, Borja A, Birchenough S, Degraer S, Fleischer D, et al. (2010) The use of benthic indicators in Europe: from the Water Framework Directive to the Marine Strategy Framework Directive. Mar Pollut Bull 60: 2187-2196. doi:10.1016/j.marpolbul.2010.09.015. PubMed: 21051051.
11. Heink U, Kowarik I, (2010) What are indicators? On the definition of indicators in ecology and environmental planning. Ecol Indic 10: 584-593. doi:10.1016/j.ecolind.2009.09.009.
12. Bellan G, Bellan-Santini D, (1972) Influence de la pollution sur les peuplements marins de la région de Marseille. In: Ruivo M, eds. Marine Pollution and Sea Life. London, UK: FAO, Fishing News (Books) Ltd. pp. pp. 396-401.
13. Pérès JM, Bellan G, (1972) Aperçu sur l'influence des pollutions sur les peuplements benthiques. Ruivo M, eds. Marine Pollution and Sea Life. London, UK: FAO, Fishing News (Books) Ltd. pp. pp. 375-386.
14. Leppäkoski E, (1975) Assessment of degree of pollution on the basis of macrozoobenthos in marine brackish-water environments. Acta Acad Abo Ser B 35: 1-96.
15. Pantle R, Buck H, (1955) Die biologische Überwachung der Gewässer und die Darstellung der Ergebnisse. Gas Und Wasserfach Wasser Abwasser 96: 604-607 (in German).
16. Zettler ML, Schiedek D, Bobertz B, (2007) Benthic biodiversity indices versus salinity gradient in the southern Baltic Sea. Mar Pollut Bull 55: 258-270. doi:10.1016/j.marpolbul.2006.08.024. PubMed: 17010998.
17. Fleischer D, Zettler ML, (2009) An adjustment of benthic ecological quality assessment to effects of salinity. Mar Pollut Bull 58: 351-357. doi:10.1016/j.marpolbul.2008.10.016. PubMed: 19084875.
18. Barbone E, Rosati I, Reizopoulou S, Basset A, (2012) Linking classification boundaries to sources of natural variability in transitional waters: A case study of benthic macroinvertebrates. Ecol Indic 12: 105-122. doi:10.1016/j.ecolind.2011.04.014.
19. Magni P, Tagliapietra D, Lardicci C, Balthis L, Castelli A, et al. (2009) Animal-sediment relationships: Evaluating the 'Pearson-Rosenberg paradigm' in Mediterranean coastal lagoons. Mar Pollut Bull 58: 478-486. doi:10.1016/j.marpolbul.2008.12.009. PubMed: 19162282.
20. Tagliapietra D, Sigovini M, Magni P, (2012) Saprobity: A unified view of benthic succession models for coastal lagoons. Hydrobiologia 686: 15-28. doi:10.1007/s10750-012-1001-8.
21. Majeed SA, (1987) Organic matter and biotic indices on the beaches of North Brittany. Mar Pollut Bull 18: 490-495. doi:10.1016/0025-326X(87)90360-2.
22. Grall J, Glémarec M, (1997) Using biotic indices to estimate macrobenthic community perturbations in the Bay of Brest. Estuar Coast Shelf Sci 44: 43-53. doi:10.1016/S0272-7714(97)80006-6.
23. Weisberg SB, Ranasighe JA, Schaffner LC, Diaz RJ, Dauer DM, et al. (1997) An estuarine index of biological integrity (B-IBI) for Chesapeake Bay. Estuaries 20: 149-158. doi:10.2307/1352728.
24. Borja A, Franco J, Pérez V, (2000) A marine biotic index to establish the ecological quality of soft-bottom benthos within European estuarine and coastal environments. Mar Pollut Bull 40: 1100-1114. doi:10.1016/S0025-326X(00)00061-8.
25. Simboura N, Zenetos A, (2002) Benthic indicators to use in Ecological Quality classification of Mediterranean soft bottom marine ecosystems, including a new Biotic Index. Medit Mar Sci 3: 77-111.
26. Rosenberg R, Blomqvist M, Nilsson HC, Cederwall H, Dimming A, (2004) Marine quality assessment by use of benthic species-abundance distributions: a proposed new protocol within the European Union Water Framework Directive. Mar Pollut Bull 49: 728-739. doi:10.1016/j.marpolbul.2004.05.013. PubMed: 15530516.
27. Meng TT, Ni J, Harrison SP, (2009) Plant morphometric traits and climate gradients in northern China: a meta-analysis using quadrat and flora data. Ann Bot 104: 1217-1229. doi:10.1093/aob/mcp230. PubMed: 19805404.
28. Dowdall JRT, (2012) Intra- and interspecific variation along environmental gradients: Adaption, plasticity, and range limits [PhD Dissertation]. Colorado State University. p. pp. 162.
29. Bolnick DI, Amarasekare P, Araújo MS, Bürger R, Levine JM, et al. (2012) Why intraspecific trait variation matters in community ecology. Trends Ecol Evol 26: 183-192. PubMed: 21367482.
30. Grémare A, Labrune C, Vanden Berghe E, Amouroux JM, Bachelet G, et al. (2009) Comparison of the performances of two biotic indices based on the MacroBen database. Mar Ecol Prog Ser 382: 297-311. doi:10.3354/meps08030.
31. Kolkwitz R, Marsson M, (1902) Grundsätze für die biologische Beurteilung des Wassers nach seiner Flora und Fauna. Mittheilungen Königlichen Versuchs Und Prüfungsanstalt Wasserversorgung Abwässerbeseitigung Berl 1: 33-72 (in German).
32. Kolkwitz R, Marsson M, (1908) Ökologie der pflanzlichen Saprobien. Ber Deutschen Botanischen Gesellschaft pp. 26a: 505-519 (in German).
33. Kolkwitz R, Marsson M, (1909) Ökologie der tierischen Saprobien. Int Rev Gesamten Hydrobiol 2: 126-152 (in German). doi:10.1002/iroh.19090020108.
34. Zelinka M, Marvan P, (1961) Zur Präzisierung der biologischen Klassifikation der Reinheit fließender Gewässer. Arch Hydrobiol 57: 389-407 (in German).
35. Wilhelmi J, (1916) Übersicht über die biologische Beurteilung des Wassers. Sber Ges Naturf Fr Bln. pp. pp. 297-306 (in German).
36. Meyer T, Berg T, Fürhaupter K, (2008) Ostsee Makrozoobenthos Klassifizierungssystem für die Wasserrahmenrichtlinie. Referenz-Artenlisten, Bewertungsmodell und Monitoring. MARILIM Gewässeruntersuchung. p. 131. Available: http://www.marilim.de/marbit/download/files/MarBIT.pdf. [Accessed 20 May 2013].
37. Keely NB, Macleod CK, Forrest BM, (2012) Combining best professional judgement and quantile regression splines to improve characterisation of macrofaunal responses to enrichment. Ecol Indic 12: 154-166. doi:10.1016/j.ecolind.2011.03.022.
38. Pelletier MC, Gold AJ, Heltshe JF, Buffum HW, (2010) A method to identify estuarine macroinvertebrate pollution indicator species in the Virginian Biogeographic Province. Ecol Indic 10: 1037-1048. doi:10.1016/j.ecolind.2010.03.005.
39. Dauvin JC, Alizier S, Rolet C, Bakalem A, Bellan G, et al. (2012) Response of different benthic indices to diverse human pressures. Ecol Indic 12: 143-153. doi:10.1016/j.ecolind.2011.03.019.
40. Ysebaert T, Herman PMJ, Meire P, Craeymeersch J, Verbeek H, et al. (2003) Large-scale spatial patterns in estuaries: estuarine macrobenthic communities in the Schelde estuary, NW Europe. Estuar Coast Shelf Sci 57: 335-355. doi:10.1016/S0272-7714(02)00359-1.
41. Zettler ML, Schiedek D, Glockzin M, (2008) Zoobenthos. In: Feistel R, Nausch G, Wasmund N, eds. State and Evolution of the Baltic Sea, 1952- 2005. A Detailed 50-Year Survey of Meteorology and Climate, Physics, Chemistry, Biology, and Marine Environment. Hoboken: John Wiley & Sons. pp. pp. 517-541.
42. Telesh IV, Khlebovich VV, (2010) Principal processes within the estuarine salinity gradient: A review. Mar Pollut Bull 61: 149-155. doi:10.1016/j.marpolbul.2010.02.008. PubMed: 20304437.
43. Ganoulis J, (2009) Risk analysis of water pollution (2nd ed.). Weinheim: Wiley VCH Verlag.
44. Hyland J, Balthis LW, Karakassis I, Magni P, Petrov A, et al. (2005) Organic carbon content of sediments as an indicator of stress in the marine benthos. Mar Ecol Prog Ser 295: 91-103. doi:10.3354/meps295091.
45. Reusser DA, Lee H, (2011) Evolution of natural history information in the 21st century - developing an integrated framework for biological and geographical data. J Biogeogr 38: 1225-1239. doi:10.1111/j.1365-2699.2011.02515.x.
46. Mebius LJ, (1960) A rapid method for the determination of organic carbon in soil. Anal Chim Acta 22: 120-124. doi:10.1016/S0003-2670(00)88254-9.
47. Magni P, De Falco G, Como S, Casu D, Floris A, et al. (2008) Distribution and ecological relevance of fine sediments in organic-enriched lagoons: the case study of the Cabras lagoon (Sardinia, Italy). Mar Pollut Bull 56: 549-564. doi:10.1016/j.marpolbul.2007.12.004. PubMed: 18234238.
48. MarLIN (The Marine Life Information Network). Available: http://www.marlin.ac.uk/. [Accessed 20 May 2013].
49. Hartmann-Schröder G, (1996) Annelida, Borstenwürmer, Polychaeta. (2. Aufl.) In: Dahl F, eds., Die Tierwelt Deutschlands und der angrenzenden Meeresteile nach ihren Merkmalen und ihrer Lebensweise. Teil 58. Jena: Gustav Fischer Verlag. p. pp. 648 (in German).
50. Krause JC, (2002) he effects of marine sediment extraction on sensitive macrozoobenthic populations in the southern Baltic Sea [PhD Thesis]. University of Rostock.
51. Scaps P, (2002) A review of the biology, ecology and potential use of the common ragworm Hediste diversicolor (OF Müller) (Annelida: Polychaeta). Hydrobiologia 470: 203-218. doi:10.1023/A:1015681605656.
52. d'Udekem d'Acoz C, (2004) The genus Bathyporeia Lindström, 1855, in western Europe (Crustacea: Amphipoda: Pontoporeiidae). Zool Verhand 348: 1-164.
53. Hrs-Brenko M, (2006) The basket shell, Corbula gibba Olivi, 1792 (Bivalve Mollusks) as a species resistant to environmental disturbances: A review. Acta Adriat 47: 49-64.
54. Yonge CM, (1946) On the habits and adaptations of Aloidis (Corbula) gibba. J Mar Biol Assoc UK 26: 358-376. doi:10.1017/S0025315400012182. PubMed: 20992402.
55. Russell PJ, Petersen GH, (1973) The use of ecological data in the elucidation of some shallow water European Cardium species. Malacologia 14: 223-232.
56. Thrush SF, Hewitt JE, Herman PMJ, Ysebaert T, (2005) Multi-scale analysis of species-environment relationships. Mar Ecol Prog Ser 302: 13-26. doi:10.3354/meps302013.
57. Anderson MJ, (2008) Animal-sediment relationships re-visited: Characterising species' distributions along an environmental gradient using canonical analysis and quantile regression splines. J Exp Mar Biol Ecol 366: 16-27. doi:10.1016/j.jembe.2008.07.006.
58. Koenker R, (2012) quantreg: Quantile Regression. R package version 4.79. Available: http://CRAN.R-project.org/package=quantreg.
59. Hastie TJ, (1992) Generalized additive models. Chapter 7 of Statistical Models in S. In: Chambers JM, Hastie TJ, eds. Wadsworth Publishing House & Brooks/Cole.
60. R Development Core Team (2012) R: A language and environment for statistical computing. Vienna, Austria: R Foundation for Statistical Computing. Available: http://www.R-project.org/.
61. Burnham KP, Anderson DR, (2002) Model selection and multi-model inference: a practical information-theoretic approach, 2nd edition. New York: Springer Verlag.
62. Gray S, Elliott M, (2009) Ecology of Marine Sediments: From Science to Management, second edition. New York: Oxford University Press.
63. Herkül K, Kotta J, Kotta I, Orav-Kotta H, (2006) Effects of physical disturbance, isolation and key macrozoobenthic species on community development, recolonisation and sedimentation processes. Oceanologia 48(S): 267-282.
64. Cai MH, Lin J, Hong QQ, Wang Y, Cai MG, (2011) Content and distribution of trace metals in surface sediments from the northern Bering Sea, Chukchi Sea and adjacent Arctic areas. Mar Pollut Bull 63: 523-527. doi:10.1016/j.marpolbul.2011.02.007. PubMed: 21377172.
65. Rubio B, Nombela MA, Vilas F, (2000) Geochemistry of major and trace elements in sediments of the Ria de Vigo (NW Spain): an assessment of metal pollution. Mar Pollut Bull 40: 968-980. doi:10.1016/S0025-326X(00)00039-4.
66. Rakocinski CF, Brown SS, Gaston GR, Heard RW, Walker WW, et al. (1997) Macrobenthic responses to natural and contaminant related gradients in northern Gulf of Mexico estuaries. Ecol Appl 7: 1278-1298. doi:10.1890/1051-0761(1997)007[1278:MRTNAC]2.0.CO;2.
67. Jirkov IA, (2001) Polychaeta of the Arctic Ocean. Moscow: Yanus-K (in Russian).
68. Parapar J, Helgason GV, Jirkov I, Moreira J, (2012) Polychaetes of the genus Ampharete (Polychaeta: Ampharetidae) collected in Icelandic waters during the BIOICE project. Helgol Mar Res 66: 331-344.
69. Virgilio M, Fauvelot C, Costantini F, Abbiati M, Backeljau T, (2009) Phylogeography of the common ragworm Hediste diversicolor (Polychaeta: Nereididae) reveals cryptic diversity and multiple colonization events across its distribution. Mol Ecol 18: 1980-1994. doi:10.1111/j.1365-294X.2009.04170.x. PubMed: 19344353.
70. Röhner M, Bastrop R, Jürss K, (1997) Genetic differentiation in Hediste diversicolor (Polychaeta: Nereididae) for the North Sea and the Baltic Sea. Mar Biol 130: 171-180. doi:10.1007/s002270050236.
71. Nikula R, Väinölä R, (2003) Phylogeography of Cerastoderma glaucum (Bivalvia: Cardiidae) across Europe: a major break in the Eastern Mediterranean. Mar Biol 143: 339-350. doi:10.1007/s00227-003-1088-6.
72. Kesäniemi JE, Rawson PD, Lindsay SM, Knott KE, (2012) Phylogenetic analysis of cryptic speciation in the polychaete Pygospio elegans. Ecol Evol 2: 994-1007. doi:10.1002/ece3.226. PubMed: 22837844.
73. Gamenick I, Vismann B, Grieshaber MK, Giere O, (1998) Ecophysiological differentiation of Capitella capitata (Polychaeta). Sibling species from different sulfidic habitats. Mar Ecol Prog Ser 175: 155-166. doi:10.3354/meps175155.
74. Luttikhuizen PC, Bol A, Cardoso JFMF, Dekker R, (2011) Overlapping distributions of cryptic Scoloplos cf. armiger species in the western Wadden Sea. J Sea Res 66: 231-237. doi:10.1016/j.seares.2011.07.002.
75. Baird HP, Miller KJ, Stark JS, (2012) Genetic Population Structure in the Antarctic Benthos: Insights from the Widespread Amphipod, Orchomenella franklini. PLOS ONE 7: e34363. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0034363. PubMed: 22479613.
76. Covich AP, Palmer MA, Crowl TA, (1999) The role of benthic invertebrate species in freshwater ecosystems. Zoobenthic species influence energy flows and nutrient cycling. BioScience 49: 119-127.
77. Maurer D, Nguyen H, Robertson G, Gerlinger T, (1999) The infaunal trophic index (ITI): its suitability for marine environmental monitoring. Ecol Appl 9: 699-713. doi:10.1890/1051-0761(1999)009[0699:TITIII]2.0.CO;2.
78. Kinne O, (1971) Salinity: animals-invertebrates, In Kinne O, eds. Marine Ecology, Vol. 1, Environmental Factors, Part 2. New York: John Wiley and Sons. pp. pp. 821-996.
79. Deaton LE, Greenberg MJ, (1986) There is no horohalinicum. Estuaries 9: 20-30. doi:10.2307/1352189.
80. Khlebovich VV, Abramova EN, (2000) Some problems of crustacean taxonomy related to the phenomenon of Horohalinicum. Hydrobiologia 417: 109-111. doi:10.1023/A:1003863623267.
81. Warwick RM, (1993) Environmental impact studies on marine communities: Pragmatical considerations. Aust J Ecol 18: 63-80. doi:10.1111/j.1442-9993.1993.tb00435.x.
82. Marques JC, Salas F, Patrício J, Teixeira H, Neto JM, (2009) Ecological indicators for coastal and estuarine environmental assessment. A user guide. Southampton: WIT-Press.
83. Weisberg SB, Thompson B, Ranasinghe JA, Montagne DE, Cadien DB, et al. (2008) The level of agreement among experts applying best professional judgment to assess the condition of benthic infaunal communities. Ecol Indic 8: 389-394. doi:10.1016/j.ecolind.2007.04.001.
84. Teixeira H, Borja Á, Weisberg SB, Ranasinghe JA, Cadien DB, et al. (2010) Assessing coastal benthic macrofauna community condition using best professional judgement - Developing consensus across North America and Europe. Mar Pollut Bull 60: 589-600. doi:10.1016/j.marpolbul.2009.11.005. PubMed: 19969316.
85. Thompson B, Weisberg SB, Melwani A, Lowe S, Ranasinghe JA, et al. (2012) Low levels of agreement among experts using best professional judgment to assess benthic condition in the San Francisco Estuary and Delta. Ecol Indic 12: 167-173. doi:10.1016/j.ecolind.2011.03.020.
86. Magni P, Hyland J, Manzella G, Rumohr H, Viaroli P, et al., editors (2005) Proceedings of the Workshop "Indicators of Stress in the Marine Benthos", Torregrande-Oristano, (Italy): IOC Workshop Reports, 195. Available: http://unesdoc.unesco.org/images/0013/001397/139719e.pdf. [Accessed 2013 May 20].
87. Crema R, Castelli A, Prevedelli D, (1991) Long term eutrophication effects on macrofaunal communities in Northern Adriatic Sea. Mar Pollut Bull 22: 503-508. doi:10.1016/0025-326X(91)90405-H.