Evaluation of a feeding strategy to reduce greenhouse gas emissions from dairy farming: The level of analysis matters

Agricultural Systems

Volumn 121, Issue , 2013, Pages 9-22

  Van Middelaar, C E ^a   Berentsen, P B M ^a   Dijkstra, J ^a   De Boer, I J M ^a  

^a WAGENINGEN UNIVERSITY   (Netherlands)

Author keywords

Life cycle assessment; Maize silage; Methane; Mitigation; System boundaries

Indexed keywords

AGRICULTURAL EMISSION; AGRICULTURAL MODELING; ARTIFICIAL DIET; ATMOSPHERIC POLLUTION; CARBON DIOXIDE; DAIRY FARMING; DIET; EMISSION CONTROL; EMISSION INVENTORY; EUROPEAN UNION; GRASS; GRASSLAND; GREENHOUSE GAS; LAND USE CHANGE; LIFE CYCLE ANALYSIS; MAIZE; METHANE; NITROUS OXIDE; PLOWING; SILAGE;

NETHERLANDS;

ANIMALIA; BOS; ZEA MAYS;

EID: 84883447705     PISSN: 0308521X     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.agsy.2013.05.009     Document Type: Article

References (90)

1. Aarts, H.F.M., Bussink, D.W., Hoving, I.E., Van der Meer, H.G.R., Schils, L.M., Velthof, G.L., 2002. Milieutechnische en landbouwkundige effecten van graslandvernieuwing. Een verkenning aan de hand van praktijksituaties. Plant Research International, Rapport 41A, Wageningen.
2. Abrahamse P.A., Tamminga S., Dijkstra J. Effect of daily movement of dairy cattle to fresh grass in morning or afternoon on intake, grazing behaviour, rumen fermentation and milk production. J. Agric. Sci. Cambridge 2009, 147:721-730.
3. Alemu A.W., Dijkstra J., Bannink A., France J., Kebreab E. Rumen stoichiometric models and their contribution and challenges in predicting enteric methane production. Anim. Feed Sci. Technol. 2011, 166-167:761-778.
4. Andrén O., Kätterer T. ICBM: the introductory carbon balance model for exploration of soil carbon balances. J. Appl. Ecol. 1997, 7:1226-1236.
5. Audsley, E., Brander, M., Chatterton, J., Murphy-Bokern, D., Webster, C., Williams, A., 2009. How Low Can We Go? An Assessment of Greenhouse Gas Emissions from the UK Food System and the Scope to Reduce them by 2050. WWF-UK, 10.
6. Bannink A., Kogut J., Dijkstra J., France J., Kebreab E., Van Vuuren A.M., Tamminga S. Estimation of the stoichiometry of volatile fatty acid production in the rumen of lactating cows. J. Theor. Biol. 2006, 238:36-51.
7. Bannink A., van Schijndel M.W., Dijkstra J. A model of enteric fermentation in dairy cows to estimate methane emission for the Dutch National Inventory Report using the IPCC Tier 3 approach. Anim. Feed Sci. Technol. 2011, 166-167:603-618.
8. Basset-Mens C., Ledgard S., Boyes M. Eco-efficiency of intensification scenarios for milk production in New Zealand. Ecol. Econ. 2009, 68:1615-1625.
9. Basset-Mens C., Kelliher F., Ledgard S., Cox N. Uncertainty of global warming potential for milk production on a New Zealand farm and implications for decision making. Int. J. Life Cycle Assess. 2009, 14:630-638.
10. Bauman H., Tillman A.M. The Hitchhiker's Guide to LCA 2004, Chalmers University of Technology, Goteborg, Sweden.
11. Beauchemin K.A., Kreuzer M., O'Mara F., McAllister T.A. Nutritional management for enteric methane abatement: a review. Aust. J. Exp. Agric. 2008, 48:21-27.
12. Berentsen P.B.M., Giesen G.W.J. An environmental-economic model at farm level to analyse institutional and technical change in dairy farming. Agric. Syst. 1995, 49:153-175.
13. CBS, 2013. CBS Statline - Centraal Bureau voor de Statistiek. <>(visited 25.03.13). http://www.statline.cbs.nl/StatWeb/selection.
14. CeHaVe, 2012. Dutch Feeding Company, Veghel, the Netherlands. Personal Communication.
15. Chianese D.S., Rotz C.A., Richard T.L. Simulation of nitrous oxide emissions from dairy farms to assess greenhouse gas reduction strategies. Trans. ASABE 2009, 52:1325-1335.
16. De Mol, R.M., Hilhorst, M.A., 2003. Emissions of Methane, Nitrous Oxide and Ammonia from Production, Storage and Transport of Manure. Institute of Agricultural and Environmental Engineering, Report 2003-03 (in Dutch, with summary in English).
17. De Vries M., De Boer I.J.M. Comparing environmental impacts for livestock products: a review of life cycle assessments. Livest. Sci. 2010, 128:1-11.
18. De Vries J.W., Hoeksma P., Groenestein C.M. Levens Cyclus Analyse (LCA) Pilots Mineralenconcentraten 2011, Wageningen UR Livestock Research, Wageningen, the Netherlands.
19. Dijkstra J., Neal H.D.S.C., Beever D.E., France J. Simulation of nutrient digestion, absorption and outflow in the rumen: model description. J. Nutr. 1992, 122:2239-2256.
20. Dijkstra J., Kebreab E., Mills J.A.N., Pellikaan W.F., López S., Bannink A., France J. Predicting the profile of nutrients available for absorption: from nutrient requirement to animal response and environmental impact. Animal 2007, 1:99-111.
21. Dijkstra J., Oenema O., Bannink A. Dietary strategies to reducing N excretion from cattle: implications for methane emissions. Curr. Opin. Environ. Sustain. 2011, 3:414-422.
22. DR Loket, 2012. Dienst Regelingen. Ministerie van Economische Zaken, Landbouw, en Innovatie. Dutch Ministry of Agriculture. <> (visited 06.01.12). http://www.hetlnvloket.nl/onderwerpen/mest/dossiers/dossier/gebruiksruimte-en-gebruiksnormen/gebruiksnormen.
23. Eco-invent, 2007. Ecoinvent Data v2.0 Final Reports Ecoinvent 2007. Swiss Centre for Life Cycle Inventories, Dubendorf, Switzerland.
24. EL&I, 2009. The Dutch Ministry of Economic Affairs, Agriculture and Innovation. Vierde Nederlandse Actieprogramma betreffende de Nitraatrichtlijn (2010-2013). <>(visited 12.05.12). http://www.rijksoverheid.nl/documenten-en-publicaties/rapporten/2009/03/24/vierde-nederlandse-actieprogramma-betreffende-de-nitraatrichtlijn-2010-2013.html.
25. Ellis J.L., Dijkstra J., Kebreab E., Bannink A., Odongo N.E., McBride B.W., France J. Aspects of rumen microbiology central to mechanistic modelling of methane production in cattle. J. Agric. Sci. 2008, 146:213-233.
26. EU, 2010. The European Commission. Official Journal of the European Union, 6.2.2010. Commission Decision, amending Decision 2005/880/EC Granting a Derogation Requested by the Netherlands pursuant to Council Directive 91/676/EEC Concerning the Protection of Waters against Pollution Caused by Nitrates from Agricultural Sources (2010/65/EU). Notified under Document C (2010) 606.
27. FADN, 2010. Farm Accountancy Data Network. <>. http://www.lei.wur.nl/NL/statistieken/Binternet.
28. Flysjö A., Henriksson M., Cederberg C., Ledgard S., Englund J.-E. The impact of various parameters on the carbon footprint of milk production in New Zealand and Sweden. Agric. Syst. 2011, 104:459-469.
29. Flysjö A., Cederberg C., Henriksson M., Ledgard S. The interaction between milk and beef production and emissions from land use change - critical considerations in life cycle assessment and carbon footprint studies of milk. J. Cleaner Prod. 2012, 28:134-142.
30. Forster, P., Ramaswamy, V., Artaxo, P., Berntsen, T., Betts, R., Fahey, D.W., Haywood, J., Lean, J., Lowe, D.C., Myhre, G., Nganga, J., Prinn, R., Raga, G., Schulz M., Van Dorland, R., 2007. Changes in atmospheric constituents and in radiative forcing. In: Solomon, S., Qin, D., Manning, M., Chen, Z., Marquis, M., Averyt, K.B., Tignor, M., Miller, H.L. (Eds.), Climate Change 2007: The Physical Science Basis. Contribution of Working Group I to the Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, United Kingdom and New York, NY, USA.
31. Fraters, B., Boumans, L.J.M., van Leeuwen, T.C., Reijs, J.W., 2007. De uitspoeling van het stikstofoverschot naar grond- en oppervlaktewater op landbouwbedrijven. Rijksinstituut voor Volksgezondheid en Milieu (RIVM). RIVM Rapport 680716002.
32. Galford G.L., Melillo J., Mustard J.F., Cerri C.E.P., Cerri C.C. The Amazon frontier of land-use change: croplands and consequences for greenhouse gas emissions. Earth Interact 2010, 14.
33. Gerber P., Vellinga T., Opio C., Henderson B., Steinfeld H. Greenhouse Gas Emissions from the Dairy Sector, A Life Cycle Assessment 2010, FAO Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, Animal Production and Health Division, Rome.
34. Goossensen, F.R., Van den Ham, A., 1992. Rekenregels voor het vaststellen van de nitraatuitspoeling. Ministry of Agriculture, Nature Management and Fisheries, Report Nr. 23, Ede, Neth. (in Dutch).
35. Grainger C., Beauchemin K.A. Can enteric methane emissions from ruminants be lowered without lowering their production?. Anim. Feed Sci. Technol. 2011, 166-167:308-320.
36. Guinée J.B., Gorrée M., Jeijungs R., Huppes G., Kleijn R., de Koning A., van Oers L., Wegener Sleeswijk A., Suh S., Udo de Haes H.A., de Bruijn H., van Duin R., Huijbregts M.A.J., Lindeijer E., Roorda A.A.H., van der Ven B.L., Weidema B.P. Life Cycle Assessment: An Operational Guide to the ISO Standards. Centrum voor Milieukunde - Leiden University 2002, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Leiden, the Netherlands.
37. Hopkins A., Gilbey J., Dibb C., Bowling P.J., Murray P.J. Response of permanent and re-seeded grassland to fertilizer nitrogen. 1. Herbage production and herbage quality. Grass Forage Sci. 1990, 45:43-55.
38. Huijsmans J.F.M., Hol J.M.G. Ammoniakemissie bij toediening van concentraat op beteeld bouwland en grasland. Concept rapport 2010, Plant Research International, Wageningen, the Netherlands.
39. IPCC, 2006. Intergovernmental panel on climate change. In: Eggleston, H.S., Buendia, L., Miwa, K., Ngara, T., Tanabe, K. (Eds.), Guidelines for National Greenhouse Gas Inventories. Agriculture, Forestry and Other Land Use, vol. 4. Prepared by the National Greenhouse Gas Inventories Program. Published: IGES, Japan.
40. ISO 14040, 1997. Environmental Management - Life Cycle Assessment: Principles and Framework. European Committee for Standardization (CEN). Brussels, Belgium.
41. ISO 14041, 1998. Environmental Management - Life Cycle Assessment: Goal and Scope Definition and Inventory Analysis. European Committee for Standardization (CEN). Brussels, Belgium.
42. ISO 14042, 2000. Environmental Management - Life Cycle Assessment: Life Cycle Impact Assessment. European Committee for Standardization (CEN). Brussels, Belgium.
43. ISO 14043, 2000. Environmental Management - Life Cycle Assessment: Life Cycle Interpretation. European Committee for Standardization (CEN). Brussels, Belgium.
44. Jarrige, R., 1988. Alimentation des bovins, ovins et caprins. Institut National de la Reserch Agronomique, Paris (in French).
45. Jungbluth, N., Chudacoff, M., Dauriat, A., Dinkerl, F., Doka, G., Faist Emmenegger, M., Gnansounou, E., Kljun, N., Schleiss, K., Spielmann, M., Stettler, C., Sutter, J., 2007. Life Cycle Inventories of Bioenergy. Ecoinvent Report No. 17, Swiss Centre for Life Cycle Inventories, Dübendorf, CH.
46. Kätterer T., Andrén O. Long-term agricultural field experiments in Northern Europe: analysis of the influence of management on soil carbon stocks using the ICBM model. Agric. Ecosyst. Environ. 1999, 72:165-179.
47. Kebreab E., Johnson K.A., Archibeque S.L., Pape D., Wirth T. Model for estimating enteric methane emissions from United States dairy and feedlot cattle. J. Anim. Sci. 2008, 86:2738-2748.
48. Kebreab E., Strathe A., Fadel J., Moraes L., France J. Impact of dietary manipulation on nutrient flows and greenhouse gas emissions in cattle. Rev. Bras. Zootecn. 2010, 39:458-464.
49. Kristensen T., Mogensen L., Knudsen M.T., Hermansen J.E. Effect of production system and farming strategy on greenhouse gas emissions from commercial dairy farms in a life cycle approach. Livest. Sci. 2011, 140:136-148.
50. Kuikman, P.J., de Groot, W.J.M., Hendriks, R.F.A., Verhagen, J., de Vries, F., 2003. Stocks of C in Soils and Emissions of CO2 from Agricultural Soils in the Netherlands. Wageningen, Alterra, Research Instituut voor de Groene Ruimte. Alterra-rapport 561.
51. KWIN-AGV, 2009. Quantitative Information on Agriculture and Cultivation on Full Land 2009 (Kwantitaitieve Informantie Akkerbouw en Vollegrondsteelt 2009). Practical Research Plant and Environment (Praktijkonderzoek Plant en Omgeving B.V.). Lelystad, the Netherlands.
52. KWIN-V, 2008. Quantitative Livestock Farming Information 2008-2009 (Kwantitatieve Informative Veehouderij 2008-2009). Animal Science Group, Wageingen UR, the Netherlands.
53. Leifeld J., Bassin S., Fuhrer J. Carbon stocks in Swiss agricultural soils predicted by land-use, soil characteristics, and altitude. Agric. Ecosyst. Environ. 2005, 105:255-266.
54. LMM, 2008. Landelijk Meetnet effecten Mestbeleid (Dutch Minerals Policy Monitoring Programme). <>. http://www.lmm.wur.nl.
55. Louhichi K., Kanellopoulos A., Janssen S., Flichman G., Blanco M., Hengsdijk H., Heckelei T., Berentsen P., Oude Lansink A., Ittersum M.V. FSSIM, a bio-economic farm model for simulating the response of EU farming systems to agricultural and environmental policies. Agric. Syst. 2010, 103:585-597.
56. Lovett D.K., Shalloo L., Dillon P., O'Mara F.P. A systems approach to quantify greenhouse gas fluxes from pastoral dairy production as affected by management regime. Agric. Syst. 2006, 88:156-179.
57. Macedo M.N., DeFries R.S., Morton D.C., Stickler C.M., Galford G.L., Shimabukuro Y.E. Decoupling of deforestation 598 and soy production in the southern Amazon during the late 2000s. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 2012, 109:1341-1346.
58. Mills J.A.N., Dijkstra J., Bannink A., Cammell S.B., Kebreab E., France J. A mechanistic model of whole-tract digestion and methanogenesis in the lactating dairy cow: model development, evaluation, and application. J. Anim. Sci. 2001, 79:1584-1597.
59. Nevedi, 2009. De Nederlandse Vereniging Diervoederindustrie. The Dutch Feed Industry Association. Lineaire programmeringen rundvee-, varkens en pluimveevoerders. Linear Programming Cattle-, Pig, and Poultry Feed. Schothorst Feed Research B.V. Report Nr 1 t/m 12, year 2009.
60. Nevedi, 2010. De Nederlandse Vereniging Diervoederindustrie. The Dutch Feed Industry Association. Lineaire programmeringen rundvee-, varkens en pluimveevoerders. Linear Programming Cattle-, Pig, and Poultry Feed. Schothorst Feed Research B.V. Report Nr 1 t/m 12, year 2010.
61. Nevedi, 2011. De Nederlandse Vereniging Diervoederindustrie. The Dutch Feed Industry Association. Lineaire programmeringen rundvee-, varkens en pluimveevoerders. Linear Programming Cattle-, Pig, and Poultry Feed. Schothorst Feed Research B.V. Report Nr 1 t/m 12, year 2011.
62. Nguyen T.T.H., Bouvarel I., Ponchant P., van der Werf H.M.G. Using environmental constraints to formulate low-impact poultry feeds. J. Cleaner Prod. 2012, 28:215-222.
63. O'Brien D., Shalloo L., Patton J., Buckley F., Grainger C., Wallace M. Life cycle assessment of seasonal grass-based and confinement dairy farms. Agric. Syst. 2012, 107:33-46.
64. Oenema O., Velthof G.L., Kuikman P.J. Beperking van emissie van methaan en lachgas uit de landbouw: identificatie van kennishiaten 2001, Alterra, Research Instituut voor de Groene Ruimte, Wageningen.
65. PBL, 2008. Het Planbureau voor de Leefomgeving. PBL Netherlands Environmental Assessment Agency. Depositie van verzurende stoffen per verzuringsgebied in 2007. Deposition of Acidifying Substances by Region in 2007. <>(visited 27.03.09). http://www.milieuennatuurcompendium.nl/tabellen.
66. Product Board Animal Feed, 2008. Tabellenboek Veevoeding 2008. Productschap Diervoeder, CVB, Den Haag, the Netherlands.
67. Prudêncio da Silva V., van der Werf H.M.G., Spies A., Soares S.R. Variability in environmental impacts of Brazilian soybean according to crop production and transport scenarios. J. Environ. Manage. 2010, 91:1831-1839.
68. Rebitzer G., Ekvall T., Frischknecht R., Hunkeler D., Norris G., Rydberg T., Schmidt W.P., Suh S., Weidema B.P., Pennington D.W. Life cycle assessment. Part 1: framework, goal and scope definition, inventory analysis, and applications. Environ. Int. 2004, 30:701-720.
69. Reijneveld A., van Wensem J., Oenema O. Soil organic carbon contents of agricultural land in the Netherlands between 1984 and 2004. Geoderma 2009, 152:231-238.
70. Roer A.G., Korsaeth A., Henriksen T.M., Michelsen O., Strømman A.H. The influence of system boundaries on life cycle assessment of grain production in central southeast Norway. Agric. Syst. 2012, 111:75-84.
71. Rotz C.A., Montes F., Chianese D.S. The carbon footprint of dairy production systems through partial life cycle assessment. J. Dairy Sci. 2010, 93:1266-1282.
72. Schills R.L.M., Verhagen A., Aarts H.F.M., Kuikman P.J., Šebek L.B. Effect of improved nitrogen management on greenhouse gas emissions from intensive dairy systems in the Netherlands Global Change. Biology 2006, 12:382-391.
73. Schils R.L.M., Velthof G.L., Fraters B., Willems W.J. Limits to the Use of Manure and Mineral Fertilizer in Grass and Silage Maize Production in the Netherlands, with Special Reference to the EU Nitrates Directive 2005, Plant Research International B.V, Wageningen, The Netherlands, pp. 1-48.
74. Schils, R.L.M., Oudendag, D.A., van der Hoek, K.W., de Boer, J.A., Evers, A.G., de Haan, M.H., 2006b. Praktijkrapport Rundvee 90. Broeikasgas Module BBPR. Alterra rapport 1268/RIVM rapport 680.125.006.
75. Schröder, J.J., 2005. Manure as a suitable component of precise nitrogen nutrition. In: The International Fertiliser Society Conference, Cambridge, UK.
76. Schröder, J.J., Aarts, H.F.M., de Bode, M.J.C., van Dijk, W., van Middelkoop, J.C., de Haan, M.H.A., Schils, R.L.M., Velthof, G.L., Willems, W.J., 2004. Gebruiksnormen bij verschillende landbouwkundige en milieukundige uitgangspunten. Plant Research International B.V., Wageningen. Report 79.
77. Sonneveld M.P.W., Van Den Akker J.J.H. Quantification of C and N stocks in grassland topsoils in a Dutch region dominated by dairy farming. J. Agric. Sci. 2011, 149:63-71.
78. 2O and NO emission from agricultural fields and soils under natural vegetation: summarizing available measurement data and modeling of global annual emissions. Nutr. Cycl. Agroecosyst. 2006, 74:207-228.
79. Steinfeld H., Gerber P., Wassenaar T., Castel V., Rosales M., De Haan C. Livestock's Long Shadow: Environmental Issues and Options 2006, FAO, Rome, Italy.
80. Tamminga S., Van Straalen W.M., Subnel A.P.J., Meijer R.G.M., Steg A., Wever C.J.G., Blok M.C. The Dutch protein evaluation system: the DVE/OEB-system. Livest. Prod. Sci. 1994, 40:139-155.
81. Taweel H.Z., Tas B.M., Dijkstra J., Tamminga S. Intake regulation and grazing behavior of dairy cows under continuous stocking. J. Dairy Sci. 2004, 87:3417-3427.
82. Thomassen M.A., Van Calker K.J., Smits M.C.J., Iepema G.L., De Boer I.J.M. Life Cycle Assessment of conventional and organic milk production in the Netherlands. Agric. Syst. 2008, 96:95-107.
83. Thomassen M.A., Dolman M.A., Van Calker K.J., De Boer I.J.M. Relating life cycle assessment indicators to gross value added for Dutch dairy farms. Ecol. Econ. 2009, 68:2278-2284.
84. Van Middelaar C.E., Berentsen P.B.M., Dolman M.A., de Boer I.J.M. Eco-efficiency in the production chain of Dutch semi-hard cheese. Livest. Sci. 2011, 139:91-99.
85. Van Middelaar C.E., Cederberg C., Vellinga T.V., Van der Werf H.M.G., De Boer I.J.M. Exploring variability in methods and data sensitivity in carbon footprints of feed ingredients. Int. J. Life Cycle Assess. 2013, 18:768-782.
86. Vellinga T.V., Hoving I.E. Maize silage for dairy cows: mitigation of methane emissions can be offset by land use change. Nutr. Cycl. Agroecosyst. 2011, 89:413-426.
87. 2O emissions in The Netherlands. Nutr. Cycl. Agroecosyst. 2004, 70:33-45.
88. Vellinga, T.V., Blonk, H., Marinussen, M., van Zeist, W.J., de Boer I.J.M., 2012. Methodology Used in Feedprint: A Tool Quantifying Greenhouse Gas Emissions of Feed Production and Utilization. Wageningen UR Livestock Research, the Netherlands.
89. Velthof, G.L., Mosquera, J., 2011. Calculations of Nitrous Oxide Emissions from Agriculture in the Netherlands. Update of Emission Factors and Leaching Fraction. Wageningen Alterra. Alterrareport 2151.
90. Wageningen UR, 2011. <> (visited 12.06.11). http://www.livestockresearch.wur.nl/nl/nieuwsagenda/archief/nieuws/2010/Uitgangspunten_en_normen_voor_bedrijfsbegrotingen_Melkveehouderij.htm.