Active rotor control for helicopters: Individual blade control and swashplateless rotor designs

CEAS Aeronautical Journal

Volumn 1, Issue 1-4, 2011, Pages 23-54

  Kessler, Ch ^a  

^a GERMAN AEROSPACE CENTER DLR   (Germany)

Author keywords

Active twist; Individual blade control, IBC; Swashplateless helicopter; Trailing edge flap

Indexed keywords

CHEMICAL DETECTION; COMPETITION; EMERGENCY SERVICES; HELICOPTER ROTORS; HELICOPTER SERVICES; HELICOPTERS;

ACTIVE ROTOR CONTROL; ACTIVE TWIST; EMERGENCY MEDICAL SERVICES; HIGHER HARMONIC CONTROL; INDIVIDUAL BLADE CONTROL; MAINTENANCE EFFORTS; SWASHPLATELESS ROTOR; TRAILING EDGE FLAPS;

AIRCRAFT CONTROL;

EID: 84883432715     PISSN: 18695582     EISSN: 18695590     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1007/s13272-011-0001-0     Document Type: Article

References (87)

1. Kessler, C.: Active rotor control for helicopters: motivation and survey on higher harmonic control. In: 36th ERF, Paris, France, September 7–9, 2010
2. Friedmann, P.P., Millot, T.A.: Vibration reduction in rotorcraft using active control: a comparison of various approaches. J. Guid. Control Dyn 18(4), 664–673
3. Chopra, I.: Status of application of smart structure technology to rotorcraft systems. J. AHS 45(3), 228–252 (2000)
4. Padthe, A.K., Liu, L., Friedmann, P.P.: A comprehensive study of active microflaps for vibration reduction in rotorcraft. In: 66th Annual Forum of the AHS, Phoenix, AZ, May 11–13, 2010
5. Leon, O., Hayden, E., Gandhi, F.: Rotorcraft operating envelope expansion using extendable chord sections. In: 65th Annual Forum of the AHS, Grapevine, TX, May 27–29, 2009
6. Kobiki, N., Natsuki, K., Shigeru, S., Takeshi, A., Yasutada, T.: Active Tab, a new active technique for helicopter noise reduction. In: 29th ERF, Friedrichshafen, Germany, September 16–18, 2003
7. Kobiki, N., Saito, S., Kosaka, M., Fuse, H.: A study of closed loop control of active Tab with BVI detection method for helicopter noise reduction. In: 32nd ERF, Maastricht, The Netherlands, September 12–14, 2006
8. Young, L.A.: Systems engineering: when knowledge and technology are the product. In: 64th Annual Forum of the AHS, Montreal, Canada, April 29–May 1, 2008
9. Matalanis, C.G., Kuczek, A., Lin, R.-S., Manes, E., Wake, B.E., Yeh, J., Chaudhry, Z., Brewer, P.: Development of an active trim Tab system for onboard rotor tracking. In: 66th Annual Forum of the AHS, Phoenix, AZ, May 11–13, 2010
10. Martin, P.B., McAlister, K.W., Chandrasekhara, M.S., Geissler, W.: Dynamic stall measurements and computations for a VR-12 airfoil with a droop leading edge. In: 59th Annual Forum of the AHS, Phoenix, AZ, May 6–8, 2003
11. Geissler, W., Dietz, G., Mai, H., Junker, B.: Dynamic stall control investigation on a full size chord blade section. In: 30th ERF, Marseille, France, September 14–16, 2004
12. Maucher, C.K., Grohmann, B.A., Jaenker, P., Altmikus, A., Jensen, F., Baier, H.: Actuator design for the active trailing edge of a helicopter rotor blade. In: 33rd ERF, Kazan, Russia, September 11–13, 2007
13. Bernhard, A.P.F., Chopra, I.: Mach-scale design of a rotor-model with active blade tips. In: 55th Annual Forum of the AHS, Montreal, Canada, May 25–27, 1999
14. Bernhard, A.P.F., Chopra, I.: Hover test of a Mach-scale rotor model with active blade tips. J. AHS 47(4), 273–284 (2002)
15. Ham, N.D.: Helicopter individual-blade-control research at MIT 1977–1985. Vertica 11(1/2), 109–122 (1987)
16. Ham, N.D.: Helicopter individual-blade-control: promising technology for the future helicopter. In: 21st ERF, Saint Petersburg, Russia, August 30–September 1, 1995
17. Ham, N.D.: Helicopter gust alleviation, attitude stabilization, and vibration alleviation using individual-blade-control through conventional swash plate. In: 41st Annual Forum of the AHS, Fort Worth, Texas, May 15–17, 1985
18. Ham, N.D.: A simple system for helicopter individual-blade-control using modal decomposition. Vertica 4(1), 23–28 (1980)
19. Ham, N.D.: A simple system for helicopter individual-blade-control and its application to gust alleviation. In: 6th ERF, Bristol, England, September 16–19, 1980
20. Ham, N.D., Behal, B.L., McKillip, R.M.: Helicopter rotor lag damping augmentation through individual-blade-control. Vertica 7(4), 361–371 (1983)
21. Reichert, G., Arnold U.T.P.: Active control of helicopter ground and air resonance. In: 16th ERF, Glasgow, Scotland, September 18–20, 1990
22. Kessler, C., Reichert, G.: Active control to augment rotor lead-lag damping. Aeronaut. J. 102(1011), 245–258 (1998)
23. Quackenbush, T.R.: Testing and evaluation of a stall-flutter-suppression system for helicopter rotors using individual-blade-control. J. AHS 39(2) (1984)
24. Nguyen, K.: Active suppression of stall on helicopter rotors. In: 25th ERF, Rome, Italy, September 14–16, 1999
25. Richter, P., Blaas, A.: Full scale wind tunnel investigation of an Individual Blade Control (IBC) system for the Bo105 Hingeless rotor. In: 19th ERF, Cernobbio, Italy, September 14–16, 1993
26. Jacklin, S.A., Swanson, S., Blaas, A., Richter, P., Teves, D., Niesl, G., Kube, R., Gmelin, B., Key, D.L.: Investigation of a Helicopter Individual Blade Control (IBC) System in Two Full-Scale Wind Tunnel Tests, vols. I + II. NASA TP-2003-212276+7 (2003)
27. Arnold, U.T.P., Mueller, M., Richter, P.: Theoretical and experimental prediction of individual blade control. In: 23rd ERF, Dresden, Germany, September 16–18, 1997
28. Richter, P., Eisbrecher, H.-D.: Design and first flight tests of individual blade control actuators. In: 16th ERF, Glasgow, Scotland, September 18–20, 1990
29. Teves, D., Kloeppel, V., Richter, P.: Development of active control technology in the rotating system, flight testing and theoretical investigations. In: 18th ERF, Avignon, France, September 15–18, 1992
30. Schimke, D., Arnold, U.T.P., Kube, R.: Individual blade control demonstration evaluation of recent flight tests. In: 54th Annual Forum of the AHS, Washington, DC, May 20–22, 1998
31. Morbitzer, D., Arnold, U.T.P., Mueller, M.: Vibration and noise reduction through individual blade control—experimental and theoretical results. In: 24th ERF, Marseille, France, September 15–17, 1998
32. Mueller, M., Arnold, U.T.P., Morbitzer, D.: On the importance and efficiency of 2/rev IBC for noise, vibration and pitch link load reduction. In: 25th ERF, Rome, Italy, September 14–16, 1999
33. Bebesel, M., Roth, D., Pongratz, R.: Reduction of BVI noise on ground—inflight evaluation of closed-loop controller. In: 28th ERF, Bristol, UK, September 17–20, 2002
34. Roth, D.: Advanced vibration reduction by IBC technology. In: 30th ERF, Marseille, France, September 14–16, 2004
35. Dieterich, O.: Application of a modern control technology for advanced IBC systems. In: 24th ERF, Marseille, France, September 15–17, 1998
36. Kessler, C., Fuerst, D., Arnold, U.T.P.: Open loop flight test results and closed loop status of the IBC system on the CH-53G helicopter. In: 59th Annual Forum of the AHS, Phoenix, AZ, May 6–8, 2003
37. Fuerst, D., Kessler, Ch., Auspitzer, T., Mueller, M., Hausberg, A., Witte, H.: Closed loop IBC-system and flight test results on the CH-53G helicopter. In: 60th Annual Forum of the AHS, Baltimore, MD, June 7–10, 2004
38. Arnold, U.T.P., Fuerst, D.: Closed loop IBC results from CH-53G flight tests. Aerosp. Sci. Technol. 9(5), 421–435 (2005)
39. Norman, T.R., Shinoda, P.M., Kitaplioglu, C., Jacklin, S.A., Sheikman, A.: Low-speed wind tunnel investigation of a full scale UH-60 rotor system. In: 58th Annual Forum of the AHS, Montreal, Canada, June 11–13, 2002
40. Jacklin, S.A., Haber, A., de Simone, G., Norman, T.R., Kita-plioglu, C., Shinoda, P.M.: Full-scale wind tunnel test of an individual blade control system for a UH-60 helicopter. In: 58th Annual Forum of the AHS, Montreal, Canada, June 11–13, 2002
41. Norman, T.R., Theodore C., Shinoda, P.M., Fuerst, D., Arnold, U.T.P., Makinen, S., Lorber, P., O’Neill, J.: Full-scale wind tunnel test of a UH-60 individual blade control system for performance improvement and vibration, loads, and noise control. In: 65th Annual Forum of the AHS, Grapevine, TX, May 27–29, 2009
42. Friedmann, P.P.: Vibration reduction in rotorcraft using actively controlled flaps—their evolution and potential for improving rotorcraft technology. In: 30th ERF, Marseille, France, September 14–16, 2004
43. McCloud, J.L., Evans, W.T., Biggers, J.C.: Performance characteristics of a jet-flap rotor. In: Conference on V/STOL and STOL Aircraft. NASA-SP 116, 29–40 (1966)
44. McCloud, J.L., Kretz, M.: Multicyclic jet-flap control for alleviation of helicopter blade stresses and fuselage vibrations. NASA-SP 352, 233–238 (1974)
45. Wei, F.-S., Weisbrich, A.L.: Multicyclic controllable twist rotor data analysis. NASA-CR-152251, 1979
46. Millot, T.A., Friedmann, P.P.: Vibration reduction in helicopter rotors using an active control surface located on the blade. In: 33rd AIAA/ASME/ASCE/AHS Structures, Structural Dynamics, and Materials Conference, AIAA-92-2451-CP, Dallas, TX, April 13–15, 1992
47. Cribbs, R., Friedmann, P.P.: Actuator saturation and its influence on vibration reduction by actively controlled flaps. In: 42nd AIAA/ASME/ASCE/AHS Structures, Structural Dynamics, and Materials Conference, AIAA-2001-1467-CP, Seattle, WA, April 16–19, 2001
48. Depailler, G., Friedmann, P.P.: Alleviation of rotor vibrations induced by dynamic stall using actively controlled flaps with freeplay. In: 28th ERF, Bristol, UK, September 17–19, 2002
49. Patt, D., Liu, L., Friedmann, P.P.: Rotorcraft vibration reduction and noise prediction using a unified aeroelastic response simulation. J. AHS 50(1), 95–106 (2005)
50. Patt, D., Liu, L., Friedmann, P.P.: Simultaneous vibration and noise reduction in rotorcraft using aeroelastic simulation. J. AHS 51(2), 127–140 (2006)
51. Liu, L., Friedmann, P.P., Kim, I., Bernstein, D.S.: Rotor performance enhancement and vibration reduction in presence of dynamic stall using actively controlled flaps. J. AHS 53(4), 338–350 (2008)
52. Yeo, H.: Assessment of active controls for rotorcraft enhancement. J. AHS 53(2), 152–163 (2008)
53. Fulton, M.V., Ormiston, R.A.: Hover testing of a small-scale rotor with on-blade elevons. J. AHS 46(2), 96–106 (2001)
54. Fulton, M.V., Ormiston, R.A.: Small-scale rotor experiments with on-blade elevons to reduce blade vibratory loads in forward flight. In: 54th Annual Forum of the AHS, Washington, DC, May 20–22, 1998
55. Ormiston, R.A., Fulton, M.V.: Aeroelastic and dynamic rotor response with on-blade elevon control. In: 24th ERF, Marseille, France, September 15–17, 1998
56. Bernhard, A.P.F., Chopra, I.: Trailing edge flap activated by a piezo-induced bending-torsion coupled beam. J. AHS 44(1), 3–15 (1999)
57. Roget, B., Chopra, I.: Individual blade control for a rotor with dissimilar blades. J. AHS 48(3), 176–185 (2003)
58. Roget, B., Chopra, I.: Closed-loop test of a rotor with individually controlled trailing-edge flaps for vibration reduction. J. AHS 55(1), 012009-1–012009-12 (2010)
59. Kobiki, N., Tsuchihashi, A., Murashige, A., Yamakawa, E.: Elementary study for the effect of HHC and active flap on blade vortex interaction. In: 23rd ERF, Dresden, Germany, September 16–18, 1997
60. Hasegawa, Y., Katayama, N., Kobiki, N., Nakasato, E.: Experimental and analytical results of Whirl test of ATIC full scale rotor system. In: 57th Annual Forum of the AHS, Washington, DC, May 9–11, 2001
61. Kobiki, N., Shigeru, S., Fukami, T., Komura, T.: Design and performance evaluation of full scale on-board active flap system. In: 63rd Annual Forum of the AHS, Virginia Beach, VA, May 1–3, 2007
62. Kobiki, N., Shigeru, S.: Performance evaluation of full scale onboard active flap system in transonic wind tunnel. In: 64th Annual Forum of the AHS, Montreal, Canada, May 1–3, 2008
63. Crozier, P., Leconte, P., Delrieux, Y., Gimonet, B., Le Pape, A., des Rochettes, H.M.: Wind-tunnel tests of a helicopter rotor with active flaps. In: 32nd ERF, Maastricht, The Netherlands, September 12–14, 2006
64. Dieterich, O., Enenkl, B., Roth, D.: Trailing Edge Flaps for Active Rotor Control: Aeroelastic Characteristics of the ADA-SYS Rotor System. In: 62nd Annual Forum of the AHS, Phoenix, AZ, May 9–11, 2006
65. Roth, D., Enenkl, B., Dieterich, O.: Active rotor control by flaps for vibration reduction—full scale demonstrator and first flight test results. In: 32nd ERF, Maastricht, The Netherlands, September 12–14, 2006
66. Straub, F.K., Anand, V.R., Birchette, T.S., Lau, B.H.: Wind tunnel test of the SMART active flap rotor. In: 65th Annual Forum of the AHS, Grapevine, TX, May 27–29, 2009
67. JanakiRam, R.D., Sim, B.W., Kitaplioglu, C., Straub, F.K.: Blade-vortex interaction noise characteristics of a full-scale active flap rotor. In: 65th Annual Forum of the AHS, Grapevine, TX, May 27–29, 2009
68. Sim, B.W., JanakiRam, R.D., Barbely, N.L., Solis, E.: Reduced in-plane, low frequency noise of an active flap rotor. In: 65th Annual Forum of the AHS, Grapevine, TX, May 27–29, 2009
69. Chopra, I.: Development of a smart rotor. In: 19th ERF, Cer-nobbio, Italy, September 14–16, 1993
70. Derham, R., Weems, D., Mathew, M.B., Bussom, R.: The design evolution of an active materials rotor. In: 57th Annual Forum of the AHS, Washington, DC, May 9–11, 2001
71. Weems, D.B., Anderson, D.M., Mathew, M.B., Bussom, R.C.: A large-scale active twist rotor. In: 66th Annual Forum of the AHS, Baltimore, MD, June 7–10, 2004
72. Wilbur, M.L., Mirick, P.H., Yaeger, W.T. Jr., Langston, C.W., Cesnik, C.E.S., Shin, S.: Vibration reduction testing of the NASA/ARMY/MIT active twist rotor. In: 57th Annual Forum of the AHS, Washington, DC, May 9–11, 2001
73. Shin, S., Cesnik, C.E.S., Hall, S.R.: Closed-loop control test of the NASA/ARMY/MIT active twist rotor for vibration reduction. In: 59th Annual Forum of the AHS, Phoenix, AZ, May 6–8, 2003
74. Monner, H.P., Opitz, S., Riemenschneider, J., Wierach, P.: Evolution of active twist rotor design at DLR. In: AIAA/ASME/ AHS Adaptive Structures Conference, Schaumburg, IL, April 7–10, 2008
75. Opitz, S., Riemenschneider, J., Monner, H.P.: Modal investigation of an active twist helicopter rotor blade. In: 20th International conference on adaptive structures and technologies, Hong Kong, China, October 20–22, 2009
76. des Rochettes, H.M., Joly, D., Buchaniek, L., Leconte P.: A new concept of active twist blade applied to main rotor of helicopter. In: RTO Applied Vehicle Technology Panel Symposium, Evora, Portugal, RTO-MP-AVT-168, April 20–24, 2009
77. Riemenschneider, J., Opitz, S., Wierach, P., des Rochettes, H.M., Buchaniek, L.: Structural design and testing of active twist blades—a comparison. In: 35th ERF, Hamburg, Germany, September 22–24, 2009
78. Hoffmann, F., Opitz, S., Riemenschneider, J.: Validation of active twist modeling on whirl tower tests. In: 65th Annual Forum of the AHS, Grapevine, TX, May 27–29, 2009
79. Wierach, P.: Low profile piezo actuators based on multilayer technology. In: 17th International Conference on Adaptive Structures and Technologies, Taipei, Taiwan, October 16–19, 2006
80. Bartels, R., Kuefmann, P., Kessler, C.: Novel concept for realising Individual Blade Control (IBC) for helicopters. In: 36th ERF, Paris, France, September 7–9, 2010
81. Kretz, M.: Research in multicyclic and active control of rotary wings. Vertica 1(2), 95–105 (1976)
82. Guinn, K.F.: Individual blade control independent of a swash-plate. J. AHS 27(3), 25–31 (1982)
83. Arnold, U.T.P., Fuerst, D., Neuheuser, T., Bartels, R.: Development of an integrated electrical swashplateless primary and individual blade control system. In: 32nd ERF, Maastricht, The Netherlands, September 12–14, 2006
84. Lorber, P.F., O’Neil, J.J., Isabella, B., Andrews, J., Wong, J., Hein, B., Geiger, D., Wake, B.E., Jonsson, U., Sun, F.: Whirl test of a large scale high authority active flap rotor. In: 66th Annual Forum of the AHS, Phoenix, AZ, May 11–13, 2010
85. Woods, B.K.S., Kothera, C.S., Wereley, N.M.: Whirl testing of a pneumatic artificial muscle actuation system for a full-scale active rotor. In: 66th Annual Forum of the AHS, Phoenix, AZ, May 11–13, 2010
86. Ghandi, F., Sekula, M.: Helicopter horizontal tail incidence control to reduce rotor cyclic pitch and blade flapping. In: 66th Annual Forum of the AHS, Baltimore, MD, June 7–10, 2004
87. Duling, C., Ghandi, F., Straub, F.: On power and actuation requirement in swashplateless primary control using trailing-edge flaps. In: 66th Annual Forum of the AHS, Phoenix, AZ, May 11–13, 2010