Simultaneous EEG and fMRI reveals a causally connected subcortical-cortical network during reward anticipation

Journal of Neuroscience

Volumn 33, Issue 36, 2013, Pages 14526-14533

  Plichta, Michael M ^a   Wolf, Isabella ^a   Hohmann, Sarah ^a   Baumeister, Sarah ^a   Boecker, Regina ^a   Schwarz, Adam J ^b   Zangl, Maria ^a   Mier, Daniela ^a,c   Diener, Carsten ^a,c   Meyer, Patric ^a,c   Holz, Nathalie ^a   Ruf, Matthias ^a   Gerchen, Martin F ^a,c   Bernal Casas, David ^a,c   Kolev, Vasil ^d   Yordanova, Juliana ^d   Flor, Herta ^a,c   Laucht, Manfred ^a   Banaschewski, Tobias ^a   Kirsch, Peter ^a,c   Meyer Lindenberg, Andreas ^a   Brandeis, Daniel ^e   more..

^a CENTRAL INSTITUTE OF MENTAL HEALTH   (Germany)

^b ELI LILLY AND COMPANY   (United States)

^c Bernstein Center for Computational Neurosciences   (Germany)

^d BULGARIAN ACADEMY OF SCIENCES   (Bulgaria)

^e UNIVERSITY OF ZURICH   (Switzerland)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ADULT; ANTICIPATION; ARTICLE; BEHAVIOR; BLOOD OXYGENATION; BOLD SIGNAL; CONTINGENT NEGATIVE VARIATION; CONTROLLED STUDY; CORPUS STRIATUM; ECHO PLANAR IMAGING; ELECTROENCEPHALOGRAPHY; FEMALE; FUNCTIONAL MAGNETIC RESONANCE IMAGING; HUMAN; HUMAN EXPERIMENT; MALE; MEDIATOR; NERVE CELL NETWORK; NORMAL HUMAN; PRIORITY JOURNAL; REWARD; SUPPLEMENTARY MOTOR AREA; THALAMUS;

ADULT; ANTICIPATION, PSYCHOLOGICAL; CEREBRAL CORTEX; ELECTROENCEPHALOGRAPHY; FEMALE; HUMANS; MAGNETIC RESONANCE IMAGING; MALE; NERVE NET; REWARD; THALAMUS;

EID: 84883428705     PISSN: 02706474     EISSN: 15292401     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1523/JNEUROSCI.0631-13.2013     Document Type: Article

References (70)

1. Abler B, Erk S, Walter H (2007) Human reward system activation is modulated by a single dose of olanzapine in healthy subjects in an event-related, double-blind, placebo-controlled fMRI study. Psychopharmacology 191: 823-833. CrossRef Medline
2. Allen PJ, Polizzi G, Krakow K, Fish DR, Lemieux L (1998) Identification of EEG events in theMRscanner: the problem of pulse artifact and a method for its subtraction. Neuroimage 8:229-239. CrossRef Medline
3. Allen PJ, Josephs O, Turner R (2000) A method for removing imaging artifact from continuous EEG recorded during functional MRI. Neuroimage 12:230-239. CrossRef Medline
4. Baron RM, Kenny DA (1986) The moderator-mediator variable distinction in social psychological research: conceptual, strategic, and statistical considerations. J Pers Soc Psychol 51:1173-1182. CrossRef Medline
5. Birbaumer N, Elbert T, Canavan AG, Rockstroh B (1990) Slow potentials of the cerebral cortex and behavior. Physiol Rev 70:1-41. Medline
6. Bland AR, Mushtaq F, Smith DV (2011) Exploiting trial-to-trial variability in multimodal experiments. FrontHumNeurosci 5:80. CrossRef Medline
7. Boyd ES, Boyd EH, Brown LE (1979) Observations on the M-wave and the CNV in the squirrel monkey. Electroencephalogr Clin Neurophysiol 46: 320-336. CrossRef Medline
8. Breiter HC, Gollub RL, Weisskoff RM, Kennedy DN, Makris N, Berke JD, Goodman JM, Kantor HL, Gastfriend DR, Riorden JP, Mathew RT, Rosen BR, Hyman SE (1997) Acute effects of cocaine on human brain activity and emotion. Neuron 19:591-611. CrossRef Medline
9. Broyd SJ, Richards HJ, Helps SK, Chronaki G, Bamford S, Sonuga-Barke EJ (2012a) An electrophysiological monetary incentive delay (e-MID) task: a way to decompose the different components of neural response to positive and negative monetary reinforcement. J Neurosci Methods 209:40-49. CrossRef Medline
10. Broyd SJ, Richards HJ, Helps SK, Chronaki G, Bamford S, Sonuga-Barke EJ (2012b) Electrophysiological markers of the motivational salience of delay imposition and escape. Neuropsychologia 50:965-972. CrossRef Medline
11. Capa RL, Bouquet CA, Dreher JC, Dufour A (2013) Long-lasting effects of performance-contingent unconscious and conscious reward incentives during cued task-switching. Cortex 49:1943-1954. CrossRef Medline
12. Cohen MX, Axmacher N, Lenartz D, Elger CE, Sturm V, Schlaepfer TE (2009) Neuroelectric signatures of reward learning and decision-making in the human nucleus accumbens. Neuropsychopharmacology 34:1649-1658. CrossRef Medline
13. Cohen MX, Cavanagh JF, SlagterHA (2011) Event-related potential activity in the basal ganglia differentiates rewards from nonrewards: temporospatial principal components analysis and source localization of the feedback negativity: commentary. Hum Brain Mapp 32:2270-2271. CrossRef Medline
14. Cohen MX, Bour L, Mantione M, Figee M, Vink M, Tijssen MA, van Rootselaar AF, van den Munckhof P, Schuurman PR, Denys D (2012) Topdown-directed synchrony from medial frontal cortex to nucleus accumbens during reward anticipation. Hum Brain Mapp 33:246-252. CrossRef Medline
15. Damen EJ, Brunia CH (1987) Changes in heart rate and slow brain potentials related to motor preparation and stimulus anticipation in a time estimation task. Psychophysiology 24:700-713. CrossRef Medline
16. Debener S, Ullsperger M, Siegel M, Engel AK (2006) Single-trial EEG-fMRI reveals the dynamics of cognitive function. Trends Cogn Sci 10:558-563. CrossRef Medline
17. Debener S, Mullinger KJ, Niazy RK, Bowtell RW (2008) Properties of the ballistocardiogram artefact as revealed by EEG recordings at 1.5, 3 and 7 T static magnetic field strength. Int J Psychophysiol 67:189-199. CrossRef Medline
18. Diekhof EK, Kaps L, Falkai P, Gruber O (2012) The role of the human ventral striatum and the medial orbitofrontal cortex in the representation of reward magnitude-an activation likelihood estimation meta-analysis of neuroimaging studies of passive reward expectancy and outcome processing. Neuropsychologia 50:1252-1266. CrossRef Medline
19. Dillon DG, Holmes AJ, Birk JL, Brooks N, Lyons-Ruth K, Pizzagalli DA (2009) Childhood adversity is associated with left basal ganglia dysfunction during reward anticipation in adulthood. Biol Psychiatry 66:206-213. CrossRef Medline
20. Fang PC, Stepniewska I, Kaas JH (2006) The thalamic connections of motor, premotor, and prefrontal areas of cortex in a prosimian primate (Otolemur garnetti). Neuroscience 143:987-1020. CrossRef Medline
21. Forbes EE, Brown SM, Kimak M, Ferrell RE, Manuck SB, Hariri AR (2009) Genetic variation in components of dopamine neurotransmission impacts ventral striatal reactivity associated with impulsivity. Mol Psychiatry 14:60-70. CrossRef Medline
22. Forbes EE, Olino TM, Ryan ND, Birmaher B, Axelson D, Moyles DL, Dahl RE (2010) Reward-related brain function as a predictor of treatment response in adolescents with major depressive disorder. Cogn Affect Behav Neurosci 10:107-118. CrossRef Medline
23. Foti D, Weinberg A, Dien J, HajcakG (2011) Event-related potential activity in the basal ganglia differentiates rewards from nonrewards: temporospatial principal components analysis and source localization of the feedback negativity. Hum Brain Mapp 32:2207-2216. CrossRef Medline
24. Fox MD, Snyder AZ, Vincent JL, Raichle ME (2007) Intrinsic fluctuations within cortical systems account for intertrial variability in human behavior. Neuron 56:171-184. CrossRef Medline
25. Friston KJ, Harrison L, PennyW (2003) Dynamic causal modelling. Neuroimage 19:1273-1302. CrossRef Medline
26. Gilman JM, Smith AR, Ramchandani VA, Momenan R, Hommer DW (2012) The effect of intravenous alcohol on the neural correlates of risky decision making in healthy social drinkers. Addict Biol 17:465-478. CrossRef Medline
27. Gómez CM, Marco J, Grau C (2003) Preparatory visuo-motor cortical network of the contingent negative variation estimated by current density. Neuroimage 20:216-224. CrossRef Medline
28. Groenewegen HJ, BerendseHW (1994) The specificity of the "nonspecific" midline and intralaminar thalamic nuclei. Trends Neurosci 17:52-57. CrossRef Medline
29. Haber SN (2011) Neuroanatomy of reward: a view from the ventral striatum. In: Source Neurobiology of Sensation and Reward (Gottfried JA, ed). Boca Raton, FL: CRC.
30. Haber SN, Calzavara R (2009) The cortico-basal ganglia integrative network: the role of the thalamus. Brain Res Bull 78:69-74. CrossRef Medline
31. Hahn T, Dresler T, Ehlis AC, Plichta MM, Heinzel S, Polak T, Lesch KP, Breuer F, Jakob PM, Fallgatter AJ (2009) Neural response to reward anticipation is modulated by Gray's impulsivity. Neuroimage 46: 1148-1153. CrossRef Medline
32. Hahn T, Heinzel S, Dresler T, Plichta MM, Renner TJ, Markulin F, Jakob PM, Lesch KP, Fallgatter AJ (2011) Association between reward-related activation in the ventral striatum and trait reward sensitivity is moderated by dopamine transporter genotype. Hum Brain Mapp 32:1557-1565. CrossRef Medline
33. Hayes AF (2012) PROCESS: a versatile computational tool for observed variable mediation, moderation, and conditional process modeling [white paper]. Retrieved from: http://www.afhayes.com/public/process2012.pdf.
34. Jewett DL, Romano MN, Williston JS (1970) Human auditory evoked potentials: possible brain stem components detected on the scalp. Science 167:1517-1518. CrossRef Medline
35. Juckel G, Friedel E, Koslowski M, Witthaus H, Ozgürdal S, Gudlowski Y, Knutson B, Wrase J, Brüne M, Heinz A, Schlagenhauf F (2012) Ventral striatal activation during reward processing in subjects with ultra-high risk for schizophrenia. Neuropsychobiology 66:50-56. CrossRef Medline
36. Kassubek J, Abler B, Pinkhardt EH (2011) Neural reward processing under dopamine agonists: imaging. J Neurol Sci 310:36-39. CrossRef Medline
37. Kimura M, Minamimoto T, Matsumoto N, Hori Y (2004) Monitoring and switching of cortico-basal ganglia loop functions by the thalamo-striatal system. Neurosci Res 48:355-360. CrossRef Medline
38. Kinomura S, Larsson J, Gulyás B, Roland PE (1996) Activation by attention of the human reticular formation and thalamic intralaminar nuclei. Science 271:512-515. CrossRef Medline
39. Kirsch P, Schienle A, Stark R, Sammer G, Blecker C, Walter B, Ott U, Burkart J, Vaitl D (2003) Anticipation of reward in a nonaversive differential conditioning paradigm and the brain reward system: an event-related fMRI study. Neuroimage 20:1086-1095. CrossRef Medline
40. Kirsch P, Reuter M, Mier D, Lonsdorf T, Stark R, Gallhofer B, Vaitl D, Hennig J (2006) Imaging gene-substance interactions: the effect of the DRD2 TaqIA polymorphism and the dopamine agonist bromocriptine on the brain activation during the anticipation of reward. Neurosci Lett 405: 196-201. CrossRef Medline
41. Knutson B, Cooper JC (2005) Functional magnetic resonance imaging of reward prediction. Curr Opin Neurol 18:411-417. CrossRef Medline
42. Knutson B, Bjork JM, Fong GW, Hommer D, Mattay VS, Weinberger DR (2004) Amphetamine modulates human incentive processing. Neuron 43:261-269. CrossRef Medline
43. Knutson B, Adams CM, Fong GW, Hommer D (2001a) Anticipation of increasing monetary reward selectively recruits nucleus accumbens. J Neurosci 21:RC159. Medline
44. Knutson B, Fong GW, Adams CM, Varner JL, Hommer D (2001b) Dissociation of reward anticipation and outcome with event-related fMRI. Neuroreport 12:3683-3687. CrossRef Medline
45. Kotani Y, Hiraku S, Suda K, Aihara Y (2001) Effect of positive and negative emotion on stimulus-preceding negativity prior to feedback stimuli. Psychophysiology 38:873-878. CrossRef Medline
46. Kratz O, Studer P, Baack J, Malcherek S, Erbe K, Moll GH, HeinrichH (2012) Differential effects of methylphenidate and atomoxetine on attentional processes in children with ADHD: an event-related potential study using the attention network test. Prog Neuropsychopharmacol Biol Psychiatry 37:81-89. CrossRef Medline
47. Liu X, Hairston J, Schrier M, Fan J (2011) Common and distinct networks underlying reward valence and processing stages: a meta-analysis of functional neuroimaging studies. Neurosci Biobehav Rev 35:1219-1236. CrossRef Medline
48. Mars RB, Debener S, Gladwin TE, Harrison LM, Haggard P, Rothwell JC, Bestmann S (2008) Trial-by-trial fluctuations in the event-related electroencephalogram reflect dynamic changes in the degree of surprise. J Neurosci 28:12539-12545. CrossRef Medline
49. Matsumoto N, Minamimoto T, Graybiel AM, KimuraM (2001) Neurons in the thalamic CM-Pf complex supply striatal neurons with information about behaviorally significant sensory events. J Neurophysiol 85:960-976. Medline
50. Nagai Y, Critchley HD, Featherstone E, Fenwick PB, Trimble MR, Dolan RJ (2004) Brain activity relating to the contingent negative variation: an fMRI investigation. Neuroimage 21:1232-1241. CrossRef Medline
51. Pierson A, Ragot R, Ripoche A, Lesevre N (1987) Electrophysiological changes elicited by auditory stimuli given a positive or negative value: a study comparing anhedonic with hedonic subjects. Int J Psychophysiol 5:107-123. CrossRef Medline
52. Plichta MM, Vasic N, Wolf RC, Lesch KP, Brummer D, Jacob C, Fallgatter AJ, Grön G (2009) Neural hyporesponsiveness and hyperresponsiveness during immediate and delayed reward processing in adult attention-deficit/ hyperactivity disorder. Biol Psychiatry 65:7-14. CrossRef Medline
53. Plichta MM, Schwarz AJ, Grimm O, Morgen K, Mier D, Haddad L, Gerdes AB, Sauer C, Tost H, Esslinger C, Colman P, Wilson F, Kirsch P, Meyer-Lindenberg A (2012) Test-retest reliability of evoked BOLD signals from a cognitive-emotive fMRI test battery. Neuroimage 60:1746-1758. CrossRef Medline
54. Preacher KJ, Hayes AF (2004) SPSS and SAS procedures for estimating indirect effects in simple mediation models. Behav Res Methods Instrum Comput 36:717-731. CrossRef Medline
55. Riba J, Krämer UM, Heldmann M, Richter S, Münte TF (2008) Dopamine agonist increases risk taking but blunts reward-related brain activity. PLoS One 3:e2479. CrossRef Medline
56. Rohrbaugh JW, Syndulko K, Lindsley DB (1976) Brain wave components of the contingent negative variation in humans. Science 191:1055-1057. CrossRef Medline
57. Sacchet MD, Knutson B (2012) Spatial smoothing systematically biases the localization of reward-related brain activity. Neuroimage 66C:270-277. Medline
58. Santesso DL, Evins AE, Frank MJ, Schetter EC, Bogdan R, Pizzagalli DA (2009) Single dose of a dopamine agonist impairs reinforcement learning in humans: evidence from event-related potentials and computational modeling of striatal-cortical function. Hum Brain Mapp 30:1963-1976. CrossRef Medline
59. Scheibe C, Ullsperger M, Sommer W, Heekeren HR (2010) Effects of parametrical and trial-to-trial variation in prior probability processing revealed by simultaneous electroencephalogram/functional magnetic resonance imaging. J Neurosci 30:16709-16717. CrossRef Medline
60. Scheres A, Milham MP, Knutson B, Castellanos FX (2007) Ventral striatal hyporesponsiveness during reward anticipation in attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder. Biol Psychiatry 61:720-724. CrossRef Medline
61. Smith Y, Raju DV, Pare JF, Sidibe M (2004) The thalamostriatal system: a highly specific network of the basal ganglia circuitry. Trends Neurosci 27:520-527. CrossRef Medline
62. Smith Y, Raju D, Nanda B, Pare JF, Galvan A, Wichmann T (2009) The thalamostriatal systems: anatomical and functional organization in normal and parkinsonian states. Brain Res Bull 78:60-68. CrossRef Medline
63. Sobotka SS, Davidson RJ, Senulis JA (1992) Anterior brain electrical asymmetries in response to reward and punishment. Electroencephalogr Clin Neurophysiol 83:236-247. CrossRef Medline
64. Stephan KE, Harrison LM, Kiebel SJ, David O, Penny WD, Friston KJ (2007) Dynamic causal models of neural system dynamics: current state and future extensions. J Biosci 32:129-144. CrossRef Medline
65. Stephan KE, PennyWD, Daunizeau J, Moran RJ, Friston KJ (2009) Bayesian model selection for group studies. Neuroimage 46:1004-1017. CrossRef Medline
66. Stephan KE, Penny WD, Moran RJ, den Ouden HE, Daunizeau J, Friston KJ (2010) Ten simple rules for dynamic causal modeling. Neuroimage 49: 3099-3109. CrossRef Medline
67. van Hell HH, Jager G, Bossong MG, Brouwer A, Jansma JM, Zuurman L, van Gerven J, Kahn RS, Ramsey NF (2012) Involvement of the endocannabinoid system in reward processing in the human brain. Psychopharmacology 219:981-990. CrossRef Medline
68. van Leeuwen TH, Steinhausen HC, Overtoom CC, Pascual-Marqui RD, van't Klooster B, Rothenberger A, Sergeant JA, Brandeis D (1998) The continuous performance test revisited with neuroelectric mapping: impaired orienting in children with attention deficits. Behav Brain Res 94:97-110. CrossRef Medline
69. van Wouwe NC, Ridderinkhof KR, Band GP, van den Wildenberg WP, Wylie SA (2012) Dose-dependent dopaminergic modulation of reward-based learning in Parkinson's disease. Neuropsychologia 50:583-591. CrossRef Medline
70. Walter WG, Cooper R, Aldridge VJ, McCallum WC, Winter AL (1964) Contingent negative variation: an electric sign of sensorimotor association and expectancy in the human brain. Nature 203:380-384. CrossRef Medline