Consciousness in dolphins? A review of recent evidence

Journal of Comparative Physiology A: Neuroethology, Sensory, Neural, and Behavioral Physiology

Volumn 199, Issue 6, 2013, Pages 565-582

  Harley, Heidi E ^a  

^a NEW COLLEGE OF FLORIDA   (United States)

Author keywords

Consciousness; Dolphin; Metacognition; Mirror self recognition; Self awareness

Indexed keywords

ANIMAL; ANIMAL BEHAVIOR; AWARENESS; COGNITION; CONSCIOUSNESS; DOLPHIN; PERCEPTION; PSYCHOLOGICAL ASPECT; RECOGNITION; REVIEW; SELF CONCEPT;

ANIMALS; AWARENESS; BEHAVIOR, ANIMAL; COGNITION; CONSCIOUSNESS; DOLPHINS; PERCEPTION; RECOGNITION (PSYCHOLOGY); SELF CONCEPT;

EID: 84878429657     PISSN: 03407594     EISSN: 14321351     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1007/s00359-013-0816-8     Document Type: Review

References (134)

1. Anderson JR (1995) Self-recognition in dolphins: credible cetaceans; compromised criteria, controls, and conclusions. Conscious Cogn 4: 239-243.
2. Anderson JR, Gallup GG (2011) Which primates recognize themselves in mirrors? PLOS Bio 9(3): e1001024.
3. Au WWL (1993) The sonar of dolphins. Springer-Verlag, New York.
4. Bard K (2008) Understanding reflections of self and other objects. In: Lange-Küttner C (ed) Drawing and the non-verbal mind. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 23-41.
5. Bauer GB, Colbert DE, Gaspard JC, Littlefield B, Fellner W (2003) Underwater visual acuity of Florida manatees (Trichechus manatus latirostris). Int J Comp Psychol 16: 130-142.
6. Beran MJ, Smith JD, Coutinho MVC, Couchman JJ, Boomer J (2009) The psychological organization of "uncertainty" responses and "middle" responses: a dissociation in capuchin monkeys (Cebus apella). J Exp Psychol Anim B 35: 371-381.
7. Block N (1995) On a confusion about a function of consciousness. Behav Brain Sci 18(2): 227-287.
8. Blumberg MS, Wasserman EA (1995) Animal mind and the argument from design. Am Psychol 50(3): 133-144.
9. Browne D (2004) Do dolphins know their own minds? Biol Philos 19: 633-653.
10. Chalmers DJ (1996) The conscious mind. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
11. Chiou T, Kleinlogel S, Cronin T, Caldwell R, Loeffler B, Siddiqi A, Goldizen A, Marshall J (2008) Circular polarization vision in a stomatopod crustacean. Curr Biol 18: 429-434.
12. Clayton NS, Emery NJ, Dickinson A (2006) The prospective cognition of food caching and recovery by western scrub-jays (Aphelocoma californica). Comp Cogn Behav Rev 1: 1-11.
13. Cohen MA, Dennett DC (2011) Consciousness cannot be separated from function. Trends Cogn Sci 15(8): 358-364.
14. Coren S (2003) Sensation and perception. In: Weiner IB (ed) Handbook of psychology, Freedheim DK (ed), vol I., History of psychologyWiley and Sons, Hoboken, pp 85-108.
15. Cowey A, Stoerig P (1995) Blindsight in monkeys. Nature 373: 247-249.
16. Cowey A, Stoerig P (1997) Visual detection in monkeys with blindsight. Neuropsychologia 35: 929-939.
17. Dawson WW (1980) The cetacean eye. In: Herman LM (ed) Cetacean behavior: mechanisms and functions. Krieger Publishing, Malabar, pp 53-100.
18. Dawson WW, Carder DA, Ridgway SH, Schmeisser ET (1981) Synchrony of dolphin eye movements and their power density spectra. Comp Biochem Phys A 68(3): 443-449.
19. de Veer MW, van den Bos R (1999) A critical review of methodology and interpretation of mirror self-recognition research in nonhuman primates. Anim Behav 58(3): 459-468.
20. Delfour F (2006) Marine mammals in front of the mirror: body experiences to self-recognition: a cognitive ethological methodology combined with phenomenological questioning. Aquat Mamm 32(4): 517-527.
21. Dennett DC (1991) Consciousness explained. Little, Brown and Company, Boston.
22. Dennett DC (2005) Sweet dreams: philosophical obstacles to a science of consciousness. MIT Press, Cambridge.
23. Descartes R (1637) Discourse on the method of rightly conducting one's reason, and seeking the truth in sciences. In: Haldane E, Ross GRT (eds) Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
24. Dral ADG (1972) Aquatic and aerial vision in the bottle-nosed dolphin. Neth J Sea Res 5(4): 510-513.
25. Dral ADG (1974) Problems in image-focusing and astigmatism in cetacea-a state of affairs. Aquat Mamm 2: 22-28.
26. Dral ADG (1975) Vision in cetacea. J Zoo Med 6(1): 17-21.
27. Fleming SM, Dolan RJ, Frith CD (2012) Metacognition: computation, biology and function. Phil Trans R Soc B 367: 1280-1286.
28. Foote A, Crystal J (2007) Metacognition in the rat. Curr Biol 17: 551-555.
29. Fuchs AH, Milar KS (2003) Psychology as a science. In: Freedheim DK, Veiner IB (eds) Handbook of psychology, volume I: history of psychology. Wiley and Sons, Hoboken, pp 1-26.
30. Gallagher S (2000) Philosophical conceptions of the self: implications for cognitive science. Trends Cogn Sci 4(1): 14-21.
31. Gallup GG Jr (1970) Chimpanzees: self-recognition. Science 167(3914): 86-87.
32. Gallup GG Jr (1982) Self-awareness and the emergence of mind in primates. Am J Primatol 2: 237-248.
33. Gallup GG Jr (1995) Mirrors, minds, and cetaceans. Conscious Cogn 4: 226-228.
34. Gallup GG Jr (1997) On the rise and fall of self-conception in primates. In: Snodgrass JG, Thompson RL (eds) The self across psychology: self-recognition, self-awareness, and the self concept. New York Academy of Sciences, New York, pp 73-82.
35. Gazzaniga MS (2011) Who's in charge? Free will and the science of the brain. Harper Collins, New York.
36. Gergely G (1994) From self-recognition to theory of mind. In: Parker ST, Mitchell RW, Boccia ML (eds) Self-awareness in animals and humans: developmental perspectives. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 51-60.
37. Gibson JJ (1979) The ecological approach to visual perception. Houghton Mifflin, Boston.
38. Gómez JC (1994) Mutual awareness in primate communication: a Gricean approach. In: Parker ST, Mitchell RW, Boccia ML (eds) Self-awareness in animals and humans: developmental perspectives. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 61-80.
39. Gould SJ (1996) Can we truly know sloth and rapacity? Nat Hist 105(4): 18-57.
40. Griffin DR (1976) The question of animal awareness: evolutionary continuity of mental experience. Rockefeller University Press, New York.
41. Griffin DR (1984) Animal thinking. Harvard University Press, Cambridge.
42. Griffin DR (1992) Animal minds. University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
43. Griffin DR (1995) Windows on animal minds. Conscious Cogn 4: 194-204.
44. Hampton RR (2001) Rhesus monkeys know when they remember. Proc Natl A Sci USA 98(9): 5359-5362.
45. Hampton RR (2009) Multiple demonstrations of metacognition in nonhumans: converging evidence or multiple mechanisms? Comp Cog Behav Rev 4: 17-28.
46. Hart D, Whitlow JW Jr (1995) The experience of self in the bottlenose dolphin. Conscious Cogn 4: 244-247.
47. Hassin RR, Uleman JS, Bargh JA (eds) (2005) The new unconscious: social cognition and social neuroscience. Oxford University Press, New York.
48. Herman LM (2010) What laboratory research has told us about dolphin cognition. Int J Comp Psychol 23: 310-330.
49. Herman LM (2012) Body and self in dolphins. Conscious Cogn 21: 526-545.
50. Herman LM, Abichandani SL, Elhajj AN, Herman EYK, Sanchez JL, Pack AA (1999) Dolphins (Tursiops truncatus) comprehend the referential character of the human pointing gesture. J Comp Psychol 113: 1-18.
51. Heyes CM (1994) Reflections on self-recognition in primates. Anim Behav 47(4): 909-919.
52. Heyes CM (1995) Self-recognition in primates: further reflections create a hall of mirrors. Anim Behav 50(6): 1533-1542.
53. Heyes CM (1996) Self-recognition in primates: irreverence, irrelevance, and irony. Anim Behav 51(2): 470-473.
54. Heyes CM (2011) Automatic imitation. Psychol Bull 137: 463-483.
55. Hodos W, Campbell CBG (1969) Scala naturae: why there is no theory in comparative psychology. Psychol Rev 76: 337-350.
56. Hughes HC (1999) Sensory exotica: a world beyond human experience. MIT Press, Cambridge.
57. Hurley S, Noë A (2003) Neural plasticity and consciousness. Biol Philos 18: 131-168.
58. Itakura S (1987) Use of a mirror to direct their responses in Japanese monkeys (Macaca fuscata fuscata). Primates 28(3): 343-352.
59. James W (1890/1950) The principles of psychology. Dover Publications, Oxford.
60. Kiefer M, Pulvermüller F (2012) Conceptual representations in mind and brain: theoretical developments, current evidence, and future directions. Cortex 48: 805-825.
61. Klein SB (2012) The self and science: is it time for a new approach to the study of human experience? Curr Dir Psychol Sci 21(4): 253-257.
62. Lilly JC (1967) The mind of the dolphin: a nonhuman intelligence. Doubleday, New York.
63. Loveland KA (1995) Self-recognition in the bottlenose dolphin: ecological considerations. Conscious Cogn 4(2): 254-257.
64. Maier NRF (1931) Reasoning in humans: II. The solution of a problem and its appearance in consciousness. J Comp Psychol 12: 181-194.
65. Marino L, Reiss D, Gallup GG Jr (1994) Mirror self-recognition in bottlenose dolphins: implications for comparative investigations of highly dissimilar species. In: Parker ST, Mitchell RW, Boccia ML (eds) Self-awareness in animals and humans: developmental perspectives. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 380-391.
66. Marten K, Psarakos S (1994) Evidence of self-awareness in the bottlenose dolphin (Tursiops truncatus). In: Parker ST, Mitchell RW, Boccia ML (eds) Self-awareness in animals and humans: developmental perspectives. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 361-379.
67. Marten K, Psarakos S (1995a) Marten and Psarakos commentary response. Conscious Cogn 4: 258-269.
68. Marten K, Psarakos S (1995b) Using self-view television to distinguish between self-examination and social behavior in the bottlenose dolphin (Tursiops truncatus). Conscious Cogn 4: 205-224.
69. McMahon S, Macpherson K, Roberts WA (2010) Dogs choose a human informant: metacognition in canines. Behav Proc 85: 293-298.
70. Mercado E, DeLong CM (2010) Dolphin cognition: representation and processes in memory and perception. Int J Comp Psychol 23: 344-378.
71. Mercado E III, Murray SO, Uyeyama RK, Pack AA, Herman LM (1998) Memory for recent actions in the bottlenosed dolphins (Tursiops truncatus): repetition of arbitrary behaviors using an abstract rule. Anim Learn Behav 26(2): 210-218.
72. Mercado E III, Uyeyama RK, Pack AA, Herman LM (1999) Memory for action events in the bottlenosed dolphin. Anim Cogn 2: 17-25.
73. Mitchell RW (1993) Mental models of mirror-self-recognition: two theories. New Ideas Psychol 11(3): 295-325.
74. Mitchell RW (1995) Evidence of dolphin self-recognition and the difficulties of interpretation. Conscious Cogn 4: 229-234.
75. Mobley JR, Helweg DA (1989) Visual ecology and cognition in cetaceans. In: Thomas JA, Kastelein RA (eds) Sensory abilities of cetaceans: laboratory and field evidence. Plenum Press, New York, pp 519-536.
76. Morgan CL (1894) An introduction to comparative psychology. Walter Scott Publishing Company, London.
77. Nagel T (1974) What is it like to be a bat? Philos Rev 83(4): 435-450.
78. Neisser U (1988) Five kinds of self-knowledge. Philos Psychol 1(1): 35-59.
79. Norris KS, Würsig B, Wells RS, Würsig M (1994) The Hawaiian spinner dolphin. University of California Press, Berkeley.
80. Overstrom NA (1983) Association between burst-pulse sounds and aggressive behavior in captive Atlantic bottlenosed dolphins (Tursiops truncatus). Zoo Biol 2: 1-93.
81. Pabst DA (1996) Morphology of the subdermal connective tissue sheath of dolphins: a new fibre-sound, thin-walled, pressurized cylinder model for swimming vertebrates. J Zool 238(1): 35-52.
82. Pack AA, Herman LM (2007) The dolphin's (Tursiops truncatus) understanding of human gaze and pointing: knowing what and where. J Comp Psychol 121: 34-45.
83. Palmer SE (1999) Color, consciousness, and the isomorphism constraint. Behav Brain Sci 22: 923-989.
84. Paukner A, Anderson JR, Borelli E, Visalberghi E, Ferrari PF (2005) Macaques (Macaca nemestrina) recognize when they are being imitated. Biol Lett 1: 219-222.
85. Pelli DG, Farell B (1995) Psychophysical methods. In: Bass M, van Stryland EW, Williams DR, Wolfe WL (eds) Handbook of optics. McGraw-Hill, New York, pp 29. 1-29. 13.
86. Pfungst O (1911) Clever Hans: a contribution to experimental animal and human psychology. Henry Holt, New York.
87. Platt MM, Thompson RL (1985) Mirror responses in a Japanese macaque troop (Arashiyama West). Primates 26: 300-314.
88. Povinelli DJ (1995) The unduplicated self. In: Rochat P (ed) The self in infancy: theory and research. Elsevier, Amersterdam, pp 161-192.
89. Povinelli DJ, Rulf AB, Landau KR, Bierschwale DT (1993) Self-recognition in chimpanzees (Pan troglodytes): distribution, ontogeny, and patterns of emergence. J Comp Psychol 107(4): 347-372.
90. Povinelli DJ, Bering JM, Giambrone S (2000) Toward a science of other minds: escaping the argument of analogy. Cogn Sci 24(3): 509-541.
91. Ramachandran VS, Hirstein W (1997) Three laws of qualia: what neurology tells us about the biological functions of consciousness. J Conscious Stud 4(5-6): 429-457.
92. Ramachandran VS, Hirstein W (1998) The perception of phantom limbs: the D. O. Hebb lecture. Brain 121: 1603-1630.
93. Ramachandran VS, Rogers-Ramachandran D, Cobb S (1995) Touching the phantom limb. Nat 377: 489-490.
94. Reiss D, Marino L (1995) Self-view television as a test of self-awareness: only in the eye of the beholder? Conscious Cogn 4: 235-238.
95. Reiss D, Marino L (2001) Mirror self-recognition in the bottlenose dolphin: a case of cognitive convergence. Proc Natl A Sci USA 98(10): 5937-5942.
96. Roberts WA, McMillan N, Musolino E, Cole M (2012) Information seeking in animals: metacognition? Comp Cog Behav Rev 7: 85-109.
97. Rochat P (2001) The infant's world. Harvard University Press, Cambridge.
98. Rochat P, Zahavi D (2011) The uncanny mirror: a re-framing of mirror self-experience. Conscious Cogn 20: 204-213.
99. Roitblat HL (1985) Introduction to comparative cognition. Freeman, New York.
100. Romanes GJ (1882) Animal intelligence. Appleton, New York.
101. Sarko D, Marino L, Reiss D (2002) A bottlenose dolphin's (Tursiops truncatus) responses to its mirror image: further analysis. Int J Comp Psychol 15(1): 69-76.
102. Scheer M (2010) Review of self-initiated behaviors of free-ranging cetaceans directed towards human swimmers and waders during open water encounters. Interact Stud 11(3): 442-466.
103. Schusterman RJ (1980) Behavioral methodology in echolocation by marine mammals. In: Busnel R, Fish JF (eds) Animal sonar systems. Plenum Press, New York, pp 11-42.
104. Sevcik R (1995) Is it live or is it Memorex? Conscious Cogn 4: 251-253.
105. Shea N, Heyes C (2010) Metamemory as evidence of animal consciousness: the type that does the trick. Biol Philos 25(1): 95-110.
106. Shettleworth SJ (1993) Where is the comparison in comparative cognition? Alternative research programs. Psychol Sci 4(3): 179-184.
107. Shettleworth SJ (1998/2010) Cognition, evolution, and behavior. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
108. Shettleworth SJ (2010) Clever animals and killjoy explanations in comparative psychology. Trends Cogn Sci 14(11): 477-481.
109. Shettleworth SJ, Sutton JE (2006) Do animals know what they know? In: Hurley S, Nudds M (eds) Rational animals. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp 235-246.
110. Smith JD (2009) The study of animal metacognition. Trends Cogn Sci 13(9): 389-396.
111. Smith JD (2010) Inaugurating the study of animal metacognition. Int J Comp Psychol 23: 401-413.
112. Smith JD, Schull J, Strote J, McGee K, Egnor R, Erb L (1995) The uncertain response in the bottlenosed dolphin (Tursiops truncates). J Exp Psychol Gen 124(4): 391-408.
113. Smith JD, Beran MJ, Couchman JJ, Coutinho VC, Boomer J (2009) The psychological organization of "uncertainty" responses and "middle" responses: a dissociation in capuchin monkeys (Cebus apella). J Exp Psychol Anim B 35(3): 371-381.
114. Smith JD, Couchman JJ, Beran MJ (2012) The highs and lows of theoretical interpretation in animal-metacognition research. Philos T R Soc B 367: 1297-1309.
115. Stoerig P, Zontanous A, Cowey A (2002) Aware or unaware? assessment of cortical blindness in four men and a monkey. Cereb Cortex 12: 565-574.
116. Stürmer B, Aschersleben G, Prinz W (2000) Correspondence effects with manual gestures and postures: a study of imitation. J Exp Psychol Human 26: 1746-1759.
117. Sutton JE, Shettleworth SJ (2008) Memory without awareness: pigeons do not show metamemory in delayed matching-to-sample. J Exp Psychol Anim B 34: 266-282.
118. Swartz K (1997) What is mirror self-recognition in nonhuman primates, and what is it not? Ann N Y Acad Sci 818(1): 65-71.
119. Swartz K, Evans S (1991) Not all chimpanzees (Pan troglodytes) show self-recognition. Primates 32: 496-583.
120. Templer VL, Hampton RR (2012) Rhesus monkeys (Macaca mulatta) show robust evidence for memory awareness across multiple generalization tests. Anim Cogn 15: 409-419.
121. Thompson RL, Boatright-Horowitz SL (1994) The question of mirror-mediated self-recognition in apes and monkeys: some new results and reservations. In: Parker ST, Mitchell RW, Boccia ML (eds) Self-awareness in animals and humans: developmental perspectives. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 330-349.
122. Tinbergen N (1951) The study of instinct. Oxford University Press, New York.
123. Velmans M (1996) Consciousness and the "causal paradox". Behav Brain Sci 19(3): 538-542.
124. Von Uexküll J (1909) Umwelt und Innenwelt der Tiere. Springer, Berlin.
125. Watson JB (1913) Psychology as the behaviorist sees it. Psychol Rev 20: 158-177.
126. Weiskrantz L (1986) Blindsight: a case study and implications. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
127. Weiskrantz L (1998) Consciousness and commentaries. Int J Comp Psychol 33(3): 227-233.
128. West MJ, King AP, Goldstein MH (2004) Singing, socializing, and the music effect. In: Marler P, Slabbekoorn H (eds) Nature's music: the science of birdsong. Elsevier, London, pp 374-387.
129. Williams TM (1999) The evolution of cost efficient swimming in marine mammals: limits to energetic optimization. Philos T R Soc B 354: 193-201.
130. Williams TM, Friedl WA, Haun JE (1993) The physiology of bottlenose dolphins (Tursiops truncatus): heart rate, metabolic rate, and plasma lactate concentration during exercise. J Exp Biol 179: 31-46.
131. Wilson EO (1975) Sociobiology: the new synthesis. Harvard University Press, Cambridge.
132. Wynne CDL (2007) What are animals? Why anthropomorphism is still not a scientific approach to behavior. Comp Cogn Behav Rev 2: 125-235.
133. Yablakov AV, Bel'kovich VM, Borisov VI (1974) Whales and dolphins. Joint Publications Research Services, Arlington.
134. Zentall TR (2010) Coding of stimuli by animals: retrospection, prospection, episodic memory and future planning. Learn Motiv 41: 225-240.