Determinants of motor vehicle crash fatalities using Bayesian model selection methods

Research in Transportation Economics

Volumn 43, Issue 1, 2013, Pages 112-122

  Blattenberger, Gail ^a   Fowles, Richard ^a   Loeb, Peter D ^b  

^a 260 S Central Campus Drive ^*  (United States)

^b RUTGERS UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

Bayesian econometrics; Cell phones; Motor vehicle crashes; Vehicle safety

Indexed keywords

EID: 84878155527     PISSN: 07398859     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.retrec.2012.12.004     Document Type: Article

References (92)

1. Asch P., Levy D.T. Does the minimum drinking age affect traffic fatalities?. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management 1987, 6:180-192.
2. Beede K.E., Kass S.J. Engrossed in conversation: the impact of cell phones on simulated driving performance. Accident Analysis and Prevention 2006, 38:415-421.
3. Bills C.B., Grabowski J., Li G. Suicide by aircraft: a comparative analysis. Aviation, Space, and Environmental Medicine 2005, 76(8):715-719.
4. Blattenberger, G., Fowles, R., Loeb, P. D., Clarke, W. A. (2009). Understanding the cell phone effect on motor vehicle fatalities using classical & Bayesian methods. In Presented at the Allied Social Sciences Associations Meeting (TPUG), San Francisco, USA January 2009.
5. Blattenberger G., Fowles R., Loeb P.D., Clarke W.A. Understanding the cell phone effect on vehicle fatalities: a Bayesian view. Applied Economics 2012, 44:1823-1835.
6. Breiman L. Statistical modeling: the two cultures. Statistical Science 2001, 16(3):199-231.
7. Bylow L.F., Savage I. The effect of airline deregulation on automobile fatalities. Accident Analysis and Prevention 1991, 23:443-452.
8. Campbell B.J., Campbell F.A. Seat belt law experience in four foreign countries compared to the United states 1986, AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety, Falls Church, VA.
9. Campbell B.J., Stewart J.R., Campbell F.A. Early results of seat belt legislation in the United states of America 1986, University of North Carolina Highway Safety Research Center, Chapel Hill, NC.
10. Campbell B.J., Stewart J.R., Campbell F.A. 1985-1986 experience with belt laws in the United states 1987, University of North Carolina Highway Safety Research Center, Chapel Hill, NC.
11. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Center for Injury Prevention and Control. Web-based injury statistics query and reporting system (WISQARS): [online] Available at: Accessed 07.07.12. http://www.cdc.gov/injury/wisqars/.
12. Chaloupka F.J., Saffer H., Grossman M. Alcohol-control policies and motor vehicle fatalities. Journal of Legal Studies 1993, 22:161-218.
13. Chamberlain G., Leamer E.E. Matrix weighted averages and posterior bounds. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society Series B 1976, 38(1):73-84.
14. Chapman S., Schoefield W.N. Lifesavers and samaritans: emergency use of cellular (mobile) phones in Australia. Accident Analysis and Prevention 1998, 30:815-819.
15. Clarke W.A., Loeb P.D. The determinants of train fatalities: keeping the model on track. Transportation Research a Part E 2005, 41:145-158.
16. Clyde M.A. Bayesian model averaging and model search strategies. Bayesian Statistics 1999, 6:157-185.
17. Coate D., Markowitz S. The effects of daylight and daylight savings time on U.S. pedestrian fatalities and motor vehicle occupant fatalities. Accident Analysis and Prevention 2004, 36(3):351-357.
18. Cohen A., Einav L. The effects of mandatory seat belt laws on driving behavior and traffic fatalities. Review of Economics and Statistics 2003, 85(4):828-843.
19. Conner K.R., Cox C., Duberstein P.R., Tian L., Nisbet P.A., Conwell Y. Violence, alcohol, and completed suicide: a case-control study. American Journal of Psychiatry 2001, 158:1701-1705.
20. Connolly J.F., Cullen A., McTigue O. Single road traffic deaths: accident or suicide. Crisis: The Journal of Crisis Intervention and Suicide Prevention 1995, 16(2):85-89.
21. Consiglio W., Driscoll P., Witte M., Berg W.P. Effect of cellular telephone conversations and other potential interference on reaction time in braking responses. Accident Analysis and Prevention 2003, 35:495-500.
22. Crain W.M. Vehicle safety inspection systems 1980, American Enterprise Institute for Public Policy Research, Washington, D.C.
23. CTIA The wireless association 2011, [online] Available at, Accessed 10.02.11. http://www.ctia.org/.
24. Cubbin C., Smith G.S. Socioeconomic inequalities in injury: critical issues in design and analysis. Annual Review of Public Health 2002, 23:349-375.
25. Cullen S. Aviation suicide: a review of general aviation accidents in the U.K., 1970-96. Aviation, Space, and Environmental Medicine 1998, 69(7):696-698.
26. Etzerdorfer E. Single road traffic deaths: accidents or suicide? Comment. Crisis: The Journal of Crisis Intervention and Suicide Prevention 1995, 16(4):188-189.
27. Evans L.E. Traffic safety and the driver 1991, Van Norstrand Reinhold, New York.
28. Forester T., McNown R.F., Singell L.D. A cost benefit analysis of the 55 mph speed limit. Southern Economic Journal 1984, 50:631-641.
29. Fowles R. Micro EBA. American Statistician 1988, 4:274.
30. Fowles R., Loeb P.D. Speeding, coordination, and the 55-MPH limit: comment. American Economic Review 1989, 79:916-921.
31. Fowles R., Loeb P.D. The interactive effect of alcohol and altitude on traffic fatalities. Southern Economic Journal 1992, 59:108-112.
32. Fowles R., Loeb P.D., Clarke W.A. The cell phone effect on motor vehicle fatality rates: a Bayesian and classical econometric evaluation. Transportation Research Part E 2010, 46:1140-1147.
33. Freeborn B.A., McManus B. Substance abuse treatment and motor vehicle fatalities 2007, College of William and Mary, Department of Economics, Working Paper Number 66.
34. Garbacz C. How effective is automobile safety regulation?. Applied Economics 1990, 22:1705-1714.
35. Garbacz C., Kelly J.G. Automobile safety inspection: new econometric and benefit/cost estimates. Applied Economics 1987, 19:763-771.
36. George E.I., McCulloch R.R. Variable selection via Gibbs sampling. Journal of the American Statistical Association 1993, 88:881-889.
37. Glassbrenner D. Driver cell phone use in 2005 - overall results 2005, Traffic Safey Facts: Research Note, NHTSA, DOT HS 809967.[online] Available at, Accessed 11.02.11. http://www-nrd.nhtsa.dot.gov/Pubs/809967.PDF.
38. Hatfield N.J., Hinshaw W.M. Evaluation of the fatality reduction effectiveness of the Texas mandatory safety belt law 1987, The Texas A&M University System, Texas Transportation Institute.
39. Hoeting J., Madigan D., Raftery A., Volinsky C. Bayesian model averaging: a tutorial. Statistical Science 1999, 14(4):382-417.
40. Hoxie P., Skinner D. Effects of mandatory seatbelt use laws on highway fatalities in 1985 1987, U.S. Department of Transportation, Research and Special Programs Administration, Transportation Systems Center, Cambridge, MA.
41. Huffine C.L. Eqivocal single-auto traffic fatalities. Life-threatening Behavior 1971, 1(2):83-95.
42. Keeler T.E. Highway safety, economic behavior, and driving environment. American Economic Review 1994, 84(3):684-693.
43. Key J.T., Pericchi L., Smith A.F.M. Bayesian model choice: what and why?. Bayesian Statistics 1999, 6:343-370.
44. Laberge-Nadeau C., Maag U., Bellavance F., Lapiere S.D., Desjardins D., Messier S., et al. Wireless telephones and risk of road crashes. Accident Analysis and Prevention 2003, 35:649-660.
45. Lave C.A. Speeding, coordination, and the 55 MPH limit. American Economic Review 1985, 75:1159-1164.
46. Leamer E.E. Specification searches: Ad Hoc inference with non-experimental data 1978, Wiley & Sons, New York.
47. Leamer E.E. Sets of posterior means with bounded variance priors. Econometrica 1982, 50(3):725-736.
48. Leamer E.E. Let's take the con out of econometrics. American Economic Review 1983, 73(1):31-43.
49. Leamer E.E. Sensitivity analyses would help. American Economic Review 1985, 75(3):308-313.
50. Leamer E.E. Revisiting Tobin's 1950 study of food expenditure. Journal of Applied Econometrics 1997, 12(5):533-553.
51. Levy D.T., Asch P. Speeding, coordination, and the 55-MPH limit: comment. American Economic Review 1989, 79:913-915.
52. Lewis R.J., Johnson R.D., Whinnery J.E., Forster E.M. Aircraft-assisted pilot suicides in the United States, 1993-2002. Archives of Suicide Research 2007, 11(2):149-161.
53. Loeb P.D. The efficacy and cost-effectiveness of motor vehicle inspection using cross-sectional data - an econometric analysis. Southern Economic Journal 1985, 52:500-509.
54. Loeb P.D. The determinants of motor vehicle accidents with special consideration to policy variables. Journal of Transport Economics and Policy 1987, 21:279-287.
55. Loeb P.D. The determinants of motor vehicle accidents - a specification error analysis. Logistics and Transportation Review 1988, 24:33-48.
56. Loeb P.D. Automobile safety inspection: further econometric evidence. Applied Economics 1990, 22:1697-1704.
57. Loeb P.D. The effectiveness of seat belt legislation in reducing driver involved injury and fatality rates in Texas, Maryland, and California - Final report 1991, U.S.D.O.T./NHTSA.
58. Loeb P.D., Clarke W.A. The determinants of truck accidents. Transportation Research Part E 2007, 43:442-452.
59. Loeb P.D., Clarke W.A., Anderson R. The impact of cell phones on motor vehicle fatalities. Applied Economics 2009, 41:2905-2914.
60. Loeb P.D., Gilad B. The efficacy and cost-effectiveness of vehicle inspection - a state specific analysis using time series data. Journal of Transport Economics and Policy 1984, 18:145-164.
61. Loeb P.D., Talley W.K., Zlatoper T. Causes and deterrents of transportation accidents: An analysis by mode 1994, Quorum Books, Westport, CT.
62. Lund A.K., Pollner J., Williams A.F. Preliminary estimates of the effects of mandatory seat belt use laws. Accident Analysis and Prevention 1987, 17:219-223.
63. McCarthy, P. (1992). Highway safety implications of expanded use of longer combination vehicles (LCVs). In Paper presented at the 6th World Conference on Transport Research, Lyon, France.
64. McEvoy S.P., Stevenson M.R., McCartt A.T., Woodward M., Haworth C., Palamara P., et al. Role of mobile phones in motor vehicle crashes resulting in hospital attendance: a case-crossover study. British Medical Journal 2005, 33:428-435.
65. Mayer T. The empirical significance of econometric models. Measurement in economics: A handbook 2007, Marcel Boumans, London.
66. Mazess R.B., Picon-Reategui E., Thomas R.B., Little M.A. Effects of alcohol and altitude on man during rest and work. Aerospace Medicine 1968, 39:403-406.
67. Newman H.W. The effect of altitude on alcohol tolerance. Quarterly Journal on Studies of Alcohol 1949, 10:398-403.
68. Neyens D.M., Boyle L.N. The effect of distractions on the crash types of teenage drivers. Accident Analysis and Prevention 2007, 39:206-212.
69. Partyka S.C. Lives saved by seat belts from 1983 through 1987 1988, NHTSA Technical Report, Washington, D.C.
70. Peltzman S. The effect of automobile regulation. Journal of Political Economy 1975, 93:677-725.
71. Phillips D.P. Motor vehicle fatalities increase just after publicized suicide stories. Science 1977, 196:1464-1466.
72. Phillips D.P. Suicide, motor vehicle fatalities, and the mass media: evidence toward a theory of suggestion. American Journal of Sociology 1979, 84(5):1150-1174.
73. Pokorny A.D., Smith J.P., Finch J.R. Vehicular suicides. Life-Threatening Behavior 1972, 2(2):105-119.
74. Porterfield A.L. Traffic fatalities, suicide, and homicide. American Sociological Review 1960, 25(6):897-901.
75. Poysti L., Rajalin S., Summala H. Factors influencing the use of cellular (mobile) phone during driving and hazards while using it. Accident Analysis and Prevention 2005, 37:47-51.
76. Raftery A., Hoeting J., Volinsky C., Painter I., Yeung K.Y. BMA: Bayesian model averaging 2009, R package version 3.10. [online], Accessed 11.0.11. http://cran.r-project.org/package%3dBMA.
77. Raftery A.E., Madigan D., Hoeting J.A. Bayesian model averaging for linear regression models. Journal of the American Statistical Association 1997, 92:179-191.
78. Redelmeier D.A., Tibshirani R.J. Association between cellular-telephone calls and motor vehicle collisions. New England Journal of Medicine 1997, 336:453-458.
79. Reinfurt D.W., Campbell B.J., Stewart J.R., Stutts J.C. North Carolina's occupant restraint law: A three year evaluation 1988, University of North Carolina Highway Safety Research Center, Chapel Hill, NC.
80. Saffer H., Grossman M. Beer taxes, the legal drinking age, and youth motor vehicle fatalities. Journal of Legal Studies 1987, 16:351-374.
81. Saffer H., Grossman M. Drinking age laws and highway mortality rates: cause and effect. Economic Inquiry 1987, 25:403-417.
82. Savage I. Trespassing on the railroad. Research in transportation Economics: Railroad economics 2007, Elsevier Science, Amsterdam. S.M. Dennis, W.K. Talley (Eds.).
83. Savage, I. (2010). Analysis of data on pedestrian/rail safety in Illinois 2005-2009. In Pedestrian Rail Safety Symposium, June 22. 2010 and Proceedings of the DuPage Rail Safety Council Conference, September 29, 2010.
84. Skinner D., Hoxie P. Effects of seatbelt laws on highway fatalities: Update - April 1988 1988, U.S. Department of Transportation, Research and Special Programs Administration, Transportation Systems Center, Cambridge, MA.
85. Snyder D. Speeding, coordination, and the 55-MPH limit. American Economic Review 1989, 79:922-925.
86. Sommers P.M. Drinking age and the 55 MPH speed limit. Atlantic Economic Journal 1985, 13:43-48.
87. Souetre E. Completed suicides and traffic accidents: longitudinal analysis in France. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica 1988, 77(5):530-534.
88. Streff F.M., Schultz R.H., Wagenaar A.C. Changes in police reported injuries associated with Michigan's safety belt law: 1988 update 1989, The University of Michigan, Transportation Research Institute, Ann Arbor, MI.
89. Sullman M.J., Baas P.H. Mobile phone use amongst New Zealand drivers. Transportation Research Part F: Traffic Psychology and Behavior 2004, 7:95-105.
90. Violanti J.M. Cellular phones and fatal traffic collisions. Accident Analysis and Prevention 1998, 30:519-524.
91. Womble K.B. The estimated effect of safety belt use laws on injury reduction 1989, U.S. Department of Transportation, NHTSA, Washington, D.C.
92. Zlatoper T.J. Regression analysis of time series data on motor vehicle deaths in the United States. Journal of Transport Economics and Policy 1984, 18:263-274.