Integrated energy planning in cities and territories: A review of methods and tools

Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews

Volumn 22, Issue , 2013, Pages 289-297

  Mirakyan, Atom ^a   De Guio, Roland ^b  

^a KARLSRUHE INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY   (Germany)

^b INSA DE STRASBOURG   (France)

Author keywords

City; Energy planning; Methods; Modeling; Tools

Indexed keywords

MODELS; TOOLS;

CITY; ENERGY PLANNING; ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING; INTEGRATED ENERGY PLANNING; MAPPING POINT; METHODS; PLANNING PROCEDURE; PLANNING TASKS;

RENEWABLE ENERGY RESOURCES;

EID: 84874870813     PISSN: 13640321     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.rser.2013.01.033     Document Type: Review

References (124)

1. C. Cormio, M. Dicorato, A. Minoia, and M. Trovato A regional energy planning methodology including renewable energy sources and environmental constraints Renewable & Sustainable Energy Reviews 7 2003 99 130
2. Commission E. Towards a thematic strategy on the urban environment, Brussels, (COM(2004)60), 〈http://ec.europa.eu/environment/urban/towards- com.htm#language-versions〉; 2012 [accessed 29.10.12].
3. Nicholas Lenssen Local integrated resource planning: a new tool for a competitive era Electricity Journal 9 1996 26 36 (Pubitemid 126400706)
4. V. Bhatt, P. Friley, and J. Lee Integrated energy and environmental systems analysis methodology for achieving low carbon cities Journal of Renewable and Sustainable Energy 2 2010 031012
5. J.S. Nilsson, and A. Mårtensson Municipal energy-planning and development of local energy-systems Applied Energy 76 2003 179 187 (Pubitemid 36990788)
6. K. Sperling, F. Hvelplund, and B.V. Mathiesen Centralisation and decentralisation in strategic municipal energy planning in Denmark Energy Policy 39 2011 1338 1351
7. Balme R. Centre d'études européennes de Sciences Po. Central-local relations in French energy policy making and the environmental shift: towards a new pattern of governance between state and local authorities?, 〈http://spire.sciences-po.fr/hdl:/2441/f0uohitsgqh8dhk97g1qi55a2〉; 2010 [accessed 29.10.12].
8. R. Joe Integrated assessment for sustainability appraisal in cities and regions Environmental Impact Assessment Review 20 2000 31 64
9. Rad FD. Application of local energy indicators in municipal energy planning: a new approach towards sustainability. ACEEE Summer Study, Asilomar (CA, USA): Lund University; 5-20 August 2010, 〈http://www.ees.energy.lth. se/fileadmin/ees/Publikationer/2010/ACEEE-2010-FDR.pdf〉 [accessed 29.10.12].
10. United Nations. Indicators of sustainable development: guidelines and methodologies, 〈www.un.org/esa/sustdev/natlinfo/indicators/guidelines. pdf〉; 2007 [accessed 29.10.12].
11. International Atomic Energy Agency. Energy indicators for sustainable development: guidelines and methodologies, Vienna; 2005. ISBN: 92-0-116204-9.
12. Mirakyan A, Lelait L, Lewald N, Imbert P. The dynamics of regional (sub-national) integrated energy planning and requirements for methods and models. Paris: International Energy Agency (IEA), International Energy Workshop; 2008.
13. A. Mirakyan, L. Lelait, N. Khomenko, and I. Kaikov Methodological framework for the analysis and development of a sustainable, integrated, regional energy plan - a French region case study 2009 EcoMod. Ottawa (Canada)
14. J. Mingers, and J. Brocklesby Multimethodology: towards a framework for mixing methodologies Omega 25 1997 489 509 (Pubitemid 127169586)
15. P.M. Williams Community strategies: mainstreaming sustainable development and strategic planning? Sustainable Development 10 2002 197 205 (Pubitemid 35400229)
16. J. Ivner Do decision-making tools lead to better energy planning? 2009 Linköping University Linköping (Sweden)
17. A. Bagheri, and P. Hjorth Planning for sustainable development: a paradigm shift towards a process-based approach Sustainable Development 15 2007 83 96 (Pubitemid 46696224)
18. IEA, ANNEX 22, Energy Efficient Communities, 1994, http://www.ecbcs.org/ annexes/annex22.htm. last accessed 12.02.2013
19. IEA, ANNEX 33, The Advanced Local Energy Planning methodology (ALEP), A Guidebook, 2000, http://www.ecbcs.org/annexes/annex33.htm. last accessed 12.02.2013
20. I. Linkov, A. Varghese, S. Jamil, T. Seager, G. Kiker, and T. Bridges I. Linkov, A. Ramadan, Multi-criteria decision analysis: a framework for structuring remedial decisions at contaminated sites comparative risk assessment and environmental decision making 2005 Springer Netherlands p. 15-54
21. The International Council for Local Environmental Initiatives (ICLEI). The local agenda 21 planning guide, Canada; 1996. ISBN: 0-88936-801-5.
22. Bertoldi P, Bornas CD, Monni S, Raveschoot RPD. Existing methodologies and tools for the development and implementation of sustainable energy action plans (SEAP), 〈http://publications.jrc.ec.europa.eu/repository/handle/ 111111111/13504〉; 2010 [accessed 29.10.12].
23. S. Albeverio, D. Andrey, P. Giordano, and A. Vancheri The dynamics of complex urban systems 2008 Physica-Verlag Heidelberg, Accademia di Architettura Mendrisio (Switzerland)
24. J. Rotmans Methods for IA: the challenges and opportunities ahead Environmental Modeling and Assessment 3 1998 155 179 (Pubitemid 128696803)
25. J. Rotmans, M. van Asselt, and P. Vellinga An integrated planning tool for sustainable cities Environmental Impact Assessment Review 20 2000 265 276 (Pubitemid 30343105)
26. R. Cynthia Neudoerffer, P. Malhotra, and P. Venkata Ramana Participatory rural energy planning in India - a policy context Energy Policy 29 2001 371 381
27. T. Anderson, and A. Doig Community planning and management of energy supplies - international experience Renewable Energy 19 2000 325 331 (Pubitemid 29534743)
28. R.L. Keeney, and T.L. McDaniels Identifying and structuring values to guide integrated resource planning at BC gas Operations Research 47 1999 651 662 (Pubitemid 30544586)
29. R.L. Keeney, and T.L. McDaniels Value-focused thinking about strategic decisions at BC hydro Interfaces 22 1992 94 109
30. Commission E. Review of the EU sustainable development strategy: initial stocktaking and future orientations, COM, 658 final, 〈http://europa.eu/ legislation-summaries/environment/sustainable-development/l28117-en.htm〉; 2005 [accessed 29.10.12].
31. L.A. Franco, G. Montibeller, J.J. Cochran, L.A. Cox, P. Keskinocak, and J.P. Kharoufeh Problem structuring for multicriteria decision analysis interventions Wiley encyclopedia of operations research and management science 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
32. Building in Europe Local Intelligent Energy Forums (BELIEF), 〈http://eaci-projects.eu/iee/page/Page.jsp?op=project-detail&prid= 1444〉; 2012 [accessed 29.10.12].
33. Climate Alliance. A strong community for global climate protection, 〈http://www.climatealliance.org/〉; 2012 [accessed 29.10.12].
34. European Association of Local Authorities, 〈http://www.energy- cities.eu/〉; 2012 [accessed 29.10.12].
35. Regions for Sustainable Change, 〈http://www.rscproject.org/〉; 2012 [accessed 29.10.12].
36. Sustainable Energy Communities (SECs), 〈http://www.musecenergy. eu〉; 2012 [accessed 29.10.12].
37. Project Practise in the Framework of EC Program Intellgent Energy for Europe, 〈http://www.energypractise.eu/〉; 2012 [accessed 29.10.12].
38. The Covenant of Mayors of local and regional authorities to increase energy efficiency and use of renewable energy sources on their territories, 〈http://www.eumayors.eu/index-en.html〉; 2012 [accessed 29.10.12].
39. C40 CITIES Climate Leadership Group, 〈http://www.c40cities.org/ 〉; 2012 [accessed 29.10.12].
40. ICLEI - Local Governments for Sustainability, 〈http://www.iclei.org/ 〉; 2012 [accessed 29.10.12].
41. European Commission. Intelligent energy elibrary bibliography - local/regional energy management, 〈http://www.iee-library.eu/〉; 2012 [accessed 29.10.12].
42. The Arctic Energy Alliance (AEA), 〈http://www.aea.nt.ca/〉; 2012 [accessed 29.10.12].
43. UN-HABITAT's Urban Environment Section, 〈http://www.unhabitat.org/ 〉; 2012 [accessed 29.10.12].
44. J. Terrados, G. Almonacid, and L. Hontoria Regional energy planning through SWOT analysis and strategic planning tools. Impact on renewables development Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 11 2007 1275 1287 (Pubitemid 44827851)
45. L.P. Neves, L.C. Dias, C.H. Antunes, and A.G. Martins Structuring an MCDA model using SSM: a case study in energy efficiency European Journal of Operational Research 199 2009 834 845
46. Local Sustainability, 〈http://www.localsustainability.eu/〉; 2012 [accessed 29.10.12].
47. D.P. van Vuuren, M. Hoogwijk, T. Barker, K. Riahi, S. Boeters, and J. Chateau Comparison of top-down and bottom-up estimates of sectoral and regional greenhouse gas emission reduction potentials Energy Policy 37 2009 5125 5139
48. S. Jebaraj, and S. Iniyan A review of energy models Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 10 2006 281 311 (Pubitemid 43131463)
49. H. Lund, N. Duić, G. Krajačić, and M.d. Graca Carvalho Two energy system analysis models: a comparison of methodologies and results Energy 32 2007 948 954 (Pubitemid 46282330)
50. Van Beeck N. Classification of energy models, internal report no. FEW 777: Tilburg University; 1999.
51. T. Nakata, D. Silva, and M. Rodionov Application of energy system models for designing a low-carbon society Progress in Energy and Combustion Science 37 2011 462 502
52. R.B. Hiremath, S. Shikha, and N.H. Ravindranath Decentralized energy planning; modeling and application - a review Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 11 2007 729 752 (Pubitemid 44829994)
53. D. Connolly, H. Lund, B.V. Mathiesen, and M. Leahy A review of computer tools for analysing the integration of renewable energy into various energy systems Applied Energy 87 2010 1059 1082
54. M. Manfren, P. Caputo, and G. Costa Paradigm shift in urban energy systems through distributed generation: methods and models Applied Energy 88 2011 1032 1048
55. International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis, 〈http://www.iiasa.ac.at/〉; 2012 [accessed 29.10.12].
56. Research Centre Jülich. Systems analysis and technology evaluation (IEK-STE), 〈http://www2.fz-juelich.de/ief/ief-ste/index.php?index=3〉; 2012 [accessed 29.10.12].
57. Energy and Power Evaluation Program (ENPEP-BALANCE). Argonne national laboratory, 〈http://www.dis.anl.gov/projects/Enpepwin.html〉; 2012 [accessed 29.10.12].
58. National Resources Canada. RETScreen international, 〈http://www. retscreen.net/〉; 2012 [accessed 29.10.12].
59. H. Lund, and E. Münster Integrated energy systems and local energy markets Energy Policy 34 2006 1152 1160 (Pubitemid 43230487)
60. H. Lund Large-scale integration of wind power into different energy systems Energy 30 2005 2402 2412
61. M. Münster, and H. Lund Use of waste for heat, electricity and transport - challenges when performing energy system analysis Energy 34 2009 636 644
62. H. Lund Large-scale integration of optimal combinations of PV, wind and wave power into the electricity supply Renewable Energy 31 2006 503 515
63. H. Lund, and W. Kempton Integration of renewable energy into the transport and electricity sectors through V2G Energy Policy 36 2008 3578 3587
64. H. Lund Renewable energy strategies for sustainable development Energy 32 2007 912 919 (Pubitemid 46282335)
65. H.B. Bjorn, I.S. Hans, and W. Ove eTransport: investment planning in energy supply systems with multiple energy carriers Energy 32 2007 1676 1689
66. Bakken BH, Holen AT. Energy service systems: integrated planning case studies. Power engineering society general meeting, vol. 2, IEEE; 2004. p. 2068-73 (Pubitemid 40197057)
67. SINTEF Energy Research. eTransport case studies, 〈http://www.sintef. no/home/SINTEF-Energy-Research/Project-work/eTransport-/Case-studies/〉; 2012 [accessed 29.10.12].
68. E.H.A. Fragniére A Stochastic programming model for energy/environment choices under uncertainty International Journal of Environment and Pollution 6 1996 587 603
69. Haurie A., MARKAL-LITE An Energy/Environment Model to Assess Urban Sustainable Development Policies, University of Geneva, 2001, http://130.203.133.150/viewdoc/summary?doi=10.1.1.142.4541. last accessed 12.02.2013
70. Fedra K., Haurie A., Kanala R., INTEGRATED DECISION SUPPORT SYSTEM FOR AIR QUALITY MANAGEMENT, University of Geneva, Switzerland, http://www.google.de/ url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=1&ved= 0CEAQFjAA&url=http%3A%2F%2Fciteseerx.ist.psu. edu%2Fviewdoc%2Fdownload%3Fdoi%3D10.1.1.131.457%26rep%3Drep1%26type%3Dpdf& ei=t1MaUZabMoejtAa84ICwCw&usg=AFQjCNHcIk99qttvSqIIZV51okfBjmrsjQ&bvm=bv. 42261806,d.Yms last accessed 12.02.2013
71. D.A. Carlson, A. Haurie, J.P. Vial, and D.S. Zachary Large-scale convex optimization methods for air quality policy assessment Automatica 40 2004 385 395
72. Lenz V, Matheis HP, Mirakyan A, Schreiber P. Klimabilanz für die Stadt Damrstadt. Öko-Institute: Darmstadt, 〈http://www.oeko.de/ service/klima-da/files/klida-kurz.pdf〉; 2000 [accessed 29.10.12].
73. Deutsche Umwelthilfe e.V. (DUH), Bioenergie, Eine Chance für Kommunen und Regionen, Beispiele und Strategien für eine kommunale und regionale Bioenergienutzung, 〈http://www.bioenergie-regionen.de/〉; 2007 [accessed 29.10.12].
74. Baur F, Bemmann U, Nina Müller, Ziegler C, Fritsche UR, Effinger A, et al., IZES gGmbH, Strategien zur nachhaltigen energetischen Nutzung von Biomasse in ausgewählten Modellregionen, 〈http://www.izes.de/cms/ upload/pdf/BioRegio-2007.pdf〉; 2007 [accessed 29.10.12].
75. F. Manzini Inserting renewable fuels and technologies for transport in Mexico City Metropolitan Area International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 31 2006 327 335 (Pubitemid 43112176)
76. I.A. Bowles Massachusetts clean energy and climate plan for 2020 2010 Secretary of Energy and Environmental Affairs Massachusetts 〈http://www. mass.gov/eea/air-water-climate-change/climate-change/mass-clean-energy-and- climate-plan.html〉 [accessed 29.10.12]
77. R. Ghanadan, and J.G. Koomey Using energy scenarios to explore alternative energy pathways in California Energy Policy 33 2005 1117 1142 (Pubitemid 40058833)
78. A. Bailie, B. Dougherty, C. Heaps, and M. Lazarus Turning the corner on global warming emissions: an analysis of ten strategies for California Oregon, and Washington 2012 Tellus Institute Boston (Massachusetts) 〈http://www.ef. org/westcoastclimate/B-Tellus-Turning-%20Corner.pdf〉 [accessed 29.10.12
79. Phdungsilp A. Energy analysis for sustainable mega-cities. Licentiate Thesis. Stockholm (Sweden): Royal Institute of Technology; 2006.
80. A. Phdungsilp Integrated energy and carbon modeling with a decision support system: policy scenarios for low-carbon city development in Bangkok Energy Policy 38 2010 4808 4817
81. C. Schlenzig Energy planning and environmental management with the information and decision support system MESAP International Journal of Global Energy 12 1999 81 91
82. C. Schlenzig PlaNet - Ein entscheidungsunterstützendes System für die Energie- und Umweltplanung (PlaNet - a decision support system for energy and environmental planning) 1997 Universität Stuttgart Stuttgart
83. F. Pietrapertosa, C. Cosmi, M. Macchiato, M. Salvia, and V. Cuomo Life cycle assessment, externE and comprehensive analysis for an integrated evaluation of the environmental impact of anthropogenic activities Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 13 2009 1039 1048
84. M. Salvia, F. Pietrapertosa, C. Cosmi, V. Cuomo, and M. Macchiato Approaching the Kyoto targets: a case study for Basilicata region (Italy) Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 8 2004 73 90
85. F. Pietrapertosa, C. Cosmi, M. Macchiato, G. Marmo, and M. Salvia Comprehensive modelling for approaching the Kyoto targets on a local scale Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 7 2003 249 270
86. R. Loulou, and A. Kanudia Minimax regret strategies for greenhouse gas abatement: methodology and application Operations Research Letters 25 1999 219 230 (Pubitemid 30523559)
87. M.F. Macchiato, C. Cosmi, M. Ragosta, and G. Tosato Atmospheric emission reduction and abatement costs in regional environmental planning Journal of Environmental Management 41 1994 141 156 (Pubitemid 24214950)
88. J. Johnsson, O. Björkqvist, and C.O. Wene Integrated energy-emissions control planning in the community of Uppsala International Journal of Energy Research 16 1992 173 188
89. Cosmi C., Cuomo V., Macchiato M., Mangiamele L., Salvia M., Tosato G., Cost analysis in the definition of environmental recovery strategies- case study Basilicata Region (Southern Italy), 2000, http://hdl.handle.net/10122/165. last accessed 12.02.2013
90. B.-M.S. Hodge, S. Huang, J.D. Siirola, J.F. Pekny, and G.V. Reklaitis A multi-paradigm modeling framework for energy systems simulation and analysis Computers & Chemical Engineering 35 2011 1725 1737
91. J. Duran-Encalada, and A. Paucar-Caceres System dynamics urban sustainability model for Puerto Aura in Puebla, Mexico Systemic Practice and Action Research 22 2009 77 99
92. W. Jin, L. Xu, and Z. Yang Modeling a policy making framework for urban sustainability: incorporating system dynamics into the ecological footprint Ecological Economics 68 2009 2938 2949
93. S. Manish, I.R. Pillai, and R. Banerjee Sustainability analysis of renewables for climate change mitigation Energy for Sustainable Development 10 2006 25 36
94. H. Hertle, J. Stroh, B. Gugel, and N. Igel Klimaschutzkonzeption für die Stadtwerke Lemgo 2008 Institut für Energie- und Umweltforschung GmbH Heidelberg 〈http://www.lemgo.net/fileadmin/image/Klimaschutz/Endbericht-KK- Lemgo-081210.pdf〉 [accessed 29.10.12]
95. L.A. Greening, and S. Bernow Design of coordinated energy and environmental policies: use of multi-criteria decision-making Energy Policy 32 2004 721 735 (Pubitemid 37307331)
96. S.D. Bond, K.A. Carlson, and R.L. Keeney Generating objectives: can decision makers articulate what they want? Management Science 54 2008 56 70 (Pubitemid 351206490)
97. J.-J. Wang, Y.-Y. Jing, C.-F. Zhang, and J.-H. Zhao Review on multi-criteria decision analysis aid in sustainable energy decision-making Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 13 2009 2263 2278
98. P. Zhou, B.W. Ang, and K.L. Poh Decision analysis in energy and environmental modeling: an update Energy 31 2006 2604 2622
99. DECISIONARIUM. A site for interactive multicriteria decision support 〈http://www.decisionarium.tkk.fi/〉 for academic and 〈http://www.decisionarium.net/〉 for general use; 2012 [accessed 29.10.12].
100. Decision Deck, 〈http://www.decision-deck.org/index.html〉; 2012 [accessed 29.10.12].
101. InfoHarvest Services, 〈http://www.infoharvest.com/ihroot/index. asp〉; 2012 [accessed 29.10.12].
102. School of Management. SUNY-Buffalo, 〈http://mgt2.buffalo.edu/ webaim〉; 2012 [accessed 29.10.12].
103. International Atomic Energy Agency, 〈http://www.iaea.org/〉; 2012 [accessed 29.10.12].
104. EURO Working Group Multicriteria Aid for Decisions, 〈http://www.cs. put.poznan.pl/ewgmcda/〉; 2012 [accessed 29.10.12].
105. International Society on Multiple Criteria Decision Making, 〈http://www.mcdmsociety.org/〉; 2012 [accessed 29.10.12].
106. International Organization for Standardization (ISO). Environmental management - Life Cycle Assessment - Principles and framework, ISO 14040, 〈http://www.iso.org/iso/catalogue-detail?csnumber=37456〉; 2006 [accessed 29.10.12].
107. The EU Eco-Management and Audit Scheme (EMAS), 〈http://ec.europa.eu/ environment/emas/index-en.htm〉; 2012 [accessed 29.10.12].
108. Goedecke U., Frey T., Energieagentur NRW, Marktspiegel Energiemanagemnt-Software, Teil I, Wupperta, Germany, 2004, http://www.perpendo. de/files/EM%20Marktspiegel.pdf last accessed 12.02.2013
109. Løken E. Multi-criteria planning of local energy systems with multiple energy carriers. Doctoral thesis. Norway, (Trondheim): Norwegian University of Science and Technology; 2007.
110. J. Terrados, G. Almonacid, and P. Pérez-Higueras Proposal for a combined methodology for renewable energy planning Application to a Spanish region, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 13 2009 2022 2030
111. Mirakyan A, Khomenko N, Lelait L, IK. The potential of OTSM-TRIZ as a frameworking method for modern regional, integrated energy planning and modeling. In: Proceedings of the fifth TRIZ symposium in Japan. Tokyo; 2009.
112. K. Kowalski, S. Stagl, R. Madlener, and I. Omann Sustainable energy futures: methodological challenges in combining scenarios and participatory multi-criteria analysis European Journal of Operational Research 197 2009 1063 1074
113. T. Kaya, and C. Kahraman Multicriteria renewable energy planning using an integrated fuzzy VIKOR & AHP methodology: the case of Istanbul Energy 35 2010 2517 2527
114. Miglio DR, Gargiulo M, Lavagno E. Integration of comprehensive analysis with sub-system and component modelling tools for local energy planning. Cape Town (South Africa): International energy workshop; 2006.
115. Möller B. Geographical information systems for energy planning - integration of geographical methods in local and national energy systems analysis, Ph.D. thesis: Aalborg University; 2003.
116. M. Biberacher Fusion in the global energy system - GIS and TIMES 2006 International Energy Agency
117. N. Strachan, N. Balta-Ozkan, D. Joffe, K. McGeevor, and N. Hughes Soft-linking energy systems and GIS models to investigate spatial hydrogen infrastructure development in a low-carbon UK energy system International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 34 2009 642 657
118. T.V. Ramachandra, S.V. Krishna, and B.V. Shruthi Decision Support System for Regional Domestic Energy Planning Journal of Scientific and Industrial Research 64 2005 163 174 (Pubitemid 40451376)
119. S. Sushil Flexible systems methodology Systemic Practice and Action Research 7 1994 633 652
120. C.-O. Wene Energy-economy analysis: linking the macroeconomic and systems engineering approaches Energy 21 1996 809 824
121. M. Contaldi, F. Gracceva, and G. Tosato Evaluation of green-certificates policies using the MARKAL-MACRO-Italy model Energy Policy 35 2007 797 808 (Pubitemid 44913633)
122. S.C. Morris, G.A. Goldstein, and V.M. Fthenakis NEMS and MARKAL-MACRO models for energy-environmental-economic analysis: a comparison of the electricity and carbon reduction projections Environmental Modeling and Assessment 7 2002 207 216 (Pubitemid 37111034)
123. bp-Imperial College Urban Energy Systems Project. Fifth annual report, 〈http://www3.imperial.ac.uk/urbanenergysystems〉; February 2011 [accessed 29.10.12].
124. C. Bouvy, and K. Lucas Multicriterial optimisation of communal energy supply concepts Energy Conversion and Management 48 2007 2827 2835 (Pubitemid 47498671)