A review of macroscopic thrombus modeling methods

Thrombosis Research

Volumn 131, Issue 2, 2013, Pages 116-124

  Cito, Salvatore ^a   Mazzeo, Marco Domenico ^b   Badimon, Lina ^c  

^a UNIVERSITAT ROVIRA I VIRGILI   (Spain)

^b UNIVERSITAT POMPEU FABRA   (Spain)

^c CATALAN INSTITUTE OF CARDIOVASCULAR SCIENCES   (Spain)

Author keywords

Cardiovascular; CFD; Coagulation; Hemodynamics; Platelet adhesion aggregation; Thrombosis

Indexed keywords

BLOOD CLOTTING FACTOR 10A; BLOOD CLOTTING FACTOR 11; BLOOD CLOTTING FACTOR 12; BLOOD CLOTTING FACTOR 13; BLOOD CLOTTING FACTOR 5; BLOOD CLOTTING FACTOR 7; BLOOD CLOTTING FACTOR 8; BLOOD CLOTTING FACTOR 9; CALCIUM; FIBRINOGEN; PROTHROMBIN; THROMBIN; THROMBOPLASTIN;

BLOOD CLOTTING; CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASE; CELL SIZE; COMPUTATIONAL FLUID DYNAMICS; ENDOTHELIUM INJURY; ERYTHROCYTE; FIBRINOLYSIS; FINITE ELEMENT ANALYSIS; HEMOSTASIS; HYDRODYNAMICS; MATHEMATICAL MODEL; PRIORITY JOURNAL; REVIEW; THROMBOCYTE; THROMBOCYTE ADHESION; THROMBOCYTE AGGREGATION; THROMBOSIS; VASOCONSTRICTION;

BLOOD FLOW VELOCITY; COMPUTER SIMULATION; HEMODYNAMICS; HUMANS; MODELS, CARDIOVASCULAR; THROMBOSIS;

EID: 84872339400     PISSN: 00493848     EISSN: 18792472     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.thromres.2012.11.020     Document Type: Review

References (104)

1. V. Fuster, L. Badimon, M. Cohen, J.A. Ambrose, J.J. Badimon, and J. Chesebro Insights into the pathogenesis of acute ischemic syndromes Circulation 77 6 1988 1213 1220
2. V. Fuster, L. Badimon, J.J. Badimon, and J.H. Chesebro The pathogenesis of coronary artery disease and the acute coronary syndromes - Part I N Engl J Med 326 4 1992 242 250
3. V. Fuster, L. Badimon, J.J. Badimon, and J.H. Chesebro The pathogenesis of coronary artery disease and the acute coronary syndromes - Part II N Engl J Med 326 4 1992 242 250
4. A. Merino, P. Hauptman, L. Badimon, J.J. Badimon, M. Cohen, and V. Fuster Echocardiographic "smoke" is produced by an interaction of erythrocytes and plasma proteins modulated by shear forces J Am Coll Cardiol 20 7 1992 1661 1668
5. C. Patrono, F. Andreotti, H. Arnesen, L. Badimon, C. Baigent, and J.P. Collet Antiplatelet agents for the treatment and prevention of atherothrombosis Eur Heart J 32 23 2011 2922 2932
6. L. Badimon, R.F. Storey, and G. Vilahur Update on lipids, inflammation and atherothrombosis Thromb Haemost 105 2011 S34 S42 [Suppl.]
7. L. Badimon, J.J. Badimon, A. Galvez, J.H. Chesebro, and V. Fuster Influence of arterial damage and wall shear rate on platelet deposition. Ex vivo study in a swine model Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol 6 1986 312 320
8. L. Badimon, J.J. Badimon, V.T. Turitto, and V. Fuster Thrombosis: Studies under flow conditions Ann N Y Acad Sci 516 1987 527 540
9. L. Badimon, V.T. Turitto, J.A. Rosemark, J.J. Badimon, and V. Fuster Characterization of a tubular flow chamber for studying platelet interaction with biologic and prosthetic materials: Deposition of Indium-111 labeled platelets on collagen, subendothelium and expanded polytetrafluoroethylene J Lab Clin Med 110 6 1987 706 718
10. P.C. Adams, V. Fuster, L. Badimon, J.J. Badimon, and J.H. Chesebro Platelet-vessel wall interactions, rheologic factors and thrombogenic substrate in acute coronary syndromes: Preventive strategies Am J Cardiol 60 1987 9G 16G
11. A. Merino, M. Cohen, J.J. Badimon, V. Fuster, and L. Badimon Synergistic action of severe wall injury and shear forces on thrombus formation in arterial stenosis: definition of a thrombotic shear rate threshold J Am Coll Cardiol 24 4 1994 1091 1097
12. C.E. Sing, and A. Alexander-Katz Elongational flow induces the unfolding of von Willebrand factor at physiological flow rates Biophys J 98 2010 L35 L37
13. M. Stiefel, A. Shaner, and S.D. Schaefer The Edwin Smith Papyrus: the birth of analytical thinking in medicine and otolaryngology Laryngoscope 116 2 2006 182 188
14. M. Schultze Ein heizbarer Objecttisch und seine Verwendung bei Untersuchungen des Blutes Arch Mikrosk Anat 1 1 1865 1 42
15. D.B. Brewer Max Schultze (1865), G. Bizzozero (1882) and the discovery of the platelet Br J Haematol 133 3 2006 251 258
16. J. Bizzozero Über einen neuen Formbestandtheil des Blutes und dessen Rolle bei der Thrombose und der Blutgerinnung Virchows Arch Pathol Anat Physiol Klin Med 90 3 1882 261 332
17. M.H. Kroll, J.D. Hellums, L.V. McIntire, A.I. Schafer, and J.L. Moake Platelets and shear stress Blood 88 5 1996 1525 1541
18. M.F. Hockin, K.C. Jones, S.J. Everse, and K.G. Mann A model for the stoichiometric regulation of blood coagulation J Biol Chem 277 21 2002 18322 18333
19. A. Kuharsky, and A.L. Fogelson Surface mediated control of blood coagulation: the role of binding site densities and platelet deposition Biophys J 80 2001 1050 1094
20. M. Anand, K. Rajagopal, and K.R. Rajagopal A model incorporating some of the mechanical and biochemical factors underlying clot formation and dissolution in flowing blood J Theor Med 5 3-4 2003 183 218
21. F.I. Ataullakhanov, and M.A. Panteleev Mathematical modeling and computer simulation in blood coagulation Pathophysiol Haemost Thromb 34 2-3 2005 60 70
22. D.M. Wootton, and D.N. Ku Fluid mechanics of vascular systems, diseases, and thrombosis Annu Rev Biomed Eng 1 1 1999 299 329
23. A. Bedekar, K. Pant, Y.P. Ventikos, and S. Sundaram A computational model combining vascular biology and haemodynamics for thrombosis prediction in anatomically accurate cerebral aneurysms Food Bioprod Process 83 C2 2005 118 126
24. C.A. Taylor, and J.D. Humphrey Open problems in computational vascular biomechanics: hemodynamics and arterial wall mechanics Comput Methods Appl Mech Eng 198 45-46 2009 3514 3523
25. M. Schenone, B.C. Furie, and B. Furie The blood coagulation cascade Curr Opin Hematol 11 4 2004 272 276
26. A. Fernández-Ortiz, J.J. Badimon, E. Falk, V. Fuster, B. Meyer, and A. Mailhac Characterization of the relative thrombogenicity of atherosclerotic plaque components: implications for consequences of plaque rupture J Am Coll Cardiol 23 7 1994 1562 1569
27. A. Mailhac, J.J. Badimon, J.T. Fallon, A. Fernández-Ortiz, B. Meyer, and J.H. Chesebro Effect of an eccentric severe stenosis on fibrin(ogen) deposition on severely damaged vessel wall in arterial thrombosis. Relative contribution of fibrin(ogen) and platelets Circulation 90 2 1994 988 996
28. M.K. Runyon, B.L. Johnson-Kerner, and R.F. Ismagilov Minimal functional model of hemostasis in a biomimetic microfluidic system Angew Chem Int Ed Engl 116 12 2004 1557 1562
29. L. Badimon, and J.J. Badimon Mechanisms of arterial thrombosis in non-parallel streamlines. Platelet thrombi grow on the apex of stenotic severely injured vessel wall. Experimental study in the pig model J Clin Invest 84 4 1989 1134 1144
30. V.D. Butty, K. Gudjonsson, P. Buchel, V.B. Makhijani, Y. Ventikos, and D. Poulikakos Residence times and basins of attraction for a realistic right internal carotid artery with two aneurysms Biorheology 39 3-4 2002 387 393
31. X. Jin, Y. Otonashi-Satoh, Y. Zamami, T. Koyama, P. Sun, and Y. Kitamura Endothelial modulation of agonist-induced vasoconstriction in mesenteric microcirculation Yakugaku Zasshi 130 5 2010 723 728
32. Z.M. Ruggeri Platelets in atherothrombosis Nat Med 8 11 2002 1227 1234
33. S.P. Jackson The growing complexity of platelet aggregation Blood 109 12 2007 5087 5095
34. R.L.C. Adams, and R.J. Bird Review article: Coagulation cascade and therapeutics update: relevance to nephrology. Part 1: Overview of coagulation, thrombophilias and history of anticoagulants Nephrology 14 5 2009 462 479
35. G. Cesarman-Maus, and K.A. Hajjar Molecular mechanics of fibrinolysis Br J Haematol 129 3 2005 307 321
36. T. David, S. Thomas, and P.G. Walker Platelet deposition in stagnation point flow: an analytical and computational simulation Med Eng Phys 23 5 2001 299 312
37. T. David, P.G. de Groot, and P.G. Walker Boundary-layer type solutions for initial platelet activation and deposition J Theor Med 4 2 2002 95 108
38. T. David, and P.G. Walker Activation and extinction models for platelet adhesion Biorheology 39 3-4 2002 293 298
39. P.D. Richardson Effect of blood velocity on growth rate of platelet thrombi Nature 245 5420 1973 103 104
40. K.C. Jones, and K.G. Mann A model for the tissue factor pathway to thrombin J Biol Chem 269 37 1994 23367 23373
41. A. Alenitsyn, A. Kondratyev, I. Mikhailova, and I. Siddique Mathematical modeling of thrombus growth in mesenteric vessels Math Biosci 224 1 2010 29 34
42. M.S. Chatterjee, J.E. Purvis, L.F. Brass, and S.L. Diamond Pairwise agonist scanning predicts cellular signaling responses to combinatorial stimuli Nat Biotechnol 28 7 2010 727 732
43. A.L. Fogelson A mathematical model and numerical method for studying platelet adhesion and aggregation during blood clotting J Comput Phys 56 1 1984 111 134
44. A.L. Fogelson Continuum models of platelet aggregation: Formulation and mechanical properties SIAM J Appl Math 52 4 1992 1089 1110
45. Bjorstad PE. Numerical solution of the biharmonic equation. Ph.D. thesis; Stanford University; 1980.
46. N.T. Wang, and A.L. Fogelson Computational methods for continuum models of platelet aggregation J Comput Phys 151 2 1999 649 675
47. N.T. Wang, and A.L. Fogelson Platelet-wall interactions in continuum models of platelet thrombosis: formulation and numerical solution Math Med Biol 21 4 2004 293 334
48. A.L. Fogelson, and R.D. Guy A mathematical model and numerical method for studying platelet adhesion and aggregation during blood clotting Comput Methods Appl Mech Eng 197 25-28 2008 2087 2104
49. S.L. Diamond, and S. Anand Inner clot diffusion and permeation during fibrinolysis Biophys J 65 6 1993 2622 2643
50. M. Anand, K. Rajagopal, and K.R. Rajagopal A model for the formation and lysis of blood clots Pathophysiol Haemost Thromb 34 2-3 2005 109 120
51. M. Anand, K. Rajagopal, and K.R. Rajagopal A model for the formation, growth, and lysis of clots in quiescent plasma. A comparison between the effects of antithrombin III deficiency and protein C deficiency J Theor Biol 253 4 2008 725 738
52. D.V. Sakharov, J.F. Nagelkerke, and D.C. Rijken Rearrangements of the fibrin network and spatial distribution of fibrinolytic components during plasma clot lysis J Biol Chem 271 4 1996 2133 2138
53. E.C. Eckstein, and F. Belgacern Model of platelet transport in flowing blood with drift and diffusion terms Biophys J 60 1 1991 53 69
54. E.A. Ermakova, M.A. Panteleev, and E.E. Shnol Blood coagulation and propagation of autowaves in flow Pathophysiol Haemost Thromb 34 2-3 2005 135 142
55. A.I. Lobanov, and T.K. Starozhilova The effect of convective flows on blood coagulation processes Pathophysiol Haemost Thromb 34 2-3 2005 121 134
56. K. Leiderman, and A.L. Fogelson Grow with the flow: a spatial-temporal model of platelet deposition and blood coagulation under flow Math Med Biol 28 1 2011 47 84
57. www.ansys.com, ANSYS. 2012.
58. www.openfoam.org, OpenFOAM Foundation. 2012.
59. www.esigroup.com, CFD-ACE. 2012.
60. E.N. Sorensen, G.W. Burgreen, W.R. Wagner, and J.F. Antaki Computational simulation of platelet deposition and activation: II. Results for Poiseuille flow over collagen Ann Biomed Eng 27 4 1999 449 458
61. D.M. Wootton, C.P. Markou, S.R. Hanson, and D.K. Nu A mechanistic model of acute platelet accumulation in thrombogenic stenoses Ann Biomed Eng 29 4 2001 321 329
62. A. Jordan, T. David, S. Homer-Vanniasinkam, A. Graham, and P. Walker The effects of margination and red cell augmented platelet diffusivity on platelet adhesion in complex flow Biorheology 41 5 2004 641 653
63. P.W. Longest, and C. Kleinstreuer Comparison of blood particle deposition models for non-parallel flow domains J Biomech 36 3 2003 421 430
64. J. Jenkins, B. Prabhakarpandian, K. Lenghaus, J. Hickman, and S.S. Sundaram Fluidics-resolved estimation of protein adsorption kinetics in a biomicrofluidic system Anal Biochem 331 2 2004 207 215
65. T. Bodnar, and A. Sequeira Numerical simulation of the coagulation dynamics of blood Comput Math Methods Med 9 2 2008 83 104
66. P.D. Goodmam, E.T. Barlow, P.M. Crapo, S.F. Mohammad, and K.A. Solen Computational model of device-induced thrombosis and thromboembolism Ann Biomed Eng 33 6 2005 780 797
67. F.F. Weller Platelet deposition in non-parallel flow J Math Biol 57 3 2008 333 0359
68. F.F. Weller A free boundary problem modeling thrombus growth: model development and numerical simulation using the level set method J Math Biol 61 6 2010 805 818
69. D.M. Wootton, A.S. Popel, and B.R. Alevriadou An experimental and theoretical study on the dissolution of mural fibrin clots by tissue-type plasminogen activator Biotechnol Bioeng 77 4 2002 405 419
70. S. Succi The lattice Boltzmann equation for fluid dynamics and beyond 2001 Oxford University Press 0198503989
71. S. Melchionna, M. Bernaschi, S. Succi, E. Kaxiras, F.J. Rybicki, and D. Mitsouras Hydrokinetic approach to large-scale cardiovascular blood flow Comput Phys Commun 181 3 2010 462 472
72. Z. Guo, and T.S. Zhao Explicit finite-difference lattice Boltzmann method for curvilinear coordinates Phys Rev E 67 6 2003 066709
73. S. Ubertini, G. Bella, and S. Succi Lattice Boltzmann method on unstructured grids: Further developments Phys Rev E 68 1 2003 016701
74. Y. Li, E.J. LeBoeuf, and P.K. Basu Least-squares finite-element lattice Boltzmann method Phys Rev E 69 6 2004 065701
75. J. Janela, A. Sequeira, G. Pontrelli, S. Succi, and S. Ubertini Unstructured Lattice Boltzmann method for hemodynamic flows with shear-dependent viscosity Int J Mod Phys C 21 6 2010 795 811
76. C. Feichtinger, S. Donath, H. Köstler, J. Hötz, and U. Rüde WaLBerla: HPC software design for computational engineering simulations J Comput Sci 2 2 2011 105 112
77. J. Zhang Lattice Boltzmann method for microfluidics: models and applications Microfluid Nanofluid 10 1 2011 1 28
78. J. Bernsdorf, S.E. Harrison, S.M. Smith, P.V. Lawford, and D.R. Hose Applying the lattice Boltzmann technique to biofluids: A novel approach to simulate blood coagulation Comput Math Appl 55 7 2008 1408 1414
79. R. Ouared, and B. Chopard Lattice Boltzmann simulations of blood flow: non-Newtonian rheology and clotting processes J Stat Phys 121 1-2 2005 209 221
80. S. Li, and W.K. Liu Meshfree particle methods 2004 Springer Verlag 3540222561
81. S. Li, and W.K. Liu Meshfree and particle methods and their applications Appl Mech Rev 55 1 2002 1 34
82. M.B. Liu, and G.R. Liu Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics (SPH): an overview and recent developments Arch Comput Methods Eng 17 1 2010 25 76
83. T. Yamaguchi, T. Ishikawa, Y. Imai, N. Matsuki, M. Xenos, and Y. Deng Particle-based methods for multiscale modeling of blood Flow in the circulating and in devices: Challenges and future directions Ann Biomed Eng 38 3 2010 1225 1235
84. Y.P. Chui, and P.A. Heng A meshless rheological model for blood-vessel interaction in endovascular simulation Prog Biophys Mol Biol 103 2-3 2010 252 261
85. H.C. Hemker, S. Kerdelo, and R.M.W. Kremers Is there value in kinetic modeling of thrombin generation? No (unless.) Thromb Haemost 10 8 2012 1470 1477
86. K.G. Mann Is there value in kinetic modeling of thrombin generation? Yes Thromb Haemost 10 8 2012 1463 1469
87. J.E. Purvis, R. Radhakrishnan, and S.L. Diamond Steady-state kinetic modeling constrains cellular resting states and dynamic behavior PLoS Comput Biol 5 3 2009 e1000298
88. D. Luan, M. Zai, and J.D. Varner Computationally derived points of fragility of a human cascade are consistent with current therapeutic strategies PLoS Comput Biol 3 7 2007 e142
89. D. Luan, F. Szlam, K.A. Tanaka, P.S. Barie, and J.D. Varner Ensembles of uncertain mathematical models can identify network response to therapeutic interventions Mol Biosyst 6 11 2010 2272 2286
90. C.M. Danforth, T. Orfeo, K.G. Mann, K.E. Brummel-Ziedins, and S.J. Everse The impact of uncertainty in a blood coagulation model Math Med Biol 26 4 2009 323 336
91. I.V. Pivkin, P.D. Richardson, and G. Karniadakis Blood flow velocity effects and role of activation delay time on growth and form of platelet thrombi Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 103 46 2006 17164 17169
92. Z. Xu, M. Kamocka, M. Alber, and E.D. Rosen Computational approaches to studying thrombus development Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol 31 3 2011 500 505
93. M.H. Flamm, T.V. Colace, M.S. Chatterjee, H. Jing, S. Zhou, and D. Jaeger Multiscale prediction of patient-specific platelet function under flow Blood 120 1 2012 190 198
94. J.H. Lawson, M. Kalafatis, S. Stram, and K.G. Mann A model for the tissue factor pathway to thrombi. I. An empirical study J Biol Chem 269 37 1994 23357 23366
95. M. Sato, and N. Ohshima Hemodynamics at stenoses formed by growing platelet thrombi in mesenteric microvasculature of rat Microvasc Res 31 1 1986 66 76
96. J.A. Hubbell, and L.V. McIntire Visualization and analysis of mural thrombogenesis on collagen, polyurethane and nylon Biomaterials 7 5 1986 354 363
97. B.R. Alevriadou, J.L. Moake, N.A. Turner, Z.M. Ruggeri, B.J. Folie, and M.D. Phillips Real-time analysis of shear-dependent thrombus formation and its blockage by inhibitors of von Willebrand factor binding to platelets Blood 81 5 1993 1263 1276
98. C. Markou, S.R. Hanson, J.M. Siegel, and D.N. Ku The role of high wall shear rate on thrombus formation in stenoses Adv Bioeng ASME 26 1993 555 558
99. T. Karino, and H.L. Goldsmith Adhesion of human platelets to collagen on the walls distal to a tubular expansion Microvasc Res 17 3 1979 238 262
100. K. Affeld, A.J. Reininger, J. Gadischke, K. Grunert, S. Schmidt, and F. Thiele Fluid mechanics of the stagnation point flow chamber and its platelet deposition Artif Organs 19 7 1995 597 602
101. P.D. Goodmam, M.W. Hall, S. Sukavaneshvar, and K.A. Solen In vitro model for studying the effects of hemodynamics on device induced thromboembolism in human blood ASAIO J 46 5 2000 576 578
102. Smith SM. Development of a technique for the prediction of clot localisation in vitro. Ph.D. thesis; University of Sheffield; 2005.
103. S.E. Harrison, S.M. Smith, J. Bernsdorf, D.R. Hose, and P.V. Lawford Application and validation of the lattice Boltzmann method for modelling flow-related clotting J Biomech 40 1 2010 3023 3028
104. D. Slatter Textbook of small animal surgery 2003 W. B. Saunders 0721686079