Comparison of cognitive-behaviour therapy with psychoanalytic and psychodynamic therapy for depressed patients - A three-year follow-up study

Zeitschrift fur Psychosomatische Medizin und Psychotherapie

Volumn 58, Issue 3, 2012, Pages 299-316

  Huber, Dorothea ^a,b,c   Zimmermann, Johannes ^d   Henrich, Gerhard ^a   Klug, Guenther ^a  

^a TECHNICAL UNIVERSITY OF MUNICH   (Germany)

^b Klinikum Harlaching   (Germany)

^c INTERNATIONAL PSYCHOANALYTIC UNIVERSITY   (Germany)

^d UNIVERSITY OF KASSEL   (Germany)

Author keywords

Cognitive behaviour therapy; Depression; Long term follow up; Outcome research; Psychoanalytic therapy; Psychodynamic therapy

Indexed keywords

ADULT; ARTICLE; BECK DEPRESSION INVENTORY; COGNITIVE THERAPY; CONTROLLED STUDY; FEMALE; FOLLOW UP; GLOBAL SEVERITY INDEX; HUMAN; MAJOR CLINICAL STUDY; MAJOR DEPRESSION; MALE; MENTAL PATIENT; OUTCOME ASSESSMENT; PERSONALITY; PROSPECTIVE STUDY; PSYCHOANALYSIS; PSYCHODYNAMICS; PSYCHOTHERAPY; QUASI EXPERIMENTAL STUDY; QUESTIONNAIRE; RATING SCALE; SOCIAL PSYCHOLOGY; STATISTICAL SIGNIFICANCE;

EID: 84871014013     PISSN: 14383608     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.13109/zptm.2012.58.3.299     Document Type: Article

References (83)

1. Ablon, J. S., Jones, E. E. (2005): On psychoanalytic process. J Am Psychoanal Assoc 53, 541-68.
2. APA (1994): Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (4th edn) (DSM-IV). Washington, DC: APA.
3. Backs-Dermott, B. J., Dobson, K. S., Jones, S. I. (2010): An evaluation of an integrated model of relapse in depression. J Affective Disord 124, 60-67.
4. Benjamin, L. S. (1974): Structural analysis of social behaviour. Psychol Rev 81, 392-425.
5. Benjamin, L. S. (1983): The INTREX user's manual.Part I and II. Intrex Interpersonal Institute, Inc., P.O. Box 55218,Madison, WI 53705, Madison.
6. Beshai, S., Dobson, K. S., Bockting, C., Quigley, L. (2011): Relapse and recurrence prevention in depression: current research and future prospects. Clin Psychol Rev 31, 1349-1360.
7. Bockting, C., Spinhoven, P., Wouters, L. F., Koeter, M. W. J., Schene, A. H., and DELTA study group (2009): Long-term effect of preventive cognitive therapy in recurrent depression: 5,5 year follow-up. J Clin Psychiatry 70, 1621-1628.
8. Burcusa, S. L., Iacono, W.G. (2007): Risk for recurrence in depression. Clin Psychol Rev 27, 959-985. (Pubitemid 47600441)
9. Cohen, J. (1988): Statistical power analysis for behavioural sciences. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum Assoc.
10. Coyne, J. C., DeLongis, A. (1986): Going beyond social support: the role of social relationships in adaptation. J Consult Clin Psychol 54, 454-460.
11. Coyne, J. C., Downey, G. (1991): Social factors and psychopathology: stress, social support, and coping processes. Annu Rev Psychol 42, 401-425.
12. Cuijpers, P., van Straten, A., Schuurmans, J., van Oppen, P., Hollon, S. D., Andersson, G. (2010): Psychotherapy for chronic major depression and dysthymia: a meta-analysis. Clin Psychol Rev 30, 51-62.
13. DeMaat, S., de Jonghe, F., Schoevers, R., Dekker, J. (2009): The effectiveness of long-term psychoanalytic therapy: a systematic review of empirical studies. Harv Rev Psychiatry 17, 1-23.
14. DGPPN, BAEK, KBV, AWMF, AkdÄ, BPtK, BApK, DAGSHG, DEGAM, DGPM, DGPs, DGRW für die Leitliniengruppe Unipolare Depression (eds.) (2009): S3-Leitlinie/Nationale Versorgungsleitlinie Unipolare Depression. DGPPN, ÄZQ, AWMF.
15. Dobson, K. S., Dozois, D. J. A. (2008): Risk factors in depression. New York: Academic Press.
16. Dozois, D. J. A., Bieling, B. J., Patelis-Siotis, I., Hoar, L., Chudzik, S., McCabe, K., Westra, H. A. (2009): Changes in self-schema structure in cognitive therapy for major depressive disorder: a randomized clinical trial. J Consult Clin Psychol 77, 1078-88.
17. Driessen, E., Cuijpers, P., de Maat, S. C., Abbass, A. A., de Jonghe, F., Dekker, J. J. (2010): The efficacy of short-term psychodynamic psychotherapy for depression: A meta-analysis. Clin Psychol Rev 30, 25-36.
18. Dunkel, D., Antretter, E., Fröhlich-Walser, S., Haring, C. (2005): Evaluation of the short-form Social Support Questionnaire (SOZU-K-22) in clinical and non-clinical samples. Psychother Psych Med 55, 266-277. (Pubitemid 40769837)
19. Eaton, W. W. (2008): Population-based study of first onset and chronicity in major depressive disorder. Arch Gen Psychiatry 65, 513-520.
20. Ekers, D., Richards, D., Gilbody, S. (2008): A meta-analysis of randomized trials of behavioural treatment of depression. Psychol Med 38, 611-623. (Pubitemid 351483232)
21. Fava, G. A., Grandi, S., Zielezny, M., Raffanelli, C., Canestrari, R. (1996): Four-year outcome for cognitive behavioural treatment of residual symptoms in major depression. Am J Psychiatry 153, 945-947. (Pubitemid 26225469)
22. Fava, G. A., Ruini, C., Rafanelli, C., Finos, L., Conti, S., Grandi, S. (2004): Six-year outcome of cognitive behaviour therapy for prevention of recurrent depression. Am J Psychiatry 161, 1872-1876. (Pubitemid 39314682)
23. Fava, G. A., Ruini, C., Belaise, C. (2007): The concept of recovery in major depression. Psychol Med 37, 307-317.
24. Fitzmaurice, G. M., Laird, N.M., Ware, J. H. (2004): Applied longitudinal analysis. New York: John Wiley and Sons.
25. Frank, E., Kupfer, D. J., Perel, J. M., Cornes, C., Jarrett, D. B., Mallinger, A. G., Thase, M. E., McEachran, A. B., Grochocinski, V. J. (1990): Three-year outcomes for maintenance therapies in recurrent depression. Arch Gen Psychiatry 47, 1093-1099.
26. Franke, G. (1995): Die Symptom-Checkliste von Derogatis. Deutsche Version. Manual [The symptom-checklist of Derogatis. German version.Manual]. Goettingen: Beltz.
27. Freud, S. (1914/1967): Erinnern, Wiederholen und Durcharbeiten. Sigmund Freund: Gesammelte Werke, Frankfurt a. M.: S. Fischer.
28. Fydrich, T., Geyer, M., Hessel, A., Sommer, G., Brähler, E. (1999): Social Support Questionnaire (F-SozU): norms of a representative sample. Diagnostica 45, 212-216.
29. Godwin, M., Ruhland, L., Casson, I., MacDonald, S., Delva, D., Birtwhistle, R., Lam, M., Seguin, R. (2003): Pragmatic controlled clinical trials in primary care: the struggle between external and internal validity. BMC Medical Research Methodology 3, 28.
30. Grande, T., Dilg, R., Jakobsen, T., Keller, W., Krawietz, B., Langer, M., Oberbracht, C., Stehle, S., Stennes, M., Rudolf, G. (2006): Differential effects of two forms of psychoanalytic therapy: results of the Heidelberg-Berlin study. Psychotherapy Research 18, 470-485. (Pubitemid 43932031)
31. Grande, T., Dilg, R., Jakobsen, T., Keller, W., Krawietz, B., Langer, M., Oberbracht, C., Stehle, S., Stennes, M., Rudolf, G. (2009): Structural change as a predictor of long-term follow-up outcome. Psychotherapy Research 19, 344-357.
32. Greenson, R. R. (1965): The problem of working through. In: Schur, M. (Editor): Drives, affects, and behaviour. New York: International Universities Press.
33. Hautzinger, M., Bailer, M., Worall, H., Keller, F. (1994): Beck-Depressions-Inventar (BDI) [Beck Depression Inventory]. Bern, Goettingen, Toronto, Seattle: Huber.
34. Henry, W. P., Schacht, T. E., Strupp, H. H. (1990): Patient and therapist introject, interpersonal process, and differential psychotherapy outcome. J Consult Clin Psychol 58, 768-774.
35. Hiller, W., Dichtl, G., Hecht, H., Hundt, W., Mombour, W., von Zeerssen, D. (1994): Evaluating the new ICD-10 categories of depressive episode and recurrent depressive disorder. J Affect Disord 31, 49-60. (Pubitemid 24158033)
36. Hiller, W., Zaudig, M., Mombour, W. (1995): IDCL - International Diagnostic Checklists for ICD-10 and DSM-IV (Manual and 32 checklists as part of the WHO ICD-10-Checklists package). Bern: Huber.
37. Hollon, S. D., Stewart, M. O., Strunk, D. (2006): Enduring effects for cognitive behaviour therapy in the treatment of depression and anxiety. Annu Rev Psychol 57, 285-315. (Pubitemid 43237234)
38. Horowitz, L. M., Rosenberg, S. E., Baer, B. A., Ureno, G., Villasenor, G. (1988): Inventory of Interpersonal Problems: psychometric properties and clinical applications. J Consult Clin Psychol 56, 885-892.
39. Horowitz, L. M., Strauß, B., Kordy, H. (2000): Inventar zur Erfassung Interpersoneller Probleme [Inventory of Interpersonal Problems].Weinheim: Beltz.
40. Huber, D., Henrich, G., Klug, G. (2007): The Inventory of Interpersonal Problems (IIP): sensitivity to change. Psychotherapy Research 17, 474-481. (Pubitemid 46930280)
41. Huber, D.,Henrich, G., Gastner, J., Klug, G. (2012):Must all have prices? TheMunich Psychotherapy Study. In: Ablon, J. S., Levy, R., Kaechele, H. (Editors): Evidence based psychodynamic psychotherapy. New York: Humana Press.
42. Jakobsen, T., Rudolf, G., Brockmann, J., Eckert, J., Huber, D., Klug, G., Grande, T., Keller, W., Staats, H., Leichsenring, F. (2007): Results of psychoanalytic long-term therapy in specific diagnostic groups: improvement in symptoms and interpersonal relationships. Z Psychosom Med Psychother 53, 87-110. (Pubitemid 47014113)
43. Jones, E. E. (2000): Therapeutic action. A guide to psychoanalytic therapy. Northvale, N. J., London: Jason Aronson.
44. Judd, L. L. (1997): The clinical course of unipolar major depressive disorders. Arch Gen Psychiatry 54, 989-991.
45. Kazdin, A. E. (2007): Mediators and mechanisms of change in psychotherapy research. Annu Rev Clin Psychol 3, 1-27.
46. Keller, M. B., Shapiro, R. W. (1981): Major depressive disorder: initial results from a one-year prospective naturalistic follow-up study. J Nerv Ment Dis 169, 761-768. (Pubitemid 12216093)
47. Keller, M. B., Lavori, P. W., Mueller, T. I., Endicott, J., Hirschfeld, R. M., Shea, T. (1992): Time to recovery, chronicity, and levels of psychopathology in major depression: a 5-year prospective follow-up of 431 subjects. Arch Gen Psychiatry 49, 809-816.
48. Keller, M. B., Hirschfeld, R. M. A., Hanks, D. (1997): Double depression: a distinctive subtype of unipolar depression. J Affect Disord 45, 65-73. (Pubitemid 27357464)
49. Knekt, P., Lindfors, O., Härkänen, T., Välikoski, M., Virtala, E., Laaksonen,M. A.,Marttunen, M., Kaipainen, M., Renlund, C., and the Helsinki Study Group (2008): Randomized trial on the effectiveness of long- and short-term psychotherapy and solution-focused therapy on psychiatric symptoms during a 3-year follow-up. Psychol Med 38, 689-703. (Pubitemid 351483233)
50. Knekt, P., Lindfors, O., Laaksonen, M. A., Renlund, C., Haaramo, P., Härkänen, T., Virtala, E., and the Helsinki Psychotherapy Study Group (2011): Quasi-experimental study on the effectiveness of psychoanalysis, long-term and short-term psychotherapy on psychiatric symptoms, work ability and functional capacity during a 5-year follow-up. J Affect Disord 132, 37-47.
51. Koppers, D., Peen, J., Niekerken, S., Van, R., Dekker, J. (2011): Prevalence and risk factors for recurrence of depression five years after short term psychodynamic treatment. J Affect Disord 134, 468-472.
52. Kopta, S. M., Howard, K. I., Lowry, J. L., Beutler, L. E. (1994): Patterns of symptom recovery in psychotherapy. J Consult Clin Psychol 62, 1009-1016.
53. Lambert, M. J., Ogles, B. M. (2004): The efficacy and effectiveness of psychotherapy. In: Lambert, M. (Editor): Handbook of psychotherapy and behaviour change, p. 139-193. New York: Wiley.
54. Leichsenring, F., Rabung, S. (2008): Effectiveness of long-term psychodynamic psychotherapy: a meta-analysis. JAMA 300, 1551-1565.
55. Leichsenring, F., Rabung, S. (2011): Long-term psychodynamic psychotherapy in complex mental disorders: update of a meta-analysis. B J Psychiatry 199, 15-22.
56. Leuzinger-Bohleber, M., Stuhr, U., Rueger, B., Beutel, M. (2003): How to study the "quality of psychoanalytic treatments" and their long-term effects on patients' well-being. Int J Psychoanal 84, 263-290. (Pubitemid 36519252)
57. Lynch, D., Laws, K. R., McKenna, P. J. (2010): Cognitive behavioural therapy for major psychiatric disorder: does it reallywork? A meta-analytical review of well-controlled trials. Psychol Med 40, 9-24.
58. Oremland, J. D. (1991): Interpretation and interaction: psychoanalysis or psychotherapy? Hillsdale, NJ:, London: The Analytic Press.
59. Paykel, E. S., Scott, J., Cornwall, P. L., Abbott, R., Crane, C., Pope, M., Johnson, A. I. (2005): Duration of relapse prevention after cognitive therapy in residual depression: follow-up of controlled trial. Psychol Med 35, 59-68. (Pubitemid 40201916)
60. Puschner, B., Kraft, S., Kaechele, H., Kordy, H. (2007): Course of improvement over 2 years in psychoanalytic and psychodynamic outpatient psychotherapy. Psychol Psychother 80, 51-68. (Pubitemid 46493229)
61. Roth, A., Fonagy, P. (2005): What works for whom? New York, London: Guilford.
62. Scher, C. D., Ingram, R. E., Segal, Z. V. (2005): Cognitive reactivity and vulnerability: empirical evaluation of construct activation and cognitive diatheses in unipolar depression. Clin Psychol Rev 25, 487-510. (Pubitemid 40725816)
63. Seeds, P. M., Dozois, D. J. A. (2010): Prospective evaluation of a cognitive vulnerability-stress model for depression: the interaction of schema self-structures and negative life events. J Clin Psychol 66, 1307-1323.
64. Segal, Z. V. (1988): Appraisal of self-schema construct in cognitive models of depression. Psychol Bull 103, 147-162.
65. Segal, Z. V., Gemar, M., Williams, S. (1999): Differential cognitive response to a mood challenge following successful cognitive therapy or pharmacotherapy for unipolar depression. J Abnorm Psychol 108, 3-10. (Pubitemid 29108305)
66. Segal, Z. V., Kennedy, S., Gemar, M., Hood, K., Pedersen, R., Buis,T. (2006): Cognitive reactivity to sad mood provocation and the prediction of depressive relapse. Arch Gen Psychiatry 63, 749-755.
67. Shea, M. T., Elkin, E., Imber, S., Sotsky, S. M., Watkins, J. T., Collins, J. F., Pilkonis, P. A., Beckham, E., Glass, D. R., Dolan, R. T., Parloff, M. B. (1992): Course of depressive symptoms over follow-up. Arch Gen Psychiatry 49, 782-787.
68. Sommer, G., Fydrich, T. (1991): Development and evaluation of a questionnaire for social support. Diagnostica 37, 160-178.
69. Taylor, D. J., Walters, H. M., Vittengl, J. R., Krebaum, S., Jarrett, R. B. (2010):Which depressive symptoms remain after response to cognitive therapy of depression and predict relapse and recurrence? J Affect Disord 123, 181-187.
70. ten Doesschate, M. C., Bockting, C., Koeter, M.W.J., Schene, A. H., and the DELTA group (2010): Prediction of recurrence in recurrent depression: a 5,5 year prospective study. J Clin Psychiat 71, 984-991.
71. Thorpe, K. E., Zwarenstein, M., Oxman, A.D., Treweek, S., Furberg, C.D., Altman, D. G., Tunis, S., Bergel, E., Harvey, I., Magid, D. J., Chalkidou, K. (2009): A pragmatic-explanatory continuum indicator summary (PRECIS): a tool to help trial designers. J Clin Epidemiol 62, 464-475.
72. Tress, W. (1993): INTREX-Kurzform-Fragebogen: Formulare, Itemformulierungen, und Fragestellungen. In: Tress, W. (Editor): SASB - Die strukturale Analyse sozialen Verhaltens, p. 259-263. Heidelberg: Asanger.
73. Tunis, S. R., Stryer, D. B., Clancy, C. M. (2003): Practical clinical trials: increasing the value of clinical research for decision making in clinical and health policy. JAMA 24, 1624-1632. (Pubitemid 37430387)
74. Uestuen, T. B., Ayuso-Mateos, J. L., Chatterji, S., Mathers, C., Murray, C. J. (2004): Global burden of depressive disorders in the year 2000. B J Psychiatry 184, 386-392. (Pubitemid 38624764)
75. Vittengl, J. R., Clark, L. A., Jarrett, D. B. (2003): Interpersonal problems, personality pathology, and social adjustment after cognitive therapy for depression. Psychological Assessment 15, 29-40. (Pubitemid 36314924)
76. Vittengl, J. R., Clark, L. A., Jarrett, R. B. (2004): Improvement in social-interpersonal functioning after cognitive therapy for recurrent depression. Psychol Med 34, 643-658. (Pubitemid 38735459)
77. Vittengl, J. R., Clark, L. A., Jarrett, R. B. (2009a): Deterioration in psychosocial functioning predicts relapse/recurrence after cognitive therapy for depression. J Affect Disord 112, 135-143.
78. Vittengl, J. R., Clark, L. A., Jarrett,R. B. (2009b): Continuation-phase cognitive therapy's effects on remission and recovery from depression. J Consult Clin Psychol 77, 367-371.
79. Wallerstein, R. S. (1986): Forty-two lives in treatment. New York: Guilford.
80. Wells, K., Sherbourne, C., Schoenbaum, M., Ettner, S., Duan, N., Miranda, J., Unuetzer, J., Rubenstein, L. (2004): Five-year impact of quality improvement for depression: results of a group-level randomized controlled trial. Arch Gen Psychiatry 61, 378-386. (Pubitemid 38451547)
81. WHO (1993): The ICD-10 Classification of mental and behavioural disorders: Diagnostic criteria for research. Geneva: World Health Organization.
82. Williams, J. W., Noel, P. H., Cordes, J. A., Ramirez, G., Pignone, M. (2002): Is this patient clinically depressed? JAMA 287, 1160-1170. (Pubitemid 34252086)
83. Wittchen, H.-U. (1988): Zum Spontanverlauf unbehandelter Fälle mit Angststörungen bzw. Depressionen. In: Wittchen, H.-U., von Zeerssen, D. (Editors): Verläufe behandelter und unbehandelterDepressionen und Angststörungen, S. 252-284.Berlin,Heidelberg: Springer-Verlag.