A maturity model formanagement control systems: Five evolutionary steps to guide development

Business and Information Systems Engineering

Volumn 4, Issue 4, 2012, Pages 193-207

  Marx, Frederik ^a   Wortmann, Felix ^a   Mayer, Jörg H ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF ST GALLEN   (Switzerland)

Author keywords

Business intelligence; Corporate management; Design science; Management accounting; Management control systems; Maturity models

Indexed keywords

EID: 84869464519     PISSN: None     EISSN: 18670202     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1007/s12599-012-0220-x     Document Type: Article

References (94)

1. Ahern DM, Clouse A, Turner R (2003) CMMI distilled: a practical introduction to integrated process improvement, 2nd edn. Addison-Wesley, Boston
2. Ahlemann F, Schroeder C, Teuteberg F (2005) Kompetenz- und Reifegradmodelle für das Projektmanagement - Grundlagen, Vergleich und Einsatz. ISPRI-Arbeitsbericht No. 01/2005, Osnabrück
3. Aho M (2009) A capability maturity model for corporate performance management - an empirical study in large Finnish manufacturing companies. In: eBRF - a research forum to understand business in knowledge society, Jyväskylä
4. Alter S (2003) 18 reasons why IT-reliant work systems should replace "the IT artifact" as the core subject matter of the IS field. Communications of the Association for Information Systems 12(23):366-395
5. Ansoff HI (1980) Strategic issuemanagement. Strategic Management Journal 1(2):131-148
6. Anthony RN, Govindarajan V (2007) Management control systems, 12th edn. McGraw-Hill/Irwin, New York
7. Arveson P, Rohm H,Wilsey D, Perry G, Halbach L, DeCarlo J (2010) The strategic management maturity model. Balanced Scorecard Institute, Cary
8. Baars H, Kemper HG (2008) Management support with structured and unstructured data - an integrated business intelligence framework. Information Systems Management 25(2):132-148
9. Bange C, Dahnken O, Friedrich D (2008) Planung und Budgetierung in europäischen Unternehmen: Konzepte, Lösungen und Potenzial von Performance Management. BARC, Würzburg
10. Becker J, Knackstedt R, Pöppelbuß J (2009) Developing maturity models for IT management - a procedure model and its application. Business & Information Systems Engineering 1(3):13-222
11. Becker J, Niehaves B, Pöppelbuss J, Simons SA (2010) Maturity models in IS research. In: 18th European conference on information systems (ECIS 2010), Pretoria
12. Biberoglu E, Haddad H (2002) A survey of industrial experiences with CMM and the teaching ofCMMpractices. Journal of Computing Sciences in Colleges 18(2):143-152
13. Bond TG, Fox CM (2007) Applying the Rasch model. Fundamental measurement in the human sciences, 2nd edn. Erlbaum, Mahwah
14. Bostrom RP, Heinen S (1977) MIS problems and failures - a socio-technical perspective. Part I. The causes. Management Information Systems Quarterly 1(3):17-32
15. Burns J, Vaivio J (2001)Management accounting change. Management Accounting Research 12:389-402 (Pubitemid 33381029)
16. Capgemini (2008) CFO Agenda 2008: Dimensionen einer erfolgreichen Strategie. Capgemini
17. Clark TD Jr, Jones MC, Armstrong CP (2007) The dynamic structure of management support systems: theory development, research focus, and direction. Management Information Systems Quarterly 31(3):579-615 (Pubitemid 47359825)
18. Cooper P, Dart E (2009) Change in the management accountant's role: drivers and diversity. University of Bath, School of Management, Bath
19. Daum JH (2008) Die Entwicklung der Rolle des CFO in europäischen Unternehmen. Zeitschrift für Controlling und Management 52(6):387-393
20. Davenport TH (2006) Competing on analytics. Harvard Business Review 84(1):98-107
21. Davila A, Foster G (2005) Management accounting systems adoption decisions: evidence and performance implications from early-stage/startup companies. The Accounting Review 80(4):1039-1068 (Pubitemid 41650935)
22. de Bruin T, Rosemann M, Freeze R, Kulkarni U (2005) Understanding the main phases of developing a maturity assessment model. In: 16th Australasian conference on information systems (ACIS 2005). Sydney
23. Dekleva S, Drehmer D (1997) Measuring software engineering evolution: a Rasch calibration. Information Systems Research 8(1):95-104
24. Eckerson WW (2010) Transforming finance - how CFOs use business intelligence to turn finance from record keepers to strategic advisors. TDWI Research, Renton
25. Ernstberger J, Vogler O (2008) Analyzing the German accounting triad - "accounting premium" for IAS/IFRS and U.S. GAAP vis-avis German GAAP. The International Journal of Accounting 43:339-386
26. Esch D, Ganczarski W, Gohr V, Padberg J (2008) Serviceorientierte Strukturen zur Unterstützung eines integrierten Konzernrechnungswesens - Exemplarisches Integrationsmodell für einen Telekommunikationskonzern. Zeitschrift für Controlling und Management (Sonderheft Unternehmenssteuerungssysteme) 52:92-99
27. Frank U (2000) Evaluation von Artefakten in der Wirtschaftsinformatik. In: Heinrich LJ, Häntschel I (eds) Evaluation und Evaluationsforschung in der Wirtschaftsinformatik - Handbuch für Praxis, Lehre und Forschung. Oldenbourg, München, pp 35-48
28. Fraser P, Moultrie J, Gregory M (2002) The use of maturity models/grids as a tool in assessing product development capability. In: IEEE international engineering management conference (IEMC 2002). IEEE Engineering Management Society, Cambridge, pp 244-249 (Pubitemid 35413211)
29. Frezatti F, Aguiar AB, Guerreiro R, Gouvea MA (2009) Does management accounting play role in planning process? Journal of Business Research 64(3):242-249. http://majmavaredat.com/media/file/english/ Does%20management%20accounting%20play%20role%20in%20planning%20process.pdf. Accessed 2012-05-20
30. Friedl B (2002) Controlling. UTB, Stuttgart
31. Fuchs C, Bange C (2010) Softwarewerkzeuge für die Finanzkonsolidierung: 19 Systeme für die legale Konsolidierung und Managementkonsolidierung. BARC,Würzburg
32. Gartner Inc (2010) Magic quadrant for business intelligence platforms. http://www.gartner.com/technology/media-products/reprints/oracle/article121/ article121.html. Accessed 2010-05-30
33. Gleich R, Greiner O, Hofmannn S (2006) Better, Advanced and Beyond Bugeting: Von der Evolution zur Revolution. In: Gleich R, Hofmann S, Leyk J (eds) Planungs- und Budgetierungsinstrumente: Innovative Ansätze und Best-Practice für den Managementprozess. Haufe, Freiburg, pp 23-38
34. Gluck FW, Kaufmann SP, Walleck SA (1980) Strategic management for competitive advantage. Harvard Business Review 58:154-161
35. Hahn D, Taylor B (2006) Vorwort. In: Hahn D, Taylor B (eds) Strategische Unternehmensplanung - Strategische Unternehmensführung, 9th edn. Springer, Berlin, pp XI-XIV
36. Hansen SC, Van der Stede WA (2003) Multiple facets of budgeting: an explanatory analysis. Management Accounting Research 15:415-439
37. Hevner AR, Chatterjee S (2010) Design research in information systems - theory and practice. Springer, New York
38. Hevner AR, March T, Park J, Ram S (2004) Design science in information systems research. Management Information Systems Quarterly 28(1):75-105
39. Horváth P (2006) Controlling, 10th edn. Vahlen, München
40. Kammer K (2005) Reporting internationaler Unternehmen - Auswirkungen der Harmonisierung und der Konvergenz des Rechnungswesens in Europa. Gabler, Wiesbaden
41. Kaplan RS (1990) The four-stagemodel of cost systems design. Management Accounting 71(8):22-26
42. Kaplan RS, Norton DP (1996) The balanced scorecard: translating strategy into action. Harvard Business School Press, Boston
43. Kaplan RS, Norton DP (2004) How strategy maps frame an organization's objectives. Financial Executive 20(2):40-45
44. Krönke B,Marx F (2008) Organisatorische Veränderungen als Problemstellung des Corporate Controllings bei der Continental AG. Zeitschrift für Controlling und Management (Sonderheft Unternehmenssteuerungssysteme) 52:84-90
45. Lahrmann G, Marx F, Winter R, Wortmann F (2010) Business intelligence maturity models: an overview. In: D'Atri A, Ferrara M, George JF, Spagnoletti P (eds) VII conference of the Italian chapter of AIS (itAIS 2010). Italian chapter of AIS, Naples
46. Lahrmann G,Marx F,Mettler T,Winter R,Wortmann F (2011) Inductive design of maturity models: applying the Rasch algorithm for design science research. In: Jain H, Sinha AP, Vitharana P (eds) Desrist 2011. Springer, Milwaukee
47. Levie J, Lichtenstein BB (2009) Final assessment of stages theory: introducing a dynamic states approach to entrepreneurship. College of Management working Papers http://scholarworks.umb.edu/management-wp/17. Accessed 2011-07-15
48. Machin JL (1995) Management control system: whence and whither? In: Emmanuel C, Otley D, Merchant KA (eds) Readings in accounting for management control. Chapman & Hall, London, pp 9-27
49. Malmi T, Brown DA (2008) Management control systems as a package - opportunities, challenges and research directions. Management Accounting Research 19:287-300
50. March ST, Smith GF (1995) Design and natural science research on information technology. Decision Support Systems 15(4):251-266
51. Marx F, Lahrmann G,Winter R (2010) Aligning corporate planning and BI: towards a combined maturity model. In: D'Atri A, Ferrara M, George JF, Spagnoletti P (eds) 7th conference of the Italian chapter of AIS (itAIS 2010), Naples
52. Mayer JH, Stock D (2011) Nutzertypen für die situative FIS-Gestaltung: Ergebnisse einer empirischen Untersuchung. In: 10th international conference onWirtschaftsinformatik, Zurich
53. McRoberts HA, Sloan BC (1998) Financial management capability model. International Journal of Government Auditing 25(3):8-11
54. Mettler T, Rohner P (2009) Situational maturity models as instrumental artifacts for organizational design. In: 4th international conference on design science research in information systems and technology, Philadelphia
55. Mettler T, Rohner P, Winter R (2009) Towards a classification of maturity models in information systems. In: 6th conference of the Italian chapter of AIS, Costa Smeralda
56. Moores K, Yuen S (2001) Management accounting systems and organizational configuration: a lifecycle perspective accounting. Accounting, Organizations and Society 26:351-389 (Pubitemid 33377408)
57. National-Audit-Office (2010) Financial management maturity model. http://www.nao.org.uk/help-for-public-services/financial-management/fmmm.aspx. Accessed 2011-02-14
58. Nilsson F, Olve NG (2001) Control systems in multibusiness companies: from performance management to strategic management. European Management Journal 19(4):344-358 (Pubitemid 33619727)
59. Nolan RL (1973) Managing the computer resource: a stage hypothesis. Communications of the ACM 16(7):399-405
60. Oehler K (2006) Planung und Budgetierung: (Neue) Anforderungen an die Softwareunterstützung. In: Gleich R, Hofmann S, Leyk J (eds) Planungs- und Budgetierungsinstrumente. Rudolf Haufe Verlag, Freiburg, pp 93-120
61. Otley DT (1999) Performance management: a framework for management control systems research. Management Accounting Research 10:363-382
62. Paulk MC, Curtis B, Chrissis MB, Weber CV (1993) Capability maturity model, Version 1.1. IEEE Software 10(4):18-27
63. Pöppelbuß J, Röglinger M (2011) What makes a useful maturity model? A framework of general design principles for maturity models and its demonstration in business process management. In: Proc 19th European conference on information systems (ECIS 2011), Helsinki
64. Pfitzmayer KH (2005) Prozessoptimierung im Rechnungswesen - mit Re-Engineering Transaktions- und Abschlussprozesse optimieren. Gabler, Wiesbaden
65. Plattner H (2009) A common database approach for OLTP and OLAP using an inmemory column database. In: Binnig C, Dageville B (eds) Proc 35th SIGMOD international conference on management of data (SIGMOD '09), New York
66. Rayner N, Schlegel K (2008) Maturity model overview for business intelligence and performance management. Gartner, Stamford
67. Ribaudo B, Gimpert J, Borelli R (2010) Reducing financial reporting risk: it is more than fixing financial controls. Deloitte
68. Rickards R (2008) An endless debate: the sense and nonsense of budgeting. International Journal of Productivity and Performance Management 57(7):569-592
69. Rieg R (2008) Planung und Budgetierung - Was wirklich funktioniert. Gabler, Wiesbaden
70. Rom A, Rohde C (2007) Management accounting and integrated information systems: a literature review. International Journal of Accounting Information Systems 8:40-68
71. Rönkkö M, Järvi A, Mäkelä MM (2008) Measuring and comparing the adoption of software practices in the software product industry. In: International conference on software process (ICSP2008), Leipzig
72. Rosemann M, De Bruin T (2005) Towards a business process management maturity model. In: 13th European conference on information systems (ECIS2005), Regensburg
73. Samuelson PA (1983) Foundations of economic analysis. Harvard University Press, Cambridge
74. Schäffer U (2007) Management accounting & control scales handbook. Gabler, Wiesbaden
75. Schelp J, Winter R (2007) Integration management for heterogeneous information systems. In: Desouza KC (ed) Agile information systems - conceptualizations, construction, and management. Butterworth-Heinemann, Oxford, pp 134-149
76. Seal W (2010) Managerial discourse and the link between theory and practice: from ROI to value-based management.Management Accounting Research 21(2):95-109
77. Seeley M, Targett D (1999) Patterns of senior executives' personal use of computers. Information & Management 35:315-330 (Pubitemid 129523516)
78. Sheikh G, Kracklauer S, Michel J (2010) The CFO agenda: finances top issues in 2010. The Hackett Group Inc
79. Shilakes C, Tylman J (1998) Enterprise information portals. Merrill Lynch Inc, New York
80. Simons R (1994) How top managers use control systems as levers of strategic renewal. Strategic Management Journal 15:169-189
81. Simpson JA, Weiner ECS (1989) The Oxford English dictionary, 2nd edn. Oxford University Press, Oxford
82. Stern JM, Shiely JS (2001) The EVA challenge. Wiley, New York
83. Thiruvenkatachari S, Kartick R (2009) Corporate performance management - maturity model approach. Satyam
84. Tremblay MC, Hevner AR, Berndt DJ (2010) Focus groups for artifact refinement and evaluation in design research. Communications of the Association for Information Systems 26(27):599-618
85. van der Walt PW, du Troit ASA (2007) Developing a scaleable information architecture for an enterprise-wide consolidated information management platform. Aslib Proceedings New Information Perspectives 59(1):08-96
86. van Steenbergen M, Bos R, Brinkkemper S, van de Weerd I, Bekkers W (2010) The design of focus area maturity models. In: 5th international conference on design science research in information systems and technology (DESRIST 2010), St Gallen
87. vom Brocke J, Simons A, Niehaves B, Riemer K, Plattfaut R, Cleven A (2009) Reconstructing the giant: on the importance of rigour in documenting the literature search process. In: Newell S, Whitley E, Pouloudi N, Wareham J, Mathiassen L (eds) 17th European conference on information systems, Verona, pp 2206-2217
88. Wagner C (2004) Enterprise strategy management systems: current and next generation. Journal of Strategic Information Systems 13(2):105-128
89. Webster J, Watson RT (2002) Analyzing the past to prepare for the future: writing a literature review. Management Information Systems Quarterly 26(2):13-23
90. Weisberg M (2007) Performance managementmaturitymodel methodology. http://www.lumeninc.com/Maturity/. Accessed 2011-02-14
91. Wettstein T, Kueng P (2002) Amaturitymodel for performance measurement systems. Fribourg
92. Woods M (2007) Linking risk management to strategic control: a case study of Tesco plc. International Journal of Risk Assessment and Management 7(8):1074-1088
93. WixomB,Watson H (2010) The BI-based organization. International Journal of Business Intelligence Research 1(1):13-28
94. Wright T (2010) Technology trends CFOs must know. Financial Executive 26(5):65-66