A critical assessment of the Hapke photometric model

Journal of Quantitative Spectroscopy and Radiative Transfer

Volumn 113, Issue 18, 2012, Pages 2431-2456

  Shkuratov, Y ^a,b   Kaydash, V ^a   Korokhin, V ^a   Velikodsky, Y ^a   Petrov, D ^a   Zubko, E ^a,c   Stankevich, D ^a   Videen, G ^d,e  

^a V N KARAZIN KHARKIV NATIONAL UNIVERSITY   (Ukraine)

^b INSTITUTE OF RADIO ASTRONOMY   (Ukraine)

^c UNIVERSITY OF HELSINKI   (Finland)

^d Center for Exoplanetary Systems   (United States)

^e U S ARMY RESEARCH LABORATORY   (United States)

Author keywords

Hapke model; Lunar photometry; Photometry

Indexed keywords

AZIMUTH ANGLES; AZIMUTHAL DEPENDENCE; CELESTIAL BODIES; CLEMENTINE; CRITICAL ASSESSMENT; HAPKE MODEL; LUNAR SAMPLES; LUNAR SURFACE; MODEL PARAMETERS; NIR CAMERA; PHASE ANGLES; PHASE FUNCTIONS; PHOTOMETRIC MEASUREMENTS; POWDERED SAMPLES; SINGLE SCATTERING; TWO WAVELENGTH;

ANISOTROPY; BACKSCATTERING; COMPUTER SIMULATION; MOON; MULTIPLE SCATTERING;

PHOTOMETRY;

ALBEDO; BACKSCATTER; LABORATORY METHOD; LIGHT EFFECT; MODEL TEST; MODEL VALIDATION; MOON; NUMERICAL MODEL; PARAMETERIZATION; PHOTOMETER; PLANETARY ATMOSPHERE; RAY TRACING;

CITRUS RETICULATA;

EID: 84868190967     PISSN: 00224073     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.jqsrt.2012.04.010     Document Type: Article

References (112)

1. Lumme K., Penttilä A. Light scattering by dust particles in the solar system: applications to cometary comae and planetary regoliths. J Quant Spectrosc Radiat Transfer 2011, 112(11):1658-1670.
2. Maignana F., Breon F.-M., Lacaze R. Bidirectional reflectance of Earth targets: evaluation of analytical models using a large set of spaceborne measurements with emphasis on the hot spot. Remote Sens Environ 2004, 90:210-220.
3. Hapke B. A theoretical photometric function for the lunar surface. J Geophys Res 1963, 68:4571-4586.
4. Hapke B. An improved theoretical lunar photometric function. Astron J 1966, 71(5):333-339.
5. Hapke B. Bidirectional reflectance spectroscopy. 1. Theory. J Geophys Res 1981, 86(B4):3039-3054.
6. Hapke B. Bidirectional reflectance spectroscopy: 3. Correction for macroscopic roughness. Icarus 1984, 59:41-59.
7. Hapke B. Bidirectional reflectance spectroscopy. 4. The extinction coefficient and the opposition effect. Icarus 1986, 67:264-280.
8. Hapke B. Theory of Reflectance and Emittance Spectroscopy 1993, Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge, 450 p.
9. Hapke B. Bidirectional reflectance spectroscopy. 5. The coherent backscatter opposition effect and anisotropic scattering. Icarus 2002, 157:523-534.
10. Hapke B. Bidirectional reflectance spectroscopy 6. Effects of porosity. Icarus 2008, 195:918-926.
11. Irvine W.M. The shadowing effect in diffuse reflection. J Geophys Res 1966, 71:2931-2937.
12. Lumme K., Bowell E. Radiative transfer in the surfaces of atmosphereless bodies. I. Theory. Astron J 1981, 86(11):1694-1704.
13. Shkuratov Y.G. The shadow-hiding component of brightness phase curves of atmosphereless celestial bodies. Kinematics Phys Celestial Bodies 1988, 4(5):60-66. In Russian.
14. Shkuratov Y.G., Helfenstein P. The opposition effect and the quasi-fractal structure of regolith: I. Theory. Icarus 2001, 152:96-116.
15. Hillier J.K. Shadow-hiding opposition surge for a two-layer surface. Icarus 1997, 128:15-27.
16. Shunlin Liang, Townshend J.R. A modified Hapke model for soil bidirectional reflectance. Remote Sens Environ 1996, 55:1-10.
17. Yang G.-J., Zhao C.-J., Huang W.-J., Wang J.-H. Extension of the Hapke bidirectional reflectance model to retrieve soil water content. Hydrol Earth Syst Sci 2011, 15:2317-2326.
18. Helfenstein P., Shepard M. Testing the Hapke photometric model: improved inversion and the porosity correction. Icarus 2011, 215(1):83-100.
19. Souchon A.L., Pinet P.C., Chevrel S.D., Daydou Y.H., Baratoux D., Kurita K., Shepard M.K., Helfenstein P. An experimental study of Hapke's modeling of natural granular surface samples. Icarus 2011, 215:313-331.
20. Dhingra D., Mustard J.F., Wiseman S., Pariente M., Pieters C.M., Isaacson P.J. Non-linearspectral un-mixing using Hapke modeling: application to acquired M3 spectra of spinel bearing lithologies on the Moon. Lunar Planet Sci Conf 42-nd 2011, 2431. pdf.
21. Li Shuai, Li Lin Radiative transfer modeling for quantifying lunar surface minerals, particle size, and submicroscopic metallic Fe. J Geophys Res 2011, 116. 10.1029/2011JE003837.
22. Mishchenko M.I. Multiple scattering, radiative transfer, and weak localization in discrete random media: unified microphysical approach. Rev Geophys 2008, 46:RG2003.
23. Mishchenko M.I., Dlugach J.M., Yanovitskij E.G., Zakharova N.T. Bidirectional reflectance of flat, optically thick particulate layers: an efficient radiative transfer solution and applications to snow and soil surfaces. J Quant Spectrosc Radiat Transfer 1999, 63:409-432.
24. Mishchenko M.I. Polarization effects in weak localization of light: calculation of the copolarized and depolarized backscattering enhancement factors. Phys Rev 1991, B44(22):597-600. 12.
25. Hapke B. Are planetary regolith particles back scattering? Response to a paper by M. Mishchenko. J Quant Spectrosc Radiat Transfer 1996, 55(6):837-848.
26. Hapke B. Scattering and diffraction of light by particles in planetary regoliths. J Quant Spectrosc Radiat Transfer 1999, 61:565-581.
27. Mishchenko M.I. Asymmetry parameters of the phase function for densely packed scattering grains. J Quant Spectrosc Radiat Transfer 1994, 52(1):95-110.
28. Mishchenko M.I., Macke A. Asymmetry parameters of the phase function for isolated and densely packed spherical particles with multiple internal inclusions in the geometric optics limit. J Quant Spectrosc Radiat Transfer 1997, 57(6):767-771.
29. Hapke B., Shepard M., Nelson R., Smythe W., Piatek J. A quantitative test of the ability of models based on the equation of radiative transfer to predict the bidirectional reflectance of a well-characterized medium. Icarus 2009, 199:210-218.
30. Zhang H., Voss K.J. Comparisons of bidirectional reflectance distribution function measurements on prepared particulate surfaces and radiative-transfer models. Appl Opt 2005 2005, 44(4):597-610.
31. Zhang H., Voss K.J. On Hapke photometric model predictions on reflectance of closely packed particulate surfaces. Icarus 2011, 215:27-33.
32. Zubko E., Shkuratov Y., Mishchenko M., Videen G. Light scattering in a finite multi-particle system. J Quant Spectrosc Radiat Transfer 2008, 109:2195-2206.
33. Penttila A., Zubko E., Lumme K., Muinonen K., Yurkin M., Draine B., Rahola J., Hoekstra A., Shkuratov Yu Comparison between discrete dipole implementations and exact techniques. J Quant Spectrosc Radiat Transfer 2007, 106:417-436.
34. Grin'ko E.S., Shkuratov Y.G. The scattering matrix of transparent particles of random shape in the geometrical optics approximation. Opt Spectrosc 2002, 93(6):885-893.
35. Stankevich D.G., Shkuratov Y.G. Multiple scattering of light in regolith-like media: geometric optics approximation. Sol Syst Res 2002, 36(5):409-416.
36. Sobolev V.V. Light Scattering in Planetary Atmospheres 1975, Pergamon Press, N.Y, 256 p.
37. Petrov D.V., Shkuratov Y.G. Shadow effect for ambiguous and disconnected random surfaces. Opt Spectrosc 2005, 99(1):146-151.
38. Shkuratov Y.G., Stankevich D.G., Petrov D.V., Pinet P.C., Cord A.M., Daydou Y.H., Chevrel S.D. Interpreting photometry of regolith-like surfaces with different topographies: shadowing and multiple scatter. Icarus 2005, 173:3-15.
39. Hapke B.W. Lumme-Bowell photometric parameters: reality or fantasy?. Bull Am Astron Soc 1982, 14:726.
40. Bowell E., Hapke B., Lumme K., Harris A., Domingue D., Peltoniemi J. Application of photometric models to asteroids. Asteroids II/ 1989, 524-556. Ariz Press, Tucson. R. Binzel. (Ed.).
41. Morozhenko A.V., Yanovitskii E.G. Optical properties of the uppermost layer of the Moon. Astronomicheskii Zhurnal 1971, 48:172-183.
42. Walthall C.L., Norman J.M., Welles J.M., Campbell G., Blad B. Simple equation to approximate the bidirectional reflectance from vegetative canopies and bare soil surfaces. Appl Opt 1985, 24:383-387.
43. Zhang H., Voss K.J., Reid R., Louchard E. Bidirectional reflectance measurements of sediments in the vicinity of Lee Stocking Island, Bahamas. Limnol Oceanogr 2003, 48(1/2):380-389.
44. Nilson T., Kuusk A. A reflectance model for the homogeneous plant canopy and its inversion. Remote Sens Environ 1989, 27:157-167.
45. Yu Shkuratov Diffraction model of the brightness surge of complex structure surfaces. Kinematics Phys Celestial Bodies 1988, 4:33-39.
46. Akkermans E., Wolf P., Maynard R., Maret G. Theoretical study of the coherent backscattering of light by disordered media. J Phys (Fr) 1988, 49(1):77-98.
47. Tishkovets V., Mishchenko M. Approximate calculation of coherent backscattering for semi-infinite discrete random media. J Quant Spectrosc Radiat Transfer 2009, 110:139-145.
48. Etemad S., Thompson R., Andrejko M., John S., MacKintosh F. Weak localization of photons: termination of coherent random walks by absorption and confined geometry. Phys Rev Lett 1987, 59:1420-1423.
49. Hapke B., Nelson R. Comments on "Approximate calculation of coherent backscattering for semi-infinite discrete random media" by Victor P. Tishkovets, and Michael I. Mishchenko. J Quant Spectrosc Radiat Transfer 2010, 111:643-644.
50. Psarev V., Ovcharenko A., Shkuratov Y., Belskaya I., Videen G. Photometry of surfaces with complicated structure at extremely small phase angles. J Quant Spectrosc Radiat Transfer 2007, 106:455-463.
51. Shkuratov Yu, Psarev V, Stankevich D., Ovcharenko A., Videen G. Why the Opposition Spikes of Regolith-Like Media are Usually Sharp and do not Show Rounding off. 12th Conference on Electromagnetic and Light scattering by Nonspherical Particles. June 28-July 02, 2010. Finland, Helsinki Univ. 278-281.
52. Bertolotti J., Vynck K., Wiersma D. Multiple scattering of light in superdiffusive media. Phys Rev Lett 2010, 105:163902.
53. Shkuratov Y., Kreslavsky M., Ovcharenko A., Stankevich D., Zubko E., Pieters C., Arnold G. Opposition effect from Clementine data and mechanisms of backscatter. Icarus 1999, 141:132-155.
54. Shkuratov Y.G. Photometric properties of physical fractals. Opt Spectrosc 1995, 79(1):102-108.
55. Shkuratov Y.G. Fractoids and photometry of solid surfaces of celestial bodies. Sol Syst Res 1995, 29:421-432.
56. Shkuratov Y.G., Petrov D.V., Videen G. Classical photometry of pre-fractal surfaces. J Opt Soc Am 2003, 20(11):2081-2092.
57. Shkuratov Y., Bondarenko S., Kaydash V., Videen G., Munos O., Volten H. Photometry and polarimetry of particulate surfaces and aerosol particles over a wide range of phase angles. J Quant Spectrosc Radiat Transfer 2007, 106:487-508.
58. Goguen J.D., Stone T.C., Kieffer H.H., Buratti B.J. A new look at photometry of the Moon. Icarus 2010, 208:548-557.
59. van Ginneken B., Stavridi M., Koenderink J. Diffuse and specular reflectance from rough surfaces. Appl Opt 1998, 37:130-139.
60. Smith B.G. Geometrical shadowing of a random rough surface. IEEE Trans Antennas Propag 1967, 15:668-671.
61. Shkuratov Y., Stankevich D., Sitko M., Sprague A. Thermal emission indicatrix for rough planetary surfaces at arbitrary heating/observing geometry. Thermal Emission Spectroscopy and Analysis of Dust, Disk, and Regoliths/ 2000, 196:221-230. ASP Conf Series, San Francisco.
62. Stankevich D.G., Shkuratov Y.G., Muinonen K.O., Miloslavskaya O.V. Simulation of shadings in systems of opaque particles. Opt Spectrosc 2000, 88(4):619-622.
63. Stankevich D.G., Shkuratov Y.G. Numerical simulation of multiple lightscattering in layers consisting of opaque particles with a dull surface (geometrical optics approximation. Opt Spectrosc 2002, 92(6):908-914.
64. Stankevich D.G., Shkuratov Y.G. The shadowing effect in regolith-type media: numerical modeling. Sol Syst Res 2000, 34(4):285-294.
65. Stankevich D., Shkuratov Y., Grynko E., Muinonen K. Computer simulation of multiple scattering in random gaussian media. J Quant Spectrosc Radiat Transfer 2003, 76(1):1-16.
66. Stankevich D., Shkuratov Y. Monte Carlo ray-tracing simulation of light scattering in particulate media with optically contrast structure. J Quant Spectrosc Radiat Transfer 2004, 87(3-4):289-296.
67. Muinonen K., Stankevich D., Shkuratov Y., Kaasalainen S., Piironen J. Shadowing effect in clusters of opaque spherical particles. J Quant Spectrosc Radiat Transfer 2001, 70:787-810.
68. Peltoniemi J.I., Lumme K. Light scattering by closely packed particulate media. J Opt Soc Am 1992, A9:1320-1326.
69. Cord A.M., Pinet P.C., Daydou Y.D., Chevrel D.S. Planetary regolith surface analogs: optimized determination of Hapke parameters using multi-angular spectro-imaging laboratory data. Icarus 2003, 165:414-427.
70. Cord A.M., Pinet P.C., Daydou Y.D., Chevrel D.S. Experimental determination of the surface photometric contribution in the spectral reflectance deconvolution processes for a simulated martian crater-like regolithic target. Icarus 2005, 175:78-91.
71. Ovcharenko A.A., Bondarenko S.Y., Zubko E.S., Shkuratov Y.G., Videen G., Nelson R. Particle size effect on the opposition spike and negative polarization. J Quant Spectrosc Radiat Transfer 2006, 101:394-403.
72. Munoz O., Volten H., de Haan J., Vassen W., Hovenier J. Experimental determination of scattering matrices of olivine and Allende meteorite particles. Astron Astrophys 2000, 360:777-788.
73. Shkuratov Y., Bondarenko S., Ovcharenko A., Pieters C., Hiroi T., Volten H., Munos O., Videen G. Comparative studies of the reflectance and degree of linear polarization of particulate surfaces and independently scattering particles. J Quant Spectrosc Radiat Transfer 2006, 100(1-3):340-358.
74. Velikodsky Y.I., Opanasenko N.V., Akimov L.A., Korokhin V.V., Shkuratov Y.G., Kaydash V.G., Videen G., Ehgamberdiev S.A., Berdalieva N.E. New Earth-based absolute photometry of the Moon. Icarus 2011, 214(1):30-45.
75. Shkuratov Y., Kaydash V., Korokhin V., Velokodsky Y., Opanasenko N., Videen G. Optical measurements of the Moon as a tool to study its surface. Planet Space Sci 2011, 59:1326-1371.
76. Akimov L.A. Influence of mesorelief on the brightness distribution over a planetary disk. Sov Astron 1976, 19(3):385-388.
77. Akimov L.A. Light reflection by the Moon I. Kinematics Phys Celestial Bodies 1988, 4(1):3-10. In Russian.
78. Akimov L.A. Light reflection by the Moon. II. Kinematics Phys Celestial Bodies 1988, 4(2):10-16. In Russian.
79. McEwen A.S. A precise lunar photometric function. Lunar Planet Sci Conf 27-th 1996, 841-842.
80. Shkuratov Y., Starukhina L., Kreslavsky M., Opanasenko N., Stankevich D., Shevchenko V. Principle of perturbation invariance in photometry of atmosphereless celestial bodies. Icarus 1994, 109:168-190.
81. Akimov L.A., Velikodsky Y.I., Korokhin V.V. Dependence of lunar highland brightness on photometric latitude. Kinematics Phys Celestial Bodies 1999, 15(4):232-236. In Russian.
82. Akimov L.A., Velikodsky Y.I., Korokhin V.V. Dependence of latitudinal brightness distribution over the lunar disk on albedo and surface roughness. Kinematics Phys Celestial Bodies 2000, 16(2):137-141. [in russian].
83. Korokhin V.V., Velikodsky Y.I., Shkuratov Y.G., Kaydash V.G., Gerasimenko S.Y., Opanasenko N.V., Videen G., Pieters C. Removal of topographic effects from lunar images using Kaguya (LALT) and telescope observations. Planet Space Sci 2010, 58:1298-1306.
84. Helfenstein P., Veverka J. Photometric properties of lunar terrains derived from Hapke's equation. Icarus 1987, 72:342-357.
85. Helfenstein P., Veverka J., Hillier J. The lunar opposition effect: a test of alternative models. Icarus 1997, 128:2-14.
86. Hillier J.K., Buratti B.J., Hill K. Multispectral photometry of the Moon and absolute calibration of the Clementine UV/Vis camera. Icarus 1999, 141:205-225.
87. Kaidash V.G., Gerasimenko S.Y., Shkuratov Y.G., Opanasenko N.V., Velikodskii Y.I., Korokhin V.V. Photometric function variations observed on the near side of the Moon: mapping. Sol Syst Res 2009, 43(2):89-99.
88. Hapke B., Nelson R., Smith W. The opposition effect of the Moon: the contribution of coherent backscatter. Science 1993, 260:509-511.
89. Hapke B., Nelson R., Smith W. The opposition effect of the Moon: coherent backscatter and shadow hiding. Icarus 1998, 133:89-97.
90. Mishchenko M.I., Dlugach J.M., Li Liu Azimuthal asymmetry of the coherent backscattering cone: theoretical results. Phys Rev 2009, A80:053824.
91. Petrov D., Shkuratov Y., Videen G. Light scattering by arbitrary shaped particles with rough surface: Sh-matrices approach. J Quant Spectrosc Radiat Transfer 2012 see this issue.
92. Petrov D., Synelnyk E., Shkuratov Y., Videen G. The T-matrix technique for calculations of scattering properties of ensembles of randomly oriented particles with different size. J Quant Spectrosc Radiat Transfer 2006, 102:85-110.
93. Petrov D., Shkuratov Y., Videen G. Electromagnetic wave scattering from particles of arbitrary shapes. J Quant Spectrosc Radiat Transfer 2011, 112(11):1636-1645.
94. McKay D.S., Heiken G., Basu A., Blanford G., Simon S., Reedy R., French B.M., Papike J. The lunar regolith. Lunar Sourcebook 1991, 736. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. G.H. Heiken, D.T. Vaniman, B.M. French (Eds.).
95. Shkuratov Y., Ovcharenko A., Zubko E., Miloslavskaya O., Nelson R., Smythe W., Muinonen K., Piironen J., Rosenbush V., Helfenstein P. The opposition effect and negative polarization of structurally simulated planetary regoliths. Icarus 2002, 159:396-416.
96. Shkuratov Y., Ovcharenko A. Experimental modeling of opposition effect and negative polarization of regolith-like surfaces. Optics of Cosmic Dust/ 2002, 225-238. NATO Science Series. Kluwer Academic Publishers, London. G. Videen, M. Kocifaj. (Eds.).
97. Mishchenko M., Dlugach J., Liu L., Rosenbush V., Kiselev N., Shkuratov Y. Direct solutions of the Maxwell equations explain opposition phenomena observed for high-albedo solar system objects. Astrophys J Lett 2009, 705:L118-L122.
98. Kreslavsky M.A., Shkuratov Y.G., Velikodsky Y.I., Kaydash V.G., Stankevich D.G., Pieters C.M. Photometric properties of the lunar surface derived from Clementine observations. J Geophys Res Planets 2000, 105(E8):281-295. 20.
99. Kreslavsky M.A., Shkuratov Y.G., Kaydash V.G., Omelchenko V.V., Blewett D.T., Lucey P.G. Lunar opposition spike observed by Clementine NIR camera: preliminary results. Lunar Planet Sci 32-nd 2001, 1140.
100. Buratti B.J., Hiller J.K., Wang M. The lunar opposition surge: observation by Clementine. Icarus 1996, 124:490-499.
101. Shkuratov Y.G., Melkumova L.Y., Opanasenko N.V., Stankevich D.G. Phase dependence of the color index of solid surfaces of celestial bodies. Sol Syst Res 1996, 30:71-79.
102. O'Leary B., Briggs F. Optical properties of Apollo-11 Moon samples. J Geophys Res 1970, 75(32):6532-6537.
103. Akimov L.A., Antipova-Karataeva, Shkuratov Y.G. Indicatrix measurements of lunar samples from landing sites of Luna 24, Luna 16, and Luna 20. Lunar Planet Sci Conf 10-th 1979, 9-11.
104. Korokhin V.V., Velikodsky Y.I., Shkuratov Y.G., Mall U. The phase dependence of brightness and color of the lunar surface: a study based on integral photometric data. Sol Syst Res 2007, 41(1):19-27.
105. Kaydash V.G., Gerasimenko S.Y., Shkuratov Y.G., Opanasenko N.V., Velikodsky Y.I., Korokhin V.V. Mapping of phase ratio of color index for two areas of the lunar nearside. Sol Syst Res 2010, 44(4):267-280.
106. Yokota Y, Matsunaga T, Ohtake M, Haruyama J, Ogawa Y, Nakamura R, Honda C, Morota T, Saiki K, Kawabe S, Nagasawa K, Kitazato K, and LISM Working Group. Lunar phase curve at VIS/NIR wavelength observed by Selena spectral profiler. Lunar Planet Sci Conf 40th. 2009:#2525.
107. Velikodsky Y.I., Volvach Y.S., Korokhin V.V., Shkuratov Y.G., Kaydash V.G., Opanasenko N.V., Muminov M.M., Kahharov B.B. Phase curve of lunar color ratio. Lunar Planet Sci 2011, 42:2060. Abstract #.
108. Denevi BW, Robinson MS, Hapke BW, Lawrence SJ, Wiseman SM, Jolliff BL, and the LROC Team. Global ultraviolet through visible color observations of the Moon with the Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter Wide Angle Camera Lunar Planet. Sci. Conf. 41st 2010:#2263.
109. Hapke B, Denevi B, Sato H, Braden S, Robinson M. The wavelength dependence of the lunar phase curve as seen by the Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter Wide Angle Camera. J Geophys Res 2012;117: E00H15. 10.1029/2011JE003916.
110. Domingue D., Hapke B., Lockwood G., Thompson D. Europa's phase curve: implications for surface structure. Icarus 1991, 90:30-42.
111. Skypeck A., Veverka J., Helfenstein P., Baker L. The Photometric rougness of Ariel is not unusual. Icarus 1991, 90:181-183.
112. Muinonen K., Parviainen H., Näränen J., Beauvivre S., Pinet P., Chevrel S., Koschny D., Grieger B., Foing B., SMART-1 A.M.I.E. Team. Lunar mare single-scattering, porosity, and surface-roughness properties with SMART-1 AMI. Astron Astrophys 2011, 531:A150.