Disentangling linear and nonlinear brain responses to evoked deep tissue pain

Pain

Volumn 153, Issue 10, 2012, Pages 2140-2151

  Loggia, Marco L ^a,b,c   Edwards, Robert R ^a   Kim, Jieun ^c   Vangel, Mark G ^c   Wasan, Ajay D ^a   Gollub, Randy L ^b,c   Harris, Richard E ^d   Park, Kyungmo ^c,e   Napadow, Vitaly ^a,c,f  

^a BRIGHAM AND WOMEN S HOSPITAL   (United States)

^b MASSACHUSETTS GENERAL HOSPITAL   (United States)

^c HARVARD MEDICAL SCHOOL   (United States)

^d UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN MEDICAL SCHOOL   (United States)

^e Kyung Hee University   (South Korea)

^f LOGAN COLLEGE OF CHIROPRACTIC   (United States)

Author keywords

BOLD fMRI; Cuff pain algometry; Default mode network; Human; Neuroimaging; Psychophysics

Indexed keywords

ADULT; ARTICLE; BRAIN FUNCTION; BRAIN REGION; CLINICAL ARTICLE; FEMALE; FUNCTIONAL MAGNETIC RESONANCE IMAGING; HUMAN; MALE; MOTOR CORTEX; NOCICEPTION; PAIN; PAIN ASSESSMENT; POSTERIOR CINGULATE; PREFRONTAL CORTEX; PRIMARY SOMATOSENSORY CORTEX; PRIORITY JOURNAL; SECONDARY SOMATOSENSORY CORTEX;

BRAIN; EVOKED POTENTIALS, SOMATOSENSORY; FEMALE; HUMANS; LINEAR MODELS; MALE; MODELS, NEUROLOGICAL; NONLINEAR DYNAMICS; PAIN; PAIN THRESHOLD; YOUNG ADULT;

EID: 84866430561     PISSN: 03043959     EISSN: 18726623     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.pain.2012.07.014     Document Type: Article

References (86)

1. A.V. Apkarian, M.C. Bushnell, R.D. Treede, and J.K. Zubieta Human brain mechanisms of pain perception and regulation in health and disease Eur J Pain 9 2005 463 484
2. A.V. Apkarian, J.A. Hashmi, and M.N. Baliki Pain and the brain: specificity and plasticity of the brain in clinical chronic pain PAIN® 152 2011 S49 S64
3. M.N. Baliki, P.Y. Geha, and A.V. Apkarian Parsing pain perception between nociceptive representation and magnitude estimation J Neurophysiol 101 2009 875 887
4. L. Becerra, H.C. Breiter, R. Wise, R.G. Gonzalez, and D. Borsook Reward circuitry activation by noxious thermal stimuli Neuron 32 2001 927 946
5. L. Becerra, W. Harris, D. Joseph, T. Huppert, D.A. Boas, and D. Borsook Diffuse optical tomography of pain and tactile stimulation: activation in cortical sensory and emotional systems Neuroimage 41 2008 252 259
6. L.R. Becerra, H.C. Breiter, M. Stojanovic, S. Fishman, A. Edwards, A.R. Comite, R.G. Gonzalez, and D. Borsook Human brain activation under controlled thermal stimulation and habituation to noxious heat: an fMRI study Magn Reson Med 41 1999 1044 1057
7. C.F. Beckmann, M. Jenkinson, and S.M. Smith General multilevel linear modeling for group analysis in FMRI Neuroimage 20 2003 1052 1063
8. K. Bornhovd, M. Quante, V. Glauche, B. Bromm, C. Weiller, and C. Buchel Painful stimuli evoke different stimulus-response functions in the amygdala, prefrontal, insula and somatosensory cortex: a single-trial fMRI study Brain 125 2002 1326 1336
9. A.J. Brisben, S.S. Hsiao, and K.O. Johnson Detection of vibration transmitted through an object grasped in the hand J Neurophysiol 81 1999 1548 1558
10. C. Buchel, K. Bornhovd, M. Quante, V. Glauche, B. Bromm, and C. Weiller Dissociable neural responses related to pain intensity, stimulus intensity, and stimulus awareness within the anterior cingulate cortex: a parametric single-trial laser functional magnetic resonance imaging study J Neurosci 22 2002 970 976
11. R.L. Buckner, J.R. Andrews-Hanna, and D.L. Schacter The brain's default network: anatomy, function, and relevance to disease Ann N Y Acad Sci 1124 2008 1 38
12. N.F. Capra, and J.Y. Ro Human and animal experimental models of acute and chronic muscle pain: intramuscular algesic injection PAIN® 110 2004 3 7
13. J.I. Chen, B. Ha, M.C. Bushnell, B. Pike, and G.H. Duncan Differentiating noxious- and innocuous-related activation of human somatosensory cortices using temporal analysis of fMRI J Neurophysiol 88 2002 464 474
14. E.H. Chudler, F. Anton, R. Dubner, and D.R. Kenshalo Jr. Responses of nociceptive SI neurons in monkeys and pain sensation in humans elicited by noxious thermal stimulation: effect of interstimulus interval J Neurophysiol 63 1990 559 569
15. R.C. Coghill, I. Gilron, and M.J. Iadarola Hemispheric lateralization of somatosensory processing J Neurophysiol 85 2001 2602 2612
16. R.C. Coghill, C.N. Sang, J.M. Maisog, and M.J. Iadarola Pain intensity processing within the human brain: a bilateral, distributed mechanism J Neurophysiol 82 1999 1934 1943
17. J.E. Cometto-Muniz, and M.H. Abraham Olfactory detectability of homologous n-alkylbenzenes as reflected by concentration-detection functions in humans Neuroscience 161 2009 236 248
18. A.M. Dale, B. Fischl, and M.I. Sereno Cortical surface-based analysis. I. Segmentation and surface reconstruction Neuroimage 9 1999 179 194
19. S.W. Derbyshire, A.K. Jones, F. Gyulai, S. Clark, D. Townsend, and L.L. Firestone Pain processing during three levels of noxious stimulation produces differential patterns of central activity PAIN® 73 1997 431 445
20. J. Downar, A.P. Crawley, D.J. Mikulis, and K.D. Davis A multimodal cortical network for the detection of changes in the sensory environment Nat Neurosci 3 2000 277 283
21. J. Downar, D.J. Mikulis, and K.D. Davis Neural correlates of the prolonged salience of painful stimulation Neuroimage 20 2003 1540 1551
22. W.C. Drevets, H. Burton, T.O. Videen, A.Z. Snyder, J.R. Simpson Jr, and M.E. Raichle Blood flow changes in human somatosensory cortex during anticipated stimulation Nature 373 1995 249 252
23. C. Eccleston, and G. Crombez Pain demands attention: a cognitive-affective model of the interruptive function of pain Psychol Bull 125 1999 356 366
24. A.L. Edwards Experimental design in psychological research 1968 Holt, Rinehart and Winston New York
25. B. Fischl, M.I. Sereno, and A.M. Dale Cortical surface-based analysis. II: Inflation, flattening, and a surface-based coordinate system Neuroimage 9 1999 195 207
26. J.M. Foley, S. Varadharajan, C.C. Koh, and M.C. Farias Detection of Gabor patterns of different sizes, shapes, phases and eccentricities Vision Res 47 2007 85 107
27. J. Gonzalez-Castillo, Z.S. Saad, D.A. Handwerker, S.J. Inati, N. Brenowitz, and P.A. Bandettini Whole-brain, time-locked activation with simple tasks revealed using massive averaging and model-free analysis Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 109 2012 5487 5492
28. D.N. Greve, and B. Fischl Accurate and robust brain image alignment using boundary-based registration Neuroimage 48 2009 63 72
29. J.V. Haxby, B. Horwitz, L.G. Ungerleider, J.M. Maisog, P. Pietrini, and C.L. Grady The functional organization of human extrastriate cortex: a PET-rCBF study of selective attention to faces and locations J Neurosci 14 1994 6336 6353
30. L.A. Henderson, R. Bandler, S.C. Gandevia, and V.G. Macefield Distinct forebrain activity patterns during deep versus superficial pain PAIN® 120 2006 286 296
31. L.A. Henderson, S.C. Gandevia, and V.G. Macefield Somatotopic organization of the processing of muscle and cutaneous pain in the left and right insula cortex: a single-trial fMRI study PAIN® 128 2007 20 30
32. L.A. Henderson, T.K. Rubin, and V.G. Macefield Within-limb somatotopic representation of acute muscle pain in the human contralateral dorsal posterior insula Hum Brain Mapp 32 2011 1592 1601
33. Y. Hlushchuk, and R. Hari Transient suppression of ipsilateral primary somatosensory cortex during tactile finger stimulation J Neurosci 26 2006 5819 5824
34. M. Jenkinson Fast, automated, N-dimensional phase-unwrapping algorithm Magn Reson Med 49 2003 193 197
35. M. Jenkinson, P. Bannister, M. Brady, and S. Smith Improved optimization for the robust and accurate linear registration and motion correction of brain images Neuroimage 17 2002 825 841
36. M. Jenkinson, and S. Smith A global optimisation method for robust affine registration of brain images Med Image Anal 5 2001 143 156
37. G. Ji, and V. Neugebauer Pain-related deactivation of medial prefrontal cortical neurons involves mGluR1 and GABA(A) receptors J Neurophysiol 106 2011 2642 2652
38. E.G. Jones, and D.P. Friedman Projection pattern of functional components of thalamic ventrobasal complex on monkey somatosensory cortex J Neurophysiol 48 1982 521 544
39. A. Kastrup, J. Baudewig, S. Schnaudigel, R. Huonker, L. Becker, J.M. Sohns, P. Dechent, C. Klingner, and O.W. Witte Behavioral correlates of negative BOLD signal changes in the primary somatosensory cortex Neuroimage 41 2008 1364 1371
40. R. Kawashima, B.T. O'Sullivan, and P.E. Roland Positron-emission tomography studies of cross-modality inhibition in selective attentional tasks: closing the "mind's eye" Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 92 1995 5969 5972
41. D.R. Kenshalo Jr, E.H. Chudler, F. Anton, and R. Dubner SI nociceptive neurons participate in the encoding process by which monkeys perceive the intensity of noxious thermal stimulation Brain Res 454 1988 378 382
42. D.R. Kenshalo Jr, and O. Isensee Responses of primate SI cortical neurons to noxious stimuli J Neurophysiol 50 1983 1479 1496
43. C.M. Klingner, C. Hasler, S. Brodoehl, and O.W. Witte Dependence of the negative BOLD response on somatosensory stimulus intensity Neuroimage 53 2010 189 195
44. C.M. Klingner, R. Huonker, S. Flemming, C. Hasler, S. Brodoehl, C. Preul, H. Burmeister, A. Kastrup, and O.W. Witte Functional deactivations: multiple ipsilateral brain areas engaged in the processing of somatosensory information Hum Brain Mapp 32 2011 127 140
45. J. Kong, M.L. Loggia, C. Zyloney, P. Tu, P. Laviolette, and R.L. Gollub Exploring the brain in pain: activations, deactivations and their relation PAIN® 148 2010 257 267
46. J. Kong, N.S. White, K.K. Kwong, M.G. Vangel, I.S. Rosman, R.H. Gracely, and R.L. Gollub Using fMRI to dissociate sensory encoding from cognitive evaluation of heat pain intensity Hum Brain Mapp 27 2006 715 721
47. S. Konishi, D.I. Donaldson, and R.L. Buckner Transient activation during block transition Neuroimage 13 2001 364 374
48. M.L. Loggia, J.S. Mogil, and M.C. Bushnell Experimentally induced mood changes preferentially affect pain unpleasantness J Pain 9 2008 784 791
49. B. Mazoyer, L. Zago, E. Mellet, S. Bricogne, O. Etard, O. Houde, F. Crivello, M. Joliot, L. Petit, and N. Tzourio-Mazoyer Cortical networks for working memory and executive functions sustain the conscious resting state in man Brain Res Bull 54 2001 287 298
50. K.A. McKiernan, J.N. Kaufman, J. Kucera-Thompson, and J.R. Binder A parametric manipulation of factors affecting task-induced deactivation in functional neuroimaging J Cogn Neurosci 15 2003 394 408
51. M. Moayedi, and I. Weissman-Fogel Is the insula the "how much" intensity coder? J Neurophysiol 102 2009 1345 1347
52. A. Mouraux, A. Diukova, M.C. Lee, R.G. Wise, and G.D. Iannetti A multisensory investigation of the functional significance of the "pain matrix" Neuroimage 54 2011 2237 2249
53. T.P. Naidich, E. Kang, G.M. Fatterpekar, B.N. Delman, S.H. Gultekin, D. Wolfe, O. Ortiz, I. Yousry, M. Weismann, and T.A. Yousry The insula: anatomic study and MR imaging display at 1.5 T AJNR Am J Neuroradiol 25 2004 222 232
54. T. Obata, T.T. Liu, K.L. Miller, W.M. Luh, E.C. Wong, L.R. Frank, and R.B. Buxton Discrepancies between BOLD and flow dynamics in primary and supplementary motor areas: application of the balloon model to the interpretation of BOLD transients Neuroimage 21 2004 144 153
55. Y. Oshiro, A.S. Quevedo, J.G. McHaffie, R.A. Kraft, and R.C. Coghill Brain mechanisms supporting spatial discrimination of pain J Neurosci 27 2007 3388 3394
56. D.G. Owen, C.F. Clarke, S. Ganapathy, F.S. Prato, and K.S. St Lawrence Using perfusion MRI to measure the dynamic changes in neural activation associated with tonic muscular pain PAIN® 148 2010 375 386
57. J. Persson, C. Lustig, J.K. Nelson, and P.A. Reuter-Lorenz Age differences in deactivation: a link to cognitive control? J Cogn Neurosci 19 2007 1021 1032
58. R. Peyron, L. Garcia-Larrea, M.C. Gregoire, N. Costes, P. Convers, F. Lavenne, F. Mauguiere, D. Michel, and B. Laurent Haemodynamic brain responses to acute pain in humans: sensory and attentional networks Brain 122 1999 1765 1780
59. M. Ploner, J. Gross, L. Timmermann, and A. Schnitzler Cortical representation of first and second pain sensation in humans Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 99 2002 12444 12448
60. R. Polianskis, T. Graven-Nielsen, and L. Arendt-Nielsen Computer-controlled pneumatic pressure algometry - a new technique for quantitative sensory testing Eur J Pain 5 2001 267 277
61. R. Polianskis, T. Graven-Nielsen, and L. Arendt-Nielsen Modality-specific facilitation and adaptation to painful tonic stimulation in humans Eur J Pain 6 2002 475 484
62. R. Polianskis, T. Graven-Nielsen, and L. Arendt-Nielsen Pressure-pain function in desensitized and hypersensitized muscle and skin assessed by cuff algometry J Pain 3 2002 28 37
63. R. Polianskis, T. Graven-Nielsen, and L. Arendt-Nielsen Spatial and temporal aspects of deep tissue pain assessed by cuff algometry PAIN® 100 2002 19 26
64. C.A. Porro, V. Cettolo, M.P. Francescato, and P. Baraldi Temporal and intensity coding of pain in human cortex J Neurophysiol 80 1998 3312 3320
65. D.D. Price, P.A. McGrath, A. Rafii, and B. Buckingham The validation of visual analogue scales as ratio scale measures for chronic and experimental pain PAIN® 17 1983 45 56
66. M.E. Raichle, A.M. MacLeod, A.Z. Snyder, W.J. Powers, D.A. Gusnard, and G.L. Shulman A default mode of brain function Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 98 2001 676 682
67. V. Renvall, and R. Hari Transients may occur in functional magnetic resonance imaging without physiological basis Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 106 2009 20510 20514
68. D.A. Seminowicz, and K.D. Davis Interactions of pain intensity and cognitive load: the brain stays on task Cereb Cortex 17 2007 1412 1422
69. G.L. Shulman, J.A. Fiez, M. Corbetta, R.L. Buckner, F.M. Miezin, M.E. Raichle, and S.E. Peterson Common blood flow changes across visual tasks: II. Decreases in cerebral cortex J Cogn Neurosci 9 1997 648 663
70. K.D. Singh, and I.P. Fawcett Transient and linearly graded deactivation of the human default-mode network by a visual detection task Neuroimage 41 2008 100 112
71. S.M. Smith Fast robust automated brain extraction Hum Brain Mapp 17 2002 143 155
72. E. Tapia, B.G. Breitmeyer, and J. Jacob Metacontrast masking with texture-defined second-order stimuli Vision Res 51 2011 2453 2461
73. L. Timmermann, M. Ploner, K. Haucke, F. Schmitz, R. Baltissen, and A. Schnitzler Differential coding of pain intensity in the human primary and secondary somatosensory cortex J Neurophysiol 86 2001 1499 1503
74. D. Tomasi, T. Ernst, E.C. Caparelli, and L. Chang Common deactivation patterns during working memory and visual attention tasks: an intra-subject fMRI study at 4 Tesla Hum Brain Mapp 27 2006 694 705
75. C.W. Tyler, L.L. Kontsevich, and T.C. Ferree Independent components in stimulus-related BOLD signals and estimation of the underlying neural responses Brain Res 1229 2008 72 89
76. J. Upadhyay, G. Pendse, J. Anderson, A.J. Schwarz, R. Baumgartner, A. Coimbra, J. Bishop, J. Knudsen, E. George, I. Grachev, S. Iyengar, D. Bleakman, R. Hargreaves, D. Borsook, and L. Becerra Improved characterization of BOLD responses for evoked sensory stimuli Neuroimage 49 2010 2275 2286
77. C. Villemure, and M.C. Bushnell Mood influences supraspinal pain processing separately from attention J Neurosci 29 2009 705 715
78. C. Villemure, B.M. Slotnick, and M.C. Bushnell Effects of odors on pain perception: deciphering the roles of emotion and attention PAIN® 106 2003 101 108
79. K.C. Whang, H. Burton, and G.L. Shulman Selective attention in vibrotactile tasks: detecting the presence and absence of amplitude change Percept Psychophys 50 1991 157 165
80. P.B. Wood, P. Schweinhardt, E. Jaeger, A. Dagher, H. Hakyemez, E.A. Rabiner, M.C. Bushnell, and B.A. Chizh Fibromyalgia patients show an abnormal dopamine response to pain Eur J Neurosci 25 2007 3576 3582
81. M. Woolrich Robust group analysis using outlier inference Neuroimage 41 2008 286 301
82. M.W. Woolrich, T.E. Behrens, C.F. Beckmann, M. Jenkinson, and S.M. Smith Multilevel linear modelling for FMRI group analysis using Bayesian inference Neuroimage 21 2004 1732 1747
83. M.W. Woolrich, B.D. Ripley, M. Brady, and S.M. Smith Temporal autocorrelation in univariate linear modeling of FMRI data Neuroimage 14 2001 1370 1386
84. K.J. Worsley Statistical analysis of activation images P. Jezzard, P.M. Matthews, S.M. Smith, Functional MRI: an introduction to methods 2001 Oxford University Press New York 251 270
85. R.H. Wurtz, W.M. Joiner, and R.A. Berman Neuronal mechanisms for visual stability: progress and problems Phil Trans R Soc Lon 366 2011 492 503
86. R.M. Yerkes, and J.D. Dodson The relation of strength of stimulus to rapidity of habit-formation J Comp Neurol Psychol 18 1908 459 482.