Reasoning About Evolution's Grand Patterns: College Students' Understanding of the Tree of Life

American Educational Research Journal

Volumn 50, Issue 1, 2013, Pages 138-177

  Novick, Laura R ^a   Catley, Kefyn M ^b  

^a VANDERBILT UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^b WESTERN CAROLINA UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

cladograms; evolution education; scientific reasoning; Tree of Life; tree thinking

Indexed keywords

EID: 84865433686     PISSN: 00028312     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.3102/0002831212448209     Document Type: Article

References (51)

1. Atlas of science literacy. Washington, DC: Author; 2001:.
2. American Museum of Natural History. (2002). Assembling the Tree of Life: Harnessing life's history to benefit science and society. Retrieved from http://www.phylo.org/sub_sections/outreach/outreach_b.php.
3. Baum D. A.,Smith S. D.,Donovan S. S.The tree thinking challenge.Science. 2005;310:979-980.
4. CatleyK. M. (1994). Descriptions of new Hypochilus species from New Mexico and California with a cladistic analysis of the Hypochilidae (Araneae). American Museum Novitates, 3088, 1-27. Retrieved from http://digitallibrary.amnh.org/dspace/handle/2246/4985.
5. Catley K. M.Darwin's missing link: A new paradigm for evolution education.Science Education. 2006;90:767-783.
6. CatleyK. M.LehrerR.ReiserB. (2005). Tracing a prospective learning progression for developing understanding of evolution (Paper Commissioned by the National Academies Committee on Test Design for K-12 Science Achievement). Retrieved from http://www7.nationalacademies.org/bota/Evolution.pdf.
7. Catley K. M.,Novick L. R.Seeing the wood for the trees: An analysis of evolutionary diagrams in biology textbooks.BioScience. 2008;58:976-987.
8. Catley K. M.,Novick L. R.Digging deep: Exploring college students' knowledge of macroevolutionary time.Journal of Research in Science Teaching. 2009;46:311-332.
9. Catley K. M.,Novick L. R.Evidence for a confirmation bias in students' reasoning about relationships depicted in cladogram. 2012;:.
10. Catley K. M.,Phillips B. C.,Novick L. R.Snakes and eels and dogs! Oh, my! Evaluating high school students' tree-thinking skills: An entry point to understanding evolution. 2012;:.
11. Chinn C. A.,Brewer W. F.The role of anomalous data in knowledge acquisition: A theoretical framework and implications for science instruction.Review of Educational Research. 1993;63:1-49.
12. Cohen J.Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences. 1988). Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences (2nd ed.). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum; 1988:.
13. Corter J. E.,Nickerson J. V.,Tversky B.,Zahner D.,Rho Y. J.Using diagrams to design information systems. Proceedings of the Thirtieth Annual Conference of the Cognitive Science Society; 2008Austin, TX: Cognitive Science Society; 2008. 2259.
14. Cromley J. G.,Perez A. C.,Fitzhugh S.,Tanaka J.,Newcombe N.,Wills T. W. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association; 2010Denver, CO; 2010.
15. Evans E. M.,Spiegel A. N.,Gram W.,Frazier B. N.,Tare M.,Thompson S.,Diamond J.A conceptual guide to natural history museum visitors' understanding of evolution.Journal of Research in Science Teaching. 2010;47:326-353.
16. Freeman S.Biological science: Evolution, diversity, & ecology. 2011). Biological science: Evolution, diversity, & ecology (Vol. 2, 4th ed.). Boston, MA: Benjamin Cummings.Boston, MA: Benjamin Cummings; 2011:.
17. Futuyma D. J.Assembling the tree of life. Cracraft J.Donoghue M. J., ed. New York, NY: Oxford University Press; 2004:25-39.
18. Goldsmith D. W.Presenting cladistic thinking to biology majors & general science students.The American Biology Teacher. 2003;65:679-682.
19. Goldstone R. L.,Barsalou L. W.Reuniting perception and conception.Cognition. 1998;65:231-262.
20. Gregory T. R.Understanding evolutionary trees.Evolution: Education and Outreach. 2008;1:121-137.
21. Gyselinck V.,Cornoldi C.,Dubois V.,De Beni R.,Ehrlich M-F.Visuospatial memory and phonological loop in learning from multimedia.Applied Cognitive Psychology. 2002;16:665-685.
22. Hegarty M.,Carpenter P. A.,Just M. A.Handbook of reading research. Barr R.Kamil M. L.Mosenthal P.Pearson P. D., ed. New York, NY: Longman; 1991:641-668.
23. Hegarty M.,Stull A. T.Oxford handbook of thinking and reasoning. Holyoak K. J.Morrison R. G., ed. New York, NY: Oxford University Press; in press:.
24. Hennig W.Phylogenetic systematics. Urbana, IL: University of Illinois Press; 1966:.
25. Hochberg J. E.Perception. 1978). Perception (2nd ed.). Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall; 1978:.
26. Kaup B.,Lüdtke J.,Zwaan R. A.Processing negated sentences with contradictory predicates: Is a door that is not open mentally closed?.Journal of Pragmatics. 2006;38:1033-1050.
27. Kaup B.,Yaxley R. H.,Madden C. J.,Zwaan R. A.,Lüdtke J.Experiential simulations of negated text information.The Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology. 2007;60:976-990.
28. Kendeou P.,van den Broek P.The effects of readers' misconceptions on comprehension of scientific text.Journal of Educational Psychology. 2005;97:235-245.
29. Kindfield A. C. H.Biology diagrams: Tools to think with.The Journal of the Learning Sciences. 1993/1994;3:1-36.
30. Kozma R. B.,Russell J.Multimedia and understanding: Expert and novice responses to different representations of chemical phenomena.Journal of Research in Science Teaching. 1997;34:949-968.
31. Landy D.,Goldstone R. L.How abstract is symbolic thought?.Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition. 2007;33:720-733.
32. Larkin J. H.,Simon H. A.Why a diagram is (sometimes) worth ten thousand words.Cognitive Science. 1987;11:65-99.
33. Lynch M.Representation in scientific practice. Lynch M.Woolgar S., ed. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press; 1990:153-186.
34. Maienschein J.From presentation to representation in E. B. Wilson's The Cell.Biology and Philosophy. 1991;6:227-254.
35. Matlin M. W.Cognition. 2009). Cognition (7th ed.). Hoboken, NJ: Wiley.Hoboken, NJ: Wiley; 2009:.
36. Meir E.,Perry J.,Herron J. C.,Kingsolver J.College students' misconceptions about evolutionary trees.The American Biology Teacher Online. 2007;69 (7): e71-e76.
37. Morabito N.,Catley K. M.,Novick L. R.Reasoning about evolutionary history: The effects of biology background on post-secondary students' knowledge of most recent common ancestry and homoplasy.Journal of Biological Education. 2010;44:166-174.
38. Morse R.,Calderone N. W.The value of honey bees as pollinators of U.S. crops in 2000.Bee Culture. 2000;128:1-15.
39. National science education standards. Washington, DC: National Academy Press; 1996:.
40. Novick L. R.The psychology of learning and motivation. Medin D. L., ed. San Diego, CA: Academic Press; 2001:279-325.
41. Novick L. R.Diagram literacy in pre-service math teachers, computer science majors, and typical undergraduates: The case of matrices, networks, and hierarchies.Mathematical Thinking and Learning. 2004;6:307-342.
42. Novick L. R.Diagrammatic representation and inference (Diagrams 2006), LNAI 4045. Barker-Plummer D.Cox R.Swoboda N., ed. Berlin: Springer-Verlag; 2006a:1-11.
43. Novick L. R.Understanding spatial diagram structure: An analysis of hierarchies, matrices, and networks.The Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology. 2006b;59:1826-1856.
44. Novick L. R.,Catley K. M.Understanding phylogenies in biology: The influence of a Gestalt perceptual principle.Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied. 2007;13:197-223.
45. O'Hara R. J.Homage to Clio, or, toward an historical philosophy for evolutionary biology.Systematic Zoology. 1988;37:142-155.
46. Reece J. B.,Urry L. A.,Cain M. L.,Wasserman S. A.,Minorsky P. V.,Jackson R. B.Campbell biology. 2010). Campbell biology (9th ed.). Boston, MA: Benjamin Cummings.Boston, MA: Benjamin Cummings; 2010:.
47. SandvikH. (2008). Tree thinking cannot taken for granted: Challenges for teaching phylogenetics. Theory in Biosciences, 127, 45-51. Retrieved from http://www.springerlink.com/content/eu62420p381402xr/.
48. Thanukos A.A name by any other tree.Evolution: Education & Outreach. 2009;2:303-309.
49. Winn W.Knowledge acquisition from text and pictures. Mandl H.Levin J. R., ed. Amsterdam, the Netherlands: Elsevier; 1989:125-144.
50. Yates T. L.,Salazar-Bravo J.,Dragoo J.W.Assembling the tree of life. Cracraft J.Donoghue M. J., ed. New York, NY: Oxford University Press; 2004:7-17.
51. Yeh Y-F. Y.,McTigue E. M.The frequency, variation, and function of graphical representations within standardized state science tests.School Science and Mathematics. 2009;109:435-449.