A Tale of two chinese courts: Economic development and contract enforcement

Journal of Law and Society

Volumn 39, Issue 3, 2012, Pages 384-409

  He, Xin ^a  

^a CITY UNIVERSITY OF HONG KONG   (Hong Kong)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 84864948209     PISSN: 0263323X     EISSN: 14676478     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1467-6478.2012.00590.x     Document Type: Article

References (95)

1. D.C. Clarke, 'Power and Politics in the Chinese Court System: The Execution of Civil Judgments' (1996) 10 Colum J. of Asian Law 1-125
2. M. Pei, 'Does Legal Reform Protect Economic Transactions? Commercial Disputes in China' in Assessing the Value of Law in Transition Economies, ed. P. Murrell (2001) 180-210
3. M. Trebilcock and J. Leng, 'The Role of Formal Contract Law and Enforcement in Economic Development' (2006) 92 Virginia Law Rev. 1517-80, at 1519
4. M. Moser (ed.), Managing Business Disputes in Today's China: Duelling with Dragons (2007)
5. J.A. Cohen, 'Reforming China's Civil Procedure: Judging the Courts' (1997) 45 Am. J. of Comparative Law 793-805
6. S. Lubman, Bird in a Cage (1999).
7. G. Yu and H. Zhang, 'Adaptive Efficiency and Financial Development in China: The Role of Contracts and Contractual Enforcement' (2008) 11 J. of International Economic Law 459-94.
8. R. Peerenboom, 'Seek Truth from Facts: An Empirical Study of Enforcement Arbitral Awards in the PRC' (2001) 49 Am. J. of Comparative Law 249-327
9. M. Pei et al., 'A Survey of Corporate Litigants in Shanghai' in Judicial Independence in China, ed. R. Peerenboom (2010)
10. X. He, 'Enforcing Commercial Judgments in the Pearl River Delta of China' (2009) 52 Am. J. of Comparative Law 419-56.
11. S. Whiting, 'Contracting and Dispute Resolution among Chinese Firms: Law and Its Substitutes' in Dynamics of Local Governance in China during the Reform Era, eds. T.K. Ling and Y.H. Chu (2010) 181-224, at 193.
12. X. He, 'Debt-Collection in the Less Developed Regions of China: An Empirical Study from a Basic-Level Court in Shaanxi Province' (2011) 206 The China Q. 253-75, at 273.
13. E. Michelson and B.L. Read, 'Public Attitudes toward Official Justice in Beijing and Rural China' in Chinese Justice: Civil Dispute Resolution in Contemporary China, eds. M. Woo and M. Gallagher (2011) 169-203, at 195.
14. G. K. Hadfield, 'The Many Legal Institutions that Support Contractual Commitments' in Handbook of New Institutional Economics, eds. C. MeÂnard and M.M. Shirley (2005) 175-203.
15. K.E. Davis and M.J. Trebilcock, 'Legal Reforms and Development' (2001) 22 Third World Q. 21-37.
16. citing D. North, Institutions, Institutional Change, and Economic Performance (1990).
17. A. Greif, 'Reputation and Coalitions in Medieval Trade: Evidence on the Maghribi Traders' (1989) 49 J. of Economic History 857-82
18. A. Greif, 'Contract Enforceability and Economic Institutions in Early Trade: The Maghribi Traders' Coalition' (1993) 83 Am. Economic Rev. 525-48
19. J. McMillan and C. Woodruff, 'Private Order under Dysfunctional Public Order' (2000) 98 Michigan Law Rev. 2421-58
20. K. Hendley et al., 'Law, Relationships and Private Enforcement: Transactional Strategies of Russian Enterprises' (2001) 52 Europe-Asia Studies 627-56
21. World Bank, Doing Business in 2004: Understanding Regulation (2003)
22. A. Chong and C. Caldero n, 'Causality and Feedback between Institutional Measures and Economic Growth' (2000)12 Economics and Politics 69-81
23. R. Rigobon and D. Rodrik, 'Rule of Law, Democracy, Openness, and Income: Estimating the Interrelationships' (2005) 13 Economics of Transition 533-64.
24. K. Hendley, 'The Rule of Law and Economic Development in a Global Era' in The Blackwell Companion to Law and Society, ed. A. Sarat (2004) 605-23.
25. M. Weber, Max Weber on Law in Economy and Society, ed. M. Rheinstein (1954)
26. D. North, Institutions, Institutional Change, and Economic Performance (1990);
27. O.Williamson, The Economic Institutions of Capitalism (1985) 2
28. O. Williamson, The Mechanisms of Governance (1996) 332
29. T. Ginsburg, 'Does Law Matter for Economic Development? Evidence from East Asia' (2000) 34 Law & Society Rev. 829-56.
30. D. Rodrik, 'Introduction' to In Search of Prosperity: Analytic Narratives on Economic Growth, ed. D. Rodrik (2003) 8-15
31. K. Dam, The Law-Growth Nexus (2006)
32. D.C. Clarke, P. Murrell, and S. Whiting, 'The Role of Law in China's Economic Development' in China's Great Economic Transformation, eds. T. Rawski and L. Brandt (2008) 375-428.
33. K. Pistor and P.A. Wellons, The Role of Law and Legal Institutions in Asian Economic Development 1960-1995 (1999).
34. M. Woo, 'Law and Discretion in the Contemporary Chinese Courts' (1999) 8 Pacific Rim Law & Policy J. 581-615
35. M. Woo and Y. Wang, 'Civil Justice in China: An Empirical Study of Three Provinces' (2005) 53 Am. J. of Comparative Law 911-40
36. H. Fu and R. Cullen, 'From Mediatory to Adjudicatory Justice: The Limits of Civil Justice Reform in China' in Chinese Justice: Civil Dispute Resolution in Contemporary China, eds. M. Woo, M. Gallagher, and M. Goldman (2011) 25-57.
37. J. Zhu (ed.), Zhongguo faluÈ fazhan baogao (1979-2004) [China Legal Development Report (1979-2004)] (2007).
38. SPC (Supreme People's Court), 'The Outlines of Five-Year Reforms' (1999) Promulgated by the SPC on 20 October 1999
39. Article 18 of The Five-Year Reform Outlines states: 'The court decisions shall be rendered by the chief adjudicator or the sole adjudicator according to the law by 2000'
40. See Articles 32-35 of the Judges Law of the PRC, amended in 2001.
41. Mingpao, 'Responsibilities for Wrongfully Decided Cases in a Chongqing Intermediate Court', Mingpao Section A15, 4 September 2007.
42. X. He, 'Routinization of Divorce Law Practice in China: Institutional Constraints' Influence on Judicial Behaviour' (2009) 23 International J. of Law, Policy and the Family 83-109.
43. All socio-economic information comes from local annals.
44. X. He, 'Court Finance and Court Reactions to Judicial Reforms: A Tale of Two Chinese Courts' (2009) 31 Law & Policy 463-86.
45. State Council, 'The Measures for Taking Litigation Fees' (2006) issued 19 December 2006, implemented 1 April 2007.
46. Y. Liao and S. Li, 'Woguo minshi susong feiyong zhidu zhi yunxing xianzhuang' ['The Current Operational Status of the System of Civil Litigation Fees in China'] (2005) 3 Zhongwai faxue [Peking University Law J.] 304-27.
47. Debt-collection cases between individuals are thus not included.
48. The cases from Court G were completed in 2002 while the ones from Court S were from 2004. This is because the earliest year of the available docket was 2004 when I reached Court S in 2007.
49. X. He, 'The Recent Decline in Economic Caseloads in Chinese Courts: Exploration of a Surprising Puzzle' (2007) 190 The China Q. 352-74.
50. The reasons for unavailability include invalid or outdated contact information, and missing or deceased litigants. A tiny proportion of litigants simply declined to answer questions. There were no abnormal patterns of characteristics among the litigants who were not accessible.
51. City G Government, Government Work Report (2007), internal document.
52. The Editorial Committee of the Annals (eds.), G Annal (2006).
53. The Editorial Committee (eds.), S Annal (2003).
54. K. Hendley, 'Business Litigation in the Transition: A Portrait of Debt Collection in Russia' (2004) 31 Law & Society Rev. 305-47.
55. M. Galanter and J. Rogers 'The Transformation of Business Disputing? Some Preliminary Observations' (1991) Institute for Legal Studies, Working Paper DPRP 10-3
56. See author's interview, 2007.
57. L.M. Friedman, 'Opening the Time Capsule: A Progress Report on Studies of Courts Over Time' (1990) 24 Law & Society Rev. 229-40.
58. S. Macaulay, 'Non-Contractual Relations in Business: A Preliminary Study' (1963) 28 Am. Sociological Rev. 55-67.
59. R.A. Kagan, 'The Routinization of Debt Collection: An Essay on Social Change and Conflict in the Courts' (1984) 18 Law & Society Rev. 323-72.
60. M.Y. Gechlik, 'Judicial Reform in China: Lessons from Shanghai' (2006) 19 Colum J. of Asian Law 97-137, at 100.
61. B. Ahl, 'Advancing the Rule of Law through Education?' (2006) 42 Issues & Studies 171-204, at 184.
62. It is believed that, unlike politically sensitive cases, courts in authoritarian states handle routine cases efficiently and effectively.
63. R. Sharlet, 'Stalinism and Soviet Legal Culture' in Stalinism: Essays in Historical Interpretation, ed. R.C. Tucker (1977) 155-79.
64. J. Landa, 'A Theory of the Ethnically Homogeneous Middleman Group: An Institutional Alternative to Contract Law' (1988) 10 J. of Legal Studies 349-62
65. L. Lim and P. Gosling, 'Strengths and Weakness of Minority Status for South Asian Chinese at a Time of Economic Growth and Liberalization' in The Essential Outsiders, eds. D. Chirot and A. Reid (1997) 285-311
66. L. Bernstein, 'Opting Out of the Legal System: Extralegal Contractual Relations in the Diamond Industry' (1992) 21 J. of Legal Studies 115-57.
67. Y. Su and X. He, 'Street as Courtroom: State Accommodation of Labor Protests in South China' (2010) 44 Law & Society Rev. 157-84.
68. R. Peerenboom, 'More Law, Less Courts: Legalized Governance, Judicialization, and Dejudicialization in China' in Administrative Law and Governance in Asia, eds. T. Ginsburg and A. Chen (2009) 175-202.
69. R. Peerenboom, China's Long March toward Rule of Law (2002) 466.
70. D.S.G. Goodman, 'The Campaign to ''Open up the West'': National, Provincial-level and Local Perspectives' (2004) 178 The China Q. 317-34
71. E.B. Vermeer, 'Shaanxi: Building a Future on State Support' (2004) 178 The China Q. 400-25
72. C.A. McNally, 'Sichuan: Driving Capitalist Development Westward' (2004) 178 The China Q. 426-47.
73. Supreme People's Court Drafting Group, 'Reform of the People's Court: A Review and Future Prospects' (2007).
74. State Council, 'The Outlines of Administration in Accordance with Law' (1999)
75. State Council, 'Implementing Outlines to Comprehensively Further Administration in Accordance with Law' (2005).
76. State Council, The Measures on Litigation, Fees Taking (2006).
77. K. Jayasuriya, 'Introduction: A Framework for the Analysis of Legal Institutions in East Asia' in Law, Capitalism and Power in Asia: The Rule of Law and Legal Institutions, ed. K. Jayasuriya (1999) 1-27
78. X. Ding, 'Institutional Amphibiousness and the Transition from Communism: The Case of China' (1994) 24 Brit. J. of Political Sci. 293-368.
79. V. Shue, The Reach of the State: Sketches of Chinese Body Politics (1988).
80. X. He, 'Administrative Law as a Political Control Mechanism in Contemporary China' in Building Constitutionalism in China, eds. S. Balme and M. Dowdle (2009) 143-61.
81. S. Zhu, Songfa Xiaxiang [Sending Law to the Countryside] (2000).
82. One may argue that judicial reforms across the nation are still driven by the economic development of the richer areas. For instance, it could be that economic factors produce a demand for court reforms in economically richer area and, for constitutional reasons, any reforms must be carried out on a nationwide basis. This is because, constitutionally, China does not have a federal system which allows judicial reforms to be implemented only in the richer area and not in the poorer area. Yet, even if this argument makes sense, it only suggests that it is the economic development in the richer area, rather than the poorer area themselves, that drives judicial reforms in the poorer area, or that economic forces lead to judicial reforms in the poorer area only in a remote or indirect way.
83. L.F.Y. Ng and C. Tuan, 'FDI Promotion Policy in China: Governance and Effectiveness' (2001) 24 World Economy 1051-74, at 1072
84. L.F.Y. Ng and C. Tuan, 'Building a Favourable Investment Environment: Evidence for the Facilitation of FDI in China' (2002) 25 World Economy 1095-114.
85. H. Wang, 'Informal Institutions and Foreign Investment in China' (2000) 13 Pacific Rev. 525-56;
86. A. Hampton, 'Local Government and Investment Promotion in China' (2008) working paper for Institute of Development Studies, at www2.ids.ac.uk/gdr/ cfs/pdfs/AndreaHamptonFDI-WPDec06final%20.pdf.
87. Y. Huang, FDI in China: An Asian Perspective (1998) 31-41.
88. Y. Dezalay and B.G. Garth, The Internationalization of Palace Wars (2002)
89. A. Perry, 'The Relationship between Legal Systems and Economic Development: Integrating Economic and Cultural Approaches (2002) 29 J. of Law and Society 282.
90. C. Jones, 'Capitalism, Globalism, and the Rule of Law: An Alternative Trajectory of Legal Change in China' (1994) 3 Social & Legal Studies 195-221
91. J.K. Winn, 'Relational Practices and the Marginalization of Law: Informal Financial Practices of Small Businesses in Taiwan' (1994) 28 Law & Society Rev. 193-232
92. R. Peerenboom, China Modernizes: Threat to the West or Model for the Rest? (2007).
93. D.C. Clarke 'Economic Development and the Rights Hypothesis: The China Problem' (2003) 51 Am. J. of Comparative Law 89-111
94. D. Acemoglu and S. Johnson, 'Unbundling Institutions' (2005) 113 J. of Political Economy 949-95
95. F. Upham, 'From Demsetz to Deng: Speculations on the Implications of Chinese Growth for Law and Development Theory' (2009) 41 NYU J. of Law & Politics 551-602.