Comparative performance of private and public healthcare systems in low- and middle-income countries: A systematic review

PLoS Medicine

Volumn 9, Issue 6, 2012, Pages 19-

  Basu, Sanjay ^a,b,c   Andrews, Jason ^d   Kishore, Sandeep ^e   Panjabi, Rajesh ^f   Stuckler, David ^c,g  

^a UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA   (United States)

^b SAN FRANCISCO GENERAL HOSPITAL   (United States)

^c LONDON SCHOOL OF HYGIENE AND TROPICAL MEDICINE   (United Kingdom)

^d MASSACHUSETTS GENERAL HOSPITAL   (United States)

^e WEILL CORNELL MEDICAL COLLEGE   (United States)

^f BRIGHAM AND WOMEN S HOSPITAL   (United States)

^g UNIVERSITY OF CAMBRIDGE   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; FUNDING; HEALTH CARE COST; HEALTH CARE DELIVERY; HEALTH CARE QUALITY; HEALTH CARE SYSTEM; HEALTH SERVICE; HUMAN; LOWEST INCOME GROUP; ORGANIZATION AND MANAGEMENT; PRIVATE HEALTH CARE SYSTEM; PRODUCTIVITY; PUBLIC HEALTH CARE SYSTEM; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW; WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION; COMPARATIVE STUDY; DEVELOPING COUNTRY; INCOME; REVIEW; STANDARD; TREATMENT OUTCOME;

DELIVERY OF HEALTH CARE; DEVELOPING COUNTRIES; HEALTH SERVICES ACCESSIBILITY; HUMANS; INCOME; PRIVATE SECTOR; PUBLIC SECTOR; QUALITY OF HEALTH CARE; TREATMENT OUTCOME;

EID: 84864690981     PISSN: 15491277     EISSN: 15491676     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1371/journal.pmed.1001244     Document Type: Article

References (114)

1. Berendes S, Heywood P, Oliver S, Garner P, (2011) Quality of private and public ambulatory health care in low and middle income countries: systematic review of comparative studies. PLoS Med 8: e1000433 doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.1000433.
2. Stuckler D, Basu S, Wang SW, McKee M, (2011) Does recession reduce global health aid? evidence from 15 high-income countries, 1975-2007. Bull World Health Organ 89: 252-257.
3. Stuckler D, Basu S, (2009) The International Monetary Fund's effects on global health: before and after the 2008 financial crisis. Int J Health Serv 39: 771-781.
4. Elliott L, (2009 October 1) Cut NHS costs to pay off debt, IMF warns Britain. The Guardian.
5. Oxfam (2009) Blind optimism: challenging the myths about private health care in poor countries. Oxford: Oxfam International.
6. World Bank (2009) World Bank responds to new Oxfam health report. Washington (District of Columbia): World Bank.
7. Harding A, (2009) Oxfam-this is not how to help the poor. Washington (District of Columbia): Center for Global Development.
8. Rosenthal G, Newbrander W, (1996) Public policy and private sector provision of health services. Int J Health Plann Manage 11: 203-216.
9. Montague D, Feachem R, Feachem NS, Koehlmoos TP, Kinlaw H, et al. (2009) Oxfam must shed its ideological bias to be taken seriously. BMJ 338: b1202.
10. Stocking B, (2009) Critique of Oxfam paper inaccurate, unconstructive and ideologically biased. BMJ 338: b667 [response]. Available:http://www.bmj.com/rapid-response/2011/11/02/critique-oxfam-paper-inaccurate-unconstructive-and-ideologically-biased. Accessed 22 May 2012.
11. Smith R, Feachem R, Feachem NS, Koehlmoos TP, Kinlaw H, (2009) The fallacy of impartiality: competing interest bias in academic publications. J R Soc Med 102: 44-45.
12. World Health Organization (2011) Global health observatory. Geneva: World Health Organization.
13. Murray C, Frenk J, (2000) World health report 2000: a step towards evidence-based health policy. Lancet 357: 1698-1700.
14. World Bank (2011) How we classify countries. Washington (District of Columbia): World Bank.
15. Gwatkin DR, Wagstaff A, Yazbeck AS, (2005) Reaching the poor with health, nutrition, and population services: what works, what doesn't, and why. Washington (District of Columbia): World Bank.
16. Agampodi SB, Amarasinghe DA, (2007) Private sector contribution to childhood immunization: Sri Lankan experience. Indian J Med Sci 61: 192-200.
17. Bustreo F, Harding A, Axelsson H, (2003) Can developing countries achieve adequate improvements in child health outcomes without engaging the private sector? Bull World Health Organ 81: 886-895.
18. Mbonye AK, Hansen KS, Wamono F, Magnussen P, (2009) Increasing access to prevention of mother-to-child transmission of HIV services through the private sector in Uganda. Sex Transm Infect 85: 534-539.
19. Wang W, Sulzbach S, De S, (2011) Utilization of HIV-related services from the private health sector: a multi-country analysis. Soc Sci Med 72: 216-223.
20. Prata N, Montagu D, Jefferys E, (2005) Private sector, human resources and health franchising in Africa. Bull World Health Organ 83: 274-279.
21. Gwatkin DR, (2000) Health inequalities and the health of the poor: what do we know? What can we do? Bull World Health Organ 78: 3-18.
22. World Bank (2011) Private health sector assessment in Ghana. Washington (District of Columbia): World Bank.
23. Brugha R, Pritze-Aliassime S, (2003) Promoting safe motherhood through the private sector in low- and middle-income countries. Bull World Health Organ 81: 616-623.
24. Gilson L, Alilio M, Heggenhougen K, (1994) Community satisfaction with primary health care services: an evaluation undertaken in the Morogoro region of Tanzania. Soc Sci Med 39: 767-780.
25. Lindelow M, Serneels P, (2006) The performance of health workers in Ethiopia: results from qualitative research. Soc Sci Med 62: 2225-2235.
26. Deressa W, Ali A, Hailemariam D, (2008) Malaria-related health-seeking behaviour and challenges for care providers in rural Ethiopia: implications for control. J Biosoc Sci 40: 115-135.
27. Lewis M, Eskeland G, Traa-Valerezo X, (2004) Primary health care in practice: is it effective? Health Policy 70: 303-325.
28. Hoa NB, Cobelens FG, Sy DN, Nhung NV, Borgdorff MW, et al. (2011) Diagnosis and treatment of tuberculosis in the private sector, Vietnam. Emerg Infect Dis 17: 562-564.
29. Turan JM, Bulut A, Nalbant H, Ortayli N, Akalin AA, (2006) The quality of hospital-based antenatal care in Istanbul. Stud Fam Plann 37: 49-60.
30. Lim MK, Yang H, Zhang T, Feng W, Zhou Z, (2004) Public perceptions of private health care in socialist China. Health Aff (Millwood) 23: 222-234.
31. Pongsupap Y, Van Lerberghe W, (2006) Choosing between public and private or between hospital and primary care: responsiveness, patient-centredness and prescribing patterns in outpatient consultations in Bangkok. Trop Med Int Health 11: 81-89.
32. Siddiqi S, Hamid S, Rafique G, Chaudhry SA, Ali N, et al. (2002) Prescription practices of public and private health care providers in Attock District of Pakistan. Int J Health Plann Manage 17: 23-40.
33. Bhatia J, Cleland J, (2004) Health care of female outpatients in south-central India: comparing public and private sector provision. Health Policy Plan 19: 402-409.
34. Brugha R, Zwi A, (1998) Improving the quality of private sector delivery of public health services: challenges and strategies. Health Policy Plan 13: 107-120.
35. Paphassarang C, Philavong K, Boupha B, Blas E, (2002) Equity, privatization and cost recovery in urban health care: the case of Lao PDR. Health Policy Plan 17 (Suppl) pp. 72-84.
36. World Bank (2005) Comparative advantages of public and private health care providers in Bangladesh. Dhaka: World Bank.
37. Auer C, Lagahid JY, Tanner M, Weiss MG, (2006) Diagnosis and management of tuberculosis by private practitioners in Manila, Philippines. Health Policy 77: 172-181.
38. Dato MI, Imaz MS, (2009) Tuberculosis control and the private sector in a low incidence setting in Argentina. Rev Salud Publica (Bogota) 11: 370-382.
39. Greaves F, Ouyang H, Pefole M, MacCarthy S, Cash RA, (2007) Compliance with DOTS diagnosis and treatment recommendations by private practitioners in Kerala, India. Int J Tuberc Lung Dis 11: 110-112.
40. Lambert ML, Delgado R, Michaux G, Volz A, van der Stuyft P, (2004) Tuberculosis control and the private health sector in Bolivia: a survey of pharmacies. Int J Tuberc Lung Dis 8: 1325-1329.
41. Naterop E, Wolffers I, (1999) The role of the privatization process on tuberculosis control in HoChiMinh City Province, Vietnam. Soc Sci Med 48: 1589-1598.
42. Udwadia ZF, Pinto LM, Uplekar MW, (2010) Tuberculosis management by private practitioners in Mumbai, India: has anything changed in two decades? PLoS ONE 5: e12023 doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0012023.
43. Vandan N, Ali M, Prasad R, Kuroiwa C, (2009) Assessment of doctors' knowledge regarding tuberculosis management in Lucknow, India: a public-private sector comparison. Public Health 123: 484-489.
44. Mahendradhata Y, Lambert ML, Boelaert M, van der Stuyft P, (2007) Engaging the private sector for tuberculosis control: much advocacy on a meagre evidence base. Trop Med Int Health 12: 315-316.
45. Ogwal-Okeng JW, Obua C, Waako P, Aupont O, Ross-Degnan D, (2004) A comparison of prescribing practices between public and private sector physicians in Uganda. East Afr Med J.
46. Uzochukwu BS, Chiegboka LO, Enwereuzo C, Nwosu U, Okorafor D, et al. (2010) Examining appropriate diagnosis and treatment of malaria: availability and use of rapid diagnostic tests and artemisinin-based combination therapy in public and private health facilities in south east Nigeria. BMC Public Health 10: 486.
47. Gbotosho GO, Happi CT, Ganiyu A, Ogundahunsi OA, Sowunmi A, et al. (2009) Potential contribution of prescription practices to the emergence and spread of chloroquine resistance in south-west Nigeria: caution in the use of artemisinin combination therapy. Malar J 8: 313.
48. Gupta S, Gunter JT, Novak RJ, Regens JL, (2009) Patterns of Plasmodium vivax and Plasmodium falciparum malaria underscore importance of data collection from private health care facilities in India. Malar J 8: 227.
49. Muhuri PK, Anker M, Bryce J, (1996) Treatment patterns for childhood diarrhoea: evidence from demographic and health surveys. Bull World Health Organ 74: 135-146.
50. Arrieta A, (2011) Health reform and cesarean sections in the private sector: the experience of Peru. Health Policy 99: 124-130.
51. Bateman C, (2008) Private sector cannot be left to 'own devices'. S Afr Med J 98: 77-78.
52. Makuch MY, Petta CA, Osis MJ, Bahamondes L, (2010) Low priority level for infertility services within the public health sector: a Brazilian case study. Hum Reprod 25: 430-435.
53. Justin-Temu M, Nondo RS, Wiedenmayer K, Ramaiya KL, Teuscher A, (2009) Anti-diabetic drugs in the private and public sector in Dar es Salaam, Tanzania. East Afr Med J 86: 110-114.
54. Connolly AM, Wilkinson D, Harrison A, Lurie M, Karim SS, (1999) Inadequate treatment for sexually transmitted diseases in the South African private health sector. Int J STD AIDS 10: 324-327.
55. Schneider H, Blaauw D, Dartnall E, Coetzee DJ, Ballard RC, (2001) STD care in the South African private health sector. S Afr Med J 91: 151-156.
56. Bate R, Coticelli P, Tren R, Attaran A, (2008) Antimalarial drug quality in the most severely malarious parts of Africa-a six country study. PLoS ONE 3: e2132 doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0002132.
57. Sengaloundeth S, Green MD, Fernandez FM, Manolin O, Phommavong K, et al. (2009) A stratified random survey of the proportion of poor quality oral artesunate sold at medicine outlets in the Lao PDR-implications for therapeutic failure and drug resistance. Malar J 8: 172.
58. Jacobs B, Whitworth J, Kambugu F, Pool R, (2004) Sexually transmitted disease management in Uganda's private-for-profit formal and informal sector and compliance with treatment. Sex Transm Dis 31: 650-654.
59. Schneider H, Palmer N, (2002) Getting to the truth? Researching user views of primary health care. Health Policy Plan 17: 32-41.
60. Russell S, (2005) Treatment-seeking behaviour in urban Sri Lanka: trusting the state, trusting private providers. Soc Sci Med 61: 1396-1407.
61. Chengsorn N, Bloss E, Anekvorapong R, Anuwatnonthakate A, Wattanaamornkiat W, et al. (2009) Tuberculosis services and treatment outcomes in private and public health care facilities in Thailand, 2004-2006. Int J Tuberc Lung Dis 13: 888-894.
62. Hong YP, Kim SJ, Lee EG, Lew WJ, Bai JY, (1999) Treatment of bacillary pulmonary tuberculosis at the chest clinics in the private sector in Korea, 1993. Int J Tuberc Lung Dis 3: 695-702.
63. Akhtar S, Rozi S, White F, Hasan R, (2011) Cohort analysis of directly observed treatment outcomes for tuberculosis patients in urban Pakistan. Int J Tuberc Lung Dis 15: 90-96.
64. Bisson GP, Frank I, Gross R, Lo Re V 3rd, Strom JB, et al. (2006) Out-of-pocket costs of HAART limit HIV treatment responses in Botswana's private sector. AIDS 20: 1333-1336.
65. Howard DH, Roy K, (2004) Private care and public health: do vaccination and prenatal care rates differ between users of private versus public sector care in India? Health Serv Res 39: 2013-2026.
66. Soeung SC, Grundy J, Morn C, Samnang C, (2008) Evaluation of immunization knowledge, practices, and service-delivery in the private sector in Cambodia. J Health Popul Nutr 26: 95-104.
67. De Groote T, De Paepe P, Unger JP, (2005) Colombia: in vivo test of health sector privatization in the developing world. Int J Health Serv 35: 125-141.
68. Giffin K, (1994) Women's health and the privatization of fertility control in Brazil. Soc Sci Med 39: 355-360.
69. Fiedler JL, (1996) The privatization of health care in three Latin American social security systems. Health Policy Plan 11: 406-417.
70. Masjedi MR, Fadaizadeh L, Taghizadeh Asl R, (2007) Notification of patients with tuberculosis detected in the private sector, Tehran, Iran. Int J Tuberc Lung Dis 11: 882-886.
71. Peters DH, Mirchandani GG, Hansen PM, (2004) Strategies for engaging the private sector in sexual and reproductive health: how effective are they? Health Policy Plan 19: i5-i21.
72. Patouillard E, Goodman CA, Hanson KG, Mills AJ, (2007) Can working with the private for-profit sector improve utilization of quality health services by the poor? A systematic review of the literature. Int J Equity Health 6: 17.
73. Singh A, Mavalankar DV, Bhat R, Desai A, Patel SR, et al. (2009) Providing skilled birth attendants and emergency obstetric care to the poor through partnership with private sector obstetricians in Gujarat, India. Bull World Health Organ 87: 960-964.
74. Kumaranayake L, (1997) The role of regulation: influencing private sector activity within health sector reform. J Int Dev 9: 641-649.
75. Kumaranayake L, Mujinja P, Hongoro C, Mpembeni R, (2000) How do countries regulate the health sector? Evidence from Tanzania and Zimbabwe. Health Policy Plan 15: 357-367.
76. Hongoro C, Kumaranayake L, (2000) Do they work? Regulating for-profit providers in Zimbabwe. Health Policy Plan 15: 368-377.
77. Wilkinson D, Karim SS, Lurie M, Harrison A, (2001) Public-private health sector partnerships for STD control in South Africa-perspectives from the Hlabisa experience. S Afr Med J 91: 517-520.
78. World Bank (2011) Healthy partnerships: how governments can engage the private sector to improve health in Africa. Washington (District of Columbia): World Bank.
79. Blumenthal D, Hsiao W, (2005) Privatization and its discontents-the evolving Chinese health care system. N Engl J Med 353: 1165-1170.
80. Van Den Heever AM, (1998) Private sector health reform in South Africa. Health Econ 7: 281-289.
81. Sharma S, Dayaratna V, (2005) Creating conditions for greater private sector participation in achieving contraceptive security. Health Policy 71: 347-357.
82. Benson JS, (2001) The impact of privatization on access in Tanzania. Soc Sci Med 52: 1903-1915.
83. Scarpaci JL, (1987) HMO promotion and the privatization of health care in Chile. J Health Polit Policy Law 12: 551-567.
84. Waitzkin H, Jasso-Aguilar R, Iriart C, (2007) Privatization of health services in less developed countries: an empirical response to the proposals of the World Bank and Wharton School. Int J Health Serv 37: 205-227.
85. Larson CP, Saha UR, Islam R, Roy N, (2006) Childhood diarrhoea management practices in Bangladesh: private sector dominance and continued inequities in care. Int J Epidemiol 35: 1430-1439.
86. Yoong J, Burger N, Spreng C, Sood N, (2010) Private sector participation and health system performance in sub-saharan Africa. PLoS ONE 5: e13243 doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0013243.
87. Agha S, Do M, (2008) Does an expansion in private sector contraceptive supply increase inequality in modern contraceptive use? Health Policy Plan 23: 465-475.
88. Loevinsohn B, Harding A, (2005) Buying results? Contracting for health service delivery in developing countries. Lancet 366: 676-681.
89. Decker M, Montagu D, (2007) Reaching youth through franchise clinics: assessment of Kenyan private sector involvement in youth services. J Adolesc Health 40: 280-282.
90. Fiedler JL, Wight JB, (2003) Privatization and the allure of franchising: a Zambian feasibility study. Int J Health Plann Manage 18: 179-204.
91. Schwartz JB, Bhushan I, (2004) Improving immunization equity through a public-private partnership in Cambodia. Bull World Health Organ 82: 661-667.
92. Mavalankar D, Singh A, Patel SR, Desai A, Singh PV, (2009) Saving mothers and newborns through an innovative partnership with private sector obstetricians: Chiranjeevi scheme of Gujarat, India. Int J Gynaecol Obstet 107: 271-276.
93. Babar ZD, Izham MI, (2009) Effect of privatization of the drug distribution system on drug prices in Malaysia. Public Health 123: 523-533.
94. Broomberg J, De Beer C, Price MR, (1990) The private health sector in South Africa-current trends and future developments. S Afr Med J 78: 139-142; discussion 142-133.
95. Price MR, (1990) A comparison of prescribing patterns and consequent costs at Alexandra Health Centre and in the private fee-for-service medical aid sector. S Afr Med J 78: 158-160.
96. Patel V, Vaidya R, Naik D, Borker P, (2005) Irrational drug use in India: a prescription survey from Goa. J Postgrad Med 51: 9-12.
97. Lambert ML, Delgado R, Michaux G, Volz A, Speybroeck N, et al. (2005) Delays to treatment and out-of-pocket medical expenditure for tuberculosis patients, in an urban area of South America. Ann Trop Med Parasitol 99: 781-787.
98. Lambert ML, Delgado R, Michaux G, Vols A, Speybroeck N, et al. (2005) Collaboration between private pharmacies and national tuberculosis programme: an intervention in Bolivia. Trop Med Int Health 10: 246-250.
99. International Finance Corporation (2007) The Business of health in Africa: partnering with the private sector to improve people's lives. Washington (District of Columbia): International Finance Corporation.
100. Maiga FI, Haddad S, Fournier P, Gauvin L, (2003) Public and private sector responses to essential drugs policies: a multilevel analysis of drug prescription and selling practices in Mali. Soc Sci Med 57: 937-948.
101. Sekhri N, Feachem R, Ni A, (2011) Public-private integrated partnerships demonstrate the potential to improve health care access, quality, and efficiency. Health Aff (Millwood) 30: 1498-1507.
102. Chabikuli N, Schneider H, Blaauw D, Zwi AB, Brugha R, (2002) Quality and equity of private sector care for sexually transmitted diseases in South Africa. Health Policy Plan 17 (Suppl): 40-46.
103. Stuckler D, Basu S, McKee M, (2011) Health care capacity and allocations among South Africa's provinces: infrastructure-inequality traps after the end of apartheid. Am J Public Health 101: 165-172.
104. Birungi H, Mugisha F, Nsabagasani X, Okuonzi S, Jeppsson A, (2001) The policy on public-private mix in the Ugandan health sector: catching up with reality. Health Policy Plan 16: 80-87.
105. Hensley S, (1999) Brazilian healthcare at a crossroads. Private sector flourishes as the government's program buckles under heavy demand, lack of funding. Mod Healthc 29: 34-36
106. Sengupta A, Nundy S, (2005) The private health sector in India. BMJ 331: 1157-1158.
107. De Costa A, Diwan V, (2007) 'Where is the public health sector?' Public and private sector healthcare provision in Madhya Pradesh, India. Health Policy 84: 269-276.
108. World Bank (2009) New private equity fund launched to strengthen health care in Africa. Washington (District of Columbia): International Finance Corporation.
109. Black N, Barker M, Payne M, (2004) Cross sectional survey of multicentre clinical databases in the United Kingdom. London: BMJ 328: 1478.
110. Palmer N, (2000) The use of private-sector contracts for primary health care: theory, evidence and lessons for low-income and middle-income countries. Bull World Health Organ 78: 821-829.
111. Campbell SM, Reeves D, Kontopantelis E, Sibbald B, Roland M, (2009) Effects of pay for performance on the quality of primary care in England. N Engl J Med 361: 368-378.
112. Maru DS, Sharma A, Andrews J, Basu S, Thapa J, et al. (2009) Global health delivery 2.0: using open-access technologies for transparency and operations research. PLoS Med 6: e1000158 doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.1000158.
113. Gold MR, Siegel JE, Russell LB, Weinstein MC, (1996) Cost-effectiveness in health and medicine. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
114. World Health Organization (2011) World health statistics 2011. Available:http://www.who.int/whosis/whostat/EN_WHS2011_Full.pdf. Accessed 15 May 2012.