Can the joint effect of ternary mixtures be predicted from binary mixture toxicity results?

Science of the Total Environment

Volumn 427-428, Issue , 2012, Pages 229-237

  Cedergreen, Nina ^a   Sørensen, Helle ^a   Svendsen, Claus ^b  

^a UNIVERSITY OF COPENHAGEN   (Denmark)

^b CENTRE FOR ECOLOGY AND HYDROLOGY   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Antagony; Mixtures toxicity; Modelling; Risk assessment; Synergy

Indexed keywords

ANTAGONY; BINARY INTERACTIONS; CHEMICAL MIXTURES; CONCENTRATION ADDITION; JOINT EFFECT; LEMNA MINOR; MIXTURE TOXICITY; MODEL PREDICTION; MODELLING; REFERENCE MODELS; ROBUST ESTIMATION; SYNERGY; TERNARY MIXTURES; VIBRIO FISCHERI;

FORECASTING; MODELS; RISK ASSESSMENT; TOXICITY;

BINARY MIXTURES;

ACIFLUORFEN; CLOFENVINFOS; DIMETHOATE; DIQUAT; GLYPHOSATE; HERBICIDE; MECOPROP; MESOTRIONE; PROCHLORAZ; TERBUTYLAZINE; UNCLASSIFIED DRUG;

CHEMICAL COMPOUND; MODELING; RISK ASSESSMENT; TOXICITY;

ARTICLE; CHEMICAL INTERACTION; CONCENTRATION RESPONSE; DRUG ANTAGONISM; DRUG POTENTIATION; HYPOTHESIS; LEMNA MINOR; MATHEMATICAL ANALYSIS; MATHEMATICAL MODEL; NONHUMAN; PREDICTION; PRIORITY JOURNAL; RISK ASSESSMENT; TOXICITY TESTING; VIBRIO FISCHERI;

ALIIVIBRIO FISCHERI; ARACEAE; DOSE-RESPONSE RELATIONSHIP, DRUG; ENVIRONMENTAL POLLUTANTS; FUNGICIDES, INDUSTRIAL; HERBICIDES; INSECTICIDES; MODELS, BIOLOGICAL; REPRODUCIBILITY OF RESULTS; RISK ASSESSMENT; TOXICITY TESTS;

LEMNA MINOR; VIBRIO FISCHERI;

EID: 84861194924     PISSN: 00489697     EISSN: 18791026     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2012.03.086     Document Type: Article

References (47)

1. Altenburger R., Backhaus T., Boedeker W., Faust M., Scholze M., Grimme L.H. Predictability of the toxicity of multiple chemical mixtures to Vibrio fischeri: mixtures composed of similarly acting chemicals. Environ Toxicol Chem 2000, 19:2341-2347.
2. Altenburger R., Nenza M., Schüürmann G. Mixture toxicity and its modeling by quantitative structure-activity relationships. Environ Toxicol Chem 2003, 22:1900-1915.
3. Arrhenius A., Gronvall F., Scholze M., Backhaus T., Blanck H. Predictability of the mixture toxicity of 12 similarly acting congeneric inhibitors of photosystem II in marine periphyton and epipsammon communities. Aquat Toxicol 2004, 68:351-367.
4. Baas J., Willems J., Jager T., Kraak M.H.S., Vandenbrouck T., Kooijman S.A.L.M. Prediction of daphnid survival after in situ exposure to complex mixtures. Environ Sci Technol 2009, 43:6064-6069.
5. Backhaus T., Altenburger R., Boedeker W., Faust M., Scholze M., Grimme L.H. Predictability of the toxicity of multiple mixture of dissimilarly acting chemicals to Vibrio fischeri. Environ Toxicol Chem 2000, 19:2348-2356.
6. Belden J.B., Gilliom R.J., Lydy M.J. How well can we predict the toxicity of pesticide mixtures to aquatic life?. Integr Environ Assess Manag 2007, 3:364-372.
7. Cedergreen N., Kamper A., Streibig J.C. Is prochloraz a potent synergist across species? A study on bacteria, daphnia, algae and higher plants. Aquat Toxicol 2006, 78:243-252.
8. Cedergreen N., Kudsk P., Mathiassen S.K., Sørensen H., Streibig J.C. The reproducibility of binary mixture toxicity studies. Environ Toxicol Chem 2007, 26:149-156.
9. Cedergreen N., Kudsk P., Matthiasen S., Streibig J.C. Combination effects of herbicides: do species and test system matter?. Pest Manag Sci 2007, 63:282-295.
10. Cedergreen N., Christensen A.M., Kamper A., Kudsk P., Matthiasen S., Streibig J.C., et al. A review of independent action as a reference model for binary mixtures of compounds with different molecular target sites. Environ Toxicol Chem 2008, 27:1621-1632.
11. Chalvet-Monfray K., Auger P., Belzunces L.P., Fléche C., Sabatier P. Modelling based methods for pharmacokinetic hypotheses test. Acta Biotheor 1996, 44:335-348.
12. Charles G.D., Gennings C., Zacharewski T.R., Gollapudi B.B., Carney E.W. An approach for assessing estrogen receptor-mediated interactions in mixtures of three chemicals: a pilot study. Toxicol Sci 2002, 68:349-360.
13. Cooper N.L., Bidwell J.R., Kumar A. Toxicity of copper, lead, and zinc mixtures to Ceriodaphnia dubia and Daphnia carinata. Ecotoxicol Environ Saf 2009, 72:1523-1528.
14. El-Merhibi A., Kumar A., Smeaton T. Role of piperonyl butoxide in the toxicity of chlorpyrifos to Ceriodaphnia dubia and Xenopus laevis. Ecotoxicol Environ Saf 2004, 57:202-212.
15. European Council Directive 1999/45/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 31 May 1999 concerning the approximation of the laws, regulations and administrative provisions of the Member States relating to classification, packaging and labelling of dangerous preparations 1999, 1-68.
16. Faust M., Altenburger R., Backhaus T., Blanck H., Boedeker W., Gramatica P., et al. Predicting the joint algal toxicity of multi-component s-triazine mixtures at low-effect concentrations of individual toxicants. Aquat Toxicol 2001, 56:13-32.
17. Faust M., Altenburger R., Backhaus T., Blanck H., Boedeker W., Gramatica P., et al. Joint algal toxicity of 16 dissimilarly acting chemicals is predictable by the concept of independent action. Aquat Toxicol 2003, 63:43-63.
18. George T.K., Liber K., Solomon K.R., Sibley P.K. Assessment of the probabilistic ecological risk assessment-toxic equivalent combination approach for evaluating pesticide mixture toxicity to zooplankton in outdoor microcosms. Arch Environ Contam Toxicol 2003, 45:453-461.
19. Gilliom R.J., Barbach J.E., Kolpin D.W., Larson S.J. Testing water quality for pesticide pollution. Environ Sci Technol 1999, 33:164A-169A.
20. Greco W.R., Unkelbach H.D., Pöch G., Sühnel J., Kundi M., Bödeker W. Consenses on concepts and terminology for combined-action assessment: the Saariselkä Agreement. ACES 1992, 4:65-69.
21. Greco W.R., Bravo G., Parsons J.C. The search for synergy: a critical review from a response surface perspective. Pharmacol Rev 1995, 47:332-385.
22. Grimme L.H., Backhaus T. Bridging effect assessment of mixtures to ecosystem situations and regulation. BEAM. Final Summary Report 2003, 1-23.
23. Jensen J.P., Søndergaard M., Jeppesen E., Bjerring Olsen R., Landkildehus F., Lauridsen T.L., Sortkjær L., Poulsen A.M. Søer 1999. NOVA 2003 2000, 335:1-108. Miljøundersøgelser, Danmarks.
24. Jonker M.J., Svendsen C., Bedaux J.J.M., Bongers M., Kammenga J.E. Significance testing of synergistic/antagonistic, dose level-dependent, or dose ratio-dependent effects in mixture dose-response analysis. Environ Toxicol Chem 2005, 24:2701-2713.
25. Junghans M., Backhaus T., Faust M., Scholze M., Grimme L.H. Application and validation of approaches for the predictive hazard assessment of realistic pesticide mixtures. Aquat Toxicol 2006, 76:93-110.
26. Koutsaftis A., Aoyama I. Toxicity of four antifouling biocides and their mixtures on the brine shrimp Artemia salina. Sci Total Environ 2007, 387:166-174.
27. Lin Z., Ping Z., Kong D., Yin K., Cai Z. The ratios of individual chemicals in a mixture determine the degree of joint effect: the climax hypothesis. Arch Environ Contam Toxicol 2005, 49:1-8.
28. McCarty L.S., Borgert C.J. Review of the toxicity of chemical mixtures containing at least one organochlorine. Regul Toxicol Pharmacol 2006, 45:104-118.
29. Munkegaard M., Abbaspoor M., Cedergreen N. Organophosphorous insecticides as herbicide synergists on the green algae Pseudokirchneriella subcapitata and the aquatic plant Lemna minor. Ecotoxicology 2008, 17:29-35.
30. Neter N., Kutner H.K., Nachtsheim C.J., Wasserman W. Applied linear statistical models 1996, WCB/McGraw-Hill, Boston, Massachusetts.
31. Nørgaard K.B., Cedergreen N. Pesticide cocktails can interact synergistically on aquatic crustaceans. Environ Sci Pollut Res 2010, 17:957-967.
32. Pilling E.D., Jepson P.C. Synergism between EBI fungicides and a pyrethroid insecticide in the honeybee (Apis-Mellifera). Pest Sci 1993, 39:293-297.
33. Ren S.J., Mee R.W., Frymier P.D. Using factorial experiments to study the toxicity of metal mixtures. Ecotoxicol Environ Saf 2004, 59:38-43.
34. Ritz C. Towards a unified approach to dose-response modeling in ecotoxicology 2010.
35. Rosal R., Rodea-Palomares I., Boltes K., Fernandez-Pinas F., Leganes F., Petre A. Ecotoxicological assessment of surfactants in the aquatic environment: combined toxicity of docusate sodium with chlorinated pollutants. Chemosphere 2010, 81:288-293.
36. Sørensen H., Cedergreen N., Skovgaard I., Streibig J.C. An isobole-based statistical model and test for synergism/antagonism in binary mixture toxicity experiments. Environ Ecol Stat 2007, 14:383-398.
37. Sprague J.B. Measurement of pollutant toxicity to fish. 2. Utilizing and applying bioassay results. Water Res 1970, 4:3-&.
38. Streibig J.C., Kudsk P., Jensen J.E. A general joint action model for herbicide mixtures. Pest Sci 1998, 53:21-28.
39. Syberg K. Mixture toxicity and European chemical regulations 2009, 1-75. Roskilde University, Denmark.
40. Syberg K., Jensen T.S., Cedergreen N., Rank J. On the use of mixture toxicity assessment in REACH and the water framework directive: a review. Hum Ecol Risk Assess 2009, 15:1257-1272.
41. Thompson H.M. Interactions between pesticides; a review of reported effects and their implications for wildlife risk assessment. Ecotoxicology 1996, 5:59-81.
42. Tomlin C.D.S. The e-pesticide manual 2002, British Crop Protection Council, Surrey, [2.2]. 2002. C.D.S. Tomlin (Ed.).
43. Varsano R., Rabinowitch H.D., Ruben B. Mode of action of piperonyl butoxide as herbicide synergist of atrazine and terbutryn in maize. Pestic Biochem Physiol 1992, 44:174-182.
44. Walker C.H. Factors determining the toxicity of organic pollutants to animals and plants. Organic pollutants 2009, 17-66. CRC Press, London.
45. Wang H., Li Y., Huang H.H., Xu X., Wang Y.H. Toxicity evaluation of single and mixed antifouling biocides using the Strongylocentrotus intermedius sea urchin embryo test. Environ Toxicol Chem 2011, 30:692-703.
46. Warne M.S.J., Hawker D.W. The number of components in a mixture determines whether synergistic and antagonistic or additive toxicity predominate - the funnel hypothesis. Ecotoxicol Environ Saf 1995, 31:23-28.
47. Woods M., Kumar A., Correll R. Acute toxicity of mixtures of chlorpyrifos, profenofos, and endosulfan to Ceriodaphnia dubia. Bull Environ Contam Toxicol 2002, 68:801-808.