Analyzing cause and effect in environmental assessments: Using weighted evidence from the literature

Freshwater Science

Volumn 31, Issue 1, 2012, Pages 5-21

  Norris, R H ^a   Webb, J A ^b   Nichols, S J ^a   Stewardson, M J ^b   Harrison, E T ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF CANBERRA   (Australia)

^b UNIVERSITY OF MELBOURNE   (Australia)

Author keywords

Causal criteria analysis; Causal inference; Causality; Eco Evidence; Environmental assessment; Systematic review; Weak inference

Indexed keywords

DECISION MAKING; ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT; ENVIRONMENTAL STRESS; EPIDEMIOLOGY; FRESHWATER ENVIRONMENT; GRANGER CAUSALITY TEST; LITERATURE REVIEW; SOFTWARE;

EID: 84858848083     PISSN: 21619549     EISSN: 21619565     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1899/11-027.1     Document Type: Review

References (63)

1. ADAMS, S. M. 2005. Assessing cause and effect of multiple stressors on marine systems. Marine Pollution Bulletin 51:649-657.
2. BEYERS, D. W. 1998. Causal inference in environmental impact studies. Journal of the North American Benthological Society 17:367-373.
3. BUCK, C. 1975. Popper's philosophy for epidemiologists. International Journal of Epidemiology 4:159-168.
4. BURKHARDT-HOLM, P., AND K. SCHEURER. 2007. Application of the weight-of-evidence approach to assess the decline of brown trout (Salmo trutta) in Swiss rivers. Aquatic Sciences 69:51-70.
5. COLLIER, T. K. 2003. Forensic ecotoxicology: Establishing causality between contaminants and biological effects in field studies. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment 9: 259-266.
6. CORMIER, S. M., S. B. NORTON, G. W. SUTER, D. ALTFATER, AND B. COUNTS. 2002. Determining the causes of impairments in the Little Scioto River, Ohio, USA: Part 2. Characterization of causes. Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry 21:1125-1137.
7. CORMIER, S. M., G. W. SUTER, AND S. B. NORTON. 2010. Causal characteristics for ecoepidemiology. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment 16:53-73.
8. DOWNES, B. J., L. A. BARMUTA, P. G. FAIRWEATHER, D. P. FAITH, M. J. KEOUGH, P. S. LAKE, B. D. MAPSTONE, AND G. P. QUINN. 2002. Monitoring ecological impacts: Concepts and practice in flowing waters. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK.
9. EVANS, A. S. 1976. Causation and disease: Henle-Koch postulates revisited. Yale Journal of Biology and Medicine 49:175-195.
10. EWATER CRC (EWATER COOPERATIVE RESEARCH CENTRE). 2010. Eco Evidence: A systematic approach to evaluate causality in environmental science. eWater Cooperative Research Centre, Canberra, Australia. (Available from: Www.toolkit.net.au/tools/eco-evidence)
11. FABRICIUS, K. E., AND G. DE'ATH. 2004. Identifying ecological change and its causes: A case study on coral reefs. Ecological Applications 14:1448-1465.
12. FOX, G. A. 1991. Practical causal inference for ecoepidemiologists. Journal of Toxicology and Environmental Health 33:359-373.
13. GREEN, R. H. 1979. Sampling design and statistical methods for environmental biologists. Wiley, New York.
14. GREENLAND, S. 1998. Meta-analysis. Pages 643-673 in K. J. Rothman and S. Greenland (editors). Modern epidemiology. Lippincott-Raven, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.
15. GREET, J., J. A. WEBB, AND R. D. COUSENS. 2011. The importance of seasonal flow timing for riparian vegetation dynamics: A systematic review using causal criteria analysis. Freshwater Biology 56:1231-1247.
16. GROVE, J. R., J. A. WEBB, P. M. MARREN, M. J. STEWARDSON, AND S. R. WEALANDS. High and dry: An investigation using the causal criteria methodology to investigate the effects of regulation, and subsequent environmental flows, on floodplain geomorphology. Wetlands (in press). doi: 10.1007/s13157-011-0253-99
17. GUREVITCH, J., AND L. V. HEDGES. 2001. Meta-analysis: Combining the results of independent experiments. Pages 346-369 in S. M. Scheiner and J. Gurevitch (editors). Design and analysis of ecological experiments. Oxford University Press, New York.
18. HAAKE, D. M., T. WILTON, K. KRIER, A. J. STEWART, AND S. M. CORMIER. 2010. Causal assessment of biological impairment in the Little Floyd River, Iowa, USA. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment 16:116-148.
19. HARRISON, E. T. 2010. Fine sediment in rivers: Scale of ecological outcomes. PhD Dissertation, University of Canberra, Canberra, Australia. (Available from: http://tinyurl.com/Harrison-2010)
20. HILL, A. B. 1965. The environment and disease: Association or causatioñProceedings of the Royal Society of Medicine 58:295-300.
21. JOHNSON, D. H. 2002. The importance of replication in wildlife research. Journal of Wildlife Management 66: 919-932.
22. KORICHEVA, J. 2003. Non-significant results in ecology: A burden or a blessing in disguise? Oikos 102:397-401.
23. LOWELL, R. B., J. M. CULP, AND M. G. DUBE. 2000. A weight-ofevidence approach for Northern River risk assessment: Integrating the effects of multiple stressors. Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry 19:1182-1190.
24. MORABIA, A. 1991. On the origin of Hill's causal criteria. Epidemiology 2:367-369.
25. NICHOLS, S., A. WEBB, R. NORRIS, AND M. STEWARDSON. 2011. Eco Evidence analysis methods manual: A systematic approach to evaluate causality in environmental science. eWater Cooperative Research Centre, Canberra, Australia. (Available from: http://tinyurl.com/Eco-Evidence-manual)
26. NORRIS, R. H., P. LISTON, J. MUGODO, S. NICHOLS, G. P. QUINN, P. COTTINGHAM, L. METZELING, S. PERRISS, D. ROBINSON, TILLER, AND G. WILSON. 2005. Multiple lines and levels of evidence for detecting ecological responses to management intervention. Pages 456-463 in I. D. Rutherfurd, I. Wiszniewski, M. J. Askey-Doran, and R. Glazik (editors). Proceedings of the 4th Australian Stream Management Conference: Linking Rivers to Landscapes. Department of Primary Industries, Water and Environment, Launceston, Tasmania. (Available from: Http://tinyurl.com/Norris-et-al-2005)
27. NORTON, S. B., S. M. CORMIER, G. W. SUTER, K. SCHOFIELD, L. YUAN, P. SHAW-ALLEN, AND C. R. ZIEGLER. 2008. CADDIS: The causal analysis/diagnosis decision information system. Pages 351-374 in A. Marcomini, G. W. Suter, and A. Critto (editors). Decision support systems for risk-based management of contaminated sites. Springer, New York.
28. OSENBERG, C. W., O. SARNELLE, AND D. E. GOLDBERG. 1999. Meta-analysis in ecology: Concepts, statistics, and applications. Ecology 80:1103-1104.
29. PLATT, J. R. 1964. Strong inference: Certain systematic methods of scientific thinking may produce much more rapid progress than others. Science 146:347-353.
30. PLOWRIGHT, R. K., S. H. SOKOLOW, M. E. GORMAN, P. DASZAK, AND J. E. FOLEY. 2008. Causal inference in disease ecology: Investigating ecological drivers of disease emergence. Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment 6:420-429.
31. POPPER, K. R. 1980. The logic of scientific discovery. Hutchinson, London, UK.
32. POPPER, K. R. 1983. Realism and the aim of science: Postscript to the logic of scientific discovery. Hutchinson, London, UK.
33. PULLIN, A. S., AND T. M. KNIGHT. 2001. Effectiveness in conservation practice: Pointers from medicine and public health. Conservation Biology 15:50-54.
34. PULLIN, A. S., T. M. KNIGHT, AND A. R. WATKINSON. 2009. Linking reductionist science and holistic policy using systematic reviews: Unpacking environmental policy questions to construct an evidence-based framework. Journal of Applied Ecology 46:970-975.
35. PULLIN, A. S., AND G. B. STEWART. 2006. Guidelines for systematic review in conservation and environmental management. Conservation Biology 20:1647-1656.
36. ROTHMAN, K. J. 2002. Epidemiology: An introduction. Oxford University Press, New York.
37. ROTHMAN, K. J., S. GREENLAND, AND T. L. LASH. 2008. Modern epidemiology. Wolters Kluwer Health/Lippincott Williams and Wilkins, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.
38. SLAVIN, R. E. 1995. Best evidence synthesis: An intelligent alternative to meta-analysis. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology 48:9-18.
39. SONG, F. J., K. S. KHAN, J. DINNES, AND A. J. SUTTON. 2002. Asymmetric funnel plots and publication bias in metaanalyses of diagnostic accuracy. International Journal of Epidemiology 31:88-95.
40. STEVENS, A., AND R. MILNE. 1997. The effectiveness revolution and public health. Pages 197-225 in G. Scally (editor). Progress in public health. Royal Society of Medicine Press, London, UK.
41. STEWART, G. B., H. R. BAYLISS, D. A. SHOWLER, A. S. PULLIN, AND W. J. SUTHERLAND. 2006. Does the use of in-stream structures and woody debris increase the abundance of salmonids? Collaboration for Environmental Evidence. (Available from: Http://www.environmentalevidence. org/SR12.html).
42. SUSSER, M. 1986a. Rules of inference in epidemiology. Regulatory Toxicology and Pharmacology 6:116-128.
43. SUSSER, M. 1986b. The logic of Sir Karl Popper and the practice of epidemiology. American Journal of Epidemiology 124:711-718.
44. SUTER, G. W., AND S. M. CORMIER. 2011. Why and how to combine evidence in environmental assessments: Weighing evidence and building cases. Science of the Total Environment 409:1406-1417.
45. SUTER, G. W., S. B. NORTON, AND S. M. CORMIER. 2002. A methodology for inferring the causes of observed impairments in aquatic ecosystems. Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry 21:1101-1111.
46. SUTER, G. W., S. B. NORTON, AND S. M. CORMIER. 2010. The science and philosophy of a method for assessing environmental causes. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment 16:19-34.
47. SUTHERLAND, W. J., A. S. PULLIN, P. M. DOLMAN, AND T. M. KNIGHT. 2004. The need for evidence-based conservation. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 19:305-308.
48. SUTTON, A. J., AND J. P. I. HIGGINS. 2008. Recent developments in meta-analysis. Statistics in Medicine 27:625-650.
49. TUGWELL, B., AND R. B. HAYNES. 2006. Assessing claims of causation. Pages 356-387 in R. B. Haynes, D. L. Sackett, G. H. Guyatt, and P. Tugwell (editors). Clinical epidemiology: How to do clinical practice research. Lippincott Williams and Wilkins, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.
50. UNDERWOOD, A. J. 1997. Experiments in ecology: Their logical design and interpretation using analysis of variance. Cambridge University Press, New York.
51. USDHEW (US DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH, EDUCATION, AND WELFARE). 1964. Smoking and health. Report of the advisory committee to the Surgeon General of the Public Health Service. US Department of Health, Education, and Welfare, Washington, DC.
52. VAN SICKLE, J., AND S. G. PAULSEN. 2008. Assessing the attributable risks, relative risks, and regional extents of aquatic stressors. Journal of the North American Benthological Society 27:920-931.
53. VAN SICKLE, J., J. L. STODDARD, S. G. PAULSEN, AND A. R. OLSEN. 2006. Using relative risk to compare the effects of aquatic stressors at a regional scale. Environmental Management 38:1020-1030.
54. WARD, A. C. 2009. The role of causal criteria in causal inferences: Bradford Hill's ''aspects of association''. Epidemiologic Perspectives and Innovations 6. doi:10.1186/1742-5573-6-22
55. WEALANDS, S. R., J. A. WEBB, AND M. J. STEWARDSON. 2009. Evidence-based model structure: The role of causal analysis in hydro-ecological modelling. Pages 2465-24711 in R. S. Anderssen, R. D. Braddock, and L. T. H. Newham (editors). 18th World IMACS Congress and MODSIM09 International Congress on Modelling and Simulation.
56. Modelling and Simulation Society of Australia and New Zealand and International Association for Mathematics and Computers in Simulation, Cairns, Australia. (Available from: Http://tinyurl.com/ybcb3we)
57. WEBB, J. A., S. J. NICHOLS, R. H. NORRIS, M. J. STEWARDSON, S. R. WEALANDS, AND P. LEA. Ecological responses to flow alteration: Assessing causal relationships with Eco Evidence. Wetlands (in press a). doi: 10.1007/s13157-011-0249-55
58. WEBB, J. A., S. R. WEALANDS, P. LEA, S. J. NICHOLS, S. C. De LITTLE, M. J. STEWARDSON, AND R. H. NORRIS. Eco Evidence: Using the scientific literature to inform evidence-based decision making in environmental management. In F. Chan, D. Marinova and R. S. Anderssen (editors). MODSIM2011 International Congress on Modelling and Simulation. Modelling and Simulation Society of Australia and New Zealand, Australia (in press b).
59. WEED, D. L. 1997. On the use of causal criteria. International Journal of Epidemiology 26:1137-1141.
60. WEED, D. L. 2000. Interpreting epidemiological evidence: How meta-analysis and causal inference methods are related. International Journal of Epidemiology 29:387-390.
61. WEED, D. L. 2002. Environmental epidemiology: Basics and proof of cause-effect. Toxicology 181:399-403.
62. WEED, D. L., AND L. S. GORELIC. 1996. The practice of causal inference in cancer epidemiology. Cancer Epidemiology Biomarkers and Prevention 5:303-311.
63. WISEMAN, C. D., M. LEMOINE, AND S. CORMIER. 2010. Assessment of probable causes of reduced aquatic life in the Touchet River, Washington, USA. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment 16:87-115.