The importance of seasonal flow timing for riparian vegetation dynamics: A systematic review using causal criteria analysis

Freshwater Biology

Volumn 56, Issue 7, 2011, Pages 1231-1247

  Greet, Joe ^a,b   Angus Webb, J ^a,b   Cousens, Roger D ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF MELBOURNE   (Australia)

^b Water Cooperative Research Centre   (Australia)

Author keywords

Flow inversion; Hydrochory; Regulation; Riverine plants; Seasonal timing; Wetland flora

Indexed keywords

EID: 79958714058     PISSN: 00465070     EISSN: 13652427     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1365-2427.2011.02564.x     Document Type: Review

References (107)

1. Adams S.M. (2005) Assessing cause and effect of multiple stressors on marine systems. Marine Pollution Bulletin, 51, 649-657.
2. Andersson E. & Nilsson C. (2002) Temporal variation in the drift of plant litter and propagules in a small boreal river. Freshwater Biology, 47, 1674-1684.
3. Andersson E., Nilsson C. & Johansson M.E. (2000a) Effects of river fragmentation on plant dispersal and riparian flora. Regulated Rivers: Research and Management, 16, 83-89.
4. Andersson E., Nilsson C. & Johansson M.E. (2000b) Plant dispersal in boreal rivers and its relation to the diversity of riparian flora. Journal of Biogeography, 27, 1095-1106.
5. Baldwin A.H., Egnotovich M.S. & Clarke E. (2001) Hydrologic change and vegetation of tidal freshwater marshes: field, greenhouse, and seed-bank experiments. Wetlands, 21, 519-531.
6. Beauchamp V.B. & Stromberg J.C. (2007) Flow regulation of the Verde River, Arizona encourages Tamarix recruitment but has minimal effect on Populus and Salix stand density. Wetlands, 27, 381-389.
7. Bekkering G.E., Harris R.J., Thomas S., Mayer A.B., Beynon R., Ness A.R. et al. (2008) How much of the data published in observational studies of the association between diet and prostate or bladder cancer is usable for meta-analysis?. American Journal of Epidemiology, 167, 1017-1026.
8. Beyers D.W. (1998) Causal inference in environmental impact studies. Journal of the North American Benthological Society, 17, 367-373.
9. Bissels S., Holzel N., Donath T.W. & Otte A. (2004) Evaluation of restoration success in alluvial grasslands under contrasting flooding regimes. Biological Conservation, 118, 641-650.
10. Blanch S.J., Ganf G.G. & Walker K.F. (1999) Tolerance of riverine plants to flooding and exposure indicated by water regime. Regulated Rivers: Research and Management, 15, 43-62.
11. Blanch S.J., Walker K.F. & Ganf G.G. (2000) Water regimes and littoral plants in four weir pools of the River Murray, Australia. Regulated Rivers: Research and Management, 16, 445-456.
12. Boedeltje G., Bakker J.P., Bekker R.M., Van Groenendael J.M. & Soesbergen M. (2003) Plant dispersal in a lowland stream in relation to occurrence and three specific life-history traits of the species in the species pool. Journal of Ecology, 91, 855-866.
13. Boedeltje G., Bakker J.P., Ten Brinke A., Van Groenendael J.M. & Soesbergen M. (2004) Dispersal phenology of hydrochorous plants in relation to discharge, seed release time and buoyancy of seeds: the flood pulse concept supported. Journal of Ecology, 92, 786-796.
14. Bonilla-Warford C.M. & Zedler J.B. (2002) Potential for using native plant species in stormwater wetlands. Environmental Management, 29, 385-394.
15. Britton D.L. & Brock M.A. (1994) Seasonal germination from wetland seed banks. Australian Journal of Marine and Freshwater Research, 45, 1445-1457.
16. Brooks S.S. & Lake P.S. (2007) River restoration in Victoria, Australia: change is in the wind, and none too soon. Restoration Ecology, 15, 584-591.
17. Brown R.L. & Chenoweth J. (2008) The effect of Glines Canyon Dam on hydrochorous seed dispersal in the Elwha River. Northwest Science, 82, 197-209.
18. Budelsky R.A. & Galatowitsch S.M. (2004) Establishment of Carex stricta Lam. seedlings in experimental wetlands with implications for restoration. Plant Ecology, 175, 91-105.
19. Bunn S.E. & Arthington A.H. (2002) Basic principles and ecological consequences of altered flow regimes for aquatic biodiversity. Environmental Management, 30, 492-507.
20. Capon S.J. (2007) Effects of flooding on seedling emergence from the soil seed bank of a large desert floodplain. Wetlands, 27, 904-914.
21. Catford J.A. & Downes B.J. (2010) Using multi-scale species distribution data to infer drivers of biological invasion in riparian wetlands. Diversity and Distributions, 16, 20-32.
22. Chambert S. & James C.S. (2009) Sorting seed by hydrochory. River Research and Applications, 25, 48-61.
23. Danvind M. & Nilsson C. (1997) Seed floating ability and distribution of alpine plants along a northern Swedish river. Journal of Vegetation Science, 8, 271-276.
24. David P.G. (1999) Response of exotics to restored hydroperiod at Dupuis Reserve, Florida. Restoration Ecology, 7, 407-410.
25. Decamps H., Plantytabacchi A.M. & Tabacchi E. (1995) Changes in the hydrological regime and invasions by plant-species along riparian systems of the Ardour River, France. Regulated Rivers: Research and Management, 11, 23-33.
26. Downes B., Barmuta L., Fairweather P., Faith D., Keough M., Lake P.S. et al. (2002) Monitoring Ecological Impacts: Concepts and Practice in Flowing Waters. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, U.K.
27. van Eck W., Lenssen J.P.M., van de Steeg H.M., Blom C. & de Kroon H. (2006) Seasonal dependent effects of flooding on plant species survival and zonation: a comparative study of 10 terrestrial grassland species. Hydrobiologia, 565, 59-69.
28. Engstrom J., Nilsson C. & Jansson R. (2009) Effects of stream restoration on dispersal of plant propagules. Journal of Applied Ecology, 46, 397-405.
29. Fabricius K.E. & De'Ath G. (2004) Identifying ecological change and its causes: a case study on coral reefs. Ecological Applications, 14, 1448-1465.
30. Fenner P., Brady W.W. & Patton D.R. (1985) Effect of regulated water flows on regeneration of freemont cottonwood. Journal of Range Management, 38, 135-138.
31. Froend R.H. & McComb A.J. (1994) Distribution, productivity, production and reproductive phenology of emergent macrophytes in relation to water regimes at wetland of south-western Australia. Australian Journal of Marine and Freshwater Research, 45, 1491-1508.
32. Gerard M., El Kahloun M., Mertens W., Verhagen B. & Meire P. (2008) Impact of flooding on potential and realised grassland species richness. Plant Ecology, 194, 85-98.
33. Gerritsen J. & Greening H.S. (1989) Marsh seed banks of the Okefenokee swamp - effect of hydrologic regime and nutrients. Ecology, 70, 750-763.
34. Gordon E. & van der Valk A.G. (2003) Secondary seed dispersal in Montrichardia arborescens (L.) schott dominated wetlands in Laguna Grande, Venezuela. Plant Ecology, 168, 177-190.
35. Greenland S. (1998) Meta-analysis. In: Modern Epidemiology (Eds K.J. Rothman & S. Greenland), pp. 643-673. Lippincott-Raven, Philadelphia.
36. Gurevitch J. & Hedges L.V. (2001) Meta-analysis: combining the results of independent experiments. In: Design and Analysis of Ecological Experiments (Eds S.M. Scheiner & J. Gurevitch), pp. 346-369. Oxford University Press, New York.
37. Gurnell A.M. (2007) Analogies between mineral sediment and vegetative particle dynamics in fluvial systems. Geomorphology, 89, 9-22.
38. Gurnell A.M., Boitsidis A.J., Thompson K. & Clifford N.J. (2006) Seed bank, seed dispersal and vegetation cover: colonization along a newly-created river channel. Journal of Vegetation Science, 17, 665-674.
39. Gurnell A., Goodson J., Thompson K., Clifford N. & Armitage P. (2007) The river-bed: a dynamic store for plant propagules? Earth Surface Processes and Landforms, 32, 1257-1272.
40. Gurnell A., Thompson K., Goodson J. & Moggridge H. (2008) Propagule deposition along river margins: linking hydrology and ecology. Journal of Ecology, 96, 553-565.
41. Hill A.B. (1965) The environment and disease: association or causation? Proceedings of the Royal Society of Medicine, 58, 295-300.
42. Holzel N. & Otte A. (2001) The impact of flooding regime on the soil seed bank of flood-meadows. Journal of Vegetation Science, 12, 209-218.
43. Hopfensperger K.N. & Baldwin A.H. (2009) Spatial and temporal dynamics of floating and drift-line seeds at a tidal freshwater marsh on the Potomac River, USA. Plant Ecology, 201, 677-686.
44. Jansson R., Nilsson C., Dynesius M. & Andersson E. (2000) Effects of river regulation on river-margin vegetation: a comparison of eight boreal rivers. Ecological Applications, 10, 203-224.
45. Jansson R., Zinko U., Merritt D.M. & Nilsson C. (2005) Hydrochory increases riparian plant species richness: a comparison between a free-flowing and a regulated river. Journal of Ecology, 93, 1094-1103.
46. Johansson M.E., Nilsson C. & Nilsson E. (1996) Do rivers function as corridors for plant dispersal? Journal of Vegetation Science, 7, 593-598.
47. Kubitzki K. & Ziburski A. (1994) Seed dispersal in flood-plain forests of Amazonia. Biotropica, 26, 30-43.
48. Levine T.R. & Hullett C.R. (2002) Eta squared, partial eta squared, and misreporting of effect size in communication research. Human Communication Research, 28, 612-625.
49. Leyer I. (2006) Dispersal, diversity and distribution patterns in pioneer vegetation: the role of river-floodplain connectivity. Journal of Vegetation Science, 17, 407-416.
50. Leyer I. & Pross S. (2009) Do seed and germination traits determine plant distribution patterns in riparian landscapes? Basic and Applied Ecology, 10, 113-121.
51. Lopez O.R. (2001) Seed flotation and postflooding germination in tropical terra firme and seasonally flooded forest species. Functional Ecology, 15, 763-771.
52. Maheshwari B.L., Walker K.F. & McMahon T.A. (1995) Effects of regulation on the flow regime of the River Murray, Australia. Regulated Rivers: Research and Management, 10, 15-38.
53. Mahoney J.M. & Rood S.B. (1998) Streamflow requirements for cottonwood seedling recruitment - An integrative model. Wetlands, 18, 634-645.
54. Malin G.L., Morris R.K. & Khan K.S. (2010) Strength of association between umbilical cord pH and perinatal and long term outcomes: systematic review and meta-analysis. British Medical Journal, 340, c1471.
55. Markwith S.H. & Leigh D.S. (2008) Subaqueous hydrochory: open-channel hydraulic modelling of non-buoyant seed movement. Freshwater Biology, 53, 2274-2286.
56. McLaren J.A., Silins E., Hutchinson D., Mattick R.P. & Hall W. (2010) Assessing evidence for a causal link between cannabis and psychosis: a review of cohort studies. International Journal of Drug Policy, 21, 10-19.
57. Merritt D.M. & Wohl E.E. (2002) Processes governing hydrochory along rivers: hydraulics, hydrology, and dispersal phenology. Ecological Applications, 12, 1071-1087.
58. Merritt D.M. & Wohl E.E. (2006) Plant dispersal along rivers fragmented by dams. River Research and Applications, 22, 1-26.
59. Merritt D.M., Nilsson C. & Jansson R. (2010a) Consequences of propagule dispersal and river fragmentation for riparian plant community diversity and interannual turnover. Ecological Monographs, 80, 609-626.
60. Merritt D.M., Scott M.L., Poff N.L., Auble G.T. & Lytle D.A. (2010b) Theory, methods and tools for determining environmental flows for riparian vegetation: riparian vegetation-flow response guilds. Freshwater Biology, 55, 206-225.
61. Middleton B. (2000) Hydrochory, seed banks, and regeneration dynamics along the landscape boundaries of a forested wetland. Plant Ecology, 146, 169-184.
62. Moggridge H. & Gurnell A. (2009) Hydrological controls on the transport and deposition of plant propagules within riparian zones. River Research and Applications, 26, 512-527.
63. Moggridge H.L., Gurnell A.M. & Mountford J.O. (2009) Propagule input, transport and deposition in riparian environments: the importance of connectivity for diversity. Journal of Vegetation Science, 20, 465-474.
64. Naiman R.J. & Decamps H. (1997) The ecology of interfaces: Riparian zones. Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics, 28, 621-658.
65. Nakayama N., Nishihiro J., Kayaba Y., Muranaka T. & Washitani I. (2007) Seed deposition of Eragrostis curvula, an invasive alien plant on a river floodplain. Ecological Research, 22, 696-701.
66. Nielsen D.L. & Chick A.J. (1997) Flood-mediated changes in aquatic macrophyte community structure. Marine and Freshwater Research, 48, 153-157.
67. Nilsson C. & Svedmark M. (2002) Basic principles and ecological consequences of changing water regimes: Riparian plant communities. Environmental Management, 30, 468-480.
68. Nilsson C., Gardfjell M. & Grelsson G. (1991) Importance of hydrochory in structuring plant-communities along rivers. Canadian Journal of Botany-Revue Canadienne De Botanique, 69, 2631-2633.
69. Nilsson C., Andersson E., Merritt D.M. & Johansson M.E. (2002) Differences in riparian flora between riverbanks and river lakeshores explained by dispersal traits. Ecology, 83, 2878-2887.
70. Nilsson C., Brown R.L., Jansson R. & Merritt D.M. (2010) The role of hydrochory in structuring riparian and wetland vegetation. Biological Reviews of the Cambridge Philosophical Society, 85, 837-858.
71. Noe G.B. (2002) Temporal variability matters: effects of constant vs. varying moisture and salinity on germination. Ecological Monographs, 72, 427-443.
72. Norris R., Nichols S., Ransom G., Liston P., Webb A., Stewardson M. et al. (2008) Causal Criteria Analysis Manual: A Systematic Approach to Evaluate Causality in Environmental Science. eWater Cooperative Research Centre, Canberra. Available at: (last accessed on 5 September 2010).
73. Palmer M.A., Bernhardt E.S., Allan J.D., Lake P.S., Alexander G., Brooks S. et al. (2005) Standards for ecologically successful river restoration. Journal of Applied Ecology, 42, 208-217.
74. Pettit N.E. & Froend R.H. (2001) Availability of seed for recruitment of riparian vegetation: a comparison of a tropical and a temperate river ecosystem in Australia. Australian Journal of Botany, 49, 515-528.
75. Planty-Tabacchi A.M., Tabacchi E., Naiman R.J., Deferrari C. & Decamps H. (1996) Invasibility of species rich communities in riparian zones. Conservation Biology, 10, 598-607.
76. Plowright R.K., Sokolow S.H., Gorman M.E., Daszak P. & Foley J.E. (2008) Causal inference in disease ecology: investigating ecological drivers of disease emergence. Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment, 6, 420-429.
77. Poff N.L. & Zimmerman J.K.H. (2010) Ecological responses to altered flow regimes: a literature review to inform the science and management of environmental flows. Freshwater Biology, 55, 194-205.
78. Poff N.L., Allan J.D., Bain M.B., Karr J.R., Prestegaard K.L., Richter B.D. et al. (1997) The natural flow regime. BioScience, 47, 769-784.
79. Puckridge J.T., Sheldon F., Walker K.F. & Boulton A.J. (1998) Flow variability and the ecology of large rivers. Marine and Freshwater Research, 49, 55-72.
80. Pullin A.S., Knight T.M. & Watkinson A.R. (2009) Linking reductionist science and holistic policy using systematic reviews: unpacking environmental policy questions to construct an evidence-based framework. Journal of Applied Ecology, 46, 970-975.
81. Rea N. & Ganf G.G. (1994) The role of sexual reproduction and water regime in shaping the distribution patterns of clonal emergent aquatic plants. Australian Journal of Marine and Freshwater Research, 45, 1469-1479.
82. Reid M.A. & Quinn G.P. (2004) Hydrologic regime and macrophyte assemblages in temporary floodplain wetlands: implications for detecting responses to environmental water allocations. Wetlands, 24, 586-599.
83. Reily P.W. & Johnson W.C. (1982) The effects of altered hydrologic regime on tree growth along the Missouri River in North-Dakota. Canadian Journal of Botany-Revue Canadienne De Botanique, 60, 2410-2423.
84. Richardson D.M., Holmes P.M., Esler K.J., Galatowitsch S.M., Stromberg J.C., Kirkman S.P. et al. (2007) Riparian vegetation: degradation, alien plant invasions, and restoration prospects. Diversity and Distributions, 13, 126-139.
85. Riis T. (2008) Dispersal and colonisation of plants in lowland streams: success rates and bottlenecks. Hydrobiologia, 596, 341-351.
86. Roberts J. (2002) Species-level knowledge of riverine and riparian plants: a constraint for determining flow requirements in the future. Australian Journal of Water Resources, 5, 21-31.
87. Robertson A.I., Bacon P. & Heagney G. (2001) The responses of floodplain primary production to flood frequency and timing. Journal of Applied Ecology, 38, 126-136.
88. Roffey D.M., Wai E.K., Bishop P., Kwon B.K. & Dagenais S. (2010) Causal assessment of occupational pushing or pulling and low back pain: results of a systematic review. Spine Journal, 10, 544-553.
89. Rood S.B. & Mahoney J.M. (1990) Collapse of riparian poplar forests downstream from dams in western prairies - probable causes and prospects for mitigation. Environmental Management, 14, 451-464.
90. Rosenthal G. (2006) Restoration of wet grasslands - effects of seed dispersal, persistence and abundance on plant species recruitment. Basic and Applied Ecology, 7, 409-421.
91. Schneider R.L. & Sharitz R.R. (1988) Hydrochory and regeneration in a bald cypress water tupelo swamp forest. Ecology, 69, 1055-1063.
92. Skoglund S.J. (1990) Seed dispersing agents in two regularly flooded river sites. Canadian Journal of Botany-Revue Canadienne De Botanique, 68, 754-760.
93. Slavin R.E. (1995) Best evidence synthesis - an intelligent alternative to metaanalysis. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology, 48, 9-18.
94. Staniforth R.J. & Cavers P.B. (1976) Experimental-study of water dispersal in Polygonum spp. Canadian Journal of Botany-Revue Canadienne De Botanique, 54, 2587-2596.
95. Stella J.C., Battles J.J., Orr B.K. & McBride J.R. (2006) Synchrony of seed dispersal, hydrology and local climate in a semi-arid river reach in California. Ecosystems, 9, 1200-1214.
96. Stromberg J.C. & Patten D.T. (1990) Riparian vegetation instream flow requirements - a case-study from a diverted stream in the eastern Sierra-Nevada, California, USA. Environmental Management, 14, 185-194.
97. Susser M. (1991) What is a cause and how do we know one - a grammar for pragmatic epidemiology. American Journal of Epidemiology, 133, 635-648.
98. Suter G.W., Norton S.B. & Cormier S.M. (2010) The science and philosophy of a method for assessing environmental causes. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment, 16, 19-34.
99. Sutton A.J. & Higgins J.P.I. (2008) Recent developments in meta-analysis. Statistics in Medicine, 27, 625-650.
100. Tabacchi E., Planty-Tabacchi A.M., Roques L. & Nadal E. (2005) Seed inputs in riparian zones: implications for plant invasion. River Research and Applications, 21, 299-313.
101. Toner M. & Keddy P. (1997) River hydrology and riparian wetlands: a predictive model for ecological assembly. Ecological Applications, 7, 236-246.
102. Vogt K., Rasran L. & Jensen K. (2006) Seed deposition in drift lines during an extreme flooding event - evidence for hydrochorous dispersal? Basic and Applied Ecology, 7, 422-432.
103. Walker K.F. (1985) A review of the ecological effects of river regulation in Australia. Hydrobiologia, 125, 111-129.
104. Walker K.F., Boulton A.J., Thoms M.C. & Sheldon F. (1994) Effects of water-level changes induced by weirs on the distribution of littoral plants along the River Murray, South Australia. Australian Journal of Marine and Freshwater Research, 45, 1421-1438.
105. Warwick N.W.M. & Brock M.A. (2003) Plant reproduction in temporary wetlands: the effects of seasonal timing, depth, and duration of flooding. Aquatic Botany, 77, 153-167.
106. Weed D.L. (1997) On the use of causal criteria. International Journal of Epidemiology, 26, 1137-1141.
107. Wolters M., Garbutt A. & Bakker J.P. (2005) Plant colonization after managed realignment: the relative importance of diaspore dispersal. Journal of Applied Ecology, 42, 770-777.