Positive surgical margins after nephron-sparing surgery

European Urology

Volumn 61, Issue 4, 2012, Pages 757-763

  Marszalek, Martin ^a,b   Carini, Marco ^c   Chlosta, Piotr ^d   Jeschke, Klaus ^e   Kirkali, Ziya ^f   Knüchel, Ruth ^g   Madersbacher, Stephan ^a   Patard, Jean Jacques ^h   Van Poppel, Hendrik ⁱ  

^a DANUBE HOSPITAL   (Austria)

^b MEDICAL UNIVERSITY OF GRAZ   (Austria)

^c UNIVERSITY OF FLORENCE   (Italy)

^d Institute of Oncology   (Poland)

^e GENERAL HOSPITAL KLAGENFURT   (Austria)

^f DOKUZ EYLUL UNIVERSITY   (Turkey)

^g UNIVERSITY HOSPITAL RWTH AACHEN   (Germany)

^h BICÊTRE HOSPITAL   (France)

ⁱ UNIVERSITY HOSPITALS LEUVEN   (Belgium)

Author keywords

Frozen section; Margin; Nephron sparing surgery; Partial nephrectomy; Recurrence

Indexed keywords

FOLLOW UP; FROZEN SECTION; HUMAN; KIDNEY PARENCHYMA; KIDNEY TUMOR; LAPAROSCOPIC SURGERY; NEPHRON SPARING SURGERY; PARTIAL NEPHRECTOMY; PRIORITY JOURNAL; RELIABILITY; REVIEW; RISK FACTOR; SURGICAL APPROACH; SURGICAL TECHNIQUE; TUMOR RECURRENCE;

EVIDENCE-BASED MEDICINE; HUMANS; KIDNEY NEOPLASMS; LAPAROSCOPY; NEOPLASM RECURRENCE, LOCAL; NEOPLASM, RESIDUAL; NEPHRECTOMY; ORGAN SPARING TREATMENTS; RISK ASSESSMENT; RISK FACTORS; ROBOTICS; SURGERY, COMPUTER-ASSISTED; TIME FACTORS; TREATMENT OUTCOME;

EID: 84857650186     PISSN: 03022838     EISSN: 18737560     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.eururo.2011.11.028     Document Type: Review

References (69)

1. B.R. Lane, A.F. Fergany, W.M. Linehan, and G. Bratslavsky Should preservable parenchyma, and not tumour size, be the main determinant of the feasibility of partial nephrectomy? Urology 76 2010 608 609
2. A.S. Go, G.M. Chertow, D. Fan, C.E. McCulloch, and C. Hsu Chronic kidney disease and the risks of death, cardiovascular events, and hospitalization N Engl J Med 351 2004 1296 1305
3. C.G. Weight, B.T. Larson, and A.F. Fergany Nephrectomy induced chronic renal insufficiency is associated with increased risk of cardiovascular death and death from any cause in patients with localized cT1b renal masses J Urol 183 2010 1317 1323
4. O. Yossepowitch, R.H. Thompson, and B.C. Leibovich Positive surgical margins at partial nephrectomy: predictors and oncological outcomes J Urol 179 2008 2158 2163
5. I.S. Gill, S.F. Matin, and M.M. Desai Comparative analysis of laparoscopic versus open partial nephrectomy for renal tumours in 200 patients J Urol 170 2003 64 68 (Pubitemid 36734412)
6. J.-J. Patard, A.J. Pantuck, and M. Crepel Morbidity and clinical outcome of nephron-sparing surgery in relation to tumour size and indication Eur Urol 52 2007 148 154 (Pubitemid 46803014)
7. E.O. Kwon, B.S. Carver, M.E. Snyder, and P. Russo Impact of positive surgical margins in patients undergoing partial nephrectomy for renal cortical tumours BJU Int 99 2007 286 289 (Pubitemid 46103105)
8. K. Kieran, J.S. Montgomery, S. Daignault, W.W. Roberts, and J.S. Wolf Comparison of intraoperative parameters and perioperative complications of retroperitoneal and transperitoneal approaches to laparoscopic partial nephrectomy: support for a retroperitoneal approach in selected patients J Endourol 21 2007 754 759 (Pubitemid 47311421)
9. D.A. Lifshitz, S.A. Shikanov, and T. Deklaj Laparoscopic partial nephrectomy: a single-center evolving experience Urology 75 2010 282 287
10. J.W. Saranchuk, A.K. Touijer, P. Hakimian, M.E. Snyder, and P. Russo Partial nephrectomy for patients with a solitary kidney: the Memorial Sloan-Kettering experience BJU Int 94 2004 1323 1328 (Pubitemid 40052102)
11. M. Peycelon, V. Hupertan, and E. Comperat Long-term outcomes after nephron sparing surgery for renal cell carcinoma larger than 4 cm J Urol 181 2009 35 41
12. R. Zigeuner, F. Quehenberger, K. Pummer, P. Petritsch, and G. Hubmer Long-term results of nephron-sparing surgery for renal cell carcinoma in 114 patients: risk factors for progressive disease BJU Int 92 2003 567 571 (Pubitemid 37271731)
13. B.J. Scoll, R.G. Uzzo, and D.Y. Chen Robot-assisted partial nephrectomy: a large single-institutional experience Urology 75 2010 1328 1334
14. H. Van Poppel, L. Da Pozzo, and W. Albrecht A prospective randomized EORTC intergroup phase 3 study comparing the complications of elective nephron-sparing surgery and radical nephrectomy for low-stage renal cell carcinoma Eur Urol 51 2007 1606 1615 (Pubitemid 46634740)
15. I.S. Gill, L.R. Kavoussi, and B.R. Lane Comparison of 1,800 laparoscopic and open partial nephrectomies for single renal tumours J Urol 178 2007 41 46 (Pubitemid 46898481)
16. M. Marszalek, H. Meixl, M. Polajnar, M. Rauchenwald, K. Jeschke, and S. Madersbacher Laparoscopic and open partial nephrectomy: a matched-pair comparison of 200 patients Eur Urol 55 2009 1171 1178
17. E.M. Gong, M.A. Orvieto, K.C. Zorn, A. Lucioni, G.D. Steinberg, and A.L. Shalhav Comparison of laparoscopic and open partial nephrectomy in clinical T1a renal tumours J Endourol 22 2008 953 957 (Pubitemid 351693933)
18. F. Porpiglia, C. Fiori, C. Terrone, E. Bollito, D. Fontana, and R.M. Scarpa Assessment of surgical margins in renal cell carcinoma after nephron sparing: a comparative study: laparoscopy vs open surgery J Urol 173 2005 1098 1101 (Pubitemid 40380510)
19. S. Permpongkosol, J.R. Colombo Jr., I.S. Gill, and L.R. Kavoussi Positive surgical parenchymal margin after laparoscopic partial nephrectomy for renal cell carcinoma: oncological outcomes J Urol 176 2006 2401 2404 (Pubitemid 44665990)
20. I.S. Gill, K. Kamoi, M. Aron, and M.M. Desai 800 Laparoscopic partial nephrectomies: a single surgeon series J Urol 183 2010 34 42
21. B.M. Benway, S.B. Bhayani, and C.G. Rogers Robot-assisted partial nephrectomy: an international experience Eur Urol 57 2010 815 820
22. C.G. Rogers, M. Menon, and E.S. Weise Robotic partial nephrectomy: a multi-institutional analysis J Robotic Surg 2 2008 141 143
23. A. Mottrie, G. De Naeyer, P. Schatteman, P. Carpentier, M. Sangalli, and V. Ficarra Impact of the learning curve on perioperative outcomes in patients who underwent robotic partial nephrectomy for parenchymal renal tumours Eur Urol 58 2010 127 133
24. G. Spana, G.P. Haber, and L.M. Dulabon Complications after robotic partial nephrectomy at centers of excellence: multi-institutional analysis of 450 cases J Urol 186 2011 417 422
25. R.E. Link, S.B. Bhayani, and M.E. Allaf Exploring the learning curve, pathological outcomes and perioperative morbidity of laparoscopic partial nephrectomy performed for renal mass J Urol 173 2005 1690 1694 (Pubitemid 40524807)
26. B.M. Benway, S.B. Bhayani, and C.G. Rogers Robot assisted partial nephrectomy versus laparoscopic partial nephrectomy for renal tumours: a multi-institutional analysis of perioperative outcomes J Urol 182 2009 866 872
27. R.G. Uzzo, and A.C. Novick Nephron sparing surgery for renal tumours: indications, techniques and outcomes J Urol 166 2001 6 18 (Pubitemid 32565331)
28. S.E. Sutherland, M.I. Resnick, G.T. Maclennan, and H.B. Goldman Does the size of the surgical margin in partial nephrectomy for renal cell cancer really matter? J Urol 167 2002 61 64 (Pubitemid 34024499)
29. E.A. Castilla, L.S. Liou, and N.A. Abrahams Prognostic importance of resection margin width after nephron-sparing surgery for renal cell carcinoma Urology 60 2002 993 997 (Pubitemid 35447553)
30. H. Van Poppel, and R. Van Reusel How much margin to spare in partial nephrectomy? J. De La Rosette, C. Sternberg, H.P. Van Poppel, Renal cell cancer: diagnosis and therapy 2008 Springer London 229 235
31. N. Berdjis, O.W. Hakenberg, S. Zastrow, S. Oehlschläger, V. Novotny, and M.P. Wirth Impact of resection margin status after nephron-sparing surgery for renal cell carcinoma BJU Int 97 2006 1208 1210 (Pubitemid 43907323)
32. N.Y. Piper, J.T. Bishoff, and C. Magee Is a 1-cm margin necessary during nephron-sparing surgery for renal cell carcinoma? Urology 586 2001 849 852 (Pubitemid 34017255)
33. P. Puppo, C. Introini, P. Calvi, and A. Naselli Long term results of excision of small renal cancer surrounded by a minimal layer of grossly normal parenchyma: review of 94 cases Eur Urol 46 2004 477 481 (Pubitemid 39200856)
34. Q.-L. Li, H.-W. Guan, Q.-P. Zhang, L.-Z. Zhang, F.-P. Wang, and Y.-J. Liu Optimal margin in nephron-sparing surgery for renal cell carcinoma 4 cm or less Eur Urol 44 2003 448 451 (Pubitemid 37185670)
35. Q.L. Li, L. Cheng, H.W. Guan, Y. Zhang, F.P. Wang, and X.S. Song Safety and efficacy of mini-margin nephron-sparing surgery for renal cell carcinoma 4-cm or less Urology 71 2008 924 927
36. A. Minervini, C. di Cristofano, and A. Lapini Histopathologic analysis of peritumoral pseudocapsule and surgical margin status after tumor enucleation for renal cell carcinoma Eur Urol 55 2009 1410 1418
37. B. Ljungberg, N.C. Cowan, D.C. Hanbury European Association of Urology Guideline Group EAU guidelines on renal cell carcinoma: the 2010 update Eur Urol 58 2010 398 406
38. M. Carini, A. Minervini, A. Lapini, L. Masieri, and S. Serni Simple enucleation for the treatment of renal cell carcinoma between 4 and 7 cm in greatest dimension: progression and long-term survival J Urol 175 2006 2022 2026 (Pubitemid 43668511)
39. M. Carini, A. Minervini, L. Masieri, A. Lapini, and S. Serni Simple enucleation for the treatment of PT1a renal cell carcinoma: our 20-year experience Eur Urol 50 2006 1263 1271 (Pubitemid 44692920)
40. A. Minervini, S. Serni, and A. Tuccio Local recurrence after tumour enucleation for renal cell carcinoma with no ablation of the tumour bed: results of a prospective single-centre study BJU Int 107 2011 1394 1399
41. A. Minervini, V. Ficarra, and F. Rocco Simple enucleation is equivalent to traditional partial nephrectomy for renal cell carcinoma: results of a nonrandomized, retrospective, comparative study J Urol 185 2011 1604 1610
42. D.J. Lee, G. Hruby, M.C. Benson, and J.M. McKiernan Renal function and oncologic outcomes in nephron sparing surgery for renal masses in solitary kidneys World J Urol 29 2011 343 348
43. M.F. Wszolek, P.A. Kenney, Y. Lee, and J.A. Libertino Comparison of hilar clamping and non-hilar clamping partial nephrectomy for tumours involving a solitary kidney BJU Int 107 2010 1886 1892
44. F. Porpiglia, C. Fiori, R. Bertolo, and R.M. Scarpa Does tumour size really affect the safety of laparoscopic partial nephrectomy? BJU Int 108 2010 268 274
45. O. Raz, S. Mendlovic, and Y. Shilo Positive surgical margins with renal cell carcinoma have a limited influence on long-term oncological outcomes of nephron sparing surgery Urology 75 2010 277 280
46. A. Breda, S.V. Stepanian, and J. Liao Positive margins in laparoscopic partial nephrectomy in 855 cases: a multi-institutional survey from the United States and Europe J Urol 178 2007 47 50 (Pubitemid 46898489)
47. I. Frank, J.R. Colombo Jr., M. Rubinstein, M. Desai, J. Kaouk, and I.S. Gill Laparoscopic partial nephrectomy for centrally located renal tumors J Urol 175 2006 849 852 (Pubitemid 43199994)
48. K. Bensalah, A.J. Pantuck, and N. Rioux-Leclercq Positive surgical margin appears to have negligible impact on survival of renal cell carcinomas treated by nephron-sparing surgery Eur Urol 57 2010 466 473
49. R. Venkatesh, K. Weld, and C.D. Ames Laparoscopic partial nephrectomy for renal masses: effect of tumor location Urology 67 2006 1169 1174 (Pubitemid 43818109)
50. V. Ficarra, G. Novara, and S. Secco Preoperative aspects and dimensions used for an anatomical (PADUA) classification of renal tumours in patients who are candidates for nephron-sparing surgery Eur Urol 56 2009 786 793
51. A. Kutikov, and R.G. Uzzo The R.E.N.A.L. nephrometry score: a comprehensive standardized system for quantitating renal tumor size, location and depth J Urol 182 2009 844 853
52. P.J. Desai, P.E. Andrews, R.G. Ferrigni, and E.P. Castle Laparoscopic partial nephrectomy at the Mayo Clinic Arizona: follow-up surveillance of positive margin disease Urology 71 2008 283 286 (Pubitemid 351282341)
53. M.A. Lopez-Costea, L. Fumadó, D. Lorente, L. Riera, and E.F. Miranda Positive margins after nephron-sparing surgery for renal cell carcinoma: long-term follow-up of patients on active surveillance BJU Int 106 2010 645 648
54. E.R. Ray, B.W. Turney, R. Singh, A. Chandra, D.W. Cranston, and T.S. O'Brien Open partial nephrectomy: outcomes from two UK centres BJU Int 97 2006 1211 1215 (Pubitemid 43907324)
55. J.-C. Bernhard, A.J. Pantuck, and H. Wallerand Predictive factors for ipsilateral recurrence after nephron-sparing surgery in renal cell carcinoma Eur Urol 57 2010 1080 1086
56. R. Bollens, A. Rosenblatt, and B.P. Espinoza Laparoscopic partial nephrectomy with "on-demand" clamping reduces warm ischemia time Eur Urol 52 2007 804 810 (Pubitemid 47126172)
57. M. Duvdevani, Y. Mor, and A. Kastin Renal artery occlusion during nephron-sparing surgery: retrospective review of 301 cases Urology 68 2006 960 963 (Pubitemid 44750128)
58. G.L. Smith, P.A. Kenney, and Y. Lee Non-clamped partial nephrectomy: techniques and surgical outcomes BJU Int 107 2011 1054 1058
59. T.T. Nguyen, J.P. Parkinson, D.M. Kuehn, and H.N. Winfield Technique for ensuring negative surgical margins during laparoscopic partial nephrectomy J Endourol 19 2005 410 415 (Pubitemid 40656323)
60. T.J. Polascik, M.V. Meng, J.I. Epstein, and F.F. Marshall Intraoperative sonography for the evaluation and management of renal tumors: experience with 100 patients J Urol 154 1995 1676 1680
61. S. Tobis, J. Knopf, and C. Silver Near infrared fluorescence imaging with robotic assisted laparoscopic partial nephrectomy: initial clinical experience for renal cortical tumors J Urol 186 2011 47 52
62. D. Teber, S. Guven, and T. Simpfendörfer Augmented reality: a new tool to improve surgical accuracy during laparoscopic partial nephrectomy? Preliminary in vitro and in vivo results Eur Urol 56 2009 332 338
63. M.E. Allaf, S.B. Bhayani, and C. Rogers Laparoscopic partial nephrectomy: evaluation of long-term oncological outcome J Urol 172 2004 871 873 (Pubitemid 39096410)
64. M. Duvdevani, M. Laufer, and A. Kastin Is frozen section analysis in nephron sparing surgery necessary? A clinicopathological study of 301 cases J Urol 173 2005 385 387
65. D.J. Kubinski, P.E. Clark, D.G. Assimos, and M.C. Hall Utility of frozen section analysis of resection margins during partial nephrectomy Urology 64 2004 31 34 (Pubitemid 38887572)
66. Z. Kirkali, F. Algaba, M. Scarpelli, I. Trias, F.P. Selvaggi, and H. Van Poppel What does the urologist expect from the pathologist (and what can the pathologists give) in reporting on adult kidney tumour specimens? Eur Urol 51 2007 1194 1201 (Pubitemid 46436301)
67. I.S. Hagemann, and J.S. Lewis Jr. A retrospective comparison of 2 methods of intraoperative margin evaluation during partial nephrectomy J Urol 181 2009 500 505
68. M.O. Timsit, J.P. Bazin, and N. Thiounn Prospective study of safety margins in partial nephrectomy: intraoperative assessment and contribution of frozen section analysis Urology 67 2006 923 926 (Pubitemid 43956418)
69. V. Sundaram, R.S. Figenshau, and T.M. Roytman Positive margin during partial nephrectomy: does cancer remain in the renal remnant? Urology 77 2011 1400 1403