Nurse staffing and deficiencies in the largest for-profit nursing home chains and chains owned by private equity companies

Health Services Research

Volumn 47, Issue 1 PART 1, 2012, Pages 106-128

  Harrington, Charlene ^a   Olney, Brian ^b   Carrillo, Helen ^a   Kang, Taewoon ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA   (United States)

^b UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA   (United States)

Author keywords

long term care: home care nursing homes; Ownership governance (for profit NFP public chains systems); quality of care patient safety (measurement)

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; GOVERNMENT; HEALTH CARE FACILITY; HEALTH CARE QUALITY; HEALTH SURVEY; MEDICAID; MEDICARE; MORTALITY; NURSING HOME; NURSING STAFF; ORGANIZATION AND MANAGEMENT; OUTCOME ASSESSMENT; PATIENT SAFETY; PRIVATE HOSPITAL; PROFIT; REGISTERED NURSE;

HEALTH FACILITIES, PROPRIETARY; HUMANS; NURSING HOMES; NURSING STAFF; PRIVATE SECTOR; QUALITY INDICATORS, HEALTH CARE; UNITED STATES;

EID: 84855830963     PISSN: 00179124     EISSN: 14756773     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1475-6773.2011.01311.x     Document Type: Article

References (50)

1. Alexander, J. A., and, T. A. D'Aunno,. 1990. " Transformation of Institutional Environments: Perspectives on the Corporatization of U.S. Healthcare. " In Innovations in Health Care Delivery: Insights for Organization Theory, edited by, S. S. Mick, pp 53-85. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
2. Banaszak-Holl, J., W. B. Berta, D. Bowman, J. A. C. Baum, and, W. Mitchell,. 2002. " The Rise of Human Service Chains: Antecedents to Acquisitions and Their Effects on the Quality of Care in US Nursing Homes, 1991-1997." Managerial and Decision Economics 23: 261-82.
3. Baum, J. A. C., 1999. " The Rise of Chain Nursing Homes in Ontario, 1971-1996." Social Forces 78 (2): 543-83.
4. Bostick, J. E., M. J. Rantz, M. K. Flesner, and, C. J. Riggs,. 2006. " Systematic Review of Studies of Staffing and Quality in Nursing Homes." Journal of the American Medical Directors Association 7: 366-76. (Pubitemid 44028631)
5. Castle, N,. 2008. " Nursing Home Caregiver Staffing Levels and Quality of Care: A Literature Review." Journal of Applied Gerontology 27: 375-405.
6. Castle, N., and, J. Engberg,. 2007. " The Influence of Staffing Characteristics on Quality of Care in Nursing Homes." Health Services Research 42: 1822-47. (Pubitemid 47397184)
7. Castle, N.,and, J. Engberg,. 2008. " Further Examination of the Influence of Caregiver Staffing Levels on Nursing Home Quality." Gerontologist 48: 464-76.
8. Chen, L. W., and, D. G. Shea,. 2004. " The Economics of Scale for Nursing Home Care." Medical Care Research and Review 61 (1): 38-63. (Pubitemid 38240978)
9. Cohen, J., and, W. Spector,. 1996. " The Effect of Medicaid Reimbursement on Quality of Care in Nursing Homes." Journal of Health Economics 15: 23-48. (Pubitemid 26148844)
10. Comondore, V. R., P. J. Devereaux, Q. Zhou, S. B. Stone, L. W. Busse, N. C. Ravindran, K. E. Burns, T. Haines, B. Stringer, D. J. Cook, S. D. Walter, T. Sullivan, O. Berwanger, M. Bhandari, S. Banglawala, J. N. Lavis, B. Petrisor, H. Schunemann, K. Walsh, N. Bhatnagar, and, G. H. Guyatt,. 2009. " Quality of Care in For-Profit and Not-For-Profit Nursing Homes: Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis." British Medical Journal 339: b2732.
11. Davis, G., and, S. Stout,. 1992. " Organization Theory and the Market for Corporate Control, 1980-1990." Administrative Science Quarterly 37: 605-33.
12. Davis, G., and, T. Thompson,. 1994. " A Social Movement Perspective on Corporate Control." Administrative Science Quarterly 39: 171-93.
13. Diamond, S. F,. 2008. " Private Equity and Public Good. " Dissent Magazine (Winter) [accessed on May 15, 2010]. Available at
14. Duhigg, C,. 2007. " At Many Homes, More Profit and Less Nursing. " New York Times, September 23, A1-A20, A21.
15. Feng, Z., D. C. Grabowski, O. Intrator, J. Zinn, and, V. Mor,. 2008. " Medicaid Payment Rates, Case-Mix Reimbursement, and Nursing Home Staffing-1996-2004." Medical Care 46 (1): 33-40.
16. Fligstein, N,. 2001. The Architecture of Markets: An Economic Sociology of Twenty-First Century Capitalist Societies. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
17. Grabowski, D. C,. 2001a. " Medicaid Reimbursement and the Quality of Nursing Home Care." Journal of Health Economics 20: 549-69. (Pubitemid 32515170)
18. Grabowski, D. C,. 2001b. " Does An Increase in the Medicaid Reimbursement Rate Improve Nursing Home Quality? " Journal of Gerontology: Social Sciences 56B: S84-93. (Pubitemid 32193153)
19. Grabowski, D. C., and, D. G. Stevenson,. 2008. " Ownership Conversion and Nursing Home Performance. " Health Services Research 43 (4): 1184-203. (Pubitemid 352019155)
20. Harrington, C., H. Carrillo, B. W. Blank, and, T. O'Brian,. 2010. Nursing Facilities, Staffing, Residents, and Facility Deficiencies, 2004-09. San Francisco, CA: University of California [accessed December 10, 2010]. Available at
21. Harrington, C., J. Mullan, and, H. Carrillo,. 2004. " State Nursing Home Enforcement Systems." Journal of Health Politics, Policy, and Law 29 (1): 43-73. (Pubitemid 38258197)
22. Harrington, C., J. H. Swan, and, H. Carrillo,. 2007. " Nurse Staffing Levels and Medicaid Reimbursement Rates in Nursing Facilities." Health Services Research 42: 1105-29. (Pubitemid 46699470)
23. Harrington, C., D. Zimmerman, S. L. Karon, J. Robinson, and, P. Beutel,. 2000. " Nursing Home Staffing and Its Relationship to Deficiencies." Journal of Gerontology: Social Sciences 55B (5): S278-86.
24. Harrington, C., S. Woolhandler, J. Mullan, H. Carrillo, and, D. Himmelstein,. 2001. " Does Investor-Ownership of Nursing Homes Compromise the Quality of Care? " American Journal of Public Health 91: 1452-5. (Pubitemid 32803333)
25. Harrington, C., C. Hauser, B. Olney, and, P. V. Rosenau,. 2011. " Ownership, Financing, and Management Strategies of the Ten Largest For-Profit Nursing Home Chains in the US. " International Journal of Health Services 41 (4): 725-46.
26. Hillmer, M. P., W. P. Wodchis, S. S. Gill, G. M. Anderson, and, P. A. Rochon,. 2005. " Nursing Home Profit Status and Quality of Care: Is There Any Evidence of an Association? " Medical Care Research and Review 62 (2): 139-66. (Pubitemid 40397251)
27. Institute of Medicine. 2003. Keeping Patients Safe: Transforming the Work Environment of Nurses. Washington, DC: National Academy of Medicine.
28. Kash, B. A., C. Hawes, and, C. D. Phillips,. 2007. " Comparing Staffing Levels in the Online Survey Certification and Reporting (OSCAR) System with the Medicaid Cost Report Data: Are Differences Systematic? " Gerontologist 347 (4): 480-9. (Pubitemid 47413955)
29. Kim, H., C. Harrington, and, W. Greene,. 2009a. " Registered Nurse Staffing Mix and Quality of Care in Nursing Homes: A Longitudinal Analysis." Gerontologist 49 (1): 81-90.
30. Kim, H., C. Kovner, C. Harrington, W. Greene, and, M. Mezey,. 2009b. " A Panel Data Analysis of the Relationships of Nursing Home Staffing Levels and Standards to Regulatory Deficiencies." Journal of Gerontology: Social Sciences 64B (2): 269-78.
31. Kitchener, M., J. O'Meara, A. Brody, H. Lee, and, C. Harrington,. 2008. " Shareholder Value and the Performance of a Large Nursing Home Chain." Health Services Research 43 (3): 1062-84. (Pubitemid 351623963)
32. Konetzka, R. T., D. Yi, E. C. Norton, and, K. E. Kilpatrick,. 2004. " Effects of Medicare Payment Changes on Nursing Home Staffing and Deficiencies." Health Services Research 39 (3): 463-87. (Pubitemid 38685564)
33. LaPorte, M,. 2008. " Top 50 Nursing Facility Chains: Steady Growth. " Provider Magazine, June 39-43.
34. LaPorte, M,. 2009. " Top 50 Nursing Facility Chains: Weathering the Storm. " Provider Magazine, June 47-51.
35. Medicare Payment Advisory Commission (MedPac). 2009. Report to Congress: Medicare Payment Policy. Washington, DC: MedPac [accessed on March 12, 2009]. Available at
36. Mor, V., J. Zinn, J. Angelelli, J. M. Teno, and, S. C. Miller,. 2004. " Driven to Tiers: Socioeconomic Factors and Racial Disparities in the Quality of Nursing Home Care." Milbank Quarterly 82 (2): 227-56. (Pubitemid 38992735)
37. Office of Inspector General (OIG), Department of Health and Human Services, and, Levinson, D,. 2010. Questionable Billing by Skilled Nursing Facilities. OEI-02-09-00202. Washington, DC: OIG.
38. O'Neill, C., C. Harrington, M. Kitchener, and, D. Saliba,. 2003. " Quality of Care in Nursing Homes: An Analysis of the Relationships among Profit, Quality, and Ownership." Medical Care 41: 1318-30.
39. Schnelle, J. F., S. F. Simmons, C. Harrington, M. Cadogan, E. Garcia, and, B. Bates-Jensen,. 2004. " Relationship of Nursing Home Staffing to Quality of Care? " Health Services Research 39 (2): 225-50. (Pubitemid 38344124)
40. Stevenson, D., and, D. Grabowski,. 2008. " Private Equity Investment and Nursing Home Care: Is It a Big Deal? " Health Affairs 27 (5): 1399-408.
41. Stevenson, D., D. Grabowski, and, L. Coots,. 2006. Nursing Home Divestiture and Corporate Restructuring: Final Report. Washington, DC: US Assistant Secretary for Planning and Evaluation, December.
42. U.S. Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS), Prepared by Abt Associates Inc. 2001. Appropriateness of Minimum Nurse Staffing Ratios in Nursing Homes. Report to Congress: Phase II Final, Vols. I-III. Baltimore, MD: CMS.
43. U.S. General Accounting Office. 2002. Skilled Nursing Facilities: Medicare Payments Exceed Costs for Most But Not All Facilities. Report to Congressional Requestors. GAO/HEHS-03-183. Washington, DC: General Accounting Office, December.
44. U.S. General Accounting Office. 2003. Nursing Homes Quality: Prevalence of Serious Problems, While Declining, Reinforces Importance of Enhanced Oversight-Report to Congressional Requesters GAO-03-561. Washington, D.C.: General Accounting Office.
45. U.S. General Accounting Office (GAO). 1987. Report to the Chairman, Subcommittee on Health and Long-Term Care, Select Committee on Aging, House of Representatives. Medicare and Medicaid: Stronger Enforcement of Nursing Home Requirements Needed. Washington, DC: U.S. GAO.
46. U.S. Government Accountability Office. 2007. Nursing Homes: Efforts to Strengthen Federal Enforcement Have Not Deterred Some Homes from Repeatedly Harming Residents. GAO-07-241. Washington, D.C.: GAO.
47. U.S. Government Accountability Office. 2009a. CMS's Specific Focus Facility Methodology Should Better Target the Most Poorly Performing Facilities Which Tend to Be Chain Affiliated and For-Profit. GAO-09-689. Washington, D.C.: GAO [accessed on August 13, 2010]. Available at
48. U.S. Government Accountability Office. 2009b. Nursing Homes: Addressing the Factors Underlying Understatement of Serious Care Problems Requires Sustained CMS and State Commitment. GAO-10-70. Washington, D.C.: GAO [accessed on August 13, 2010]. Available at
49. U.S. Government Accountability Office. 2010. Nursing Homes: Complexity of Private Investment Purchases Demonstrates Need for CMS to Improve the Usability and Completeness of Ownership Data. GAO-10-710. Washington, D.C.: GAO. Available at
50. Zhang, Z. X., and, D. C. Grabowski,. 2004. " Nursing Home Staffing and Quality under the Nursing Home Reform Act." Gerontologist 44 (1): 13-23. (Pubitemid 38252509)