Activation likelihood estimation meta-analysis of motor-related neural activity after stroke

NeuroImage

Volumn 59, Issue 3, 2012, Pages 2771-2782

  Rehme, Anne K ^a   Eickhoff, Simon B ^b,c   Rottschy, Claudia ^b,c,d   Fink, Gereon R ^c,e   Grefkes, Christian ^a,e  

^a MAX PLANCK INSTITUTE FOR NEUROLOGICAL RESEARCH   (Germany)

^b UNIVERSITY HOSPITAL RWTH AACHEN   (Germany)

^c Juelich Research Centre   (Germany)

^d UNIVERSITY OF TEXAS HEALTH SCIENCE CENTER AT SAN ANTONIO   (United States)

^e UNIVERSITY OF COLOGNE   (Germany)

Author keywords

Functional magnetic resonance imaging; Motor impairment; Positron emission tomography; Reorganization; Time post stroke

Indexed keywords

ARM MOVEMENT; ARTICLE; CEREBELLUM; HAND MOVEMENT; HUMAN; MOTOR ACTIVITY; MOTOR DYSFUNCTION; MOTOR PERFORMANCE; PARESIS; PREMOTOR CORTEX; PRIMARY MOTOR CORTEX; PRIORITY JOURNAL; STROKE; SUPPLEMENTARY MOTOR AREA;

AGED; ARM; BRAIN; CEREBELLUM; FEMALE; FUNCTIONAL LATERALITY; HUMANS; LIKELIHOOD FUNCTIONS; MAGNETIC RESONANCE IMAGING; MALE; MIDDLE AGED; MOTOR CORTEX; MOTOR NEURONS; MOVEMENT; MOVEMENT DISORDERS; POSITRON-EMISSION TOMOGRAPHY; PSYCHOMOTOR PERFORMANCE; RECOVERY OF FUNCTION; STROKE; UPPER EXTREMITY;

EID: 84855424349     PISSN: 10538119     EISSN: 10959572     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2011.10.023     Document Type: Article

References (88)

1. Aizawa H., Inase M., Mushiake H., Shima K., Tanji J. Reorganization of activity in the supplementary motor area associated with motor learning and functional recovery. Exp. Brain Res. 1991, 84:668-671.
2. Ameli M., Grefkes C., Kemper F., Riegg F.P., Rehme A.K., Karbe H., Fink G.R., Nowak D.A. Differential effects of high-frequency repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation over ipsilesional primary motor cortex in cortical and subcortical middle cerebral artery stroke. Ann. Neurol. 2009, 66:298-309.
3. Andrade A., Paradis A.L., Rouquette S., Poline J.B. Ambiguous results in functional neuroimaging data analysis due to covariate correlation. NeuroImage 1999, 10:483-486.
4. Askim T., Indredavik B., Vangberg T., Haberg A. Motor network changes associated with successful motor skill relearning after acute ischemic stroke. Neurorehabil. Neural Repair 2009, 23:295-304.
5. Bestmann S., Swayne O., Blankenburg F., Ruff C.C., Teo J., Weiskopf N., Driver J., Rothwell J.C., Ward N.S. The role of contralesional dorsal premotor cortex after stroke as studied with concurrent TMS-fMRI. J. Neurosci. 2010, 30:11926-11937.
6. Biernaskie J., Szymanska A., Windle V., Corbett D. Bi-hemispheric contribution to functional motor recovery of the affected forelimb following focal ischemic brain injury in rats. Eur. J. Neurosci. 2005, 21:989-999.
7. Bütefisch C.M., Kleiser R., Körber B., Müller K., Wittsack H.-J., Hömberg V., Seitz R.J. Recruitment of contralesional motor cortex in patients with recovery of hand function. Neurology 2005, 64:1067-1069.
8. Calautti C., Jones P.S., Guincestre J.-Y., Naccarato M., Sharma N., Day D.J., Carpenter T.A., Warburton E.A., Baron J.-C. The neural substrate of impaired finger tapping regularity after stroke. NeuroImage 2010, 50:1-6.
9. Calautti C., Leroy F., Guincestre J.Y., Baron J.C. Dynamics of motor network overactivation after striatocapsular stroke: a longitudinal PET study using a fixed-performance paradigm. Stroke 2001, 32:2534-2542.
10. Calautti C., Naccarato M., Jones P.S., Sharma N., Day D.D., Carpenter A.T., Bullmore E.T., Warburton E.A., Baron J.-C. The relationship between motor deficit and hemisphere activation balance after stroke. NeuroImage 2007, 34:322-331.
11. Carey L.M., Abbott D.F., Egan G.F., O'Keefe G.J., Jackson G.D., Bernhardt J., Donnan G.A. Evolution of brain activation with good and poor motor recovery after stroke. Neurorehabil. Neural Repair 2006, 20:24-41.
12. Carmichael S.T. Plasticity of cortical projections after stroke. Neuroscientist 2003, 9:64-75.
13. Carr J.H., Shepherd R.B., Nordholm L., Lynne D. Investigation of a new motor assessment scale for stroke patients. Phys. Ther. 1985, 65:175-180.
14. Chassagnon S., Minotti L., Kremer S., Hoffmann D., Kahane P. Somatosensory, motor, and reaching/grasping responses to direct electrical stimulation of the human cingulate motor areas. J. Neurosurg. 2008, 109:593-604.
15. Chollet F., DiPiero V., Wise R.J., Brooks D.J., Dolan R.J., Frackowiak R.S. The functional anatomy of motor recovery after stroke in humans: a study with positron emission tomography. Ann. Neurol. 1991, 29:63-71.
16. Cramer S.C. Repairing the human brain after stroke: I. Mechanisms of spontaneous recovery. Ann. Neurol. 2008, 63:272-287.
17. Dancause N., Barbay S., Frost S.B., Plautz E.J., Chen D., Zoubina E.V., Stowe A.M., Nudo R.J. Extensive cortical rewiring after brain injury. J. Neurosci. 2005, 25:10167-10179.
18. Dechaumont-Palacin S., Marque P., De Boissezon X., Castel-Lacanal E., Carel C., Berry I., Pastor J., Albucher J.F., Chollet F., Loubinoux I. Neural correlates of proprioceptive integration in the contralesional hemisphere of very impaired patients shortly after a subcortical stroke: an fMRI study. Neurorehabil. Neural Repair 2008, 22:154-165.
19. Demeurisse G., Demol O., Robaye E. Motor evaluation in vascular hemiplegia. Eur. Neurol. 1980, 19:382-389.
20. Dum R.P., Strick P.L. Motor areas in the frontal lobe of the primate. Physiol. Behav. 2002, 77:677-682.
21. Duncan P.W., Goldstein L.B., Matchar D., Divine G.W., Feussner J. Measurement of motor recovery after stroke. Outcome assessment and sample size requirements. Stroke 1992, 23:1084-1089.
22. Eickhoff S.B., Bzdok D., Laird A.R., Kurth F., Fox P.T. Activation likelihood estimation meta-analysis revisited. NeuroImage 2011, 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2011.09.017.
23. Eickhoff S.B., Jbabdi S., Caspers S., Laird A.R., Fox P.T., Zilles K., Behrens T.E. Anatomical and functional connectivity of cytoarchitectonic areas within the human parietal operculum. J. Neurosci. 2010, 30:6409-6421.
24. Eickhoff S.B., Laird A.R., Grefkes C., Wang L.E., Zilles K., Fox P.T. Coordinate-based activation likelihood estimation meta-analysis of neuroimaging data: a random-effects approach based on empirical estimates of spatial uncertainty. Hum. Brain Mapp. 2009, 30:2907-2926.
25. Eickhoff S.B., Stephan K.E., Mohlberg H., Grefkes C., Fink G.R., Amunts K., Zilles K. A new SPM toolbox for combining probabilistic cytoarchitectonic maps and functional imaging data. NeuroImage 2005, 25:1325-1335.
26. Eisner-Janowicz I., Barbay S., Hoover E., Stowe A.M., Frost S.B., Plautz E.J., Nudo R.J. Early and late changes in the distal forelimb representation of the supplementary motor area after injury to frontal motor areas in the squirrel monkey. J. Neurophysiol. 2008, 100:1498-1512.
27. Fugl-Meyer A.R., Jaasko L., Leyman I., Olsson S., Steglind S. The post-stroke hemiplegic patient. 1. a method for evaluation of physical performance. Scand. J. Rehabil. Med. 1975, 7:13-31.
28. Gerloff C., Bushara K., Sailer A., Wassermann E.M., Chen R., Matsuoka T., Waldvogel D., Wittenberg G.F., Ishii K., Cohen L.G., Hallett M. Multimodal imaging of brain reorganization in motor areas of the contralesional hemisphere of well recovered patients after capsular stroke. Brain 2006, 129:791-808.
29. Gladstone D.J., Danells C.J., Black S.E. The fugl-meyer assessment of motor recovery after stroke: a critical review of its measurement properties. Neurorehabil. Neural Repair 2002, 16:232-240.
30. Goldman-Rakic P.S., Bates J.F., Chafee M.V. The prefrontal cortex and internally generated motor acts. Curr. Opin. Neurobiol. 1992, 2:830-835.
31. Grefkes C., Nowak D.A., Eickhoff S.B., Dafotakis M., Kust J., Karbe H., Fink G.R. Cortical connectivity after subcortical stroke assessed with functional magnetic resonance imaging. Ann. Neurol. 2008, 63:236-246.
32. Grefkes C., Nowak D.A., Wang L.E., Dafotakis M., Eickhoff S.B., Fink G.R. Modulating cortical connectivity in stroke patients by rTMS assessed with fMRI and dynamic causal modeling. NeuroImage 2010, 50:233-242.
33. Habas C. Functional connectivity of the human rostral and caudal cingulate motor areas in the brain resting state at 3T. Neuroradiology 2010, 52:47-59.
34. Hendricks H.T., Zwarts M.J., Plat E.F., van Limbeek L.J. Systematic review for the early prediction of motor and functional outcome after stroke by using motor-evoked potentials. Arch. Phys. Med. Rehabil. 2002, 83:1303-1308.
35. Hoshi E., Tanji J. Distinctions between dorsal and ventral premotor areas: anatomical connectivity and functional properties. Curr. Opin. Neurobiol. 2007, 17:234-242.
36. Jaillard A., Martin C.D., Garambois K., Lebas J.F., Hommel M. Vicarious function within the human primary motor cortex? A longitudinal fMRI stroke study. Brain 2005, 128:1122-1138.
37. Johansen-Berg H., Rushworth M.F., Bogdanovic M.D., Kischka U., Wimalaratna S., Matthews P.M. The role of ipsilateral premotor cortex in hand movement after stroke. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 2002, 99:14518-14523.
38. Kwakkel G., Kollen B., Lindeman E. Understanding the pattern of functional recovery after stroke: facts and theories. Restor. Neurol. Neurosci. 2004, 22:281-299.
39. Kwakkel G., Kollen B., Twisk J. Impact of time on improvement of outcome after stroke. Stroke 2006, 37:2348-2353.
40. Lindberg P.G., Gäverth J., Fagergren A., Fransson P., Forssberg H., Borg J. Cortical activity in relation to velocity dependent movement resistance in the flexor muscles of the hand after stroke. Neurorehabil. Neural Repair 2009, 23:800-810.
41. Lindberg P.G., Schmitz C., Engardt M., Forssberg H., Borg J. Use-dependent up- and down-regulation of sensorimotor brain circuits in stroke patients. Neurorehabil. Neural Repair 2007, 21:315-326.
42. Lotze M., Markert J., Sauseng P., Hoppe J., Plewnia C., Gerloff C. The role of multiple contralesional motor areas for complex hand movements after internal capsular lesion. J. Neurosci. 2006, 26:6096-6102.
43. Loubinoux I., Carel C., Pariente J., Dechaumont S., Albucher J.F., Marque P., Manelfe C., Chollet F. Correlation between cerebral reorganization and motor recovery after subcortical infarcts. NeuroImage 2003, 20:2166-2180.
44. Loubinoux I., Dechaumont-Palacin S., Castel-Lacanal E., De B.X., Marque P., Pariente J., Albucher J.F., Berry I., Chollet F. Prognostic value of FMRI in recovery of hand function in subcortical stroke patients. Cereb. Cortex 2007, 17:2980-2987.
45. Luft A.R., Waller S., Forrester L., Smith G.V., Whitall J., Macko R.F., Schulz J.B., Hanley D.F. Lesion location alters brain activation in chronically impaired stroke survivors. NeuroImage 2004, 21:924-935.
46. Lyle R.C. A performance test for assessment of upper limb function in physical rehabilitation treatment and research. Int. J. Rehabil. Res. 1981, 4:483-492.
47. Marshall R.S., Zarahn E., Alon L., Minzer B., Lazar R.M., Krakauer J.W. Early imaging correlates of subsequent motor recovery after stroke. Ann. Neurol. 2009, 65:596-602.
48. Medical Research Council Aids to the Examination of the Peripheral Nervous System 1976, HMSO, London.
49. Middleton F.A., Strick P.L. Anatomical evidence for cerebellar and basal ganglia involvement in higher cognitive function. Science 1994, 266:458-461.
50. Mima T., Sadato N., Yazawa S., Hanawaka T., Fukuyama H., Yonekura Y., Shibasaki H. Brain structures related to active and passive finger movements in man. Brain 1999, 122:1989-1997.
51. Mintzopoulos D., Astrakas L.G., Khanicheh A., Konstas A.A., Singhal A., Moskowitz M.A., Rosen B.R., Tzika A.A. Connectivity alterations assessed by combining fMRI and MR-compatible hand robots in chronic stroke. NeuroImage 2009, 47(Suppl. 2):T90-T97.
52. Murase N., Duque J., Mazzocchio R., Cohen L.G. Influence of interhemispheric interactions on motor function in chronic stroke. Ann. Neurol. 2004, 55:400-409.
53. Nair D.G., Hutchinson S., Fregni F., Alexander M., Pascual-Leone A., Schlaug G. Imaging correlates of motor recovery from cerebral infarction and their physiological significance in well-recovered patients. NeuroImage 2007, 34:253-263.
54. Nathan P.W., Smith M.C. Effects of two unilateral cordotomies on the motility of the lower limbs. Brain 1973, 96:471-494.
55. Nelles G., Jentzen W., Jueptner M., Müller S., Diener H.C. Arm training induced plasticity in stroke studied with serial positron emission tomography. NeuroImage 2001, 13:1146-1154.
56. Nelles G., Spiekermann G., Jueptner M., Leonhardt G., Müller S., Gerhard H., Diener H.C. Evolution of functional reorganization in hemiplegic stroke: a serial positron emission tomographic activation study. Ann. Neurol. 1999, 46:901-909.
57. Nelles G., Spiekermann G., Jueptner M., Leonhardt G., Muller S., Gerhard H., Diener H.C. Reorganization of sensory and motor systems in hemiplegic stroke patients. A positron emission tomography study. Stroke 1999, 30:1510-1516.
58. Nowak D.A., Grefkes C., Dafotakis M., Eickhoff S., Kust J., Karbe H., Fink G.R. Effects of low-frequency repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation of the contralesional primary motor cortex on movement kinematics and neural activity in subcortical stroke. Arch. Neurol. 2008, 65:741-747.
59. O'Shea J., Johansen-Berg H., Trief D., Gobel S., Rushworth M.F. Functionally specific reorganization in human premotor cortex. Neuron 2007, 54:479-490.
60. Pariente J., Loubinoux I., Carel C., Albucher J.-F., Leger A., Manelfe C., Rascol O., Chollet F. Fluoxetine modulates motor performance and cerebral activation of patients recovering from stroke. Ann. Neurol. 2001, 50:718-729.
61. Picard N., Strick P.L. Imaging the premotor areas. Curr. Opin. Neurobiol. 2001, 11:663-672.
62. Rehme A.K., Eickhoff S.B., Wang L.E., Fink G.R., Grefkes C. Dynamic causal modeling of cortical activity from the acute to the chronic stage after stroke. NeuroImage 2011, 55:1147-1158.
63. Rehme A.K., Fink G.R., von Cramon D.Y., Grefkes C. The role of the contralesional motor cortex for motor recovery in the early days after stroke assessed with longitudinal FMRI. Cereb. Cortex 2011, 21:756-768.
64. Riecker A., Groschel K., Ackermann H., Schnaudigel S., Kassubek J., Kastrup A. The role of the unaffected hemisphere in motor recovery after stroke. Hum. Brain Mapp. 2010, 31:1017-1029.
65. Rouiller E.M., Babalian A., Kazennikov O., Moret V., Yu X.H., Wiesendanger M. Transcallosal connections of the distal forelimb representations of the primary and supplementary motor cortical areas in macaque monkeys. Exp. Brain Res. 1994, 102:227-243.
66. Schmidlin E., Brochier T., Maier M.A., Kirkwood P.A., Lemon R.N. Pronounced reduction of digit motor repsonses evoked from macaque ventral premotor cortex after reversible inactivation of the primary motor cortex hand area. J. Neurosci. 2008, 28:5772-5783.
67. Schubotz R.I., von Cramon D.Y. Predicting perceptual events activates corresponding motor schemes in lateral premotor cortex: an fMRI study. NeuroImage 2002, 15:787-796.
68. Seitz R.J., Hoflich P., Binkofski F., Tellmann L., Herzog H., Freund H.J. Role of the premotor cortex in recovery from middle cerebral artery infarction. Arch. Neurol. 1998, 55:1081-1088.
69. Sharma N., Baron J.C., Rowe J.B. Motor imagery after stroke: relating outcome to motor network connectivity. Ann. Neurol. 2009, 66:604-616.
70. Sharma N., Simmons L.H., Jones P.S., Day D.J., Carpenter T.A., Pomeroy V.M., Warburton E.A., Baron J.-C. Motor imagery after subcortical stroke. A functional magnetic resonance imaging study. Stroke 2009, 40:1315-1324.
71. Small S.L., Hlustik P., Noll D.C., Genovese C., Solodkin A. Cerebellar hemispheric activation ipsilateral to the paretic hand correlates with functional recovery after stroke. Brain 2002, 125:1544-1557.
72. Stinear C.M., Barber P.A., Smale P.R., Coxon J.P., Fleming M.K., Byblow W.D. Functional potential in chronic stroke patients depends on corticospinal tract integrity. Brain 2007, 130:170-180.
73. Stoodley C.J., Schmahmann J.D. Functional topography in the human cerebellum: a meta-analysis of neuroimaging studies. NeuroImage 2009, 44:489-501.
74. Struppler A., Binkofski F., Angerer B., Bernhardt M., Spiegel S., Drzezga A., Bartenstein P. A fronto-parietal network is mediating improvement of motor function related to repetitive peripheral magnetic stimulation: a PET H2O15 study. NeuroImage 2007, 36:T174-T186.
75. Takeuchi N., Chuma T., Matsuo Y., Watanabe I., Ikoma K. Repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation of contralesional primary motor cortex improves hand function after stroke. Stroke 2005, 36:2681-2686.
76. Tardy J., Pariente J., Leger A., Dechaumont-Palacin S., Gerdelat A., Guirad V., Conchou F., Albucher J.-F., Marque P., Franceries X., Cognard C., Rascol O., Chollet F., Loubinoux I. Methylphenidate modulates cerebral post-stroke reorganization. NeuroImage 2006, 33:913-922.
77. Tombari D., Loubinoux I., Pariente J., Gerdelat A., Albucher J.F., Tardy J., Cassol E., Chollet F. A longitudinal fMRI study: in recovering and then in clinically stable sub-cortical stroke patients. NeuroImage 2004, 23:827-839.
78. Turkeltaub P.E., Eickhoff S.B., Laird A.R., Fox M., Wiener M., Fox P. Minimizing within-experiment and within-group effects in activation likelihood estimation meta-analyses. Hum. Brain Mapp. 2011, 10.1002/hbm.21186.
79. Wang L.E., Fink G.R., Diekhoff S., Rehme A.K., Eickhoff S.B., Grefkes C. Noradrenergic enhancement improves motor network connectivity in stroke patients. Ann. Neurol. 2011, 69:375-388.
80. Ward N.S., Brown M.M., Thompson A.J., Frackowiak R.S. Neural correlates of motor recovery after stroke: a longitudinal fMRI study. Brain 2003, 126:2476-2496.
81. Ward N.S., Brown M.M., Thompson A.J., Frackowiak R.S. Neural correlates of outcome after stroke: a cross-sectional fMRI study. Brain 2003, 126:1430-1448.
82. Ward N.S., Brown M.M., Thompson A.J., Frackowiak R.S. The influence of time after stroke on brain activations during a motor task. Ann. Neurol. 2004, 55:829-834.
83. Ward N.S., Newton J.M., Swayne O.B., Lee L., Thompson A.J., Greenwood R.J., Rothwell J.C., Frackowiak R.S. Motor system activation after subcortical stroke depends on corticospinal system integrity. Brain 2006, 129:809-819.
84. Weder B., Knorr U., Herzog H., Nebeling B., Kleinschmidt A., Huang Y., Steinmetz H., Freund H.-J., Seitz R.J. Tactile exploration of shape after subcortical ischaemic infarction studied with PET. Brain 1994, 117:593-605.
85. Weiller C., Chollet F., Friston K.J., Wise R.J., Frackowiak R.S. Functional reorganization of the brain in recovery from striatocapsular infarction in man. Ann. Neurol. 1992, 31:463-472.
86. Weiller C., Juptner M., Fellows S., Rijntjes M., Leonhardt G., Kiebel S., Muller S., Diener H.C., Thilmann A.F. Brain representation of active and passive movements. NeuroImage 1996, 4:105-110.
87. Werhahn K.J., Conforto A.B., Kadom N., Hallett M., Cohen L.G. Contribution of the ipsilateral motor cortex to recovery after chronic stroke. Ann. Neurol. 2003, 54:464-472.
88. Yozbatiran N., Der-Yeghiaian L., Cramer S.C. A standardized approach to performing the action research arm test. Neurorehabil. Neural Repair 2008, 22:78-90.