End-of-life care pathways as tools to promote and support a good death: A critical commentary

European Journal of Cancer Care

Volumn 21, Issue 1, 2012, Pages 20-30

  Watts, T ^a  

^a SWANSEA UNIVERSITY   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Care pathways; Dying; End of life care; Good death; Palliative care; Terminal care

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; ATTITUDE TO DEATH; CLINICAL PATHWAY; HUMAN; ORGANIZATION AND MANAGEMENT; PALLIATIVE THERAPY; STANDARD; TERMINAL CARE; UNITED KINGDOM;

ATTITUDE TO DEATH; CRITICAL PATHWAYS; GREAT BRITAIN; HUMANS; PALLIATIVE CARE; TERMINAL CARE;

EID: 84155170678     PISSN: 09615423     EISSN: 13652354     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1365-2354.2011.01301.x     Document Type: Article

References (125)

1. Addington-Hall J. & O'Callaghan A.C. (2009) A comparison of the quality of care provided to cancer patients in the UK in the last three months of life in in-patient hospices compared with hospitals, from the perspective of bereaved relatives: results from a survey using the VOICES questionnaire. Palliative Medicine 23, 190-197.
2. Agar M., Currow D.C., Shelby-James T.M., Plummer J., Sanderson C. & Abernethy A.P. (2008) Preference for place of care and place of death in palliative care: are these different questions? Palliative Medicine 22, 787-795.
3. Allen D. (2010) Care pathways: an ethnographic description of the field. International Journal of Care Pathways 14, 4-9.
4. Allen D., Gillen E. & Rixson L. (2009) Systematic review of the effectiveness of integrated care pathways: what works, for whom, in which circumstances? International Journal of Evidence Based Healthcare 7, 61-74.
5. Aoun S.M. & Kristjanson L.J. (2005) Challenging the framework for evidence in palliative care research. Palliative Medicine 19, 461-465.
6. Aries P. (1974) Western Attitudes to Death. John Hopkins University Press, London, UK.
7. Atwal A. & Caldwell K. (2002) Do multidisciplinary integrated care pathways improve interprofessional collaboration? Scandinavian Journal of Caring Sciences 16, 360-367.
8. Back I., Jenkins K., Blower A. & Beckhelling J. (2001) A study comparing hyoscine hydrobromide and glycopyrrolate in the treatment of death rattle. Palliative Medicine 15, 329-336.
9. Beccaro M., Costantini M., Giorgi Rossi P., Miccinesi G., Grimaldi M. & Bruzzi P. (2006) Actual and preferred place of death of cancer patients. Results from the Italian survey of dying with cancer. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health 60, 412-416.
10. Beccaro M., Caraceni A. & Costantini M. (2010) End-of-life care in Italian hospitals: quality of and satisfaction with care from the caregivers' point of view - results from the Italian survey of dying of cancer. Journal of Pain and Symptom Management 39, 1003-1015.
11. Berkwits M. (1998) From practice to research: the case for criticism in this age of evidence. Social Science and Medicine 47, 1539-1545.
12. Bestall J.C., Ahmed N., Ahmedzai S.H., Payne S.A., Noble B. & Clark D. (2004) Access and referral to specialist palliative care: patients' and professionals' experiences. International Journal of Palliative Nursing 10, 381-389.
13. Bookbinder M., Arney E., Wollner D., Lesage P., McHugh M., Indelicao R.A., Harding S., Barenboim A., Mironzyev T. & Portenoy R.K. (2005) Improving end-of-life care: development and pilot-test of a clinical pathway. Journal of Pain and Symptom Management 29, 529-543.
14. du Boulay S. (1984) Cicely Saunders. The Founder of the Modern Hospice Movement. Hodder and Stoughton, London, UK.
15. Bradbury M. (1999) Representations of Death: A Social Psychological Perspective. Routledge, London, UK.
16. Bradley K., Wee B. & Aoun S. (2010) Management of death rattle: what influences the decision-making of palliative medicine doctors and clinical nurse specialists? Progress in Palliative Care 18, 270-274.
17. Bragato L. & Jacobs K. (2003) Care pathways: the road to better health services? Journal of Health Organisation and Management 17, 164-180.
18. Callaghan D. (1993) Pursuing a peaceful death. Hastings Centre Report 23, 33-38.
19. Campbell H., Hotchkiss R., Bradshaw N. & Porteus M. (1998) Integrated care pathways. British Medical Journal 316, 133-137.
20. Cassell E.J. (1991) The Nature of Suffering and the Goals of Medicine. Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK.
21. Chan R. & Webster J. (2010) End-of-life care pathways for improving outcomes in caring for the dying. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews (1), CD008006. doi: 10.1002/14651858.pub2.
22. Clark D. (1998) Originating a movement: Cicely Saunders and the development of St Christopher's Hospice, 1957-1967. Mortality 3, 43-63.
23. Clark D. (2002) Between hope and acceptance: the medicalisation of dying. British Medical Journal 13, 905-907.
24. Clark D. & Seymour J. (1999) Reflections on Palliative Care. Open University Press, Buckingham, UK.
25. Closs S., Johnstone R. & Fowell A. (2007) An all-Wales audit of the Integrated Care Pathway for the last days of life: establishing the audit cycle. Journal of Integrated Care Pathways 11, 16-31.
26. Constantini M., Ottonelli S., Canavacci L., Pellegrini F. & Beccaro M. (2011) The effectiveness of the Liverpool Care Pathway in improving end of life care for dying cancer patients in hospital. A cluster randomised trial. BMC Health Services Research 11, 1-10. doi: 10.1186/1472-6963-11-13.
27. Copp G. & Field D. (2002) Open awareness and dying: the use of denial and acceptance as coping strategies by hospice patients. Nursing Times Research 7, 118-127.
28. Costello J. (2006) Dying well: nurses experiences of 'good and bad' deaths in hospital. Journal of Advanced Nursing 54, 594-601.
29. Costello J. & Horne M. (2003) Nurses' and health support workers' views on cardiopulmonary resuscitation in a hospice setting. International Journal of Palliative Nursing 9, 157-165.
30. Currie V.L. & Harvey G. (2000) The use of care pathways as tools to support the implementation of evidence based practice. Journal of Interprofessional Care 14, 311-324.
31. Curtis J.R., Patrick D.L., Engelberg R.A., Norris K., Asp C. & Byock I. (2002) A measure of the quality of dying and death: initial validation using after-death interviews with family members. Journal of Pain and Symptom Management 24, 17-31.
32. Davies E. & Higginson I. (2004) Palliative Care: The Solid Facts. World Health Organization, Copenhagen, Denmark.
33. Dekkers W., Sandman L. & Webb P. (2002) Good death or good life as a goal of palliative care? In: The Ethics of Palliative Care: European Perspectives (eds Ten Have H. & Clark D.), pp. 106-125. Open University Press, Buckingham, UK.
34. Department of Health (2008) End of Life Care Strategy: Promoting High Quality Care for All Adults at the End of Life. Department of Health, London, UK.
35. Edmonds P. & Rogers A. (2003) 'If only someone had told me....' A review of the care of patients dying in hospital. Clinical Medicine 3, 149-152.
36. Ellershaw J. & Murphy D. (2005) The Liverpool Care Pathway (LCP) influencing the UK national agenda on care of the dying. International Journal of Palliative Nursing 11, 132-134.
37. Ellershaw J., Murphy D., Shea T., Foster A. & Overill S. (1997) Developing an integrated care pathway for the dying patient. European Journal of Palliative Care 4, 203-208.
38. Ellershaw J., Smith C., Walker S.E. & Aldridge J. (2001) Care of the dying: setting standards for symptom control in the last 48 hours of life. Journal of Pain and Symptom Management 21, 12-17.
39. Ellershaw J., Dewar S. & Murphy D. (2010) Achieving a good death for all. British Medical Journal 341, 656-658.
40. Evans-Lacko S., Jarrett M., McCrone P. & Thornicroft G. (2010) Facilitators and barriers to implementing clinical care pathways. BMC Health Services Research 10, 182. Available at:
41. Every N.R., Hochman J., Becker R., Kopecky S. & Cannon C.P. (2000) Critical pathways: a review. Circulation 101, 461-465.
42. Field D. (1989) Nursing the Dying. Routledge, London, UK.
43. Field D. (1994) Palliative medicine and the medicalisation of death. European Journal of Cancer Care 3, 58-62.
44. Fokkema T. & Liefbroer A.C. (2008) Trends in living arrangements in Europe: convergence or divergence? Demographic Research 19, 1351-1417.
45. Fowell A., Finlay I., Johnstone R. & Minto L. (2002a) The Welsh Collaborative Care Pathway Project: implementing an integrated care pathway for the dying patient in Wales. Journal of Integrated Care Pathways 6, 59-62.
46. Fowell A., Finlay I., Johnstone R. & Minto L. (2002b) An integrated care pathway for the last two days of life: Wales-wide benchmarking in palliative care. International Journal of Palliative Nursing 8, 566-573.
47. Fowell A., Johnstone R., Russell I., Russell D. & Finlay I. (2006) Reported symptoms in the last days of life: the need for robust research. Palliative Medicine 20, 845-846.
48. Gambles M., Stirzaker S., Jack B.A. & Ellershaw J.E. (2006) The Liverpool Care Pathway in hospices: an exploratory study of doctor and nurse perceptions. International Journal of Palliative Nursing 12, 414-421.
49. Glaser B. & Strauss A. (1964) Awareness contexts and social interaction. American Sociological Review 29, 669-679.
50. Glaser B. & Strauss A. (1965) Awareness of Dying. Aldine, New York, NY, USA.
51. Goldsteen M., Houtepen R., Proote I.M., Abu-Saad H.H., Spreeuwenberg C. & Widdershoven G. (2006) What is a good death? Terminally ill patients dealing with normative expectations around death and dying. Patient Education and Counseling 64, 378-386.
52. Gomes B. & Higginson I. (2006) Factors influencing death at home in terminally ill patients with cancer: systematic review. British Medical Journal 310, 515-521.
53. Gott M., Small N., Barnes S., Payne S. & Seamark D. (2008) Older people's views of a good death in heart failure: implications for palliative care provision. Social Science and Medicine 67, 1113-1121.
54. Grande G.E. & Todd C.J. (2000) Why are trials in palliative care so difficult? Palliative Medicine 14, 69-74.
55. Greenhalgh T., Robert G., Bate P., Kyriakidou O., McFarlane F. & Peacock R. (2004) How to Spread Good Ideas: A Systematic Review of the Literature on Diffusion, Dissemination and Sustainability in Health Service Delivery and Organisation. National Co-ordinating Centre for NHS Service Delivery and Organisation. Available at:.
56. Hart B., Sainsbury P. & Short S. (1998) Whose dying? A sociological critique of the good death. Mortality 3, 65-77.
57. Health Service Ombudsman (2011) Care and Compassion: Report of the Health Service Ombudsman on Ten Investigations into NHS Care of Older People. The Stationary Office, London, UK.
58. Higginson I.J. & Costantini M. (2008) Dying with cancer: living well with advanced cancer. European Journal of Cancer 44, 1414-1424.
59. Hockley J., Dewar B. & Watson J. (2005) Promoting end-of-life care in nursing homes using an 'integrated care pathway for the last days of life'. Journal of Research in Nursing 10, 131-152.
60. Hopkinson J. & Hallett C. (2002) Good death? An exploration of newly qualified nurses' understanding of good death. International Journal of Palliative Nursing 8, 532-539.
61. House of Commons Public Accounts Committee (2009) End of Life Care. The Stationary Office, London, UK.
62. Hunter B. & Segrott J. (2008) Re-mapping client journeys and professional identities: a review of the literature on clinical pathways. International Journal of Nursing Studies 45, 608-625.
63. Illich I. (1974) Medical Nemesis: The Expropriation of Health. Marian Boyars, London, UK.
64. Jack B.A., Gambles M., Murphy D. & Ellershaw J.E. (2003) Nurses' perceptions of the Liverpool Care Pathway for the dying patient in the acute hospital setting. International Journal of Palliative Nursing 9, 375-381.
65. Jackson K., Mooney C. & Campbell D. (2009) The development and implementation of the pathway for improving the care of the dying in general medical wards. Internal Medicine Journal 39, 695-699.
66. James N. & Field D. (1992) The routinization of hospice: charisma and bureaucratization. Social Science and Medicine 34, 1363-1375.
67. Jones A. (2004) Perceptions on the standardization of psychiatric work: development of a care pathway. Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing 11, 705-713.
68. Kellehear A. (1990) Dying of Cancer: The Final Year of Life. Harwood Academic Publishers, Reading, UK.
69. Kellehear A. (2007) A Social History of Dying. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK.
70. Kellehear A. (2009a) What the social and behavioural studies say about dying. In: The Study of Dying: From Autonomy to Transformation (ed. Kellehear A.), pp. 1-26. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK.
71. Kellehear A. (2009b) Dying old - and preferably alone? Agency, resistance and dissent at the end of life. International Journal of Ageing and Later Life 4, 5-21.
72. Kelly D. (2003) A commentary on 'an integrated care pathway for the last two days of life'. International Journal of Palliative Nursing 9, 39.
73. Kitchiner D., Davidson C. & Bundred P. (1996) Integrated Care Pathways: effective tools for continuous evaluation of clinical practice. Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice 2, 65-69.
74. Kubler-Ross E. (1969) On Death and Dying. Tavistock, London, UK.
75. Lawton J. (2000) The Dying Process: Patients' Experiences of Palliative Care. Routledge, London, UK.
76. Lhussier M., Carr S.M. & Wilcockson J. (2007) The evaluation of an end-of-life integrated care pathway. International Journal of Palliative Nursing 13, 74-81.
77. Lo S.H., Chan C.Y., Chan C.H., Sze W.-K., Yuen K.K., Wong C.S., Ng T.Y. & Tung Y. (2009) The implementation of an end-of-life integrated care pathway in a Chinese population. International Journal of Palliative Nursing 15, 384-388.
78. de Luc K. (2000) Care pathways: an evaluation of their effectiveness. Journal of Advanced Nursing 32, 485-496.
79. Marie Curie Palliative Care Institute Liverpool (2009) National Care of the Dying Audit - Hospitals: Generic Report 2008/2009. Marie Curie Palliative Care Institute Liverpool, Liverpool, UK.
80. Masson J.D. (2002) Non-professional perceptions of 'good death': a study of the views of hospice care patients and relatives of deceased hospice care patients. Mortality 7, 191-209.
81. McNamara B. (2001) Fragile Lives: Death, Dying and Care. Open University Press, Buckingham, UK.
82. McNamara B. (2004) Good enough death: autonomy and choice in Australian palliative care. Social Science and Medicine 58, 929-938.
83. McNamara B., Waddell C. & Colvin M. (1995) Threats to the good death: the cultural context of stress and coping among hospice nurses. Sociology of Health and Illness 17, 223-244.
84. Middlewood S., Gardner G. & Gardner A. (2001) Dying in hospital: medical failure or natural outcome? Journal of Pain and Symptom Management 22, 1035-1041.
85. Mills M., Davies H. & Macrae W. (1994) Care of dying patients in hospital. British Medical Journal 309, 583-586.
86. Mirando S., Davies P. & Lipp A. (2005) Introducing and integrated care pathway for the last days of life. Palliative Medicine 19, 33-39.
87. National Confidential Enquiry into Patient Outcomes and Death (2009) Caring to the End: A Review of the Care of Patients Who Died in Hospital within Four Days of Admission. National Confidential Enquiry into Patient Outcomes and Death, London, UK.
88. National Institute for Clinical Excellence (2004) Improving Supportive and Palliative Care for Adults with Cancer: The Manual. National Institute for Clinical Excellence, London, UK.
89. Neuberger J. (2003) Commentary: a 'good death' is possible in the NHS. British Medical Journal 326, 30-34.
90. NHS Wales (2010) All Wales Care Pathway for the Last Days of Life. NHS Wales, Cardiff, UK.
91. Parkes C.M. (1990) Risk factors in bereavement: implications for the prevention and treatment of pathological grief. Psychiatric Annals 20, 308-313.
92. Payne S., Langley-Evans A. & Hillier R. (1996a) Perceptions of a 'good' death: a comparative study of the views of hospice staff and patients. Palliative Medicine 10, 307-312.
93. Payne S., Hillier R., Langley-Evans A. & Roberts T. (1996b) Impact of witnessing death on hospice patients. Social Science and Medicine 43, 1785-1794.
94. Pinder R., Petchey R., Shaw S. & Carter Y. (2005) What's in a care pathway? Towards a cultural cartography of the new NHS. Sociology of Health and Illness 27, 759-779.
95. Pooler J., McCrory F., Steadman Y., Westwell H. & Peers S. (2003) Dying at home: a care pathway for the last days of life in a community setting. International Journal of Palliative Nursing 9, 258-264.
96. Renholm M., Leino-Kilpi H. & Suominen T. (2002) Critical pathways: a systematic review. Journal of Nursing Administration 32, 196-202.
97. Rietjens J.A.C., van der Heide A., Onwuteaka-Philipsen B.D., van der Maas P.J. & van der Wal G. (2006) Preferences of the Dutch general public for a good death and associations with attitudes to end-of-life care decision-making. Palliative Medicine 20, 685-692.
98. Rogers A., Karlsen S. & Addington-Hall J. (2000) 'All the services were excellent: it is when the human element comes in that things go wrong': dissatisfaction with hospital care in the last year of life. Journal of Advanced Nursing 31, 768-774.
99. Sandelowski M. (2004) Using qualitative evidence. Qualitative Health Research 14, 1366-1386.
100. Saunders C. (2000) The evolution of palliative care. Patient Education and Counseling 41, 7-13.
101. Saunders C. (2001) The evolution of palliative care. Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine 94, 430-432.
102. Seale C. (2004) Media constructions of dying alone: a form of 'bad death'. Social Science and Medicine 58, 967-974.
103. Seymour J. (1999) Revisiting medicalisation and 'natural' death. Social Science and Medicine 49, 691-704.
104. Steinhauser K.E., Clipp E.C., McNeilly M., Christakis N.A., McIntyre L.M. & Tulsky J.A. (2000a) In search of a good death: observations of patients, families and providers. Annals of Internal Medicine 132, 825-832.
105. Steinhauser K.E., Christakis N.A., Clipp E.C., McNeilly M., McIntyre L.M. & Tulsky J.A. (2000b) Factors considered important at the end of life by patients, family, physicians and other care providers. Journal of the American Medical Association 284, 2476-2482.
106. Strange J.M. (2009) Historical approaches to dying. In: The Study of Dying: from Autonomy to Transformation (ed. Kellehear A.), pp. 123-146. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK.
107. Sudnow D. (1967) Passing On: the Social Organisation of Dying. Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ, USA.
108. Swart S., van Veluw H., van Zuylen L., Gambles M. & Ellershaw J. (2006) Dutch experiences with the Liverpool Care Pathway. European Journal of Palliative Care 13, 156-159.
109. Teunissen S.C.C.M., Wesker W., Kruitwagen C., de Haes H.C.J.M., Voest E.E. & de Graeff A. (2007) Symptom prevalence in patients with incurable cancer: a systematic review. Journal of Pain and Symptom Management 34, 94-104.
110. Thomas C. (2005) The place of death of cancer patients: can qualitative data add to known factors? Social Science and Medicine 60, 2597-2607.
111. Thomas C., Morris S.M. & Clark D. (2004) Place of death: preferences among cancer patients and their carers. Social Science and Medicine 58, 2413-2444.
112. Tong E., McGraw S.A., Dobihal E., Baggish R., Cherlin E. & Bradley E.H. (2003) What is a good death? Minority and non-minority perspectives. Journal of Palliative Care 19, 168-175.
113. Vanhaecht K., Panella M., van Zelm R. & Sermeus W. (2010) An overview on the history and concept of care pathways as complex interventions. International Journal of Care Pathways 14, 117-123.
114. Veerbeek L., van Zuylen L., Swart S.J., van der Maas P.J., de Vogel-Voogt E., van der Rijt C.C. & van der Heide A. (2008) The effect of the Liverpool Care Pathway for the dying: a multi-centre study. Palliative Medicine 22, 145-151.
115. Vig E. & Pearlman R. (2004) Good and bad dying from the perspective of terminally ill men. Archives of Internal Medicine 164, 977-981.
116. Walker R. & Read S. (2010) The Liverpool Care Pathway in intensive care: an exploratory study of doctor and nurse perceptions. International Journal of Palliative Nursing 16, 267-273.
117. Walter T. (1994) The Revival of Death. Routledge, London, UK.
118. Watts T. & Jenkins K. (1999) Palliative care nurses' feelings about death rattle. Journal of Clinical Nursing 8, 615-618.
119. Watts T., Jenkins K. & Back I. (1997) Problem and management of noisy rattling breathing in dying patients. International Journal of Palliative Nursing 3, 245-252.
120. Watts T., Jones M., Wainwright P. & Williams A. (2001) Methodologies analysing individual practice: a systematic review. Journal of Advanced Nursing 35, 238-256.
121. Welsh Assembly Government (2008) Palliative Care Planning Group Wales: Report to the Minister for Health and Social Services. Welsh Assembly Government, Cardiff, UK.
122. Willard C. & Luker K. (2006) Challenges to end of life care in the acute hospital setting. Palliative Medicine 20, 611-615.
123. World Health Organization (2004) Better Care for Older People. WHO, Copenhagen, Denmark.
124. Young M. & Cullen L. (1996) A Good Death: Conversations with East Londoners. Routledge, London, UK.
125. Zander K. (2002) Integrated care pathways: eleven international trends. Journal of Integrated Care Pathways 6, 101-107.