A comparison between manganese nodules and cobalt crust economics in a scenario of mutual exclusivity

Marine Policy

Volumn 36, Issue 3, 2012, Pages 790-800

  Martino, Simone ^a   Parson, Lindsay M ^a  

^a NATIONAL OCEANOGRAPHY CENTRE   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Break even point analysis; Cobalt crusts; Deep seabed mining; Manganese nodules; Mining economics; Sensitivity analysis

Indexed keywords

COBALT; COMPUTER SIMULATION; DEEP SEA; ECONOMICS; MANGANESE; MINING; MONTE CARLO ANALYSIS; ORE MINERAL; SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS;

EID: 83455178136     PISSN: 0308597X     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.marpol.2011.11.008     Document Type: Article

References (60)

1. Halfar J., Fujita R.M. Precautionary management of deep-sea mining. Mar Policy 2002, 26:103-106.
2. Hoagland P., Beaulieu S., Tivey M.A., Eggert R.G., German C., Glowka L., et al. Deep-sea mining of seafloor massive sulfides. Mar Policy 2010, 34:728-732.
3. CDI. The Cobalt conference. Cobalt News 2008;3:9-10. Available at: [Consulted in February 2011]. http://www.thecdi.com/cobaltnews.php.
4. CDI. 2009 production statistics. Cobalt News 2010;2:3-4. Available at: [Consulted in February 2011]. http://www.thecdi.com/cdi/images/news_pdf/cobalt_news_apr10.pdf.
5. Sorensen P.E., Mead W. A cost-benefit analysis of ocean mineral resource development: the case of manganese nodules. Am J Agric Econ 1968, 50(5):1611-1620.
6. Rajesh S, Gnanaraj AA, Velmurugan A, Ramesh R, Muthuvel P, Babu MK, et al. Qualification tests on underwater mining system with manganese nodule collection and crushing systems. In: Proceedings of the ninth ocean mining symposium. Maui; 19-24 June 2011. p. 110-5.
7. Yoon CH, Park JM, Kang JS, Kim YJ, Park YC, Park SG, et al. Shallow lifting test for the development of deep ocean mineral resources in Korea. In: Proceedings of the ninth ocean mining symposium. Maui; 19-24 June 2011. p. 149-152.
8. Clark A.L., Clark J.C. Marine metallic mineral resources from the Pacific basin. Mar Resour Econ 1986, 3(1):45-62.
9. Lenoble JP. A comparison of possible economic returns from mining deep sea polymetallic nodules, polymetallic massive sulphides and cobalt rich ferromanganese crusts. In: Proceedings of the workshop on mineral resources of the international seabed area. Kingston, Jamaica; 26-30, 2000. p. 265-427.
10. Andrews B.W., Flipse J.E., Brown F.C. The economic viability of a four metal pioneer deep ocean mining venture 1983, A&M University, Texas.
11. Charles C., et al. Views on future nodule technologies based on IFREMER-GEMONOD studies. Mater Soc 1990, 14(3/4):299-326.
12. Soreide F, Lund F, Markussen JM. Deep ocean mining reconsidered a study of the manganese nodules deposits in the Cook Islands. In: Proceedings of the fourth ocean mining symposium. Szczecin, Poland; September 23-27, 2001. p. 88-93.
13. Yamazaki T. Development of technical and economical examination method for cobalt rich ferromanganese crusts. In: Proceedings of the twelfth international offshore and polar engineering conference. Kitalyushu, Japan; May 26-31, 2002. p. 454-61.
14. Yamazaki T. Technological issues associated with commercialising cobalt-rich ferromanganese crusts deposits in the Area. In: Proceedings of the international seabed authority's workshop "Mining cobalt-rich ferromanganese crusts and polymetallic sulphides deposits: technological and economic considerations". Kingston, Jamaica; 31 July-4 August, 2006. p. 208-20.
15. Yamazaki T. Model mining units of the 20th century and the economies (production requirements, area requirements and vertical integration). In: Proceedings of the technical paper for ISA workshop on polymetallic nodule mining technology-current status and challenges ahead. Chennai, India; 18-22 February, 2008. p. 1-9. Available at: [web page consulted in February 2011]. http://www.isa.org.jm/files/documents/EN/Workshops/Feb2008/Yamazaki-Abst.pdf.
16. Hein J.R., Conrad T.A., Staudigel H. Seamount mineral deposits. A source of rare metals for high-technology industries. Oceanography 2010, 23(1):184-189.
17. Yamazaki T. Effect of microtopography on mining possibility of cobalt-rich manganese crusts. In: Proceedings of the eighth ISOPE ocean mining symposium. Chennai, India; 20-24 September, 2009. p. 239-45.
18. Agarwal H.P., Goodrich J.D. Extraction of copper, nickel and cobalt from Indian Ocean nodules. Can J Chem Eng 2003, 81:303-306.
19. Johnson C.J., Otto J.M. Manganese nodule project economics. Factors relating to the Pacific Region. Resour Policy 1986, 12(1):17-28.
20. Brooks D.B. Deep sea manganese nodules: from scientific phenomenon to world resources. Nat Resour J 1968, 8:401-423.
21. Mero J.L. Economic aspect of nodule mining. Marine manganese deposits 1977, 327-355. Elsevier, Amsterdam. G.P. Glasby (Ed.).
22. Medford R.D. Marine mining in Britain. Min Mag 1969, 121(5):369-381. [and 121(6):474-80].
23. Glasby G.P. Marine minerals in the Pacific. Oceanogr Mar Biol Annu Rev 1986, 24:11-24.
24. Broadus J.M. Seabed materials. Science 1987, 235:853-860.
25. Herrouin G, Lenoble JP, Charles C. A manganese nodule industrial venture would be profitable. In: Proceedings of the summary of a 4 year study in France, in offshore technology conference, OTC 5997. Houston (Texas, USA); May 1-4, 1989. p. 321-31.
26. ISA. Marine mineral resources. Scientific advances and economic perspective; 2004. 126 p. Available at: [Web page consulted in February 2011]. http://www.isa.org.jm/files/documents/EN/Pubs/ISA-Daolos.pdf.
27. ISA. Polymetallic massive sulphides and cobalt-rich ferromanganese crusts: status and prospects. ISA technical study: no. 2; 2002. 113 p. Available at: [Web page consulted in February 2011]. http://www.isa.org.jm/files/documents/EN/Pubs/TechStudy2.pdf.
28. Hilman C.T., Gosling B.B. Mining deep ocean manganese nodules: description and economic analysis of a potential venture 1985, IC9015. Bureau of Mines, US, [19 p.].
29. Marsh J.B. The potential economic impact of technological progress on the development of manganese nodule mining. The emerging marine economy of the Pacific 1984, 49-60. Butterworth, Boston, MA. C. Gopalakrishnan (Ed.).
30. Dick R. Deep-sea mining versus land based mining: a cost comparison. The economics of deep sea mining 1984, 2-61. Springer-Verlag, New York. J.B. Donges (Ed.).
31. Marvasti A. Resource characteristics, extraction costs and optimal exploitation of mineral resources. Environ Resour Econ 2000, 17:395-408.
32. Glasby G.P. Deep seabed mining: past failure and future prospects. Mar Georesour Geotechnol 2002, 20:161-176.
33. Padan J.W. Commercial recovery of deep seabed manganese nodules: twenty years of accomplishment. Mar Min 1990, 9:87-103.
34. Rona P.A. The changing vision of marine minerals. Ore Geol Rev 2008, 33:618-666.
35. Handschuh R, Schulte E, Grebe H, Schwarz W. Economic simulation for a small scale manganese nodule mining system taking into account new technologies. In: Proceedings of the fifth ocean mining symposium. Tsukuba, Japan; September 15-19, 2003. p. 71-5.
36. Sen PK, Singh TRP. Design of flexible configuration nodule pilot plants in the context of evolving metal markets. In: Proceedings of the third ocean mining symposium. Goa, India; November 8-10, 1999. p. 254-9.
37. Marvasti A. An Assessment of technology transfer systems and the new law of the sea. Ocean Coastal Manage 1998, 39:197-210.
38. Loudat TA, Zaiger KK, Wiltshire JC. Solution mining of Johnston island and manganese crusts: an economic evaluation. In: Proceedings of the Oceans'95 MTS/IEEE, challenges of our changing global environment, vol. 2; 1995. p. 713-22.
39. Loudat TA, Wiltshire JC, Zaiger K, Allen J, Hirt W. An economic analysis of the feasibility of manganese crusts mining and processing. Technical report. Honolulu: State of Hawaii Department of Business, Economic Department and Tourism; 1994. 105 p.
40. Zimmermann W., Fries H.P. Betriebliches Rechnungswesen 1995, Munchen-Wien, Verlag. R. Oldenburg (Ed.).
41. Hoagland P. Manganese nodule price trends. Dim prospects for the commercialization of deep seabed mining. Resour Policy 1993, 19(4):287-298.
42. Ham KS. A study on economics of development of deep seabed manganese nodules. In: Proceedings of the second ocean mining symposium. Seoul, Korea; November, 24-26, 1997. p. 105-11.
43. Martino S, Parson LM. Nodules and crust economics: relationship between cobalt and nickel price. In: Proceedings of the ninth ocean mining symposium. Maui; 19-24 June 2011. p. 213-20.
44. Goto K, Yamazaki T, Nakatani N, Arai R. Preliminary economic feasibility analysis of cobalt-rich manganese crust mining for rare metal recovery. In: Proceedings of the ASME 29th international conference on ocean, offshore and arctic engineering. Shangay, China: OMAE; June 6-11, 2010. p. 1-6.
45. ISA. Issues associated with the implementation of the article 82 of the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea. Technical study no .4; 2010. 117 p. Available at: [Web page consulted in February 2011]. http://www.isa.org.jm/files/documents/EN/Pubs/TechStudy4.pdf.
46. Hein J.R., Conrad T.A., Dunham R.E. Seamount characteristics and mine-site model applied to exploration- and mining lease-block selection for cobalt-rich ferromanganese crusts. Mar Georesour Geotechnol 2009, 27:160-176.
47. ISA. Biodiversity, species ranges, and gene flow in the abyssal Pacific nodule province: predicting and managing the impacts of deep seabed mining. Technical study no. 3; 2008. 45 p. Available at: [Web page consulted in February 2011]. http://www.isa.org.jm/files/documents/EN/Pubs/TechStudy3.pdf.
48. Clark J.P., Neutra M.R. Mining manganese nodules Potential economic and environmental effects. Resour Policy 1983, 9(2):99-102.
49. Yamada A, Yamazaki T, Nakatani N. Combined analysis of ecology and economy of manganese nodule mining. In: Proceedings of the eighth ISOPE ocean mining symposium. Chennai, India; September 20-24, 2009. p. 73-9.
50. Kamphausen D. Raw materials from the deep sea: what implications for land-based mining in developing countries?. Econ Bull 1978, 15(8):3-8.
51. Gordon RB, Bertram M, Graedel T.E. Metal stock and sustainability. Proc Natl Acad Sci 2006, 103(5):1209-1214.
52. Gordon R.B., Bertram M., Graedel T.E. On the sustainability of metal supplies: a response to Tilton and Lagos. Resour Policy 2007, 32:24-28.
53. Tilton J.E., Lagos G. Assessing the long-run availability of copper. Resour Policy 2007, 32:19-23.
54. Berck P., Roberts M. Natural resource prices: will they ever turn up?. J Environ Econ Manage 1996, 31:65-78.
55. Ghoshray A. A re-examination of trends in primary commodity prices. J Dev Econ 2011, 95:242-251.
56. Tilton JE. The impact of seabed nodules mining: a qualitative analysis. Research report. Laxemburg, Austria: International Institute for Applied System Analysis; 1983. 77 p. Available at: [Web page consulted in February 2011]. http://www.iiasa.ac.at/Admin/PUB/Documents/RR-83-033.pdf.
57. Lenoble JP. New scenarios of the world metal markets and the eventual contribution from deep sea mining. In: Proceedings of the 25th annual offshore technology conference, OTC 7101. Houston, Texas, USA; 3-6 May 1993. p. 197-202.
58. The Economist. The unplumbed riches of the deep and why they'll wait a while longer before being disturbed; 14th May 2009. Available at: [Web page consulted in February 2011]. http://www.economist.com/node/13649273.
59. Grosz RWG. Consortium opportunities for deep seabed mining in the Republic of Kiribati, Central Pacific Ocean, based on its competitive advantages vis-à-vis other deep seabed resource owning nations and the International Seabed Authority; 2005. Available at: [Web page consulted in February 2011]. http://www.atollinstitute.org/Institute%20Legal%20Papers/Consortium%20Opportunities%20for%20Deep%20Seabed%20Mining.doc.
60. ISA. Non-living resources of the continental shelf beyond 200 nautical miles: speculation on the implementation of article 82 of the United Nations convention on the Law of the Sea. Technical study no. 5; 2010. 85 p. Available at: [Web page consulted in February 2011]. http://www.isa.org.jm/files/documents/EN/Pubs/TechStudy5.pdf.